Evaluating statistical analyses and reproducibility of microbial mutagenicity assays

The NCI/NTP has completed the first phase of a 4-laboratory study on the reproducibility of testing chemicals for mutagenicity in the Salmonella/microsome assay. This paper is report of the statistical analysis of some of that data. This analysis involved (1) identifying and removing spurious data; (2) determining the adequacy of the remaining data in making a decision on the mutagenicity of the test chemical; (3) performing the statistical tests; and (4) interpreting the results. Using this procedure, 7 approaches were used to determine the mutagenicity of a test. These approaches were the (1) 2-fold rule, (2) modified 2-fold rule, (3) one-way analysis of variance (homogeneity test), (4) test for linear trend, (5) combination of 3 and 4, (6) 97.5th percentile threshold rule and (7) confidence interval threshold rule. The conclusions drawn by each rule were compared to the microbiologists' interpretation, and the results of these comparisons were presented. In addition, the strengths and weaknesses of each rule were discussed. The reproducibility of the assay in this study was examined, and a discussion of the significance of these results was presented.     

Specificity and performance of PCR detection assays for microbial pathogens

PCR has become a widely used tool for detection, identification and differentiation of pathogenic microorganisms in diagnosis of animal and human diseases. However, quite a number of currently used protocols can be further optimized to exclude nonspecific reactions. On the one hand, target sequences as defined by primer binding sites should be checked carefully for the absence of significant homologies to other organisms in order to insure high specificity of detection. A major part of PCR assays is still based on target sequences in the ribosomal RNA operon, but, as the differentiating potential of this region is limited, genes encoding cellular proteins, such as toxins, surface antigens or enzymes, have been shown to be a viable alternative in many instances. On the other hand, various approaches are available to improve the performance of the amplification reaction itself. The kinetics of amplification is known to be heavily dependent on primer-to-template ratio, efficiency of primer annealing and enzyme-to-template ratio. In the present paper, recently published PCR detection assays for microorganisms, particularly bacterial pathogens, are reviewed and optimization strategies are explained. The practical implications and epidemiological consequences of routine use of PCR in the diagnostic laboratory are also discussed.     

Comparison of microbial community assays for the assessment of stream biofilm ecology

We investigated a range of microbiological community assays performed on scrapes of biofilms formed on artificial diffusing substrates deployed in 8 streams in eastern Scotland, with a view to using them to characterize ecological response to stream water quality. The assays considered were: Multiplex Terminal Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism or M-TRFLP (a molecular method), Phospholipid Fatty Acid or PLFA analysis (a biochemical method) and MICRORESP^™ (a physiological method) alongside TDI, diatom species, and chlorophyll a content. Four of the streams were classified as of excellent status (3-6 μg/L Soluble Reactive Phosphorus (SRP)) with respect to soluble P content under the EU Water Framework Directive and four were of borderline good/moderate or moderate status (43-577 μg/L SRP). At each site, 3 replicates of 3 solute diffusion treatments were deployed in a Latin square design. Solute diffusion treatments were: KCl (as a control solute), N and P (to investigate the effect of nutrient enrichment), or the herbicide isoproturon (as a “high impact” control, which aimed to affect biofilm growth in a way detectable by all assays). Biofilms were sampled after 4 weeks deployment in a low flow period of early summer 2006.The chlorophyll a content of biofilms after 4 weeks was 2.0 ± 0.29 mg/m² (mean ± se). Dry matter content was 16.0 ± 13.1 g/m². The M-TRFLP was successfully used for generating community profiles of cyanobacteria, algae and bacteria and was much faster than diatom identification. The PFLA and TDI were successful after an increase in the sample size, due to low counts. The MICRORESP^™ assays were often below or near detection limit. We estimated the per-sample times for the successful assays as follows: M-TRFLP: 20 min, PLFA 40 min, TDI 90 min. Using MANOVA on the first 5 principal co-ordinates, all the assays except MICRORESP^™ showed significant differences between sites, but none of the assays showed a significant effect of either initial stream trophic status (as classified by the EU Water Framework Directive using chemical standards for soluble P), or of the diffusing solute treatment. Multiple Procrustes analysis on the ordination results showed that the diatom and M-TRFLP data sets hold distinct, though as yet unexplored, information about the ecological factors affecting stream biofilms. The diatom data were subjected to principal components analysis, to identify which taxa were more strongly influenced by site variables, trophic status or treatment effects. These were Acnanthes lanceolata, A. minutissimma, Nitzchia spp., Coccineis spp. and Navicula spp. Further experimentation and data analysis on a larger number of sites, to identify specific M-TRFLP bands that could be used as indicators linked to specific taxa, are desirable. Results highlight the need for a multifactorial approach to understanding controls on stream ecology.     

Rapid CE microbial assays for consumer products that contain active bacteria

Recent advances in high efficiency separation methods of bacteria allow their rapid identification and quantitation in some cases. A specific capillary electrophoresis (CE) technique is used to identify and quantitate Lactobacillus acidophilus in both pill and syrup health products as well as Bifidobacterium infantis in a powdered formula supplement. Cell viability can be evaluated as well. In some cases, both the living and dead bacterial cells as well as the molecular excipients can be evaluated in a single run.     

Mutagenicity and DNA- modifying activity: A comparison of two microbial assays

Aspects of the Salmonella mutagenesis and Escherichia coli DNA polymerase deficient (pol A1^?) assay procedures for detecting environmental mutagens are discussed.The chief limitation of the pol A1^?1- assay involves substances that do not diffuse rapidly in agar. This problem can be overcome by performing the test in suspension. A simple procedure for accomplishing this is described.Although the Salmonella assay is more flexible, under routine conditions it does not respond to several classes of substances which give positive responses in the pol A1^?1 system.For optimal testing, it is recommended that the two microbial assays be used in tandem.The DNA-modifying properties of povidone-iodine for eukaryotic and prokaryotic cells are described. Even though this substance does not display mutagenic properties in the standard Salmonella assay, it does so in suspension culture. The basis of the mutagenic and DNA-modifying properties of povidone-iodine appears to involve the iodination of the cystosine residue of DNA.     

Assessment of soil microbial community structure by use of taxon-specific quantitative PCR assays

Here we describe a quantitative PCR-based approach to estimating the relative abundances of major taxonomic groups of bacteria and fungi in soil. Primers were thoroughly tested for specificity, and the method was applied to three distinct soils. The technique provides a rapid and robust index of microbial community structure.     

Enzyme immunoassays for the detection of microbial antigens and prospects for improved assays

The rapid diagnosis of viral infections is an important tool in the management of patients with infectious diseases. Solid-phase enzyme immunoassays have proved to be useful tools for the direct detection of the antigens of some viruses directly in clinical specimens. Such assays have been particularly useful in the diagnosis of viral infections in the gastrointestinal and respiratory tracts. However, standard solid-phase enzyme immunoassays often do not display sufficient sensitivity for the diagnosis of all cases of viral infections. Techniques which might be utilized to increase the sensitivity of solid-phase immunoassays include the use of monoclonal antibodies to maximize the efficiency of the antigen-antibody interactions and the use of high-turnover enzymes to increase the amount of signal generated by the ensuing enzyme-substrate reactions. In addition, techniques making use of nucleic acid hybridization have a great deal of potential for the accurate detection of viral nucleic acids in human body fluids. The successful application of these techniques to the diagnosis of viral infections could lead to a marked improvement in the care of patients with suspected infectious diseases as well as to a decrease in the transmission of viral infections to high-risk individuals.     

Chemical and microbial community analysis during aerobic biostimulation assays of non-sulfonated alkyl-benzene-contaminated groundwater

A chemical and microbial characterization of lab-scale biostimulation assays with groundwater samples taken from an industrial site in which the aquifer had been contaminated by linear non-sulfonate alkyl benzenes (LABs) was carried out for further field-scale bioremediation purposes. Two lab-scale biodegradability assays were performed, one with a previously obtained gas-oil-degrading consortium and another with the native groundwater flora. Results for the characterization of the groundwater microbial population of the site revealed the presence of an important LAB-degrading microbial population with a strong degrading capacity. Among the microorganisms identified at the site, the detection of Parvibaculum lavamentivorans, which have been described in other studies as alkyl benzene sulfonates degraders, is worth mentioning. Incubation of P. lavamentivorans DSMZ13023 with LABs as reported in this study shows for the first time the metabolic capacity of this strain to degrade such compounds. Results from the biodegradation assays in this study showed that the indigenous microbial population had a higher degrading capacity than the gas-oil-degrading consortium, indicating the strong ability of the native community to adapt to the presence of LABs. The addition of inorganic nutrients significantly improved the aerobic biodegradation rate, achieving levels of biodegradation close to 90%. The results of this study show the potential effectiveness of oxygen and nutrients as in situ biostimulation agents as well as the existence of a complex microbial community that encompasses well-known hydrocarbon- and LAS-degrading microbial populations in the aquifer studied.     

A tripartite microbial reporter gene system for real-time assays of soil nutrient status

Plant-derived carbon is the substrate which drives the rate of microbial assimilation and turnover of nutrients, in particular N and P, within the rhizosphere. To develop a better understanding of rhizosphere dynamics, a tripartite reporter gene system has been developed. We used three lux-marked Pseudomonas fluorescens strains to report on soil (1) assimilable carbon, (2) N-status, and (3) P-status. In vivo studies using soil water, spiked with C, N and P to simulate rhizosphere conditions, showed that the tripartite reporter system can provide real-time assessment of carbon and nutrient status. Good quantitative agreement for bioluminescence output between reference material and soil water samples was found for the C and P reporters. With regard to soil nitrate, the minimum bioavailable concentration was found to be greater than that analytically detectable in soil water. This is the first time that bioavailable soil C, N and P have been quantified using a tripartite reporter gene system.     

Quantitative analysis of small-subunit rRNA genes in mixed microbial populations via 5'-nuclease assays

Few techniques are currently available for quantifying specific prokaryotic taxa in environmental samples. Quantification of specific genotypes has relied mainly on oligonucleotide hybridization to extracted rRNA or intact rRNA in whole cells. However, low abundance and cellular rRNA content limit the application of these techniques in aquatic environments. In this study, we applied a newly developed quantitative PCR assay (5'-nuclease assay, also known as TaqMan) to quantify specific small-subunit (SSU) rRNA genes (rDNAs) from uncultivated planktonic prokaryotes in Monterey Bay. Primer and probe combinations for quantification of SSU rDNAs at the domain and group levels were developed and tested for specificity and quantitative reliability. We examined the spatial and temporal variations of SSU rDNAs from Synechococcus plus Prochlorococcus and marine Archaea and compared the results of the quantitative PCR assays to those obtained by alternative methods. The 5'-nuclease assays reliably quantified rDNAs over at least 4 orders of magnitude and accurately measured the proportions of genes in artificial mixtures. The spatial and temporal distributions of planktonic microbial groups measured by the 5'-nuclease assays were similar to the distributions estimated by quantitative oligonucleotide probe hybridization, whole-cell hybridization assays, and flow cytometry.     

16S rDNA analysis reveals low microbial diversity in community level physiological profile assays

The metabolic diversity of microbial communities is fundamental for the multiple soil functions mediated by microorganisms. Community level physiological profiles (CLPPs) based on sole C source oxidation have been used as a fast and reproducible tool to study soil microbial functional diversity because the utilisation of available carbon is the key factor governing microbial growth in soil. Our aim was to assess the phylogenetic affiliation of the microorganisms responsible for C consumption after inoculating Biolog plates. For this purpose, two semi-arid Mediterranean forest soils with significantly different patterns of C consumption and microbial community structure were used. Following the inoculation of the Biolog plates, suspensions from seven wells were sampled after 1, 2 and 7 d of incubation. DNA was extracted and the microbial communities analysed by polymerase chain reaction followed by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (PCR-DGGE) and sequencing of excised bands. Despite major differences in the microbial communities of the soils studied, their DGGE banding patterns after incubation were similar for all the analysed C source suspensions. Microorganisms belonging to beta-Proteobacteria (Ralstonia sp. and Burkholderia sp.) and alpha-Proteobacteria (Rhizobium sp.) were dominant. These opportunists had a competitive advantage under the conditions at which the CLPPs were analysed. This study reveals that significantly different CLPP patterns can be generated on the basis of only 3-4 genera, as reflected by PCR-DGGE analysis. Also for this reason, CLPPs based on incubations of soil suspensions should just be used as a screening method and always be accompanied by other techniques for community analysis.     

High-throughput colorimetric assays optimized for detection of ketones and aldehydes produced by microbial cell factories

Randomized strain and pathway engineering are critical to improving microbial cell factory performance, calling for the development of high-throughput screening and selection systems. To facilitate this effort, we have developed two 96-well plate format colorimetric assays for reliable quantification of various ketones and aldehydes from culture supernatants, based on either a vanillin-acetone reaction or the 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine (2,4-DNPH) reagent. The vanillin-acetone assay enabled accurate and selective measurement of acetone titers up to 2 g l⁻¹ in a minimal culture medium. The 2,4-DNPH-based assay can be used for a wide range of aldehydes and ketones, shown here through the optimization of conditions for 15 different compounds. Both assays were implemented to improve acetone production from different substrates by an engineered Escherichia coli strain. The fast and user-friendly colorimetric assays proposed here open the potential for iterative rounds of (automated) strain and pathway engineering and screening, facilitating the efforts towards further boosting production titers of industrially relevant ketones and aldehydes.     

Evaluation of Escherichia coli K-12 343/113 and derived strains for microbial mutagenicity assays

Several characteristics of the E. coli K-12 mutagenicity tester strains 343/113 and 343/120 have been investigated for their effects on induced mutagenesis using the arg56 and nad113 genes, and resistance to valine. We found, as have earlier authors, that the nad113 marker is relatively specific for detecting frameshift-inducing mutagens and relatively insensitive to agents that cause point mutations. In contrast, both the Arg and Val markers are primarily specific for reversion (or mutation) induction by point mutagens. In all cases tested, the Arg and Val markers respond to mutagens in a qualitatively similar manner. We have enhanced the sensitivity of this tester system to a wide variety of mutagens by permeabilization of the tester cell population using Tris-EDTA treatment. This treatment prior to mutagen exposure enables the detection of mutagenicity of several compounds that are weakly mutagenic or nonmutagenic in untreated cells. We have also increased the mutagenicity of some chemicals by preincubating with rat-liver S9 at pH values other than 7.4. For diethylnitrosamine, for instance, maximal induction occurred at pH 6.5, and for benzo[a]pyrene, maximal induction was at pH 6.8.     

The microbial pan-genome

A decade after the beginning of the genomic era, the question of how genomics can describe a bacterial species has not been fully addressed. Experimental data have shown that in some species new genes are discovered even after sequencing the genomes of several strains. Mathematical modeling predicts that new genes will be discovered even after sequencing hundreds of genomes per species. Therefore, a bacterial species can be described by its pan-genome, which is composed of a "core genome" containing genes present in all strains, and a "dispensable genome" containing genes present in two or more strains and genes unique to single strains. Given that the number of unique genes is vast, the pan-genome of a bacterial species might be orders of magnitude larger than any single genome.