Application of isothermal titration calorimetry and column chromatography for identification of biomolecular targets

This protocol describes a method for identifying unknown target proteins from a mixture of biomolecules for a given drug or a lead compound. This method is based on a combination of chromatography and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) where ITC is used as a tracking tool. The first step involves the use of ITC to confirm the binding of ligand to a component in the biomolecular mixture. Subsequently, the biomolecular mixture is fractionated by chromatography, and the binding of the ligand with individual fractions (or subfractions) is verified by ITC. The iteration of chromatographic purification on the fractions combined with ITC results in identifying the target protein. This method is useful when the target protein or ligand is unknown and/or not amenable to labeling, chemical modification or immobilization. This protocol has been successfully used by our team and by others to identify both low-abundance and highly abundant target proteins present in biomolecular mixtures. With this protocol, it takes approximately 3-5 d to identify the target protein from a mixture.     

RepTAGs: universal tags for isolation and labeling of proteins, for labeling live mammalian cells and for drug discovery

Methods for specific immobilization, isolation and labeling of proteins are central to the elucidation of cellular functions. Based on bacterial repressor proteins, which bind to specific target sequences in response to small molecules (macrolide and tetracycline antibiotics) or environmental parameters (temperature), we have developed a set of protein tags (RepTAGs), which enable reversible immobilization of the protein of interest on a solid support for the isolation and quantification as well as for the specific labeling of target proteins with fluorescent dyes for tracking them within a complex protein mixture. Similarly, live mammalian cells were specifically labeled with a fluorescent operator sequence bound to RepTAGs, which were directed towards the cell surface for easy discrimination between transfected and untransfected cell populations. Based on the drug-responsive RepTAG-DNA interactions, it was also possible to quantify or discover antibiotics in environmental samples or compound libraries by means of rapid, sensitive detection methods involving fluorescence polarization and bioluminescence. We believe that the universally applicable RepTAGs will become essential for the analysis and manipulation of proteins in the most diverse areas of protein chemistry and cell biology.     

Cloning and characterization of a family C orphan G-protein coupled receptor

Members of the family C receptors within the G-protein coupled receptor superfamily include the metabotropic glutamate receptors, GABA(B) receptors, the calcium-sensing receptor (CaSR), the V2R pheromone receptors, the T1R taste receptors, and a small group of uncharacterized orphan receptors. We have cloned and studied the mouse GPRC6A family C orphan receptor. The open reading frame codes for a protein with highest sequence identity to the fish 5.24 odorant receptor and the mammalian CaSR. The gene structure shows a striking resemblance to that of the CaSR. Results from RT-PCR analyses showed that mouse GPRC6A mRNA is expressed in mouse brain, skeletal muscle, heart, lung, spleen, kidney, liver, and in the early stage mouse embryo. Immunocytochemical analysis of the cloned mouse GPRC6A cDNA expressed in human embryonic kidney 293 cells demonstrated that GPRC6A was present on the plasma membrane, as well as in the endoplasmic reticulum and nuclear envelope membranes of transfected cells. A chimeric cDNA construct in which the extracellular ligand binding domain of the fish 5.24 amino acid-activated odorant receptor was ligated to the complementary downstream sequence of the mouse GPRC6A receptor indicated that GPRC6A is coupled to phosphoinositol turnover and release of intracellular calcium. Further studies with mouse GPRC6A expressed in Xenopus laevis oocytes demonstrated that this receptor possesses a pharmacological profile resembling that of the fish 5.24 odorant receptor. These findings suggest that GPRC6A may function as the receptor component of a novel cellular transmitter system in mammals.     

Chemical proteomics from a nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy perspective

Proteomics is the study of the protein complement of a genome and employs a number of newly emerging tools. One such tool is chemical proteomics, which is a branch of proteomics devoted to the exploration of protein function using both in vitro and in vivo chemical probes. Chemical proteomics aims to define protein function and mechanism at the level of directly observed protein–ligand interactions, whereas chemical genomics aims to define the biological role of a protein using chemical knockouts and observing phenotypic changes. Chemical proteomics is therefore traditional mechanistic biochemistry performed in a systems-based manner, using either activity- or affinity-based probes that target proteins related by chemical reactivities or by binding site shape/properties, respectively. Systems are groups of proteins related by metabolic pathway, regulatory pathway or binding to the same ligand. Studies can be based on two main types of proteome samples: pooled proteins (1 mixture of N proteins) or isolated proteins in a given system and studied in parallel (N single protein samples). Although the field of chemical proteomics originated with the use of covalent labeling strategies such as isotope-coded affinity tagging, it is expanding to include chemical probes that bind proteins noncovalently, and to include more methods for observing protein–ligand interactions. This review presents an emerging role for nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in chemical proteomics, both in vitro and in vivo. Applications include: functional proteomics using cofactor fingerprinting to assign proteins to gene families; gene family-based structural characterizations of protein–ligand complexes; gene family-focused design of drug leads; and chemical proteomic probes using nuclear magnetic resonance SOLVE and studies of protein–ligand interactions in vivo.     

SpeedScreen: label-free liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry-based high-throughput screening for the discovery of orphan protein ligands

A high-throughput screening methodology tailored to the discovery of ligands for known and orphan proteins is presented. With this method, labeling of neither target protein nor screened compounds is required, as the ligands are affinity selected by incubation of the protein with mixtures of compounds in aqueous binding buffer. Unbound small-molecular-weight compounds are removed from the target protein:ligand complex by rapid size-exclusion chromatography in the 96-well format. The protein fraction is analyzed subsequently by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry for detection and identification of the bound ligand. This screening method was validated with known protein:ligand model systems and optimized for selection of high-affinity binders in an industrial screening environment. All sample handling steps and the analytics are rapid, robust, and largely automated, adopting this technology to the needs of present high-throughput screening processes. This affinity-selection technology, termed SpeedScreen, is currently an integral part of our lead discovery process.     

The mammalian orphan nuclear receptors: orphans as cellular guardians

In classical endocrinology, receptors are molecules that bind a hormone or a ligand to transduce signal within a target cell. Later, however, many intracellular receptors have been discovered in mammals, which have not been shown to bind endogenous ligands and are now are referred as “orphan receptors.” The orphan receptors share high degree of structural and functional homology with the classical nuclear receptors (NRs) and are now part of the NR superfamily and therefore referred as orphan nuclear receptors (ONRs). Interestingly, however, ONR members are not evolutionarily or functionally linked and they form a highly diverse group within the NR superfamily. In mammals, ONRs exhibit great functional diversity and majority of them are expressed in a tissue-specific fashion. In the past one decade, functional studies have revealed that they are mediators of multitude of crucial metabolic, developmental, reproductive, and immunological functions in mammals. Emerging studies also indicate the role of ONRs in the onset of several complex human diseases and hence they may be potential candidates for therapeutic drug targeting in the future.     

The thermodynamic signature of ligand binding to histone deacetylase-like amidohydrolases is most sensitive to the flexibility in the L2-loop lining the active site pocket

BackgroundThe analysis of the thermodynamic driving forces of ligand-protein binding has been suggested to be a key component for the selection and optimization of active compounds into drug candidates. The binding enthalpy as deduced from isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is usually interpreted assuming single-step binding of a ligand to one conformation of the target protein. Although successful in many cases, these assumptions are oversimplified approximations of the reality with flexible proteins and complicated binding mechanism in many if not most cases. The relationship between protein flexibility and thermodynamic signature of ligand binding is largely understudied.MethodsDirected mutagenesis, X-ray crystallography, enzyme kinetics and ITC methods were combined to dissect the influence of loop flexibility on the thermodynamics and mechanism of ligand binding to histone deacetylase (HDAC)-like amidohydrolases.ResultsThe general ligand-protein binding mechanism comprises an energetically demanding gate opening step followed by physical binding. Increased flexibility of the L2-loop in HDAC-like amidohydrolases facilitates access of ligands to the binding pocket resulting in predominantly enthalpy-driven complex formation.ConclusionsThe study provides evidence for the great importance of flexibility adjacent to the active site channel for the mechanism and observed thermodynamic driving forces of molecular recognition in HDAC like enzymes.General significanceThe flexibility or malleability in regions adjacent to binding pockets should be given more attention when designing better drug candidates. The presented case study also suggests that the observed binding enthalpy of protein-ligand systems should be interpreted with caution, since more complicated binding mechanisms may obscure the significance regarding potential drug likeness.     

Efficient stable isotope labeling and purification of vitamin D receptor from inclusion bodies

Vitamin D receptor (VDR) plays a crucial role in many cellular processes including calcium and phosphate homeostasis. Previous purification methods from prokaryotic and eukaryotic expression systems were challenged by low protein solubility accompanied by multi purification steps resulting in poor protein recovery. The full-length VDR and its ligand binding domain (LBD) were mostly (>90%) insoluble even when expressed at low temperatures in the bacterial system. We describe a one-step procedure that results in the purification of rat VDR and LBD proteins in high-yield from Escherichia coli inclusion bodies. The heterologously expressed protein constructs retained full function as demonstrated by ligand binding and DNA binding assays. Furthermore, we describe an efficient strategy for labeling these proteins with (2)H, (13)C, and (15)N for structural and functional studies by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. This efficient production system will facilitate future studies on the mechanism of vitamin D action including characterization of the large number of synthetic vitamin D analogs that have been developed.     

Development of surface plasmon resonance biosensor assays for primary and secondary screening of acetylcholine binding protein ligands

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensors recently gained an important place in drug discovery. Here we present a primary and secondary SPR biosensor screening methodology. The primary screening method is based on a direct binding assay with covalent immobilized drug target proteins. For the secondary screening method, a sequential competition assay has been developed where the captured protein is first exposed to an unknown test compound, followed directly by an exposure to a high-molecular-weight reporter ligand. Using the high-molecular-weight reporter ligand to probe the remaining free binding site on the sensor, a significant signal enhancement is obtained. Furthermore, this assay format allows the validation of the primary direct binding assay format, efficiently revealing false positive data. As a model system, acetylcholine binding protein (AChBP), which is a soluble model protein for neuronal nicotinic acetylcholine receptors, has been used. The secondary assay is lower in throughput than the primary assay; however, the signal-to-noise ratio is two times higher compared with the direct assay, and it has a z′ factor of 0.96. Using both assays, we identified the compound tacrine as a ligand for AChBP.     

Multiplex GPCR assay in reverse transfection cell microarrays

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are a superfamily of proteins that include some of the most important drug targets in the pharmaceutical industry. Despite the success of this group of drugs, there remains a need to identify GPCR-targeted drugs with greater selectivity, to develop screening assays for validated targets, and to identify ligands for orphan receptors. To address these challenges, the authors have created a multiplexed GPCR assay that measures greater than 3000 receptor: ligand interactions in a single microplate. The multiplexed assay is generated by combining reverse transfection in a 96-well plate format with a calcium flux readout. This assay quantitatively measures receptor activation and inhibition and permits the determination of compound potency and selectivity for entire families of GPCRs in parallel. To expand the number of GPCR targets that may be screened in this system, receptors are cotransfected with plasmids encoding a promiscuous G protein, permitting the analysis of receptors that do not normally mobilize intracellular calcium upon activation. The authors demonstrate the utility of reverse transfection cell microarrays to GPCR-targeted drug discovery with examples of ligand selectivity screening against a panel of GPCRs as well as dose-dependent titrations of selected agonists and antagonists.     

Thermal proteome profiling: unbiased assessment of protein state through heat-induced stability changes

In recent years, phenotypic-based screens have become increasingly popular in drug discovery. A major challenge of this approach is that it does not provide information about the mechanism of action of the hits. This has led to the development of multiple strategies for target deconvolution. Thermal proteome profiling (TPP) allows for an unbiased search of drug targets and can be applied in living cells without requiring compound labeling. TPP is based on the principle that proteins become more resistant to heat-induced unfolding when complexed with a ligand, e.g., the hit compound from a phenotypic screen. The melting proteome is also sensitive to other intracellular events, such as levels of metabolites, post-translational modifications and protein-protein interactions. In this review, we describe the principles of this approach, review the method and its developments, and discuss its current and future applications. While proteomics has generally focused on measuring relative protein concentrations, TPP provides a novel approach to gather complementary information on protein stability not present in expression datasets. Therefore, this strategy has great potential not only for drug discovery, but also for answering fundamental biological questions.     

Aptamers as reagents for high-throughput screening

The identification of new drug candidates from chemical libraries is a major component of discovery research in many pharmaceutical companies. Given the large size of many conventional and combinatorial libraries and the rapid increase in the number of possible therapeutic targets, the speed with which efficient high-throughput screening (HTS) assays can be developed can be a rate-limiting step in the discovery process. We show here that aptamers, nucleic acids that bind other molecules with high affinity, can be used as versatile reagents in competition binding HTS assays to identify and optimize small-molecule ligands to protein targets. To illustrate this application, we have used labeled aptamers to platelet-derived growth factor B-chain and wheat germ agglutinin to screen two sets of potential small-molecule ligands. In both cases, binding affinities of all ligands tested (small molecules and aptamers) were strongly correlated with their inhibitory potencies in functional assays. The major advantages of using aptamers in HTS assays are speed of aptamer identification, high affinity of aptamers for protein targets, relatively large aptamer-protein interaction surfaces, and compatibility with various labeling/detection strategies. Aptamers may be particularly useful in HTS assays with protein targets that have no known binding partners such as orphan receptors. Since aptamers that bind to proteins are often specific and potent antagonists of protein function, the use of aptamers for target validation can be coupled with their subsequent use in HTS.     

NMR resonance assignment of selectively labeled proteins by the use of paramagnetic ligands

Selective isotopic labeling of larger proteins greatly simplifies protein NMR spectra and reduces signal overlap, but selectively labeled proteins cannot be easily assigned since the sequential assignment method is not applicable. Here we describe a strategy for resonance assignment in selectively labeled proteins. Our approach involves a spin-labeled analog of a ligand of which the three-dimensional structure in complex with the target protein is known. Other methods for introduction of the spin label are possible. The paramagnetic center causes faster relaxation of all neighboring nuclei in a distance-dependent manner. Measurement of this effect allows to deduce distances between isotopically labeled residues and the paramagnetic center which can be used for resonance assignment. The method is demonstrated for the catalytic domain of Abl kinase in complex with the inhibitor, STI571.     

Comparative thermodynamic analysis of cyclic nucleotide binding to protein kinase A

We have investigated the thermodynamic parameters and binding of a regulatory subunit of cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) to its natural low-molecular-weight ligand, cAMP, and analogues thereof. For analysis of this model system, we compared side-by-side isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) with surface plasmon resonance (SPR). Both ITC and SPR analyses revealed that binding of the protein to cAMP or its analogues was enthalpically driven and characterised by similar free energy values (DeltaG=-9.4 to -10.7 kcal mol-1) for all interactions. Despite the similar affinities, binding of the cyclic nucleotides used here was characterised by significant differences in the contribution of entropy (-TDeltaS) and enthalpy (DeltaH) to DeltaG. The comparison of ITC and SPR data for one cAMP analogue further revealed deviations caused by the method. These equilibrium parameters could be complemented by thermodynamic data of the transition state (DeltaHnot equal, DeltaGnot equal, DeltaSnot equal) for both association and dissociation measured by SPR. This direct comparison of ITC and SPR highlights method-specific advantages and drawbacks for thermodynamic analyses of protein/ligand interactions.     

Chemical synthesis and biochemical characterization of a biotinylated derivative of 17beta-estradiol with a long side chain covalently attached to its C-7alpha position

High-affinity biotinylated derivatives of 17beta-estradiol (E(2)) are of value for isolation of various estrogen-binding proteins (including estrogen receptors) and also for studying protein-protein interactions involving these proteins. In this study, we developed a simplified route for the chemical synthesis of a biotinylated derivative of E(2) (compound 7) with a side chain attached to its C-7alpha position. Compound 7, i.e., 7alpha-{7-[8-(biotinamido)-octanamido]-heptyl}-estradiol, could be readily synthesized from 6-keto-estradiol-3,17beta-di-tetrahydropyranyl ether (compound 2, which can be prepared from E(2)), with a final yield of 36%. In vitro receptor-binding assay confirmed that the synthesized affinity ligand has a high binding affinity for both human estrogen receptor alpha and beta. When the affinity ligand (compound 7) was immobilized with avidin on an affinity column, it effectively bound human estrogen receptor alpha, and the receptor protein could be selectively eluted with a biotin-containing buffer. Using the same affinity ligand, prolyl 4-hydroxylase beta-subunit (also known as protein disulfide isomerase) was identified as one of the high-affinity E(2)-binding proteins in the whole cytosolic protein mixture prepared from MCF-7 human breast cancer cells. Computational molecular modeling analysis showed that compound 7 can bind to human estrogen receptor alpha in a similar manner as ICI-182,780 and raloxifene, and their binding energy values are also similar.     

Chemical proteomics from a nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy perspective

Proteomics is the study of the protein complement of a genome and employs a number of newly emerging tools. One such tool is chemical proteomics, which is a branch of proteomics devoted to the exploration of protein function using both in vitro and in vivo chemical probes. Chemical proteomics aims to define protein function and mechanism at the level of directly observed protein-ligand interactions, whereas chemical genomics aims to define the biological role of a protein using chemical knockouts and observing phenotypic changes. Chemical proteomics is therefore traditional mechanistic biochemistry performed in a systems-based manner, using either activity- or affinity-based probes that target proteins related by chemical reactivities or by binding site shape/properties, respectively. Systems are groups of proteins related by metabolic pathway, regulatory pathway or binding to the same ligand. Studies can be based on two main types of proteome samples: pooled proteins (1 mixture of N proteins) or isolated proteins in a given system and studied in parallel (N single protein samples). Although the field of chemical proteomics originated with the use of covalent labeling strategies such as isotope-coded affinity tagging, it is expanding to include chemical probes that bind proteins noncovalently, and to include more methods for observing protein-ligand interactions. This review presents an emerging role for nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy in chemical proteomics, both in vitro and in vivo. Applications include: functional proteomics using cofactor fingerprinting to assign proteins to gene families; gene family-based structural characterizations of protein-ligand complexes; gene family-focused design of drug leads; and chemical proteomic probes using nuclear magnetic resonance SOLVE and studies of protein-ligand interactions in vivo.     

14C-methylamine-glutaraldehyde conjugation as an alternative to iodination for protein labeling

Radiolabeling of native proteins conventionally has required iodination using 125Iodine (125I). Although radioiodination can result in high specific activity, there are several drawbacks in the use of 125I (e.g., radiological hazards and short half-life). 14C-Methylamine-glutaraldehyde conjugation to proteins offers an alternative for radiolabeling of proteins that is safer and longer-lived alpha-2-Macroglobulin was radiolabeled by conjugation to a 14C-methylamine-glutaraldehyde conjugate. Analysis of the labeling procedure was performed using scintillation counting, gel filtration chromatography, and protein assays. The radiolabeled alpha-2-macroglobulin was activated using established protocols and tested for functional integrity using competitive binding assays in the presence of recombinant receptor associated protein, an alternative ligand for the alpha-2-macroglobulin cellular receptor. The function of alpha-2-macroglobulin was unaffected by the labeling procedure. Comparison of 14C-methylamine-labeling and iodination by Scatchard analysis yielded nonlinear plots that suggested the presence of two sets of receptors with different binding affinities but that do not show cooperativity. This technique offers an alternative to radioiodination for the sensitive labeling of proteins.     

Reactive group-embedded affinity labeling reagent for efficient intracellular protein labeling

Affinity labeling of a target protein is a powerful method for chemical biology studies. However, it is still difficult to label intracellular proteins efficiently in living cells. We propose the novel design strategy of a reactive group-embedded affinity labeling reagent for efficient protein labeling. With FKBP12 as the model target protein, the ligand binding pocket-oriented labeling reagent could label intracellular protein, whereas protein surface-oriented reagent was ineffective for labeling in living cells, partially because of the intracellular protein fluctuation under the macromolecular crowding effects. These results provide new insight for efficient intracellular protein labeling.     

Differential signaling properties at the kappa opioid receptor of 12-epi-salvinorin A and its analogues

The kappa opioid receptor (KOPR) has been identified as a potential drug target to prevent or alter the course of mood, anxiety and addictive disorders or reduce response to stress. In a search for highly potent and selective KOPR partial agonists as pharmacological tools, we have modified 12-epi-salvinorin A, a compound which we have previously observed to be a KOPR partial agonist. Five analogues of 12-epi-salvinorin A were synthesized and their effects on G protein activation as well as β-arrestin2 recruitment were evaluated. Only 12-epi-salvinorin A (1) partially activated signaling through G proteins, yet acted as a full agonist in the β-arrestin 2 DiscoveRx assay. Other salvinorin analogues tested in these functional assays were full agonists in both assays of KOPR activation. By comparison, the non-selective opioid ligand nalbuphine, known to be a partial agonist for G-protein activation, was also a partial agonist for the β-arrestin mediated signaling pathway activated through KOPR.     

Ligand binding affinity determined by temperature-dependent circular dichroism: cyclin-dependent kinase 2 inhibitors

To support drug discovery efforts for cyclin-dependent kinase 2 (CDK2), a moderate-throughput binding assay that can rank order or estimate the affinity of lead inhibitors has been developed. The method referred to as temperature-dependent circular dichroism (TdCD) uses the classical temperature-dependent unfolding of proteins by circular dichroism (CD) to measure the degree of protein unfolding in the absence and presence of potential inhibitors. The midpoint of unfolding is the Tm value. Rank ordering the affinity and predictions of the dissociation constant of compounds is obtained by measuring the increase in Tm for different protein-inhibitor complexes. This is the first time an extensive characterization of the TdCD method has been described for characterizing lead inhibitors in a drug discovery mode. The method has several favorable properties. Using the new six-cell Peltier temperature controller for the Jasco 810 spectropolarimeter, one can determine the affinity of 12-18 compounds per day. The method also requires only 20-40 microg protein per sample and can be used to estimate the affinity of compounds with dissociation constants of picomolar to micromolar. An important property of the method for lead discovery is that dissociation constants of approximately 5 microM can be estimated from a single experiment using a low concentration of compound such as 20 microM, which is generally low enough for most small molecules to be soluble for testing. In addition, the method does not require labeling the compound or protein. Although other methods such as isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) can provide a full thermodynamic characterization of binding, ITC requires 1-2 mg protein per sample, cannot readily determine binding constants below nanomolar values, is most versatile with soluble compounds, and has a throughput of two to three experiments per day. The ITC method is not usually used in a high-throughput drug discovery mode; however, using the thermodynamic information from several ITC experiments can make the TdCD method very robust in determining reliable binding constants. Using the kinase inhibitors BMS-250595, purvalanol B, AG-12275, flavopiridol, and several other compounds, it is demonstrated that one can obtain excellent comparisons between the Kd values of binding to CDK2 obtained by TdCD and ITC.