Appraisal of root leakage as a method for estimation of root viability

Abstract

We review the applications of REL test as a technique for detecting injury and thereby forecasting survivability of transplanted seedlings. The objectives of the present review are to present the fundamentals of this method, assess the relevant literature, present evidence of seasonal variations of REL, describe how REL responds to different stress conditions, suggest priorities for future research as well as practical recommendations for REL testing, and assess leakage of organic compounds as an indicator of root damage. Seasonal changes in REL may be connected with root freezing tolerance that varies among plants of different seed sources and species and thus does not always indicate health state of seedlings. REL technique can be used for assessing frost hardiness of roots under certain conditions (e.g. roots should be sampled into the test tubes prior to the freezing test). It can be used for studying heat stress with certain prerequisites (e.g. series of high temperatures or different exposure times should be used to find a threshold for heat tolerance). In desiccation tolerance assessment, REL presents high variation depending on species. In case of rough handling or hypoxic conditions, the effect depends on certain developmental stages. Additionally, though REL may be useful in quantifying damage caused by cold storage, it should be considered as a relative index of plant quality only since the relationship between REL and survivability could vary depending on cultural and handling practices prior to planting as well as on post-planting environmental conditions. In some cases, REL is correlated with field performance of seedlings, but in other cases the correlation is weak. Factors as species, seed lots, developmental stage of root tissue, season, and bud dormancy intensity may affect REL. Thus, REL must first be calibrated to these factors before it can be reliably used to predict the field performance of all types of seedling stock. Ambient storage, ageing and amino acids and protein leakage are also discussed. Limitations and questions for future research are suggested (e.g. species-dependence and decreasing variation). In general, REL is casually and statistically related with root damage and survivability of seedling. However, it depends on many other factors apart from root damages, and thus it remains a great challenge to improve its reliability.     

Influence of simulated snow cover on the cold tolerance and freezing injury of yellow-cedar seedlings

It has been hypothesized that yellow‐cedar [Chamaecyparis nootkatensis (D. Don) Spach] decline may result from root freezing injury following climate change‐induced reductions in protective snow cover. To test this hypothesis, we measured the freezing tolerance and injury expression of yellow‐cedar seedlings in three treatments that differed in the insulative protection they provided to soils during winter and spring: (1) full exposure to ambient temperatures (exposed treatment), (2) continuous protection from ambient temperatures via addition of perlite over pots (full protection), and (3) perlite protection only during winter and exposure to ambient temperatures during spring (partial protection). Foliage from all treatments was cold tolerant enough to prevent foliar freezing injury throughout the study period. However, on all sample dates, roots of seedlings from all treatments were only tolerant to about ?5 °C – a level considerably warmer than the reported maximum cold tolerance for the species and well above the soil temperature recorded in the exposed treatment. As a result of this limited root cold tolerance, visibly uninjured roots of seedlings from the exposed treatment had significantly higher relative electrolyte leakage (REL) throughout the winter and early spring than seedlings in soil protection treatments. Seedlings from the exposed treatment also had significantly higher foliar REL values and greater visual foliar injury than seedlings from the other treatments starting in early spring. For both roots and foliage, REL measurements consistently detected tissue damage before visual injury was evident. Patterns of injury from both REL and visual injury assessments showed the same pattern: damage began with freezing injury to roots and subsequently became evident as foliar browning after spring temperatures increased. All seedlings in the exposed treatment eventually had 100% fine root damage and died. This progression of initial root damage followed by foliar browning and mortality after the onset of warming conditions is consistent with reports of yellow‐cedar decline symptom development in the field.     

Assessing frost hardiness of Pinus bungeana shoots and needles by electrical impedance spectroscopy with and without freezing tests

Aims Nursery and forest operations require that frost hardiness results be produced faster than can be provided by controlled freezing tests. There is a great challenge to develop a rapid method for predicting frost hardiness that might not necessitate controlled freezing tests. The aim of this study was to examine the assessment of the frost hardiness of shoots and needles of Pinus bungeana by electrical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) with and without controlled exposure to freezing.Methods The frost hardiness of current-year shoots and needles of P. bungeana in an 8-year-old provenance field trial was measured at Shisanlin Nursery in Beijing, China, from September 2006 to January 2007 by means of EIS and conventional electrolyte leakage (EL). In the same plants, but without controlled freezing test, were monitored the EIS parameters in current-year shoots and needles.Important findings The results showed that (i) after controlled freezing tests, the frost hardiness estimated by EIS parameters (extracellular resistance, r e, and membrane time constant, τ m) was significantly correlated with the frost hardiness assessed by EL method (r = 0.95) and (ii) for the samples not exposed to controlled freezing treatment, the relaxation time τ 1 for shoots and β for needles had greater correlations with the frost hardiness estimated by EL after controlled freezing tests relative to the other parameters (r = ?0.90 for shoots and r = 0.84 for needles, respectively). The parameters r e of shoots and needles and τ m of needles might be applied for measuring frost hardiness of samples after exposed to controlled freezing tests. The frost hardiness results can be obtained within 48 h. The parameters τ 1 of shoots and β of needles could be used for estimating the frost hardiness of samples without using a controlled freezing test. The frost hardiness results can be obtained within 24 h.     

Membrane permeability to electrolytes in relation to frost hardiness in bromegrassBromus inennis Leyss) Cell Suspension Culture

Bromegrass cell suspension cultures, varying in frost hardiness, were immersed ìn distilled water and electrical conductivity of the bathing solutions was measured at various intervals after immersion. It was found that tissue frost-hardened by maintenance at 2?C leaked more electrolytes than the relatively frost-sensitive tissue grown at 20?C, but that tissue frost-hardened by abscisic add treatment displayed decreased leakage, despite comparable levels of frost-hardiness having been achieved. It is concluded, in contrast with the conclusion of a previous report, that changes in membrane permeability to electrolytes may not be directly related to the capacity of cells to tolerate freezing stress.     

水杨酸对大叶黄杨茎抗寒性和电阻抗图谱参数的影响

在抗寒锻炼前,对当年生大叶黄杨(Euonymus japonicus)扦插苗喷施不同浓度水杨酸,用电阻抗图谱(EIS)法和电导(EL)法估测茎的抗寒性,以探明抗寒锻炼期间水杨酸对大叶黄杨抗寒性和电阻抗图谱参数的影响,找到适合不经冷冻处理估测大叶黄杨茎抗寒性和经冷冻处理后测定其抗寒性的EIS参数。结果表明,水杨酸处理能够提高大叶黄杨茎的抗寒性,最适浓度为5.0mmol.L-1;不经冷冻处理茎的EIS参数电阻率r和r1、胞外电阻率re、胞内电阻率ri、弛豫时间τ、弛豫时间分布系数ψ与EL法测定的抗寒性有较高的相关性(r=0.70~0.87),说明不经冷冻处理样本用以上参数估测大叶黄杨茎抗寒性是可行的,r1为最佳参数;冷冻处理后茎的re、τ、ri求得的抗寒性与EL法测定的抗寒性有较高的相关性(r=0.85~0.94),说明冷冻处理后re、τ、ri可以作为测定大叶黄杨茎抗寒性的参数,re为最佳参数。     

Induction of Frost Hardiness in Stem Cortical Tissues of Cornus stolonifera Michx. by Water Stress: I. Unfrozen Water in Cortical Tissues and Water Status in Plants and Soil

Water supply and day length were varied in cold hardiness studies of red osier dogwood plants (Cornus stolonifera Michx.). The frost killing temperature, the content and freezing of stem cortical tissue water along with soil moisture content and tension were evaluated. Seven days of water stress in long and short day photoperiod regimes caused a rapid decrease in soil moisture content and plant water potential. During the same period, the frost hardiness increased from −3 to −11 C. Further water stress treatment had little effect. Control plants in short days showed only a gradual decrease in plant water potential and only gradually increased in frost hardiness while control plants in long days were unchanged. Freezing studies using nuclear magnetic resonance showed that increased hardiness in water-stressed plants resulted from both an increased tolerance of freezing and an increased avoidance of freezing, the latter resulting from higher solute concentration in the tissue solutions. The short day controls also showed similar changes; however, the changes were smaller over the 21 days of the study.     

Induction of Frost Hardiness in Stem Cortical Tissues of Cornus stolonifera Michx. by Water Stress: II. Biochemical Changes

A decrease of protein, RNAs, and starch, and an increase of sugar were observed in 3-day water-stressed red osier dogwood plants (Cornus stolonifera Michx.) when the frost hardiness increased from −3 to −6 C. As the frost hardiness increased to −11 C after 7 days of treatment, the starch continuously decreased, however, the proteins and RNAs increased with a continuous increase of sugar. Further water stress treatment had little effect on the changes of these chemicals. Control plants in short days showed similar gradual biochemical changes in patterns. From the results of frost hardiness increases, the pattern of biochemical changes, and the mechanism of the increased freezing resistance, it appears that the water stress and short days accomplished essentially the same physiological end(s) in inducing frost hardiness in red-osier dogwood.     

Effect of photoperiod and temperature on the development of frost hardiness in three Alnus species

The influence of short day and low temperature on cold acclimation of A. crispa (Ait.) Pursh, A. glutinosa (L.) Gaertn. and A. rubra Bong, was investigated. Two clones of each species originating from in vitro propagation were exposed to three daylength/temperature treatments. Periodically plantlets were exposed to controlled freezing temperature in order to evaluate their level of frost hardiness.
Short day (SD) and cold temperature (CT) and long day (LD) and cold temperature (CT) were the most effective treatments for the development of frost hardiness in shoots and roots of the three species tested. Short day (SD) and warm temperature (WT) induced a significant increase in hardiness in shoots of all three species. However, this treatment did not trigger root hardening. A. crispa was found to be the hardiest species followed by A. glutinosa and A. rubra . Intraspecific variation was observed between the two A. glutinosa clones. A glutinosa clone AG8, a Russian provenance, showed a greater freezing resistance than A. glutinosa clone AG2, a German provenance.     

Influence of soil temperature on root freezing tolerance of Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) seedlings

The influence of soil temperature on the root freezing tolerance of one-year-old containerized Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) seedlings was investigated. In addition, the TTC and electrolyte leakage methods were evaluated in terms of their suitability for use in detecting damage to roots caused by freezing. In mid-August, seedlings were placed in three thermostat-controlled soil beds in a greenhouse with an initial soil temperature of 14.3 °C. Soil temperature was lowered in two of the soil beds, resulting in temperatures of 10.7 and 5.3 °C respectively. Each soil temperature, i.e. 14.3, 10.7 and 5.3 °C was maintained for eight weeks. Starting in early September, damage to roots induced by artificial freezing was estimated biweekly by measuring electrolyte leakage, triphenyl tetrazolium chloride (TTC) reduction and potential root growth in a three-week cultivation test. In addition, the root freezing tolerance of seedlings placed outdoors was tested. Measurements showed that these seedlings were exposed to soil temperatures ranging from 13.0 °C in mid-August to 0.5 °C in November. Generally, the development of root freezing tolerance was more pronounced for seedlings exposed to lower (0.5 and 5.3 °C) soil temperatures compared with those exposed to higher (10.7 and 14.3 °C) ones. Root freezing tolerance was highest among the seedlings placed outdoors which were also exposed to the lowest soil temperatures registered in the study. To examine the effect of a temporary warm period, the soil temperature in one treatment was increased from 5.4 °C to 13.9 °C, maintained at the latter temperature for two weeks in October and then lowered to 5.7 °C. Root freezing tolerance was reduced by exposure to the warmer soil temperature. However, after four weeks at the colder soil temperature, the tolerance of the seedlings had returned to the level measured prior to exposure to the warm soil temperature. Methods based on the measurement of root electrolyte leakage and TTC reduction were both found to have limitations when used to detect root freezing damages in containerized seedlings. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Effect of frost nights and day and night temperature during dormancy induction on frost hardiness, tolerance to cold storage and bud burst in seedlings of Norway spruce

For trees, the ability to obtain and maintain sufficient levels of frost hardiness in late autumn, winter and spring is crucial. We report that temperatures during dormancy induction influence bud set, frost hardiness, tolerance to cold storage, timing of bud burst and spring frost hardiness in seedlings of Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.). Bud set occurred later in 12°C than in 21°C, and later in cool nights (7°C) than in constant temperature. One weekly frost night (−2.5°C) improved frost hardiness. Cool nights reduced frost hardiness early, but improved hardiness later during cold acclimation. Buds and stems were slightly hardier in 21°C than in 12°C, while needles were clearly hardier in 12°C. Cold daytime temperature, cool nights and one weekly frost night improved cold storability (0.7°C). Seedlings receiving high daytime temperatures burst buds later, and were less injured by light frost some days after bud burst.     

The effects of long-term elevation of air temperature and CO on the frost hardiness of Scots pine

The frost hardiness of 20 to 25-year-old Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) saplings was followed for 2 years in an experiment that attempted to simulate the predicted climatic conditions of the future, i.e. increased atmospheric CO₂ concentration and/or elevated air temperature. Frost hardiness was determined by an electrolyte leakage method and visual damage scoring on needles. Elevated temperatures caused needles to harden later and deharden earlier than the controls. In the first year, elevated CO₂ enhanced hardening at elevated temperatures, but this effect disappeared the next year. Dehardening was hastened by elevating CO₂ in both springs. The frost hardiness was high (相似文献   

Are budburst dates,dormancy and cold acclimation in walnut trees (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Juglans regia</Emphasis> L.) under mainly genotypic or environmental control?

As observed for most stresses, tree frost resistance can be split into two main processes: avoidance and tolerance. Avoidance of freezing is achieved by introducing species only in the climatic context in which the probability of freezing events is very low for the sensitive stages of buds or stems; i.e., when good synchronism exists between the annual cycle and the critical climatic periods. Buds become able to grow only after chilling requirements have been satisfied (endodormancy released) during winter; they subsequently break after heat requirements have been completed (end of ecodormancy) in early spring. Actually, this period is often subject to more or less severe freezing events. Trees are also able to adjust their freezing tolerance by increasing their capacity of extracellular freezing and decreasing the possibility of intracellular freezing through the process of frost acclimation. Both freezing resistance processes (avoidance and tolerance) are environmentally driven (by photoperiod and temperature), but there are also genotypic effects among species or cultivars. Here, we evaluated the degree to which differences in dormancy release and frost acclimation were related to environmental and genetic influences by comparing trees growing in common garden conditions. This investigation was carried out for two winters in lowland and mountain locations on different walnut genotypes differing significantly for budburst dates. Chilling requirement for endodormancy release and heat requirement during ecodormancy were evaluated in all situations. In addition, frost acclimation was assessed by the electrolyte leakage method on stems from the same trees before leaf fall through budburst. No significant differences were observed in chilling requirements among genotypes. Moreover, frost acclimation dynamics were similar between genotypes or locations when expressed depending on chilling units accumulated since 15 September as a time basis instead of Julian day. The only exception was for maximal frost hardiness observed during winter with the timber-oriented being significantly more resistant than fruit-oriented genotypes. Heat requirement was significantly different among genotypes. Thus, growth was significantly faster in fruit-oriented than in wood-oriented genotypes. Furthermore, among wood-oriented genotypes, differences in growth rate were observed only at cold temperatures. Frost acclimation changes differed significantly between fruit- and wood- walnuts from January through budburst. In conclusion, from September through January, the acclimation dynamic was driven mainly by environmental factors whereas from January through budburst a significant genotype effect was identified in both frost tolerance and avoidance processes.     

Freezing injury and root development in winter cereals

Upon exposure to 2°C, the leaves and crowns of rye (Secale cereale L. cv `Puma') and wheat (Triticum aestivum L. cv `Norstar' and `Cappelle') increased in cold hardiness, whereas little change in root cold hardiness was observed. Both root and shoot growth were severely reduced in cold-hardened Norstar wheat plants frozen to −11°C or lower and transplanted to soil. In contrast, shoot growth of plants grown in a nutrient agar medium and subjected to the same hardening and freezing conditions was not affected by freezing temperatures of −20°C while root growth was reduced at −15°C. Thus, it was apparent that lack of root development limited the ability of plants to survive freezing under natural conditions.

Generally, the temperatures at which 50% of the plants were killed as determined by the conductivity method were lower than those obtained by regrowth. A simple explanation for this difference is that the majority of cells in the crown are still alive while a small portion of the cells which are critical for regrowth are injured or killed.

Suspension cultures of Norstar wheat grown in B-5 liquid medium supplemented with 3 milligrams per liter of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid could be cold hardened to the same levels as soil growth plants. These cultures produce roots when transferred to the same growth medium supplemented with a low rate of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (<1 milligram per liter). When frozen to −15°C regrowth of cultures was 50% of the control, whereas the percentage of calli with root development was reduced 50% in cultures frozen to −11°C. These results suggest that freezing affects root morphogenesis rather than just killing the cells responsible for root regeneration.

     

Effect of a strong cold storage induced desiccation on metabolic solutes,stock quality and regrowth,in seedlings of two oak species

Bare-root seedlings of pedunculate oak (Quercus robur L.) and northern red oak (Quercus rubra L.) were lifted in January and stored at 1.8°C, at 82% relative humidity, until their fresh weight declined by 33%. Root growth potential (RGP), fine root electrolyte leakage (REL), fine root water content (RWC), shoot tip water content (SWC), starch and metabolic solute contents in root and shoot, were measured just after lifting and after treatment. Survival of treated seedlings was also assessed in a field trial. RWC, SWC, REL, RGP were dramatically affected by desiccation during cold storage. In both species, root soluble carbohydrate level, inositol level and isocitrate level increased, whereas root starch level and shoot soluble carbohydrate level decreased. In northern red oak, treated seedlings had higher root contents of soluble carbohydrates, inositol and proline than in pedunculate oak. Moreover, treatment induced proline accumulation only in northern red oak roots. These differences could explain why field survival of treated seedlings was significantly better in northern red oak than in pedunculate oak.     

低温处理葡萄根系对叶片PSII活性的影响

以美乐葡萄(Vitis vinifera cv. ‘Merlot’)幼苗为试材, 对叶片进行霜冻胁迫的同时控制土壤降温过程, 造成根系冷胁迫(2°C)和冻胁迫(0°C)。测定霜冻胁迫后和恢复期间叶片的快速叶绿素荧光参数, 并分析低温胁迫不同根系对叶片霜冻害程度的影响。结果表明, 根系在不同低温胁迫下会影响叶片对霜冻的反应, 根系冻胁迫造成叶片严重的霜冻伤害, 光系统II (PSII)反应中心活性难以得到恢复; 根系冷胁迫能避免叶片严重的低温伤害, 低温胁迫后PSII的活性也能很快恢复。     

Overexpression of a western white pine PR10 protein enhances cold tolerance in transgenic Arabidopsis

The PmPR10-1.10 protein from western white pine is known to be associated with frost hardiness, and up-regulated by seasonal cold acclimation and biotic and abiotic stresses. To gain insight into the molecular basis of cold hardiness, we investigated the potential physiological role of PmPR10-1.10 by gene overexpression in transgenic Arabidopsis plants. A binary vector was constructed for PmPR10-1.10 synthesis in higher plants and transgenic Arabidopsis lines were generated by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Following Western protein blot analysis confirming target protein production, transgenic Arabidopsis lines were tested for cold tolerance by electrolyte leakage analysis post treatment of different freezing temperatures. Our results demonstrate that accumulation of PmPR10-1.10 protein resulted in significantly greater freezing tolerance in transgenic plants than in wild type plants. This indicates that the transfer and selection of cold acclimation proteins like PmPR10-1.10 may be a breeding strategy for the development of freezing tolerance in conifers.     

The relative hardening of roots and shoots and the influence of day-length during hardening in perennial ryegrass

The influence of long and short days during the hardening period on the cold hardiness of perennial ryegrass seedlings was studied as was the relative hardiness of roots and shoots. Hardiness was assessed by the electrolyte release method which was a measure of the amount of damage subsequent to low temperature treatment. Long days promoted hardiness in shoots of Pax 0tofte plants and in one case under short days the roots were found to be hardy. Generally roots were less hardy than shoots in Pax 0tofte and S23 plants hardened under long days for 2 wk. When hardened at the fourth leaf stage for 2 wk at + 5 ^oC under long day conditions, Pax 0tofte plants were more hardy than those of S23. The long day effect on hardiness was arrived at more rapidly, there being no difference in hardiness after 3 wk in Pax 0tofte hardened under long or short days, whereas a significant degree of hardening was observed after 1 wk of hardening under long days at – 4 ^oC. The results obtained are discussed in relation to winter kill of grasses in the West of Scotland, and it is considered that root damage is not an important factor in causing winter kill. The promotive effect of long days on hardiness when hardening commences in late autumn is considered an advantage in temperate regions as it may also allow early frosts to be withstood.     

Differences in frost hardiness of two Norway spruce morphotypes growing at Mt. Brocken, Germany

Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) exhibits strong ecotypic variation along altitudinal gradients in morphological traits, e.g. slenderness of crowns or arrangement of second-order branches. We were interested whether montane and lowland morphotypes differ in a key trait for the survival in cold environments, i.e. frost hardiness, and asked: (i) are montane morphotypes more resistant to frost damage and (ii) do they have a lower risk of frost damage by late frosts in spring than lowland morphotypes?We used the electrolyte leakage-method to measure frost hardiness on a monthly basis from October 2006 to May 2007 in stands of the montane and lowland morphotypes at Mt. Brocken in the Harz Mountains, Germany.LT₅₀ (i.e. the temperature that results in 50% of maximum electrolyte leakage) was assessed by freezing treatments in a frost chamber and was significantly influenced by morphotype, month and minimum ambient temperatures. LT₅₀ was significantly lower in the montane than in the lowland morphotype, with −107 °C and −49 °C, respectively. However, the interactions between morphotype with minimum ambient temperature or month were not significant. Thus, as frost hardiness of the two morphotypes responded to temperature in the same way, both morphotypes can be supposed to be exposed to the same risk of frost damage during hardening in autumn and dehardening in spring.     

烟草NTHK1基因提高杨树根系的耐盐性

以受体杨树‘107号’和转入NTHK1（Nicotiana tabacum histidine kinase-1）基因的‘18-1’及‘18-4’的水培苗为材料,不同浓度的NaCl胁迫12d后,发现‘18-1’及‘18-4’的根长和根重显著大于‘107号’。以离体根段为材料,在400mmol·L-1NaCl溶液中胁迫60min后,‘107号’的K＋外渗量比‘18-1’和‘18-4’分别高49.34%和19.68%;在400mmol·L-1KCl或NaCl胁迫30min,‘107号’的电解质外渗率（REL）显著大于‘18-1’和‘18-4’;等渗的30%PEG对离体根段的REL影响很小。在400mmol·L-1NaCl溶液中添加200～400mmol·L-1的KNO3或KCl能显著增加离体根段的REL,并使不同基因型的REL差异更大。这表明,测定离体根段的K＋外渗量和REL可以快速鉴定不同基因型杨树的耐盐潜力。     

Studies of Frost Hardiness in Woody Plants. II. Effect of Temperature on Hardening

The effect of temperature on hardening was studied at temperatures ranging from 0° to −20° using twigs of willow and poplar. In October and in late April when the twigs are not very frost hardy, hardening at 0° produced a considerable increase in their frost hardiness, although the effectiveness of hardening at 0° decreased with a decrease in the environmental temperature. In twigs which could withstand continuous freezing without injury, hardening at −3° to −5° was most effective in increasing the frost hardiness of the twigs. Below −20°, only negligible increase was observed either in frost hardiness or sugar content.

The rate of starch to sugar conversion differed remarkably in different twig tissues. The starch in xylem was more slowly converted to sugar than that in the cortex. The optimum temperature for converting starch into sugar during frost hardening was also found to be −3° to −5°. In addition, the greater the effectiveness of the hardening treatment, the greater the rate of conversion from starch to sugar. The frost hardiness of a twig is closely related to the sugar content of the twig, especially in the xylem.