Analysis of myogenesis by somatic cell hybridization: III. Myogenic competence of hybrids derived from rat L6 myoblasts and mouse primary fibroblasts and myoblasts

Hybrid cells derived from rat L6 myoblasts and mouse primary fibroblasts (M x F hybrids), as well as those derived from rat L6 myoblasts and mouse primary myoblasts (M x M hybrids), were examined for their ability to engage in myogenesis as judged by muscle fiber formation plus the expression of skeletal muscle myosin and creatine kinase (CK). Of 172 primary hybrid colonies scored, 59% were myogenic in the M x F fusion and 97% exhibited muscle fiber formation in the M x M fusion. Individual hybrid clones from each cross were isolated, expanded and analyzed for myogenic capabilities as well. All three M x M and all ten M x F isolated clones exhibited preferential elimination of mouse chromosomes. Nonetheless, all were capable of fusing spontaneously and of elaborating skeletal muscle myosin and CK. The three M x M hybrids expressed only MM-CK whereas nine out of ten M x F hybrids produced all three CK isoenzymes (MM, MB, BB). These results suggest that M X M hybrids express CK patterns reminiscent of the rat L6 parental cells while M X F hybrids apparently mimic mouse muscle fiber CK patterns. Various models are discussed which address these phenomena.     

Genetic regulation of CFA expression in interspecific avian hybrids and somatic cell hybrids

Chicken fetal-leukemic antigen (CFA) is an oncodevelopmental antigen present on embryonic and neonatal chicken peripheral red blood cells (RBCs) but is not restricted to fetal stages of development in other avian species. Crosses between white Leghorn chickens and Japanese quail resulted in adult hybrids whose peripheral RBCs were positive for CFA. Of the four CFA determinants normally found in adult quail RBCs, only two were present on quail-chicken hybrid RBCs. Adult quail--chicken hybrid RBCs also possessed on CFA determinant associated with early development in both quail and chicken and one chicken-specific CFA determinant. Evidence is presented for the possible association of CFA-positive adult peripheral RBCs and the level of circulating reticulocytes. Crosses between pheasant and turkey (both with CFA-positive adult RBCs) resulted in hybrid adult RBCs expressing only a portion of the parental CFA determinants. Through the formation of somatic cell hybrids between adult chicken and embryonic Japanese quail RBCs, it was possible to induce the appearance of CFA determinants normally restricted to embryonic chicken RBCs. Approximately 50% of the hybrid cells showed reexpression of CFA, and this induction was both time and temperature dependent. Hybridization between RBCs of adult chicken and those of either adult Japanese quail or adult turkey failed to elicit the reexpression of chicken-specific CFA.     

Evidence for trans regulation of apoptosis in intertypic somatic cell hybrids.

The genetic components required for glucocorticoid induction of apoptosis were studied by using somatic cell hybridization. Intertypic whole-cell hybrids were generated by crossing the glucocorticoid-resistant rat liver cell line Fado-2 with the glucocorticoid-sensitive mouse thymoma cell line BW5147.3. Morphological and biochemical criteria were used to assess sensitivity or resistance to glucocorticoid-induced cell death. Both phenotypes were observed, and all of the hybrids retained a functional glucocorticoid receptor as judged by their abilities to induce the metallothionein gene in response to dexamethasone (Dex). Sensitivity to apoptosis did not correlate with morphological phenotype in that not all suspension cells were sensitive. The effect of glucocorticoids on the expression of apoptosis-linked genes was analyzed in a subset of Dex-sensitive and Dex-resistant hybrids. p53 and c-myc mRNAs were present in parental cells as well as sensitive and resistant hybrid cells, and their levels were not affected by glucocorticoid treatment. bcl-2 expression was restricted to the thymoma cell line and was also not affected by glucocorticoids. We did not detect any bcl-2 mRNA in the hepatoma cell line and the hybrids, suggesting that, as with most tissue-specific genes, bcl-2 is regulated in trans. Furthermore, while the majority of hybrids analyzed retained a full complement of mouse chromosomes, sensitive hybrids were missing some rat chromosomes (preferentially chromosomes 16 and 19), indicating that apoptosis is subject to trans repression. Resistant cells thus appear to repress the activity or synthesis of a nuclear factor that interacts with a glucocorticoid-dependent gene(s) to activate the cell death pathway.     

Expression of the regulation of cAMP metabolism in somatic cell hybrids

Normal rat liver cells (BRL-1) that respond to isoproterenol (beta+2), prostaglandin E1 (PGE+1) and adenosine (Ado+) with a rise in adenosine 3':5'-monophosphate (cAMP) content have been hybridized with rat hepatoma cells (H35) which do not respond to any of these agonists (beta-2, PGE-1 and Ado-). Both the initial hybrid line (BF5) and a subclone (BF5-1-1) expressed a beta+2, PGE+1, Ado- phenotype. However, full expression of the responsive phenotype in the BF5 line was apparent only if phosphodiesterase activity was blocked, for example, by methylisobutylxanthine (MIX). Direct measurements showed the rate of degradation of cAMP to be 7 times greater in intact BF5 cells than in the BRL-1 parent. In contrast to BF5 cells, the BF5-1-1 cells did not express maximal responsiveness to any of the agonists even in the presence of MIX. The differential accumulation of intracellular cAMP observed with BRL-1, BF5 and BF5-1-1 cells in response to isoproterenol was shown not to be as a result of differential rates of excretion of cAMP. Furthermore, no differences in the apparent affinities of the beta 2-catecholamine receptors for isoproterenol were observed. It is suggested that the increased degradative capacity of BF5 cells accounts for the difference in cAMP accumulation in these cells compared with the BRL-1 parent. The reduced responsiveness of BF5-1-1 cells, however, does not appear to be solely due to increased phosphodiesterase activity. It appears that the beta 2- phenotype may not always be dominant in hybrid crosses of this type as has been reported previously.     

MyoD and myogenesis in C. elegans

One of the goals in developmental biology is the identification of key regulatory genes that govern the transition of embryonic cells from a pluripotent potential to a specific, committed cell fate. During vertebrate skeletal myogenesis, this transition is regulated by the MyoD family of genes. C. elegans has muscle analogous to vertebrate skeletal muscle and has a gene(hlh-1) related to the MyoD family. The molecular and genetic characterization of hlh-1 shows that it is very similar to the vertebrate MyoD family in many respects, including its expression pattern and DNA binding activity. The hlh-1 product is required for proper myogenesis, but it is not required for myogenic commitment during embryogenesis in the nematode. The role of this MyoD-related gene in nematode myogenesis is discussed and compared to those of the vertebrate MyoD family.     

Genetic complementation in somatic cell hybrids of cerebroside sulfatase activator deficiency and metachromatic leukodystrophy fibroblasts

Summary Several cases of metachromatic leukodystrophy (MLD) have been described with normal or near normal activities of arylsulfatase A (cerebroside sulfatase). However, the ability of intact cultured fibroblasts to hydrolyze cerebroside sulfate was impaired. Since the impairment was corrected by cerebroside sulfatase activator, a deficiency of activator was implied. In the absence of direct demonstration of deficiency, other types of evidence were needed to support the premise that the genetic defect was not associated with the arylsulfatase A locus as in classical MLD. Therefore, somatic cell hybrids of activator deficiency and MLD fibroblasts were analyzed. Complementation was indicated by enhanced hydrolysis of cerebroside sulfate, supporting the view that cerebroside sulfatase activator deficiency and MLD are nonallelic.     

Inheritance of malignancy in somatic cell hybrids

After a recall of the importance of early basic developments of in vitro established cell lines for investigations on malignant transformation, a survey of essential steps in the study of malignancy by means of somatic cell hybridization is presented. Since the early sixties, in vitro crosses of malignant versus nonmalignant parental cells have provided many experimental models in which mechanisms of expression of malignancy have been approached. Allogenic as well as xenogenic cell matings resulted in tumor-producing or nontumorigenic hybrids which have been analyzed, particularly in terms of karyology in order to determine possible chromosomal patterns linked with inheritance of malignancy and its suppression. The authors discuss the successive concepts devised for interpretation of experimental data, implicating specific genetic "normalizing" information, genetic dosage as well as, more recently, epigenetic and cytoplasmic mechanisms.     

Syrian Hamster-human somatic cell hybrids: Isolation and characterization

Summary Cultured Syrian hamster and human fibroblasts were hybridized by means of Sendai virus. The hybrids were selected chemically. They show preferential loss of human chromosomes and biochemical markers. Therefore they can be used for gene linkage and localization studies in man. Hybrids between Syrian hamster and fibroblasts of a human translocation carrier (46,X,t(14q+,Xq-)) enabled the assignment of the human nucleoside phosphorylase gene to chromosome 14 to be confirmed.

---

Zusammenfassung Kultivierte Fibroblasten des syrischen Hamsters und des Menschen wurden mittels Sendai-Virus hybridisiert. Die Hybriden wurden durch chemische Selektion isoliert. Chromosomen und biochemische Marker der menschlichen Elternzellen segregieren bevorzugt aus den Hybriden. Man kann diese daher für Genkopplungs-und Genlokalisierungsuntersuchungen beim Menschen verwenden. Mit Hilfe von Hybriden zwischen Zellen des syrischen Hamsters und Zellen der Trägerin einer Translokation (46,X,t(14q+,Xq-)) konnte die Lokalisierung des Gens für die Nucleosid-Phosphorylase des Menschen auf Chromosom 14 bestätigt werden.

     

Host cell-dependent regulation of growth transformation-associated Epstein-Barr virus antigens in somatic cell hybrids.

We have analyzed the expression of the three major known growth transformation-associated Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) proteins, EBNA-1, EBNA-2, and latent membrane protein (LMP), in a series of somatic cell hybrids derived from the fusion of EBV-carrying Burkitt lymphoma (BL) lines with EBV-positive or EBV-negative B-cell lines. Independently of the cell phenotype, EBNA-1 was invariably coexpressed in all EBV-carrying hybrids. In hybrids between EBV-carrying, LMP-positive and LMP-negative Burkitt lymphoma lines, LMP was expressed, indicating positive control. Two EBV-negative lymphoma lines, Ramos and BJAB, differed in their ability to express LMP after B95-8 virus-induced conversion and after hybridization with Raji cells. BJAB was permissive while Ramos was nonpermissive for LMP, although both expressed EBNA-2. The EBNA-2-deleted P3HR-1 virus gave the same pattern of LMP expression in these two cells. Our findings indicate that the expression of EBNA-1, EBNA-2, and LMP is regulated by independent mechanisms.     

Regulation of expression of tyrosine aminotransferase in somatic cell hybrids between rat hepatoma cells and mouse fibroblasts

Somatic cell hybrids between rat hepatoma cells and mouse 3T3 fibroblasts fail to produce the liver-specific enzyme tyrosine aminotransferase. A novel approach using gamma-irradiation to induce chromosome loss from the non-expressing parent cell was applied to dissect genetically the factors in 3T3 cells that interact with the regulation of expression of tyrosine aminotransferase in these hybrids. Suppression of basal and steroid-inducible tyrosine aminotransferase activities was progressively relieved with increasing dose of radiation. The wide range in degree of reexpression suggests a complex of regulatory mechanisms. Suppression of steroid-inducibility was not linked to the mouse X-chromosome. Nor did the mouse genome affect the modulation of enzyme activity induced by insulin and by serum.     

Limited lifespan in somatic cell hybrids and cybrids

The transformed phenotype is believed to be dominant in fusions between limited lifespan cells and transformed cells, based on heterokaryon experiments and on the isolation of transformed hybrids from mass cultures of fused cells. A series of fusions has been performed between limited lifespan Lesch-Nyhan fibroblast cells and a permanent HeLa cell line with a complementary genetic marker. The growth of independently isolated hybrid clones was followed in parallel with Lesch-Nyhan cells. In fusions involving Lesch-Nyhan cells which had completed about 50% of their lifespan, all hybrids initially show fibroblastic properties. Thirty-five hybrids had a limited lifespan slightly longer than Lesch-Nyhan controls. Three other hybrid clones, and all mass cultures of hybrids, showed the appearance of transformed colonies at a rate of approx. one transformant in 2 × 10₅ hybrid cells. These transformed cells showed anchorage independence, low serum requirement, chromosome loss, and have been maintained in culture for 50–100 population doublings with no signs of senescence. Fusions involving enucleated HeLa cells did not show transformation. Fusions with senescent Lesch-Nyhan cells yielded hybrids which grew beyond the normal Lesch-Nyhan cell lifespan, but which again showed limited lifespan and low frequency transformation. It is concluded that limited lifespan is expressed in a dominant manner in these fusions, and that transformation or “escape from senescence” is a low frequency event requiring the presence of the HeLa nucleus.     

Centromere conversion and retention in somatic cell hybrids

The generation of somatic cell hybridization-derived cell lines between highly divergent species affords the opportunity to examine the concept of 'genome dominance' in the context of genetic and epigenetic changes. While whole-scale genome dominance has been well documented in natural hybrids among closely related species, an examination of centromere position and sequence retention in 2 marsupial-eutherian hybrids has revealed a mechanism for 'centromere dominance' as a driving force in the generation of stable somatic cell hybrids following an initial period of genomic instability. While one somatic cell hybrid cell line appeared to retain marsupial centromere sequences which remained competent to recruit the centromere-specific histone variant CENP-A in a Chinese hamster background, fusion events between marsupial and mouse-derived chromosomes in another hybrid line led to a centromere sequence conversion from one species to the other. We postulate that the necessity to maintain an epigenetically defined centromere following genome hybridization may be responsible for retention of specific chromosomes and may result in rapid sequence turnover to facilitate the recruitment of CENP-A containing histones.     

Analysis of myogenesis by somatic cell hybridization : I. Myogenic competence of homotypic hybrids derived from rat L6 myoblasts

Several authors have described the extinction of myogenic competence in hybrids produced by fusion of myogenic and non-myogenic cells. Interpretations of such experiments rest upon the assumption that extinction does not occur with any appreciable frequency as a non-specific consequence of the cell hybridization process itself. In order to test this assumption we have analyzed the myogenic competence of over 140 independent homotypic hybrid clones produced by PEG-mediated fusion of rat L6 myoblasts. Based upon an evaluation of myotube formation in hybrid colonies, we demonstrate that 99% of primary hybrid clones are myogenic. The fact that 97% of secondary hybrid colonies also differentiate indicates that myogenic competence is a stable characteristic of the hybrids. Four hybrid clones were isolated and expanded for analyses of chromosome numbers, myotube formation, creatine kinase activities, and microfluorimetric DNA determinations of myotube nuclei. Our results demonstrate that polyploid homotypic hybrid cells produced by fusion of non-neoplastic, developmentally determined rat myoblasts retain and express their program of differentiation. This work provides a foundation for future studies which will investigate the expression of myogenic properties in hybrids between myogenic and non-myogenic cells.     

The cyclic adenosine monophosphate phosphodiesterases of myoblasts, fibroblasts, and their somatic cell hybrids.

Three forms of cAMP phosphodiesterases are found in mouse L cells (fibroblasts) and rat skeletal myoblasts. The myoblast enzymes can be resolved by chromatography on DEAE-cellulose and the fibroblast enzymes by chromatography on DEAE-Biogel. The myoblast enzymes are "high affinity" cAMP specific forms and have different molecular weights, while all L-cell enzymes have an apparent molecular weight of 450,000. Only one of the L-cell enzymes is able to hydrolyze both cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP) and cAMP. Hydrolysis of the latter is stimulated by micromolar amounts of cGMP. The myoblast x L cell hybrids possess at least five phosphodiesterases, three of which can be identified as being of myoblast or fibroblast origin. One of the fibroblast enzymes appears to be modified in hybrids. The entire phosphodiesterase regulatory system of the myoblasts is active in the hybrids.     

Utilization of somatic cell hybrids for genetic studies in man

Summary Mammalian cells grown in vitro can be substituted for the intact organisms in genetic studies. Parasexual events in these cells lead to the formation of proliferating somatic cell hybrids. The production and isolation of intra- and interspecific somatic cell hybrids and their use in human genetic studies are reviewed.Cell hybrids have been successfully applied to characterize inherited biochemical defects in man and to establish linkage relationships and assignment of human genes. The prerequisites and pitfalls of this approach are discussed. Recent results allow the assignment of genes to 15 human chromosomes. The data resulting from these studies could be useful for prenatal diagnosis or the therapy of inherited diseases.

---

Zusammenfassung In vitro kultivierte somatische Zellen von Säugetieren können lebende Tiere bei genetischen Untersuchungen ersetzen. Parasexuelle Vorgänge in diesen Zellen führen zur Bildung proliferierender Hybriden somatischer Zellen.Die vorliegende Übersicht behandelt die Bildung und Isolierung intra- und interspezifischer Hydbriden somatischer Zellen und ihre Verwendung bei der Untersuchung humangenetischer Fragestellungen. Zellhyriden wurden mit Erfolg zur Charakterisierung erblicher biochemischer Defekte beim Menschen und zu Genkopplungs- und Lokalisierungsanalyse menschlicher Gene eingesetzt. Voraussetzungen und Schwierigkeiten der Methode werden besprochen. Gegenwärtig können mit diesem Verfahren 15 menschlichen Chromosomen Gene oder Kopplungsgruppen zugeordnet werden. Die Ergebnisse dieser Untersuchungen können hilfreich bei den Bemühungen sein, genetische Defekte durch pränatale Diagnose frühzeitig zu erkennen oder betroffene Individuen zu behandeln.

---

---

The author's work on cell hybrids is supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.