Abnormal Stomatal Behavior and Hormonal Imbalance in flacca, a Wilty Mutant of Tomato: II. Auxin- and Abscisic Acid-like Activity

The wilty tomato mutant, flacca, and the control variety, Rheinlands Ruhm, were compared with regard to the endogenous activity and concentration of auxin- and abscisic acid-like substances during ontogeny. The mutant wilts fast under water deficit because of inability to close its stomata. Symptoms characteristic of excessive auxin are evident in the developing mutant. Among these symptoms are branch and leaf epinasty, excessive rooting along the stem, and increased apical dominance. By using a leucine-incorporation assay, spray of whole plants with 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, and wheat coleoptile bioassay, indications were found of an excess of activity and concentration of auxin-like substances in shoots of young and mature mutant plants. The wheat coleoptile bioassay also revealed a much lower amount of substances with abscisic acid-like activity in the mutant compared with the normal plant. In contrast to the appearance during ontogeny of morphological symptoms characteristic of auxin excess in the mutant, the absolute amount of auxin-like substances and their activity in incorporation of leucine decreased with age. A parallel decrease of the concentration and activity of auxin-like compounds was also found in the normal plant. The concentration of abscisic acid-like substances increased with age in both genotypes. The disagreement between the increasing morphological symptoms and the decrease of auxin-like activity and concentration is discussed, together with the possibility of a causal relationship between auxin-and abscisic acid-like activity and stomatal behavior.     

Abscisic Acid and C10 Dicarboxylic Acids in Wilty Tomato Mutants

Linforth, R. S. T., Taylor, I. B. and Hedden, P. 1987. Abscisicacid and C10 dicarboxylic acids in wilty tomato mutants.—J.exp. Bot. 38: 1734–1740. The concentration of C₁₀ dicarboxylic acids in wilty tomatomutants was investigated. Three of the genotypes studied (flacca,sitiens and the double mutant homozygote flacca/sitiens) werefound to have higher concentrations of 2,7-dimethyl-2,4-octadienedioicacid (ODA) than the isogenic normal form. In contrast, the othergenotypes (notabilisand the double mutant homozygotes notabilis/flaccaand notabilis/sitiens) were found to have lower concentrationsof ODA than the isogenic normal form. The concentration of ODAin flacca plants was increased by water stress and reduced byexogenously applied abscisic acid (ABA). A second structurallyrelated compound, 2,7-dimethyl-4-octenedioic acid (OEA) wasalso quantified, but it showed no clear genotype-related pattern. The concentration of ABA in the wilty tomato mutants was alsoinvestigated. As expected in the light of previously publishedresults, it was reduced in the single mutants relative to theisogenic control plants. In the double mutant flacca/sitiensABA levels were similar to those of the single mutant sitiens.However, in the two double mutants notabilis/flacca and notabilis/sitiensABA was substantially lower than those in any other genotypeinvestigated. Key words: Abscisic acid, 2,7-dimethyl-2,4-octadienedioic acid, 2,7-dimethyl-4-octenedioc acid, tomato, wilty mutants     

Abnormal Stomatal Behavior and Hormonal Imbalance in flacca, a Wilty Mutant of Tomato: I. Root Effect and Kinetin-like Activity

The wilty tomato mutant, flacca, and the normal variety, Rheinlands Ruhm, were compared for kinetin-like activity in ontogeny. The mutant wilts easily because its stomata resist closure. This stomatal resistance decreases with age. The occurrence of a root factor which induces stomatal opening was inferred from grafting experiments. It was hypothesized that the excessive stomatal openings in the mutant may result from excess of kinetin-like activity in the leaf of that plant. In addition, it was suggested that the closure of stomata in the aging mutant is due to a decrease of kinetin-like activity with age. Kinetin-like activity in the leaf was determined by incorporation of labeled leucine. The concentration of cytokinins in root exudate and leaf extract was determined by the soybean callus assay. Evidence was presented of higher kinetin-like activity in the leaves of the mutant and higher cytokinin concentration in its root exudate. Cytokinin concentration in the shoot was found to be only slightly higher in the mutant than in the normal plants. Kinetin-like activity in the leaf and cytokinin concentration of root exudate decreased with age in both mutant and normal plants. Kinetin-like activity in the leaves of mutant plants, which phenocopy the normal variety as a result of continuous application of abscisic acid, was lower than in control mutant plants. The significance of these findings per se and in connection with stomatal behavior is discussed.     

Plasmodesmata, Tropisms, and Auxin Transport

Attempts were made to disrupt the plasmodesmata between oatcoleoptile cells (Avena saliva L. cv. Victory) by severe plasmolysis.Coleoptiles, allowed to regain turgor after plasmolysis, wereable to execute geotropic and phototropic curvatures and segmentswould grow in response to applied auxin. In coleoptiles similarlytreated, studies with [¹⁴C]IAA have shown that longitudinal,basipetal transport of auxin still takes place and, as in controls,IAA is preferentially redistributed laterally within coleoptilesorientated horizontally. Physical continuity of the symplast of oat coleoptile cellsmay not always be disrupted by severe plasmolysis. Nevertheless,functional continuity appears to be interrupted. Despite this,all the processes involved in the execution of tropistic curvaturesremain intact, including transport of hormones. Plasmodesmatalcontinuity between oat coleoptile cells appears not to be anecessary requirement for auxin transport.     

Long‐distance ABA transport can mediate distal tissue responses by affecting local ABA concentrations

Environmental stresses that perturb plant water relations influence abscisic acid (ABA) concentrations, but it is unclear whether long‐distance ABA transport contributes to changes in local ABA levels. To determine the physiological relevance of ABA transport, we made reciprocal‐ and self‐grafts of ABA‐deficient flacca mutant and wild‐type (WT) tomato plants, in which low phosphorus (P) conditions decreased ABA concentrations while salinity increased ABA concentrations. Whereas foliar ABA concentrations in the WT scions were rootstock independent under conditions, salinity resulted in long‐distance transport of ABA: flacca scions had approximately twice as much ABA when grafted on WT rootstocks compared to flacca rootstocks. Root ABA concentrations were scion dependent: both WT and flacca rootstocks had less ABA with the flacca mutant scion than with the WT scion under conditions. In WT scions, whereas rootstock genotype had limited effects on stomatal conductance under conditions, a flacca rootstock decreased leaf area of stressed plants, presumably due to attenuated root‐to‐shoot ABA transport. In flacca scions, a WT rootstock decreased stomatal conductance but increased leaf area of stressed plants, likely due to enhanced root‐to‐shoot ABA transport. Thus, long‐distance ABA transport can affect responses in distal tissues by changing local ABA concentrations.     

Boron deficiency effects on peroxidase, hydroxyproline, and boron in cell walls and cytoplasm of Helianthus annuus L. hypocotyls

Boron-deficient sunflower hypocotyls have, on a fresh weightbasis, more cytoplasmic and cell wall peroxidase, more cytoplasmichydroxyproline but equal cell wall hydroxyproline, and slightlyless cell wall boron, than controls. Incubation of either Bdeficientor control cell wall suspensions with Sclerotium rolfsii culturenitrate released 80% of the peroxidase activity, but only 14to 30% of the hydroxyproline. This differential extraction suggeststhat the hydroxyproline-containing protein of cell walls isnot identical with peroxidase. Boron deficiency increased thesusceptibility of cell walls to degradation by fungal enzymes,as measured by release of peroxidase and hydroxyproline, butnot by reduction in dry weight. ¹Scientific article No. A1847, Contribution No. 4756 of theUniversity of Maryland Agricultural Experiment Station. Thisresearch represents part of a thesis for the M.S. degree, Universityof Maryland, by J.B.S., Jr. This paper is dedicated to ProfessorHugh G. Gauch on the occasion of his sixtieth birthday. (Received December 5, 1972; )     

Combined Effects of Auxin Transport Inhibitors and Cytokinin: Alterations of Organ Development in Tobacco

We have examined the effects of the auxin transport inhibitors1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) and 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid(TIBA) on leaf morphogenesis of transgenic Nicotiana tabacum(cv. Xanthi) plants expressing the Agrobacterium tumefacienscytokinin biosynthetic gene, ipt. We have observed the formationof saucer-shaped leaf-like organs at the shoot apex and at lateralbuds. The formation of apical saucer-shaped leaf-like organscan be duplicated by the application of exogenous NPA and cytokininto wild-type tobacco seedlings. We have also observed adventitiousleaf-like organs with altered petiole and blade morphology inthe transgenic plants treated with auxin transport inhibitors.These results suggest that the combination of diminished auxintransport and elevated cytokinin can lead to alterations inleaf development in tobacco. ⁴Present address: Genesis Research and Development Corporation,P.O. Box 50, Auckland, New Zealand     

Transport and Accumulation of IAA-14C in Tumour-forming Nicotiana Hybrids

The polar transport of indol-3yl-acetic acid (IAA-2-¹⁴C) instem explants and decapitated shoots of tumour-prone Nicotianahybrids (2n, 3n, and 4n) was compared with that in the normal,non-tumorous parent species N. glauca and N. langsdorffii. Thetotal uptake of the auxin from donor blocks was greatest inthe hybrids and N. glauca. The velocity of the basipetal movementof IAA-¹⁴C was the same in all species tested, i.e. 8 mm/h.The transport capacity for the hormone, however, was decreasedin the three tumour-prone hybrids. Gas chromatography showedthat between 70 and 90 per cent of the transported auxin waspresent in the form of IAA, between 10 and 30 per cent in theform of indol-3yl-aldehyde (IAld). The basipetal transport exceeded the acropetal transport inyoung (third) intemodes of all plants studied, whereas in olderstem segments (tenth intenodes) the reverse was found. The polarity of auxin transport was less well expressed in thetumorous hybrids. Blocking the active transport by pre-treatment of stem cuttingswith 2,4-dinitrophenol (2,4-DNP) caused a drastic reductionin the polar IAA-¹⁴C movement; in all plants tested the auxintransport was reduced to the same low level. The accumulation of auxin at the base of cuttings was higherin N. glauca and the 2n hybrid than in N. langsdorffii, i.e.about seven times higher after 1-h and three times higher after12-h transport experiments. The release of ¹⁴C from the cuttinginto an agar receiver block, however, was markedly reduced inthe 2n hybrid, whereas in N. glauca the labelled substancesmoved more freely into the receiver blocks. Differences in the capacity for the accumulation and the releaseof IAA-¹⁴C in hybrid and N. glauca stem tissues were studiedusing decapitated greenhouse plants wounded by incision abovethe fourth internode. Accumulation of the auxin occurred onlyabove the wound-cut in hybrid plants. This observation is consistentwith the view that tumour formation on hybrid stems occurs atsites of wounding. Our data suggest an elevated auxin levelto be present during tumour initiation at these sites. These results on polar transport and accumulation of IAA-¹⁴Cin tumorous Nicotiana plants together with our previous dataon various endogenous auxins suggest that the induction of neoplasticgrowth in tobacco plants is correlated with increased auxinlevels and an accumulation of the hormone at sites of wounding.     

Abnormal Stomatal Behavior and Hormonal Imbalance in flacca, a Wilty Mutant of Tomato: IV. Effect of Abscisic Acid and Water Content on RNase Activity and RNA

Plants of the wilty tomato (Lycopersicum esculentum) mutant, flacca, and of the normal cultivar Rheinlands Ruhm growing under either “normal” or high humidity were used in this research. Under normal humidity, RNase activity was much higher in mutant plants in which abscisic acid (ABA) and water content were lower than in the normal plant. The mutant also contained less RNA and protein per cell and less soluble RNA relative to ribosomal RNA as compared with the normal genotype. In ABA-treated mutant plants, RNase activity decreased while RNA, protein, the ratio of soluble to ribosomal RNA and water content increased.     

The metabolism of abscisic acid in flacca,a wilty mutant of tomato

The wilty tomato mutant flacca and the normal variety Rheinlands Ruhm were used in this research. The mutant phenotype was explained mainly by hormonal changes. One of these, the decrease in abscisic acid level, was suggested as the hormonal change closest to the mutated gene. The cause of the lower abscisic acid level in the mutant, which may be enhanced breakdown or inactivation, or inhibited biosynthesis, was investigated. The first possibility was studied by comparing mutant and normal plants treated with t-abscisic acid-2-C¹⁴ for (1) rate of production of labeled methanol-extractable metabolites and (2) radioactivity remaining in the methanol-unextractable fraction. The level of trans, trans-abscisic acid relative to that of cis,trans-abscisic acid was studied in untreated plants. Only two radioactive regions containing metabolites of abscisic acid were detected from either of the plant types, and their rates of production relative to total radioactivity was equal. The radioactivity in the methanolunextractable fraction and the level of trans,trans-abscisic acid were very low in both mutant and normal plants. The second possibility was studied partly by comparing the levels of various xanthophylls in mutant and normal plants and their effect after illumination on cress seed germination. Xanthophylls of both plant types were identical in their absorption spectra, but their levels were higher in the mutant. Of these xanthophylls, illuminated neoxanthin inhibited seed germination in both plant types, but more effectively in the mutant. The most probable explanation for the low level of cis,trans-abscisic acid in flacca is that the conversion of farnesyl PiP to abscisic acid is inhibited in this plant.     

Fusicoccin and Air Pollutant Injury to Plants : Evidence for Enhancement of SO(2) but Not O(3) Injury

Garden peas (Pisum sativum L. cv Alsweet) and a tomato mutant (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. var flacca) were sprayed with fusicoccin, a fungal toxin affecting membrane transport properties, before exposure to SO₂ or O₃. Tomatoes treated with 10 micromolar fusicoccin and exposed to SO₂ (0.6 microliter per liter for 2 hours) exhibited twice as much foliar necrosis as untreated plants exposed to SO₂. Peas treated with fusicoccin and exposed to SO₂ (0.7 to 1.0 microliter per liter for 2 hours) exhibited 2 to 6 times more injury than untreated plants exposed to SO₂. Peas treated with fusicoccin and exposed to O₃ had less injury than untreated plants exposed to O₃ (0.1 to 0.3 microliter per liter for 2 hours). Several lines of evidence suggested that the fusicoccin enhancement of SO₂ injury is not the result of increased gas exchange, i.e. the tomato mutant has permanently open stomata under all conditions, and in peas fusicoccin had no effect on SO₂ or H₂O flux in plants exposed to 0.12 microliter per liter SO₂. However, a 21% greater leaf conductance in fusicoccin treated versus untreated plants indicated the possibility of some differences in gas exchange for peas exposed to 1.0 microliter per liter SO₂.     

Promotion of peroxidase activity in the cell wall of Nicotiana

Peroxidase catalyzes the oxidation of indole-3-acetic acid. The primary products of this reaction stimulate growth in plants. Therefore, our concept is that an increase in peroxidase activity will increase the effect of indole-3-acetic acid as a growth hormone. Our objective was to study the effect of 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid, a growth regulator, on isoperoxidases in the cell wall and cytoplasm of Nicotiana. Isoperoxidases from the cell wall and cytoplasmic fractions were separated by acrylamide gel electrophoresis. We found that 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid and indole-3-acetic acid increase peroxidase activity in the cell wall. Since both 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid and indole-3-acetic acid increase the activity of the same isoperoxidase, we conclude that 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid synergizes rather than antagonizes auxin action, and we suggest that this increase in indole-3-acetic acid oxidase activity sensitizes plant tissues to auxin.     

Dynamic Properties of Endogenous Phytochrome A in Arabidopsis Seedlings

The flacca tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum) mutant displays a wilty phenotype as a result of abscisic acid (ABA) deficiency. The Mo cofactor (MoCo)-containing aldehyde oxidases (AO; EC 1.2.3.1) are thought to play a role in the final oxidation step required for ABA biosynthesis. AO and related MoCo-containing enzymes xanthine dehydrogenase (XDH; EC 1.2.1.37) and nitrate reductase (EC 1.6.6.1) were examined in extracts of the flacca tomato genotype and of wild-type (WT) roots and shoots. The levels of MoCo were found to be similar in both genotypes. No significant XDH or AO (MoCo-containing hydroxylases) activities were detected in flacca leaves; however, the mutant exhibited considerable MoCo-containing hydroxylase activity in the roots, which contained notable amounts of ABA. Native western blots probed with an antibody to MoCo-containing hydroxylases revealed substantial, albeit reduced, levels of cross-reactive protein in the flacca mutant shoots and roots. The ABA xylem-loading rate was significantly lower than that in the WT, indicating that the flacca is also defective in ABA transport to the shoot. Significantly, in vitro sulfurylation with Na₂S reactivated preexisting XDH and AO proteins in extracts from flacca, particularly from the shoots, and superinduced the basal-level activity in the WT extracts. The results indicate that in flacca, MoCo-sulfurylase activity is impaired in a tissue-dependent manner.     

Genetic Analysis of the Effects of Polar Auxin Transport Inhibitors on Root Growth in Arabidopsis thaliana

Polar auxin transport inhibitors, including N-1-naphthylphthalamicacid (NPA) and 2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA), have variouseffects on physiological and developmental events, such as theelongation and tropism of roots and stems, in higher plants.We isolated NPA-resistant mutants of Arabidopsis thaliana, withmutations designated pir1 and pir2, that were also resistantto TIBA. The mutations specifically affected the root-elongationprocess, and they were shown ultimately to be allelic to aux1and ein2, respectively, which are known as mutations that affectresponses to phytohormones. The mechanism of action of auxintransport inhibitors was investigated with these mutants, inrelation to the effects of ethylene, auxin, and the polar transportof auxin. With respect to the inhibition of root elongationin A. thaliana, we demonstrated that (1) the background levelof ethylene intensifies the effects of auxin transport inhibitors,(2) auxin transport inhibitors might act also via an inhibitorypathway that does not involve ethylene, auxin, or the polartransport of auxin, (3) the hypothesis that the inhibitory effectof NPA on root elongation is due to high-level accumulationof auxin as a result of blockage of auxin transport is not applicableto A. thaliana, and (4) in contrast to NPA, TIBA itself hasa weak auxin-like inhibitory effect. (Received April 12, 1996; Accepted September 2, 1996)     

Abnormal Stomatal Behaviour and Leaf Anatomy in Capsicum annuum, scabrous diminutive, a Wilty Mutant of Pepper

An attempt is made to explain the tendency to excessive wiltingin scabrous diminutive, a pepper mutant. For this, mutant andnormal plants were compared with respect to leaf anatomy, transpirationof whole plants and detached drying leaves, density and openingof stomata, staining of potassium in epidermal cells and rootpressure. A much greater proportion of intracellular space was found inthe mutant leaf which contains fewer and smaller mesophyll cellsthan the normal plant. The anticlinal walls of the epidermisof the mutant leaf were almost straight whereas those of thenormal were wavy. Transpiration per unit leaf area of wholeplants, percentage of stomata open both day and night, and waterloss from detached drying leaves were all higher in the mutant.Potassium staining in guard cells was similar in both planttypes, slightly less in darkness and marginally higher in light.The subsidiary cells of normal leaves did not stain at all,but those of the mutant leaves stained heavily in both lightand darkness. Root pressure was lower in the mutant. Possible explanations for the tendency of the pepper mutantto wilt are discussed.     

Effect of indoleacetic Acid and hydroxyproline on isoenzymes of peroxidase in wheat coleoptiles

Indoleacetic acid at 0.017 millimolar inhibited the formation of three peroxidase isoenzymes in both soluble and wall-bound enzyme fractions of wheat coleoptile (Triticum vulgare) tissue. Hydroxyproline at 1 millimolar prevented the indoleacetic acid-induced inhibition. Indoleacetic acid oxidase activity in the soluble fraction was decreased by indoleacetic acid and was restored by hydroxyproline. Most of the indoleacetic acid oxidase activity was located in the electrophoretic zones occupied by two of the peroxidase isoenzymes influenced by indoleacetic acid and hydroxyproline. At least part of the effect of hydroxyproline on auxin-induced elongation of coleoptile tissue may be through control of auxin levels by indoleacetic acid oxidase.     

Auxin Physiology of the Tomato Mutant diageotropica

The tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum, Mill.) mutant diageotropica (dgt) exhibits biochemical, physiological, and morphological abnormalities that suggest the mutation may have affected a primary site of auxin perception or action. We have compared two aspects of the auxin physiology of dgt and wild-type (VFN8) seedlings: auxin transport and cellular growth parameters. The rates of basipetal indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) polar transport are identical in hypocotyl sections of the two genotypes, but dgt sections have a slightly greater capacity for IAA transport. 2,3,5-Triiodobenzoic acid and ethylene reduce transport in both mutant and wild-type sections. The kinetics of auxin uptake into VFN8 and dgt sections are nearly identical. These results make it unlikely that an altered IAA efflux carrier or IAA uptake symport are responsible for the pleiotropic effects resulting from the dgt mutation. The lack of auxin-induced cell elongation in dgt plants is not due to insufficient turgor, as the osmotic potential of dgt cell sap is less (more negative) than that of VFN8. An auxin-induced increase in wall extensibility, as measured by the Instron technique, only occurs in the VFN8 plants. These data suggest dgt hypocotyls suffer a defect in the sequence of events culminating in auxin-induced cell wall loosening.     

Effect of kinetin on auxin uptake and distribution in normal and tumor-prone Nicotiana shoots

Stem segments of non-tumorous Nicotiana glauca and N. langsdorffiiplants and of their tumor-producing amphidiploid F₁ hybrid weretreated with 6-furfurylaminopurine (kinetin) prior to transporttests with applied labeled indoleacetic acid (IAA-2-¹⁴C). Kinetin-treatmentsincreased the uptake of IAA in non-tumorous shoots; the IAAuptake by N. langsdorffii segments was increased up to 3-fold.The auxin uptake in stem-segments of the tumor-forming hybrid,however, could not be increased significantly by kinetin. Theeven distribution of IAA-¹⁴C in segments of normal and tumorproneNicotiana shoots is stimulated by kinetin. Data are discussedin conjunction with previous results on auxin transport andtumorformation in Nicotiana. (Received August 8, 1972; )     

Stomata and transpiration of droopy potatoes

A diploid potato (Solanum tuberosum) mutant called droopy wilts easily. Excised leaves of the mutant lost weight, and hence water, more rapidly and had many more open stomata than leaves of a normal sibling. Further, the stomata of abnormal plants remained open in wilted leaves. When the stomata of the abnormal mutant were closed by a chemical spray, its excised leaves lost water no more rapidly than normal. Thus, the wilting of the mutant must be caused by wide stomata. The wilting of the abnormal leaves and the small dry weight of the plants indicate the advantage of the stomatal hydrostat in the normal plants.     

Proteoid Root Development of Phosphorus Deficient Lupin is Mimicked by Auxin and Phosphonate

White lupin (Lupinus albus L.) develops proteoid (cluster) rootsin response to phosphorus deficiency. Proteoid roots are composedof tight clusters of rootlets that initiate from the pericycleopposite protoxylem poles and emerge from every protoxylem polewithin the proteoid root axis. Auxins are required for lateralroot development, but little is known of their role in proteoidroot formation. Proteoid root numbers were dramatically increasedin P-sufficient (+P) plants by application of the syntheticauxin, naphthalene acetic acid (NAA), to leaves, and were reducedin P-deficient (-P) plants by the presence of auxin transportinhibitors [2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid (TIBA) and naphthylphthalamicacid (NPA)]. While ethylene concentrations in the root zonewere 1.5-fold higher in -P plants, there was no effect on proteoidroot numbers of the ethylene inhibitors aminoethoxyvinvylglycine(AVG) and silver thiosulphate. Phosphonate, which interfereswith plant perception of internal P concentration, dramaticallyincreased the number of proteoid root segments in +P plants.Activities of phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC), malatedehydrogenase (MDH) and exuded acid phosphatase in proteoidroot segments were not different from +P controls when NAA wasapplied to +P lupin plants, but increased to levels comparableto -P plants in the phosphonate treatment. Addition of TIBAor NPA to -P plants reduced PEPC and MDH activity of -P proteoidroots to levels found in +P or -P normal root tissues, but didnot affect acid phosphatase in root exudates. These resultssuggest that auxin transport from the shoot plays a role inthe formation of proteoid roots during P deficiency. Auxin-stimulatedproteoid root formation is necessary, but not sufficient, tosignal the up-regulation of PEPC and MDH in proteoid root segments.In contrast, phosphonate applied to P-sufficient white lupinelicits the full suite of coordinated responses to P deficiencyCopyright2000 Annals of Botany Company Lupinus albus L., white lupin, proteoid roots, auxin, ethylene, phosphonate, phosphorus deficiency