Anion-induced increases in the affinity of colcemid binding to tubulin

Colcemid binds tubulin rapidly and reversibly in contrast to colchicine which binds tubulin relatively slowly and essentially irreversibly. At 37 degrees C the association rate constant for colcemid binding is 1.88 X 10(6) M-1 h-1, about 10 times higher than that for colchicine; this is reflected in the activation energies for binding which are 51.4 kJ/mol for colcemid and 84.8 kJ/mol for colchicine. Scatchard analysis indicates two binding sites on tubulin having different affinities for colcemid. The high-affinity site (Ka = 0.7 X 10(5) M-1 at 37 degrees C) is sensitive to temperature and binds both colchicine and colcemid and hence they are mutually competitive inhibitors. The low-affinity site (Kb = 1.2 X 10(4) M-1) is rather insensitive to temperature and binds only colcemid. Like colchicine, 0.6 mol of colcemid are bound/mol of tubulin dimer (at the high-affinity site) and the reaction is entropy driven (163 J K-1 mol-1). Similar to colchicine, colcemid binding to tubulin is stimulated by certain anions (viz. sulfate and tartrate) but by a different mechanism. Colcemid binding affinity at the lower-affinity site of tubulin is increased in the presence of ammonium sulfate. Interestingly, the lower-affinity site on tubulin for colcemid, even when converted to higher affinity in presence of ammonium sulfate, is not recognized by colchicine. We conclude that tubulin possesses two binding sites, one of which specifically recognized the groups present on the B-ring of colchicine molecule and is effected by the ammonium sulfate, whereas the higher-affinity site, which could accommodate both colchicine and colcemid, possibly recognized the A and C ring of colchicine.     

Energy-transfer studies of the distance between the high-affinity metal binding site and the colchicine and 8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid binding sites on calf brain tubulin

The high-affinity metal divalent cation Mg2+, associated with the exchangeable guanosine 5'-triphosphate (GTP) binding site (E site) on purified tubulin, has been replaced by the transition metal ion Co2+ on tubulin as well as on the tubulin-colchicine, tubulin-allocolchicine and tubulin-8-anilino-1-naphthalenesulfonic acid (tubulin-ANS) complexes. While pure native tubulin readily incorporated 0.8 atom of Co2+ per tubulin alpha-beta dimer, incorporation was reduced to 0.4 atom of Co2+ per mole of tubulin when it was complexed with colchicine, indicating that the conformational change induced in tubulin by the binding of colchicine leads to a reduced accessibility of the divalent cation binding site linked to the E site without necessarily changing the intrinsic binding constant. The fluorescence emission spectra of tubulin-bound colchicine, allocolchicine, and ANS displayed a strong overlap with the Co2+ absorption spectrum, identifying these as adequate donor-acceptor pairs. Fluorescence energy-transfer measurements were carried out between tubulin-bound colchicine (or allocolchicine) and ANS as donors and tubulin-complexed Co2+ as acceptor. It was found that the distance between the ANS and the high-affinity divalent cation binding sites is greater than 28 A, while that between the colchicine and the divalent cation binding sites is greater than 24 A.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Colchicine binding in the free-living nematode Caenorhabditis elegans

The [3H]colchicine-binding activity of a crude supernatant of the free-living nematode Caenorhabditis elegans was resolved into a non-saturable component and a tubulin-specific component after partial purification of tubulin by polylysine affinity chromatography. The two fractions displayed opposing thermal dependencies of [3H]colchicine binding, with non-saturable binding increasing, and tubulin binding decreasing, at 4 degrees C. Binding of [3H]colchicine to C.elegans tubulin at 37 degrees C is a pseudo-first-order rate process with a long equilibration time. The affinity of C. elegans tubulin for [3H]colchicine is relatively low (Ka = 1.7 x 10(5) M(-1)) and is characteristic of the colchicine binding affinities observed for tubulins derived from parasitic nematodes. [3H]Colchicine binding to C. elegans tubulin was inhibited by unlabelled colchicine, podophyllotoxin and mebendazole, and was enhanced by vinblastine. The inhibition of [3H]colchicine binding by mebendazole was 10-fold greater for C. elegans tubulin than for ovine brain tubulin. The inhibition of [3H]colchicine binding to C. elegans tubulin by mebendazole is consistent with the recognised anthelmintic action of the benzimidazole carbamates. These data indicate that C. elegans is a useful model for examining the interactions between microtubule inhibitors and the colchicine binding site of nematode tubulin.     

Mechanism of binding of the new antimitotic drug MDL 27048 to the colchicine site of tubulin: equilibrium studies.

MDL 27048 [trans-1-(2,5-dimethoxyphenyl)-3-[4-(dimethylamino)phenyl]-2- methyl-2-propen-1-one] fluoresces when bound to tubulin but not in solution. This effect has been investigated and found to be mimicked by viscous solvents. Therefore, MDL 27048 appears to be a fluorescent compound whose intramolecular rotational relaxation varies as a function of microenvironment viscosity. The binding parameters of MDL 27048 to tubulin have been firmly established by fluorescence of the ligand, quenching of the protein fluorescence, and gel equilibrium chromatography. The apparent binding equilibrium constant was (2.75 +/- 0.45) x 10(6)M-1, and the binding site number was 0.81 +/- 0.12 (10 mM sodium phosphate-0.1 mM GTP, pH 7.0, at 25 degrees C). The binding is exothermic. The binding of MDL 27048 overlaps the colchicine and podophyllotoxin binding sites. Binding of MDL 27048 to the colchicine site was also measured by competition with MTC [2-methoxy-5-(2,3,4-trimethoxyphenyl)-2,4,6-cycloheptatrien-1-one] , a well-characterized reversibly binding probe of the colchicine site [Andreu et al. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 1742-1752; Bane et al., (1984) J. Biol. Chem. 259, 7391-7398]. In contrast with close analogues of colchicine, MDL 27048 and podophyllotoxin neither affected the far-ultraviolet circular dichroism spectrum of tubulin, within experimental error, nor induced tubulin GTPase activity. Like podophyllotoxin, an excess of MDL 27048 over tubulin induced no abnormal cooperative polymerization of tubulin, which is characteristic of colchicine binding.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The binding of isocolchicine to tubulin. Mechanisms of ligand association with tubulin

Isocolchicine is a structurally related isomer of colchicine altered in the methoxytropone C ring. In spite of virtual structural homology of colchicine and isocolchicine, isocolchicine is commonly believed to be inactive in binding to tubulin and inhibiting microtubule assembly. We have found that isocolchicine does indeed bind to the colchicine site on tubulin, as demonstrated by its ability to competitively inhibit [3H]colchicine binding to tubulin with a KI approximately 400 microM. Isocolchicine inhibits tubulin assembly into microtubules with an I50 of about 1 mM, but the affinity of isocolchicine for the colchicine receptor site, 5.5 +/- 0.9 x 10(3) M-1 at 23 degrees C, is much less (approximately 500-fold) than that of colchicine. Unlike colchicine, isocolchicine binds rapidly, and the absorption and fluorescence properties of the complex are only modestly altered compared to free ligand. It is proposed that the binding of isocolchicine to tubulin may be rationalized either in terms of conformational states of colchicinoids when liganded to tubulin or by the structural requirements for C-10 substituents for high affinity binding to the colchicine receptor.     

THE MECHANISM OF ACTION OF COLCHICINE : Colchicine Binding Properties of Sea Urchin Sperm Tail Outer Doublet Tubulin

The thermal depolymerization procedure of Stephens (1970. J. Mol. Biol. 47:353) has been employed for solubilization of Strongylocentrotus purpuratus sperm tail outer doublet microtubules with the use of a buffer during solubilization which is of optimal pH and ionic strength for the preservation of colchicine binding activity of chick embryo brain tubulin. Colchicine binding values were corrected for first-order decay during heat solubilization at 50°C (t_½ = 5.4 min) and incubation with colchicine at 37°C in the presence of vinblastine sulfate (t_½ = 485 min). The colchicine binding properties of heat-solubilized outer doublet tubulin were qualitatively identical with those of other soluble forms of tubulin. The solubilized tubulin (mol wt, 115,000) bound 0.9 ± 0.2 mol of colchicine per mol of tubulin, with a binding constant of 6.3 x 10⁵ liters/mol at 37°C. The colchicine binding reaction was both time and temperature dependent, and the binding of colchicine was prevented in a competitive manner by podophyllotoxin (K_i = 1.3 x 10^-6 M). The first-order decay of colchicine binding activity was substantially decreased by the addition of the vinca alkaloids, vinblastine sulfate or vincristine sulfate, thus demonstrating the presence of a vinca alkaloid binding site(s) on the outer doublet tubulin. Tubulin contained within the assembled microtubules did not decay. Intact outer doublet microtubules bound less than 0.001 mol of colchicine per mol of tubulin contained in the microtubules, under conditions where soluble tubulin would have bound 1 mol of colchicine per mol of tubulin (saturating concentration of colchicine, no decay of colchicine binding activity). The presence of colchicine had no effect on the rate of solubilization of outer doublet microtubules during incubation at 37°C. Therefore, the colchicine binding site on tubulin is blocked (not available to bind colchicine) when the tubulin is in the assembled outer doublet microtubules.     

Interaction of 1-propargyl-5-chloropyrimidin-2-one (a metahalone) with rat brain tubulin

The mitotic inhibitor 1-propargyl-5-chloropyrimidin-2-one (a metahalone) was found to bind to DEAE-cellulose purified rat brain tubulin. A decrease in the fluorescence of 1-propargyl-5-chloropyrimidin-2-one was seen when the drug was incubated in the presence of increasing tubulin concentrations. The decrease in metahalone fluorescence was not affected by the addition of GTP, indicating drug interaction at other portions of the tubulin molecule than the nucleotide binding sites. Scatchard plot analysis following incubation of tubulin with 1-propargyl-5-chloro-[2-14C]pyrimidin-2-one revealed that 1 mol of metahalone bound to 1 mol of tubulin dimer with a measured association constant of 8.0 X 10(3) M-1. Double reciprocal plots of vincristine and colchicine binding to tubulin in the presence of 1-propargyl-5-chloropyrimidin-2-one showed that the metahalone competitively inhibited colchicine binding to tubulin but had no influence on vincristine binding. This conclusion was supported by gel filtration chromatography where an increase in unbound colchicine was measured when 1-propargyl-5-chloropyrimidin-2-one was present in an incubation mixture containing colchicine and tubulin. In the presence of 5 mM 1-propargyl-5-chloropyrimidin-2-one, tubulin self-aggregated into crystalline structures. The binding of 1-propargyl-5-chloropyrimidin-2-one to tubulin at or near the colchicine binding site may be responsible for the metaphase arresting characteristics of this drug.     

Colchicine-binding sites of brain tubulins from an antarctic fish and from a mammal are functionally similar, but not identical: implications for microtubule assembly at low temperature.

The tubulins of Antarctic fishes possess adaptations that favor microtubule formation at low body temperatures (Detrich et al.: Biochemistry 28:10085-10093, 1989). To determine whether some of these adaptations may be present in a domain of tubulin that participates directly or indirectly in lateral contact between microtubule protofilaments, we have examined the energetics of the binding of colchicine, a drug thought to bind to such a site, to pure brain tubulins from an Antarctic fish (Notothenia gibberifrons) and from a mammal (the cow, Bos taurus). At temperatures between 0 and 20 degrees C, the affinity constants for colchicine binding to the fish tubulin were slightly smaller (1.5-2.6-fold) than those for bovine tubulin. van't Hoff analysis showed that the standard enthalpy changes for colchicine binding to the two tubulins were comparable (delta H degrees = +10.6 and +7.4 kcal mol-1 for piscine and bovine tubulins, respectively), as were the standard entropy changes (delta S degrees = +61.3 eu for N. gibberifrons tubulin, +51.2 eu for bovine tubulin). At saturating concentrations of the ligand, the maximal binding stoichiometry for each tubulin was approximately 1 mol colchicine/mol tubulin dimer. The data indicate that the colchicine-binding sites of the two tubulins are similar, but probably not identical, in structure. The apparent absence of major structural modifications at the colchicine site suggests that this region of tubulin is not involved in functional adaptation for low-temperature polymerization. Rather, the colchicine site of tubulin may have been conserved evolutionarily to serve in vivo as a receptor for endogenous molecules (i.e., "colchicine-like" molecules or MAPs) that regulate microtubule assembly.     

Involvement of colchicine binding site of tubulin in the polymerisation process

Role of lysine residues in the colchicine binding site and in the assembly-disassembly process was examined. It was observed that at 4 degrees C (pH 7.5-8, 8 +/- 1) lysine residues and the N-terminal methionine residue of tubulin were all buried within the molecule. Evidence indicates that epsilon-amino groups of lysine residues of tubulin are shared by both the colchicine binding site and the polymerisation process.     

The effect of TN-16 on the alkylation of tubulin

The synthetic anti-tumor drug 3-(1-anilinoethylidene)-5-benzylpyrrolidine-2,4-dione (TN-16) is known to block microtubule assembly and colchicine binding to tubulin, although its structure does not resemble those of either colchicine, podophyllotoxin, or nocodazole (Arai, FEBS Lett. 155:273-276 (1983]. We have found that TN-16 affects the intra-chain cross-linking of beta-tubulin by N,N'-ethylene-bis(iodoacetamide) in a manner identical to that of colchicine, podophyllotoxin, and nocodazole, but different from that of vinblastine or maytansine. TN-16 also inhibits alkylation of tubulin by iodo[14C]acetamide, as do colchicine and its congeners. TN-16 appears to bind to tubulin at the colchicine binding site and one of its phenyl groups is likely to bind at the site on tubulin where colchicine's A ring binds.     

Effect of tubulin binding and self-association on the near-ultraviolet circular dichroic spectra of colchicine and analogues

Near-UV circular dichroic (CD) spectra of three colchicine analogues that differ at the C-10 position have been obtained in the presence and absence of tubulin. All three colchicine analogues show dramatic alterations in the low-energy near-UV CD band upon tubulin binding that cannot be mimicked by solvent, but in no event does the rotational strength of the CD band decrease to nearly zero as in the case of colchicine [Detrich, H. W., III, Williams, R. C., Jr., Macdonald, T. L., & Puett, D. (1981) Biochemistry 20, 5999-6005]. The effect of self-association of colchicine and one of the C-10 analogues, thiocolchicine, on the near-UV CD band was also investigated. A qualitative similarity was seen between the near-UV CD spectra of colchicine and thiocolchicine dimers and the spectra of these molecules bound to tubulin. These observations support the previous suggestion that ligands bound to the colchicine site on tubulin may be interacting with an aromatic amino acid in the colchicine binding site [Hastie, S. B., & Rava, R. P. (1989) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 110, 6993-7001].     

The interaction of the B-ring of colchicine with alpha-tubulin: a novel footprinting approach

Tubulin, the major structural component of the microtubules, participates actively in mitotic spindle formation and chromosomal organization during cell division. Tubulin is the major target for a variety of anti-mitotic drugs. Some of the drugs, such as Vinca alkaloids and taxol, are routinely used for cancer chemotherapy. It is unfortunate that our knowledge of the binding sites on tubulin of these drugs is limited because of lack of a useful and appropriate tool. The photoaffinity labeling approach is the major technique available at present to detect the binding sites of drugs on tubulin. This method, however, has several limitations. First, only part of the binding site can be identified, namely, the residues which react with the photoaffinity label. Second, there are regions of tubulin which are not at the binding site but are affected by the binding of the drug; these regions can not be detected by the photoaffinity labeling approach. The third, and perhaps most serious, limitation is that the traditional approach can detect areas which have nothing to do with the binding of the ligand but which are within a certain distance of the binding site, that distance being less than the length of the photoreactive moiety attached to the ligand. There has been a great deal of controversy on the localization of the binding site of colchicine on tubulin, with some reports suggesting that the binding site is on alpha and some supporting a binding site on beta. Colchicine also has significant effects on tubulin conformation, but the regions which are affected have not been identified. We have attempted here to address these questions by a novel "footprinting" method by which the drug-binding sites and as well as the domain of tubulin affected by drug-induced conformational changes could be determined. Here, we report for the first time that the interaction of the B-ring of colchicine with the alpha-subunit affects a domain of tubulin which appears to be far from its binding site. This domain includes the cysteine residues at positions 295, 305, 315 and 316 on alpha-tubulin; these residues are located well away from the alpha/beta interface where colchicine appears to bind. This is correlated with the stabilizing effect of colchicine on the tubulin molecule. Furthermore, we also found that the B-ring of colchicine plays a major role in the stability of tubulin while the A and the C-rings have little effect on it. Our results therefore, support a model whereby colchicine binds at the alpha/beta interface of tubulin with the B-ring on the alpha-subunit and the A and the C-rings on the beta-subunit.     

Tubulin and tubulin-colchicine complex bind to brain microsomal membrane in vitro

Brain tubulin was labeled in vitro by post-translational incorporation of [14C]-tyrosine or in vivo by intra-cranial injection of [3H]-leucine. The labeled protein was purified by ion-exchange chromatography. After incubating at 37 degrees C with a microsomal membrane preparation from rat brain, part of the labeled soluble tubulin became sedimentable at high-speed centrifugation. This was independent of the native configuration of tubulin, the state of tyrosination of the COOH-terminus, or the presence of 100 microM colchicine in the mixture. In addition, the double-labeled tubulin-colchicine complex obtained from the binding of [3H]-colchicine to [14C]-tyrosinated tubulin, bound to the membrane preparation to the same extent as [14C]-tyrosinated tubulin. The data show that either tubulin or the complex resulting from its binding to colchicine distributed between the soluble and the membrane fractions when mixed at 37 degrees C with a microsome preparation. Seemingly, the site for colchicine binding to tubulin needs not to be free for the protein-membrane association.     

Binding to tubulin of an allocolchicine spin probe: interaction with the essential SH groups and other active sites

EPR titration of tubulin with an allocolchicine spin probe showed more than one binding site: one high-affinity binding site (Kd = 8 microM), consistent with the Ki found for competition with colchicine, and one or more low-affinity site(s) (Kd higher than 50 microM). No disturbance of the EPR signal of the tubulin-bound allocolchicine spin probe could be observed at room temperature in the presence of other paramagnetic probes: Mn(II) for the binding site of Mg(II), Co(II) for the Zn(II) binding site and Cr(III)GTP for the binding site of the exchangeable GTP. Labelling of tubulin with both the allocolchicine and a SH-group spin probe also showed lack of interaction. The colchicine-binding site is thus sterically isolated from the binding sites for GTP, Mg(II), Zn(II) and the two essential SH-groups. In the tubulin-colchicin complex, all SH-groups could still be labelled with an excess of the SH-reagent, N-ethylmaleimide. Furthermore, colchicine binding was only minimally influenced by the blocking of the two essential SH-groups. However, the rate constant of the reaction of two equivalents of the SH-reagent, a maleimide spin probe, with the tubulin-colchicine complex was only 50% of the rate constant found with uncomplexed tubulin. As direct steric interaction of the essential SH-groups with the colchicine-binding site can be excluded, we can now definitively decide that binding of colchicine to tubulin induces a conformational change, which affects the accessibility of the most reactive SH-groups.     

Charge effect on the colchicine binding-site of tubulin

Poly(L-lysine) was found to enhance colchicine binding activity of brain tubulin to a several folds. Bases of biological interests that were tested and found to be inactive were spermine, spermidine and even L-lysine. Part of this enhance binding is due to the increase in the affinity of colchicine-tubulin interaction in the presence of poly(L-lysine). Moreover, poly(L-lysine) stabilized the colchicine binding site of tubulin against thermal denaturation.     

Spectroscopic and kinetic features of allocolchicine binding to tubulin

Allocolchicine is a structural isomer of colchicine in which colchicine's tropone C ring is replaced with an aromatic ester. In spite of the structural differences between the two ligands, the association parameters for both molecules binding to tubulin are quite similar. The association constant for allocolchicine binding to tubulin was determined by fluorescence titration to be 6.1 x 10(5) M-1 at 37 degrees C, which is about a factor of 5 less than that of the colchicine-tubulin association. In particular, analysis of the kinetics of the association of allocolchicine with tubulin yielded nearly equivalent activation parameters for the two ligands. The activation energy of the allocolchicine binding reaction was found to be 18.4 +/- 1.5 kcal/mol, which is only slightly less than the activation energy for colchicine binding to tubulin. This finding argues against conformational flexibility of the C ring as the structural feature of colchicine responsible for the slow kinetics of colchicinoid-tubulin binding reactions. Tubulin binding promote a dramatic enhancement of allocolchicine fluorescence. Unlike colchicine, the emission energy and intensity of the tubulin-bound allocolchicine fluorescence can be mimicked by solvent, and a general hydrophobic environment for the ligand binding site is indicated. The excitation spectrum of the protein-bound species, however, is shown to possess two bands which center at higher and lower energy than the energy maximum of the spectrum of the ligand in apolar solvents, indicating that properties of the colchicine binding site in addition to a low dielectric constant contribute to the fluorescence of the bound species.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Quantitative characterization of the binding of fluorescently labeled colchicine to tubulin in vitro using fluorescence correlation spectroscopy

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) is a new technique that allows the determination of the diffusion constant of a fluorescent molecule in solution. Also, the binding of the fluorescent molecule to a target can be analyzed, if the difference in the diffusion coefficients of the free and bound ligand is sufficiently large. With FCS, the interaction between fluorescein-colchicine (FC) and tubulin has been studied in vitro. A fast and reversible binding is observed with an association constant at room temperature of (3.9 +/- 0.1) x 10(4) M-1. No competition with colchicine is seen, indicating that FCS reveals the existence of a new binding site on tubulin. FCS is not able to show the binding of FC to the original colchicine binding site, even though it exists, because the fluorescence of FC is strongly quenched upon binding to this site. This quenching is evident in spectrofluorometry experiments, revealing a slow binding of FC to tubulin that is subject to competition with colchicine. FCS allows the determination of the diffusion coefficients of both free and bound fluorescent colchicine which were found to be (2.6 +/- 0.2) x 10(-)10 and (2.0 +/- 0.2) x 10(-)11 m2 s-1, respectively. It can be concluded that fluorescent labeling, especially of small molecules, can interfere considerably with the binding behavior that is being studied. Although general qualitative effects in vivo are similar for colchicine and its fluorescein derivative, this quantitative study of the binding to tubulin presents a nuanced view, and the existence of a second binding site for FC can even explain some conflicting indications in the literature.     

Synthesis and mechanism of action of novel pyrimidinyl pyrazole derivatives possessing antiproliferative activity

Pyrimidinyl pyrazole derivatives 1-4, prepared as a new scaffold of an anti-tumor agent, showed antiproliferative activity against human lung cancer cell lines and inhibited tubulin polymerization. Furthermore, it was found that compound 2 bound at the colchicine site on tubulin, but the tubulin binding pattern was different from that of colchicine. Here, we describe the synthesis of the derivatives and the differences of the action mechanism on tubulin polymerization inhibition between compound 2 and colchicine.     

Roles of colchicine rings B and C in the binding process to tubulin

The interactions of tubulin with colchicine analogues in which the tropolone methyl ether ring had been transformed into a p-carbomethoxybenzene have been characterized. The analogues were allocolchicine (ALLO) and 2,3,4-trimethoxy-4'-carbomethoxy-1,1'-biphenyl (TCB), the first being transformed colchicine and the second transformed colchicine with ring B eliminated. The binding of both analogues has been shown to be specific for the colchicine binding site on tubulin by competition with colchicine and podophyllotoxin. Both analogues bind reversibly to tubulin with the generation of ligand fluorescence. The binding of ALLO is slow, the fluorescence reaching a steady state in the same time span as colchicine; that of TCB is rapid. The displacement of ALLO by podophyllotoxin proceeds with a half-life of ca. 40 min. Binding isotherms generated from gel filtration and fluorescence measurements have shown that both analogues bind to tubulin with a stoichiometry of 1 mol of analogue/mol of alpha-beta tubulin. The equilibrium binding constants at 25 degrees C have been found to be (9.2 +/- 2.5) x 10(5) M-1 for ALLO and (1.0 +/- 0.2) X 10(5) M-1 for TCB. Binding of both analogues was accompanied by quenching of protein fluorescence, perturbation of the far-ultraviolet circular dichroism of tubulin, and induction of the tubulin GTPase activity, similarly to colchicine binding. Both inhibited microtubule assembly in vitro, ALLO substoichiometrically, and both induced the abnormal cooperative polymerization of tubulin, which is characteristic of the tubulin-colchicine complex. Analysis in terms of the simple bifunctional ligand binding mechanism developed for colchicine [Andreu, J.M., & Timasheff, S.N. (1982) Biochemistry 21, 534-543] and comparison with the binding of the colchicine two-ring analogue, 2-methoxy-5-(2,3,4-trimethoxyphenyl)-2,4,6-cycloheptatrien-1-one [Andreu, J. M., Gorbunoff, M. J., Lee, J. C., & Timasheff, S. N. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 1742-1752], have shown that transformation of the tropolone methyl ether part of colchicine into p-carbomethoxybenzene weakens the standard free energy of binding to tubulin by 1.4 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol, while elimination of ring B weakens it by 1.0 +/- 0.1 kcal/mol. The roles of rings C and B of colchicine in the thermodynamic and kinetic mechanisms of binding to tubulin were analyzed in terms of these findings.     

Comparative molecular field analysis of colchicine inhibition and tubulin polymerization for combretastatins binding to the colchicine binding site on beta-tubulin

A molecular modeling study using Comparative Molecular Field Analysis (CoMFA) was undertaken to develop a predictive model for combretastatin binding to the colchicine binding site of tubulin. Furthermore, we examined the potential contribution of lipophilicity (log P) and molecular dipole moment and were unable to correlate these properties to the observed biological data. In this study we first confirmed that tubulin polymerization inhibition (IC50) correlated (R2 = 0.92) with [3H]colchicine displacement. Although these data correlated quite well, we developed two independent models for each set of data to quantify structural features that may contribute to each biological property independently. To develop our predictive model we first examined a series of molecular alignments for the training set and ultimately found that overlaying the respective trimethoxyphenyl rings (A ring) of the analogues generated the best correlated model. The CoMFA yielded a cross-validated R2 = 0.41 (optimum number of components equal to 5) for the tubulin polymerization model and an R2 = 0.38 (optimum number of components equal to 5) for [3H]colchicine inhibition. Final non-cross-validation generated models for tubulin polymerization (R2 of 0.93) and colchicine inhibition (R2 of 0.91). These models were validated by predicting both biological properties for compounds not used in the training set. These models accurately predicted the IC50 for tubulin polymerization with an R2 of 0.88 (n = 6) and those of [3H]colchicine displacement with an R2 of 0.80 (n = 7). This study represents the first predictive model for the colchicine binding site over a wide range of combretastatin analogues.