Intronic gene conversion in the evolution of human X-linked color vision genes

Human red and green visual pigment genes are X-linked duplicate genes. To study their evolutionary history, introns 2 and 4 (1,987 and 1,552 bp, respectively) of human red and green pigment genes were sequenced. Surprisingly, we found that intron 4 sequences of these two genes are identical and that the intron 2 sequences differ by only 0.3%. The low divergences are unexpected because the duplication event producing the two genes is believed to have occurred before the separation of the human and Old World monkey (OWM) lineages. Indeed, the divergences in the two introns are significantly lower than both the synonymous divergence (3.2% +/- 1.1%) and the nonsynonymous divergence (2.0% +/- 0.5%) in the coding sequences (exons 1-6). A comparison of partial sequences of exons 4 and 5 of human and OWM red and green pigment genes supports the hypothesis that the gene duplication occurred before the human-OWM split. In conclusion, the high similarities in the two intron sequences might be due to very recent gene conversion, probably during evolution of the human lineage.      

A new mechanism in blue cone monochromatism

Blue cone monochromatism (BCM) is a rare X-linked colour vision disorder characterized by the absence of both red and green cone sensitivity. Most mutations leading to BCM fall into two classes of alterations in the red and green pigment gene array at Xq28. In one class the red and green pigment genes are inactivated by deletion in the locus control region. In the second class genetic rearrangements have created an isolated pigment gene that carries an inactivating point mutation. Here we describe a clinical case of BCM caused by a new mutation where exon 4 of an isolated red pigment gene has been deleted. The finding represents the first intragenic deletion yet described among red and green pigment genes. Received: 29 December 1995 / Revised: 30 May 1996     

Gene conversion and natural selection in the evolution of X-linked color vision genes in higher primates

During higher primate evolution, gene conversion seems to have occurred often between the red and green photo-pigment genes, which are tandemly linked on the X chromosome. To understand this phenomenon better, intron 4 sequences of the red and green pigment genes of a male human (an Asian Indian), a male chimpanzee, and a male baboon were amplified by PCR and sequenced. The data show that the intron 4 sequences between the two genes have been strongly or completely homogenized in the three species studied. Apparently recent gene conversion events have occurred in introns 4 of the red and green pigment genes in humans and chimpanzees. Two or more conversion events may have occurred at different times in introns 4 of the two pigment genes in baboons. The divergence between the two genes is significantly lower in intron 4 than in exons 4 and 5 in each species, contrary to the usual situation that introns evolve faster than exons. It is most likely that strong natural selection for maintaining the distinct functions of exons 4 and 5 of the red and green pigment genes has acted against sequence homogenization of these exons.      

Molecular patterns and sequence polymorphisms in the red and green visual pigment genes of Japanese men

The red-green pigment gene arrays of 203 (101 from a previous study and 102 from this study) randomly selected men of Japanese ancestry from the Seattle area were screened for the abnormal molecular patterns (deletions and red/green or green/red hybrid genes) that are usually associated with defective color vision. Such molecular patterns were found in approximately 5% of these individuals, which is equivalent to the frequency of phenotypic color vision defects in Japanese males in Japan. Thus, the majority of hybrid genes carried by Japanese males appear to be associated with defective color vision. In contrast, the frequency of hybrid genes among Caucasians and African-Americans is approximately two and five times the frequency of color vision defects in these two ethnic groups, respectively. The coding sequences of 50 males of Japanese ancestry were determined. All the polymorphisms in the red and green pigment genes that were detected in the Japanese sample had been observed in Caucasians and African-Americans. The same polymorphisms of the red pigment gene were present in the green pigment gene, suggesting that gene conversion contributes to sequence homogenization between these pigment genes. As is the case for Caucasians, exon 3 of the red and green pigment genes was observed to be a hot spot for recombination and gene conversion. Fewer polymorphic sites (4 vs 11) and haplotypes (5 vs 14) of the red pigment gene were observed in Japanese than in Caucasians. The Japanese population was more uniform with respect to the red pigment gene, with 70% of individuals having the same haplotype, as compared with the 43% for the Caucasian population. This difference was largely due to the lower degree of polymorphism at position 180 of the red pigment gene in Japanese (84% Ser and 16% Ala vs 62% Ser and 38% Ala.) The number of polymorphic sites and haplotypes in the green pigment gene was similar in the two populations. Nevertheless, the Japanese population was more uniform with 65% having the same haplotype. The difference in the frequency of alleles at position 283 accounted for this difference in haplotype distribution.     

Molecular basis of abnormal red-green color vision: a family with three types of color vision defects

The molecular nature of three different types of X-linked color-vision defects, protanomaly, deuteranomaly, and protanopia, in a large 3-generation family was determined. In the protanomalous and protanopic males the normal red pigment gene was replaced by a 5' red-3' green fusion gene. The protanomalous male had more red pigment DNA in his fusion gene than did the more severely affected protanopic individual. The deuteranomalous individual had four green pigment genes and one 5' green-3' red fusion gene. These results extend those of Nathans et al., who proposed that most red-green color-vision defects arise as a result of unequal crossing-over between the red and green pigment genes. The various data suggest that differences in severity of color-vision defects associated with fusion genes are caused by differences in crossover sites between the red and green pigment genes. Currently used molecular methodology is not sufficiently sensitive to define these fusion points accurately, and the specific color-vision defect within the deutan or protan class cannot be predicted. The DNA patterns for color-vision genes of female heterozygotes have not previously been described. Patterns of heterozygotes may not be distinguishable from those of normals. However, a definite assignment of the various color pigment gene arrays could be carried out by family study. Two compound heterozygotes for color-vision defects who tested as normal by anomaloscopy were found to carry abnormal fusion genes. In addition, a normal red pigment gene was present on one chromosome and at least one normal green pigment gene was present on the other.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Frequent gene conversion between human red and green opsin genes

To study the evolution of human X-linked red and green opsin genes, genomic sequences in large regions of the two genes were compared. The divergences in introns 3, 4, and 5 and the 3′ flanking sequence of the two genes are significantly lower than those in exons 4 and 5. The homogenization mechanism of introns and the 3′ flanking sequence of human red and green opsin genes is probably gene conversion, which also occurred in exons 1 and 6. At least one gene conversion event occurred in each of three regions (1, 3, and 5) in the sequences compared. In conclusion, gene conversion has occurred frequently between human red and green opsin genes, but exons 2, 3, 4, and 5 have been maintained distinct between the two genes by natural selection. Received: 29 September 1997 / Accepted: 29 September 1997     

Unexpected Conservation of the X-Linked Color Vision Gene in Nocturnal Prosimians: Evidence from Two Bush Babies

Bush babies have had a long history of nocturnal life and it would be interesting to know whether their color vision genes have become degenerate. Therefore, we used PCR techniques to sequence the X-linked pigment gene of two of these nocturnal prosimians: Galago senegalensis and Otolemur garnettii. Southern hybridization of genomic DNA of G. senegalensis showed a single X-linked pigment gene. Interestingly, the deduced pigment sequences of the two bush babies are identical. By comparing the X-linked pigments of bush baby, human, squirrel monkey, and marmoset, 38 variable positions were identified. At those positions that may cause a spectral shift, the bush baby pigment has identical or biochemically similar residues to those of the marmoset cone pigment with a spectral peak of 543 nm. This result is consistent with the estimate of 544–545 nm for the spectral peak of the X-linked pigment of Otolemur crassicaudatus, which is closely related to Otolemur garnettii. The neighbor-joining tree of mammalian X-linked pigments showed a significantly shorter branch in the bush baby lineage than in other primate lineages. A relative rate test showed that the nonsynonymous substitution rate of the bush baby X-linked pigment gene is about three times slower than that of the human red pigment gene, though the synonymous substitution rates of the two genes are similar. The slower nonsynonymous rate in the bush baby lineage suggests that the bush baby X-linked pigment gene is under functional constraints, in spite of its nocturnal life. Two radical changes at positions in the intradiskal surface next to the sixth transmembrane domain were observed in the X-linked cone pigment of bush babies but not in other primates. They are changes from Ala to Ser and from Asn to His, which are similar in function to the corresponding residues in rhodopsins. These two changes may be of importance for dim light sensitivity, which is consistent with our proposal that the evolution of the bush baby X-linked pigment gene is under selective pressure. In addition, the 2.5% divergence in introns 2 and 5 of the X-linked pigment gene between the two bush babies supports their classification into two separate genera. Received: 30 November 1996 / Accepted: 17 June 1997     

Molecular evolution of human visual pigment genes

By comparing the published DNA sequences for (a) the genes encoding the human visual color pigments (red, green, and blue) with (b) the genes encoding human, bovine, and Drosophila rhodopsins, a phylogenetic tree for the mammalian pigment genes has been constructed. This evolutionary tree shows that the common ancestor of the visual color pigment genes diverged first from that of the rhodopsin genes; then the common ancestor of the red and green pigment genes and the ancestor of the blue pigment gene diverged; and finally the red and green pigment genes diverged from each other much more recently. Nucleotide substitutions in the rhodopsin genes are best explained by the neutral theory of molecular evolution. However, important functional adaptations seem to have occurred twice during the evolution of the color pigment genes in humans: first, to the common ancestor of the three color pigment genes after its divergence from the ancestor of the rhodopsin gene and, second, to the ancestor of the red pigment gene after its divergence from that of the green pigment gene.     

Spectrum of color gene deletions and phenotype in patients with blue cone monochromacy

Blue cone monochromacy (BCM) is an X-linked ocular disease characterized by poor visual acuity, nystagmus, and photodysphoria in males with severely reduced color discrimination. Deletions, rearrangements and point mutations in the red and green pigment genes have been implicated in causing BCM. We assessed the spectrum of genetic alterations in ten families with BCM by Southern blot, polymerase chain reaction, and sequencing analysis, and the phenotype was characterized by ophthalmoscopy, fluorescein angiography, and a battery of tests to assess color vision in addition to routine ophthalmological examination. All families showed clinical features associated with BCM. Acuities were reduced in all affected males, and photopic b-wave was reduced by more than 90% in seven families. In three families, however, the photopic b-wave response showed uncharacteristic relative preservation of 30-80% (of the clinical low-normal value). The color vision was unusually preserved in two affected males, but this was not correlated with photopic electroretinography retention. Progressive macular atrophy was observed in affected members of two BCM families while the rest of the families presented with normal fundus. In nine families deletions were identified in the gene encoding the red-sensitive photopigment and/or in the region up to 17.8 kb upstream of the red gene which contains the locus control region and other regulatory sequences. In the same nine families the red pigment gene showed a range of deletions from the loss of a single exon to loss of the complete red gene. In one family no mutation was found in the exons of the red gene or the locus control region but showed loss of the complete green gene. No association was observed between the phenotypes and genotypes in these families.     

Signatures of selection and gene conversion associated with human color vision variation

Trichromatic color vision in humans results from the combination of red, green, and blue photopigment opsins. Although color vision genes have been the targets of active molecular and psychophysical research on color vision abnormalities, little is known about patterns of normal genetic variation in these genes among global human populations. The current study presents nucleotide sequence analyses and tests of neutrality for a 5.5-kb region of the X-linked long-wave "red" opsin gene (OPN1LW) in 236 individuals from ethnically diverse human populations. Our analysis of the recombination landscape across OPN1LW reveals an unusual haplotype structure associated with amino acid replacement variation in exon 3 that is consistent with gene conversion. Compared with the absence of OPN1LW amino acid replacement fixation since divergence from chimpanzee, the human population exhibits a significant excess of high-frequency OPN1LW replacements. Our results suggest that subtle changes in L-cone opsin wavelength absorption may have been adaptive during human evolution.     

Frequent alterations of visual pigment genes in adrenoleukodystrophy.

Both adrenoleukodystrophy (ALD) and red/green color blindness have been mapped to the distal long arm of the human X chromosome (Xq28). Color-vision defects are frequently associated with ALD, and study of the red and green visual pigment genes in eight ALD kindreds has shown frequent structural changes including deletions and possible intragenic recombinations. Such changes may reflect chromosomal events underlying both ALD and the associated visual defects and should help define both the structural gene responsible for ALD and physical genetic relationships in the Xq28 region.     

A 195-kb cosmid walk encompassing the human Xq28 color vision pigment genes

By using cosmid walking, we have cloned a 195-kb region from chromosome band Xq28 that encompasses the red and green color pigment genes and 85 kb of flanking sequences. This has allowed us to confirm that the color pigment genes are within very homologous units arranged in tandem array. Each unit contains two BssHII sites and one NruI site that are frequently methylated in male leukocyte DNA. A NotI and an EagI site are present 6 kb upstream from the red pigment gene promoter; the NotI site was shown to be unmethylated in the active X chromosome in leukocytes and may represent a CpG island for the whole cluster. We have identified another CpG island, 61 kb 3' from the last green pigment gene, that is unmethylated in leukocytes on the active X chromosome, but methylated on the inactive X. This island is flanked by sequences conserved in evolution and may thus correspond to an expressed gene. We also describe an informative three-allele restriction fragment length polymorphism within the pigment gene cluster.     

The gene encoding L1, a neural adhesion molecule of the immunoglobulin family, is located on the X chromosome in mouse and man

The murine and human genes for the L1 neural adhesion molecule were shown to lie on conserved regions of the X chromosome to which genes responsible for several neuromuscular diseases have been mapped and which are adjacent to the fragile site (FRAXA) associated with mental retardation. By pulsed-field gel mapping we have demonstrated physical linkage between the L1 gene and other genes located in Xq28: L1 lies between the eye pigment RCP, GCP locus and the glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD) gene. This location is compatible with the implication of the L1 molecule in one of the X-linked neuromuscular diseases mapped to this region.     

Sex-linked mammalian sperm proteins evolve faster than autosomal ones

X-linked genes can evolve slower or faster depending on whether most recessive, or at least partially recessive alleles are deleterious or beneficial due to their hemizygous expression in males. Molecular studies of X chromosome divergence have provided conflicting evidence for both a higher and lower rate of nucleotide substitution at both synonymous and nonsynonymous sites, depending on the nucleotide sites sampled. Using human and mouse orthologous genes, we tested the hypothesis that genes encoding male-specific sperm proteins are evolving faster on the X chromosome compared with autosomes. X-linked sperm proteins have an average nonsynonymous mutation rate almost twice as high as sperm genes found on autosomes, unlike other tissue-specific genes, where no significant difference in the nonsynonymous mutation rate between the X chromosome and autosomes was found. However, no difference was found in the average synonymous mutation rate of X-linked versus autosomal sperm proteins, which along with corresponding higher values of Ka/Ks in X-linked sperm proteins suggest that differences in selective forces and not mutation rates are the underlying cause of higher X-linked mammalian sperm protein divergence.     

Genetic heterogeneity among blue-cone monochromats

Thirty-three unrelated subjects with blue-cone monochromacy or closely related variants of blue-cone monochromacy were examined for rearrangements in the tandem array of genes encoding the red- and green-cone pigments. In 24 subjects, eight genotypes were found that would be predicted to eliminate the function of all of the genes within the array. As observed in an earlier study, the rearrangements involve either deletion of a locus control region adjacent to the gene array or loss of function via homologous recombination and point mutation. One inactivating mutation, Cys²⁰³-to-Arg, was found in 15 probands who carry single genes and in both visual pigment genes in one subject whose array has two genes. This mutation was also found in at least one of the visual pigment genes in 1 subject whose array has multiple genes and in 2 of 321 control subjects, suggesting that preexisting Cys²⁰³-to-Arg mutations constitute a reservoir of chromosomes that are predisposed to generate blue-cone-monochromat genotypes by unequal homologous recombination and/or gene conversion. Two other point mutations were identified: (a) Arg²⁴⁷-to-Ter in one subject with a single red-pigment gene and (b) Pro³⁰⁷-to-Leu in one subject with a single 5' red-3' green hybrid gene. The observed heterogeneity of genotypes points to the existence of multiple one- and two-step mutational pathways to blue-cone monochromacy.     

Genotype-phenotype relationships in human red/green color-vision defects: molecular and psychophysical studies.

The relationship between the molecular structure of the X-linked red and green visual pigment genes and color-vision phenotype as ascertained by anomaloscopy was studied in 64 color-defective males. The great majority of red-green defects were associated with either the deletion of the green-pigment gene or the formation of 5' red-green hybrid genes or 5' green-red hybrid genes. A rapid PCR-based method allowed detection of hybrid genes, including those undetectable by Southern blot analysis, as well as more precise localization of the fusion points in hybrid genes. Protan color-vision defects appeared always associated with 5' red-green hybrid genes. Carriers of single red-green hybrid genes with fusion in introns 1-4 were protanopes. However, carriers of hybrid genes with red-green fusions in introns 2, 3, or 4 in the presence of additional normal green genes manifested as either protanopes or protanomalous trichromats, with the majority being protanomalous. Deutan defects were associated with green-pigment gene deletions, with 5' green-red hybrid genes, or, rarely, with 5' green-red-green hybrid genes. Complete green-pigment gene deletions or green-red fusions in intron 1 were usually associated with deuteranopia, although we unexpectedly found three carriers of a single red-pigment gene without any green-pigment genes to be deuteranomalous trichromats. All but one of the other deuteranomalous subjects had green-red hybrid genes with intron 1, 2, 3, or 4 fusions, as well as several normal green-pigment genes. The one exception had a grossly normal gene array, presumably with a more subtle mutation. Amino acid differences in exon 5 largely determine whether a hybrid gene will be more redlike or more greenlike in phenotype. Various discrepancies as to severity (dichromacy or trichromacy) remain unexplained but may arise because of variability of expression, postreceptoral variation, or both. When phenotypic color-vision defects exist, the kind of defect (protan or deutan) can be predicted by molecular analysis. Red-green hybrid genes are probably always associated with protan color-vision defects, while the presence of green-red hybrid genes may not always manifest phenotypically with color-vision defects. Four subjects who were found to have 5' green-red hybrid genes in addition to normal red- and green-pigment genes had normal color vision as determined by anomaloscopy. These were discovered among a group of 129 Caucasian males who had been recruited as volunteers for a vision study.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

A visual pigment from chicken that resembles rhodopsin: amino acid sequence, gene structure, and functional expression.

The amino acid sequence of a rhodopsin-like visual pigment from chickens has been determined by isolating and sequencing its gene. The predicted sequence is between 70% and 80% identical to bovine, human, and chicken rhodopsins and between 40% and 50% identical to human blue, green, and red cone pigments, the chicken red cone pigment, and cavefish long-wave cone pigments. The encoded pigment, produced by transfection of cDNA into cultured cells, absorbs maximally at 495 nm as determined from photobleaching difference spectra and reacts at 20 degrees C with 50 mM hydroxylamine with a half-time of 16 min. These properties, together with a high pI predicted from the amino acid sequence, suggest that this cloned gene encodes the chicken green pigment previously identified by biochemical and spectroscopic studies. This sequence defines a new branch of the visual pigment gene family.     

The Rap and Hor proteins of Erwinia, Serratia and Yersinia: a novel subgroup in a growing superfamily of proteins regulating diverse physiological processes in bacterial pathogens

The enteric bacterium Serratia marcescens is an opportunistic human pathogen. The strain ATCC39006 makes the red pigment, prodigiosin (Pig), and the β-lactam antibiotic carbapenem (Car). Mutants were isolated that were concomitantly defective for Pig and Car production. These mutants were found to have a mutation in the rap gene (regulation of antibiotic and pigment). Sequence analysis of the rap gene revealed a predicted protein product showing strong homology to SlyA, originally thought to be a haemolytic virulence determinant in Salmonella typhimurium. Homologues of rap were detected in several bacterial genera, including Salmonella, Yersinia, Enterobacter , and species of the plant pathogen, Erwinia. The Erwinia hor_Er (homologue of rap ) and the Yersinia hor_Ye genes were also found to be very similar to rap and slyA. Marker exchange mutagenesis of hor_Er revealed that it encoded a regulatory protein controlling the production of antibiotic and exoenzyme virulence determinants in the phytopathogen, Erwinia carotovora subspecies carotovora. We have shown that these new homologues of SlyA form a highly conserved subgroup of a growing superfamily of bacterial regulatory proteins controlling diverse physiological processes in human, animal and plant pathogens.     

Interchromosomal gene conversion as a possible mechanism for explaining divergence patterns of ZFY-related genes

Summary The divergence pattern of mammalian ZFY-related genes from human (ZFY and ZFX) and mouse (Zfy-1 and Zfx) was reexamined on the basis of nucleotide substitutions at the synonymous codon-alternating positions. It is possible to explain the unusual divergence pattern of the mammalian Y-linked ZF genes by interchromosomal gene conversion by X-linked ZF genes. Furthermore, the rates of evolution of mammalian X- and Y-linked ZF genes were shown to agree well with those expected from our model. Offprint requests to: T. Miyata     

Sequence and evolutionary history of the length polymorphism in intron 1 of the human red photopigment gene

The length of intron 1 of the red pigment gene is domorphic among Africans but not among Caucasians or Asians. This dimorphism was found to result from the presnce or basence of a block of 1,284 bp comprised of threeAlu elements and 328 bp of intervening unique-sequence DNA. This additional sequence in the long intron 1 of the red pigment gene was shown to have inserted into a fourth and olderAlu element present in the short form of intron 1. Furthermore, the size and sequence of the short intron 1 of the red pigment gene is equivalent to that of the adjacent green pigment gene. The block containing the threeAlu elements was not found in intron 1 of the red or green pigment genes of Old World monkeys and orangutans but was present in intron 1 ofboth the green and red pigment genes of gorillas and chimpanzees. The nucleotide sequence of this block in Old World primates and the estimated ages of the three elements suggest that their insertion occurred sequentially in the Old World monkey lineage prior to duplication of the ancestral X-chromosome-linked pigment gene. After gene duplication, deletion of the entire block containing the threeAlu elements from one of the genes created the short intron variant. Unequal recombination between the adjacent and highly homologous red and green pigment genes may have resulted in the formation of the short intron variant of the other gene.