Structural determinants of a glucocorticoid receptor recognition element

Analysis of the relative inducibility of an extensive series of mutant glucocorticoid response elements (GREs) defines features critical to the constitution of an active GRE. Assuming that function as a GRE reflects binding of glucocorticoid receptor, our activity data are consistent with the recognition of the GRE as two hexamer half-sites, each half-site recognized by a single subunit of a receptor dimer, probably in a cooperative fashion. Integrity of both half-sites is necessary for an active element, and spacing of the half-sites is critical. The identity of 1 basepair within the hexamer half-site is unconstrained; the receptor probably makes no base-specific contacts at this position. In contrast, at other positions within the half-site, limited substitutions (if any) can be tolerated. These results along with data from certain insertion mutations suggest that the receptor recognizes each hexamer half-site as two separable subelements. A further implication is that the DNA-binding domain of the glucocorticoid receptor is composed of distinct subdomains, which interact with the subelements of the recognition sequence.     

Molecular interactions of steroid hormone receptor with its enhancer element: evidence for receptor dimer formation

A steroid hormone responsive element (GRE/PRE), sufficient to confer glucocorticoid and progesterone inducibility when linked to a reporter gene, was used in band-shift assays to examine its molecular interactions with steroid hormone receptors. Both progesterone and glucocorticoid receptors bound directly and specifically to the GRE/PRE. The purine contact sites for both form A and form B chicken progesterone receptor, as well as those for rat glucocorticoid receptor, are identical. A peptide fragment produced in bacteria that primarily contain the DNA binding domain of the glucocorticoid receptor binds first to the TGTTCT half-site of the GRE/PRE, and a second molecule binds subsequently to the TGTACA (half-site) of the GRE/PRE in a cooperative manner. Utilizing the peptide fragment and the protein A-linked fragment, we demonstrated that the receptor interacts with its cognate enhancer as a dimer.     

Efficient binding of glucocorticoid receptor to its responsive element requires a dimer and DNA flanking sequences

A combination of the gel retardation assay and interference by hydroxyl radical modification (missing nucleoside technique) was used to analyze the interaction of the glucocorticoid receptor (GR) with various glucocorticoid responsive elements (GRE). Short oligonucleotides containing the 15-bp GRE and 1 to 3 flanking base pairs on each side, are bound with very low affinity. The same GREs, when positioned in the center of a large DNA fragment (40-50 bp), show high affinity for the receptor. However, when the GRE is positioned at the border of a 54-bp fragment, the affinity of the GR for the GRE decreases markedly. The DNA binding affinity increases linearly with each added flanking base pair and optimal binding is observed with 8-10 flanking bp. Thus, the nonconserved DNA sequences flanking the GRE contribute significantly to the free energy of receptor binding to DNA. Using larger DNA fragments (greater than 100 bp) and a smaller form of the receptor (40 kD), two retarded complexes are found that correspond to monomeric and homodimeric receptor DNA complexes. The DNA-binding domain of the GR (20 kD), expressed in bacteria, binds to the GRE as a monomer as well as a dimer and can form heterodimers with the native 94-kD GR. Insertion or deletion of one single base pair between the two halves of the GRE reduces the affinity for the homodimeric form of the native GR, and inhibits the function of the GRE in gene transfer experiments, suggesting that a dimer of the GR is the functional entity that binds to the GRE.     

Glucocorticoid receptor binds cooperatively to adjacent recognition sites.

In order to define the mechanism of synergistic induction mediated by multiple glucocorticoid response elements (GRE), the affinity of the glucocorticoid receptor to a single or duplicated GRE was analyzed by gel retardation, nitrocellulose filter binding and by footprinting experiments. Direct measurement of the relative affinity and indirect determination by competition showed greater than 10-fold higher affinity of the glucocorticoid receptor to a duplicated GRE when compared to a single element. Maximal stability of the GRE-receptor complex was obtained using two closely spaced GREs positioned on the same side of the DNA helix. Increasing the distance or changing the helical position of the GREs considerably increased the off rate of the receptor. DNase I footprinting shows in addition to the protection of the GRE region, an altered pattern in the nonprotected intervening DNA indicating structural alteration of the DNA helix by the receptor bound to adjacent GREs.     

1H NMR studies of DNA recognition by the glucocorticoid receptor: complex of the DNA binding domain with a half-site response element.

The complex of the rat glucocorticoid receptor (GR) DNA binding domain (DBD) and half-site sequence of the consensus glucocorticoid response element (GRE) has been studied by two-dimensional 1H NMR spectroscopy. The DNA fragment is a 10 base-pair oligonucleotide, 5'd(GCTGTTCTGC)3'.5'd-(GCAGAACAGC)3', containing the stronger binding GRE half-site hexamer, with GC base pairs at each end. The 93-residue GR-DBD contains an 86-residue segment corresponding to residues 440-525 of the rat GR. Eleven NOE cross peaks between the protein and DNA have been identified, and changes in the chemical shift of the DNA protons upon complex formation have been analyzed. Using these protein-DNA contact points, it can be concluded that (i) the "recognition helix" formed by residues C460-E469 lies in the major groove of the DNA; (ii) the GR-DBD is oriented on the GRE half-site such that residues A477-D481, forming the so-called D-loop, are available for protein-protein interaction in the GR-DBD dimer on the intact consensus GRE; and (iii) the 5-methyl of the second thymine in the half-site and valine 462 interact, confirming indirect evidence [Truss et al. (1990) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 87, 7180-7184; Mader et al. (1989) Nature 338, 271-274] that both play an important role in GR-DBD DNA binding. These findings are consistent with the model proposed by H?rd et al. [(1990) Science 249, 157-160] and the X-ray crystallographic complex structure determined by Luisi et al. [(1991) Nature 352, 497-505].     

Affinity of interactions between human glucocorticoid receptors and DNA: at physiologic ionic strength, stable binding occurs only with DNAs containing partially symmetric glucocorticoid response elements

Sucrose density gradient shift assays were adapted to permit determination of the affinity of interaction between human glucocorticoid receptors (GR) and DNA under conditions of DNA excess. Saturation analyses were performed to ascertain dissociation constants for the interaction of activated human GR with each of five DNA fragments. Centrifugation of GR-DNA complexes on sucrose gradients under nearly isotonic salt conditions revealed similar affinities with dissociation constants in the range of 2-16 nM for GR interaction with DNA fragments containing glucocorticoid response elements (GREs) exhibiting partial dyad symmetry. By contrast, GR exhibited virtually no affinity for non-GRE-containing DNA or for DNA containing only GRE half-sites. Additionally, GR showed evidence of multiple-site interaction with a DNA fragment containing two partially symmetric GREs, but interacted at only one site of an MMTV LTR DNA fragment containing a single partially symmetric GRE along with a cluster of three half-GREs. Together these data indicate that under physiologically relevant conditions, glucocorticoid receptors have high selectivity and affinity only for DNA containing specific partially symmetric GREs and further suggest that this high affinity for such DNA sites may be sufficient to account for the selective regulation of gene expression observed in glucocorticoid-responsive cells.     

UV cross-linking/immunoprecipitation assay: glucocorticoid receptor-adrenergic receptor gene sequence interaction

The rat beta 1-adrenergic receptor (beta 1-AR) gene contains glucocorticoid response element (GRE) half-sites at positions -2767 and -945. In electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) experiments, neither beta 1-AR GRE half-site recognized glucocorticoid receptors (GRs) obtained from baculovirus high-level expression systems or from mammalian cells. We have developed a sensitive UV cross-linking/immunoprecipitation assay, using a 524-bp fragment containing the prototypical GRE obtained from the rat tyrosine aminotransferase promoter sequence and using antibodies recognizing mammalian GR. Using this assay, we provide evidence that rat beta 1-AR gene sequences recognize mammalian GRs expressed in mouse 3T3 cells and that the site of GR interaction does not appear to specifically contain the beta 1-AR GRE half-sites. This represents one of the first reports demonstrating the utility of a UV cross-linking/immunoprecipitation assay in the detection of mammalian GR interaction with beta 1-AR sequences, is consistent with the lack of specific DNA-GR protein complexes observed in EMSA experiments using oligonucleotide probes containing the beta 1-AR GRE half-sites, and provides evidence that mammalian GR interaction occurs at complex rate beta 1-AR gene sequences.     

Estrogen receptor alpha interaction with estrogen response element half-sites from the rat prolactin gene

Estrogen regulation of the rat prolactin gene requires sequences within the DNase I hypersensitive site II (HSII). We have used overexpressed mouse estrogen receptor alpha (ERalpha) protein to study interactions of ERalpha with an imperfect estrogen response element (ERE) and four ERE half-site sequences from HSII. We confirmed that ERalpha has higher affinity for ERE half-sites than for the imperfect ERE. As expected, the imperfect ERE formed a complex with ERalpha similar to that between mERalpha and a consensus ERE in gel shift assays. The ERalpha complex with half-sites, however, had faster mobility on a 4% polyacrylamide gel than the ERalpha complex with a consensus ERE, indicating that the complexes had different compositions. Ferguson analysis revealed that the ERalpha/half-site complex had a larger molecular weight and higher negative charge than the ERalpha/consensus ERE complex. Similar results were observed with purified human ERalpha, showing that the ERalpha/half-site complex contained only ERalpha and oligonucleotides. These results are best explained by a model in which a dimer of ERalpha is bound to two half-site oligonucleotides. We propose that two ERalpha dimers may interact with the four ERE half-sites in HSII to influence estrogen regulation of this gene.