Self-reactive, T cell receptor-gamma delta+, lymphocytes from the intestinal epithelium of weanling mice.

Intraepithelial T lymphocytes (IEL) are dispersed throughout the intestinal epithelial lining but their role in cellular immune defense is unknown. Their location suggests that their highly activated state may be due to constant exposure to bacterial Ag. To study IEL specificity and function we have prepared a panel of IEL-T cell hybridomas from both adult and weanling C57B1/6 mice. Many of these expressed TCR-gamma delta, a cell type rare in peripheral lymph nodes and spleen but predominant at epithelial surfaces. We have identified a subset of gamma delta T cells from weanling mice which is self reactive, i.e., these hybrids secrete IL-2 spontaneously, without antigenic stimulation or a requirement for APC. Self-reactive TCR-gamma delta+ hybrids and lines, all of which bear a particular TCR (V gamma 1.1C gamma 4V delta 6), have previously been derived from neonatal thymus and the skin. Northern blot and immunoprecipitation analyses suggest that the self-reactive IEL hybrids also bear a C gamma 4/V delta 6 TCR. Antibody inhibition experiments showed that the self-reactivity of the IEL hybrids is TCR mediated. Spontaneous IL-2 production was blocked by soluble anti-CD3 and anti-TCR-gamma delta antibodies but not by antibodies to the TCR-alpha beta. The self-reactive IEL hybrids lack class II MHC and the class I-like proteins CD1 and TLA but express class I MHC. IEL hybrids may also require the vitronectin receptor as an accessory molecule for their activation because spontaneous IL-2 production is blocked by antibody to the vitronectin receptor as well as by the extracellular matrix protein active site peptide RGDS, but not the control peptide RGES. V gamma 1.1C gamma 4V delta 6 T cells in the thymus, skin, and intestine may represent a small and unique subpopulation of lymphocytes with a potential for autoimmune reactivity at peripheral sites.     

Functional gamma delta T-lymphocyte defect associated with human immunodeficiency virus infections.

BACKGROUND: Antiviral cellular immune responses may influence immunological homeostasis in HIV-infected persons. Recent data indicate that V gamma 9/V delta 2 T lymphocytes display potent cytotoxic activities against human cells infected with certain viruses including HIV. Understanding the role of gamma delta T cells in the course of HIV infection may be helpful for designing novel treatment strategies for HIV-associated disorders. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The constitutive recognition of Daudi cells and monoethyl pyrophosphate (Etpp) by peripheral blood V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells was assessed using a proliferation assay. The cytotoxicity of Daudi-stimulated lymphocyte populations was measured by chromium release assays. The HIV infectivity for gamma delta T cell clones was determined by measuring the levels of HIV p24 in cell supernatants. The effect of in vitro HIV-infection on cytokine mRNA production by gamma delta T cell clones was assessed by PCR. RESULTS: The constitutive proliferative responses of peripheral blood V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells and the lytic functions of Daudi-expanded lymphoid cells from HIV+ persons were substantially diminished in comparison with those of HIV-seronegative persons. These alterations were present in asymptomatic HIV+ persons prior to substantial alpha beta CD4+ T cell loss. Productive HIV infection of gamma delta T cells in vitro had no measurable effect either on their proliferative response to Daudi stimuli or on the expression of cytokine mRNAs for IFN-gamma, IL-2, IL-4, IL-5, IL-6, IL-10, and IL-13. CONCLUSIONS: The constitutive responsiveness of V gamma 9/V delta 2 T lymphocytes to Daudi and Etpp is severely altered in HIV+ persons. HIV infection of gamma delta T cells in vitro does not substantially change their cytokine expression or antigenic response.     

Local expansion of allergen-specific CD30+Th2-type gamma delta T cells in bronchial asthma.

BACKGROUND: T lymphocytes infiltrating airways during the allergic immune response play a fundamental role in recruiting other specialized cells, such as eosinophils, by secreting interleukin 5 (IL-5), and promoting local and systemic IgE synthesis by producing IL-4. Whether these presumed allergen-specific T cells are of mucosal or systemic origin is still a matter of conjecture. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Immunophenotype, IL-4 production, and in vitro proliferative response to specific or unrelated allergens were analyzed in the bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) fluid lymphocyte suspensions obtained from untreated patients with allergic asthma. Healthy subjects and patients affected by pulmonary sarcoidosis, a granulomatous lung disease characterized by infiltrating Th1 CD4+ lymphocytes, served as controls. RESULTS: The proportions of gamma delta T lymphocytes, mostly CD4+ or CD4- (-)CD8-, was higher in asthmatic subjects than in controls (p < 0.05). Most BAL gamma delta CD4+ lymphocytes of asthmatic patients displayed the T cell receptor (TCR)-gamma delta V delta 1 chain. While CD30 antigen coexpression on the surface of BAL alpha beta(+) T lymphocytes was low (ranging from 5 to 12%), about half of pulmonary gamma delta T cells coexpressed it. These cells produced IL-4 and negligible amounts of interferon-gamma (IFN gamma), and proliferated in vitro in response to purified specific but not unrelated allergens. In contrast, control or sarcoidosis gamma delta T cells never displayed the CD30 surface molecule or produced significant quantities of IL-4. CONCLUSIONS: These findings not only confirm our previous hypothesis that the allergen-specific Th2-type lymphocytes found in the lungs of asthmatic patients are gamma delta T cells belonging to airway mucosal immunocytes, but also strongly support the notion that asthma is a local rather than a systemic disease.     

Different roles of the CD2 and LFA-1 T-cell co-receptors for regulating cytotoxic, proliferative, and cytokine responses of human V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells

BACKGROUND: Human V gamma 9/V delta 2 T lymphocytes recognize nonpeptidic antigens in a manner distinct from the classical antigen recognition by alpha beta T cells. The apparent lack of major histocompatibility (MHC) restriction and antigen processing allows very fast responses against pathogenic insults. To address the potential functional requirement for accessory molecules, we investigated the roles of the CD2 and lymphocyte function-associated antigen (LFA)-1 T-cell co-receptors in antigen-induced activities of human V gamma 9/V delta 2 T-cell clones. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Human peripheral blood V gamma 9/V delta 2 T lymphocytes were cloned and their cytotoxicity against Daudi lymphoma was measured by a standard 51Cr-release assay. The responses of V gamma 9/V delta 2 T lymphocytes to nonpeptidic antigens were assessed using DNA synthesis and cytokine ELISA assays. Monoclonal antibodies specific for various molecules with potential T-cell accessory functions were utilized in blocking assays. RESULTS: All of our V gamma 9/V delta 2 T-cell clones displayed the Th1 phenotype. The anti-LFA-1 antibody strongly inhibited the cytotoxicity of V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells against Daudi B-cell lymphoma; whereas, it had no influence on the antigen-induced cytokine release or proliferation. In contrast, antibodies against CD2 and LFA-3 had no effect on the lytic activity of V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells, but strongly inhibited the cytokine release and proliferation. However, the CD2-LFA-3 interaction was not an absolute requirement for the cytokine release and the DNA synthetic activity of antigen-stimulated V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells, since the inhibitory effect could be reversed by addition of exogenous interleukin 2 (IL-2). CONCLUSIONS: These novel observations indicate that the signals generated by different accessory molecules and IL-2 can contribute in an integrated fashion to the regulation of V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells. These interactions may be important for the effectiveness of V gamma 9/V delta 2 T-cell responses.     

Systematic development of distinct T cell receptor-gamma delta T cell subsets during fetal ontogeny

To elucidate the developmental pattern and diversity of murine cluster of differentiation (CD)3-associated TCR-gamma delta heterodimers, adult and fetal thymocytes were examined for cell-surface expression of various gamma- and delta-encoded TCR. Biochemical analysis, using antisera specific for distinct C gamma gene products, revealed the presence of T cells expressing C gamma 1 and/or C gamma 4 heterodimers in adult and fetal CD4- CD8- thymocyte populations. Although CD4-CD8- thymocyte populations express both C gamma 1 and C gamma 4 TCR-gamma delta heterodimers early in fetal thymus development, the relative level of C gamma 4-expressing T cells was significantly lower than previously observed in peripheral lymphoid organs. In addition, biochemical studies revealed the presence of TCR-gamma delta heterodimer(s) expressed during fetal ontogeny which were not detected in adult thymocyte or peripheral lymphoid populations. Studies of N-glycosylation patterns of one of these heterodimers suggested that it contained a rearranged V gamma 3/C gamma 1 gene product. To examine in detail individual TCR-gamma delta heterodimers, a panel of TCR-gamma delta expressing hybridomas was prepared. Biochemical analysis at the clonal level revealed that indeed three distinct TCR-gamma delta heterodimers were present at day 16 of fetal thymus development, with TCR-gamma-chains most likely encoded by V gamma 2/C gamma 1, V gamma 3/C gamma 1, and V gamma/C gamma 4. Together these findings suggest an ordered development of TCR-gamma delta T cells in the thymus and selective expression of distinct TCR-gamma delta subsets in peripheral lymphoid organs such as spleen and lymph nodes.     

Activation requirements of newborn thymic gamma delta T cells.

We have analyzed the requirements for the induction of proliferative responses by thymic CD4-CD8- gamma delta T cells. Enriched populations of CD4-CD8- thymocytes from newborn mice, purified by negative selection with anti-CD4, anti-CD8, and anti-TCR alpha beta mAbs were found to contain approximately 20% gamma delta T cells that were p55IL-2R-. When these cells were cultured with a panel of lymphokines (IL-1, -2, -4, and -7), a small response was observed to some of the cytokines tested individually; however, combinations of certain lymphokines (IL-1 + 2, IL-1 + 7, and IL-2 + 7) were found to induce significant proliferation and the selective outgrowth (75-90%) of gamma delta T cells. These cells were IL-2R+, remained CD4-, yet expressed variable levels of CD8. A limited analysis with specific anti-V gamma and V delta mAb suggested that there had not been a selective expansion of preexisting V gamma 2, V gamma 3, or V delta 4 populations in response to the stimulatory lymphokine combinations. Thymic CD4-CD8- gamma delta T cells were unresponsive to stimulation with immobilized anti-pan gamma delta mAb alone. However, in the presence of immobilized anti-pan gamma delta mAb and IL-1, IL-2, or IL-7, but not IL-4, a vigorous proliferative response was observed. Phenotypic analysis showed that 80 to 95% of the proliferating cells were polyclonally expanded gamma delta T cells, expressed the p55IL-2R, and the majority remained CD4-CD8-. Blocking studies with anti-IL-2R mAb showed that stimulation with anti-pan gamma delta + IL-1, but not anti-pan gamma delta + IL-7 was dependent on endogenously produced IL-2. Collectively, these studies suggest that the activation requirements of newborn thymic gamma delta T cells differ markedly from alpha beta T cells in that gamma delta T cells 1) respond to combinations of cytokines in the absence of TCR cross-linking, 2) can respond to TCR cross-linking in the presence of exogenous cytokines, 3) but are unable to activate endogenous cytokine production solely in the presence of TCR cross-linking.     

Response of murine gamma delta T cells to the synthetic polypeptide poly-Glu50Tyr50

Random heterocopolymers of glutamic acid and tyrosine (pEY) evoke strong, genetically controlled immune responses in certain mouse strains. We found that pE50Y50 also stimulated polyclonal proliferation of normal gamma delta, but not alpha beta, T cells. Proliferation of gamma delta T cells did not require prior immunization with this Ag nor the presence of alpha beta T cells, but was enhanced by IL-2. The gamma delta T cell response proceeded in the absence of accessory cells, MHC class II, beta 2-microglobulin, or TAP-1, suggesting that Ag presentation by MHC class I/II molecules and peptide processing are not required. Among normal splenocytes, as with gamma delta T cell hybridomas, the response was strongest with V gamma 1+ gamma delta T cells, and in comparison with related polypeptides, pE50Y50 provided the strongest stimulus for these cells. TCR gene transfer into a TCR-deficient alpha beta T cell showed that besides the TCR, no other components unique to gamma delta T cells are needed. Furthermore, interactions between only the T cells and pE50Y50 were sufficient to bring about the response. Thus, pE50Y50 elicited a response distinct from those of T cells to processed/presented peptides or superantigens, consistent with a mechanism of Ig-like ligand recognition of gamma delta T cells. Direct stimulation by ligands resembling pE50Y50 may thus selectively evoke contributions of gamma delta T cells to the host response.     

Expansion of myelopoietic precursors and inhibition of B-cell precursors in mice that express a T-cell receptor gamma (V gamma 1.1J gamma 4C gamma 4) transgene.

Knowledge of the genetic determinants that can affect renewal of multipotential stem cells and their commitment to specific cell lineages is essential to our understanding of multicellular development. However, despite the vast amount of accumulated knowledge in this area, genetic determinants that affect renewal and commitment of precursor cells are unknown. In this study, we demonstrate that three independently derived founder mouse strains, transgenic for the TcR V gamma 1.1J gamma 4C gamma 4 (TcR gamma 4) chain gene, differed significantly from normal mice in their development of T and B cells as well as myelopoietic precursor cells. Ontogenic programs consistent with an acceleration of T-cell development and a delayed appearance and suppressed levels of pre-B- and B-cell precursors were evident in these transgenic mice. In addition, TcR gamma 4 transgenic mice possessed a significantly elevated level of myelopoietic pluripotential precursors. 3H-thymidine cell suicide studies suggest that higher percentages of pluripotent precursors from the bone marrow of the TcR gamma 4 transgenic mice were in the S phase of the cell cycle. These modulations of the lymphoid and myelopoietic compartments, however, were not found in other T-cell receptor transgenic mice (e.g., TcR V gamma 1.2J gamma 2C gamma 2, TcR gamma 2; or V beta 8.1D beta J beta 2.4C beta 2, TcR beta) constructed with the same or similar cDNA expression vector. The results suggest that the expression of a specific T-cell receptor gamma chain gene, and/or an elevated level of particular subset of TcR gamma delta cells, may affect the proliferation and relative proportions of haemopoietic and lymphoid precursors.     

Human V gamma 9-V delta 2 T cell receptor-gamma delta lymphocytes show specificity to Daudi Burkitt's lymphoma cells

Peripheral blood TCR-gamma delta cells with different functional V gamma or V delta gene rearrangements represent two nonoverlapping subsets. The major subset uses the V gamma 9 and the V delta 2 gene segments and the minor subset the V delta 1 gene segments in its functional TCR rearrangement. Upon in vitro activation, these TCR-gamma delta lymphocytes display MHC-unrestricted lytic activity, against a wide variety of tumor cells of distinct histologic origin. Here we show that fresh TCR-gamma delta lymphocytes that express a V gamma 9-V delta 2 encoded TCR display a specific proliferative response to Daudi, Burkitt's lymphoma cells. Moreover, cloned V gamma 9-V delta 2 lymphocytes show the capacity to lyse Daudi cells, whereas none of the cloned V gamma 1 TCR-gamma delta lymphocytes shows such specificity. Nucleotide diversity at the V-D-J junction of the TCR-V delta 2 gene did not contribute to this Daudi cell specificity. Comparison of the MHC-unrestricted cytolytic capacities of the V gamma 9-V delta 2 and the V delta 1 clones using a panel of distinct types of tumor target cells showed that on average, the level of MHC unrestricted lysis of V gamma 9-V delta 2 clones against these tumor cells exceeded that of V delta 1 clones. However, in contrast to all these tumor cell lines, only the Daudi cells showed such an absolute distinction in susceptibility to lysis by V gamma 9-V delta 2 and V delta 1 clones. V gamma 9-V delta 2 clones that were generated with a stimulator cell other than Daudi did not lyse their stimulator cells but nevertheless showed specific cytolysis of Daudi cells. The specific proliferation to and cytolysis of Daudi cells of the entire V gamma 9-V delta 2 subpopulation of TCR-gamma delta lymphocytes is reminiscent of a superantigen response.     

Monocyte-independent interleukin-2 production and proliferation of human T cells in response to murine hybridomas expressing the OKT3 monoclonal antibody: interleukin-1 is not required for T-cell proliferation

We report a new, monocyte-independent system for the induction of activation and proliferation of human T cells in response to murine hybridomas expressing the OKT3 monoclonal antibody (OKT3 hybridomas). Incubation of nylon-wool-nonadherent (NA) lymphocytes or purified T cells with OKT3 hybridomas resulted in interleukin-2 (IL-2) production, expression of IL-2 receptor, modulation of the CD3 antigen, and proliferation. In contrast, murine hybridomas (OKT4, OKT8, anti-HLA-DR, and others) expressing monoclonal antibodies (mAb) other than OKT3 did not induce T-cell activation and proliferation. T cells did not respond to OKT3 mAb alone. OKT3 hybridomas alone did not produce interleukin-1 (IL-1) or other soluble factors that might be involved in the induction of IL-2 production by T cells, and they did not contain membrane-bound IL-1. In addition, IL-1 activity was not detected in cultures of NA-lymphocytes and OKT3 hybridomas, clearly demonstrating that IL-1 was not required, at least in this system, for T-cell activation and proliferation. Direct cell-cell contact between T cells and OKT3 hybridomas was required for IL-2 production. Thirty to fifty percent of T cells formed conjugates with the OKT3 hybridomas but not with the OKT4 or OKT8 hybridomas. Both conjugate formation and IL-2 production were significantly inhibited by the OKT3 mAb and by the anti-LFA-1 mAb. The cells responsible for IL-2 production were found to be of the T3+ T4+ T8- Leu 7- Leu 11- phenotype. IL-2 activity produced by NA-lymphocytes in response to OKT3 hybridomas became detectable as early as 1 hr and reached a maximum by 8 hr, preceding IL-2 receptor expression, modulation of the CD3 antigen, and [3H]thymidine incorporation of T cells. T cells produced higher concentrations of IL-2 in response to OKT3 hybridomas than in response to equal numbers of monocytes and OKT3 mAb. Addition of monocytes to cultures of T cells and OKT3 hybridomas resulted in suppression of IL-2 production in a concentration-dependent manner, suggesting that monocytes regulate the levels of IL-2 production. This monocyte-independent system may be useful for further dissection of T-cell activation and proliferation and its regulation by monocytes.     

IL-4-producing gamma delta T cells that express a very restricted TCR repertoire are preferentially localized in liver and spleen.

IL-4-producing gamma delta thymocytes in normal mice belong to a distinct subset of gamma delta T cells characterized by low expression of Thy-1. This gamma delta thymocyte subset shares a number of phenotypic and functional properties with the NK T cell population. Thy-1dull gamma delta thymocytes in DBA/2 mice express a restricted repertoire of TCRs that are composed of the V gamma 1 gene product mainly associated with the V delta 6.4 chain and exhibit limited junctional sequence diversity. Using mice transgenic for a rearranged V gamma 1J gamma 4C gamma 4 chain and a novel mAb (9D3) specific for the V delta 6.3 and V delta 6.4 murine TCR delta chains, we have analyzed the peripheral localization and functional properties of gamma delta T cells displaying a similarly restricted TCR repertoire. In transgenic mice, IL-4 production by peripheral gamma delta T cells was confined to the gamma delta+9D3+ subset, which contains cells with a TCR repertoire similar to that found in Thy-1dull gamma delta thymocytes. In normal DBA/2 mice such cells represent close to half of the gamma delta T cells present in the liver and around 20% of the splenic gamma delta T cells.     

MHC-unrestricted cytotoxic and proliferative responses of two distinct human gamma/delta T cell subsets to Daudi cells.

Human V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells, the major subset of gamma/delta T cells in peripheral blood of adults, mediate proliferative and cytotoxic responses to Daudi Burkitt's lymphoma cells without previous in vitro exposure to Daudi. Our experiments show that some gamma/delta T cells coexpressing V gamma 9 and V delta 1 genes also react to Daudi cells in cytotoxic and proliferative assays. Expression of V gamma 9 is not sufficient for the recognition of Daudi cells because most gamma/delta T cells expressing V delta 1 paired with V gamma 9 or other V gamma genes neither kill Daudi cells nor proliferate to Daudi. V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells do not proliferate to other cell lines such as K562 or Molt4 that are sensitive to MHC-unrestricted cytolysis by NK cells and by most IL-2-activated gamma/delta T cell clones. Cold target inhibition assays demonstrate that Daudi cells are stronger inhibitors than K562 and Molt4 of MHC-unrestricted lysis by V gamma 9/V delta 2 clones. However, cold Daudi cells are relatively weaker inhibitors of MHC-unrestricted lysis by NK cell clones, most gamma/delta T cell clones expressing V delta 1 and alpha/beta T cell clones. Thus, recognition by V gamma 9/V delta 2 T cells and certain V gamma 9/V delta 1 T cells of Daudi appears to involve a specific triggering pathway that is distinct from recognition by these gamma/delta T cells of Molt4, K562, and other target cells. NK cell clones and most other gamma/delta and alpha/beta T cell clones derived from the same normal volunteer blood donors do not show this specific interaction with Daudi cells. These data show that distinct subsets of human gamma/delta T cells recognize Daudi cells and support the idea that the gamma/delta TCR may be directly involved.     

Extrathymic selection of TCR gamma delta + T cells by class II major histocompatibility complex molecules

The influence of MHC antigens on TCR gamma delta usage in CD8+ intraepithelial lymphocytes (IELs) was examined using a pan-reactive and V delta 4 region-specific MAb. While an average of 30% of IELs from the majority of mice of various MHC haplotypes were V delta 4+, a 2-fold or greater percentage of IELs from H-2k mice were V delta 4+. Analysis of IELs from F1 mice indicated that the increase in TCRs using V delta 4 was likely to be the result of positive selection. The V delta 4 usage patterns of IELs from recombinant inbred strains and from mice recombinant within H-2 revealed that the increase in V delta 4 usage mapped to H-2 and required I-E expression. Moreover, selection of TCRs using V delta 4 occurred in chimeric mice in the absence of a thymus. The results demonstrate an extrathymic selective mechanism for gamma delta TCRs of CD8+ IELs and suggest that these cells may exhibit MHC class II-restricted antigen recognition.     

Gene transfer demonstrates that the V gamma 1.1C gamma 4V delta 6C delta T cell receptor is essential for autoreactivity.

Murine T cell lines and hybridomas derived from the epidermis that express the V gamma 1.1C gamma 4V delta 6C delta TCR and may, therefore, recognize an autoantigen, secrete cytokines spontaneously in culture. In addition, activation of these cells requires engagement of the vitronectin receptor (VNR) by extracellular matrix proteins. To further evaluate the role of the TCR, the VNR, and the putative autoantigen in the activation of this T cell subset, we cloned complete cDNA encoding the V gamma 1.1C gamma 4 and V delta 6C delta TCR and transfected the cDNA constructs into a TCR- murine hybridoma and into a TCR- variant of the human Jurkat line. The murine transfectant spontaneously produced IL-2 in culture and IL-2 production could be inhibited by anti-CD3, anticlonotypic mAb to the transfected TCR, and anti-VNR mAb, as well as by RGDS. These results demonstrate that transfection of the gamma delta TCR confers to recipient T cells the phenotype of constitutive activation, as well as dependence on engagement of the VNR as an accessory molecule. In contrast, the Jurkat gamma delta transfectant failed to produce cytokines spontaneously, although the transfected TCR was capable of signal transduction after stimulation by anti-TCR mAb. Surprisingly, neither the murine transfectant nor the human transfectant could be induced to respond to autoantigen bearing cells in coculture assays. One interpretation of these results is that coexpression on the surface of the same cell of the V gamma 1.1 V delta 6 TCR, the VNR, and a putative autoantigen are necessary for T cell activation in this system.     

Human T cell receptor-gamma and -delta chain pairing analyzed by transfection of a T cell receptor-delta negative mutant cell line

Specific TCR V gamma and V delta segments are found to be coordinately used on subpopulations of gamma delta T lymphocytes. The reasons for this phenomenon are unknown, but may include the inability of particular chains expressing unique V delta and V gamma segments to physically associate. V delta 2 is typically used together with V gamma 2 on human peripheral blood gamma delta T lymphocytes. To examine whether V delta 2 can be used in conjunction with distinct V gamma segments, a TCR- mutant of the human gamma delta T cell line MOLT-13, which expresses parental TCR gamma (V gamma 1.3) but not TCR-delta protein, was transfected with plasmids containing full-length TCR-delta cDNA using either V delta 2 or V delta 3. TCR reconstitution was successful in both transfectants and resulted in TCR protein and RNA levels similar to that of the parental MOLT-13 cell line. These cell lines could be activated through their receptors as assessed by increases in cytoplasmic free calcium. These studies imply that physical constraints cannot explain the observed chain pairing preferences. Other possible explanations are discussed.