Cytology of peritoneal washings in gynecologic patients. Diagnostic criteria and pitfalls

A total of 226 peritoneal washing specimens obtained from gynecologic patients over a three-year period was reviewed. The diagnostic problems encountered were: differentiating reactive mesothelium from low-grade malignancies; distinguishing between benign ovarian tumors, ovarian tumors of borderline malignancy and low-grade ovarian malignancies; and potential false-positive diagnoses in endometriosis. Low-grade malignancies could be distinguished from reactive mesothelium by evaluating subtle cytologic criteria and by comparing the cells to those of the tumor on histologic section. The differentiation of low-grade epithelial malignancies from benign epithelial lesions caused difficulties that could only be resolved by evaluating the histologic material. Positive peritoneal washings increased the stage in 8 of 110 patients undergoing initial surgery for gynecologic malignancy. Two of 76 patients undergoing a second-look laparotomy had positive washings without histologic evidence of tumor. These ten patients did less well than did those with similar histology but negative washing cytology, despite receiving additional therapy because of the cytologic findings.     

Peritoneal washing cytology in cervical carcinoma. Analysis of 109 patients

The peritoneal washing cytologies of 109 patients (112 procedures) undergoing laparotomy for cervical carcinoma were evaluated retrospectively and compared with the clinical and pathologic findings. Nine patients (8.3%) had malignant peritoneal washings (including three of four with washings initially termed "inconclusive"). Four (4.9%) of the 82 patients with squamous carcinoma and 3 (16.7%) of 18 with adenocarcinoma had positive washings. Five (5.6%) of 90 washings obtained at initial explorations were positive, as compared with 4 (18.2%) of 22 washings obtained as follow-up operations in recurrent cases. The 111 peritoneal washing cytologies with a corresponding histologic evaluation of the peritoneal cavity showed a good correlation; peritoneal washing cytology had an efficiency of 91.0%, a sensitivity of 52.9% and a specificity of 100%. Two cases in which the cytologies were considered positive only after review had negative peritoneal histologies; both patients died of progressive disease within 11 months. Peritoneal washing cytology was positive in 5 (5.9%) of 84 cases with FIGO stage 1 cancers, 2 (18.2%) of 11 cases with stage 2 cancers, 1 (33.3%) of 3 cases with stage 3 cancers, and 1 (10%) of 10 cases with recurrent tumors. Eight (88.9%) of nine patients with malignant peritoneal washings died of disease from 3 to 15 months following surgery; one showed no evidence of disease at 9 months. These results suggest that: (1) cervical carcinomas are infrequently associated with a positive peritoneal washing; (2) peritoneal washing cytology is more likely to be positive in cases of adenocarcinoma than in cases of squamous carcinoma; (3) peritoneal washings obtained at the time of surgery for recurrence are more likely to contain malignant cells than are washings obtained during initial exploration; (4) nonkeratinizing malignant squamous cells may be confused with reactive mesothelial cells; and (5) peritoneal washing cytology is a relatively insensitive technique for detecting advanced cervical disease, but correlates with a poor prognosis when positive.     

Usefulness of endometrial aspiration cytology for the preoperative diagnosis of ovarian carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the usefulness of endometrial aspiration cytology for the preoperative diagnosis of ovarian carcinoma. STUDY DESIGN: A total of 210 patients with ovarian carcinoma were investigated by endometrial aspiration cytology. RESULTS: Fifty-five of 210 patients (26.2%) had positive endometrial aspiration cytology. The positive rates of endometrial cytology were 3.9% in stage I, 23.8% in stage II, 36.5% in stage III and 53.3% in stage IV. When classified by histologic type, the positive rates of endometrial cytology in patients with serous adenocarcinoma, mucinous adenocarcinoma, clear cell adenocarcinoma, undifferentiated carcinoma and yolk sac tumor were 38.9%, 11.8%, 21.1%, 16.7% and 16.7%, respectively. One hundred twenty-eight of 210 patients (61.0%) were positive on peritoneal cytology, and 54 of these 128 cases (42.2%) were also positive on endometrial cytology. The positive rates of endometrial cytology were especially high in patients with serous adenocarcinoma (51.2%) and those with clear cell adenocarcinoma (40.0%) among those who were positive on peritoneal cytology. Of 74 patients who were negative on peritoneal cytology, only one (1.4%) with mucinous adenocarcinoma had positive endometrial cytology. Hysterectomy was performed on 130 patients, and the positive rate of endometrial cytology was 100% in 4 patients with endometrial invasion and 15.9% in 126 cases without invasion. CONCLUSION: Endometrial aspiration cytology can detect ovarian carcinoma cells not only in patients with endometrial involvement but also in patients with positive peritoneal cytology. Endometrial aspiration cytology appears to be useful for the preoperative diagnosis of ovarian carcinoma.     

A role for tumor markers in therapeutic decisions after chemotherapy induction of objective remission in stage III epithelial ovarian neoplasms

The management of advanced stage ovarian carcinomas is presently based on initial surgical debulking, multiple drug chemotherapy including cisplatinum, second-look laparotomy. Such an aggressive approach has improved objective response rates and expected survival time, but no dramatic change has been demonstrated as for definitive cure percentages. Many Authors have attempted to turn an optimal objective response to chemotherapy (no residual or minimal residual disease at second-look) into a definitive cure with irradiation. Some reports show satisfactory results, but a high incidence of bowel obstructive complications has been demonstrated, probably due to multiple surgical manipulations before radiotherapy. A reliable diagnostic tool, that could help to avoid the second-look laparotomy (whose inherent role in improving survival is not assessed) should be therefore useful. The possible role of serum tumor markers determinations, for this purpose, is here discussed on the ground of a series of 20 patients affected by stage III ovarian carcinoma. Following this experience, a valuable role seems attributable to CA 125 in monitoring tumor response. Patients achieving values under 35 U/ml before second-look laparotomy showed tumor residuals in the range O-microscopic- less than 1 cm., that is, neoplastic localizations reliable for consolidation radiation therapy.     

Interferon-α, interferon-γ and sizofiran in the adjuvant therapy in ovarian cancer — a preliminary trial

The study included 24 cases of negative second-look laparotomy (SLL) after operation on ovarian cancer. 12 cases were treated with sizofiran and recombinant interferon-gamma before and after SLL and then with human lymphoblastoid interferon-alpha. The remaining 12 cases (controls) were followed up without any drug therapy after SLL. There were no recurrences in the treated group, but in 3 cases of the control group. Also significant difference in survival was noted in the treated group.     

Peritoneal washings in ovarian tumors. Potential sources of error in cytologic diagnosis

Peritoneal washings were performed on 48 patients with suspected or known ovarian carcinoma. The procedure was part of the initial surgical staging in 27 patients with presumed stage I and II ovarian cancer and was performed during second-look operations in 21 other cases with proven ovarian malignancy. This paper presents the microscopic features of the washings, with particular emphasis on the cytologic differentiation between benign and malignant findings outside of the ovary. Thirty-four cases showed benign or reactive mesothelial cells and no evidence of peritoneal disease. The washings of six patient showed malignant cells, which were confirmed histologically. Notable atypia that mimicked ovarian carcinoma was found in eight patients who had benign or borderline lesions. These findings included papillary and glandlike epithelial structures, with varying degrees of cellular atypia and psammoma bodies. The histologic counterparts of these atypicalities were Müllerian inclusions, mesothelial proliferations and borderline serous tumors. The differential diagnosis between these entities is essential because false-positive cytologic diagnoses may alter postoperative treatment in some patients.     

Morphologic analyses of positive peritoneal cytology in endometrial carcinoma.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the relationship between the morphologic features of endometrial adenocarcinoma cells in peritoneal fluids (effusions and washings) and macroscopic intraabdominal adenocarcinoma at laparotomy as well as prognosis. STUDY DESIGN: Seventy-one patients with endometrial adenocarcinoma who showed positive peritoneal cytology at laparotomy were clinically divided into three groups: 25 patients with macroscopic neoplastic seeding in the peritoneal cavity (type 1), 38 patients without macroscopic peritoneal metastasis who survived with no evidence of disease (type 2) and 8 patients without macroscopic peritoneal metastasis who later developed recurrence of adenocarcinoma (type 3). Morphologic features of the adenocarcinoma cells in smears of peritoneal fluids were examined. RESULTS: Most of the smears from type 1 patients showed moderate to high cellularity, scalloped edges of cell clusters and isolated adenocarcinoma cells, whereas these features were seldom observed in type 2 patients. Although not all type 3 patients demonstrated these three features, patients in the series whose specimens exhibited none of the three features did not show any peritoneal lesions or have a recurrence of their disease. CONCLUSION: The finding of endometrial adenocarcinoma cells exhibiting high cellularity, scalloped edge of cell clusters and isolated cells in smears of peritoneal fluid is associated with the presence of intraabdominal macroscopic metastatic lesions and could be regarded as a risk factor for intraabdominal recurrence of carcinoma.     

Prospective comparative cytologic study of direct peritoneal smears and lavage fluids in patients with epithelial ovarian cancer and benign gynecologic disease

Direct peritoneal samples obtained by scraping or brushing (with a Cytobrush) were compared to peritoneal lavages (washings) for the cytologic evaluation of patients with gynecologic disease. The direct samples were obtained during laparotomy or laparoscopy, following saline lavage if that was performed, and were immediately smeared on glass slides and fixed in 95% alcohol. Only 9 of the direct peritoneal samples taken from 64 patients with benign gynecologic disease were unsatisfactory for cytologic interpretation while 19 of the 33 lavage specimens simultaneously collected from these patients were considered unsuitable for analysis (P less than .001). Two direct smears from cases with benign histology were reported as suspicious. Nineteen patients with epithelial ovarian cancer also had cytologic specimens collected by direct sampling and by washing. The direct smears were positive for malignancy in 12 cases, suspicious in 4 cases and negative in 3 cases while the lavage samples were positive in 9 cases, suspicious in 4 cases, negative in 4 cases and unsatisfactory in 2 cases. These results indicate that direct peritoneal sampling is a simple and reliable alternative to peritoneal lavage and produces a significantly lower incidence of unsatisfactory specimens.     

Identification of a high-risk subgroup in cytology-positive stage IIIA endometrial cancer

OBJECTIVE: To identify a high-risk subgroup among patients with cytology-positive stage IIIA endometrial cancer. STUDY DESIGN: Fifty-four stage IIIA endometrial cancer patients who were positive only on peritoneal cytology were divided into two groups based on the cytologic pattern of their peritoneal smears. In group A, malignant cell clusters had well-defined edges, while the tumor cell clusters had scalloped edges in group B. The prognostic significance of these findings was investigated. RESULTS: The five-year disease-free survival rate was 97.5% in group A (n=40) versus 50% in group B (n = 14). Multivariate analysis confirmed that the cytologic pattern had an independent influence on survival. CONCLUSION: Positive peritoneal cytology composed of malignant cell clusters with well-defined edges has no impact on survival. Only endometrial cancer patients who show tumor cell clusters with scalloped edges in peritoneal smears are worth considering for upstaging.     

Highly specific marker genes for detecting minimal gastric cancer cells in cytology negative peritoneal washings

Peritoneal wash cytology plays a pivotal role in the decision for gastric cancer treatment because advanced gastric cancer often turns out incurable with peritoneal metastasis. Molecular detection of minimal cancer cells from peritoneal washings may overcome the sensitivity boundary of conventional cytology and contribute to the prediction of the disease outcome. To select marker candidates out of ten thousands of genes, we performed microarray analyses in 12 gastric cell lines and 8 peritoneal washings of early stage cases. With 40 candidates selected by the above expression profiling, RT-PCR in 16 representative peritoneal wash samples was performed to identify genes specific to cytology positive samples. The finally selected five genes, CK20, FABP1, MUC2, TFF1, and TFF2, were then evaluated for their utility as a marker for minimal residual disease in 99 peritoneal wash samples. Nested RT-PCR using the five genes showed positive results highly specific to incurable cases (91-100%). With a high specificity, the combination of these five genes succeeded in identifying 6 out of 20 (30%) additional patients with all types of early recurrence that could not be predicted by the conventional method. The six newly identified recurrences included four non-peritoneal ones, showing that RT-PCR using the five genes without a real-time quantitative PCR technique contributes to the detection of minimal residual disease.     

P-3THE VALUE OF PERITONEAL WASHING CYTOLOGY IN THE STAGING OF GYNAECOLOGICAL MALIGNANCY

Introduction:  Current protocols for staging gynaecological cancers include cytopathological examination of peritoneal washings taken at the time of definitive surgery. We investigated the clinical usefulness of this procedure.
Methods:  During 2004 and 2005, 140 peritoneal washings were submitted for cytopathological examination in our institutions for staging of 36 ovarian, 101 endometrial and 3 synchronous ovarian/endometrial cancers.
Results:  The washings contained malignant cells in 39 cases (28%). 35 of these cases had high stage disease – not confined to the organ of origin (i.e. stage 2 or more for ovary and stage 3 or more for endometrial). The other 4 were stage 1C ovarian cancers where there was either rupture or tumour involvement of the capsule. In only 2 of the 39 positive cases the cancer was marginally upstaged by the positive washings – these were ovarian cancers upstaged from 2A /B to 2C.
Discussion:  These findings suggest that peritoneal washing cytology as a routine procedure for staging ovarian and endometrial cancer is of limited clinical value. A larger study is needed to determine whether this procedure should continue to be included in staging protocols for gynaecological cancer.     

Endometrial aspiration cytology for diagnosis of peritoneal lesions in extrauterine malignancies

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the usefulness of endometrial aspiration cytology for assessing malignant cells of extrauterine origin. STUDY DESIGN: Endometrial cytology was performed on 224 patients with primary ovarian cancer, 10 with fallopian tube cancer and 45 with peritoneal tumors. RESULTS: Of 224 patients with ovarian cancer, 53 (23.7%) had positive endometrial cytology. Positive rates were: stage I, 4.3%; stage II, 25.0%; stage III, 39.7%; stage IV, 34.5%. Histologic positive rates were: serous, 28.7%; mucinous, 11.4%; clear cell, 23.1%; endometrioid and unclassifiable adenocarcinomas, 28.0%. Of 5 patients with ovarian cancer, 2 were asymptomatic, but aspiration cytology was positive. Of 10 patients with fallopian tube cancer, 9 (90.0%) had positive endometrial cytology. The positive rate on endometrial cytology was 56.7% in stomach cancer, 60.0% in breast cancer and 20.0% in colon cancer. Of 1,209 women with stomach cancer, 30 (2.4%) displayed ovarian metastasis. Of these, 7 (23.3%) had Krukenberg's tumor; endometrial cytology was positive in 1 (14.3%). In 7 of 17 patients with positive endometrial cytology, clinical diagnosis was made before stomach cancer therapy. CONCLUSION: Endometrial aspiration cytology is useful for identifying nongynecologic malignant cells, diagnosing ovarian and fallopian tube cancers, and determining peritoneal dissemination and metastasis originating from gastrointestinal and breast cancers.     

Clinical value of radioimmunoscintigraphy in the follow-up of ovarian carcinoma: a prospective study

Twenty-five patients treated with debulking surgery and chemotherapy for ovarian cancer were prospectively studied to evaluate the efficacy of radioimmunoscintigraphy (RIS) in detecting residual tumor before second-look surgery. RIS was performed with the monoclonal antibody OC125 F(ab')2 labelled with I-131 without knowledge of clinical data and compared with subsequent surgical results. Second look showed tumor persistence in 12 patients, mostly characterized by small lesions. The overall diagnostic sensitivity of RIS was 50% and the specificity was 85%. In particular, RIS showed better sensitivity for pelvic tumor localizations than for abdominal sites (73% vs 33%); this was due to the inability of RIS to detect upper abdominal lesions. Therefore, our conclusion is that, at present, RIS cannot substitute surgical second-look in the management of ovarian cancer, however, considering that also ultrasonography, computer tomography and magnetic resonance are not always able to give definite diagnostic evidence in the follow-up of ovarian carcinoma, RIS could be added to these procedures to balance the limitations of each method. In this regard, the best application of RIS could be in the follow-up of patients with marker elevation without clinical evidence of disease, especially in the case of pelvic fibrosis or adhesions due to previous therapy, where the other non-invasive tools can give doubtful diagnostic results.     

Out-Patient Peritoneal Lavage Cytology In the Detection of Residual Epithelial Ovarian Cancer

Peritoneal lavage fluid cytology was performed in 87 out-patients with histologically proven epithelial ovarian cancer undergoing primary management. A total of 246 peritoneal lavages were attempted, usually with temporary cannulae (n = 229). From these, 184 samples were obtained, of which 156 (85%) were suitable for cytological analysis. The sensitivity of peritoneal lavage fluid cytology in 67 patients with known residual disease was 57% whereas serum CA 125 levels were elevated in 58 (87%). Pre- and post-treatment peritoneal lavage fluid cytology had prognostic value, but this was less than that of serum CA 125 measurements.     

Diagnostic value of hair shafts and squamous cells in peritoneal washing cytology

OBJECTIVE: Little attention has been given to hair shafts and squamous cells in peritoneal fluid. To investigate their diagnostic value in peritoneal washing specimens, we reviewed peritoneal washing cytology preparations from 83 cases of ovarian tumors. STUDY DESIGN: We reviewed peritoneal washing specimens and histologic sections of 86 cases of ovarian tumors and tumorous conditions, including 22 teratomas, 16 serous adenocarcinomas, 10 clear cell adenocarcinomas, 9 endometrioid adenocarcinomas, 5 cases of endometriosis, 4 mucinous adenomas, 3 serous cystadenocarcinomas and 17 other tumors. RESULTS: We observed both squamous cells and hair shafts surrounded by inflammatory cells in 5 of the 22 cases of ovarian teratoma. Rupture of an ovarian teratoma was clinically and histologically found in one of the five cases. Hair shafts were not observed in the other tumors or in nonneoplastic conditions. The diameter of hair shafts in peritoneal washing specimens ranged from 10 to 28.8 microns (average, 16.6), and such hair shafts were present within an ovarian teratoma examined histologically. The diameter of hair shafts from six normal adults who were examined as controls ranged from 61.5 to 118.6 microns (average, 89.4). CONCLUSION: Hair shafts and squamous cells surrounded by inflammatory cells in peritoneal washing specimens are a diagnostic clue to ovarian teratoma and can be observed even when rupture of the tumor is not detected clinically or microscopically.     

Cytohistologic correlation of peritoneal washing cytology in gynecologic disease

The peritoneal washings and cul de sac aspirates from 204 patients undergoing 217 procedures for the evaluation of gynecologic disease were examined retrospectively and correlated with the histologic diagnoses. Of the 73 washings from patients with histologically benign genital disease, cytology diagnosed 64 (87.7%) as negative, 6 (8.2%) as inconclusive and 3 as malignant. One malignant washing was a true positive from a nongenital primary. False positives thus occurred in 2.7% of the benign cases on blind review. Of 144 cytologic examinations of washings from patients with histologically confirmed malignant disease of the female genital tract, 38 (26.4%) were considered positive after cytohistologic correlation. Four malignant cases (2.1%) were undercalled on blind review while 3 (2.0%) were considered overcalls. Eleven of 47 cases (23.4%) with biopsy-proven peritoneal disease had negative cytology after histologic correlation. Recurring problems in interpreting peritoneal washings included: (1) the differential diagnosis of the spectrum encompassed by reactive mesothelium, endosalpingiosis, borderline serous tumors and well-differentiated serous cystadenocarcinoma; (2) morphologic similarities between some tumor cells and mesothelial cells associated with treatment effects; and (3) a paucity of malignant cells in some washings, resulting in false-negative interpretations. Ineffective cytopreparation, particularly of bloody specimens, hampered interpretation of some specimens. Correlation with previous histology and cytology enhanced the accuracy of peritoneal washing cytology in this study.     

Diagnostic significance of flow cytometric DNA analysis applied for the detection of cancer cells in bronchial washing fluid

Since both DNA aneuploidy and increased proliferative activity are important characteristics of malignant neoplasms, flow cytometric (FCM) analysis was used to examine the cell content in bronchial washing samples obtained via fiberoptic bronchoscopy from 73 patients. The results were compared with the results of histology and conventional cytology. The patients included 30 with bronchial carcinomas, 12 with bronchopneumonia and 31 with no evidence of lung disease. Of the 30 patients with histologically confirmed lung cancers, 25 showed either aneuploid stem lines (19 cases) or high levels of proliferation (6 cases) as determined by analysis of cell-cycle stages. The same rate of cancer cell detection was obtained by cytology. In the 43 cases with neither histologic nor clinical evidence of malignancy, FCM data yielded 5 false-positive results, as compared to 4 erroneous suspicions of cancer by cytology. From these data, it is concluded that FCM measurements of both DNA ploidy and proliferative activity may complement conventional cytology in the recognition of bronchial carcinomas.     

Cervicovaginal and endometrial cytology in ovarian cancer

The clinical significance of cytologic examination was studied in 114 patients with ovarian cancer who had received preoperative cytologic examinations. The overall positive rate of the cytologic examinations was 26.3% (30 of 114): 22 (19.3%) of the 114 cases had positive cervicovaginal smears while 13 of 31 endometrial aspiration smears (41.9%) were positive. The positive rate was not related to the volume of ascites but rather to its presence or absence. Thus, if ascites was observed, the positive rate was about 2.1 times higher than if it was absent. In two of four cases of ovarian cancer with no endometrial invasion but a positive cytologic examination of ascitic fluid, fallopian tube specimens contained cancer cells; this suggests that ovarian cancer cells may reach the cervix and/or vagina by passing through the fallopian tube, particularly if ascites is present. Since cytologic examination, especially of endometrial aspiration smears, shows a high positive rate if ovarian cancer cells are observed in the abdominal cavity, cytology should be used as an important ancillary method for the assessment of ovarian cancer.     

Earlier diagnosis and survival in lung cancer

In a controlled investigation the survival prospects of lung cancer in a population of men aged 40 and over who had been offered six-monthly chest radiographs over a period of three years were compared with lung cancer in a similar population without such x-ray facilities. The five-year survival rate of lung cancer in the study series was 15%, and in cases discovered by six-monthly examination 23%, compared with 6% in the control series. The average expectation of life after diagnosis was 2·5 years for the test cases and 1·2 for the control cases. Survival declined with age. Of resected lung cancer, 32% survived five years in the test series and 23% in the control series. The five-year survival rate for squamous carcinoma and adenocarcinoma in the test series was 28% and 25% respectively, compared with 15% and nil in the control series.On the basis of these results it is concluded that through earlier radiological detection a modest improvement in the prognosis of lung cancer can be achieved.     

Postoperative bladder washing cytology after transurethral resection. Can it predict the recurrence of urothelial carcinoma?

OBJECTIVE: To assess the ability of postoperative bladder washing cytology, performed immediately after transurethral resection of mostly stage Ta or T1 papillary urothelial carcinoma, to predict early recurrence. STUDY DESIGN: In a 1-year period, preoperative and postoperative bladder washing cytology specimens were sampled from patients undergoing transurethral resections in which all visible tumor was removed. There were 38 resections in 32 patients. RESULTS: Postoperative cytology was satisfactory in 35 of 38 cases and positive in 17 (49%) after a mean of 6.9 months. Follow-up of these 35 transurethral resections disclosed a 15/17 (88%) recurrence rate after positive cytology and a 4/18 (22%) recurrence rate after negative cytology (P < .001). Postoperative cytology demonstrated a sensitivity for recurrence of 79%, specificity of 88%, positive predictive value of 88% and negative predictive value of 77%. In contrast, tumor in the transurethral resection specimen had a positive predictive value of 54% for recurrence, and its grade and stage were inferior to cytology in predicting recurrence. CONCLUSION: Postoperative bladder washing cytology is a useful adjunct to the management of papillary urothelial carcinoma. A positive result, signifying residual tumor, should encourage prompt follow-up and possibly repeat transurethral resection.