Comparison of inactivation and unfolding of methanol dehydrogenase during denaturation in guanidine hydrochloride and urea

The activity and the conformational changes of methanol dehydrogenase (MDH), a quinoprotein containing pyrrolo-quinoline quinone as its prosthetic group, have been studied during denaturation in guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) and urea. The unfolding of MDH was followed using the steady-state and time resolved fluorescence methods. Increasing the denaturant concentration in the denatured system significantly enhanced the inactivation and unfolding of MDH. The enzyme was completely inactivated at 1 M GdnHCl or 6 M urea. The fluorescence emission maximum of the native enzyme was at 332 nm. With increasing denaturant concentrations, the fluorescence emission maximum red-shifted in magnitude to a maximum value (355 nm) at 5 M GdnHCl or 8 M urea. Comparison of inactivation and conformational changes during denaturation showed that in general accord with the suggestion made previously by Tsou, the active sites of MDH are situated in a region more flexible than the molecule as a whole.     

Surface point mutations that significantly alter the structure and stability of a protein's denatured state.

Significantly different m values (1.9-2.7 kcal mol-1 M-1) were observed for point mutations at a single, solvent-exposed site (T53) in a variant of the B1 domain of streptococcal Protein G using guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) as a denaturant. This report focuses on elucidating the energetic and structural implications of these m-value differences in two Protein G mutants, containing Ala and Thr at position 53. These two proteins are representative of the high (m+) and low (m-) m-value mutants studied. Differential scanning calorimetry revealed no evidence of equilibrium intermediates. A comparison of GuHCl denaturation monitored by fluorescence and circular dichroism showed that secondary and tertiary structure denatured concomitantly. The rates of folding (286 S-1 for the m+ mutant and 952 S-1 for the m- mutant) and the rates of unfolding (11 S-1 for m+ mutant and 3 S-1 for the m- mutant) were significantly different, as determined by stopped-flow fluorescence. The relative solvation free energies of the transition states were identical for the two proteins (alpha ++ = 0.3). Small-angle X-ray scattering showed that the radius of gyration of the denatured state (Rgd) of the m+ mutant did not change with increasing denaturant concentrations (Rgd approximately 23 A); whereas, the Rgd of the m- mutant increased from approximately 17 A to 23 A with increasing denaturant concentration. The results indicate that the mutations exert significant effects in both the native and GuHCl-induced denatured state of these two proteins.     

Stability mutants of staphylococcal nuclease: large compensating enthalpy-entropy changes for the reversible denaturation reaction

By use of intrinsic fluorescence to determine the apparent equilibrium constant Kapp as a function of temperature, the midpoint temperature Tm and apparent enthalpy change delta Happ on reversible thermal denaturation have been determined over a range of pH values for wild-type staphylococcal nuclease and six mutant forms. For wild-type nuclease at pH 7.0, a Tm of 53.3 +/- 0.2 degrees C and a delta Happ of 86.8 +/- 1.4 kcal/mol were obtained, in reasonable agreement with values determined calorimetrically, 52.8 degrees C and 96 +/- 2 kcal/mol. The heat capacity change on denaturation delta Cp was estimated at 1.8 kcal/(mol K) versus the calorimetric value of 2.2 kcal/(mol K). When values of delta Happ and delta Sapp for a series of mutant nucleases that exhibit markedly altered denaturation behavior with guanidine hydrochloride and urea were compared at the same temperature, compensating changes in enthalpy and entropy were observed that greatly reduce the overall effect of the mutations on the free energy of denaturation. In addition, a correlation was found between the estimated delta Cp for the mutant proteins and the d(delta Gapp)/dC for guanidine hydrochloride denaturation. It is proposed that both the enthalpy/entropy compensation and this correlation between two seemingly unrelated denaturation parameters are consequences of large changes in the solvation of the denatured state that result from the mutant amino acid substitutions.     

Effects of denaturants at low concentrations on the reversible denaturation of staphylococcal nuclease

Three very unstable mutant forms of staphylococcal nuclease were used to quantitate the change in the apparent equilibrium constant for reversible denaturation (Kapp) as a function of denaturant concentration for a variety of different denaturing solutes. The value of this equilibrium constant in the absence of denaturant (Kapp,0) was determined by renaturation of the mutant proteins with a combination of glycerol and calcium ion, the latter of which binds at the active site in the native conformation. Because Kapp,0 fell in the easily measurable range between 0.1 and 1, the change in Kapp, and thus the change in free energy (delta Gapp), at very low concentrations of denaturants could be accurately measured. With guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl), the rate of change of the apparent free energy of denaturation with respect to denaturant concentration (d(delta Gapp)/dCGuHCl or mGuHCl) was found to be remarkably constant down to zero denaturant concentration, even though this value was different for each of the three proteins. Unlike GuHCl, urea exhibited a slightly reduced value of d delta Gapp/dCurea at low concentrations. Results with a number of thiocyanate, perchlorate, and iodide salts confirmed that the Hofmeister series holds for concentrations below 0.1 M; that is, with regard to efficacy as a denaturant SCN- greater than ClO4- greater than I- and Li+,NH4+ greater than Na+,K+. However, all of the chaotropic salts analyzed exhibited markedly increased values of d(delta Gapp)/dCsalt at concentrations below 0.2 M. One possible explanation for these large deviations from a linear relationship between delta Gapp and salt concentration is that weak binding or adsorption of chaotropic anions is occurring at a saturable number of sites in hydrophobic regions of the denatured state.     

The pH dependence of the reversible unfolding of ovalbumin A1 by guanidine hydrochloride.

The pH dependence of the reversible guanidine hydrochloride denaturation of the major fraction of ovalbumin (ovalbumin A1) was studied by a viscometric method in the pH range 1-7, at 25 degrees C and at six different denaturant concentrations (1.5-2.6 M). At any denaturant concentrationa reduction in pH favoured the transition from the native to the denatured state. The latter was essentially 'structureless', as revealed by the fact that the reduced viscosity of the acid and guanidine hydrochloride denatured state of ovalbumin A1 (obtained at different denaturant concentrations in acidic solutions) was measured (at a protein concentration of 3.8 mg/ml) to be 29.2 ml/g which is identical to that found in 6 M guanidine hydrochloride wherein the protein behaves as a cross-linked random coil. A quantitative analysis of the results on the pH dependence of the equilibrium constant for the denaturation process showed that on denaturation the intrinsic pK of two carboxyl groups in ovalbumin A1 went up from 3.1 in the native state to 4.4 in the denatured state of the protein.     

Reversible denaturation of oligomeric human chaperonin 10: denatured state depends on chemical denaturant

Chaperonins cpn60/cpn10 (GroEL/GroES in Escherichia coli) assist folding of nonnative polypeptides. Folding of the chaperonins themselves is distinct in that it entails assembly of a sevenfold symmetrical structure. We have characterized denaturation and renaturation of the recombinant human chaperonin 10 (cpn10), which forms a heptamer. Denaturation induced by chemical denaturants urea and guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) as well as by heat was monitored by tyrosine fluorescence, far-ultraviolet circular dichroism, and cross-linking; all denaturation reactions were reversible. GuHCl-induced denaturation was found to be cpn10 concentration dependent, in accord with a native heptamer to denatured monomer transition. In contrast, urea-induced denaturation was not cpn10 concentration dependent, suggesting that under these conditions cpn10 heptamers denature without dissociation. There were no indications of equilibrium intermediates, such as folded monomers, in either denaturant. The different cpn10 denatured states observed in high [GuHCl] and high [urea] were supported by cross-linking experiments. Thermal denaturation revealed that monomer and heptamer reactions display the same enthalpy change (per monomer), whereas the entropy-increase is significantly larger for the heptamer. A thermodynamic cycle for oligomeric cpn10, combining chemical denaturation with the dissociation constant in absence of denaturant, shows that dissociated monomers are only marginally stable (3 kJ/mol). The thermodynamics for co-chaperonin stability appears conserved; therefore, instability of the monomer could be necessary to specify the native heptameric structure.     

The unfolding pathway of leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor

The unfolding and denaturation curves of leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor (LCI) were elucidated using the technique of disulfide scrambling. In the presence of thiol initiator and denaturant, the native LCI denatures by shuffling its native disulfide bonds and transforms into a mixture of scrambled species. 9 of 104 possible scrambled isomers of LCI, amounting to 90% of total denatured LCI, can be distinguished. The denaturation curve that plots the fraction of native LCI converted into scrambled isomers upon increasing concentrations of denaturant shows that the concentration of guanidine thiocyanate and guanidine hydrochloride required to reach 50% of denaturation is 2.4 and 3.6 m, respectively. In contrast, native LCI is resistant to urea denaturation even at high concentration (8 m). The LCI unfolding pathway was defined based on the evolution of the relative concentration of scrambled isoforms of LCI upon denaturation. Two populations of scrambled species suffer variations along the unfolding pathway. One accumulates as intermediates under strong denaturing conditions and corresponds to open or relaxed structures, among which the beads-form isomer is found. The other population shows an inverse correlation between their relative abundances and the denaturing conditions and should have another kind of non-native structure that is more compact than the unfolded state. The rate constants of unfolding of LCI are low when compared with other disulfide-containing proteins. Overall, the results presented in this study show that LCI, a molecule with potential biotechnological applications, has slow kinetics of unfolding and is highly stable.     

The unfolding pathway and conformational stability of potato carboxypeptidase inhibitor

The unfolding and denaturation curves of potato carboxypeptidase inhibitor (PCI) were investigated using the technique of disulfide scrambling. In the presence of denaturant and thiol initiator, the native PCI denatures by shuffling its native disulfide bonds and converts to form a mixture of scrambled PCI that consists of 9 out of a possible 14 isomers. The denaturation curve is determined by the fraction of native PCI converted to scrambled isomers under increasing concentrations of denaturant. The concentration of guanidine thiocyanate, guanidine hydrochloride, and urea required to denature 50% of the native PCI was found to be 0.7, 1.45, and 8 m, respectively. The PCI unfolding curve was constructed through the analysis of structures of scrambled isomers that were denatured under increasing concentrations of denaturant. These results reveal the existence of structurally defined unfolding intermediates and a progressive expansion of the polypeptide chain. The yield of the beads-form isomer (Cys(8)-Cys(12), Cys(18)-Cys(24), and Cys(27)-Cys(34)) as a fraction of total denatured PCI was shown to be directly proportional to the strength of the denaturing condition. Furthermore, the PCI sequence was unable to fold quantitatively into a single native structure. Under physiological conditions, the scrambled isomers of PCI that constitute about 4% of the protein were in equilibrium with native PCI.     

A model of the changes in denatured state structure underlying m value effects in staphylococcal nuclease.

Hydrogen exchange kinetics were measured on the native states of wild type staphylococcal nuclease and four mutants with values of mGuHCl (defined as dDeltaG/d[guanidine hydrochloride]) ranging from 0.8 to 1.4 of the wild type value. Residues within the five-strand beta-barrel of wild type and E75A and D77A, two mutants with reduced values of m GuHCl, were significantly more protected from exchange than expected on the basis of global stability as measured by fluorescence. In contrast, mutants V23A and M26G with elevated values of mGuHCl approach a flat profile of more or less constant protection independent of position in the structure. Differences in exchange protection between the C-terminus and the beta-barrel region correlate with mGuHCl, suggesting that a residual barrel-like structure becomes more highly populated in the denatured states of m- mutants and less populated in m+ mutants. Variations in the population of such a molten globule-like structure would account for the large changes in solvent accessible surface area of the denatured state thought to underlie m value effects.     

Evidence for an intermediate in the denaturation and assembly of phosphoglucose isomerase

The denaturation of dimeric rabbit muscle phosphoglucose isomerase in guanidine hydrochloride occurs in two discrete steps consisting of partial unfolding followed by subunit dissociation. In 3.5 to 4.5 m guanidine hydrochloride the enzyme forms a stable denaturation intermediate. Formation of this intermediate abolishes catalytic activity, shifts the protein fluorescence emission maximum from 332 to 345 nm, exposes all of the unavailable sulfhydryl groups, and decreases the s_20,w from 6.8 to 4.6 S. The intermediate dissociates into fully unfolded polypeptide chains with further increases in the concentration of the denaturant. The fluorescence maximum shifts to 352 nm and the s_20,w of the denatured monomer is 1.6 S. From the equilibrium constant for subunit association, 3 × 10⁴M^?1, in 4.7 m guanidine hydrochloride, the apparent free energy of association is estimated to be ?6 kcal mol^?1. Reconstitution of the enzyme protein takes place by the reversal of the steps observed upon denaturation. The denatured monomers refold and associate to reform the dimeric intermediate which then anneals to yield the intact enzyme molecule.     

Role of quaternary structure in muscle creatine kinase stability: Tryptophan 210 is important for dimer cohesion

A mutant of the dimeric rabbit muscle creatine kinase (MM-CK) in which tryptophan 210 was replaced has been studied to assess the role of this residue in dimer cohesion and the importance of the dimeric state for the native enzyme stability. Wild-type protein equilibrium unfolding induced by guanidine hydrochloride occurs through intermediate states with formation of a molten globule and a premolten globule. Unlike the wild-type enzyme, the mutant inactivates at lower denaturant concentration and the loss of enzymatic activity is accompanied by the dissociation of the dimer into two apparently compact monomers. However, the Stokes radius of the monomer increases with denaturant concentration as determined by size exclusion chromatography, indicating that, upon monomerization, the protein structure is destabilized. Binding of 8-anilinonaphthalene-1-sulfonate shows that the dissociated monomer exposes hydrophobic patches at its surface, suggesting that it could be a molten globule. At higher denaturant concentrations, both wild-type and mutant follow similar denaturation pathways with formation of a premolten globule around 1.5-M guanidine, indicating that tryptophan 210 does not contribute to a large extent to the monomer conformational stability, which may be ensured in the dimeric state through quaternary interactions. Proteins 32:43–51, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Effects of guanidine hydrochloride on the refolding kinetics of denatured thioredoxin

The effect of guanidine hydrochloride concentration on the kinetics of the conformational change of Escherichia coli thioredoxin was examined by using fluorescence, absorbance, circular dichroic, and viscosity measurements. Native thioredoxin unfolds in a single kinetic phase whose time constant decreases markedly with increasing denaturant concentration in the denaturation base-line zone. This dependency merges with the time constant of the slowest refolding kinetic phase at the midpoint of the equilibrium transition in 2.5 M denaturant. The time constant of the slowest refolding phase becomes denaturant independent below 1 M denaturant in the native base-line region. The denaturant-independent slowest refolding phase has an activation energy of 16 kcal/mol and is generated in the denatured base-line zone in a denaturant-independent reaction having a time constant of 19 s at 25 degrees C. The fractional amplitude of the slowest refolding phase diminishes in the native base-line zone to a minimum value of 0.25. This decrease is accompanied by an increase in the fractional amplitudes of two faster refolding kinetic phases, an increase describing a sigmoidal transition centered at about 1.6 M denaturant. Manual multimixing measurements indicate that only the slowest refolding kinetic phase generates a product having the stability of the native protein. We suggest that the two faster refolding phases reflect the transient accumulation of folding intermediates which can contain a nonnative isomer of proline peptide 76.     

Monitoring protein conformational changes by quenching of intrinsic fluorescence

The quenching of intrinsic fluorescence of human serum albumin and pigeon liver malic enzyme by acrylamide was studied after the proteins were denatured to different stages. The progress of protein denaturation induced by guanidine hydrochloride was accompanied by increasing of effective dynamic quenching constant which provides a convenient parameter for monitoring protein conformational change.     

Fluorescence and conformational stability studies of Staphylococcus nuclease and its mutants, including the less stable nuclease-concanavalin A hybrids

We report steady-state and time-resolved fluorescence studies with the single tryptophan protein, Staphylococcus aureus A, and several of its site-directed mutants. A couple of these mutants, nuclease-conA and nuclease-conA-S28G (which are hybrid proteins containing a six amino acid beta-turn substitute from concanavalin A), are found to have a much lower thermodynamic stability than the wild type. The thermal transition temperatures for nuclease-conA and S28G are 32.8 and 30.5 degrees C, which are about 20 degrees C lower than the Tm for wild-type nuclease A. These mutant proteins also are denatured by a much lower concentration of the denaturants urea and guanidine hydrochloride. We also show that an unfolding transition in the structure of the nuclease-conA hybrids can be induced by relatively low hydrostatic pressure (approximately 700 bar). The free energy for unfolding of nuclease-conA (and nuclease-conA-S28G) is found to be only 1.4 kcal/mol (and 1.2 kcal/mol) by thermal, urea, guanidine hydrochloride, and pressure unfolding. Time-resolved fluorescence intensity and anisotropy measurements with nuclease-conA-S28G show the temperature-, urea-, and pressure-perturbed states each to have a reduced average intensity decay time and to depolarize with a rotational correlation time of approximately 1.0 ns (as compared to a rotational correlation time of 11 ns for the native form of nuclease-conA-S28G at 20 degrees C).     

Conformational stability of dimeric proteins: quantitative studies by equilibrium denaturation.

The conformational stability of dimeric globular proteins can be measured by equilibrium denaturation studies in solvents such as guanidine hydrochloride or urea. Many dimeric proteins denature with a 2-state equilibrium transition, whereas others have stable intermediates in the process. For those proteins showing a single transition of native dimer to denatured monomer, the conformational stabilities, delta Gu (H2O), range from 10 to 27 kcal/mol, which is significantly greater than the conformational stability found for monomeric proteins. The relative contribution of quaternary interactions to the overall stability of the dimer can be estimated by comparing delta Gu (H2O) from equilibrium denaturation studies to the free energy associated with simple dissociation in the absence of denaturant. In many cases the large stabilization energy of dimers is primarily due to the intersubunit interactions and thus gives a rationale for the formation of oligomers. The magnitude of the conformational stability is related to the size of the polypeptide in the subunit and depends upon the type of structure in the subunit interface. The practical use, interpretation, and utility of estimation of conformational stability of dimers by equilibrium denaturation methods are discussed.     

Effects of heme on the structure of the denatured state and folding kinetics of cytochrome b562

Heme-linked proteins, such as cytochromes, are popular subjects for protein folding studies. There is the underlying question of whether the heme affects the structure of the denatured state by cross-linking it and forming other interactions, which would perturb the folding pathway. We have studied wild-type and mutant cytochrome b562 from Escherichia coli, a 106 residue four-alpha-helical bundle. The holo protein apparently refolds with a half-life of 4 micros in its ferrous state. We have analysed the folding of the apo protein using continuous-flow fluorescence as well as stopped-flow fluorescence and CD. The apo protein folded much more slowly with a half-life of 270 micros that was unaffected by the presence of exogenous heme. We examined the nature of the denatured states of both holo and apo proteins by NMR methods over a range of concentrations of guanidine hydrochloride. The starting point for folding of the holo protein in concentrations of denaturant around the denaturation transition was a highly ordered native-like species with heme bound. Fully denatured holo protein at higher concentrations of denaturant consisted of denatured apo protein and free heme. Our results suggest that the very fast folding species of denatured holo protein is in a compact state, whereas the normal folding pathway from fully denatured holo protein consists of the slower folding of the apo protein followed by the binding of heme. These data should be considered in the analysis of folding of heme proteins.     

Physicochemical properties of thiol proteinase inhibitor isolated from goat pancreas

Thiol proteinase inhibitors are crucial to proper functioning of all living tissues consequent to their cathepsin regulatory and myriad important biologic properties. Equilibrium denaturation of dimeric goat pancreas thiol proteinase inhibitor (PTPI), a cystatin superfamily variant has been studied by monitoring changes in the protein's spectroscopic and functional characteristics. Denaturation of PTPI in guanidine hydrochloride and urea resulted in altered intrinsic fluorescence emission spectrum, diminished negative circular dichroism, and loss of its papain inhibitory potential. Native like spectroscopic properties and inhibitory activity are only partially restored when denaturant is diluted from guanidine hydrochloride unfolded samples demonstrating that process is partially reversible. Coincidence of transition curves and dependence of transition midpoint (3.2M) on protein concentration in guanidine hydrochloride‐induced denaturation are consistent with a two‐state model involving a native like dimer and denatured monomer. On the contrary, urea‐induced unfolding of PTPI is a multiphasic process with indiscernible intermediates. The studies demonstrate that functional conformation and stability are governed by both ionic and hydrophobic interactions. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 93: 708–717, 2010. This article was originally published online as an accepted preprint. The “Published Online” date corresponds to the preprint version. You can request a copy of the preprint by emailing the Biopolymers editorial office at biopolymers@wiley.com     

Solvent denaturation and stabilization of globular proteins

Statistical thermodynamic theory has recently been developed to account for the stabilities of globular proteins. Here we extend that work to predict the effects of solvents on protein stability. Folding is assumed to be driven by solvophobic interactions and opposed by conformational entropy. The solvent dependence of the solvophobic interactions is taken from transfer experiments of Nozaki and Tanford on amino acids into aqueous solutions of urea or guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl). On the basis of the assumption of two pathways involving collapse and formation of a core, the theory predicts that increasing denaturant should lead to a two-state denaturation transition (i.e., there is a stable state along each path separated by a free energy barrier). The denaturation midpoint is predicted to occur at higher concentrations of urea than of GuHCl. At neutral pH, the radius of the solvent-denatured state should be much smaller than for a random-flight chain and increase with either denaturant concentration or number of polar residues in the chain. A question of interest is whether free energies of folding should depend linearly on denaturant, as is often assumed. The free energy is predicted to be linear for urea but to have some small curvature for GuHCl. Predicted slopes and exposed areas of the unfolded states are found to be in generally good agreement with experiments. We also discuss stabilizing solvents and compare thermal with solvent denaturation.     

Equilibrium denaturation studies of mouse beta-nerve growth factor.

Equilibrium denaturation of dimeric mouse beta-nerve growth factor (beta-NGF) has been studied by monitoring changes in the protein's spectroscopic characteristics. Denaturation of beta-NGF in guanidine hydrochloride and urea resulted in an altered intrinsic fluorescence emission spectrum, fluorescence depolarization, and diminished negative circular dichroism. Native-like spectroscopic properties and specific biological activity are restored when denaturant is diluted from unfolded samples, demonstrating that this process is fully reversible. However, refolding of denatured beta-NGF is dependent on the three disulfide bonds present in the native protein and does not readily occur when the disulfide bonds are reduced. Graphical analysis and nonlinear least-squares fitting of beta-NGF denaturation data demonstrate that denaturation is dependent on the concentration of beta-NGF and is consistent with a two-state model involving native dimer and denatured monomer (N2 = 2D). The conformational stability of mouse beta-NGF calculated according to this model is 19.3 +/- 1.1 kcal/mol in 100 mM sodium phosphate at pH 7. Increasing the hydrogen ion concentration resulted in a 25% decrease in beta-NGF stability at pH 4 relative to pH 7.     

Thermal denaturation of iso-1-cytochrome c variants: comparison with solvent denaturation.

Thermal denaturation studies as a function of pH were carried out on wild-type iso-1-cytochrome c and three variants of this protein at the solvent-exposed position 73 of the sequence. By examining the enthalpy and Tm at various pH values, the heat capacity increment (delta Cp), which is dominated by the degree of change in nonpolar hydration upon protein unfolding, was found for the wild type where lysine 73 is normally present and for three variants. For the Trp 73 variant, the delta Cp value (1.15 +/- 0.17 kcal/mol K) decreased slightly relative to wild-type iso-1-cytochrome c (1.40 +/- 0.06 kcal/mol K), while for the Ile 73 (1.65 +/- 0.07 kcal/mol K) and the Val 73 (1.50 +/- 0.06 kcal/mol K) variants, delta Cp increased slightly. In previous studies, the Trp 73, Ile 73, and Val 73 variants have been shown to have decreased m-values in guanidine hydrochloride denaturations relative to the wild-type protein (Hermann L, Bowler BE, Dong A, Caughey WS. 1995. The effects of hydrophilic to hydrophobic surface mutations on the denatured state of iso-1-cytochrome c: Investigation of aliphatic residues. Biochemistry 34:3040-3047). Both the m-value and delta Cp are related to the change in solvent exposure upon unfolding and other investigators have shown a correlation exists between these two parameters. However, for this subset of variants of iso-1-cytochrome c, a lack of correlation exists which implies that there may be basic differences between the guanidine hydrochloride and thermal denaturations of this protein. Spectroscopic data are consistent with different denatured states for thermal and guanidine hydrochloride unfolding. The different response of m-values and delta Cp for these variants will be discussed in this context.