Characterization of pECL18 and pKPN2: a proposed pathway for the evolution of two plasmids that carry identical genes for a Type II restriction-modification system

The primary structures of the plasmids pECL18 (5571 bp) and pKPN2 (4196 bp) from Escherichia coli and Klebsiella pneumoniae, respectively, which carry genes for a Type II restriction-modification system (RMS2) with the specificity 5'-CCNGG-3', were determined in order to elucidate the structural relationship between them. The data suggest a possible role for recombination events at bom (basis of mobility) regions and the sites of resolution of multimer plasmid forms (so-called cer sequences) in the structural evolution of multicopy plasmids. Analysis of the sequences of pECL18 and pKPN2 showed that the genes for RM* Ecl18kI and RM* Kpn2kI, and the sequences of the rep (replication) regions in the two plasmids, are almost identical. In both plasmids, these regions are localized between the bom regions and the cer sites. The rest of the pECL18 sequence is almost identical to that of the mob (mobilization) region of ColE1, and the corresponding segment of pKPN2 is almost identical to part of pHS-2 from Shigella flexneri. The difference in primary structures results in different mobilization properties of pECL18 and pKPN2. The complete sequences of pECL18, pKPN2 and the pairwise comparison of the sequences of pECL18, pKPN2, ColE1 and pHS-2 suggest that plasmids may exchange DNA units via site-specific recombination events at bom and cer sites. In the course of BLASTN database searches using the cer sites of pECL18 and pKPN2 as queries, we found twenty cer sites of natural plasmids. Alignment of these sequences reveals that they fall into two classes. The plasmids in each group possess related segments between their cer and bom sites.     

Structural plasmid evolution as a result of coupled recombinations at<Emphasis Type="Italic"> bom</Emphasis> and<Emphasis Type="Italic"> cer</Emphasis> sites

We have studied the recombination of plasmids bearing bom and cer sites. The bom (basis of mobilization) site is required for conjugative transfer, while the cer (ColE1 resolution) site is involved in the resolution of plasmid multimers, which increases plasmid stability. We constructed a pair of parent plasmids in such a way as to allow us select clones containing recombinant plasmids directly. Clone selection was based on the McrA sensitivity of recipient host DNA modified by M. Ecl18kI, which is encoded by one of the parent plasmids. The recombinant plasmid contains segments originating from both parental DNAs, which are bounded by bom and cer sites. Its structure is in accordance with our previously proposed model for recombination mediated by bom and cer sequences. The frequency of recombinant plasmid formation coincided with the frequency of recombination at the bom site. We also show that bom-mediated recombination in trans, unlike in cis, is independent of other genetic determinants on the conjugative plasmids.Communicated by W. Goebel     

Resolution of ColE1 dimers requires a DNA sequence implicated in the three-dimensional organization of the cer site.

Plasmid ColE1 specifies a recombination site (cer) which participates in the conversion of plasmid dimers to monomers. The uncontrolled accumulation of dimers (and higher oligomeric forms) would otherwise lead to plasmid instability. Exonuclease III-generated deletions have been used to define the left-hand boundary of the cer site. Deletions which have lost up to 60 bp adjacent to the boundary no longer mediate the conversion of plasmid dimers to monomers, but still recombine with a wild-type site. Although this boundary region is essential for dimer resolution, its DNA sequence is poorly conserved among multimer resolution sites in related plasmids. We present evidence that its function is to influence the three-dimensional organization of the site and suggest that it may be required for the formation of a condensed nucleoprotein complex.     

Derivatives of ColE1 cer show altered topological specificity in site-specific recombination.

ColE1 contains a 250-bp sequence (cer) which is required in cis for the conversion of plasmid dimers to monomers. Recombination between cer and parB (a dimer resolution site from plasmid CloDF13) occurs in vivo at low frequency. The properties of the resulting hybrid sites have been studied. The type I hybrid closely resembles wild-type cer. It supports intramolecular recombination and requires the products of the chromosomal xerA, xerB and xerC genes together with the 250-bp site. In contrast, the type II hybrid (although differing from type I by only 2 bp) functions independently of the topological relationship of the participating sites, supporting both inter- and intramolecular recombination. Furthermore, recombination between type II sites is independent of the products of the xerA and xerB genes and requires a site of less than 50 bp.     

Site-specific recombination between ColE1 tcer and NTP16 nmr sites in vivo

The site-specific recombination system used by multicopy plasmids of the ColE1 family uses two identical plasmid-encoded recombination sites and four bacterial proteins to catalyze the recombination reaction. In the case of the Escherichia coli plasmid ColE1, the recombination site, cer, is a 280 by DNA sequence which is acted on by the products of the argR, pepA, xerC and xerD genes. We have constructed a model system to study this recombination system, using tandemly repeated recombination sites from the plasmids ColE1 and NTP16. These plasmids have allowed us precisely to define the region of strand exchange during site-specific recombination, and to derive a model for cer intramolecular site-specific recombination.     

Site-specific recombination between ColE1 tcer and NTP16 nmr sites in vivo

The site-specific recombination system used by multicopy plasmids of the ColE1 family uses two identical plasmid-encoded recombination sites and four bacterial proteins to catalyze the recombination reaction. In the case of the Escherichia coli plasmid ColE1, the recombination site, cer, is a 280 by DNA sequence which is acted on by the products of the argR, pepA, xerC and xerD genes. We have constructed a model system to study this recombination system, using tandemly repeated recombination sites from the plasmids ColE1 and NTP16. These plasmids have allowed us precisely to define the region of strand exchange during site-specific recombination, and to derive a model for cer intramolecular site-specific recombination.     

Xer-mediated site-specific recombination in vitro.

The Xer site-specific recombination system acts at ColE1 cer and pSC101 psi sites to ensure that these plasmids are in a monomeric state prior to cell division. We show that four proteins, ArgR, PepA, XerC and XerD are necessary and sufficient for recombination between directly repeated cer sites on a supercoiled plasmid in vitro. Only PepA, XerC and XerD are required for recombination at psi in vitro. Recombination at cer and psi in vitro requires negative supercoiling and is exclusively intramolecular. Strand exchange at cer produces Holliday junction-containing products in which only the top strands have been exchanged. This reaction requires the catalytic tyrosine residue of Xer C but not that of XerD. Recombination at psi gives catenated circular resolution products. Strand exchange at psi is sequential. XerC catalyses the first (top) strand exchange to make a Holiday junction intermediate and XerD catalyses the second (bottom) strand exchange.     

The ArcA/ArcB two-component regulatory system of Escherichia coli is essential for Xer site-specific recombination at psi

Two recombinases, XerC and XerD, act at the recombination sites psi and cer in plasmids pSC101 and ColE1 respectively. Recombination at these sites maintains the plasmids in a monomeric state and helps to promote stable plasmid inheritance. The accessory protein PepA acts at both psi and cer to ensure that only intramolecular recombination takes place. An additional accessory protein, ArgR, is required for recombination at cer but not at psi . Here, we demonstrate that the ArcA/ArcB two-component regulatory system of Escherichia coli , which mediates adaptation to anaerobic growth conditions, is required for efficient recombination in vivo at psi . Phosphorylated ArcA binds to psi in vitro and increases the efficiency of recombination at this site. Binding of ArcA to psi may contribute to the formation of a higher order synaptic complex between a pair of psi sites, thus helping to ensure that recombination is intramolecular.     

FtsK-dependent and -independent pathways of Xer site-specific recombination.

Homologous recombination between circular chromosomes generates dimers that cannot be segregated at cell division. Escherichia coli Xer site-specific recombination converts chromosomal and plasmid dimers to monomers. Two recombinases, XerC and XerD, act at the E. coli chromosomal recombination site, dif, and at related sites in plasmids. We demonstrate that Xer recombination at plasmid dif sites occurs efficiently only when FtsK is present and under conditions that allow chromosomal dimer formation, whereas recombination at the plasmid sites cer and psi is independent of these factors. We propose that the chromosome dimer- and FtsK-dependent process that activates Xer recombination at plasmid dif also activates Xer recombination at chromosomal dif. The defects in chromosome segregation that result from mutation of the FtsK C-terminus are attributable to the failure of Xer recombination to resolve chromosome dimers to monomers. Conditions that lead to FtsK-independent Xer recombination support the hypothesis that FtsK acts on Holliday junction Xer recombination intermediates.     

Differential regulation of multiple overlapping promoters in flagellar class II operons in Escherichia coli

The cer –Xer dimer resolution system of plasmid ColE1 is highly selective, acting only at sites on the same molecule and in direct repeat. Recombination requires the XerCD recombinase and accessory proteins ArgR and PepA. The Escherichia coli chromosome dimer resolution site dif and the type II hybrid site use the same recombinase but are independent of ArgR and PepA and show no site selectivity. This has led to the proposal that ArgR and PepA are responsible for the imposition of constraint. We describe here the characterization of a novel class of 'conditionally constrained' multimer resolution sites whose properties support this hypothesis. In the presence of ArgR and PepA, plasmids containing conditionally constrained sites are monomeric, but in their absence, extensive multimerisation is seen. A mutant ArgR derivative (ArgR110), which is defective in cer -mediated dimer resolution, remains able to prevent plasmid multimerisation by a conditionally constrained site. This implies that the accessory factors block recombination in trans rather than ensuring rapid multimer resolution. When the distance between the ArgR and XerCD binding sites in a conditionally constrained site was altered by a non-integral number of helical turns, the site became unconstrained. Constraint was restored by the insertion of a full helical turn.     

Differences in resolution of mwr-containing plasmid dimers mediated by the Klebsiella pneumoniae and Escherichia coli XerC recombinases: potential implications in dissemination of antibiotic resistance genes

Xer-mediated dimer resolution at the mwr site of the multiresistance plasmid pJHCMW1 is osmoregulated in Escherichia coli containing either the Escherichia coli Xer recombination machinery or Xer recombination elements from K. pneumoniae. In the presence of K. pneumoniae XerC (XerC(Kp)), the efficiency of recombination is lower than that in the presence of the E. coli XerC (XerC(Ec)) and the level of dimer resolution is insufficient to stabilize the plasmid, even at low osmolarity. This lower efficiency of recombination at mwr is observed in the presence of E. coli or K. pneumoniae XerD proteins. Mutagenesis experiments identified a region near the N terminus of XerC(Kp) responsible for the lower level of recombination catalyzed by XerC(Kp) at mwr. This region encompasses the second half of the predicted alpha-helix B and the beginning of the predicted alpha-helix C. The efficiencies of recombination at other sites such as dif or cer in the presence of XerC(Kp) or XerC(Ec) are comparable. Therefore, XerC(Kp) is an active recombinase whose action is impaired on the mwr recombination site. This characteristic may result in restriction of the host range of plasmids carrying this site, a phenomenon that may have important implications in the dissemination of antibiotic resistance genes.     

Xer-mediated site-specific recombination at cer generates Holliday junctions in vivo.

Normal segregation of the Escherichia coli chromosome and stable inheritance of multicopy plasmids such as ColE1 requires the Xer site-specific recombination system. Two putative lambda integrase family recombinases, XerC and XerD, participate in the recombination reactions. We have constructed an E. coli strain in which the expression of xerC can be tightly regulated, thereby allowing the analysis of controlled recombination reactions in vivo. Xer-mediated recombination in this strain generates Holliday junction-containing DNA molecules in which a specific pair of strands has been exchanged in addition to complete recombinant products. This suggests that Xer site-specific recombination utilizes a strand exchange mechanism similar or identical to that of other members of the lambda integrase family of recombination systems. The controlled in vivo recombination reaction at cer requires recombinase and two accessory proteins, ArgR and PepA. Generation of Holliday junctions and recombinant products is equally efficient in RuvC- and RuvC+ cells, and in cells containing a multicopy RuvC+ plasmid. Controlled XerC expression is also used to analyse the efficiency of recombination between variant cer sites containing sequence alterations and heterologies within their central regions.     

Plasmid recombination stimulated by restriction endonuclease EcoRI in vivo: formation of recombinant plasmids in recA+-cells of E. coli

The possible participation of restriction endonuclease EcoRI in recombination of compatible nonhomologous plasmids in E. coli cells has been studied. To study the process, plasmids RP4 and R245 have been transferred by conjugation into the recipient cells of E. coli harbouring one of isogenic plasmids, pSA14 and pSA25, different for the genes coding restriction endonuclease EcoRI. The genetic analysis of transconjugant phenotypes, coded by the plasmids, has permitted to register the recombinant plasmids after compatibility of parent plasmids in E. coli cells. Recombination of plasmid RP4 with the plasmid pSA14, carrying EcoRI genes, has been registered in E. coli cells, producing the restriction endonuclease, while plasmid recombination has not been found in the cells harbouring plasmid pSA25, isogenic for all genes, except for EcoRI genes, with plasmid pSA14. Restriction endonuclease EcoRI is concluded to stimulate site specific recombination of nonhomologous compatible plasmids in vivo. EcoRI-mediated recombination of plasmid R245 with plasmid pSA14 is discussed.     

Nucleoprotein architecture and ColE1 dimer resolution: a hypothesis

Dimers of plasmid ColE1 are converted to monomers by site-specific recombination, a process that requires 240 bp of DNA ( cer ) and four host-encoded proteins (XerC, XerD, ArgR and PepA). Here, we propose structures for nucleoprotein complexes involved in cer –Xer recombination based upon existing knowledge of the structures of component proteins and computational analyses of protein structure and DNA curvature. We propose that, in the nucleoprotein complex at a single cer site, a PepA hexamer acts as an adaptor, connecting the heterodimeric recombinase (XerCD) to an ArgR hexamer. This provides a protein core around which the cer site wraps, its exact path being defined by strong sequence-specific interactions with ArgR and XerCD, weak interactions with PepA and sequence-dependent flexibility of cer . The initial association of single-site complexes (pairing) is proposed to occur via an ArgR–PepA interaction. Pairing between sites in a plasmid dimer is stabilized by DNA supercoiling and is followed by a structural isomerization to form a recombination-proficient synaptic complex. We propose that paired structures formed between sites in trans are too short-lived to permit synaptic complex formation. There is thus an energetic barrier to inappropriate recombination reactions. Our proposals are consistent with a wide range of experimental observations.     

The arginine repressor is essential for plasmid-stabilizing site-specific recombination at the ColE1 cer locus.

The heritable stability in Escherichia coli of the multicopy plasmid ColE1 and its natural relatives requires that the plasmids be maintained in the monomeric state. Plasmid multimers, that arise through recA-dependent homologous recombination, are normally converted to monomers by a site-specific recombination system that acts at a specific plasmid site (cer in ColE1). No plasmid functions that act at this site have been identified. In contrast, two unlinked E.coli genes that encode functions required for cer-mediated site-specific recombination have been identified. Here we describe the isolation and characterization of one such gene (xerA) and show it to be identical to the gene encoding the repressor of the arginine biosynthetic genes (argR). The argR protein binds to cer DNA both in vivo and in vitro in the presence of arginine. We believe this binding is required to generate a higher order protein-DNA complex within the recombinational synapse. The argR gene of Bacillus subtilis complements an E.coli argR deficiency for cer-mediated recombination despite the two proteins having only 27% amino acid identity.     

Transduction-related cointegrate formation between staphylococcal plasmids: A new type of site-specific recombination

Small R plasmids are frequently cotransduced by staphylococcal transducing phages. Most cotransductants contain independent plasmids indistinguishable from those of the donor strain; occasionally recombinational exchanges can be demonstrated including the formation of stable cointegrates that appear to contain all of the genomes of the two starting plasmids. These cointegrates do not dissociate at a detectable frequency upon subculture of the host strain or upon further transduction. Examination of a series of these cointegrates derived by recombination between various pairs of plasmids has revealed the existence of a new type of site-specific recombination. Nineteen different cointegrates involving five different plasmids were studied by restriction endonuclease analysis and electron microscopic examination of heteroduplexes. To the limits of resolution of these techniques, it can be concluded that each plasmid contains one or more specific sites that is used for the formation of cointegrates with the other plasmids. In addition, the cointegrates are orientation specific as well as site specific so that the recombination process resembles that of prophage integration more than that of transposon insertion. Strikingly, in cases where cointegrates between one plasmid, A, and two or more others (e.g., B and C) have been isolated, the same site on A is used for cointegrate formation with both B and C; moreover, B and C also form cointegrates with each other, using the same site and orientation with which both recombine with A. The formation of cointegrates probably involves identical sequences of ≤ 100 nucleotides and is not demonstrably related to overall homology.     

A site-specific recE4-independent intramolecular recombination between Bacillus subtilis and Staphylococcus aureus DNAs in hybrid plasmids

A composite plasmid pLS253 was constructed from pLS103 [carrying the Bacillus subtilis leucine genes on B. subtilis (natto) plasmid pLS28] and pHV14 [a recombinant plasmid composed of pBR322 and the staphylococcal R-plasmid pC194] employing BamHI endonuclease, T4 DNA ligase, and B. subtilis transformation. All the Leu+ Cmr transformants tested harbored not only pLS253 but also two smaller plasmids designated as pLS251 and pLS252. pLS253 DNA, when purified on an agarose gel, retained both Leu+ and Cmr transforming activities; however, in all the Leu+ Cmr transformants, the two smaller plasmids reappeared. pLS251 and pLS252 exhibited Leu+- or Cm4-transforming activity, respectively, and must have been derived from the pLS253 parent by an intramolecular recombination event, since the sum of the pLS251 and pLS252 DNAs represent the entire pLS253 genome. The recombination occurred between specific sites on the B. subtilis (natto) and Staphylococcus aureus plasmids. When the composite plasmid, pLS254, was constructed by BamHI cleavage of pLS251 and pLS252 followed by ligation, Leu+ Cmr transformants segregated two smaller plasmids which were indistinguishable from the original plasmids pLS103 and pHV14, respectively. They must have been derived from pLS254 through a reversal of the original recombination event. No intermolecular recombination between pLS251 and pLS252 DNA was detected. The recombination process was independent of recE function of the host cells, and its mechanism is discussed.