Evolution of the master Alu gene(s)

Summary A comparison of Alu sequences that comprise more recently amplified Alu subfamilies was made. There are 18 individual diagnostic mutations associated with the different subfamilies. This analysis confirmed that the formation of each subfamily can be explained by the sequential accumulation of mutations relative to the previous subfamily. Polymerase chain reaction amplification of orthologous loci in several primate species allowed us to determine the time of insertion of Alu sequences in individual loci. These data suggest that the vast majority of Alu elements amplified at any given time comprised a single Alu subfamily. We find that, although the individual divergence relative to a consensus sequence correlate reasonably well with sequence age, the diagnostic mutations are a more accurate measure of the age of any individual Alu family member. Our data are consistent with a model in which all Alu family members have been made from a single master gene or from a series of sequential master genes. This master gene(s) accumulated diagnostic base changes, resulting in the amplification of different subfamilies from the master gene at different times in primate evolution. The changes in the master gene(s) probably occurred individually, but their appearance is clearly punctuated. Ten of them have occurred within an 15-million-year time span, 40–25 million years ago, and 8 changes have occurred within the last 5 million years. Surprisingly, no changes appeared in the 20 milion years separating these periods.     

Evolution of alu family repeats since the divergence of human and chimpanzee

Summary The DNA sequences of three members of the Alu family of repeated sequences located 5 to the chimpanzee 2 gene have been determined. The base sequences of the three corresponding human Alu family repeats have been previously determined, permitting the comparison of identical Alu family members in human and chimpanzee. Here we compare the sequences of seven pairs of chimpanzee and human Alu repeats. In each case, with the exception of minor sequence differences, the identical Alu repeat is located at identical sites in the human and chimpanzee genomes. The Alu repeats diverge at the rate expected for nonselected sequences. Sequence conversion has not replaced any of these 14 Alu family members since the divergence between chimpanzee and human.     

Species-specific homogeneity of the primate Alu family of repeated DNA sequences

We have determined the base sequence of several cloned Alu family members from the DNAs of a new world monkey (owl monkey) and a prosimian (galago). The three owl monkey Alu family members reported here belong to a single 300 base pair consensus sequence which closely resembles the human Alu family consensus. The galago Alu family members can best be represented as belonging to either of two related but distinct consensus sequences. One of the two galago Alu family subgroups (Type I) more accurately resembles the human consensus sequence than does the other subgroup (Type II). In this work we compare base sequences of human and galago Type I Alu family members. There are several examples of species-specific differences between the human and Type I galago sequences indicating that the Alu family members are effectively homogenized within a species.     

The Contribution of Alu Elements to Mutagenic DNA Double-Strand Break Repair

Alu elements make up the largest family of human mobile elements, numbering 1.1 million copies and comprising 11% of the human genome. As a consequence of evolution and genetic drift, Alu elements of various sequence divergence exist throughout the human genome. Alu/Alu recombination has been shown to cause approximately 0.5% of new human genetic diseases and contribute to extensive genomic structural variation. To begin understanding the molecular mechanisms leading to these rearrangements in mammalian cells, we constructed Alu/Alu recombination reporter cell lines containing Alu elements ranging in sequence divergence from 0%-30% that allow detection of both Alu/Alu recombination and large non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) deletions that range from 1.0 to 1.9 kb in size. Introduction of as little as 0.7% sequence divergence between Alu elements resulted in a significant reduction in recombination, which indicates even small degrees of sequence divergence reduce the efficiency of homology-directed DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair. Further reduction in recombination was observed in a sequence divergence-dependent manner for diverged Alu/Alu recombination constructs with up to 10% sequence divergence. With greater levels of sequence divergence (15%-30%), we observed a significant increase in DSB repair due to a shift from Alu/Alu recombination to variable-length NHEJ which removes sequence between the two Alu elements. This increase in NHEJ deletions depends on the presence of Alu sequence homeology (similar but not identical sequences). Analysis of recombination products revealed that Alu/Alu recombination junctions occur more frequently in the first 100 bp of the Alu element within our reporter assay, just as they do in genomic Alu/Alu recombination events. This is the first extensive study characterizing the influence of Alu element sequence divergence on DNA repair, which will inform predictions regarding the effect of Alu element sequence divergence on both the rate and nature of DNA repair events.     

Clustering and subfamily relationships of the Alu family in the human genome

Thirteen and 10 sequences of the Alu family of repeated DNA elements found within the human thymidine kinase and beta-tubulin genes, respectively, were compared. These genes have approximately five times the expected density of Alu family members. The consensus sequence that could be drawn from these 23 Alu family members would differ slightly from others drawn from random Alu family sequences but only at very heterogeneous positions. The different Alu family members do show different pairwise percentage identities, with approximately 15% (7 of 48 Alu family members analyzed) of them clearly representing a separate subfamily of sequences. This analysis also confirms the species- specific differences between human and the prosimian Galago crassicaudatus Alu family members. These data are consistent with both the origin of these sequences in primates less than 65-70 Myr ago and amplification since that time to their present 500,000 copies. The data do not show any special relationships among densely clustered Alu family members.      

The adult α-globin locus of old world monkeys: An abrupt breakdown of sequence similarity to human is defined by an Alu family repeat insertion site

Summary The haploid genomes of all known primates have two or more adult -globin genes contained within tandemly arranged duplication units. Although the tandem duplication event generating these -globin loci is believed to occur prior to the divergence of primates, a number of length polymorphisms exist within the loci among different primate species. In order to understand the molecular basis of these length polymorphisms, we have cloned and determined the nucleotide sequence of a major portion of the rhesus monkey adult -globin locus. Sequence comparison to human suggests that the length difference between the adult -globin loci of human and Old World monkey is the result of one or more DNA recombination processes, all of which appeared to be related to the transposition of Alu family repeats. First, the finding of a monomeric Alu family repeat at the junction between nonhomology block I and homology block Y of the 2 genecontaining unit in rhesus macaque suggests that the dimeric Alu family repeat, Alu 3, at the orthologous position in human was generated by insertion of a monomeric Alu family repeat into the 3 end of another preexisting Alu family repeat. Second, two Alu family repeats, Alu 1 and Alu 2, exist in human at the 3 end of each of the two X homology blocks, respectively. However, this pair of paralogous Alu family repeats is absent at the corresponding positions in rhesus macaques. This raises interesting questions regarding the evolutionary origin of Alu 1 and Alu 2. Finally, DNA sequences immediately downstream from the insertion site of Alu 2 are completely different between human and rhesus macaque. This last event is similar to DNA rearrangements occurring nearby transposable element(s) in the chromosomes of bacteria, yeast, and plant cells. Its possible role in accelerating the genomic evolution of noncoding or spacer DNA is discussed.     

Relationship of viroids and certain other plant pathogenic nucleic acids to group I and II introns

Summary The nucleotide sequences of viroids contain features believed to be essential for the splicing of group I introns. Common sequence elements include a 16-nucleotide consensus sequence and three pairs of short sequences arranged in the same sequential order in both types of RNAs. The calculated probability of finding sequences resembling the 16-nucleotide consensus sequence in random nucleotide chains showed that at low fidelity (up to 5 mismatched nucleotides), the number of such sequences in viroids, plant viral satellite RNAs, plant viral RNAs and one plant viral DNA, group I introns and flanking exons does not significantly differ from the number expected at random. As the degree of fidelity is increased, the number in both introns and viroids, but not in exons or the other plant pathogens examined, greatly exceeds that expected in random chains. These findings suggest that viroids may have evolved from group I introns and/or that processing of viroid oligomers to monomers may have structural requirements similar to those of group I introns. The nucleotide sequences of viroids do not show close homology with two conserved regions of group II introns, the 14-base pair consensus region and the 5 terminal segment. However, close homology does exist between the conserved sequence of the 3 terminal segment of group II introns and viroids thus suggesting a possible evolutionary or functional relationship.     

Characteristics of site variation among clones of the 340-base pair,tandemly repeated EcoR1 family of human DNA

Twenty-four clones of EcoR1-restricted, 340-base pair (bp) DNA derived from human DNA have been sequenced and compared to a published consensus sequence for this family. No two clones were found to have identical sequences; the clones studied differed from the consensus sequence in as few as 1 or as many as 41 sites. On the average in these clones, a 5.2% divergence from exact homology was found, with 1 of 10 of the site variations being nonrandom, i.e., cases in which five or more clones had the same nucleotide substitution at that site (viz., 53, 124, 126, 138, 152, and 157). At site 157, for example, 16 of the 24 clones differed from the reference sequence. Positions and their respective changes, as compared to the consensus sequence, are summarized. Variations are discussed with relation to possible functions for these sequences.This research was supported in part by Center for Disease Control Grant 1 K01 OH 0035-01, and K.M. was awarded a fellowship from NIOSH Educational Resource Center Grant 5-T15-OH07085.     

The structure of HSAG-1, a middle repetitive genetic element which elicits a leukemia-related cellular surface antigen.

HSAG-1 is a cloned member of a heterogeneous middle repetitive family of genetic elements which is capable of eliciting a leukemia-related surface antigen detected with a monoclonal antibody after DNA transformation of mouse cells. HSAG-1 was originally isolated from a Chinese hamster-human leukemia hybrid cell gene library both by sib-selection for antigen producing activity and by hybridization with labelled human genomic human DNA. We show here that the human labelled site is at the right hand end of the insert, while the antigen-eliciting portion is included in a 1450 bp fragment at the left hand end of the insert. We also present the complete nucleotide sequence of the 3369 bp insert. The sequence contains 12 elements which bear a significant resemblance to accepted consensus sequences for Alu repetitive elements. The right hand end contains adjacent elements with close sequence similarity to portions of the human and hamster type I and type II Alu consensus sequences. All of the other Alu-related elements have diverged relative to the Alu consensus sequences by additions, long deletions and substitutions. The left hand portion of the insert which has the antigen-producing activity contains four of these diverged elements representing a relatively high proportion (26%) of the nucleotide sequence. The sequence is thus consistent with our previous observations of a repetitive family with biological function.     

A dimorphic Alu Sb-like insertion in COL3A1 is ethnic-specific

Alu elements are a class of repetitive DNA sequences found throughout the human genome that are thought to be duplicated via an RNA intermediate in a process termed retroposition. Recently inserted Alu elements are closely related, suggesting that they are derived from a single source gene or closely related source genes. Analysis of the type III collagen gene (COL3A1) revealed a polymorphic Alu insertion in intron 8 of the gene. The Alu insertion in the COL3A1 gene had a high degree of nucleotide identity to the Sb family of Alu elements, a family of older Alu elements. The Alu sequence was less similar to the consensus sequence for the PV or Sb2 subfamilies, subfamilies of recently inserted Alu elements. These data support the observations that at least three source genes are active in the human genome, one of which is distinct from the PV and Sb2 subfamilies and predates either of these two subfamilies. Appearance of the Alu insertion in different ethnic populations suggests that the insertion may have occurred in the last 100,000 years. This Alu insert should be a useful marker for population studies and for marking COL3A1 alleles.     

The beta globin gene cluster of the prosimian primate Galago crassicaudatus: nucleotide sequence determination of the 41-kb cluster and comparative sequence analyses.

The nucleotide sequence of the beta globin gene cluster of the prosimian Galago crassicaudatus has been determined. A total sequence spanning 41,101 bp contains and links together previously published sequences of the five galago beta-like globin genes (5'-epsilon-gamma-psi eta-delta-beta-3'). A computer-aided search for middle interspersed repetitive sequences identified 10 LINE (L1) elements, including a 5' truncated repeat that is orthologous to the full-length L1 element found in the human epsilon-gamma intergenic region. SINE elements that were identified included one Alu type I repeat, four Alu type II repeats, and two methionine tRNA-derived Monomer (type III) elements. Alu type II and Monomer sequences are unique to the galago genome. Structural analyses of the cluster sequence reveals that it is relatively A+T rich (about 62%) and regions with high G+C content are associated primarily with globin coding regions. Comparative analyses with the beta globin cluster sequences of human, rabbit, and mouse reveal extensive sequence homologies in their genic regions, but only human, galago, and rabbit sequences share extensive intergenic sequence homologies. Divergence analyses of aligned intergenic and flanking sequences from orthologous human, galago, and rabbit sequences show a gradation in the rate of nucleotide sequence evolution along the cluster where sequences 5' of the epsilon globin gene region show the least sequence divergence and sequences just 5' of the beta globin gene region show the greatest sequence divergence.     

Base sequence studies of 300 nucleotide renatured repeated human DNA clones

A band of 300 nucleotide long duplex DNA is released by treating renatured repeated human DNA with the single strand-specific endonuclease S₁. Since many of the interspersed repeated sequences in human DNA are 300 nucleotides long, this band should be enriched in such repeats. We have determined the nucleotide sequences of 15 clones constructed from these 300 nucleotide S₁-resistant repeats. Ten of these cloned sequences are members of the Alu family of interspersed repeats. These ten sequences share a recognizable consensus sequence from which individual clones have an average divergence of 12.8%. The 300 nucleotide Alu family consensus sequence has a dimeric structure and was evidently formed from a head to tail duplication of an ancestral monomeric sequence. Three of the remaining clones are variations on a simple pentanucleotide sequence previously reported for human satellite III DNA. Two of the 15 clones have distinct and complex sequences and may represent other families of interspersed repeated sequences.     

Evolution of Alu repeats surrounding the human ferredoxin gene

Ferredoxin is an iron-sulfur protein that serves as an electron carrier for the mitochondrial oxidation/reduction system. During the characterization of the human ferredoxin gene, we have identified three Alu sequences surrounding it. When these Alu sequences were compared with others, all three of them are more related to the consensus Alu than the 7SL gene, the progenitor of the Alu family. It suggests that they are members of the modern Alu family. Their sequences differ from the Alu consensus sequence by about 5%, indicating that they were inserted into the chromosome about 35 million years ago.     

Sequence of an expressed human beta-tubulin gene containing ten Alu family members

The complete sequence of a functionally expressed human beta-tubulin gene (5 beta) is presented. The amino acid sequence encoded by this gene constitutes a distinct isotype, differing from a previously described human beta-tubulin sequence at 21 positions throughout the polypeptide chain. The beta-tubulin coding sequence in 5 beta is interrupted by three intervening sequences of 1014, 117 and 4826 nucleotides. The largest of these contains ten members of the Alu family of middle repetitive sequences. Together, these regions account for sixty percent of this intervening sequence. Two of the Alu elements are juxtaposed head to tail, and share the same flanking direct repeat. The ten Alu sequences are substantially divergent, both from each other and from an Alu consensus sequence, and several contain deletions of up to half the entire sequence.     

Potential for retroposition by old Alu subfamilies

Alu elements sharing sequence characteristics of the old subfamilies are thought to currently be retrotranspositionally inactive. We analyzed one of these old subfamilies of Alu elements, Sx, for sequence conservation relative to the consensus and the length of the A-tail as parameters to define the presence of potential Alu Sx source genes in the human genome. Sequence identity to the left half or the right half of the Alu Sx consensus sequence was evaluated for 4424 complete elements obtained from the human genome draft sequence. A small subset of Alu Sx left halves were found to be more conserved than any of the Alu Sx right halves. Selection for promoter function in active elements may explain the slightly higher conservation of the left half. In order to determine whether this sequence identity was the result of recent activity, or simply sequence conservation for older elements, PCR amplification of some of the loci containing Sx elements with conserved left/right halves from different primate genomes was carried out. Several of these Sx Alus were found to have amplified at a later evolutionary period (<35 mya) than expected based on previous studies of Sx elements. Analysis of A-tail length, a feature correlated with current retroposition activity, varied between Alu Sx element loci in different primates, where the length increased in specific Alu elements in the human genome. The presence of few conserved Alu Sx elements and the dynamic expansion/contraction of the A-tail suggests that some of these older subfamilies may still be active at very low levels or in a few individuals. Present address: (Claudina Alemán Stevenson) Laboratory of Cell Biology, NCI/NIH Building 37/Rm 1A09, Bethesda, MD 20892, USA     

The Evolution of MHC Diversity by Segmental Duplication and Transposition of Retroelements

Sequence analysis of a 237 kb genomic fragment from the central region of the MHC has revealed that the HLA-B and HLA-C genes are contained within duplicated segments peri-B (53 kb) and peri-C (48 kb), respectively, and separated by an intervening sequence (IF) of 30 kb. The peri-B and peri-C segments share at least 90% sequence homology except when interrupted by insertions/deletions including Alu, L1, an endogenous retrovirus, and pseudogenes. The sequences of peri-B, IF, and peri-C were searched for the presence of Alu elements to use as markers of evolution, chromosomal rearrangements, and polymorphism. Of 29 Alu elements, 14 were identified in peri-B, 11 in peri-C, and 4 in IF. The Alu elements in peri-B and peri-C clustered phylogenetically into two clades which were classified as ``preduplication' and ``postduplication' clades. Four Alu J elements that are shared by peri-B and peri-C and are flanked by homologous sequences in their paralogous locations, respectively, clustered into a ``preduplication' clade. By contrast, the majority of Alu elements, which are unique to either peri-B or peri-C, clustered into a postduplication clade together with the Alu consensus subfamily members ranging from platyrrhine-specific (Spqxcg) to catarrhine-specific Alu sequences (Y). The insertion of platyrrhine-specific Alu elements in postduplication locations of peri-B and peri-C implies that these two segments are the products of a duplication which occurred in primates prior to the divergence of the New World primate from the human lineage (35–44 mya). Examination of the paralogous Alu integration sites revealed that 9 of 14 postduplication Alu sequences have produced microsatellites of different length and sequence within the Alu 3′-poly A tail. The present analysis supports the hypothesis that HLA-B and HLA-C genes are products of an extended segmental duplication between 44 and 81 million years ago (mya), and that subsequent diversification of both genomic segments occurred because of the mobility and mutation of retroelements such as Alu repeats. Received: 21 May 1997 / Accepted: 9 July 1997     

The potential role of Alu Y in the development of resistance to SN38 (Irinotecan) or oxaliplatin in colorectal cancer

Background

Irinotecan (SN38) and oxaliplatin are chemotherapeutic agents used in the treatment of colorectal cancer. However, the frequent development of resistance to these drugs represents a considerable challenge in the clinic. Alus as retrotransposons comprise 11% of the human genome. Genomic toxicity induced by carcinogens or drugs can reactivate Alus by altering DNA methylation. Whether or not reactivation of Alus occurs in SN38 and oxaliplatin resistance remains unknown.

Results

We applied reduced representation bisulfite sequencing (RRBS) to investigate the DNA methylome in SN38 or oxaliplatin resistant colorectal cancer cell line models. Moreover, we extended the RRBS analysis to tumor tissue from 14 patients with colorectal cancer who either did or did not benefit from capecitabine + oxaliplatin treatment. For the clinical samples, we applied a concept of ‘DNA methylation entropy’ to estimate the diversity of DNA methylation states of the identified resistance phenotype-associated methylation loci observed in the cell line models. We identified different loci being characteristic for the different resistant cell lines. Interestingly, 53% of the identified loci were Alu sequences- especially the Alu Y subfamily. Furthermore, we identified an enrichment of Alu Y sequences that likely results from increased integration of new copies of Alu Y sequence in the drug-resistant cell lines. In the clinical samples, SOX1 and other SOX gene family members were shown to display variable DNA methylation states in their gene regions. The Alu Y sequences showed remarkable variation in DNA methylation states across the clinical samples.

Conclusion

Our findings imply a crucial role of Alu Y in colorectal cancer drug resistance. Our study underscores the complexity of colorectal cancer aggravated by mobility of Alu elements and stresses the importance of personalized strategies, using a systematic and dynamic view, for effective cancer therapy.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12864-015-1552-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Chromosome-specific subsets of human alpha satellite DNA: Analysis of sequence divergence within and between chromosomal subsets and evidence for an ancestral pentameric repeat

Summary The centromeric regions of human chromosomes are characterized by diverged chromosome-specific subsets of a tandemly repeated DNA family, alpha satellite, which is based on a fundamental monomer repeat unit 171 bp in length. We have compared the nucleotide sequences of 44 alphoid monomers derived from cloned representatives of the multimeric higher-order repeat units of human chromosomes 1, 11, 17, and X. The 44 monomers exhibit an average 16% divergence from a consensus alphoid sequence, and can be assigned to five distinct homology groups based on patterns of sequence substitutions and gaps relative to the consensus. Approximately half of the overall sequence divergence can be accounted for by sequence changes specific to a particular homology group; the remaining divergence appears to be independent of the five groups and is randomly distributed, both within and between chromosomal subsets. The data are consistent with the proposal that the contemporary tandem arrays on chromosomes 1, 11, 17, and X derive from a common multimeric repeat, consisting of one monomer each from the five homology groups. The sequence comparisons suggest that this pentameric repeat must have spread to these four chromosomal locations many millions of years ago, since which time evolution of the four, now chromosome-specific, alpha satellite subsets has been essentially independent.     

Association of some potential hormone response elements in human genes with the Alu family repeats.

Short interspersed repeats of the Alu family located in promoters of some human genes contain high-affinity binding sites for thyroid hormone receptor, retinoic acid receptor and estrogen receptor. The standard binding sites for the receptors represent variants of duplicated AGGTCA motif with different spacing and orientation (direct, DR, or inverted, IR), and Alu sequences were found to have functional DR-4, DR-2 or variant IR-3/IR-17 elements. In this study we analyzed distribution and abundance of the elements in a set of human genomic sequences from GenBank and their association with Alu repeats. Our results indicate that a major fraction of potentially active DR-4, DR-2 and variant IR-3/IR-17 elements in the genes is located within Alu repeats. Alu-associated DR-2 elements are conserved in primate evolution. However, very few Alu have potential DR-3 glucocorticoid-response elements. Gel-shift experiments with the probe (AUB) corresponding to the consensus Alu sequence just upstream of the RNA polymerase III promoter B-box and containing duplicated AGGTCA motif indicate that the probe interacts in a sequence-specific manner with human nuclear proteins which bind to standard IR-0, DR-1, DR-4 or DR-5 elements. The AUB sequence was also able to promote thyroid hormone-dependent trans-activation of a reporter gene. The results support the view that Alu retroposons played an important role in evolution of regulation of the primate gene expression by nuclear hormone receptors.     

Monophyletic Origin of Alu Elements in Primates

To get insight into the early evolution of the primate Alu elements, we characterized sequences of these repeats from the Malagasy prosimians, lemurs (Lemuridae) and sifakas (Indriidae), as well as from galagos (Lorisidae). These sequences were compared with the oldest Alu species known from the human genome: dimeric Alu J and S and free Alu monomers. Our analysis indicates that about 60 Myr ago, before the prosimian divergence, free left and right monomers formed an Alu heterodimer connected by a 19-nucleotide-long A-rich linker. The resulting elements successfully propagated in diverging primate lineages until about ∼20 Myr ago, conserving similar sequence features and essentially the same Alu RNA secondary structure. We suggest that until that time the same ``retropositional niche', molecular machinery making possible the proliferation by retroposition, constrained the evolution of Alu elements in extant primate species. These constraints became subsequently relaxed. In the Malagasy prosimians the dimeric Alu continued to amplify after acquiring a 34- to 36-nucleotide extension of their linker segment, whereas in the galago genome the ``retropositional niche' was occupied by novel short elements. Received: 1 December 1997 / Accepted: 30 January 1998