Latent a1 VH germline genes in an a2a2 rabbit. Evidence for gene conversion at both the germline and somatic levels

We have previously reported the sequences of putative latent a1 cDNA derived from an alpha 2 alpha 2 rabbit. Significant similarity to nominal a1 cDNA sequences was noted, but none of the latent sequences were completely a1-like. We have now probed a genomic library, produced from the same alpha 2 alpha 2 rabbit, for evidence of germline latent a1 VH genes. Four hundred ninety-four VH+ clones were screened with oligonucleotides specific for a1 diagnostic regions of framework region 1 (FR1) and FR3. Twenty-two percent of the VH+ clones hybridized with an a1FR3 oligonucleotide probe. Two a1 FR1 probes yielded weak signals with 6% to 13% of the VH+ clones. Twenty VH genes from clones positive for one or more of the a1-specific oligonucleotide probes were sequenced, revealing 14 unique germline VH genes. All but one of these genes were 85% to 92% identical to the VH1-a1 nominal gene prototype, with sequence identity extending into the leader intron. Most genes displayed extended regions of similarity to a1 in FR1, FR3, or both and expressed 13 to 17 of the 21 allotype-associated residues, consistent with the nominal a1 sequence. The a1-like sequences were variously interspersed with short non-a1 segments, suggestive of germline gene conversion. Although none of the germline a1-like VH genes we have isolated from the alpha 2 alpha 2 rabbits are identical to the known a1 genes or protein sequences from alpha 1 alpha 1 rabbits and 8 of 14 are pseudogenes, most could make significant contributions to the synthesis of a complete nominal a1 sequence by serving as a pool of sequence donors during somatic gene conversion.     

Identification of rabbit genomic Ig-VH pseudogenes that could serve as donor sequences for latent allotype expression

Synthetic DNA oligomers specific for the VHa allotypes of rabbit Ig genes have been used to identify latent allotypic sequences in homozygous a1 and a2 rabbits. Two Ig VH pseudogenes containing latent a3 regions have been cloned from the genome of a homozygous a2 rabbit. Analysis of the regions associated with allotype expression indicates that these two pseudogenes contain VHa- sequences in framework region 1 (FR1) and VHa3 sequences in FR3. One gene has undergone an unusual rearrangement with a third VH gene, deleting their intervening sequences and recombining in FR3 with sequences 5' to the leader exon. Our results demonstrate the presence of latent VH sequences in the genomic DNA of normal rabbits and suggest that a mechanism such as gene conversion is responsible for expression of genetically-unexpected Ig VH genes.     

VDJ genes in VHa2 allotype-suppressed rabbits. Limited germline VH gene usage and accumulation of somatic mutations in D regions

In this study we investigate the molecular genetic basis for VHa- Ig. Knowing that the expression of VHa allotype Ig is suppressed by neonatal injection of rabbits with anti-VHa allotype antibody, and that the decreased level of VHa allotype Ig, VHa+, in the suppressed rabbits is compensated for by an increase in VHa- Ig, we determined the nucleotide sequences of 41 VDJ genes from a2/a2 rabbits neonatally suppressed for the expression of a2 Ig. We compared these nucleotide sequences to each other and identified two groups of VH sequences. We predict that the molecules of each group are encoded by one germline VH gene. Inasmuch as VHa+ Ig is encoded predominantly by one germline VH gene, VH1, it appears that more than 95% of the VDJ repertoire of rabbits may be encoded by as few as three germline VH genes. A genomic VDJ gene whose VH sequence was similar to those of group I molecules was expressed in vitro and was shown by ELISA to encode molecules of the VHa- allotype, y33. Analysis of the D regions in the VDJ gene indicated that germline D2b and D3 gene segments were preferentially used in the VDJ gene rearrangement. A comparison of sequences of D regions of the 41 VDJ gene rearrangements in 3-, 6-, and 9-wk-old rabbits to sequences of germline D gene segments showed an accumulation of mutations in the D region. Inasmuch as we have previously shown that V regions of rabbit VDJ genes are diversified, in part, by somatic gene conversion, it appears now that rabbit VDJ genes diversify by a combination of somatic mutation and somatic gene conversion.     

Germline VH genes in an a3 rabbit not typical of any one VHa allotype

We have undertaken investigations in the rabbit of VH genes that may be responsible for the observations of VHa allotypes unexpected from an animal's pedigree (latent allotypes). A short cDNA probe was prepared and shown to be specific for VHa2 mRNA. Southern analyses with short and large probes were unrevealing but screening of a lambda phage library from a VHa3-expressing animal identified a number of unusual genes. These VH genes are remarkable in that they are far closer to one another in the genome (in one case 3085 bps) than VH genes reported in mouse or man, they are highly homologous over long stretches of sequence, and they encode proteins not typical of any one VHa allotype. Proteins similar to the sort encoded by these genomic V-regions may explain some of the observations of latent allotype. Our data suggest that the allelic behavior of VHa allotypes is not due to allelism of a regulatory mechanism that acts upon identical VH genes in rabbits of different VHa phenotypes.     

Partial molecular genetic map of the rabbit VH chromosomal region

Thirty VH-containing cosmid clones, isolated from rabbit germ-line DNA libraries, were restriction mapped and shown to contain approximately 100 VH genes in 765-kb of DNA. Twenty-two of the cosmid clones were grouped into seven distinct clusters. The VH genes were separated by an average of 8 kb, although some were separated by less than 3 kb. Comparison of the nucleotide sequences of two of these VH genes with the sequences of another 11 VH genes showed that they were all generally more than 80% homologous suggesting that rabbit VH genes are members of one highly homologous gene family. Most rabbit Ig molecules have the VH allotypic specificities a1, a2, or a3 and are designated VHa-positive. A small number (less than 30%) of Ig molecules lack these VHa allotypic specificities and are designated VHa-negative. The VH containing cosmid clones were hybridized with synthetic oligomer probes designed to be specific for genes encoding VHa-positive or VHa-negative molecules. At least 50% of the germ-line VH genes hybridized with the VHa-negative oligomer and thus presumably encode VHa-negative molecules; as few as 15% of the genes could be identified as encoding VHa-positive molecules based on hybridization with the VHa-positive oligomer. Approximately 35% of the VH genes did not hybridize with either oligomer and could not be classified as VHa-negative or VHa-positive. We propose that the predominance of serum VHa-positive molecules, in contrast to the predominance of VHa-negative encoding germ-line genes, may reflect preferential usage of a few germline VH genes. The implications of this idea toward explaining the allelic inheritance of VHa allotypes are discussed.     

B lymphocyte selection and age-related changes in VH gene usage in mutant Alicia rabbits.

Young Alicia rabbits use VHa-negative genes, VHx and VHy, in most VDJ genes, and their serum Ig is VHa negative. However, as Alicia rabbits age, VHa2 allotype Ig is produced at high levels. We investigated which VH gene segments are used in the VDJ genes of a2 Ig-secreting hybridomas and of a2 Ig+ B cells from adult Alicia rabbits. We found that 21 of the 25 VDJ genes used the a2-encoding genes, VH4 or VH7; the other four VDJ genes used four unknown VH gene segments. Because VH4 and VH7 are rarely found in VDJ genes of normal or young Alicia rabbits, we investigated the timing of rearrangement of these genes in Alicia rabbits. During fetal development, VH4 was used in 60-80% of nonproductively rearranged VDJ genes, and VHx and VHy together were used in 10-26%. These data indicate that during B lymphopoiesis VH4 is preferentially rearranged. However, the percentage of productive VHx- and VHy-utilizing VDJ genes increased from 38% at day 21 of gestation to 89% at birth (gestation day 31), whereas the percentage of VH4-utilizing VDJ genes remained at 15%. These data suggest that during fetal development, either VH4-utilizing B-lineage cells are selectively eliminated, or B cells with VHx- and VHy-utilizing VDJ genes are selectively expanded, or both. The accumulation of peripheral VH4-utilizing a2 B cells with age indicates that these B cells might be selectively expanded in the periphery. We discuss the possible selection mechanisms that regulate VH gene segment usage in rabbit B cells during lymphopoiesis and in the periphery.     

Dynamic gene interactions in the evolution of rabbit VH genes: a four codon duplication and block homologies provide evidence for intergenic exchange.

Two rabbit VHa-negative genes, RVH831 and RVH832, were isolated from a single genomic fragment selected by hybridization with the mouse VHIII gene S107V1. RVH831 is a pseudogene with a frameshift mutation in FR3 and a 19 bp deletion within the VH-D splice site. In contrast, RVH832 has an open reading frame and an intact VH-D splice site and thus may be functional. However, RVH832 displays a unique 4 codon duplication/insertion in FR1 that may be the result of an unequal exchange event between two ancestral VH genes. Sequence comparisons between these and other rabbit VH genes reveal patterns of shared blocks of nucleotide substitutions, suggestive of gene conversion. A high overall homology (greater than or equal to 73%) between the compared VH nucleotide sequences suggests that rabbit VH genes may not be organized in clearly divergent families or subgroups.     

Molecular basis of the allelic inheritance of rabbit immunoglobulin VH allotypes: implications for the generation of antibody diversity

Rabbits are unique in that their immunoglobulin VH regions bear allotypic markers encoded by allelic genes. The presence of these markers on most serum immunoglobulins is difficult to explain, as the germline contains several hundred VH genes. We cloned VH genes from normal rabbits of the VHa allotypes a1, a2, and a3 and from a mutant a2 rabbit, Alicia, which expresses almost no a2 allotype. The D-proximal VH gene VH1 of normal rabbits encoded prototype a1, a2, or a3 allotype VH regions in a1, a2, or a3 rabbits, respectively; VH1 was shown to be preferentially utilized in leukemic rabbit B cells. This VH1 gene was deleted from the germline of the Alicia rabbit. These data suggest that the allelic inheritance of a allotypes results from preferential utilization of VH1 in VDJ rearrangements. We suggest that antibody diversity in rabbit primarily results from somatic hypermutation and gene conversion.     

Nucleotide sequence of a rabbit IgG heavy chain from the recombinant F-I haplotype

We report the sequence of a cDNA encoding a rabbit immunoglobulin gamma heavy chain of d12 and e14 allotypes with high homology to partial cDNA sequences from rabbits of d11 and e15 allotypes. The encoded rabbit protein shows homologies with human (68-70%) and mouse (60-63%) gamma chains. The nucleotide sequence homologies of the CH domains range from 76-84% with human and 64-76% with mouse sequences. Comparison of the portion of VH encoding amino acid positions 34-112 with a previously determined VH sequence of the same allotype shows high conservation of sequences in the second and third framework segments but more marked differences both in length and encoded amino acids of the second and third complementarity-determining regions (CDRs). We also found a high degree of homology with a human genomic V-region, VH26 (77%) and a remarkable similarity between rabbit and human second CDR sequences and human genomic D minigenes. These results provide additional evidence that D minigene sequences share information with the CDR2 portion of VH regions.     

Nucleotide sequence of a cDNA clone encoding a rabbit immunoglobulin-lambda light chain: the V lambda region differs markedly from that of other species

A cDNA clone (pDH7) has been isolated which encodes the entire leader peptide and variable (V) region and most of the constant (C) region of a rabbit lambda-light chain. Although similar to amino acid sequences derived from fragments of isolated lambda-chains from several Basilea rabbits, differences in the first framework region (FR1) suggest that at least two germ-line V lambda genes are expressed. There are major differences between rabbit V lambda sequences and light chains of other species: in particular, rabbit lambda-chains have an additional four amino acids in the vicinity of the FR2-CDR2 junction. The same region also has significant homology with the human D2 germ-line mini-gene sequence, especially with a 14-nucleotide sequence previously shown to be homologous to human and rabbit heavy chain CDR2 sequences. Similar homologies in other heavy and light chain sequences suggest that D-gene segments may be derived from VH genes, perhaps by transposition. The framework regions of the rabbit lambda-chain encoded by clone pDH7 show the greatest homologies with those of human kappa- and lambda-sequences (46 to 54% homology), with that of chicken sequence (55%), and least with murine V lambda sequences (40%).     

In vivo activation of quiescent B cells by anti-immunoglobulin. I. Induction of latent VH allotype production in adult rabbits by treatment with heterologous antibodies or antibody fragments

We demonstrated previously that injection of adult rabbits with homologous anti-VHa1 allotype antibody induces the appearance in serum of genetically unexpected (latent) a1 immunoglobulin (Ig) and a1-like internal images. We have now investigated the mechanism for this induction effect and have found that treatment of animals with polyclonal goat or monoclonal mouse anti-a1 antibody similarly results in production of unexpected a1 determinants. The N-terminal amino acid sequences of deblocked heavy chains showed that latent a1 Ig induced by monoclonal antibody treatment was identical to nominal a1 Ig at 18 of 19 residues, with the one amino acid difference at position 13 probably due to a single nucleotide change. Like nominal a1, these molecules expressed multiple VHa1 framework epitopes, as demonstrated by direct immunoelectron microscopic visualization of immune complexes. Whereas F(ab)'2 fragments of rabbit anti-a1 antibody retained inducing activity, F(ab) fragments were effective only when administered in an aggregated form; this result suggests that cross-linking of surface Ig receptors plays a critical role in the induction process. We conclude that all rabbits contain dormant B cells expressing germ-line-encoded latent allotypes, and that in vivo administration of anti-Ig antibody causes activation of these cells directly rather than through perturbation of an allotype regulatory network.     

Rearrangement of VHa1-encoding Ig gene segment to the a2 chromosome in an a1/a2 heterozygous rabbit. Evidence for trans recombination

VDJ genes were cloned from leukemic B cells of an a1/a2 heterozygous Emu-cmyc transgenic rabbit. Restriction mapping and nucleotide sequence analysis indicated that one clone, 5C3, had a VHa1-encoding gene segment functionally rearranged to a JH gene segment from the a2 chromosome. This VDJ gene may be the result of a trans recombination between a VH gene on the a1 chromosome and a JH gene segment on the a2 chromosome or, it may be the result of a cis recombination if the a2 chromosome contains VHa1-encoding gene segments.     

Complex allotypes of the rabbit immunoglobulin kappa light chains are encoded by structural alleles.

We have isolated the rabbit immunoglobulin b9 Ck light chain gene and compared its nucleotide sequence with the b4, b4var , b5 and bas Ck sequences. In spite of the high number of substitutions found between the different rabbit Ck coding regions, only very few changes are silent. Furthermore, the nucleotide changes are clustered in segments which correlate with the bends and helical regions found in the tertiary structure of the Ck domain of the protein. The flanking regions present a higher degree of conservation than the coding regions. The two genomic EcoRI fragments hybridizing to a b4cDNA probe have been correlated with the two distinct loci, Ck1 and Ck2 : one encodes for the nominal b9 Ck allotype and the other contains the information for the bas Ck region. The b allotypes are true alleles which could have evolved by intergenic conversion.     

Organization of rabbit immunoglobulin genes. I. Structure and multiplicity of germ-line VH genes

Two rabbit germ-line VH gene segments have been isolated from a recombinant phage DNA library. Nucleotide sequence analysis indicates that both of the genes share structural and regulatory features common to mouse and human VH genes, although one appears to be a pseudogene. Comparison of the protein sequences encoded by these genes to the protein sequences of rabbit immunoglobulin V regions indicates that both genes encode VH a-negative-like molecules. Quantitative genomic blot analysis with a VH probe capable of recognizing most, if not all, germ-line VH genes indicates that there are approximately 100 VH genes in the haploid genome of rabbits. The average spacing between the germ-line VH genes was determined to be approximately 6 kb. The molecular basis for the allelic inheritance of rabbit VH allotypes is discussed in view of the structural organization of germ-line VH genes.     

Restricted utilization of germ-line VH genes and diversity of D regions in rabbit splenic Ig mRNA

Previous studies have suggested that the majority of rabbit germ-line VH genes encode molecules that are rarely found in serum or secretory Ig. To examine the repertoire of expressed VH genes, we prepared a cDNA library from splenic mRNA of an alpha 1/alpha 1 rabbit and isolated 10 complete VH-encoding cDNA clones. None of the cDNA clones hybridized to an oligomer that had hybridized to more than 50% of cloned germ-line VH genes. These data indicate that only a subset of germ-line VH genes are used in functional VDJ rearrangements. DNA sequence analysis demonstrated that the 10 cDNA clones contained highly similar VH regions, further suggesting that the repertoire of utilized VH genes is limited. In contrast, the D regions of each of the 10 clones exhibited little similarity to one another, suggesting that the rabbit has a large D region repertoire. We propose that the apparent lack of diversity within the VH segment of VDJ rearrangements is offset by extensive D region diversity.     

Heavy chain variable region gene families evolved early in phylogeny. Ig complexity in fish

The V regions of channel catfish H chain cDNA clones have been analyzed. Based upon sequence relationships and hybridization analyses, five different groups of VH genes are identified whose definition is consistent with that of five different VH families. Genomic Southern blots indicate that as many as 100 different germ-line VH genes are likely represented by these families. The sequence diversity between identified members of these different families is similar in magnitude to the divergence represented between members of different human or mouse VH families. The FR regions are the most conserved regions when members of different catfish VH families are compared; specific amino acid positions appear to be highly conserved in phylogeny. Equally important is that diversity is represented in complementarity-determining regions CDR1 and CDR2 in members of the different families as well as in members of the same VH family. These results suggest that an extensive repertoire of VH genes can contribute to antibody diversity in this lower vertebrate. Sequence comparisons indicate that one of the catfish VH families shares considerable structural similarity to several higher vertebrate VH gene families--a relationship which suggests that this VH family may be ancestral to some VH gene families of higher vertebrates. Characteristic of the genomic organization of higher vertebrate H chains, catfish appear to have different VH families wherein a VH gene likely undergoes functional recombination with putative DH gene segments and one of apparently several different JH segments. The recombined V region is expressed with the same C region gene. These combined results suggest that bony fishes are the earliest known phylogenetic representatives to have evolved extensive V region gene families.     

Organization and evolution of variable region genes of the human immunoglobulin heavy chain

We have isolated 23 different cosmid clones of the heavy-chain variable region genes (VH) of human immunoglobulin. These clones encompass about 1000 X 10(3) base-pairs of DNA containing 61 VH genes. Characterization of the 23 clones by Southern blot hybridization showed that VH genes belonging to different families were physically linked in many regions. Cluster 71, which was analyzed in detail, comprised seven VH segments arranged in the same orientation with different intervals. This clone contained internal homology regions, each carrying two VH segments of different families. Comparison of the nucleotide sequences of VH segments within each family showed that profiles of accumulation of mutations in framework (FR) and complementarity-determining (CDR) regions were different. CDR had more mutations at amino-acid-substituting positions than at silent positions, whereas FR had the reverse distribution of mutations. Five out of seven VH segments of this cluster were pseudogenes containing various mutations. VH pseudogenes were classified into two distinct groups; one with a few replacement mutations (conserved pseudogenes), and the other with rather extensive mutations (diverged pseudogenes). The possibility that conserved pseudogenes serve as a reservoir of VH segments is discussed.     

Relationship of human variable region heavy chain germ-line genes to genes encoding anti-DNA autoantibodies

In order to identify the V region genes encoding systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE)-derived anti-DNA autoantibodies, we have determined the nucleotide sequence of heavy chain mRNA from several DNA-binding immunoglobulins secreted by human hybridomas. We used the technique of cDNA primer extension for determining sequences of the VH, D, and JH gene segments of anti-DNA autoantibodies from three different primary hybridoma growths from an SLE patient and one hybridoma from a leprosy patient. Immunoglobulins from two of the SLE hybridomas expressed the same idiotype, Id-16/6, which is also expressed on immunoglobulins in sera of patients with active SLE. Their mRNA sequences showed complete homology to each other in the V, D, and J genes and more than 99% homology to the VH26 germ-line gene sequence, a member of the human VHIII gene family. The VH mRNA sequence of the third SLE hybridoma, 21/28, which was idiotypically unrelated to the other two, was 93% homologous to a different VH germ-line gene sequence, HA2, a member of the human VHI gene family. The fourth anti-DNA-producing hybridoma, 8E10, was derived from a leprosy patient of different ethnic origin than the SLE patient. It was idiotypically related to 21/28 and expressed a VH segment gene identical to that of 21/28. Hybridomas 21/28 and 8E10 shared sequence homology with the VH26 anti-DNA antibodies in the first complementarity-determining region. In addition, 21/28 shared sequence homology with the Id-16/6+ group in the region encoded by the D and J gene segments. Our findings indicate that some SLE autoantibodies are encoded by unmodified or scarcely modified VH germ-line genes that are conserved in the human population and identify two distinct VH germ-line genes that can encode segments of anti-DNA immunoglobulins.