Structural Plasticity and Rapid Evolution in a Viral RNA Revealed by In Vivo Genetic Selection

Satellite RNAs usually lack substantial homology with their helper viruses. The 356-nucleotide satC of Turnip crinkle virus (TCV) is unusual in that its 3′-half shares high sequence similarity with the TCV 3′ end. Computer modeling, structure probing, and/or compensatory mutagenesis identified four hairpins and three pseudoknots in this TCV region that participate in replication and/or translation. Two hairpins and two pseudoknots have been confirmed as important for satC replication. One portion of the related 3′ end of satC that remains poorly characterized corresponds to juxtaposed TCV hairpins H4a and H4b and pseudoknot ψ₃, which are required for the TCV-specific requirement of translation (V. A. Stupina et al., RNA 14:2379-2393, 2008). Replacement of satC H4a with randomized sequence and scoring for fitness in plants by in vivo genetic selection (SELEX) resulted in winning sequences that contain an H4a-like stem-loop, which can have additional upstream sequence composing a portion of the stem. SELEX of the combined H4a and H4b region in satC generated three distinct groups of winning sequences. One group models into two stem-loops similar to H4a and H4b of TCV. However, the selected sequences in the other two groups model into single hairpins. Evolution of these single-hairpin SELEX winners in plants resulted in satC that can accumulate to wild-type (wt) levels in protoplasts but remain less fit in planta when competed against wt satC. These data indicate that two highly distinct RNA conformations in the H4a and H4b region can mediate satC fitness in protoplasts.     

Fitness of a turnip crinkle virus satellite RNA correlates with a sequence-nonspecific hairpin and flanking sequences that enhance replication and repress the accumulation of virions

satC, a satellite RNA associated with Turnip crinkle virus (TCV), enhances the ability of the virus to colonize plants by interfering with stable virion accumulation (F. Zhang and A. E. Simon, unpublished data). Previous results suggested that the motif1-hairpin (M1H), a replication enhancer on minus strands, forms a plus-strand hairpin flanked by CA-rich sequence that may be involved in enhancing systemic infection (G. Zhang and A. E. Simon, J. Mol. Biol. 326:35-48, 2003). In this study, sequence and structural requirements of the M1H were further assayed by replacing the 28-base M1H with 10 random bases and then subjecting the pool of satellite RNA to functional selection in plants. Unlike previous results with 28-base replacement sequences (G. Zhang and A. E. Simon, J. Mol. Biol. 326:35-48, 2003), only a few of the 10-base SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) assay winners contained short motifs in their minus-sense orientation that were similar to TCV replication elements. However, all second- and third-round winning replacement sequences folded into hairpins flanked by CA-rich sequence predicted to be more stable on plus strands than minus strands. Plus strands of several of the most fit satellite RNAs contained insertions of CA-rich sequence at the base of their hairpins whose presence correlated with enhanced replication and reduced detection of virions. Deletion of the M1H resulted in no detectable virions despite very low satellite accumulation. These results support the hypothesis that a sequence-nonspecific plus-strand hairpin brings together flanking CA-rich sequences in the M1H region that confers fitness to satC by reducing the accumulation of stable virions.     

Isolation of an Arabidopsis thaliana Mutant in Which the Multiplication of both Cucumber Mosaic Virus and Turnip Crinkle Virus Is Affected

During the systemic infection of plants by viruses, host factors play an important role in supporting virus multiplication. To identify and characterize the host factors involved in this process, we isolated an Arabidopsis thaliana mutant named RB663, in which accumulation of the coat protein (CP) of cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) in upper uninoculated leaves was delayed. Genetic analyses suggested that the phenotype of delayed accumulation of CMV CP in RB663 plants was controlled by a monogenic, recessive mutation designated cum2-1, which is located on chromosome III and is distinct from the previously characterized cum1 mutation. Multiplication of CMV was delayed in inoculated leaves of RB663 plants, whereas the multiplication in RB663 protoplasts was similar to that in wild-type protoplasts. This suggests that the cum2-1 mutation affects the cell-to-cell movement of CMV rather than CMV replication within a single cell. In RB663 plants, the multiplication of turnip crinkle virus (TCV) was also delayed but that of tobacco mosaic virus was not affected. As observed with CMV, the multiplication of TCV was normal in protoplasts and delayed in inoculated leaves of RB663 plants compared to that in wild-type plants. Furthermore, the phenotype of delayed TCV multiplication cosegregated with the cum2-1 mutation as far as we examined. Therefore, the cum2-1 mutation is likely to affect the cell-to-cell movement of both CMV and TCV, implying a common aspect to the mechanisms of cell-to-cell movement in these two distinct viruses.     

The relative contribution of adduct blockage and DNA repair on template utilization during replication of 1,N2-propanodeoxyguanosine and pyrimido

The role of replication blockage by the exocyclic DNA adducts propanodeoxyguanosine (PdG) and pyrimido[1,2-alpha]purin-10(3H)-one (M1G) was determined through the use of site-specifically adducted M13MB102 genomes containing a C:C-mismatch approximately 3000 base-pairs from the site of adduct incorporation. Genomes containing either dG, PdG, or M1G positioned at site 6256 of the (-)-strand were transformed into repair-proficient and repair-deficient Escherichia coli strains and the percent template utilization was determined by hybridization analysis. Unmodified genomes containing a C:C-mismatch resulted in a percent template utilization of approximately 60 and 40% for the (-)- and (+)-strands, respectively. Transformation of PdG- or M(1)G-adducted genomes resulted in approximately a 60-40% and 50-50% (-)-strand to (+)-strand ratio, respectively, indicating that PdG and M(1)G are negligible blocks to replication in repair-proficient E. coli. This is in contrast to previous studies using (PdG:T)- and (M1G:T)-mismatched M13MB102 genomes, which resulted in a majority of the replication events using the unadducted (+)-strand and suggested that both adducts were significant blocks to replication [J. Biol. Chem. 272 (1997) 11434; Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 94 (1997) 8652]. The C:C-mismatch results, though, indicate that the large strand bias detected in the earlier studies is due to repair of the adducts and resynthesis of the (-)-strand using the (+)-strand as a template for repair synthesis. Transformation of adducted C:C-mismatched genomes into E. coli strains deficient in nucleotide excision repair did result in an increased strand bias with only approximately 20 and 34% of the replication events using the (-)-strand for PdG- and M1G-adducted genomes, respectively. The increased strand bias indicates the importance of nucleotide excision repair in the removal of PdG and M1G.     

Comparison of Turnip Crinkle Virus RNA-Dependent RNA Polymerase Preparations Expressed in Escherichia coli or Derived from Infected Plants

Turnip crinkle virus (TCV) is a small, plus-sense, single-stranded RNA virus of plants. A virus-coded protein, p88, which is required for replication has been expressed and purified from Escherichia coli. In vitro assays revealed that the recombinant p88 has an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) activity and can also bind to RNA. Deletion of the N-terminal region in p88 resulted in a more active RdRp, while further deletions abolished RdRp activity. Comparison of the E. coli-expressed p88, the N-terminal deletion mutant of p88, and a TCV RdRp preparation obtained from infected plants revealed that these preparations show remarkable similarities in RNA template recognition and usage. Both the recombinant and the plant TCV RdRp preparations are capable of de novo initiation on both plus- and minus-strand satC and satD templates, which are small parasitic RNAs associated with TCV infections. In addition, these RdRp preparations can efficiently recognize the related Tomato bushy stunt virus promoter sequences, including the minus- and plus-strand initiation promoters. Heterologous viral and artificial promoters are recognized poorly by the recombinant and the plant TCV RdRps. Further comparison of the single-component recombinant TCV RdRp and the multicomponent plant TCV RdRp will help dissect the functions of various components of the TCV replicase.     

Analysis of sequences and predicted structures required for viral satellite RNA accumulation by in vivo genetic selection.

In vivo genetic selection was used to study the sequences and structures required for accumulation of subviral sat-RNA C associated with turnip crinkle virus (TCV). This technique is advantageous over site-specific mutagenesis by allowing side-by-side selection from numerous sequence possibilities as well as sequence evolution. A 22 base hairpin and 6 base single-stranded tail located at the 3'-terminus of sat-RNA C were previously identified as the promoter for minus strand synthesis. Approximately 50% of plants co-inoculated with TCV and sat-RNA C containing randomized sequence in place of the 22 base hairpin accumulated sat-RNA in uninoculated leaves. The 22 base region differed in sat-RNA accumulating in all infected plants, but nearly all were predicted to fold into a hairpin structure that maintained the 6 base tail as a single-stranded sequence. Two additional rounds of sat-RNA amplification led to four sequence family 'winners', with three families containing multiple variants, indicating that evolution of these sequences was occurring in plants. Three of the four sequence family winners had the same 3 bp at the base of the stem as wild-type sat-RNA C. Two of the winners shared 15 of 22 identical bases, including the entire stem region and extending two bases into the loop. These results demonstrate the utility of the in vivo selection approach by showing that both sequence and structure contribute to a more active 3'-end region for accumulation of sat-RNA C.     

3'-End stem-loops of the subviral RNAs associated with turnip crinkle virus are involved in symptom modulation and coat protein binding

Many plant RNA viruses are associated with one or more subviral RNAs. Two subviral RNAs, satellite RNA C (satC) and defective interfering RNA G (diG) intensify the symptoms of their helper, turnip crinkle virus (TCV). However, when the coat protein (CP) of TCV was replaced with that of the related Cardamine chlorotic fleck virus (CCFV), both subviral RNAs attenuated symptoms of the hybrid virus TCV-CP(CCFV). In contrast, when the translation initiation codon of the TCV CP was altered to ACG and reduced levels of CP were synthesized, satC attenuated symptoms while diG neither intensified nor attenuated symptoms. The determinants for this differential symptom modulation were previously localized to the 3'-terminal 100 bases of the subviral RNAs, which contain six positional differences (Q. Kong, J.-W. Oh, C. D. Carpenter, and A. E. Simon, Virology 238:478-485, 1997). In the current study, we have determined that certain sequences within the 3'-terminal stem-loop structures of satC and diG, which also serve as promoters for complementary strand synthesis, are critical for symptom modulation. Furthermore, the ability to attenuate symptoms was correlated with weakened binding of TCV CP to the hairpin structure.     

Modulation of replication, aminoacylation and adenylation in vitro and infectivity in vivo of BMV RNAs containing deletions within the multifunctional 3'' end.

The genome of brome mosaic virus (BMV) is comprised of three (+) strand RNAs, each containing a similar, highly structured, 200 base long sequence at its 3' end. A 134 base subset of this sequence contains signals directing interaction of the viral RNA with BMV RNA replicase, ATP,CTP:tRNA nucleotidyl transferase and aminoacyl tRNA synthetase. A series of mutants containing deletions within this region, previously constructed and tested in vitro for the effect on replication and aminoacylation activities, has now been assayed in vitro for adenylation function and in vivo for ability to replicate in isolated protoplasts and whole plants. These tests indicate that features of viral RNA recognized by BMV replicase overlap those directing adenylation, but are distinct from those directing aminoacylation. Consequently, the lethality of a deletion preferentially inhibiting aminoacylation suggests that this function may have an essential role contributing to viral replication in vivo. An RNA3 mutant bearing a 20-base deletion yielding normal levels of aminoacylation and enhanced levels of replicase template activity and adenylation in vitro was able to replicate in protoplasts and plants; however, its accumulation in protoplasts was reduced relative to wild-type. This suggests that additional functions affecting the replication and accumulation of viral RNA reside in the conserved 3' sequence.     

An alfalfa mosaic virus RNA 2 mutant,which does not induce a hypersensitive reaction in cowpea plants,is multiplied to a high concentration in cowpea protoplasts

A mutant of alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV), which in contrast to wild type (wt) can invade cowpea plants systemically, is replicated more efficiently in cowpea protoplasts than the wt. Mutant preparations isolated from infected cowpea protoplasts contained a higher amount of middle component (M, containing RNA 2) than wt preparations. Both in cowpea plants and in cowpea protoplasts a wt phenotype is obtained upon addition of wt M to this mutant, suggesting a correlation between the type of plant reaction evoked by the virus infection and the regulation of viral RNA synthesis.     

Satellite RNA-mediated resistance to turnip crinkle virus in Arabidopsis involves a reduction in virus movement.

Satellite RNAs (sat-RNAs) are parasites of viruses that can mediate resistance to the helper virus. We previously showed that a sat-RNA (sat-RNA C) of turnip crinkle virus (TCV), which normally intensifies symptoms of TCV, is able to attenuate symptoms when TCV contains the coat protein (CP) of cardamine chlorotic fleck virus (TCV-CPCCFV). We have now determined that sat-RNA C also attenuates symptoms of TCV containing an alteration in the initiating AUG of the CP open reading frame (TCV-CPm). TCV-CPm, which is able to move systemically in both the TCV-susceptible ecotype Columbia (Col-0) and the TCV-resistant ecotype Dijon (Di-0), produced a reduced level of CP and no detectable virions in infected plants. Sat-RNA C reduced the accumulation of TCV-CPm by < 25% in protoplasts while reducing the level of TCV-CPm by 90 to 100% in uninoculated leaves of Col-0 and Di-0. Our results suggest that in the presence of a reduced level of a possibly altered CP, sat-RNA C reduces virus long-distance movement in a manner that is independent of the salicylic acid-dependent defense pathway.     

The SL1 stem-loop structure at the 5'-end of potato virus X RNA is required for efficient binding to host proteins and for viral infectivity

The 5'-region of Potato virus X (PVX) RNA, which contains an AC-rich, single-stranded region and stem-loop structure 1 (SL1), affects RNA replication and assembly. Using Systemic Evolution of Ligands by EXponential enrichment (SELEX) and the electrophoretic mobility shift assay, we demonstrate that SL1 interacts specifically with tobacco protoplast protein extracts (S100). The 36 nucleotides that correspond to the top region of SL1, which comprises stem C, loop C, stem D, and the tetra loop (TL), were randomized and bound to the S100. Remarkably, the wild-type (wt) sequence was selected in the second round, and the number of wt sequences increased as selection proceeded. All of the selected clones from the fifth round contained the wt sequence. Secondary structure predictions (mFOLD) of the recovered sequences revealed relatively stable stem-loop structures that resembled SL1, although the nucleotide sequences therein were different. Moreover, many of the clones selected in the fourth round conserved the TL and C-C mismatch, which suggests the importance of these elements in host protein binding. The SELEX clone that closely resembled the wt SL1 structure with the TL and C-C mismatch was able to replicate and cause systemic symptoms in plants, while most of the other winners replicated poorly only on inoculated leaves. The RNA replication level on protoplasts was also similarly affected. Taken together, these results indicate that the SL1 of PVX interacts with host protein(s) that play important roles related to virus replication.     

Allelic variation in the hepatitis C virus NS4B protein dramatically influences RNA replication

In the Huh-7.5 hepatoma cell line, replication of the genotype 1a H77 strain of hepatitis C virus (HCV) is attenuated compared to that of the genotype 1b Con1 strain. This study identifies the poorly characterized integral membrane protein, NS4B, as a major determinant for this replication difference. Chimeric H77 subgenomic replicons containing the entire NS4B gene from Con1 in place of the H77 NS4B sequence replicated approximately 10-fold better than the H77 parent and to levels similar to that of the adapted Con1 replicon. An intermediate level of replication enhancement was conferred by H77 chimeras containing the poorly conserved N-terminal 47 residues or the remaining less-divergent C terminus of Con1 NS4B. The replication-enhancing activity within the N terminus of NS4B was further mapped to two Con1-specific amino acids. Experiments to elucidate the mechanism of enhanced H77 replication revealed that Con1 NS4B primarily increased H77 RNA synthesis on a per cell basis, as indicated by the similar capacities of chimeric and parental replicons to establish replication in Huh-7.5 cells and the higher levels of both positive- and negative-strand RNAs for the chimeras than for the H77 parent. Additionally, enhanced H77 replication was not the result of Con1 NS4B-mediated effects on HCV translation efficiency or alterations in polyprotein processing. Expression of Con1 NS4B in trans did not improve the replication of the H77 parental replicon, suggesting a cis-dominant role for NS4B in HCV replication. These results provide the first evidence that allelic variation in the NS4B sequence between closely related isolates significantly impacts HCV replication in cell culture.     

An RNA domain within the 5' untranslated region of the tomato bushy stunt virus genome modulates viral RNA replication

The terminal half of the 5' untranslated region (UTR) in the (+)-strand RNA genome of tomato bushy stunt virus was analyzed for possible roles in viral RNA replication. Computer-aided thermodynamic analysis of secondary structure, phylogenetic comparisons for base-pair covariation, and chemical and enzymatic solution structure probing were used to analyze the 78 nucleotide long 5'-terminal sequence. The results indicate that this sequence adopts a branched secondary structure containing a three-helix junction core. The T-shaped domain (TSD) formed by this terminal sequence is closed by a prominent ten base-pair long helix, termed stem 1 (S1). Deletion of either the 5' or 3' segment forming S1 (coordinates 1-10 or 69-78, respectively) in a model subviral RNA replicon, i.e. a prototypical defective interfering (DI) RNA, reduced in vivo accumulation levels of this molecule approximately 20-fold. Compensatory-type mutational analysis of S1 within this replicon revealed a strong correlation between formation of the predicted S1 structure and efficient DI RNA accumulation. RNA decay studies in vivo did not reveal any notable changes in the physical stabilities of DI RNAs containing disrupted S1s, thus implicating RNA replication as the affected process. Further investigation revealed that destabilization of S1 in the (+)-strand was significantly more detrimental to DI RNA accumulation than (-)-strand destabilization, therefore S1-mediated activity likely functions primarily via the (+)-strand. The essential role of S1 in DI RNA accumulation prompted us to examine the 5'-proximal secondary structure of a previously identified mutant DI RNA, RNA B, that lacks the 5' UTR but is still capable of low levels of replication. Mutational analysis of a predicted S1-like element present within a cryptic 5'-terminal TSD confirmed the importance of the former in RNA B accumulation. Collectively, these data support a fundamental role for the TSD, and in particular its S1 subelement, in tombusvirus RNA replication.     

Turnip yellow mosaic virus RNAs with anticodon loop substitutions that result in decreased valylation fail to replicate efficiently.

Single and multiple nucleotide substitutions have been introduced into the anticodon loop of the tRNA-like structure of turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV) genomic RNA. We studied the effects of these mutations on in vitro valylation and on replication in Chinese cabbage protoplasts and plants. Only those mutants capable of efficient and complete valylation showed efficient replication in protoplasts and gave rise to systemic symptoms in whole plants. Mutants that accepted valine inefficiently (in some cases Vmax/Km values were less than 10(-3) relative to wild-type values) replicated to levels 200- to 500-fold below wild-type levels in protoplasts (estimated on the basis of coat protein and genomic RNA levels). These mutants could not support systemic spread in plants. In one plant inoculated with TYMC-A55 RNA, which replicates poorly in protoplasts, systemic symptoms developed after a delay. The reversion in replication was accompanied by improved valine acceptance and the appearance of a U57 second-site mutation. Our results indicate a correlation between valine acceptance activity and viral yield. Possible roles for valylation are discussed, and the results are compared with those of similar studies with brome mosaic virus which suggested that tyrosylation is not crucial for brome mosaic virus replication (T. W. Dreher, A. L. N. Rao, and T. C. Hall, J. Mol. Biol. 206:425-438, 1989).