The relationship of the superficial and deep facial fascias: relevance to rhytidectomy and aging.

Controversy persists regarding the relationship of the superficial facial fascia (SMAS) to the mimetic muscles, deep facial fascia, and underlying facial nerve branches. Using fresh cadaver dissection, and supplemented by several hundred intraoperative dissections, we studied facial soft-tissue anatomy. The facial soft-tissue architecture can be described as being arranged in a series of concentric layers: skin, subcutaneous fat, superficial fascia, mimetic muscle, deep facial fascia (parotidomasseteric fascia), and the plane containing the facial nerve, parotid duct, and buccal fat pad. The anatomic relationships existing within the facial soft-tissue layers are (1) the superficial facial fascia invests the superficially situated mimetic muscles (platysma, orbicularis oculi, and zygomaticus major and minor); (2) the deep facial fascia represents a continuation of the deep cervical fascia cephalad into the face, the importance of which lies in the fact that the facial nerve branches within the cheek lie deep to this deep fascial layer; and (3) two types of relationships exist between the superficial and deep facial fascias: In some regions of the face, these fascial planes are separated by an areolar plane, and in other regions of the face, the superficial and deep fascia are intimately adherent to one another through a series of dense fibrous attachments. The layers of the facial soft tissue are supported in normal anatomic position by a series of retaining ligaments that run from deep, fixed facial structures to the overlying dermis. Two types of retaining ligaments are noted as defined by their origin, either from bone or from other fixed structures within the face.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Transblepharoplasty endoscopic subperiosteal midface lift

The use of endoscopy in the transblepharoplasty midface lift is essential for preventing the complications of facial nerve injury and bleeding. Complete observation allows precise dissection and release of all structures in the composite flap. This technique fully preserves the zygo-orbicular nerve plexus and prevents denervation of the orbicularis oculi and zygomaticus muscles. Blind dissection has a significant probability of denervation of the entire zygo-orbital muscle complex, and avulsion of the zygomaticofacial vessels, with associated postoperative bleeding complications. The modification involving suturing of the "vest" of the combined lateral orbital periosteal and superficial layers of the deep temporal fascia over the elevated "pants" of the orbicularis periosteal flap provides very secure fixation for suspension of the lower eyelid and midface. The use of slowly absorbable polydioxanone sutures for this technique prevents the problems caused by permanent sutures beneath the very thin skin of the lateral canthal area. Careful trimming of the prominent roll of the orbicularis muscle that often develops with suspension eliminates the uneven contour and yields a smooth lower lid appearance. The details and modifications described should decrease the complications and morbidity that can occur with this procedure and provide for a more precise and reliable procedure for rejuvenation of the lower eyelid and midface.     

Anatomy of the frontal branch of the facial nerve: the significance of the temporal fat pad

The anatomy of the temporal region, with reference to the frontal branch of the facial nerve, was examined in 12 fresh cadaver dissections. In all dissections, the frontal branch traveled in a constant plane along the undersurface of the temporoparietal fascia and was quite superficial as it crossed the zygomatic arch. The deep temporal fascia and superficial temporal fat pad are anatomically important structures which adjoin the periosteum of the zygomatic arch and lie deep to the frontal nerve. Based on these relationships, a safe method of dissection within the temporal region is formulated.     

Composite rhytidectomy.

Signs of aging in the face reflect the change in position of deep anatomic elements, which are the platysma muscle, cheek fat, and the orbicularis oculi muscle. These changes occur from progressive ptosis of these elements, which continue to keep their intimate relationship with each other throughout the aging process. Conventional face lift procedures disrupt this normal relationship by separating the skin from these elements. All SMAS techniques reposition only the platysma muscle without repositioning the cheek fat and orbicularis muscle. This composite rhytidectomy allows elevation of a composite musculocutaneous flap containing all three elements for repositioning while maintaining their intimate relationship with each other and with the skin. One-hundred and sixty-seven composite rhytidectomies have been done with impressive results and minimal complications.     

Surgical anatomy and blood supply of the fascial layers of the temporal region

In 15 fresh cadavers (30 sides), we studied the two layers of fascia in the temporal region, with particular regard to their blood supply and to their usefulness--together or separately--as microvascular free-tissue autografts. The superficial temporal fascia (temporoparietal fascia, epicranial aponeurosis) lies immediately deep to the hair follicles. It is part of the subcutaneous musculoaponeurotic system and is continuous in all directions with other structures belonging to that layer--including the galea above and the SMAS layer of the face below. The deep temporal fascia (temporalis fascia, investing fascia of temporalis) is separated from the superficial fascia by an avascular plane of loose areolar tissue. It completely invests the superficial aspect of the temporalis muscle down to (but not beyond) the zygomatic arch. It is firmly attached to periosteum all around the margin of the muscles. Below it is attached to the upper border of the zygomatic arch. We found the deep temporal fascia to be supplied solely by the middle temporal artery, a constant branch of the superficial temporal. The middle temporal artery arises 1 to 3 cm below the upper border of the zygomatic arch, runs always superficial to the arch, and enters the deep temporal fascia immediately above that layer's attachment to the zygomatic arch. If the middle temporal vessels are protected, the two layers of temporal fascia can be raised together as a fully vascularized tissue island. This island can be fashioned as a bilobed or a double-layered flap, depending on the manner of dissection. The potential surgical usefulness of these findings is discussed.     

Anatomicohistologic study of the retaining ligaments of the face and use in face lift: retaining ligament correction and SMAS plication

Plastic surgeons have sought to improve nasolabial folds, jowls, jaw lines, and cervical contour with face-lifting procedures that are abundant in the literature. The retaining ligaments of the face support facial soft tissue in normal anatomic position, resisting gravitational change. As this ligamentous system attenuates, facial fat descends into the plane between the superficial and deep facial fascia, and the stigmata of facial age develop. In this study, surgical correction of the retaining ligaments and plication of the superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) to reposition the structures that have descended with gravitation are discussed. The anatomy of the facial retaining ligaments was studied in 22 half-faces of 11 fresh cadavers, and the localization, extension, and width of the ligaments were examined macroscopically and histologically. Surgical correction of the retaining ligaments and plication of the SMAS have been accomplished in 27 face-lift patients with this anatomicohistologic study taken into consideration. There was hematoma in one patient at the cheek region and a permanent dimple caused by postoperative edema in two patients, with a localization of one zygomatic and two parotidomasseteric ligaments. In one patient, hypesthesia in the mandibular nerve region was seen, which remitted at 14 weeks. There were no other complications, and with a follow-up of 24 months, excellent aesthetic results and a high level of patient satisfaction were encountered.     

The SMAS and the nasolabial fold.

In a series of histologic sections and clinical and cadaver dissections, the superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) is seen to become the investing fascia of the zygomaticus major and minor muscles in the medial cheek. The pull on the cheek flap during rhytidectomy is diffused by the attachment of the SMAS to these muscles. I believe that this attachment accounts for the minimal change in the nasolabial crease after a Skoog-type sub-SMAS face lift.     

Clinical applications of the subgaleal fascia

The anatomic boundaries and vascular supply of the subgaleal fascia have been described previously. The thin and malleable subgaleal fascia was selected for difficult reconstructive problems in seven patients. This flap has been based on either the supraorbital or the superficial temporal vascular leash. The subgaleal fascia is readily dissected from superficial galea and deep periosteum, leaving behind a well-vascularized scalp and a skin-graftable calvarium. The flap conforms to a cartilage framework for ear reconstruction. It takes a skin graft well. The subgaleal fascia can patch dural defects and fill sinus dead space. It has been used to augment facial contour. Free vascularized transfer of the subgaleal fascia has included the temporoparietal fascia, which was partially split from the subgaleal fascia for bilobed flap resurfacing of the hand. The subgaleal fascial flap should be considered when ultrathin, vascularized coverage is needed.     

Repositioning the orbicularis oculi muscle in the composite rhytidectomy.

While blepharoplasties are routinely done with face lift procedures, the improvement is accomplished by removing excess orbital fat with eyelid skin and muscle along the incisional line. The orbicularis oculi muscle remains intact as its inferior border, which has become ptotic and redundant with aging, and actually remains in the same position following a conventional lower lid blepharoplasty and rhytidectomy. However, by elevating the orbicularis oculi with the cheek fat and platysma in a composite face lift flap, and by excising the redundant inferior border of the orbicularis muscle, a total rejuvenation of the malar area is accomplished. The descent of the orbicularis oculi muscle is in an inferolateral vector, whereas the vector of facial aging is inferomedial. Thus, repositioning the orbicularis oculi is in a superomedial vector and is obligatory in a composite rhytidectomy.     

The extended subperiosteal face lift: a definitive soft-tissue remodeling for facial rejuvenation.

The subperiosteal face lift described by Psillakis has been criticized for not showing a more dramatic improvement over conventional brow/face lift procedures. His approach also has a significantly high incidence of nerve injury. This study reports our anatomic findings and surgical modifications, which have permitted a significant improvement in the safety of execution and clinical results using the subperiosteal face lift concept. Pertinent points of applied local anatomy and dissection techniques are as follows: First, we use extensive interconnected subperiosteal dissection that includes the entire zygomatic arch. This allows better repositioning of the deep soft tissues of the entire upper face, most of the midface, and indirectly, key structures of the lower face. Second, the upward pull of the muscles of the cheek and mouth will produce an elevation of the corner of the mouth, affecting positively the smiling mechanism, the oral frowning, and the jowls. Third, the dissection deep to both layers of the temporal fascia decreases the risk of injury to the frontalis nerve. Fourth, the temporal fascia is used as a lifter and anchoring element of the entire cheek-perioral soft tissues as opposed to the periorbital fibrofatty tissues. This will decrease the risk of injuring the frontal and zygomatic branches of the facial nerve. These modifications have been used in 28 patients. Our rate of patient satisfaction has been high, and no complications with regard to nerve injury have been observed. This compares favorably with our initial 60 patients, in whom the Psillakis or Tessier approach was used. In these patients, there was an 11 and 20 percent rate of nerve injury, respectively.     

Frey's syndrome: a preventable phenomenon.

Gustatory sweating, or Frey's syndrome, is a fairly common sequela of partial or radical parotidectomy, submaxillary gland surgery, or radical neck dissection. It is caused by an anastomotic communication with facial sweat glands by parasympathetic secretomotor nerve fibers intended for the excised parotid gland; treatments, whether surgical or topical, generally have been less than satisfactory. We present the first documented prophylactic approach to Frey's syndrome that is performed during and as part of parotidectomy. The surgery involves use of the superficial aponeurotic system (SMAS) as an interposing flap to interrupt the anastomotic nerve communication with the sweat glands. The SMAS is derived from the fascia in the periauricular cheek and neck area that is continuous with the platysma muscle. In a prospective study in 55 patients undergoing elective parotidectomy, the SMAS flap was elevated during the beginning of the operative procedure once it had been determined that fashioning of the flap would in no way compromise tumor excision. In all cases, at follow-up, there has been no clinical evidence of development of Frey's syndrome. We have shown that the development of the SMAS flap in parotid gland resections is an effective new approach both as a preventative measure against Frey's syndrome and as an aesthetic improvement over the usual defect typical of parotidectomies.     

Refinements in face lifting: enhanced facial contour using vicryl mesh incorporated into SMAS fixation

As we have gained experience with the extended superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) technique in face lifting, refinements in our procedure have led to increased consistency in results. The important factors that have led to our technical modifications include the following: (1) the significance of the retaining ligaments of the midface, which determine the degree of surgical dissection required for both skin and SMAS in rhytidectomy; (2) the changes in facial shape that occur with aging, secondary to the descent of facial fat; (3) the possibility of modifying facial shape through the repositioning of facial fat in an extended SMAS face lift; (4) the improved longevity of result to be obtained by incorporating Vicryl mesh into SMAS fixation; (5) the artistic nuances of incision design that help to minimize scar perceptibility. Understanding these factors enables surgeons to use the extended SMAS technique successfully with more challenging cases, enhancing facial appearance while minimizing signs that the patient has undergone a surgical procedure.     

Circumauricular incision (water-drop shape) for mid- to lower face lift

The conventional method of mid- to lower face rhytidectomy that involves removing a strip of occipital scalp always creates a conspicuous transverse scar crossing the postauricular skin, which may leave a stair-step deformity at the occipital hairline. The author has designed a new face lift method using a circumauricular incision, shaped like a water droplet, that curves around the auricle. In this new method, the upper part of the "O" shape is modified to the tip of a water droplet. The dissection of the cheek and neck is performed as in the conventional method with light-retractor assistance. The temporal region above the deep temporal fascia is managed under endoscopic control. This dissection can extend to the forehead region lateral to the supraoptic nerve and around the lateral orbital rim to release the arcus marginalis. A mesentery of superficial temporal fascia is created cephalic to the zygomatic arch. The postauricular dissection is performed beneath the galea in the upper part and beneath the occipital scalp and neck skin in the lower area. The lifting vector is upward and backward for the anterior skin flap and upward for the posterior skin flap. The excess skin is trimmed around the ear. The wound at the upper pole of the incision is closed in a V-to-Y advancement fashion. The dog-ear is left above the normal hairline, and there is little or no hairy scalp to be removed. The skin pleating in the postauricular region will settle down spontaneously after several months. The dog-ear in the scalp will become smaller and flat as well. The scar around the ear is quite inconspicuous and well covered under the upper pole of the auricle. From the author's experience, the new "water drop" circumauricular incision is a good alternative for the mid- to lower face lift. It can also be used in conjunction with endoforehead lift for full-face rejuvenation.     

An analysis of 123 temporoparietal fascial flaps: anatomic and clinical considerations in total auricular reconstruction.

This article presents an updated review of our experience with 122 temporoparietal fascial flaps, which were used for coverage of fabricated autogenous cartilage frameworks in total auricular reconstructions. Our indications for use of the temporoparietal fascial flap are presented. Partial flap necrosis occurred in 5 cases, total necrosis in 2 of 14 microsurgically transplanted cases, cartilage infection in 2 cases, and paralysis of the frontal branch of facial nerve in 1 case. Prospective observations of vascular anatomy were carried out in the last 93 temporoparietal fascial flaps during flap elevations. Only 59 flaps (63.4 percent) showed a typical pattern, distributed mainly by the superficial temporal artery and vein. Others (36.6 percent) were distributed mainly by various combinations of the posterior auricular artery or vein, occipital artery or vein, diploic vein, and the superficial temporal artery or vein. At the upper margin of the imaginary reconstructed auricle, the mean diameters of the artery and vein were 1.7 mm and 2.2 mm, respectively. There were no significant differences of vascular patterns and their diameters between the temporoparietal fascial flap of microtia sides and of nonmicrotia sides (sides with acquired ear deformities or free-flap donor sides). We are presenting our technical evolution in using the temporoparietal fascial flap for total auricular reconstruction with the goal of reducing surgical complications and improving aesthetic results.     

Endoscopically assisted malarplasty: one incision and two dissection planes

Asian society is uniquely concerned about the distinctive facial features associated with malar prominence. Various methods of reduction malarplasty have been developed and are currently being applied. In this study, a new approach to malarplasty was experimentally assessed between December of 1999 and August of 2001. After having received careful observations of their facial features and full counseling sessions, 32 patients were selected. These patients had three distinctive characteristics: (1) severe zygomatic arch prominence and normal zygomatic body prominence, (2) desire for only a reduction of the lateral prominence, and (3) desire for a less invasive surgery. Through a short incision in the temporal area, the authors performed the dissection as two different planes. Endoscopic dissection between the superficial layer of deep temporal fascia and the temporoparietal fascia to the zygomatic body and blunt dissection under the deep layer of the deep temporal fascia to the zygomatic arch were performed. Complete osteotomy of the zygomatic arch and an incomplete osteotomy of the zygomatic body were then performed with a reciprocating saw. Finally, the zygomatic arch for the zygoma infraction was pressed manually. The major advantages of this procedure are its simplicity and the short operation and recovery time, with little bleeding and edema.     

Biomechanical and viscoelastic properties of skin,SMAS, and composite flaps as they pertain to rhytidectomy

Previous studies have focused on biomechanical and viscoelastic properties of the superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) flap and the skin flap lifted in traditional rhytidectomy procedures. The authors compared these two layers with the composite rhytidectomy flap to explain their clinical observations that the composite dissection allows greater tension and lateral pull to be placed on the facial and cervical flaps, with less long-term stress-relaxation and tissue creep. Eight fresh cadavers were dissected by elevating flaps on one side of the face and neck as skin and SMAS flaps and on the other side as a standard composite rhytidectomy flap. The tissue samples were tested for breaking strength, tissue tearing force, stress-relaxation, and tissue creep. For breaking strength, uniform samples were pulled at a rate of 1 inch per minute, and the stress required to rupture the tissues was measured. Tissue tearing force was measured by attaching a 3-0 suture to the tissues and pulling at the same rate as that used for breaking strength. The force required to tear the suture out of the tissues was then measured. Stress-relaxation was assessed by tensing the uniformly sized strips of tissue to 80 percent of their breaking strength, and the amount of tissue relaxation was measured at 1-minute intervals for a total of 5 minutes. This measurement is expressed as the percentage of tissue relaxation per minute. Tissue creep was assessed by using a 3-0 suture and calibrated pressure gauge attached to the facial flaps. The constant tension applied to the flaps was 80 percent of the tissue tearing force. The distance crept was measured in millimeters after 2 and 3 minutes of constant tension. Breaking strength measurements demonstrated significantly greater breaking strength of skin and composite flaps as compared with SMAS flaps (p < 0.05). No significant difference was noted between skin and composite flaps. However, tissue tearing force demonstrated that the composite flaps were able to withstand a significantly greater force as compared with both skin and SMAS flaps (p < 0.05). Stress-relaxation analysis revealed the skin flaps to have the highest degree of stress-relaxation over each of five 1-minute intervals. In contrast, the SMAS and composite flaps demonstrated a significantly lower degree of stress-relaxation over the five 1-minute intervals (p < 0.05). There was no difference noted between the SMAS flaps and composite flaps with regard to stress-relaxation. Tissue creep correlated with the stress-relaxation data. The skin flaps demonstrated the greatest degree of tissue creep, which was significantly greater than that noted for the SMAS flaps or composite flaps (p < 0.05). Comparison of facial flaps with cervical flaps revealed that cervical skin, SMAS, and composite flaps tolerated significantly greater tissue tearing forces and demonstrated significantly greater tissue creep as compared with facial skin, SMAS, and composite flaps (p < 0.05). These biomechanical studies on facial and cervical rhytidectomy flaps indicate that the skin and composite flaps are substantially stronger than the SMAS flap, allowing significantly greater tension to be applied for repositioning of the flap and surrounding subcutaneous tissues. The authors confirmed that the SMAS layer exhibits significantly less stress-relaxation and creep as compared with the skin flap, a property that has led aesthetic surgeons to incorporate the SMAS into the face lift procedure. On the basis of the authors' findings in this study, it seems that that composite flap, although composed of both the skin and SMAS, acquires the viscoelastic properties of the SMAS layer, demonstrating significantly less stress-relaxation and tissue creep as compared with the skin flap. This finding may play a role in maintaining long-term results after rhytidectomy. In addition, it is noteworthy that the cervical flaps, despite their increased strength, demonstrate significantly greater tissue creep as compared with facial flaps, suggesting earlier relaxation of the neck as compared with the face after rhytidectomy.     

Double-layered free temporal fascia flap as a two-layered tendon-gliding surface

We report the use of a two-layered free fascial flap consisting of temporoparietal and deep temporal fascia based on a single vascular pedicle, the superficial temporal artery and vein. The flap was used to reconstruct an extensive degloving injury of the dorsum of the hand, in which multiple intact extensor tendons lay fully exposed on all sides, with exposed bone beneath them. By sandwiching the tendons between the layers of vascularized fascia, gliding surfaces were provided, both superficial and deep to the exposed tendons. The single-stage reconstruction was completed with a split-thickness skin graft. The patient returned to heavy manual work within 12 weeks of injury. He obtained an excellent range of movement without the need for tenolysis.     

Balanced auricular reconstruction in dystopic microtia with the presence of the external auditory canal

This article presents a new repositioning method in dystopic microtia (low-set microtia, anteriorly tilted microtia, or both) with the presence of the external auditory canal. In the case of low-set malformations, the dystopic auricular canal complex was freed from adjacent bony structure, shifted upward, and anchored to the thick periosteum of the suprameatal triangle or the adjacent superior portion of the temporal bone with nonabsorbable sutures. When the auricular vestige was large and dystopia was severe, the complex was shifted with attachment of the temporoparietal fascia on its cranial part. Meanwhile, when the auricular vestige was small and dystopia was mild, the complex was shifted without attachment of the temporoparietal fascia. Then, the ear framework fabricated with autogenous costal cartilage was positioned and wrapped with the temporoparietal fascial flap. In the case of anteriorly tilted malformations, the dystopic complex was freed, shifted posteriorly, and anchored to the periosteum of the suprameatal triangle. Preauricular dead space, resulting from shifting the complex, was obliterated with pieces of costal cartilage. Simultaneously, the ear framework was placed and wrapped with the temporoparietal fascial flap. No skin necrosis of the shifted complexes occurred in any of the cases. In one case, the facial nerve was transected during dissection and reanastomosed. Upward repositioning distances in low-set microtias were between 1 and 3.5 cm. Posteriorly repositioning distances in anteriorly tilted microtias were 2 and 3 cm. Thirteen patients with low-set malformations, two patients with anteriorly tilted malformations, and three patients with low-set and anteriorly tilted malformations underwent reconstructive operations. The new repositioning method is relatively simple, safe, and effective.     

Purse string-formed plication of the SMAS with fixation to the zygomatic bone

The superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) operation revolutionized face-lift procedures. The idea of having one direction of traction with suturing and fixation of SMAS to a stable structure is gaining popularity. The author's contribution is the fixation of the SMAS and the extension of the supraplatysmal plane to the zygomatic bone periosteum to achieve stable traction and fixation. This procedure has not been described before in medical literature. The purse string-formed plication of the SMAS is a procedure in which the soft tissue (SMAS, parotid fascia, and the extension of the supraplatysmal plane) is plicated and fixed to the periosteum of the zygomatic bone. This superficial operation avoids entering the deeper planes, which could result in severe complications. The procedure fills the cheeks and gives a more natural look than standard face lifts. A total of 250 patients underwent this procedure. The suspension achieved seemed to be more stable than some SMASectomy techniques. Complication rates and recovery times were low. The purse string-formed plication of the SMAS is a safe, quick, and simple procedure with effective results suitable for younger patients with good skin conditions.