The catalytic aspartate is protonated in the Michaelis complex formed between trypsin and an in vitro evolved substrate-like inhibitor: a refined mechanism of serine protease action

The mechanism of serine proteases prominently illustrates how charged amino acid residues and proton transfer events facilitate enzyme catalysis. Here we present an ultrahigh resolution (0.93 Å) x-ray structure of a complex formed between trypsin and a canonical inhibitor acting through a substrate-like mechanism. The electron density indicates the protonation state of all catalytic residues where the catalytic histidine is, as expected, in its neutral state prior to the acylation step by the catalytic serine. The carboxyl group of the catalytic aspartate displays an asymmetric electron density so that the O_δ2–C_γ bond appears to be a double bond, with O_δ2 involved in a hydrogen bond to His-57 and Ser-214. Only when Asp-102 is protonated on O_δ1 atom could a density functional theory simulation reproduce the observed electron density. The presence of a putative hydrogen atom is also confirmed by a residual mF_obs − DF_calc density above 2.5 σ next to O_δ1. As a possible functional role for the neutral aspartate in the active site, we propose that in the substrate-bound form, the neutral aspartate residue helps to keep the pK_a of the histidine sufficiently low, in the active neutral form. When the histidine receives a proton during the catalytic cycle, the aspartate becomes simultaneously negatively charged, providing additional stabilization for the protonated histidine and indirectly to the tetrahedral intermediate. This novel proposal unifies the seemingly conflicting experimental observations, which were previously seen as either supporting the charge relay mechanism or the neutral pK_a histidine theory.     

Catalytic cysteine residues of ER-60 protease

ER-60 protease contains two CGHC motifs that appear to include an active site cysteine residue(s). Its proteolytic activity was lost with a double mutation of the C-terminal cysteines of the two motifs to alanine, but not with a single mutation of the C-terminal cysteine of either of the motifs to alanine. This suggests that these C-terminal cysteines independently constitute the catalytic active site. A mutation of both histidine residues in the two CGHC motifs to serine did not abolish the proteolytic activity, suggesting these histidine residues in the CGHC motifs do not constitute the catalytic dyad of ER-60 protease.     

Identification of active-site residues in protease 3C of hepatitis A virus by site-directed mutagenesis.

Picornavirus 3C proteases (3Cpro) are cysteine proteases related by amino acid sequence to trypsin-like serine proteases. Comparisons of 3Cpro of hepatitis A virus (HAV) to those of other picornaviruses have resulted in prediction of active-site residues: histidine at position 44 (H44), aspartic acid (D98), and cysteine (C172). To test whether these residues are key members of a putative catalytic triad, oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis was targeted to 3Cpro in the context of natural polypeptide precursor P3. Autocatalytic processing of the polyprotein containing wild-type or variant 3Cpro was tested by in vivo expression of vaccinia virus-HAV chimeras in an animal cell-T7 hybrid system and by in vitro translation of corresponding RNAs. Comparison with proteins present in HAV-infected cells showed that both expression systems mimicked authentic polyprotein processing. Individual substitutions of H44 by tyrosine and of C172 by glycine or serine resulted in complete loss of the virus-specific proteolytic cascade. In contrast, a P3 polyprotein in which D98 was substituted by asparagine underwent only slightly delayed processing, while an additional substitution of valine (V47) by glycine within putative protein 3A caused a more pronounced loss of processing. Therefore, apparently H44 and C172 are active-site constituents whereas D98 is not. The results, furthermore, suggest that substitution of amino acid residues distant from polyprotein cleavage sites may reduce proteolytic activity, presumably by altering substrate conformation.     

Site-directed mutagenesis suggests close functional relationship between a human rhinovirus 3C cysteine protease and cellular trypsin-like serine proteases

Human rhinoviruses, like other picornaviruses, encode a cysteine protease (designated 3C) which cleaves mainly at viral Gln-Gly pairs. There are significant areas of homology between picornavirus 3C cysteine proteases and cellular serine proteases (e.g. trypsin), suggesting a functional relationship between their catalytic regions. To test this functional relationship, we made single substitutions in human rhinovirus type 14 protease 3C at seven amino acid positions which are highly conserved in the 3C proteases of animal picornaviruses. Substitutions at either His-40, Asp-85, or Cys-146, equivalent to the trypsin catalytic triad His-57, Asp-102, and Ser-195, respectively, completely abolished 3C proteolytic activity. Single substitutions were also made at either Thr-141, Gly-158, His-160, or Gly-162, which are equivalent to the trypsin specificity pocket region. Only the mutant with a conservative Thr-141 to Ser substitution exhibited proteolytic activity, which was much reduced compared with the parent. These results, together with immunoprecipitation data which indicate that Asp-85, Thr-141, and Cys-146 lie in accessible surface regions, suggest that the catalytic mechanism of picornavirus 3C cysteine proteases is closely related to that of cellular trypsin-like serine proteases.     

Understanding the Functional Roles of Amino Acid Residues in Enzyme Catalysis

The MACiE database contains 223 distinct step-wise enzyme reaction mechanisms and holds representatives from each EC sub-subclass where there is a crystal structure and sufficient evidence in the literature to support a mechanism. Each catalytic step of every reaction sequence in MACiE is fully annotated so that it includes the function of the catalytic residues involved in the reaction and the mechanism by which substrates are transformed into products. Using MACiE as a knowledge base, we have seen that the top 10 most catalytic residues are histidine, aspartate, glutamate, lysine, cysteine, arginine, serine, threonine, tyrosine and tryptophan. Of these only seven (cysteine, histidine, aspartate, lysine, serine, threonine and tyrosine) dominate catalysis and provide essentially five functional roles that are essential. Stabilisation is the most common and essential role for all classes of enzyme, followed by general acid/base (proton acceptor and proton donor) functionality, with nucleophilic addition following closely behind (nucleophile and nucleofuge). We investigated the occurrence of these residues in MACiE and the Catalytic Site Atlas and found that, as expected, certain residue types are associated with each functional role, with some residue types able to perform diverse roles. In addition, it was seen that different EC classes of enzyme have a tendency to employ different residues for catalysis. Further, we show that whilst the differences between EC classes in catalytic residue composition are not immediately obvious from the general classes of Ingold mechanisms, there is some weak correlation between the mechanisms involved in a given EC class and the functions that the catalytic amino acid residues are performing. The analysis presented here provides a valuable insight into the functional roles of catalytic amino acid residues, which may have applications in many aspects of enzymology, from the design of novel enzymes to the prediction and validation of enzyme reaction mechanisms.     

Crystal structures of two engineered thiol trypsins

We have determined the three-dimensional structures of engineered rat trypsins which mimic the active sites of two classes of cysteine proteases. The catalytic serine was replaced with cysteine (S195C) to test the ability of sulfur to function as a nucleophile in a serine protease environment. This variant mimics the cysteine trypsin class of thiol proteases. An additional mutation of the active site aspartate to an asparagine (D102N) created the catalytic triad of the papain-type cysteine proteases. Rat trypsins S195C and D102N,S195C were solved to 2.5 and 2.0 A, respectively. The refined structures were analyzed to determine the structural basis for the 10(6)-fold loss of activity of trypsin S195C and the 10(8)-fold loss of activity of trypsin D102N,S195C, relative to rat trypsin. The active site thiols were found in a reduced state in contrast to the oxidized thiols found in previous thiol protease structures. These are the first reported structures of serine proteases with the catalytic centers of sulfhydryl proteases. Structure analysis revealed only subtle global changes in enzyme conformation. The substrate binding pocket is unaltered, and active site amino acid 102 forms hydrogen bonds to H57 and S214 as well as to the backbone amides of A56 and H57. In trypsin S195C, D102 is a hydrogen-bond acceptor for H57 which allows the other imidazole nitrogen to function as a base during catalysis. In trypsin D102N,S195C, the asparagine at position 102 is a hydrogen-bond donor to H57 which places a proton on the imidazole nitrogen proximal to the nucleophile. This tautomer of H57 is unable to act as a base in catalysis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Study of intracellular localization of the proteolytic enzyme complex and its protein inhibitors in bombyx grain

Intracellular localization of serine, cysteine and aspartate proteases, as well as their protein inhibitors, in bombyx grain in the postdiapause period of embryogenesis has been studied. Proteolytic activity of aspartate and cysteine proteases was found in lysosomal, mitochondrial, and nuclear fractions of grains. Serine protease activity was not observed in subcellular fractions of grains of the fourth day of postdiapause development. It has been shown that activities of protein inhibitors and certain peptide hydrolases in subcellular fractions provide consistent functioning and fine regulation of the proteolytic enzyme complex.     

Basidiomycetes harbour a hidden treasure of proteolytic diversity

This survey is the first to investigate the proteolytic potential of a large number of basidiomycetes. Aqueous extracts of 43 basidiomycetes were investigated for their content of proteolytic activities, using gelatin zymography. The activities were characterised qualitatively using class specific inhibitors. All four catalytic classes of proteases were present, with 4% of all activities classified as aspartic, 5% as cysteine, 6% as metallo and 22% as serine proteases, while the remaining activities could not be assigned unambiguously. The majority of the latter were not inhibited by any of the inhibitors used and were termed insensitive. Different proteolytic activities are evenly distributed among members of all orders of basidiomycetes, although some taxa are a richer source of proteases than others. A significant number of the cysteine protease activities shown here have not previously been reported in basidiomycetes. The fungal cysteine and serine protease inhibitors, clitocypin and CNSPI (Clitocybe nebularis serine protease inhibitor), both inhibited a number of activities and even a few activities that were otherwise insensitive to all other inhibitors used, hence indicating their potential for a regulatory role. The number and diversity of proteases in basidiomycetes are seen to be remarkable and encourage further investigation.     

Lysosomal peptidases and glycosidases in rheumatoid arthritis

Lysosomal serine and cysteine proteases are reported to play a role in collagen degradation. In this study, the activities of the lysosomal cysteine proteases cathepsin B and H, dipeptidyl peptidase I, and the serine protease tripeptidyl peptidase I and dipeptidyl peptidase II, all ascribed a role in collagen digestion, were compared with those of the aspartate protease cathepsin D, and lysosomal glycosidases in leukocytes from rheumatoid arthritis patients at different stages of the disease. In all patients the activities of cysteine protease cathepsin B, dipeptidyl peptidase I, aspartate protease cathepsin D, and two glycosidases were elevated, but the activities of the serine proteases tripeptidyl peptidase I, dipeptidyl peptidase II, and the cysteine protease cathepsin H was unchanged. The magnitude of the increased activity was correlated with the duration of the disease. Patients with long-standing RA (10 years or more) had higher cysteine protease activity in their leukocytes than did those with disease of shorter duration. This tendency suggests that elevated lysosomal cysteine protease activities, together with aspartate protease cathepsin D and lysosomal glycosidases (but not serine proteases), are associated with progression of rheumatoid arthritis.     

Evolutionary lines of cysteine peptidases

The proteolytic enzymes that depend upon a cysteine residue for activity have come from at least seven different evolutionary origins, each of which has produced a group of cysteine peptidases with distinctive structures and properties. We show here that the characteristic molecular topologies of the peptidases in each evolutionary line can be seen not only in their three-dimensional structures, but commonly also in the two-dimensional structures. Clan CA contains the families of papain (C1), calpain (C2), streptopain (C10) and the ubiquitin-specific peptidases (C12, C19), as well as many families of viral cysteine endopeptidases. Clan CD contains the families of clostripain (C11), gingipain R (C25), legumain (C13), caspase-1 (C14) and separin (C50). These enzymes have specificities dominated by the interactions of the S1 subsite. Clan CE contains the families of adenain (C5) from adenoviruses, the eukaryotic Ulp1 protease (C48) and the bacterial YopJ proteases (C55). Clan CF contains only pyroglutamyl peptidase I (C15). The picornains (C3) in clan PA have probably evolved from serine peptidases, which still form the majority of enzymes in the clan. The cysteine peptidase activities in clans PB and CH are autolytic only. In conclusion, we suggest that although almost all the cysteine peptidases depend for activity on catalytic dyads of cysteine and histidine, it is worth noting some important differences that they have inherited from their distant ancestral peptidases.     

The role of electrostatic interactions in the mechanism of peptide bond hydrolysis by a Ser-Lys catalytic dyad.

General-base catalysis in the active site of serine proteases is carried out by the imidazole side chain of a histidine. During formation of the transition state, an adjacent carboxylic acid group stabilizes the positive charge that forms on the general-base catalyst and as a result contributes several orders of magnitude to the catalytic efficiency of these enzymes. In the recently discovered family of self-cleaving proteins exemplified by the LexA repressor of Escherichia coli, instead of the imidazole of a histidine, the active-site general-base catalyst was found to be the epsilon-amino of a lysine. The considerably higher capacity of the lysine side chain for proton acceptance raises interesting questions concerning the role of electrostatic interactions in the mechanism of proton transfer by this highly basic group. The negative charge elimination studies described here and their effects on the kmax and pK of LexA self-cleavage are consistent with a model in which electrostatic interactions between an acidic side chain and the general-base catalyst form a barrier to proton transfer. The implications are that the epsilon-amino group, unlike the imidazole group, is capable of effecting proton transfer without the intervention of a countercharge.     

A pre-aspartate-specific protease from human leukocytes that cleaves pro-interleukin-1 beta

Interleukin-1 beta is a 17.4-kilodalton hormone derived from a 33-kilodalton inactive precursor produced by monocytes. We used the precursor as a substrate to detect proteolytic activities in peripheral blood mono-nuclear cell-conditioned medium that might be involved in interleukin-1 beta processing. We found that the conditioned medium, following passage through DEAE-Sephacel, generates a biologically active fragment from the precursor that runs slightly higher than the mature hormone in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The responsible activity behaved as a single protein in ion exchange chromatography. It was completely inhibited by metal ion chelators and not by inhibitors of serine, cysteine, or aspartate proteases, and it was dependent on both calcium (or magnesium) and zinc. The enzyme was not inhibited by three substrate-based metalloprotease inhibitors, phosphoramidon, benzyloxycarbonyl-Gly-Leu-NH2, and N-(2-carboxy-3-phenylpropionyl)-Leu. NH2-terminal sequence analysis showed that cleavage of the precursor occurred between a histidine and an aspartate residue, and digestion of synthetic peptides indicated that the protease is specific for pre-aspartate cleavages.     

The Mechanisms of Action and Inhibition of Pancreatic Lipase and Acetylcholinesterase: A Comparative Modeling Study

Abstract

Pancreatic lipase and acetylcholinesterase are both serine esterases. Their X-ray structures reveal a similar overall fold, but no sequence homology can be detected. A catalytic triad like in the trypsin family of serine proteases consisting of serine, histidine and aspartate (glutamate in acetylcholinesterase) suggests mechanistic similarities. Models of the transition states of the substrate cleavage have been built and possible catalytic pathways were examined. The model that could produce a consistent pathway throughout the reactions had a transition state of the opposite handedness compared to trypsin. These models could be used to rationalise binding modes of inhibitors of both enzymes. The lipase inhibitor tetrahydrolipstatin (THL) contains a gamma-lactone which is opened by the catalytic serine; the alcohol leaving group prohibits deacylation by locking the pathway for incoming water and thus inactivates the enzyme. Carbamate inhibitors of acetylcholinesterase transfer a carbamoyl group to the serine-OH which deacylates slowly. These observations can be used as a starting point for the discovery of new classes of inhibitors.     

Structures of prolyl oligopeptidase substrate/inhibitor complexes. Use of inhibitor binding for titration of the catalytic histidine residue

Structure determination of the inactive S554A variant of prolyl oligopeptidase complexed with an octapeptide has shown that substrate binding is restricted to the P4-P2' region. In addition, it has revealed a hydrogen bond network of potential catalytic importance not detected in other serine peptidases. This involves a unique intramolecular hydrogen bond between the P1' amide and P2 carbonyl groups and another between the P2' amide and Nepsilon2 of the catalytic histidine 680 residue. It is argued that both hydrogen bonds promote proton transfer from the imidazolium ion to the leaving group. Another complex formed with the product-like inhibitor benzyloxycarbonyl-glycyl-proline, indicating that the carboxyl group of the inhibitor forms a hydrogen bond with the Nepsilon2 of His(680). Because a protonated histidine makes a stronger interaction with the carboxyl group, it offers a possibility of the determination of the real pK(a) of the catalytic histidine residue. This was found to be 6.25, lower than that of the well studied serine proteases. The new titration method gave a single pK(a) for prolyl oligopeptidase, whose reaction exhibited a complex pH dependence for k(cat)/K(m), and indicated that the observed pK(a) values are apparent. The procedure presented may be applicable for other serine peptidases.     

Recombinant Der p 1 and Der f 1 exhibit cysteine protease activity but no serine protease activity

Although mite major group 1 allergens, Der p 1 and Der f 1, were first isolated as cysteine proteases, some studies reported that natural Der p 1 exhibits mixed cysteine and serine protease activity. Clarifying whether the serine protease activity originates from Der p 1 or is due to contamination is important for distinguishing between the pathogenic proteolytic activities of group 1 allergens and mite-derived serine proteases. Recombinant mite group 1 allergens would be useful tool for addressing this issue, because they are completely free from contamination by mite serine proteases. Recombinant Der p 1 and Der f 1, and highly purified natural forms exhibited only cysteine protease activity. However, commercially available natural forms exhibited both activities, but the two activities were eluted into different fractions in size-exclusion column chromatography. The substrate specificity associated with the serine protease activity was similar to that of Der f 3. These results indicate that the serine protease activity does not originate from group 1 allergens.     

Cloning and characterization of trypsin- and chymotrypsin-like proteases from the midgut of the sand fly vector Phlebotomus papatasi

Trypsin and chymotrypsin serine proteases are the main digestive proteases in Diptera midguts and are also involved in many aspects of the vector-parasite relationship. In sand flies, these proteases have been shown to be a potential barrier to Leishmania growth and development within the midgut. Here we describe the sequence and partial characterization of six Phlebotomus papatasi midgut serine proteases: two chymotrypsin-like (Ppchym1 and Ppchym2) and four trypsin-like (Pptryp1-Pptryp4). All six enzymes show structural features typical to each type, including the histidine, aspartic acid, and serine (H/D/S) catalytic triad, six conserved cysteine residues, and other amino acid residues involved in substrate specificity. They also show a high degree of homology (40-60% identical residues) with their counterparts from other insect vectors, such as Anopheles gambiae and Aedes aegypti. The mRNA expression profiles of these six proteases vary considerably: two trypsin-like proteases (Pptryp1 and Pptryp2) are downregulated and one (Pptryp4) upregulated upon blood feeding. The two chymotrypsin-like enzymes display expression behavior similar to that of the early and late trypsins from Ae. aegypti.     

Molecular mechanical properties of short-sequence peptide enzyme mimics

While considerable attempts have been made to recreate the high turnover rates of enzymes using synthetic enzyme mimics, most have failed and only a few have produced minimal reaction rates that can barely be considered catalytic. One particular approach we have focused on is the use of short-sequence peptides that contain key catalytic groups in close proximity. In this study, we designed six different peptides and tested their ability to mimic the catalytic mechanism of the cysteine proteases. Acetylation and deacylation by Ellman’s Reagent trapping experiments showed the importance of having phenylalanine groups surrounding the catalytic sites in order to provide greater proximity between the cysteine, histidine, and aspartate amino acid R-groups. We have also carried out all-atom molecular dynamics simulations to determine the distance between these catalytic groups and the overall mechanical flexibility of the peptides. We found strong correlations between the magnitude of fluctuations in the Cys-His distance, which determines the flexibility and interactions between the cysteine thiol and histidine imidazole groups, and the deacylation rate. We found that, in general, shorter Cys-His distance fluctuations led to a higher deacylation rate constant, implying that greater confinement of the two residues will allow a higher frequency of the acetyl exchange between the cysteine thiol and histidine imidazole R-groups. This may be the key to future design of peptide structures with molecular mechanical properties that lead to viable enzyme mimics.     

On the inactivity of thiol-subtilisin. The role of the intramolecular electric field

Based on computed proton affinities for several model systems, the energetics of proton transfer and the acidity of the catalytic triads Cys-His-Asn (papain). Cys-His-Asp (thiol-subtilisin) and Ser-His-Asp (subtilisin) are discussed. It is shown that in papain the ion-pair Cys--HisH+ exists owing to the intramolecular electric field, and that a similar situation is found in thiol-subtilisin. but not in subtilisin. Assuming similar reaction mechanisms for papain and thiol-subtilisin - i.e. proton transfer from HisH+ to the NH group of the scissile peptide bond - the inactivity of thil-subtilisin towards proteins is explained by the much greater basicity of His in the complex His-Asp- than in His-Asn. In order for this explanation to be consistent, it is tentatively concluded that the catalytic mechanism of the serine proteases is different from that of the cystein proteases, and involves direct transfer of the serine proton to the leaving group in the acylation step.     

Engineering d-amino acid containing novel protease inhibitors using catalytic site architecture

The mechanism of proteolysis by serine proteases is a reasonably well-understood process. Typically, a histidine residue acting as a general base deprotonates the catalytic serine residue and the hydrolytic water molecule. We disclose here, the use of an unnatural d-amino acid as a strategic residue in P1 position, designed de novo based on the architecture of the protease catalytic site to impede the catalytic histidine residue at the stage of acyl-enzyme intermediate. Several probe molecules containing d-homoserine or its derivatives at P1 position are evaluated. Compounds 1, 6, and 8-10 produced up to 57% loss of activity against chymotrypsin. More potent and specific inhibitors could be designed with structure optimization as this strategy is completely general and can be used to design inhibitors against any serine or cysteine protease.     

Proteases in autophagy

Autophagy is a process involved in the proteolytic degradation of cellular macromolecules in lysosomes, which requires the activity of proteases, enzymes that hydrolyse peptide bonds and play a critical role in the initiation and execution of autophagy. Importantly, proteases also inhibit autophagy in certain cases. The initial steps of macroautophagy depend on the proteolytic processing of a particular protein, Atg8, by a cysteine protease, Atg4. This processing step is essential for conjugation of Atg8 with phosphatidylethanolamine and, subsequently, autophagosome formation. Lysosomal hydrolases, known as cathepsins, can be divided into several groups based on the catalitic residue in the active site, namely, cysteine, serine and aspartic cathepsins, which catalyse the cleavage of peptide bonds of autophagy substrates and, together with other factors, dispose of the autophagic flux. Whilst most cathepsins degrade autophagosomal content, some, such as cathepsin L, also degrade lysosomal membrane components, GABARAP-II and LC3-II. In contrast, cathepsin A, a serine protease, is involved in inhibition of chaperon-mediated autophagy through proteolytic processing of LAMP-2A. In addition, other families of calcium-dependent non-lysosomal cysteine proteases, such as calpains, and cysteine aspartate-specific proteases, such as caspases, may cleave autophagy-related proteins, negatively influencing the execution of autophagic processes. Here we discuss the current state of knowledge concerning protein degradation by autophagy and outline the role of proteases in autophagic processes. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Proteolysis 50 years after the discovery of lysosome.