Biomechanical measurements on scaphoid bone screws in an experimental model

A number of screws commonly used for internal fixation in scaphoid bone fractures and nonunions are compared regarding biomechanical properties and clinical applicability. The experiments were carried out on models made of ash-wood, representing a reconstruction and fixation as is performed in a cortico-cancellous inlay bone graft for scaphoid non-union. For fixation use was made of 2.7 and 3.5 AO/ASIF cortical screws respectively, 4.0 AO/ASIF cancellous screws, Herbert screws, and a newly designed screw called the three components screw (D.K.S.). The models with implanted screws were tested for bending strength, tensile strength and torsion stability. No large differences between the various screws were found regarding the measured parameters, so that a small intra-osteal implant such as the Herbert screw and the D.K.S., which can be inserted easily and which gives a certain amount of interfragmentary compression, will be sufficient for osteosynthesis of the scaphoid bone. In case an intra-osteal implant is not available a single 3.5 AO/ASIF cortical screw, inserted following lag-screw principles, is recommended.     

Comparison of compression and torque measurements of self-tapping and pretapped screws

The choice of an internal fixation system for maxillofacial surgery is made difficult because of lack of information with respect to functional load. This study attempted to clarify some of the controversy with respect to maxillofacial use of these implants. Maximal compressive force to torque values were measured in standardized bone thicknesses of 1, 2, 3, and 4 mm. The screws tested were pretapped AO 1.5-, 2.0-, 2.7-, and 3.5-mm rescue screws and self-tapping Luhr, Champy, and AO 1.5- and 2.0-mm screws. Ten measurements were made for each screw type/bone thickness combination using a piezoelectric washer and torque screwdriver. It was apparent that for 1- and 2-mm bone thicknesses the use of self-tapping screws resulted in the highest compression values. In 3- and 4-mm bone thicknesses, pretapped screws offered the highest compression values. As expected, self-tapping screws had the highest torque values on insertion owing to torque loss in cutting the screw threads. The 2.7-mm screw offered no advantage over the 2.0-mm screws in 1- and 2-mm bone thicknesses but resulted in higher compression values in 3- and 4-mm bone thicknesses.     

Calcium phosphate cement augmentation of cancellous bone screws can compensate for the absence of cortical fixation

An obvious means to improve the fixation of a cancellous bone screw is to augment the surrounding bone with cement. Previous studies have shown that bone augmentation with Calcium Phosphate (CaP) cement significantly improves screw fixation. Nevertheless, quantitative data about the optimal distribution of CaP cement is not available. The present study aims to show the effect of cement distribution on the screw fixation strength for various cortical thicknesses and to determine the conditions at which cement augmentation can compensate for the absence of cortical fixation in osteoporotic bone. In this study, artificial bone materials were used to mimic osteoporotic cancellous bone and cortical bone of varying thickness. These bone constructs were used to test the fixation strength of cancellous bone screws in different cortical thicknesses and different cement augmentation depths. The cement distribution was measured with microCT. The maximum pullout force was measured experimentally. The microCT analysis revealed a pseudo-conic shape distribution of the cement around the screws. While the maximum pullout strength of the screws in the artificial bone only was 30±7 N, it could increase up to approximately 1000 N under optimal conditions. Cement augmentation significantly increased pullout force in all cases. The effect of cortical thickness on pullout force was reduced with increased cement augmentation depth. Indeed, cement augmentation without cortical fixation increased pullout forces over that of screws without cement augmentation but with cortical fixation. Since cement augmentation significantly increased pullout force in all cases, we conclude that the loss of cortical fixation can be compensated by cement augmentation.     

Anterior vertebral body screw pullout testing with the hollow modular anchorage system--a comparative in vitro study.

Pullout of implants at the proximal and distal ends of multilevel constructs represents a common spinal surgery problem. One goal concerning the development of new spinal implants is to achieve stable fixation together with the least invasive approach to the spinal column. This biomechanical study measures the influence of different modes of implantation and different screw designs, including a new monocortical system, on the maximum pullout strength of screws inserted ventrolaterally into calf vertebrae. The force pullout of eight different groups were tested and compared. Included were three bicortical used single screws (USS, Zielke-VDS, single KASS). To further increase pullout strength either a second screw (KASS) or a pullout-resistant nut can be added (USS with pullout nut). A completely new concept of anchorage represents the Hollow Modular Anchorage System (MACS-HMA). This hollow titanium implant has an increased outside diameter and is designed for monocortical use. Additionally two screw systems suitable for bicortical use were tested in monocortical mode of anchorage (USS, single KASS). We selected seven vertebrae equal in mean size and bone mineral density for each of the eight groups. The vertebral body and implant were connected to both ends of a servohydraulic testing machine. Displacement controlled distraction was applied until failure at the metal-bone-interface occurred. The maximum axial pullout force was recorded. Mean BMD was 312 +/- 55 mg CaHA/ml in cancellous bone and 498 +/- 98 mg CaHA/ml in cortical bone. The highest resistance to pullout found, measured 4.2 kN (KASS) and 4.0 kN (USS with pullout nut). The mean pullout strength of Zielke-VDS was 2.1 kN, of single KASS 2.5 kN, of MACS-HMA 2.6 kN and of USS 3.2 kN. There was no statistically significant difference (t-test, p > 0.05) between bicortical screws and the new monocortical implant. For the strongest fixation at the proximal or distal end of long spinal constructs the addition of a second screw or a pullout-resistant nut behind the opposite cortex offers even stronger fixation.     

生物活性玻璃提高骨质疏松绵羊椎弓根螺钉稳定性的体内实验研究

目的:研究生物活性玻璃(Bioactive Glass,BG)在骨质疏松绵羊体内强化椎弓根螺钉固定的力学效果,并观察钉道界面及材料吸收等情况。方法:4只成年雌性小尾寒羊,采用去势联合激素注射方法建立骨质疏松绵羊模型。选择绵羊L2至L5双侧椎弓根,随机化选取一侧直接拧入椎弓根螺钉(空白组),对侧采用BG强化钉道后拧入椎弓根螺钉(实验组)。术后3月随机选取6个椎体(12枚椎弓根螺钉),对螺钉骨质界面行显微CT分析和组织学观察。对剩余10个椎体(20枚椎弓根螺钉)行轴向拔出实验,分析螺钉固定强度。结果:术前绵羊腰椎BMD为0.818±0.0310 g/cm2,建模完成后为1.000±0.0316 g/cm2,BMD平均值下降22.38%,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05)。实验组螺钉骨质界面的Tb.Th、Tb.N组较对照组分别增加143.60%和33.56%,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05)。实验组钉道周围材料绝大部分已经降解吸收,大量新生骨组织紧密包裹螺钉;对照组钉道周围骨量较少,钉骨结合不紧密,实验组螺钉骨质界面结合优于对照组。实验组的最大轴向拔出力为1083.04±86.37N,空白组为871.76±79.03N,前者较后者提高25.26%,差异有统计学意义(P<0.05)。结论:生物活性玻璃能显著改善骨质疏松情况下螺钉骨质界面的骨微观结构,进而提高椎弓根螺钉的把持力。     

Injectable calcium phosphate cement for augmentation around cancellous bone screws. In vivo biomechanical studies

In lower cancellous apparent bone density, it can be difficult to achieve adequate screw fixation and hence stable fracture fixation. Different strategies have been proposed, one of them is through augmentation using calcium phosphate cement in the region at or close to the screw thread itself. To support the hypothesis of an improved screw fixation technique by augmentation of the bone surrounding the implanted screw, in vivo biomechanical and densitometric studies are performed on rabbit specimen where normal and simulated weak bone quality are considered. In particular, the evolution of screw stability till 12 weeks following the implantation is quantified. A statistical significance in the pull out force for augmented versus non-augmented screws was found for the shorter time periods tested of ≤ 5 days whilst the pull out force was found to increase with time for both augmented and non-augmented screws during the 12 week course of the study. The results of the study demonstrate that the use of an injectable calcium phosphate cement which sets in vivo can significantly improve screw pull out strength at and after implantation for normal and simulated weak bone quality.     

生物活性玻璃提高骨质疏松绵羊椎弓根螺钉稳定性的体内实验研究

目的：研究生物活性玻璃（Bioactive Glass,BG）在骨质疏松绵羊体内强化椎弓根螺钉固定的力学效果,并观察钉道界面及材料吸收等情况。方法：4只成年雌性小尾寒羊,采用去势联合激素注射方法建立骨质疏松绵羊模型。选择绵羊L2至L5双侧椎弓根,随机化选取一侧直接拧入椎弓根螺钉（空白组）,对侧采用BG强化钉道后拧入椎弓根螺钉（实验组）。术后3月随机选取6个椎体（12枚椎弓根螺钉）,对螺钉骨质界面行显微CT分析和组织学观察。对剩余10个椎体（20枚椎弓根螺钉）行轴向拔出实验,分析螺钉固定强度。结果：术前绵羊腰椎BMD为0.818±0.0310 g/cm2,建模完成后为1.000±0.0316 g/cm2,BMD平均值下降22.38%,差异有统计学意义（P〈0.05）。实验组螺钉骨质界面的Tb.Th、Tb.N组较对照组分别增加143.60%和33.56%,差异有统计学意义（P〈0.05）。实验组钉道周围材料绝大部分已经降解吸收,大量新生骨组织紧密包裹螺钉;对照组钉道周围骨量较少,钉骨结合不紧密,实验组螺钉骨质界面结合优于对照组。实验组的最大轴向拔出力为1083.04±86.37N,空白组为871.76±79.03N,前者较后者提高25.26%,差异有统计学意义（P〈0.05）。结论：生物活性玻璃能显著改善骨质疏松情况下螺钉骨质界面的骨微观结构,进而提高椎弓根螺钉的把持力。     

Stress analysis of a centrally fractured rib fixated by an intramedullary screw

The stress on an intramedullary screw rib fixation device holding together a centrally fractured human rib under in vivo force loadings was studied using finite element analysis (FEA). Validation of the FEA modelling using pullout from porcine ribs proved FEA to be suitable for assessing the structural integrity of screw/bone systems such as rib fixated by a screw. In the human rib fixation investigation, it was found that intramedullary bioresorbable Bioretec screws can fixate centrally fractured human ribs under normal breathing conditions. However, under coughing conditions, simulation showed Bioretec fixating screws to bend substantially. High stresses in the screw are mainly the result of flexion induced by the force loading, and are restricted to thin regions on the outside of the screw shaft. Stiffer screws result in less locally intense stress concentrations in bone, indicating that bone failure in the bone/screw contact regions can be averted with improvements in screw stiffness.     

Analysis of human mandibular mechanics based on screw theory and in vivo data

In this paper the mechanics of human mandibular function is described in terms of the associated screws. The two distinct, yet related features of jaw mechanics, involving the motion itself as well as the forces, are both functions of the anatomical constraints, namely the contact areas that exist within the temporomandibular joint, and the forces of the muscles and tendons that allow motion to occur. The relationships that exist between these two aspects of jaw-motion are identified in this paper showing that muscle forces can be uniquely represented in terms of the action screw. This new approach to analyzing the mechanics of jaw-motion also incorporates the previously studied motion screw or helical axis. A consistent dynamic model is formulated where the action screw is used to represent the action of the closing muscle forces while the moment arms of the muscle forces are determined about the motion screw representing mandibular kinematics. The action screw formulation is verified using in vivo motion data and MR image information for a single asymptomatic subject. The results confirm the feasibility of the method and its application in dental research. A general increase in the mechanical advantage of most muscles, in the distance between action and motion screws as well as in the expended energy towards the end of the jaw-closing phase was observed. Asymmetries in the distribution of muscle force magnitudes appeared to influence the resultant force and moment of the action screw but had little effect on its spatial location. The method presented is intended to facilitate understanding of mandibular function and dysfunction.     

Evaluation of threshold stress for bone resorption around screws based on in vivo strain measurement of miniplate

The purpose of this study is to investigate the critical threshold stress causing bone resorption evaluated from strain measurement in vivo, comparing the various finite element models. In this study strains of miniplates used for mandibular fractures were measured once a week until the strains reduced. The maximum bite force for each patient was applied in the incisal, right molar and left molar region. The strains increased and reached a peak level at 2-4 weeks, whereas the bite forces increased during the period of measurements. A 3-D osteosynthesis model using finite element method showed that the compressive stresses of the bone surrounding screws ranged within approximately -40 MPa under the condition generating the same amounts of strains measured in the miniplates. Furthermore, various finite element models simulating mandibular reconstruction using the fibular graft were constructed. The models for reconstruction using single strut fibula showed distinct stress concentration in the cortical bone surrounding screws, and the peak stress levels were 2 to 3 times as strong as that of the fracture model. We conclude that critical threshold for bone resorption should be approximately -50 MPa (3600 micro strain).     

Finite Element Analysis of Minimal Invasive Transforaminal Lumbar Interbody Fusion

The purpose of our study is to develop and validate three-dimensional finite element models of transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion, and explore the most appropriate method of fixation and fusion by comparing biomechanical characteristics of different fixation method. We developed four fusion models: bilateral pedicle screws fixation with a single cage insertion model (A), bilateral pedicle screws fixation with two cages insertion model (B), unilateral pedicle screws fixation with a single cage insertion model (C), and unilateral pedicle screws fixation with two cages insertion model (D); the models were subjected to different forces including anterior bending, posterior extension, left bending, right bending, rotation, and axial compressive. The von Mises stress of the fusion segments on the pedicle screw and cages was recorded. Angular variation and stress of pedicle screw and cage were compared. There were differences of Von Mises peak stress among four models, but were within the range of maximum force. The angular variation in A, B, C, and D decreased significantly compared with normal. There was no significant difference of angular variation between A and B, and C and D. Bilateral pedicle screws fixation had more superior biomechanics than unilateral pedicle screws fixation. In conclusion, the lumbar interbody fusion models were established using varying fixation methods, and the results verified that unilateral pedicle screws fixation with a single cage could meet the stability demand in minimal invasive transforaminal interbody fusion.     

A method of quantification of stress shielding in the proximal femur using hierarchical computational modeling

Stress shielding is a biomechanical phenomenon causing adaptive changes in bone strength and stiffness around metallic implants, which potentially lead to implant loosening. Accordingly, there is a need for standard, objective engineering measures of the “stress shielding” performances of an implant that can be employed in the process of computer-aided implant design. To provide and test such measures, we developed hierarchical computational models of adaptation of the trabecular microarchitecture at different sites in the proximal femur, in response to insertion of orthopaedic screws and in response to hypothetical reductions in hip joint and gluteal muscle forces. By identifying similar bone adaptation outcomes from the two scenarios, we were able to quantify the stress shielding caused by screws in terms of analogous hypothetical reductions in hip joint and gluteal muscle forces. Specifically, we developed planar lattice models of trabecular microstructures at five regions of interest (ROI) in the proximal femur. The homeostatic and abnormal loading conditions for the lattices were determined from a finite element model of the femur at the continuum scale and fed to an iterative algorithm simulating the adaptation of each lattice to these loads. When screws were inserted to the femur model, maximal simulated bone loss (17% decrease in apparent density, 10% decrease in thickness of trabeculae) was at the greater trochanter and this effect was equivalent to the effect of 50% reduction in gluteal force and normal hip joint force. We conclude that stress shielding performances can be quantified for different screw designs using model-predicted hypothetical musculoskeletal load fractions that would cause a similar pattern and extent of bone loss to that caused by the implants.     

A method of quantification of stress shielding in the proximal femur using hierarchical computational modeling

Stress shielding is a biomechanical phenomenon causing adaptive changes in bone strength and stiffness around metallic implants, which potentially lead to implant loosening. Accordingly, there is a need for standard, objective engineering measures of the "stress shielding" performances of an implant that can be employed in the process of computer-aided implant design. To provide and test such measures, we developed hierarchical computational models of adaptation of the trabecular microarchitecture at different sites in the proximal femur, in response to insertion of orthopaedic screws and in response to hypothetical reductions in hip joint and gluteal muscle forces. By identifying similar bone adaptation outcomes from the two scenarios, we were able to quantify the stress shielding caused by screws in terms of analogous hypothetical reductions in hip joint and gluteal muscle forces. Specifically, we developed planar lattice models of trabecular microstructures at five regions of interest (ROI) in the proximal femur. The homeostatic and abnormal loading conditions for the lattices were determined from a finite element model of the femur at the continuum scale and fed to an iterative algorithm simulating the adaptation of each lattice to these loads. When screws were inserted to the femur model, maximal simulated bone loss (17% decrease in apparent density, 10% decrease in thickness of trabeculae) was at the greater trochanter and this effect was equivalent to the effect of 50% reduction in gluteal force and normal hip joint force. We conclude that stress shielding performances can be quantified for different screw designs using model-predicted hypothetical musculoskeletal load fractions that would cause a similar pattern and extent of bone loss to that caused by the implants.     

Cortical screw pullout strength and effective shear stress in synthetic third generation composite femurs

BACKGROUND: The use of artificial bone analogs in biomechanical testing of orthopaedic fracture fixation devices has increased, particularly due to the recent development of commercially available femurs such as the third generation composite femur that closely reproduce the bulk mechanical behavior of human cadaveric and/or fresh whole bone. The purpose of this investigation was to measure bone screw pullout forces in composite femurs and determine whether results are comparable to cadaver data from previous literature. METHOD OF APPROACH: The pullout strengths of 3.5 and 4.5 mm standard bicortical screws inserted into synthetic third generation composite femurs were measured and compared to existing adult human cadaveric and animal data from the literature. RESULTS: For 3.5 mm screws, the measured extraction shear stress in synthetic femurs (23.70-33.99 MPa) was in the range of adult human femurs and tibias (24.4-38.8 MPa). For 4.5 mm screws, the measured values in synthetic femurs (26.04-34.76 MPa) were also similar to adult human specimens (15.9-38.9 MPa). Synthetic femur results for extraction stress showed no statistically significant site-to-site effect for 3.5 and 4.5 mm screws, with one exception. Overall, the 4.5 mm screws showed statistically higher stress required for extraction than 3.5 mm screws. CONCLUSIONS: The third generation composite femurs provide a satisfactory biomechanical analog to human long-bones at the screw-bone interface. However, it is not known whether these femurs perform similarly to human bone during physiological screw "toggling."     

Trabecular deformations during screw pull-out: a micro-CT study of lapine bone

The mechanical fixation of endosseous implants, such as screws, in trabecular bone is challenging because of the complex porous microstructure. Development of new screw designs to improve fracture fixation, especially in high-porosity osteoporotic bone, requires a profound understanding of how the structural system implant/trabeculae interacts when it is subjected to mechanical load. In this study, pull-out tests of screw implants were performed. Screws were first inserted into the trabecular bone of rabbit femurs and then pulled out from the bone inside a computational tomography scanner. The tests were interrupted at certain load steps to acquire 3D images. The images were then analysed with a digital volume correlation technique to estimate deformation and strain fields inside the bone during the tests. The results indicate that the highest shear strains are concentrated between the inner and outer thread diameter, whereas compressive strains are found at larger distances from the screw. Tensile strains were somewhat smaller. Strain concentrations and the location of trabecular failures provide experimental information that could be used in the development of new screw designs and/or to validate numerical simulations.     

Pedicle Screw Fixation Study in Immature Porcine Spines to Improve Pullout Resistance during Animal Testing

The porcine model is frequently used during development and validation of new spinal devices, because of its likeness to the human spine. These spinal devices are frequently composed of pedicle screws with a reputation for stable fixation but which can suffer pullouts during preclinical implantation on young animals, leading to high morbidity. With a view to identifying the best choices to optimize pedicle screw fixation in the porcine model, this study evaluates ex vivo the impact of weight (age) of the animal, the level of the vertebrae (lumbar or thoracic) and the type of screw anchorage (mono- or bi-cortical) on pedicle screw pullouts. Among the 80 pig vertebrae (90- and 140-day-old) tested in this study, the average screw pullout forces ranged between 419.9N and 1341.2N. In addition, statistical differences were found between test groups, pointing out the influence of the three parameters stated above. We found that the the more caudally the screws are positioned (lumbar level), the greater their pullout resistance is, moreover, screw stability increases with the age, and finally, the screws implanted with a mono-cortical anchorage sustained lower pullout forces than those implanted with a bi-cortical anchorage. We conclude that the best anchorage can be obtained with older animals, using a lumbar fixation and long screws traversing the vertebra and inducing bi-cortical anchorage. In very young animals, pedicle screw fixations need to be bi-cortical and more numerous to prevent pullout.     

齿状突几何参数、骨密度与生物力学性质的相关性研究

目的:齿状突骨折是颈椎的严重损伤,其中大部分需要行前路螺钉内固定术治疗,齿状突的几何参数对螺钉的选择起决定性作用,其骨密度则影响螺钉对骨质的把持力,齿状突固有的生物力学性质对齿状突骨折固定效果进而对骨折愈合有较大影响,基于以上考虑,本课题分析并比较了几何参数、骨密度与生物力学性质的相关性,评价其指导临床应用的意义。方法:将15例经福尔马林浸泡的国人枢椎标本剔除周围软组织,分别测量并分析各个标本的几何参数、骨密度以及扭转刚度、剪切刚度、拉伸刚度等生物力学性质的特点,并比较它们之间的相关性。结果:齿状突为一椭球形结构,难以容纳两枚内固定螺钉,齿状突的几何参数、骨密度和生物力学性质之间没有相关性。结论:临床上在对齿状突骨折采用螺钉内固定前需要了解齿状突的解剖结构并据此选取适当尺寸的螺钉,应根据齿状突基底部的横径选择螺钉的直径,根据基底部到前唇的距离选择螺钉光滑段的长度,根据枢椎高度选择螺钉长度,齿状突的几何参数、骨密度和齿状突的生物力学性质之间并无相关性,并不能根据齿状突几何参数、骨密度来预测其生物力学强度进而预测内固定的初始稳定性。     

Micro-CT and micro-FE analysis of pedicle screw fixation under different loading conditions

Anchorage of pedicle screw instrumentation in the elderly spine with poor bone quality remains challenging. In this study, micro finite element (µFE) models were used to assess the specific influence of screw design and the relative contribution of local bone density to fixation mechanics. These were created from micro computer tomography (µCT) scans of vertebras implanted with two types of pedicle screws, including a full region-or-interest of 10 mm radius around each screw, as well as submodels for the pedicle and inner trabecular bone of the vertebral body. The local bone volume fraction (BV/TV) calculated from the µCT scans around different regions of the screw (pedicle, inner trabecular region of the vertebral body) were then related to the predicted stiffness in simulated pull-out tests as well as to the experimental pull-out and torsional fixation properties mechanically measured on the corresponding specimens. Results show that predicted stiffness correlated excellently with experimental pull-out strength (R² > 0.92, p < .043), better than regional BV/TV alone (R2 = 0.79, p = .003). They also show that correlations between fixation properties and BV/TV were increased when accounting only for the pedicle zone (R² = 0.66–0.94, p ≤ .032), but with weaker correlations for torsional loads (R² < 0.10). Our analyses highlight the role of local density in the pedicle zone on the fixation stiffness and strength of pedicle screws when pull-out loads are involved, but that local apparent bone density alone may not be sufficient to explain resistance in torsion.     

Bone mineral density and physical activity in 50–60-year-old women

The bone mineral density (BMD) of the calcaneus was measured utilizing a single energy photon absorption method in 108 women, aged 50–60 years. The women who participated in vigorous exercise two or more times a week or whose total physical activity amounted to 4 h a week had significantly higher BMD values than those who exercised less than two times a week or did less than 4 h physical activity a week. The physically active women also showed higher values for leg extension force and maximal oxygen uptake. BMD and leg extension force were positively correlated, whereas correlations between BMD and body mass, and the width of the calcaneus were negative. When other life-style variables were taken into account, such as smoking and drinking, a significant difference in BMD was found between physically active and sedentary women, but not between the smokers and non-smokers, or the drinkers and non-drinkers.