Protein secretion in the absence of ATP: the autotransporter,two-partner secretion and chaperone/usher pathways of Gram-negative bacteria (Review)

Bacteria secrete a wide variety of proteins, many of which play important roles in virulence. In Gram-negative bacteria, these proteins must cross the cytoplasmic or inner membrane, periplasm, and outer membrane to reach the cell surface. Gram-negative bacteria have evolved multiple pathways to allow protein secretion across their complex envelope. ATP is not available in the periplasm and many of these secretion pathways encode components that harness energy available at the inner membrane to drive secretion across the outer membrane. In contrast, the autotransporter, two-partner secretion and chaperone/usher pathways are comparatively simple systems that allow secretion across the outer membrane without the need for input of energy from the inner membrane. This review will present overviews of these ‘self-sufficient’ pathways, focusing on recent advances and secretion mechanisms. Similarities among the pathways and with other protein translocation mechanisms will be highlighted.     

Protein secretion through autotransporter and two-partner pathways

Two distinct protein secretion pathways, the autotransporter (AT) and the two-partner secretion (TPS) pathways are characterized by their apparent simplicity. Both are devoted to the translocation across the outer membrane of mostly large proteins or protein domains. As implied by their name, AT proteins contain their own transporter domain, covalently attached to the C-terminal extremity of the secreted passenger domain, while TPS systems are composed of two separate proteins, with TpsA being the secreted protein and TpsB its specific transporter. In both pathways, the secreted proteins are exported in a Sec-dependent manner across the inner membrane, after which they cross the outer membrane with the help of their cognate transporters. The AT translocator domains and the TpsB proteins constitute distinct families of protein-translocating, outer membrane porins of Gram-negative bacteria. Both types of transporters insert into the outer membrane as beta-barrel proteins possibly forming oligomeric pores in the case of AT and serve as conduits for their cognate secreted proteins or domains across the outer membrane. Translocation appears to be folding-sensitive in both pathways, indicating that AT passenger domains and TpsA proteins cross the periplasm and the outer membrane in non-native conformations and fold progressively at the cell surface. A major difference between AT and TPS pathways arises from the manner by which specificity is established between the secreted protein and its transporter. In AT, the covalent link between the passenger and the translocator domains ensures the translocation of the former without the need for a specific molecular recognition between the two modules. In contrast, the TPS pathway has solved the question of specific recognition between the TpsA proteins and their transporters by the addition to the TpsA proteins of an N-proximal module, the conserved TPS domain, which represents a hallmark of the TPS pathway.     

On the path to uncover the bacterial type II secretion system

Gram-negative bacteria have evolved several secretory pathways to release enzymes or toxins into the surrounding environment or into the target cells. The type II secretion system (T2SS) is conserved in Gram-negative bacteria and involves a set of 12 to 16 different proteins. Components of the T2SS are located in both the inner and outer membranes where they assemble into a supramolecular complex spanning the bacterial envelope, also called the secreton. The T2SS substrates transiently go through the periplasm before they are translocated across the outer membrane and exposed to the extracellular milieu. The T2SS is unique in its ability to promote secretion of large and sometimes multimeric proteins that are folded in the periplasm. The present review describes recently identified protein-protein interactions together with structural and functional advances in the field that have contributed to improve our understanding on how the type II secretion apparatus assembles and on the role played by individual proteins of this highly sophisticated system.     

Type I secretion in gram-negative bacteria

In gram-negative bacteria, type I secretion is carried out by a translocator made up of three proteins that span the cell envelope. One of these proteins is a specific outer membrane protein (OMP) and the other two are cytoplasmic membrane proteins: an ATP-binding cassette (ABC) and the so-called membrane fusion or adaptor protein (MFP). Type I secretion is sec-independent and bypasses the periplasm. This widespread pathway allows the secretion of proteins of diverse sizes and functions via a C-terminal uncleaved secretion signal. This C-terminal secretion signal specifically recognizes the ABC protein, triggering the assembly of the functional trans-envelope complex. This report will mainly deal will recent data concerning the structure and assembly of the secretion complex as well as the effects and role of substrate folding on secretion by this pathway.     

A TonB-like protein and a novel membrane protein containing an ATP-binding cassette function together in exotoxin secretion

Protein secretion by many Gram-negative bacteria occurs via the type II pathway involving translocation across the cytoplasmic and outer membranes in separate steps. The mechanism by which metabolic energy is supplied to the translocation across the outer membrane is unknown. Here we show that two Aeromonas hydrophila inner membrane proteins, ExeA and ExeB, are required for this process. ExeB bears sequence as well as topological similarity to TonB, a protein which opens gated ports for the inward translocation of ligands across the outer membrane. ExeA is a novel membrane protein which contains a consensus ATP-binding site. Mutations in this site dramatically decreased the rate of secretion of the toxin aerolysin from the cell. ExeB was stable when overproduced in the presence of ExeA, but was degraded when synthesized in its absence, indicating that the two proteins form a complex. These results suggest that ExeA and ExeB may act together to transduce metabolic energy to the opening of a secretion port in the outer membrane.     

The Type 1 secretion pathway — The hemolysin system and beyond

Type 1 secretion systems (T1SS) are wide-spread among Gram-negative bacteria. An important example is the secretion of the hemolytic toxin HlyA from uropathogenic strains. Secretion is achieved in a single step directly from the cytosol to the extracellular space. The translocation machinery is composed of three indispensable membrane proteins, two in the inner membrane, and the third in the outer membrane. The inner membrane proteins belong to the ABC transporter and membrane fusion protein families (MFPs), respectively, while the outer membrane component is a porin-like protein. Assembly of the three proteins is triggered by accumulation of the transport substrate (HlyA) in the cytoplasm, to form a continuous channel from the inner membrane, bridging the periplasm and finally to the exterior. Interestingly, the majority of substrates of T1SS contain all the information necessary for targeting the polypeptide to the translocation channel — a specific sequence at the extreme C-terminus. Here, we summarize our current knowledge of regulation, channel assembly, translocation of substrates, and in the case of the HlyA toxin, its interaction with host membranes. We try to provide a complete picture of structure function of the components of the translocation channel and their interaction with the substrate. Although we will place the emphasis on the paradigm of Type 1 secretion systems, the hemolysin A secretion machinery from E. coli, we also cover as completely as possible current knowledge of other examples of these fascinating translocation systems. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein trafficking and secretion in bacteria. Guest Editors: Anastassios Economou and Ross Dalbey.     

Protein Traffic in Gram-negative bacteria - how exported and secreted proteins find their way

Gram-negative bacteria assemble many proteins into the inner and outer membranes and export a large number of proteins to the periplasm or to the extracellular medium. During the billions of years bacteria have been around, they have evolved a number of different pathways with sophisticated machines to accurately and efficiently move proteins from one location to another. In this review, we first introduce specific proteins that are representative substrates of the protein transport pathways and describe their function. Then, their specific routes from synthesis to their destinations are described mentioning the signal peptide that may initiate their export and discuss what is known about the folding state of the substrates during transport. The membrane translocation device involved, the energy source required for transport, and whether a chaperone is needed will be discussed.     

The mechanism of secretion of hemolysin and other polypeptides from Gram-negative bacteria

In the secretion of polypeptides from Gram-negative bacteria, the outer membrane constitutes a specific barrier which has to be circumvented. In the majority of systems, secretion is two-step process, with initial export to the periplasm involving an N-terminal signal sequence. Transport across the outer membrane then involves a variable number of ancillary polypeptides including both periplasmic and outer membrane. While such ancillary proteins are probably specific for each secreted protein, the mechanism of movement across the outer membrane is unknown. In contrast to these systems, secretion of theE. coli hemolysin (HlyA) has several distinctive features. These include a novel targeting signal located within the last 50 or so C-terminal amino acids, the absence of any periplasmic intermediates in transfer, and a specific membrane-bound translocator, HlyB, with important mammalian homologues such as P-glycoprotein (Mdr) and the cystic fibrosis protein. In this review we discuss the nature of the HlyA targeting signal, the structure and function of HlyB, and the probability that HlyA is secreted directly to the medium through a trans-envelope complex composed of HlyB and HlyD.     

Type I secretion and multidrug efflux: transport through the TolC channel-tunnel

The crystal structure of TolC from Escherichia coli was recently determined to 2.1-A resolution and shows a unique type of channel architecture: a 12-stranded beta-barrel spans the outer membrane and is attached to a long alpha-helical channel that penetrates far into the periplasm. The structure suggests a mechanism for its role in secretion of proteins and in efflux of toxic small molecules. The TolC export pathway is compared with several import pathways of gram-negative bacteria where the outer membrane protein structures are also known.     

Protein secretion in Pseudomonas aeruginosa.

The Gram-negative bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa secretes many proteins into the extracellular medium. At least two distinct secretion pathways can be discerned. The majority of the exoproteins are secreted via a two-step mechanism. These proteins are first translocated across the inner membrane in a signal sequence-dependent fashion. The subsequent translocation across the outer membrane requires the products of at least 12 distinct xcp genes. The exact role of one of these proteins, the XcpA protein, has been resolved. It is a peptidase that is required for the processing of the precursors of four other Xcp proteins, thus allowing their assembly into the secretion apparatus. This peptidase is also required for the processing of the precursors of type IV pili subunits. Two other Xcp proteins, XcpR and XcpS, display extensive homology to proteins involved in pili biogenesis, which suggests that the assembly of the secretion apparatus and the biogenesis of type IV pili are related processes. The secretion of alkaline protease does not require the xcp gene products. This enzyme, which is encoded by the aprA gene, is not synthesized in a precursor form with an N-terminal signal sequence. Secretion across the two membranes probably takes place in one step at adhesion zones that may be constituted by three accessory proteins, designated AprD, AprE and AprF. The two secretion pathways found in P. aeruginosa appear to have disseminated widely among Gram-negative bacteria.     

Channel-tunnels: outer membrane components of type I secretion systems and multidrug efflux pumps of Gram-negative bacteria

For translocation across the cell envelope of Gram-negative bacteria, substances have to overcome two permeability barriers, the inner and outer membrane. Channel-tunnels are outer membrane proteins, which are central to two distinct export systems: the type I secretion system exporting proteins such as toxins or proteases, and efflux pumps discharging antibiotics, dyes, or heavy metals and thus mediating drug resistance. Protein secretion is driven by an inner membrane ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter while drug efflux occurs via an inner membrane proton antiporter. Both inner membrane transporters are associated with a periplasmic accessory protein that recruits an outer membrane channel-tunnel to form a functional export complex. Prototypes of these export systems are the hemolysin secretion system and the AcrAB/TolC drug efflux pump of Escherichia coli, which both employ TolC as an outer membrane component. Its remarkable conduit-like structure, protruding 100 ? into the periplasmic space, reveals how both systems are capable of transporting substrates across both membranes directly from the cytosol into the external environment. Proteins of the channel-tunnel family are widespread within Gram-negative bacteria. Their involvement in drug resistance and in secretion of pathogenic factors makes them an interesting system for further studies. Understanding the mechanism of the different export apparatus could help to develop new drugs, which block the efflux pumps or the secretion system. Electronic Publication     

Leader peptidase catalyzes the release of exported proteins from the outer surface of the Escherichia coli plasma membrane

Leader peptidase cleaves the amino-terminal leader sequences of many secreted and membrane proteins. We have examined the function of leader peptidase by constructing an Escherichia coli strain where its synthesis is controlled by the arabinose B promoter. This strain requires arabinose for growth. When the synthesis of leader peptidase is repressed, protein precursors accumulate, including the precursors of M13 coat protein (an inner membrane protein), maltose binding protein (a periplasmic protein), and OmpA protein (an outer membrane protein). These precursors are translocated across the plasma membrane, as judged by their sensitivity to added proteinase K. However, pro-OmpA and pre-maltose binding protein are retained at the outer surface of the inner membrane. Thus, leader peptides anchor translocated pre-proteins to the outer surface of the plasma membrane and must be removed to allow their subsequent release into the periplasm or transit to the outer membrane.     

Limited tolerance towards folded elements during secretion of the autotransporter Hbp

Many virulence factors secreted by pathogenic Gram-negative bacteria belong to the autotransporter (AT) family. ATs consist of a passenger domain, which is the actual secreted moiety, and a beta-domain that facilitates the transfer of the passenger domain across the outer membrane. Here, we analysed folding and translocation of the AT passenger, using Escherichia coli haemoglobin protease (Hbp) as a model protein. Dual cysteine mutagenesis, instigated by the unique crystal structure of the Hbp passenger, resulted in intramolecular disulphide bond formation dependent on the periplasmic enzyme DsbA. A small loop tied off by a disulphide bond did not interfere with secretion of Hbp. In contrast, a bond between different domains of the Hbp passenger completely blocked secretion resulting in degradation by the periplasmic protease DegP. In the absence of DegP, a translocation intermediate accumulated in the outer membrane. A similar jammed intermediate was formed upon insertion of a calmodulin folding moiety into Hbp. The data suggest that Hbp can fold in the periplasm but must retain a certain degree of flexibility and/or modest width to allow translocation across the outer membrane.     

Protein secretion in gram-negative bacteria: transport across the outer membrane involves common mechanisms in different bacteria.

The xcp genes are required for protein secretion by Pseudomonas aeruginosa. They are involved in the second step of the process, i.e. the translocation across the outer membrane, after the exoproteins have reached the periplasm in a signal peptide dependent fashion. The nucleotide sequence of a 2.5 kb DNA fragment containing xcp genes showed at least two complete open reading frames, potentially encoding proteins with molecular weights of 41 and 19 kd. Products with these apparent molecular weights were identified after expression of the DNA fragment in vitro and in vivo. Subcloning and complementation experiments showed that both proteins are required for secretion. The two products are located in the inner membrane and share highly significant homologies with the PulL and PulM proteins which are required for the specific secretion of pullulanase in Klebsiella pneumoniae. These homologies reveal the existence of a common mechanism for protein secretion in Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Klebsiella pneumoniae.     

Protein secretion systems of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and P fluorescens

Gram-negative bacteria have evolved numerous systems for the export of proteins across their dual-membrane envelopes. Three of these systems (types I, III and IV) secrete proteins across both membranes in a single energy-coupled step. Four systems (Sec, Tat, MscL and Holins) secrete only across the inner membrane, and four systems [the main terminal branch (MTB), fimbrial usher porin (FUP), autotransporter (AT) and two-partner secretion families (TPS)] secrete only across the outer membrane. We have examined the genome sequences of Pseudomonas aeruginosa PAO1 and Pseudomonas fluorescens Pf0-1 for these systems. All systems except type IV were found in P. aeruginosa, and all except types III and IV were found in P. fluorescens. The numbers of each such system were variable depending on the system and species examined. Biochemical and physiological functions were assigned to these systems when possible, and the structural constituents were analyzed. Available information regarding the mechanisms of transport and energy coupling as well as physiological functions is summarized. This report serves to identify and characterize protein secretion systems in two divergent pseudomonads, one an opportunistic human pathogen, the other a plant symbiont.     

Protein secretion in Pseudomonas aeruginosa: characterization of seven xcp genes and processing of secretory apparatus components by prepilin peptidase

The xcp genes are required for the secretion of most extracellular proteins by Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The products of these genes are essential for the transport of exoproteins across the outer membrane after they have reached the periplasm via a signal sequence-dependent pathway. To date, analysis of three xcp genes has suggested the conservation of this secretion pathway in many Gram-negative bacteria. Furthermore, the xcpA gene was shown to be identical to pilD, which encodes a peptidase involved in the processing of fimbrial (pili) subunits, suggesting a connection between pili biogenesis and protein secretion. Here the nucleotide sequences of seven other xcp genes, designated xcpR to -X, are presented. The N-termini of four of the encoded Xcp proteins display similarity to the N-termini of type IV pili, suggesting that XcpA is involved in the processing of these Xcp proteins. This could indeed be demonstrated in vivo. Furthermore, two other proteins, XcpR and XcpS, show similarity to the PilB and PilC proteins required for fimbriae assembly. Since XcpR and PilB display a canonical nucleotide-binding site, ATP hydrolysis may provide energy for both systems.     

Protein secretion in Pseudomonas aeruginosa

Abstract The Gram-negative bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa secretes many proteins into the extracellular medium. At least two distinct secretion pathways can be discerned. The majority of the exoproteins are secreted via a two-step mechanism. These proteins are first translocated across the inner membrane in a signal sequence-dependent fashion. The subsequent translocation across the outer membrane requires the products of at least 12 distinct xcp genes. The exact role of one of these proteins, the XcpA protein, has been resolved. It is a peptidase that is required for the processing of the precursors of four other Xcp proteins, thus allowing their assembly into the secretion apparatus. This peptidase is also required for the processing of the precursors of type IV pili subunits. Two other Xcp proteins, XcpR and XcpS, display extensive homology to proteins involved in pili biogenesis, which suggests that the assembly of the secretion apparatus and the biogenesis of type IV pili are related processes. The secretion of alkaline protease does not require the xcp gene products. This enzyme, which is encoded by the aprA gene, is not synthesized in a precursor form with an N-terminal signal sequence. Secretion across the two membranes probably takes place in one step at adhesion zones that may be constituted by three accessory proteins, designated AprD, AprE and AprF. The two secretion pathways found in P. aeruginosa appear to habe disseminate widely among Gram-negative bacteria.     

Tied down: tethering redox proteins to the outer membrane in Neisseria and other genera

Typically, the redox proteins of respiratory chains in Gram-negative bacteria are localized in the cytoplasmic membrane or in the periplasm. An alternative arrangement appears to be widespread within the betaproteobacterial genus Neisseria, wherein several redox proteins are covalently associated with the outer membrane. In the present paper, we discuss the structural properties of these outer membrane redox proteins and the functional consequences of this attachment. Several tethered outer membrane redox proteins of Neisseria contain a weakly conserved repeated structure between the covalent tether and the redox protein globular domain that should enable the redox cofactor-containing domain to extend from the outer membrane, across the periplasm and towards the inner membrane. It is argued that the constraints imposed on the movement and orientation of the globular domains by these tethers favours the formation of electron-transfer complexes for entropic reasons. The attachment to the outer membrane may also affect the exposure of the host to redox proteins with a moonlighting function in the host-microbe interaction, thus affecting the host response to Neisseria infection. We identify putative outer membrane redox proteins from a number of other bacterial genera outside Neisseria, and suggest that this organizational arrangement may be more common than previously recognized.     

The structure of the cytoplasmic domain of EpsL, an inner membrane component of the type II secretion system of Vibrio cholerae: an unusual member of the actin-like ATPase superfamily

The type II secretion system (T2SS) is used by several Gram-negative bacteria for the secretion of hydrolytic enzymes and virulence factors across the outer membrane. In these secretion systems, a complex of 12-15 so-called "Gsp proteins" spans from a regulatory ATPase in the cytoplasm, via several signal or energy transducing proteins in the inner membrane and the pseudopilins in the periplasm, to the actual pore in the outer membrane. The human pathogen Vibrio cholerae employs such an assembly, called the Eps system, for the export of its major virulence factor, cholera toxin, from its periplasm into the lumen of the gastro-intestinal tract of the host. Here, we report the atomic structure of the major cytoplasmic domain of the inner membrane-spanning EpsL protein from V. cholerae. EpsL is the binding partner of the regulatory ATPase EpsE as well as of EpsM and pseudopilins, and is therefore a critical link between the cytoplasmic and the periplasmic part of the Eps-system. The 2.7A resolution structure was determined by a combination of Se-Met multiple anomalous dispersion (MAD) and multiple isomorphous replacement with anomalous scattering (MIRAS) phasing methods. The 28kDa cytoplasmic domain of EpsL (cyto-EpsL) consists of three beta-sheet-rich domains. With domains I and III similar to the RNaseH-fold, cyto-EpsL unexpectedly shows structural homology with the superfamily of actin-like ATPases. cyto-EpsL, however, is an unusual member of this superfamily as it misses the canonical actin domains 1B and 2B, which are common yet variable in this superfamily. Moreover, cyto-EpsL has an additional domain II, which has the topology of an SHS2-fold module. Within the superfamily this fold module has been observed only for domain 1C of the cell division protein FtsA, in which it mediates protein-protein interactions. This domain II displays great flexibility and contributes to a pronounced negatively charged canyon on the surface of cyto-EpsL. Functional data as well as structural homology and sequence conservation suggest that domain II interacts with EpsE, the major cytoplasmic binding partner of EpsL.     

Role of DegP for two-partner secretion in Bordetella

Sorting of proteins destined to the surface or the extracellular milieu is mediated by specific machineries, which guide the protein substrates towards the proper route of secretion and determine the compartment in which folding occurs. In Gram-negative bacteria, the two-partner secretion (TPS) pathway is dedicated to the secretion of large proteins rich in β-helical structure. The secretion of the filamentous haemagglutinin (FHA), a 230 kDa adhesin of Bordetella pertussis , represents a model TPS system. FHA is exported by the Sec machinery and transits through the periplasm in an extended conformation. From there it is translocated across the outer membrane by its dedicated transporter FhaC to finally fold into a long β-helix at the cell surface in a progressive manner. In this work, we show that B. pertussis lacking the periplasmic chaperone/protease DegP has a strong growth defect at 37°C, and the integrity of its outer membrane is compromised. While both phenotypes are significantly aggravated by the presence of FHA, the chaperone activity of DegP markedly alleviates the periplasmic stress. In vitro , DegP binds to non-native FHA with high affinity. We propose that DegP chaperones the extended FHA polypeptide in the periplasm and is thus involved in the TPS pathway.