A comparison of mathematical methods for the analysis of DNA histograms obtained by flow cytometry

Abstract. Twelve methods for analysing FCM-histograms were compared using the same set of data. Some of the histograms that were analysed were simulated by computer and some were taken from experiments. Simulated data were generated assuming asynchronously growing cell populations and (i) measurement coefficients of variation ( CV ) from 2 to 16%; (ii) constant measurement CV or CV 's increasing from G₁ to G₂ phase, and (iii) varying fractions of cells in each phase. Simulated data were also generated assuming synchronous cell populations in which a block in early S phase was applied and released. DNA histograms were measured for L-929 cells at various times after mitotic selection. Labelling indices were also measured for these cells at the same time.
The fractions of cells in the G₁, S, and (G₂+ M) phases were calculated by each analytical method and compared with the actual fractions used for simulation, or in case of experimental data, with autoradiographic results. Generally, all methods yielded reasonably accurate fractions of cells in each phase with relative errors in the range of 10–20%. However, most methods tended to overestimate G₁ fractions and underestimate S fractions. In addition, variations in the shape of the S phase distribution often caused considerable errors. Phase fractions were also calculated for histograms of kinetically perturbed populations, simulated as well as experimental The errors were only slightly larger than for histograms from asynchronously growing cell populations.     

Rapid hypotonic method for flow cytofluorometry of monolayer cell cultures. Some pitfalls in staining and data analysis.

The rapid hypotonic staining procedure developed by Krishan for DNA determinations by flow cytofluorometry has been proven accurate for in vivo cell samples and for cell lines growing in suspension culture. We show that the unmodified procedure may produce distorted DNA histograms when used for staining cells growing in monolayer cultures, however. To eliminate these distortions, it was necessary to avoid the use of trypsin by staining the attached cells directly, using a hypotonic fluorochrome solution to which nonionic detergent was added. Two sublines of HeLa S3 cells are shown to exhibit major differences in their staining characteristics. By using our revised staining procedure, the two sublines appear to produce very satisfactory DNA histograms. However, in only one subline does the S phase fraction calculated from the histograms agree with the autoradiographical labeling index. Mitotic cells remain intact under these staining conditions, and the principal observed effect of nonionic detergents in this case is to decrease the coefficient of variation of fluorescence intensity.     

GROWTH CHARACTERISTICS OF MARINE PHYTOPLANKTON DETERMINED BY CELL CYCLE PROTEINS: THE CELL CYCLE OF ETHMODISCUS REX (BACILLARIOPHYCEAE) IN THE SOUTHWESTERN NORTH ATLANTIC OCEAN AND CARIBBEAN SEA1

Ethmodiscus spp. is an important contributor to oceanic tropical-ooze sediments and thus might be an important transport vehicle of carbon from the ocean surface to sediments. The knowledge of its cell cycle and growth rate, which is still lacking, is necessary to evaluate the importance of Ethmodiscus in nutrient cycling and to solve the discrepancy between its high sedimentary abundance and rarity in the plankton. We used immunofluorescence of a cell cycle protein, prolqerating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), and DNA-specific staining to study the progression of the cell cycle and roughly estimate the growth rate for E. rex (Rattray) Wiseman and Hendey in the southwestern North Atlantic Ocean and Caribbean Sea in June 1994 and January 1995. During the cell division cycle, the chloroplasts appeared to synthesize DNA before the nucleus (S phase). Following the S phase, the nucleus moved from one end of the cell toward the center underneath the midline of the girdle band (G2 phase) where it divided (M phase). During a very brief period, the parent cell split and moved apart from the girdle midline, and two new valves were produced (late M phase). The two daughter nuclei apparently remained attached at the joint of the two newly produced valves, where they appeared to be responsible for coordinating the symmetrical formation of the new valves. The morphologically complete daughter cells remained joined for a short period of time before separating into solitary cells whose nucleus was located at one end of the cell. Derived from the phase fraction curves, the duration of the cell cycle phases decreased in the order from G1, S, G2, to M. A conservative estimate of the growth rate in the study area obtained by using PCNA immunostaining was 0.39–0.46 d^?1 in June and 0.15 d^?1 in January. The validity and implication of the growth rate estimates are discussed.     

The analysis and interpretation of DNA distributions measured by flow cytometry

A principal use of flow cytometers is for the measurement of fluorescence distributions of cells stained with DNA specific dyes. A large amount of effort has been and is being expended currently in the analysis of these distributions for the fractions of cells in the G1, S, and G2 + M phases. Several methods of analysis have been proposed and are being used; new methods continue to be introduced. Many, if not most, of these methods differ only in the mathematical function used to represent the phases of the cell cycle and represent attempts to fit exactly distributions with known phase fractions or unusual shapes. In this paper we show that these refinements probably are not necessary because of cell staining and sampling variability. This hypothesis was tested by measuring fluorescence distributions for Chinese hamster ovary and KHT mouse sarcoma cells stained with Hoechst-33258, chromomycin A3, propidium iodide, and acriflavine. Our results show that: a) single measurements can result in phase fraction estimates that are in error by as much as 40% for G2 + M phase and 15-20% for G1 and S phases; b) different dyes can yield phase fraction estimates that differ by as much as 40% due to differences in DNA specificity; c) the shapes of fluorescence distributions and their interpretation are very dependent on the dye being used and on its binding mechanism.     

Expression of proliferation associated antigens in the cell cycle of synchronized mammalian cells.

Flow cytometric bivariate analysis was used to investigate the expression of PCNA, p120 and p145 during the cell cycle of a mammalian cell line (CHO-K1). Initially, aliquots of cells in exponential and plateau (G0) phase were analyzed for proliferation associated antigen expression. Expression of PCNA and p145 during G0 was markedly depressed (less than 12% positive) while 54% of the G0 cells stained positive for p120. The fluorescent intensity (mean channel fluorescence) of these G0 positive p120 cells, however, was only slightly above the mean channel fluorescence (MCF) of cells stained with a negative isotype control. In asynchronous cultures, all three antigens were expressed in greater than 70% of the cells, with PCNA staining being greater than 95%. Cells were then synchronized using mitotic selection (mitotic index of 97%) and antigen levels were measured as cells progressed synchronously through the cell cycle. From DNA analysis histograms, it appeared that the degree of synchrony was approximately 90% throughout the remainder of the cell cycle. The bivariate DNA/PCNA, DNA/p120, and DNA/p145 histograms for mitotic cells indicated that both p120 and p145 expression were elevated (percent positive and MCF) while PCNA levels were near controls (MCF). In early G1, all three markers were depressed (less than 12% positive); however PCNA levels rose precipitously in mid-G1 (greater than 50% positive). In late G1 to early S, p145 levels increased concomitantly with increases in p120. All three antigens were elevated throughout S phase and began to decline as cells moved from G2/M to G1 of the next cell cycle with p145 expression decreasing first. This report indicates that all three proliferation associated antigens studied are differentially expressed in the cell cycle and therefore may be useful in detecting and assessing the proliferation state.     

GROWTH CHARACTERISTICS OF PHYTOPLANKTON DETERMINED BY CELL CYCLE PROTEINS: PCNA IMMUNOSTAINING OF DUNALIELLA TERTIOLECTA (CHLOROPHYCEAE)1

By immunohistochemistry and immunofluorescence methods, we observed that the analog of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) in Dunaliella tertiolecta Butcher (Chlorophyceae) was exclusively located in the nucleus. Among positively stained cells, PCNA abundance varied, being highest in S-phase cells, lower in others, and undetectable in early G1- or late M-phase cells. In exponentially growing and partially synchronized cultures, the percentage of PCNA-stained cells (% PCNA-stained cells) oscillated in the photocycle (12:12 h LD). It increased during the light period and reached a peak (75%) before the onset of the dark period when the culture was mainly (71%) in the S phase of the cell cycle. The DNA synthesis inhibitor, hydroxyurea, depressed PCNA abundance, whereas no effect was detected for the mitosis inhibitor colchicine. We conclude that PCNA in D. tertiolecta is associated with the S phase of the cell cycle where it is accumulated and functioning. PCNA was used to characterize the growth pattern of cultures grown in different media, temperatures, and growth stages. The time lag between the PCNA-stained phase and the M phase was very short in a continuous culture grown in reduced f/2 medium at 22°C and was considerably longer in the cultures grown in f/2 at 15°C. When an exponentially growing culture grew older, % PCNA-stained cells decreased. In a late stationary culture where there was no net growth, a small number of cells were still cycling through the PCNA-stained phase and cell division. In the continuous culture grown at 22°C, the duration of the PCNA-stained phase (T_s) was 13 h. Calculations with this T_s and % PCNA-stained cells yielded a growth rate of 0.77 d^?1, which was close to that obtained by cell counts (0.69 d^?1). Taken together, the results suggest that PCNA is a useful indicator of growth status and a promising cell cycle marker for estimation of species-specific growth rate.     

Requirement for proliferating cell nuclear antigen expression during stages of the Chinese hamster ovary cell cycle

Proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA/cyclin) is a nuclear protein that can stimulate purified DNA polymerase delta in vitro, and its synthesis correlates with the proliferation rate of cells. We have attempted to determine whether synthesis of PCNA/cyclin in Chinese hamster ovary cells is necessary to regulate entry into S phase. We have measured cellular PCNA/cyclin concentration of the mRNA or protein throughout the cell cycle. Cells were separated by centrifugal elutriation into populations enriched for G-1, S, and G-2/M phases. Quantitative Northern hybridization analysis was performed on RNA isolated from each cell population by using a cDNA clone of PCNA/cyclin as a probe. Results demonstrated that although intact PCNA/cyclin mRNA is present during all phases of the cell cycle, an induction of about 3-fold occurs during S phase. Two-parameter staining for PCNA/cyclin and DNA, and analysis by flow cytometry, confirmed that the quantity of PCNA/cyclin protein in the cells increases severalfold in G-1 or early S phase but generally is invariant in S and G-2/M phases. This cell cycle dependence of PCNA/cyclin expression suggests that the observed synthesis is a prerequisite for initiation of DNA replication. Introduction of an antisense oligonucleotide complementary to the PCNA/cyclin mRNA to inhibit PCNA/cyclin synthesis effectively prevented entry of G-1 phase cells into S phase. A complementary sense oligonucleotide used as a control did not have an inhibitory effect. This result suggests that a threshold concentration of PCNA/cyclin is necessary for entry into S phase.     

Human DNA polymerase epsilon colocalizes with proliferating cell nuclear antigen and DNA replication late, but not early, in S phase.

DNA polymerase epsilon (pol epsilon) has been implicated in DNA replication, DNA repair, and cell cycle control, but its precise roles are unclear. When the subcellular localization of human pol epsilon was examined by indirect immunofluorescence, pol epsilon appeared in discrete nuclear foci that colocalized with proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) foci and sites of DNA synthesis only late in S phase. Early in S phase, pol epsilon foci were adjacent to PCNA foci. In contrast to PCNA foci that were only present in S phase, pol epsilon foci were present throughout mitosis and the G(1) phase of cycling cells. It is hypothesized from these observations that pol epsilon and PCNA have separate but associated functions early in S phase and that pol epsilon participates with PCNA in DNA replication late in S phase.     

Cytotoxic and antiproliferative effects induced by a non terpenoid polar extract of A. indica seeds on 3T6 murine fibroblasts in culture

Neem oil is a natural product obtained from the seeds of the tree Azadirachta indica. Its composition is very complex and the oil exhibits a number of biological activities. The most studied component is the terpenoid azadirachtin which is used for its insecticidal and putative antimicrobial properties. In this report we investigate the biological activity of partially purified components of the oil obtained from A. indica. We show that the semi-purified fractions have moderate to strong cytotoxicity. However, this is not attributable to azadirachtin but to other active compounds present in the mixture. Each fraction was further purified by appropriate extraction procedures and we observed a differential cytotoxicity in the various sub-fractions. This led us to investigate the mode of cell death. After treatment with the oil fractions we observed positivity to TUNEL staining and extensive internucleosomal DNA degradation both indicating apoptotic death. The anti-proliferative properties of the neem oil-derived compounds were also assayed by evaluation of the nuclear PCNA levels (Proliferating Cell Nuclear Antigen). PCNA is significantly reduced in cells treated with a specific fraction of neem oil. Finally, our results strongly suggest a possible involvement of the mitochondrial pathway in the apoptotic death.     

Preparation of conjugates of 19s and 7s globulins of antitularemic sera for the determination of specific fluorescence ofPasteurella tularensis

Pasteurella tularensis was detected by means of conjugates of 19S and 7S globulins from antitularemic serum with fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC). The serum was obtained by short-term immunization of rabbits. The capacity of both fractions to produce the immunofluorescence reaction with pure culturesof Pasteurella tularensis and the agglutinin titre of these fractions are compared here. It was found that the 19S globulin fraction which contained most agglutinating antibodies showed only weak immunofluorescence. The 7S fraction in which the agglutinin content was very low as compared with the 19S globulin fraction gave more intense fluorescence than the 19S fraction. On the basis of this finding the opinion is advanced that the agglutinating antibodies need not be the actual carrier of fluorescence due to fluorescent antibodies (FA) in the immunofluorescence reaction ofPasteurella tularensis. The different degrees of labelling with FITC of the individual globulin fractions as observed during simultaneous conjugation are also discussed. The 19S globulin fraction is regularly conjugated to a higher degree than the 7S component. The view is presented that the avirulent strains lack a certain part of the antigen structure as compared with virulent or vaccine strains (with residual virulence), the part being responsible for the positive reaction of immunofluorescence with preparations of fluorescent antibodies.     

A practical graphical method for estimating the fraction of cells in S in DNA histograms from clinical tumor samples containing aneuploid cell populations

A graphical method for the analysis of unperturbed DNA histograms is presented in which the area of the normalized histogram subtended by the fraction of cells in S is represented by a trapezoid whose dimensions are dependent on features common to all such histograms. The technique takes measurement variability into account. This method was applied to a variety of synthetic DNA histograms. Overall, calculated values for the fraction of cells in S correlated well with actual values. This method was applied to 36 diploid cases of non-Hodgkin lymphoma; results correlated well with those obtained by a computer-based method. The results of the graphical-method were also highly reproducible between different observers. The graphical method can be used in the presence of aneuploid cell populations. Techniques for calculating S fractions in the presence of aneuploidy in clinical samples are described. These techniques were applied to synthetic histograms of mixed diploid and aneuploid populations. Calculated values correlated well with actual values.     

Proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) is expressed in activated rat skeletal muscle satellite cells

Skeletal muscle satellite cells from uninjured muscle of adult animals are generally found to be in a quiescent state, and when cultured, they remain quiescent in vitro for a period of time which is directly related to the age of the donor animal. A technique for studying the activation of satellite cells in primary cultures has been developed and employs proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) as a marker for entrance into the S phase of the cell cycle. PCNA is a protein involved in DNA replication and is maximally expressed in S phase of the cell cycle. We monitored PCNA expression in satellite cells isolated from young (3 week) and adult (9 month) rats, and our results indicate that satellite cells begin to accumulate PCNA prior to changes in cell number in both age groups. Using ELISA techniques, we demonstrated that addition of an extract of crushed muscle (CME) activated satellite cells and significantly reduced the length of the lag phase in cells from both age groups. Addition of bFGF shortened the lag phase of PCNA synthesis in satellite cells from 3-week-old rats but had no effect on the kinetics of PCNA expression in cells from 9-month-old rats. Based on our experiments, PCNA expression can be used as a marker to follow the entry of satellite cells into the cell cycle in primary mass cultures. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Intranuclear localization of proliferating cell nuclear antigen during the cell cycle in renal cell carcinoma

OBJECTIVE: To investigate, with laser scanning cytometry (LSC), proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) expression during the cell cycle in renal cell carcinoma. STUDY DESIGN: DNA ploidy and intracellular localization of PCNA in renal cell carcinoma were determined using LSC and immunohistochemistry. The subjects were nine patients who had received surgery for renal cell carcinoma. After DNA ploidy analysis, the glass slides were restained by immunohistochemistry of PCNA. LSC allowed direct observation of PCNA localization during the cell cycle because we could obtain immunohistochemical staining of PCNA as a function of cell cycle phase for individual cells. RESULTS: PCNA was not demonstrated in the nuclei of G0/G1 cells. PCNA expression increased from the S phase of the cell cycle. PCNA rapidly degraded at the end of the G2 phase. In the late G2 and M phase, PCNA was not detected in almost any nucleus. CONCLUSION: LSC allows morphologic observation of the intracellular distribution of PCNA during the cell cycle in renal cell carcinoma.     

A method of DNA histogram analysis by computer and its evaluation by simultaneous combination with 3H-thymidine autoradiography

A method for determining the fractions of cells in the G1, S, and G2 + M phases of the cell life cycle, by quantifying DNA histograms derived from static fluorescence cytophotometry, was evaluated by simultaneous combination with 3H-thymidine autoradiography. DNA histograms were obtained by cytofluorometry on the Feulgen-stained autoradiographs of HeLa cells, and mouse and rat hepatocytes, after DNA labelling with 3H-thymidine. The synthetic histogram determined by "sum of discrete normal curves" technique was fitted to the experimental data according to a weighted least-squares method by a desk-top computer (HP 85F). The mean relative percent deviations of estimated cell cycle phase fractions from the actual phase fractions determined directly on an autoradiograph was 6.6 +/- 3.3%.     

Proliferating Cell Nuclear Antigen Bound to DNA Synthesis Sites: Phosphorylation and Association with Cyclin D1 and Cyclin A

Evidence is presented that association of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) with nuclear chromatin in human fibroblasts is related to the phosphorylation status of the protein. Using a hypotonic lysis procedure to extract the soluble form of PCNA, it has been shown that the remaining nuclear-bound form, predominantly in S-phase cells, is highly phosphorylated. Cells in early G₁, or in G₂ + M phases, contain basal levels of the bound form of the protein that is only weakly phosphorylated. Using fractionated immunoprecipitation techniques, PCNA was found to be associated with cyclin A in both soluble and insoluble fractions. In contrast, association of PCNA with cyclin D1 was found in the soluble fraction, while no detectable levels were present in the insoluble fraction. Immunofluorescence labeling and flow cytometric analysis of the cell cycle distribution of cyclin D1 and cyclin A showed that, like PCNA, maximal levels of both proteins were bound to nuclear structures at the G₁/S phase boundary. These results suggest that binding of PCNA to DNA synthesis sites occurs after phosphorylation. Association with cyclin D1 and cyclin A might occur in a macromolecular complex assembled at the G₁/S phase boundary to drive activation of DNA replication factors.     

Expression of cell cycle related proteins—proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and statin—during adaptation and de-adaptation of EUE cells to a hypertonic medium

EUE cells adapted to grow for long times in a hypertonic medium have a longer cell cycle than those growing in isotonic medium. To elucidate whether this lengthening involves specific cycle phases to differing extents, the expression of two cycle-related protein, PCNA and statin, was studied by dual parameter flow cytometry of indirect immunofluorescence protein labelling and DNA content. In isotonic medium, most cells, in all the cycle phases, were PCNA positive; in contrast, PCNA negative cells and statin positive cells were very few in number and only fell in the G0/1 range of DNA contents. In hypertonic medium, the frequency of PCNA positive cells was lower, and that of statin positive cells higher, than in isotonic medium, particularly in the G0/1 range of DNA contents: this suggests that a G0 block occurs under long-term hypertonic stress. Consistently, dual parameter flow cytometric measurement of BrdUrd immunofluorescence labelling and DNA content showed that fewer cells entered S phase in hypertonic medium and their progression through the S phase was slower; evidence was also found for the occurrence of a G2 block. These kinetics changes were fully reversible in isotonic medium, thus indicating the adaptive nature of the EUE response to hypertonicity.     

Simultaneous measurement of DNA content and cell-surface immunofluorescence of human bone marrow cells using a single laser flow cytometer.

This paper describes the measurement of S phase DNA content in human bone marrow subpopulations using a single laser method for bivariate analysis of DNA content and cell-surface immunofluorescence (s-IF). Low density (less than 1.077 g/ml) bone marrow cells were labeled with a panel of unconjugated monoclonal antibodies (MoAb) for the lymphoid (CD2 + CD19), T-lymphoid (CD2), B-lymphoid (CD19), erythroid (anti-glycophorin-A), myelomonocytic (CD13, CD33; single and as cocktail) and monocytic (CD14) lineages. A fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC)-conjugated goat anti-mouse label was used as second step. Unfixed, MoAb-labeled cells were incubated for 24 h with a hypotonic propidium iodide solution for DNA staining. Cells were analysed on a single-laser flow cytometer, operating at 488 nm. The effect of the combined staining protocol upon both s-IF and DNA stainability was evaluated. Only a slight decrease (mean: 29.0%) in s-IF intensity was observed after DNA staining. The percentages of immunofluorescent cells in the bone marrow samples of 10 normal individuals before and after DNA staining were essentially unchanged for all the MoAbs used. The DNA histograms of the immunophenotypically defined subpopulations were of excellent quality with a mean coefficient or variation of 1.8%. This procedure allows the assessment of very low levels of S-phase DNA content, as measured in normal low density blood cells of 8 healthy volunteers (mean 0.07%).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Cell-Cycle Analysis Using A Monoclonal Antibody to Brdurd

The flow cytometric measurement of DNA distributions of cells has many applications in biomedical research. Phase fractions estimated (calculated) from such distributions are used to study the growth characteristics of various types of cells, particularly when the cells have been exposed to perturbing agents such as chemotherapeutic drugs. For more than 10 years many methods for resolving DNA distributions into the three cell subpopulations (G₁, S and G₂, + M) have been reported in the literature. A new method of analysis utilizing a monoclonal antibody to bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) has been developed (Gratzner, 1982; Dolbeare et al., 1983) which makes it possible in most cases to accurately determine phase fractions without resorting to mathematical models. the procedure involves the incorporation of BrdUrd by growing (DNA synthesizing) S phase cells, labelling the BrdUrd with a fluorescent monoclonal antibody, and the bivariate measurement of the antibody and of total DNA content, the latter through propidium-iodide staining. the resulting bivariate distributions clearly and simply resolve the three subpopulations. This paper describes the method and illustrates its use in the analysis of various fractions of elutriated exponentially growing Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells.     

Investigations on Antioxidant,Antiproliferative and COX‐2 Inhibitory Potential of Alkaloids from Anthocephalus cadamba (Roxb.) Miq. Leaves

In the present study, an ayurvedic medicinal plant, Anthocephalus cadamba (Roxb .) Miq . commonly known as ‘Kadamb’ was explored for its potential against oxidative stress and cancer. The fractions namely AC‐4 and ACALK (alkaloid rich fraction) were isolated from A. cadamba leaves by employing two different isolation methods and evaluated for their in vitro antioxidant and antiproliferative activity. The structure of the isolated AC‐4 was characterized tentatively as dihydrocadambine by using various spectroscopic techniques such as ESI‐QTOF‐MS, ¹H‐ and ¹³C‐NMR, DEPT, COSY, HMQC, and HMBC. Results of various antioxidant assays viz. 2,2‐diphenyl‐1‐picrylhydrazyl (DPPH), ABTS cation radical, superoxide anion radical scavenging, and plasmid nicking assay demonstrated that both the fractions viz. AC‐4 and ACALK possess ability to scavenge DPPH, ABTS radicals and effectively protected plasmid pBR322 DNA from damage caused by hydroxyl radicals. Further, when both fractions were evaluated for their potential to suppress growth of HeLa and COLO 205 cells, only ACALK fraction showed antiproliferative effects. ACALK exhibited GI₅₀ of 205.98 and 99.54 μg/ml in HeLa and COLO 205 cell lines, respectively. Results of Hoechst staining in cervical carcinoma (HeLa) cells confirmed that ACALK induced cell death in HeLa cells via apoptotic mode. Both the fractions also inhibited COX‐2 enzyme activity.