Dependence of RelA-mediated (p)ppGpp formation on tRNA identity

The bacterial stringent response is a cellular response to amino acid limitations and is characterized by the accumulation of the alarmone polyphosphate guanosine ((p)ppGpp). A key molecular event leading to (p)ppGpp synthesis is the binding of a deacylated tRNA to the vacant A-Site of a ribosome. The resulting ribosomal complex is recognized by and activates RelA, the (p)ppGpp synthetase. Activated RelA catalyzes (p)ppGpp formation until the deacylated tRNA passively dissociates from the ribosomal A-Site. In this report, we have investigated a novel role for the identity of A-Site bound tRNA in RelA-mediated (p)ppGpp synthesis. A comparison in the stimulation of RelA activity was made using ribosome complexes with either a tightly or weakly binding deacylated tRNA occupying the A-Site. In vitro analysis reveals that ribosome complexes formed with tight binding tRNA(Val) stimulate RelA activity at lower concentrations than that required for ribosome complexes formed with the weaker binding tRNA(Phe). The data suggest that the recovery from the stringent response may be dependent on the identity of the amino acid that was initially limiting for the bacteria.     

Function of the ribosomal E-site: a mutagenesis study

Ribosomes synthesize proteins according to the information encoded in mRNA. During this process, both the incoming amino acid and the nascent peptide are bound to tRNA molecules. Three binding sites for tRNA in the ribosome are known: the A-site for aminoacyl-tRNA, the P-site for peptidyl-tRNA and the E-site for the deacylated tRNA leaving the ribosome. Here, we present a study of Escherichia coli ribosomes with the E-site binding destabilized by mutation C2394G of the 23S rRNA. Expression of the mutant 23S rRNA in vivo caused increased frameshifting and stop codon readthrough. The progression of these ribosomes through the ribosomal elongation cycle in vitro reveals ejection of deacylated tRNA during the translocation step or shortly after. E-site compromised ribosomes can undergo translocation, although in some cases it is less efficient and results in a frameshift. The mutation affects formation of the P/E hybrid site and leads to a loss of stimulation of the multiple turnover GTPase activity of EF-G by deacylated tRNA bound to the ribosome.     

A new kinetic model reveals the synergistic effect of E-, P- and A-sites on +1 ribosomal frameshifting

Programmed ribosomal frameshifting (PRF) is a process by which ribosomes produce two different polypeptides from the same mRNA. In this study, we propose three different kinetic models of +1 PRF, incorporating the effects of the ribosomal E-, P- and A-sites toward promoting efficient +1 frameshifting in Escherichia coli. Specifically, the timing of E-site tRNA dissociation is discussed within the context of the kinetic proofreading mechanism of aminoacylated tRNA (aa-tRNA) selection. Mathematical modeling using previously determined kinetic rate constants reveals that destabilization of deacylated tRNA in the E-site, rearrangement of peptidyl-tRNA in the P-site, and availability of cognate aa-tRNA corresponding to the A-site act synergistically to promote efficient +1 PRF. The effect of E-site codon:anticodon interactions on +1 PRF was also experimentally examined with a dual fluorescence reporter construct. The combination of predictive modeling and empirical testing allowed the rate constant for P-site tRNA slippage (k_s) to be estimated as k_s ≈1.9 s⁻¹ for the release factor 2 (RF2) frameshifting sequence. These analyses suggest that P-site tRNA slippage is the driving force for +1 ribosomal frameshifting while the presence of a ‘hungry codon’ in the A-site and destabilization in the E-site further enhance +1 PRF in E. coli.     

The effect of tRNA binding on the structure of 5 S RNA in Escherichia coli. A chemical modification study

The structure of 5 S RNA within the 70 S ribosome from Escherichia coli was studied using the chemical reagent kethoxal (alpha-keto-beta-ethoxybutyraldehyde) to modify accessible guanosines. The modification pattern of 5 S RNA from free 70 S ribosomes was compared with that of poly(U) programmed ribosomes where tRNA had been bound to both the A- and P-sites. Binding to the ribosomal A-site was achieved enzymatically using the elongation factor Tu and GTP in the presence of deacylated tRNA which blocks the ribosomal P-site. Modified guanosines were identified after partial RNase T1 hydrolysis and separation of the hydrolysis products on sequencing gels. Binding of tRNA to the ribosome leads to a strong protection of 5 S RNA guanosine G-41 and to some degree G-44 from kethoxal modification. The limited RNase T1 hydrolysis pattern provides evidence for the existence of a 5 S RNA conformation different from the known 5 S RNA A- and B-forms which are characterized by their gel electrophoretic mobility. The importance of 5 S RNA for the binding of tRNA to the ribosome is discussed.     

Synthesis and hydrolysis of pppGpp in mycobacteria: a ligand mediated conformational switch in Rel

Bacteria respond to starvation by synthesizing a polyphosphate derivative of guanosine, (p)ppGpp, that helps the bacteria in surviving during stress. The protein in Gram-positive organisms required for (p)ppGpp synthesis is Rel, a bifunctional enzyme that carries out both synthesis and hydrolysis of this molecule. Rel shows increased pppGpp synthesis in the presence of uncharged tRNA, the effect of which is regulated by the C-terminal of Rel. We show by fluorescence resonance energy transfer that the distance between the N-terminus cysteine residue at the catalytic domain and C692 at the C-terminus increases upon the addition of uncharged tRNA. In apparent anomaly, the steady state anisotropy of the Rel protein decreases upon tRNA binding suggesting "compact conformation" vis-à-vis "open conformation" of the free Rel. We propose that the interaction between C692 and the residues present in the pppGpp synthesis site results in the regulated activity and this interaction is abrogated upon addition of uncharged tRNA. We also report here the binding of pppGpp to the C-terminal part of the protein that leads to more unfolding in this region.     

Deacylated tRNA is released from the E site upon A site occupation but before GTP is hydrolyzed by EF-Tu

The presence or absence of deacylated tRNA at the E site sharply influences the activation energy required for binding of a ternary complex to the ribosomal A site indicating the different conformations that the E-tRNA imparts on the ribosome. Here we address two questions: (i) whether or not peptidyltransferase—the essential catalytic activity of the large ribosomal subunit—also depends on the occupancy state of the E site and (ii) at what stage the E-tRNA is released during an elongation cycle. Kinetics of the puromycin reaction on various functional states of the ribosome indicate that the A-site substrate of the peptidyltransferase center, puromycin, requires the same activation energy for peptide-bond formation under all conditions tested. We further demonstrate that deacylated tRNA is released from the E site by binding a ternary complex aminoacyl-tRNA•EF-Tu•GDPNP to the A site. This observation indicates that the E-tRNA is released after the decoding step but before both GTP hydrolysis by EF-Tu and accommodation of the A-tRNA. Collectively these results reveal that the reciprocal linkage between the E and A sites affects the decoding center on the 30S subunit, but does not influence the rate of peptide-bond formation at the active center of the 50S subunit.     

Differential regulation of opposing RelMtb activities by the aminoacylation state of a tRNA.ribosome.mRNA.RelMtb complex

Rel(Mtb) of Mycobacterium tuberculosis is responsible for the intracellular regulation of (p)ppGpp and the consequent ability of the organism to survive long-term starvation, indicating a possible role in the pathogenesis of tuberculosis. Purified Rel(Mtb) is a dual-function enzyme carrying out ATP: GTP/GDP/ITP 3'-pyrophosphoryltransferase and (p)ppGpp 3'-pyrophosphohydrolase reactions. Here we show that in the absence of biological regulators, Rel(Mtb) simultaneously catalyzes both transferase and hydrolysis at the maximal rate for each reaction, indicating the existence of two distinct active sites. The differential regulation of the opposing activities of Rel(Mtb) is dependent on the ratio of uncharged to charged tRNA and the association of Rel(Mtb) with a complex containing tRNA, ribosomes, and mRNA. A 20-fold increase in the k(cat) and a 4-fold decrease in K(ATP) and K(GTP) from basal levels for transferase activity occur when Rel(Mtb) binds to a complex containing uncharged tRNA, ribosomes, and mRNA (Rel(Mtb) activating complex or RAC). The k(cat) for hydrolysis, however, is reduced 2-fold and K(m) for pppGpp increased 2-fold from basal levels in the presence of the Rel(Mtb) activating complex. The addition of charged tRNA to this complex has the opposite effect by inhibiting transferase activity and activating hydrolysis activity. Differential control of Rel(Mtb) gives the Mtb ribosomal complex a new regulatory role in controlling cellular metabolism in response to stringent growth conditions that may be present in the dormant Mtb lesion.     

The relA/spoT-Homologous Gene in Streptomyces coelicolor Encodes Both Ribosome-Dependent (p)ppGppSynthesizing and -Degrading Activities

Streptomyces coelicolor (p)ppGpp synthetase (Rel protein) belongs to the RelA and SpoT (RelA/SpoT) family, which is involved in (p)ppGpp metabolism and the stringent response. The potential functions of the rel gene have been examined. S. coelicolor Rel has been shown to be ribosome associated, and its activity in vitro is ribosome dependent. Analysis in vivo of the active recombinant protein in well-defined Escherichia coli relA and relA/spoT mutants provides evidence that S. coelicolor Rel, like native E. coli RelA, is functionally ribosome associated, resulting in ribosome-dependent (p)ppGpp accumulation upon amino acid deprivation. Expression of an S. coelicolor C-terminally deleted Rel, comprised of only the first 489 amino acids, catalyzes a ribosome-independent (p)ppGpp formation, in the same manner as the E. coli truncated RelA protein (1 to 455 amino acids). An E. coli relA spoT double deletion mutant transformed with S. coelicolor rel gene suppresses the phenotype associated with (p)ppGpp deficiency. However, in such a strain, a rel-mediated (p)ppGpp response apparently occurs after glucose depletion, but only in the absence of amino acids. Analysis of ppGpp decay in E. coli expressing the S. coelicolor rel gene suggests that it also encodes a (p)ppGpp-degrading activity. By deletion analysis, the catalytic domains of S. coelicolor Rel for (p)ppGpp synthesis and degradation have been located within its N terminus (amino acids 267 to 453 and 93 to 397, respectively). In addition, E. coli relA in an S. coelicolor rel deletion mutant restores actinorhodine production and shows a nearly normal morphological differentiation, as does the wild-type rel gene, which is in agreement with the proposed role of (p)ppGpp nucleotides in antibiotic biosynthesis.     

Characterization of the tRNA and ribosome-dependent pppGpp-synthesis by recombinant stringent factor from Escherichia coli

Stringent factor is a ribosome-dependent ATP:GTP pyrophosphoryl transferase that synthesizes (p)ppGpp upon nutrient deprivation. It is activated by unacylated tRNA in the ribosomal amino-acyl site (A-site) but it is unclear how activation occurs. A His-tagged stringent factor was isolated by affinity-chromatography and precipitation. This procedure yielded a protein of high purity that displayed (a) a low endogenous pyrophosphoryl transferase activity that was inhibited by the antibiotic tetracycline; (b) a low ribosome-dependent activity that was inhibited by the A-site specific antibiotics thiostrepton, micrococcin, tetracycline and viomycin; (c) a tRNA- and ribosome-dependent activity amounting to 4500 pmol pppGpp per pmol stringent factor per minute. Footprinting analysis showed that stringent factor interacted with ribosomes that contained tRNAs bound in classical states. Maximal activity was seen when the ribosomal A-site was presaturated with unacylated tRNA. Less tRNA was required to reach maximal activity when stringent factor and unacylated tRNA were added simultaneously to ribosomes, suggesting that stringent factor formed a complex with tRNA in solution that had higher affinity for the ribosomal A-site. However, tRNA-saturation curves, performed at two different ribosome/stringent factor ratios and filter-binding assays, did not support this hypothesis.     

How does ppGpp affect translational accuracy in the stringent response?

With an in vitro poly(Phe) synthesis system we have tested recent models concerning translational accuracy in the stringent response during aminoacid starvation. We have found that cognate, deacylated tRNA of very high concentrations is unable to block the A-site. No influence of EF-Tu.ppGpp on ribosomal proofreading has been found. Alternative mechanisms to keep translational errors low by the stringent response are discussed.     

Locking and unlocking of ribosomal motions

During the ribosomal translocation, the binding of elongation factor G (EF-G) to the pretranslocational ribosome leads to a ratchet-like rotation of the 30S subunit relative to the 50S subunit in the direction of the mRNA movement. By means of cryo-electron microscopy we observe that this rotation is accompanied by a 20 A movement of the L1 stalk of the 50S subunit, implying that this region is involved in the translocation of deacylated tRNAs from the P to the E site. These ribosomal motions can occur only when the P-site tRNA is deacylated. Prior to peptidyl-transfer to the A-site tRNA or peptide removal, the presence of the charged P-site tRNA locks the ribosome and prohibits both of these motions.     

Interplay of the Bacterial Ribosomal A-Site,S12 Protein Mutations and Paromomycin Binding: A Molecular Dynamics Study

The conformational properties of the aminoacyl-tRNA binding site (A-site), and its surroundings in the Escherichia coli 30S ribosomal subunit, are of great relevance in designing antibacterial agents. The 30S subunit A-site is near ribosomal protein S12, which neighbors helices h27 and H69; this latter helix, of the 50S subunit, is a functionally important component of an intersubunit bridge. Experimental work has shown that specific point mutations in S12 (K42A, R53A) yield hyper-accurate ribosomes, which in turn confers resistance to the antibiotic ‘paromomycin’ (even when this aminoglycoside is bound to the A-site). Suspecting that these effects can be elucidated in terms of the local atomic interactions and detailed dynamics of this region of the bacterial ribosome, we have used molecular dynamics simulations to explore the motion of a fragment of the E. coli ribosome, including the A-site. We found that the ribosomal regions surrounding the A-site modify the conformational space of the flexible A-site adenines 1492/93. Specifically, we found that A-site mobility is affected by stacking interactions between adenines A1493 and A1913, and by contacts between A1492 and a flexible side-chain (K43) from the S12 protein. In addition, our simulations reveal possible indirect pathways by which the R53A and K42A mutations in S12 are coupled to the dynamical properties of the A-site. Our work extends what is known about the atomistic dynamics of the A-site, and suggests possible links between the biological effects of hyper-accurate mutations in the S12 protein and conformational properties of the ribosome; the implications for S12 dynamics help elucidate how the miscoding effects of paromomycin may be evaded in antibiotic-resistant mutants of the bacterial ribosome.     

GTP degradation to guanine catalyzed by ribosomal subunits and microsomal-wash factors.

Ribosomes from stringent strains of bacteria generate (p)ppGpp if incubated with uncharged tRNA, a ribosomal wash fraction, GTP and ATP. By contrast, an analogous system from rat liver does not transform GTP to (p)ppGpp but degrades it to guanine. The reaction requires the ribosomal subunits, a 40 000-Mr and a 60 000-Mr microsomal wash protein factor and is inhibited if the ribosomal A-site is charged with aminoacyl tRNA. The degradation of GTP to guanine occurs in the following four distinct reaction steps: (a) hydrolysis of GTP to GDP plus Pi, (b) hydrolysis of GDP to GMP plus Pi, (c) hydrolysis of GMP to guanosine plus Pi, (d) hydrolysis of guanosine to guanine plus ribose. The reaction step (a) is inhibited by fusidic acid, cycloheximide, emetine, tetracycline and puromycin. The hydrolysis of GDP is inhibited strongly by fusidic acid, emetine and tetracycline. A putative physiological significance of this ribosome-dependent pathway in the processes of growth control of animal cells under conditions of amino acid deprivation is discussed.     

Archaeal aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases interact with the ribosome to recycle tRNAs

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRS) are essential enzymes catalyzing the formation of aminoacyl-tRNAs, the immediate precursors for encoded peptides in ribosomal protein synthesis. Previous studies have suggested a link between tRNA aminoacylation and high-molecular-weight cellular complexes such as the cytoskeleton or ribosomes. However, the structural basis of these interactions and potential mechanistic implications are not well understood. To biochemically characterize these interactions we have used a system of two interacting archaeal aaRSs: an atypical methanogenic-type seryl-tRNA synthetase and an archaeal ArgRS. More specifically, we have shown by thermophoresis and surface plasmon resonance that these two aaRSs bind to the large ribosomal subunit with micromolar affinities. We have identified the L7/L12 stalk and the proteins located near the stalk base as the main sites for aaRS binding. Finally, we have performed a bioinformatics analysis of synonymous codons in the Methanothermobacter thermautotrophicus genome that supports a mechanism in which the deacylated tRNAs may be recharged by aaRSs bound to the ribosome and reused at the next occurrence of a codon encoding the same amino acid. These results suggest a mechanism of tRNA recycling in which aaRSs associate with the L7/L12 stalk region to recapture the tRNAs released from the preceding ribosome in polysomes.     

A flexible loop in yeast ribosomal protein L11 coordinates P-site tRNA binding

High-resolution structures reveal that yeast ribosomal protein L11 and its bacterial/archael homologs called L5 contain a highly conserved, basically charged internal loop that interacts with the peptidyl-transfer RNA (tRNA) T-loop. We call this the L11 ‘P-site loop’. Chemical protection of wild-type ribosome shows that that the P-site loop is inherently flexible, i.e. it is extended into the ribosomal P-site when this is unoccupied by tRNA, while it is retracted into the terminal loop of 25S rRNA Helix 84 when the P-site is occupied. To further analyze the function of this structure, a series of mutants within the P-site loop were created and analyzed. A mutant that favors interaction of the P-site loop with the terminal loop of Helix 84 promoted increased affinity for peptidyl-tRNA, while another that favors its extension into the ribosomal P-site had the opposite effect. The two mutants also had opposing effects on binding of aa-tRNA to the ribosomal A-site, and downstream functional effects were observed on translational fidelity, drug resistance/hypersensitivity, virus maintenance and overall cell growth. These analyses suggest that the L11 P-site loop normally helps to optimize ribosome function by monitoring the occupancy status of the ribosomal P-site.     

Molecular dissection of the mycobacterial stringent response protein Rel

Latency in Mycobacterium tuberculosis poses a barrier in its complete eradication. Overexpression of certain genes is one of the factors that help these bacilli survive inside the host during latency. Among these genes, rel, which leads to the expression of Rel protein, plays an important role by synthesizing the signaling molecule ppGpp using GDP and ATP as substrates, thereby changing bacterial physiology. In Gram-negative bacteria, the protein is thought to be activated in vivo in the presence of ribosome by sensing uncharged tRNA. In the present report, we show that Rel protein from Mycobacterium smegmatis, which is highly homologous to M. tuberculosis Rel, is functional even in the absence of ribosome and uncharged tRNA. From the experiments presented here, it appears that the activity of Rel(Msm) is regulated by the domains present at the C terminus, as the deletion of these domains results in higher synthesis activity, with little change in hydrolysis of ppGpp. However, in the presence of tRNA, though the synthesis activity of the full-length protein increases to a certain extent, the hydrolysis activity undergoes drastic reduction. Full-length Rel undergoes multimerization involving interchain disulfide bonds. The synthesis of pppGpp by the full-length protein is enhanced in the reduced environment in vitro, whereas the hydrolysis activity does not change significantly. Mutations of cysteines to serines result in monomerization with a simultaneous increase in the synthesis activity. Finally, it has been possible to identify the unique cysteine, of six present in Rel, required for tRNA-mediated synthesis of ppGpp.     

RqcH and RqcP catalyze processive poly-alanine synthesis in a reconstituted ribosome-associated quality control system

In the cell, stalled ribosomes are rescued through ribosome-associated protein quality-control (RQC) pathways. After splitting of the stalled ribosome, a C-terminal polyalanine ‘tail’ is added to the unfinished polypeptide attached to the tRNA on the 50S ribosomal subunit. In Bacillus subtilis, polyalanine tailing is catalyzed by the NEMF family protein RqcH, in cooperation with RqcP. However, the mechanistic details of this process remain unclear. Here we demonstrate that RqcH is responsible for tRNA^Ala selection during RQC elongation, whereas RqcP lacks any tRNA specificity. The ribosomal protein uL11 is crucial for RqcH, but not RqcP, recruitment to the 50S subunit, and B. subtilis lacking uL11 are RQC-deficient. Through mutational mapping, we identify critical residues within RqcH and RqcP that are important for interaction with the P-site tRNA and/or the 50S subunit. Additionally, we have reconstituted polyalanine-tailing in vitro and can demonstrate that RqcH and RqcP are necessary and sufficient for processivity in a minimal system. Moreover, the in vitro reconstituted system recapitulates our in vivo findings by reproducing the importance of conserved residues of RqcH and RqcP for functionality. Collectively, our findings provide mechanistic insight into the role of RqcH and RqcP in the bacterial RQC pathway.     

Dissection of the mechanism for the stringent factor RelA

During conditions of nutrient deprivation, ribosomes are blocked by uncharged tRNA at the A site. The stringent factor RelA binds to blocked ribosomes and catalyzes synthesis of (p)ppGpp, a secondary messenger that induces the stringent response. We demonstrate that binding of RelA and (p)ppGpp synthesis are inversely coupled, i.e., (p)ppGpp synthesis decreases the affinity of RelA for the ribosome. RelA binding to ribosomes is governed primarily by mRNA, but independently of ribosomal protein L11, while (p)ppGpp synthesis strictly requires uncharged tRNA at the A site and the presence of L11. A model is proposed whereby RelA hops between blocked ribosomes, providing an explanation for how low intracellular concentrations of RelA (1/200 ribosomes) can synthesize (p)ppGpp at levels that accurately reflect the starved ribosome population.     

Charging levels of four tRNA species in Escherichia coli Rel(+) and Rel(-) strains during amino acid starvation: a simple model for the effect of ppGpp on translational accuracy

Escherichia coli strains mutated in the relA gene lack the ability to produce ppGpp during amino acid starvation. One consequence of this deficiency is a tenfold increase in misincorporation at starved codons compared to the wild-type. Previous work had shown that the charging levels of tRNAs were the same in Rel(+) and Rel(-) strains and reduced, at most, two- to fivefold in both strains during starvation. The present reinvestigation of the charging levels of tRNA(2)(Arg), tRNA(1)(Thr), tRNA(1)(Leu) and tRNA(His) during starvation of isogenic Rel(+) and Rel(-) strains showed that starvation reduced charging levels tenfold to 40-fold. This reduction corresponds much better with the decreased rate of protein synthesis during starvation than that reported earlier. The determination of the charging levels of tRNA(2)(Arg) and tRNA(1)(Thr) during starvation were accurate enough to demonstrate that charging levels were at least fivefold lower in the Rel(-) strain compared to the Rel(+) strain. Together with other data from the literature, these new data suggest a simple model in which mis-incorporation increases as the substrate availability decreases and that ppGpp has no direct effect on enhancing translational accuracy at the ribosome.