Diagnostic accuracy of liquid‐based endometrial cytology in the evaluation of endometrial pathology in postmenopausal women

C. Remondi, F. Sesti, E. Bonanno, A. Pietropolli and E. Piccione
Diagnostic accuracy of liquid‐based endometrial cytology cytology in the evaluation of endometrial pathology in postmenopausal women Objective: The aim of this study was to compare liquid‐based endometrial cytology with hysteroscopy and endometrial biopsy regarding its diagnostic accuracy in a series of postmenopausal women with abnormal uterine bleeding (AUB) or asymptomatic women with thickened endometrium assessed by transvaginal ultrasound as a screening procedure. Methods: Inclusion criteria were: menopausal status; the presence of AUB and/or thickened endometrium assessed by ultrasound (cut‐off 4 mm); a normal Papanicolaou (Pap) smear; and no adnexal pathology at ultrasound. Exclusion criteria were: previous endometrial pathology; and previous operative hysteroscopy. Of 768 postmenopausal women referred to our general gynaecology clinics, 121 fulfilled the inclusion criteria and were recruited to the trial. Twenty‐one refused to participate. Cytological sampling was carried out by brushing the uterine cavity using the Endoflower device with no cervical dilation and the vial was processed using a ThinPrep® 2000 automated slide processor. The slides were stained using a Pap method. Results: In 98 cases with histological biopsies, endometrial cytology detected five cases of endometrial carcinoma, 10 of atypical hyperplasia and 47 of non‐atypical hyperplasia; 36 cases were negative. In two cases cytology was inadequate because of uterine cervical stenosis. Taking atypical hyperplasia or worse as a positive test and outcome, the diagnostic accuracy of the endometrial cytology was 93.5%, with a sensitivity of 92% and specificity of 95%, a positive predictive value of 73% and a negative predictive value of 99%. All the carcinomas were detected by cytology. Only 42% of women with a positive diagnosis were symptomatic. The cytological sampling was well tolerated by all patients. No complication was registered. Conclusions: Liquid‐based endometrial cytology can be considered an useful diagnostic method in the detection of endometrial pathology as a first‐line approach, particularly if associated with transvaginal ultrasound.     

Liquid-based endometrial cytology: cyto-histological correlation in a population of 917 women

OBJECTIVE: Liquid-based cytology, because of its capacity to reduce the obscuring factors and to provide thin-layer specimens, represents an opportunity to reevaluate endometrial cytology. In order to assess the utility of the liquid-based method in endometrial diagnosis, we evaluated its accuracy in comparison with histology. METHODS: Nine hundred and seventeen women scheduled for hysteroscopy were enrolled in the study. After providing informed consent, all the women proceeded sequentially to hysteroscopy, endometrial cytology and then biopsy endometrial sampling. RESULTS: Cyto-histological correlations were possible in 519 cases (57%): in 361 (39%) cases the biopsy was inadequate, in 15 (2%) the cytology was inadequate, and in 22 (2%) both were inadequate. At biopsy 25 (3%) women had adenocarcinoma, 5 (1%) had adenomatous atypical hyperplasia and 21 (2%) had simple non atypical hyperplasia. At cytology two adenocarcinomas and one adenomatous atypical hyperplasia were underrated as atypical hyperplasias and as non-atypical hyperplasia; two simple non-atypical hyperplasias were reported as negative; and eight cases were false positive (non-atypical hyperplasia at cytology, negative at biopsy). In our population, the cytology provided sufficient material more often than biopsy (P < 0.04). Sensitivity was estimated at 96%, specificity at 98%, positive predictive value at 86% and negative predictive value at 99%. CONCLUSIONS: We concluded that endometrial cytology may be an efficient diagnostic method. It could be applied to selected patients solely or in association with ultrasonography. The combination of these two noninvasive procedures may improve their diagnostic accuracy and reduce unnecessary hysteroscopies, thereby producing benefits for women and society.     

Salivary gland fine needle aspiration using the ThinPrep technique: diagnostic accuracy, cytologic artifacts and pitfalls

OBJECTIVE: To retrospectively assess the diagnostic accuracy, cytologic features and pitfalls of ThinPrep (TP) (Cytyc Corporation, Marlborough, Massachusetts, U.S.A.) versus conventional (smear) preparation (CP) in salivary gland fine needle aspiration biopsies (FNABs) and second, to evaluate the reproducibility of the cytomorphologic criteria used in the evaluation of FNABs prepared by CP versus TP. STUDY DESIGN: All salivary gland fine needle aspiration biopsies (SGFNABs) between January 1996 and June 1999 were retrieved from the cytology files of the University of Michigan Hospital. Histologic correlation was identified when available. Two cytopathologists reevaluated the slides for artifacts, cellular preservation, background material, cellularity, and cytoplasmic and nuclear details. RESULTS: Seventy-four of the 134 (55%) cases identified had histologic follow-up. Fifty (68%) cases were processed by TP and 24 (32%) by CP. FNAB processed by TP and CP correctly identified malignancy in 14 and 9 cases, respectively. There were three (4%) false negative cases. These included two acinic cell carcinomas and one mucoepidermoid carcinoma. There were 37 true negative cases (24 TP and 13 CP) and one false positive case of cellular pleomorphic adenoma (cytologic interpretation, mucoepidermoid carcinoma). All discrepant cases were processed using the TP method. The overall specificity and sensitivity were 98% and 88%, respectively. However, specificity and sensitivity for TP-processed SGFNABs were 96% and 82% as compared to a 100% specificity and sensitivity for CP. Additionally, there were 10 (14%) nondiagnostic cases, 8 of which were processed by TP. Cytologic artifacts associated with TP included diminished/distorted extracellular and stromal elements, cellular shrinkage and tissue fragmentation CONCLUSION: The diagnostic accuracy of TP-processed SGFNABs approaches that of the CP. However, there are several artifacts that may lead to erroneous diagnoses. Additional studies, that depend on real-life clinical samples processed by TP are suggested to modify current diagnostic criteria.     

Endocyte endometrial smears in the cytodiagnosis of endometrial carcinoma

The cytologic diagnosis of endometrial cancer using material obtained with the Endocyte endometrial sampler was assessed for 874 patients. The samples obtained were smeared directly on slides for fixation and staining; the smears were more difficult to assess than cervicovaginal smears, however, due to the presence of blood, the small size and density of the cells and the flattened three-dimensional architecture of the tissue fragments obtained. Only 8.2% of the samples were classified as inadequate; repeat sampling in some of those cases produced diagnostic material. All 12 cases of carcinoma (including one case in a woman less than 40 years of age) were diagnosed by cytology as malignant; however, the original cytologic sample in one of those cases was inadequate. For the diagnosis of benign versus malignant, cytology had a sensitivity of 92%, a specificity of 100% and predictive value of 100%. Cytology also diagnosed as suspicious the smears from 5 of 13 cases of endometrial hyperplasia and 2 of the 9 cases of endometrial polyps. The cytologic findings for benign and malignant samples are described and illustrated in detail. Relative to other endometrial sampling devices, the Endocyte is inexpensive and was easily used by the gynecologist and well tolerated by the patients, with no complications and minimal discomfort.     

Potential of the learning vector quantizer in the cell classification of endometrial lesions in postmenopausal women

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the potential of artificial neural networks for cell identification in endometrial lesions from postmenopausal women. STUDY DESIGN: The study was performed on cytologic material obtained by the Gynoscann endometrial cell samplerfrom 12 cases of atrophic endometrium, 48 cases of hyperplasia without cytologic atypia (18 cases of simple hyperplasia and 30 cases of complex hyperplasia), 12 cases of hyperplasia with cytologic atypia (complex atypical hyperplasia) and 48 cases of adenocarcinoma (30 cases of well-differentiated, 12 cases of moderately differentiated and 6 cases of poorly differentiated carcinoma). From each case approximately 100 cells were examined using a custom image analysis system. A learning vector quantizer (LVQ) identified the collected data. RESULTS: Investigation of cells from Endometrial Alterations with LVQ proved that according to the nuclear characteristics, as expressed by morphometric and textural measures, the endometrial cells from postmenopausal women may be identified as belonging to one of thefollowing three groups: atrophy, hyperplasia without cytologic atypia (simple and complex hyperplasia) and malignant neoplastic lesions (atypical complex and adenocarcinoma). CONCLUSION: The role of nuclear morphologic features in the cytologic diagnosis of endometrial alterations was confirmed. The overlap in thefeature space observed indicates that cell characteristics do not form strictly separate clusters. Thatfact explains the difficulty that morphologists have with the reproducible identification of cells from endometrial lesions in postmenopausal women. Application of LVQ offers a good classification at the cell level and promises to be a powerful toolfor classification on the individual patient level andfor the clarification of the natural history of endometrial pathology.     

Endometrial hyperplasia with berrylike squamous metaplasia and pilomatrixomalike shadow cells. Report of an intriguing cytohistologic case

BACKGROUND: The usefulness of endometrial cytology as a diagnostic method in asymptomatic women, especially in postmenopause, in the interpretation of composite pictures characterized by borderline features between atypical hyperplasia and well-differentiated adenocarcinoma, especially if associated metaplastic features are present, is somewhat controversial. CASE: An asymptomatic, 50-year-old, postmenopausal woman underwent a Pap smear and endometrial cytology for routine screening, disclosing three-dimensional, sometimes pseudopapillary groupings of hyperplastic endometrial glandular cells with focal atypia in direct continuity with large, squamoid cells of the keratinizing type and shadow cells. Histologic examination of endometrial tissue was advised, and two subsequent endometrial biopsies and hysteroscopic ablation were performed. The borderline character of the lesion (complex atypical hyperplasia vs. well-differentiated adenocarcinoma) with concomitant squamous metaplasia and pilomatrixomalike shadow cells prevented diagnostic agreement between several pathologists. CONCLUSION: Diagnostic cytology with direct endometrial sampling represents a valuable diagnostic screening tool for the differential diagnosis between normal and pathologic endometrium, a mucosal picture that deserves a subsequent (histologic) diagnostic procedure. In a few cases, as in the one presented above, even histologic examination, especially of so-called borderline lesions, reveals squamous or other types of metaplasia that can lead to interobserver discrepancies.     

Cytological criteria of endometrial lesions with emphasis on stromal and epithelial cell clusters: result of 8 years of experience with intrauterine sampling

Objective:  There are a number of unresolved issues in endometrial cytology. They include the significance of nuclear atypia for the diagnosis of grade1 adenocarcinoma (G1AC) and atypical endometrial hyperplasia (AEH), cytological criteria of endometrial hyperplasia without atypia, and recognition of stromal cell cluster (SC) and its distinction from epithelial cell cluster (EC).
Methods:  We examined nuclear atypia, SC and EC in typical cases of five categories: normal endometrium (NEM), simple endometrial hyperplasia without atypia (SEH), complex endometrial hyperplasia without atypia (CEH), G1AC and grade2 adenocarcinoma (G2AC). We classified EC into four types: simple EC (SPEC), large regular EC (LREC), large irregular EC (LIEC) and small irregular EC (SIEC). Based on the results, we developed criteria of endometrial cytology and have evaluated 13 639 cases over 8 years.
Results:  Nuclear atypia was significantly more frequent in G2AC than in any of the other four categories ( P  <   0.001). SC was significantly more frequent in NEM and SEH than in the other three categories ( P  <   0.001). G1AC and G2AC showed significantly higher frequency of LIEC than the other three categories ( P  <   0.001). CEH exhibited significantly higher frequency of LREC than the four categories ( P  <   0.001). The sensitivity and the specificity was 88.8% and 99.0% respectively.
Conclusions:  We could diagnose G1AC, G2AC and CEH with high accuracy using the established criteria mainly based on SC and EC. We think that the criteria may facilitate an effective screening and an objective interpretation of endometrial samples.     

Comparison of ThinPrep and conventional preparations on fine needle aspiration cytology material

OBJECTIVE: To compare the various cytologic features on ThinPrep 2000 (TP) (Cytyc Corporation, Marlborough, Massachusetts, U.S.A.) and conventional preparation (CP) specimens from fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) material by a semiquantitative scoring system. STUDY DESIGN: In this prospective study a total of 71 consecutive cases were included. In each case, two passes were performed. The first pass was used for conventional preparations, with direct smears made and fixed immediately in 95% alcohol for Papanicolaou stain. For TP preparation a second pass produced material for processing in the ThinPrep 2000. The TP and CP slides were studied independently by two observers and representative slides of CP and TP compared for cellularity, background blood and necrotic cell debris, cell architecture, informative background, presence of monolayer cells, and nuclear and cytoplasmic details by a semiquantitative scoring system. Statistical analysis was performed by Wilcoxon's signed rank test on an SPSS program (Chicago, Illinois, U.S.A.). RESULTS: TP preparations contained adequate diagnostic cells in all cases and were tangibly superior to CP preparations concerning monolayer cells, absence of blood and necrosis, and preservation of nuclear and cytoplasmic detail (statistically significant, Wilcoxon's signed rank test, P < .000). CONCLUSION: TP preparations are superior to conventional preparations with regard to clear background, monolayer cell preparation and cell preservation. It is easier and less time consuming to screen and interpret TP preparations because the cells are limited to smaller areas on clear backgrounds, with excellent cellular preservation. However, TP preparations are more expensive than CP and require some experience for interpretation.     

Stereotaxic fine needle aspiration cytology of clinically occult malignant and premalignant breast lesions

Stereotaxic fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology was used to study clinically occult (nonpalpable) breast lesions in 114 consecutive patients with mammographically suspicious findings prior to excisional biopsy. The aspirate contained insufficient material for cytologic evaluation in 15 cases (13.2%), which were histologically diagnosed as benign (7 cases), atypical hyperplasia (7 cases) or carcinoma in situ (1 case). The cytologic findings indicated a benign lesion in 77 cases (67.5%), which were histologically diagnosed as benign (71 cases) or atypical ductal hyperplasia (6 cases). The cytologic sample showed atypia in eight cases (7.0%), which were histologically diagnosed as severe atypical ductal hyperplasia (three cases), carcinoma in situ (one case) or proliferative fibrocystic disease (four cases). In the eight cases (7.0%) cytologically interpreted as probably malignant, histology confirmed six invasive carcinomas, one carcinoma in situ and one fibrocystic disease. Of six cases (4.4%) cytologically reported as malignant, five were histologically diagnosed as invasive carcinoma and one as carcinoma in situ. Overall, stereotaxic FNA cytology reported as malignant or probably malignant 14 of the 15 cases with a histologic confirmation of malignancy, for a sensitivity of 93.3%. Cytology correctly identified 78 of the 83 histologically negative cases, for a specificity of 94.0%. The 16 cases histologically diagnosed as ductal hyperplasia, which carries a high risk for subsequent malignancy, were studied in detail in an effort to define histologic and cytologic criteria for this entity. Using selected histologic criteria, 11 of these cases were graded as showing mild-to-moderate atypical hyperplasia and 5 as showing severe atypical hyperplasia. Three of the latter cases were similarly identified by an analogous cytologic grading; the other two cases had insufficient cytologic samples. The total results in this series of 114 cases support the use of stereotaxic FNA cytology in the diagnosis of these nonpalpable breast lesions, examples of which are illustrated. In particular, it may help to raise the low specificity yielded by mammography alone, which would represent a significant advance for the patient in terms of the accuracy, expediency and reduced cost of diagnosing these lesions.     

A comparative study: conventional preparation and ThinPrep® 2000 in respiratory cytology

In order to compare and contrast conventional preparation (CP) with ThinPrep 2000 (TP) in respiratory cytology, 207 samples were divided equally and processed by the two different preparation methods, generating three CP and one TP slide per sample. No lesion identified by CP was missed by TP and there were no significant differences between TP and CP in the diagnostic categories. However, two cases of squamous cell carcinoma were detected on TP which had been classified as unsatisfactory and moderate squamous dyskaryosis, respectively, on CP. ThinPrep was found to be superior to CP in many respects as it provided standardized preparations in a greater proportion of cases and problems such as cell overlapping and background debris were markedly reduced. In several instances the diagnostic accuracy in CP was compromised by smears that were either too thick, too thin, or too scanty. Cell preservation was also better on TP when compared with CP, facilitating more accurate diagnosis and significantly reducing the primary screening and reporting time, especially of sputum samples. A major advantage of TP methodology is the fact that it facilitates optimal use of skilled cytotechnologists and streamlines the workflow in the laboratory.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of primary bone lesions

Fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytologic findings were compared with the results of conventional histology in a series of primary bone lesions to determine the diagnostic accuracy of FNA cytology. The series included 12 osteogenic sarcomas, 4 Ewing's sarcomas, 3 chordomas, 3 myelomas, 2 chondrosarcomas, 2 undifferentiated sarcomas and 1 case each of normal bone and marrow elements, lymphoma and giant-cell tumor. All aspirates yielded adequate material for smear diagnosis, and all 29 cases were correctly identified as benign or malignant by cytology. In 19 cases (66%), specific cytologic diagnoses were rendered and histologically confirmed. This series is compared with other published series of bone aspirations in terms of technique, accuracy and ability to obtain diagnostic material. The importance of technique, radiographic investigations and experience in performing the aspirations in achieving a high diagnostic yield is emphasized.     

Performance of monolayered cervical smears in a gynecology outpatient setting in Kuwait

OBJECTIVE: To compare ThinPrep (TP) Papanicolaou smears (Cytyc Corp., Box-borough, Massachusetts, U.S.A.) with matching conventional Papanicolaou (CP) smears for specimen adequacy, cytologic quality, diagnostic accuracy and screening time. STUDY DESIGN: In this prospective study of 1,024 women a split-sample, matched-pair design in favor of CP slides based on single-blind criteria was followed with a smear on a glass slide for CP and the remaining material collected in Preserv-Cyt solution (Cytyc) for a TP smear. A Cytobrush (Medscand, Hollywood, Florida, U.S.A.) was used for smear preparation for CP. TP smears were processed in ThinPrep 2000 (Cytyc). Smears were stained with Papanicolaou stain and were interpreted according to the Bethesda system. RESULTS: The number of satisfactory but limited (SBL) cases with TP were 77 (7.5%) as compared to 127 (12.4%) with the CP method. This reduction in SBL smears with the TP method and consequent increase in satisfactory smears were highly significant (P < .001) by McNemar's test. As regards unsatisfactory smears in discordant pairs, although the number of unsatisfactory smears was higher with TP (41 cases) as against CP (27 cases), the difference was not statistically significant (P < .05). The split-sample method showed a high correlation between the CP and TP diagnoses. TP smears had a significant advantage over CP smears in the reduction in the number of ASCUS and AGUS cases (14 vs. 29) (P < .05) and increased the pickup rate of LSIL, 6 vs. 1. Time taken to screen the TP smears was half that of CP smears. No cases of LSIL or HSIL were missed on TP smears. CONCLUSION: The liquid-based processor significantly improved the adequacy and quality of smears, resulting in fewer recall cases for SBL smears, leading to more definitive diagnoses in atypical cases, increasing the pickup rate of LSILs and reducing the screening time. A machine handling multiple specimens automatically would decrease cost and be an asset to a cytopathology laboratory.     

Diagnostic pitfalls in the evaluation of fine needle aspiration cytology of the thyroid: correlation with histopathology in 260 cases

Objectives:  Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) of the thyroid is a non-invasive, cost-effective screening procedure that is valuable for distinguishing neoplastic lesions from non-neoplastic nodules. The aim of this study was to determine the diagnostic accuracy of FNACs performed at our institution by correlating FNAC results with histopathological diagnoses.
Methods:  Two hundred and seventy-one aspiration cytology specimens followed by thyroidectomy were included in the study, and the results of 260 adequate FNACs were compared with their histological diagnoses.
Results:  The sensitivity and specificity of thyroid FNAC for detecting neoplasia were 92.6% and 91.6%, respectively. There were 15 (5.7%) false positives and six (2.3%) false negatives.
Conclusions:  The results showed that follicular cells that exhibit some of the features of papillary carcinoma could be observed in a cytology slide of Hashimoto's thyroiditis, leading to a diagnostic pitfall. In addition, cellularity and overlapping cytological criteria in hyperplasia might lead to a false diagnosis.     

Are significant numbers of abnormal cells lost on the discarded ThinPrep® broom when used for cervical cytology?

A. Umana, H. Dunsmore, A. Herbert, A. Jokhan and A. Kubba
Are significant numbers of abnormal cells lost on the discarded ThinPrep® broom when used for cervical cytology? Background: In view of a study with SurePath® showing that cells were lost on the broom if it was discarded, we decided to investigate whether cells were lost on the ThinPrep® (TP) broom, which is discarded according to the manufacturer’s protocol. Aim: To determine whether significant amounts of cellular material are lost on the discarded TP broom, and whether the loss is operator dependent. Methods: Three hundred and six women attending the Guy’s Hospital Colposcopy Unit gave their consent for TP liquid‐based cytology samples to be taken and the broom immersed in a second vial instead of being discarded. The cellularity of the first and second vials was compared by counting cells in 10 ×40 high‐power fields (HPFs). The significance of cell loss was ascertained by correlating the likelihood of abnormal cells and transformation zone (TZ) material being present with the degree of cellularity of the two vials. Results: More than 10 cells per HPF were seen in 3.2%, 19.4% and 35.8% of slides from the second vial taken by three experienced colposcopists, which was significantly different between them (P < 0.001); cellularity of the first vial was not significantly different between colposcopists but the one with highest cellularity in the first vial discarded most in the second. Abnormal cells were more likely to be seen in slides with more than 10 cells per HPF (P < 0.001) and with evidence of TZ sampling (P < 0.001), but there was no preferential loss of TZ material in the second vial. Of 126 slides with abnormal cells on the slides from the second vial, 113 (89.7%) were also present on the significantly more cellular first vial (P < 0.001). Conclusion: Abnormal cells were potentially lost on the broom, but were usually represented in the first vial. The likelihood of abnormal cells being discarded was operator dependent in this small study, but this did not affect the quality of the initial preparation. The likelihood of abnormal cells being seen on TP slides was dependent on their cellularity, which provided our laboratory with a criterion for the assessment of sample adequacy.     

European guidelines for quality assurance in cervical cancer screening: recommendations for collecting samples for conventional and liquid-based cytology.

The current paper presents an annex in the second edition of the European Guidelines for Quality Assurance in Cervical Cancer Screening. It provides guidance on how to make a satisfactory conventional Pap smear or a liquid-based cytology (LBC) sample. Practitioners taking samples for cytology should first explain to the woman the purpose, the procedure and how the result will be communicated. Three sampling methods are considered as acceptable for preparing conventional Pap smears: (i) the cervical broom; (ii) the combination of a spatula and an endocervical brush; and (iii) the extended tip spatula. Smear takers should take care to sample the entire circumference of the transformation zone, to quickly spread the cellular material over a glass slide, and to fix the preparation within a few seconds to avoid drying artefacts. According to local guidelines, one of these three methods may be preferred. Sampling with a cotton tip applicator is inappropriate. Similar procedures should be followed for sampling cells for LBC, but only plastic devices may be used. The collected cells should be quickly transferred into a vial with fixative liquid according to the instructions of the manufacturer of the LBC system. Subsequently, the slide or vial and the completed request form are sent to the laboratory for cytological interpretation.     

Contribution of exfoliative cytology to the diagnosis of laryngeal lesions

OBJECTIVE: To estimate the diagnostic accuracy and reliability of exfoliative laryngeal cytology. STUDY DESIGN: Over three years (1996-1999) cytologic smears were obtained from clinically suspicious laryngeal lesions during laryngoscopy in a total of 31 selected patients (28 males and 3 females with an age range from 28-90 years). The cytologic diagnoses were analyzed and correlated with the histologic and final clinical diagnoses in 17 and 14 cases, respectively. Cytologic identification of the exact histologic type of the lesion was evaluated in 17 patients from whom both cytologic smears and biopsy material were obtained. RESULTS: The overall specificity was 100%, with no false positive diagnoses. The overall sensitivity was 93.3%, with one false negative cytologic diagnosis, in a case of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. Cytohistologic correlation showed complete agreement between cytologic and histologic diagnoses in five of six benign lesions, in four cases of dysplasia and in six cases of squamous cell carcinoma. The overall diagnostic accuracy of cytology was 96.7% CONCLUSION: Exfoliative cytology by the smear technique is a reliable and accurate method in clinically suspected laryngeal lesions. Moreover, exfoliative cytology may be applied as the only alternative diagnostic method, especially in elderly patients with coexistent cardiorespiratory problems, when biopsy is not advisable or indicated.     

Cervicovaginal cytology in uterine adenocarcinoma and adenosquamous carcinoma. Comparison of cytologic and histologic findings

To investigate the diagnostic accuracy and to characterize the findings in false-negative cases, the results of cervicovaginal cytology in 56 adenocarcinomas and 25 adenosquamous carcinomas (42 cervical, 36 endometrial, 2 metastatic and 1 arising synchronously from both cervix and endometrium) were reviewed, including review of the actual slides in 56 cases. Overall, 80% of the initial cytologic diagnoses resulted in diagnostic curettage (i.e., cytology was effectively positive); 84% of the postreview diagnosis were effectively positive. Nine cytology slides showed no malignant cells; eight of these negative smears showed repair, five were atrophic, two showed a high estrogen effect and one had enlarged atypical bare nuclei. These false-negative diagnoses were associated with an endometrial primary site (P less than .01), endometrioid histology (P less than .005), low-grade or intermediate-grade histology (P less than .005), small size of tumor (P less than .05) and absence of cervical involvement (P less than .005) in those cases in which a hysterectomy was performed. False-negative diagnoses were not associated with an absence of endocervical cells or with scanty cellularity. Of 39 cervical and 28 endometrial carcinomas with a positive cytologic diagnosis (initially or after review of the available slides), cytology correctly identified the primary site in 18% and 54% of the cases, respectively. Cytology incorrectly classified the anatomic site of four cervical and three endometrial carcinomas and considered one case arising in both the endometrium and cervix to be endometrial. Routine cervicovaginal cytology does have a role in screening for uterine glandular carcinoma; to maximize its diagnostic sensitivity, we suggest using a recommendation for curettage in the report of positive cases so that all of the varied cytologic diagnoses associated with glandular carcinomas will receive a uniform clinical response. In those cases with preserved cancer cells, a correlation can be made with the histologic type of the carcinoma, rather than with the anatomic site.     

Optimizing specimen collection and laboratory procedures reduces the non‐diagnostic rate for endoscopic ultrasound‐guided fine‐needle aspiration of solid lesions of the pancreas

Objectives: Endoscopic ultrasound‐guided fine‐needle aspiration (EUS‐FNA) is a routine technique to assess solid pancreatic lesions. The aim of this study was to analyse the effect of optimizing laboratory procedures for specimen preparation on the rate and accuracy of the procedure. Methods: All EUS‐FNAs of solid pancreatic lesions performed during the year 2000 (Period 1) and from May 2003 to May 2004 (Period 2) were analysed. During Period 1, one experienced gastroenterologist performed all EUS‐FNAs, making direct smears and retrieving small fragments if present on the smear for histology. In Period 2, two endoscopists performed the EUS‐FNAs and all the material was emptied into a vial containing a fixative. Slide preparation was carried out in the pathology laboratory: one slide was processed using cytocentrifugation and cell blocks were made from left‐over material. Neither period utilized rapid on‐site evaluation. Results: During the two periods, 67 and 102 FNAs were analysed and showed significantly different (P < 0.001) non‐diagnostic rates of 22.8% and 4.2%, respectively. The increased diagnostic yield can be explained by the modified laboratory procedures and to a lesser extent by the increased experience of the gastroenterologists. Sensitivity, specificity, PPV, NPV and accuracy in the second time period were, respectively, 90.6%, 100%, 100%, 81.8% and 93.4%, not significantly different from the first time period. Conclusion: This study shows that accurate EUS‐FNA results may be obtained with a low non‐diagnostic rate comparable to those reported for rapid on‐site evaluation by optimizing laboratory specimen processing in a setting of solid pancreatic lesions.     

The endoscopic diagnosis of gastroesophageal malignancy. A cytologic review

Cytologic reports were compared to final diagnoses for 1,157 gastroesophageal samples from an eight-year period in order to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of endoscopic cytology and to determine the significance of a "suspicious" cytologic report. In the subgroup of patients with adenocarcinoma evaluated by paired endoscopic biopsy and cytology, the relative and combined sensitivities of the sampling methods were studied. Cytologic examination was reported as positive or suspicious in 85% of 229 cases of malignancy. There were three false-positive diagnoses of squamous-cell carcinoma of the esophagus, representing 0.3% of all submitted samples. Suspicious cytologic reports were issued in 5% of all cases. The majority (63%) of patients with a suspicious cytologic report had a final diagnosis of malignancy, with gastric adenocarcinoma present in almost half of the cases. Adenocarcinoma was diagnosed in 168 of the patients. Combined endoscopic biopsy and cytology was more sensitive (96%) than biopsy alone (90%) in making the initial diagnosis. Cytology may be of particular value in the diagnosis of gastroesophageal malignancy when the lesions are small and superficial or where stricture precludes adequate biopsy. Regardless of the biopsy findings, patients with "suspicious" cytologic reports require careful reevaluation since a high percentage of those cases in our series were subsequently verified as having malignancy.     

Multiple sampling for increasing the diagnostic sensitivity of nipple aspirate fluid for atypical cytology

OBJECTIVE: To determine if repeated collection of nipple aspirate fluid (NAF) can improve the diagnostic sensitivity for cytologic atypia, a marker of increased risk of breast cancer. STUDY DESIGN: Two hundred sixty-seven women without known breast disease volunteered for NAF cytology at 5 6-month intervals over 2 years. NAF samples were prepared on Millipore filters (Millipore Filter Corp., Bedford, Massachusetts, U.S.A.) and stained with a modified Papanicolaou method. Fluid availability and cellular abnormalities were evaluated for each collection attempt. Cellular findings were classified as benign, hyperplasia or atypia. RESULTS: NAF was obtained from 178 women (66.6%) at the first visit and from an additional 15, 10, 2 and 4 women at visits 2, 3, 4 and 5, respectively, for a cumulative total of 78.2% by visit 5. The number of women yielding NAF containing hyperplastic or atypical epithelial cells was determined at each visit. Hyperplastic cells were found in 34 (19.1%) at visit 1 and in an additional 20, 10, 5 and 4 women at visits 2, 3, 4 and 5, respectively. Atypical epithelial cells were present in 12 (6.7%) women at the initial visit and in an additional 11, 7, 5 and 1 women at visits 2, 3, 4 and 5, respectively, for a cumulative percent of 18.2 at visit 5. NAF could not be obtained from 58 women at any visit. CONCLUSION: These findings suggest that an optimum collection method for NAF cytology should consist of at least 3 or 4 separate fluid aspiration attempts. Reviewing repeated multiple samples instead of 1 increases the number of women who can be evaluated and the likelihood of detecting cytologic atypia.