Combining transgenic and natural resistance to obtain broad resistance to tospovirus infection in tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum mill)

This study was undertaken to develop tomato plants with broad resistanceto tospoviruses which are a major limiting factor to tomato productionworldwide. A nontransgenic tomato line Stevens-Rodale (S-R), six transgenictomato lines expressing the nucleocapsid (N) protein gene of the lettuceisolate of tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV-BL), and progeny of the crosses between S-Rand three of the transgenic lines homozygous for the N gene were evaluated fortheir resistance to tospovirus infection in greenhouse inoculation tests. S-Rhas the Sw-5 gene that confers resistance to several TSWVisolates. The six transgenic lines showed high levels of resistance wheninoculated with either TSWV-BL or a tomato isolate from Hawaii (TSWV-H).However, these same plants were highly susceptible to the Brazilian isolate ofgroundnut ringspot virus (GRSV-BR). Plants with the Sw-5gene were resistant to TSWV-BL and GRSV-BR, but were susceptible to TSWV-H.When inoculated with any of the three viruses, the F₁ progeny of thecrosses exhibited a susceptible, tolerant, or resistant phenotype with a higherproportion of the plants being either tolerant or resistant. When F₂progeny from F₁ resistant plants of each cross were inoculated withany of the three viruses, a higher proportion of tolerant and resistant plantswas observed compared to the F₁ progeny. Our results show thepotential to obtain broad resistance to tospoviruses by combining transgenicand natural resistance in a single plant.     

Transmission of Tomato spotted wilt virus isolates able and unable to overcome tomato or pepper resistance by its vector Frankliniella occidentalis

Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) causes serious diseases of many economically important crops. Disease control has been achieved by breeding tomato and pepper cultivars with the resistance genes Sw‐5 and Tsw, respectively. However, TSWV isolates overcoming these genetic resistances have appeared in several countries. To evaluate the risk of spread of these resistance‐breaking isolates, we tested their ability of transmission by the main vector of TSWV, the thrips Frankliniella occidentalis. We compared the transmission rate by thrips of six TSWV isolates of different biotype (able or unable to overcome this resistance in pepper and tomato), and with divergent genotype (A and B). Our results indicate that the transmission rate was related to the amount of virus accumulated in thrips but not to virus accumulation in the source plants on which thrips acquired the virus. No correlation was found between transmission efficiency by thrips and the genotype or between transmission efficiency and the ability of overcoming both resistances. This result suggests that resistance‐breaking isolates have the same potential to be transmitted as the isolates unable to infect resistant tomato and pepper cultivars.     

Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of cultivated tomato with construct carrying the nucleoprotein (N) gene from tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV)

Significant yield losses in commercial tomato production caused by tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) are the reason why we have undertaken studies on resistance to this pathogen. One of the possible sources of resistance can be the incorporation of the nucleoprotein N viral gene by Agrobacterium transformation. The N gene was introduced into three Lycopersicon esculentum forms. Out of the total of 3044 cotyledon explants 14.7% regenerated shoots, but only a few were rooted on medium containing kanamycin. The preliminary analysis indicated that 18 plants are putative transformants.     

Engineered resistance to tomato spotted wilt virus in transgenic peanut expressing the viral nucleocapsid gene

The nucleocapsid gene of tomato spotted wilt virus Hawaiian L isolate in a sense orientation, and the GUS and NPTII marker genes, were introduced into peanut (Arachis hypogaea cv. New Mexico Valencia A) using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Modifications to a previously defined transformation protocol reduced the time required for production of transformed peanut plants. Transgenes were stably integrated into the peanut genome and transmitted to progeny. RNA expression and production of nucleocapsid protein in transgenic peanut were observed. Progeny of transgenic peanut plants expressing the nucleocapsid gene showed a 10- to 15-day delay in symptom development after mechanical inoculations with the donor isolate of tomato spotted wilt virus. All transgenic plants were protected from systemic tomato spotted wilt virus infection. Inoculated non-transformed control plants and plants transformed with a gene cassette not containing the nucleocapsid gene became systemically infected and displayed typical tomato spotted wilt virus symptoms. These results demonstrate that protection against tomato spotted wilt virus can be achieved in transgenic peanut plants by expression of the sense RNA of the tomato spotted wilt virus nucleocapsid gene     

The Tomato spotted wilt virus cell‐to‐cell movement protein (NSM) triggers a hypersensitive response in Sw‐5‐containing resistant tomato lines and in Nicotiana benthamiana transformed with the functional Sw‐5b resistance gene copy

Although the Sw‐5 gene cluster has been cloned, and Sw‐5b has been identified as the functional gene copy that confers resistance to Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV), its avirulence (Avr) determinant has not been identified to date. Nicotiana tabacum ‘SR1‘ plants transformed with a copy of the Sw‐5b gene are immune without producing a clear visual response on challenge with TSWV, whereas it is shown here that N. benthamiana transformed with Sw‐5b gives a rapid and conspicuous hypersensitive response (HR). Using these plants, from all structural and non‐structural TSWV proteins tested, the TSWV cell‐to‐cell movement protein (NS_M) was confirmed as the Avr determinant using a Potato virus X (PVX) replicon or a non‐replicative pEAQ‐HT expression vector system. HR was induced in Sw‐5b‐transgenic N. benthamiana as well as in resistant near‐isogenic tomato lines after agroinfiltration with a functional cell‐to‐cell movement protein (NS_M) from a resistance‐inducing (RI) TSWV strain (BR‐01), but not with NS_M from a Sw‐5 resistance‐breaking (RB) strain (GRAU). This is the first biological demonstration that Sw‐5‐mediated resistance is triggered by the TSWV NS_M cell‐to‐cell movement protein.     

Mapping the Sw-5 locus for tomato spotted wilt virus resistance in tomatoes using RAPD and RFLP analyses

The Sw-5 locus confers dominant resistance to tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV). To map the location and facilitate the identification of markers linked to Sw-5 we developed a pair of near-isogenic lines (NILs) and an F₂ Lycopersicon esculentum x L. pennellii population segregating for resistance to TSWV. DNA from the NILs was analyzed using 748 random 10-mer oligonucleotides to discern linked molecular markers using a random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) approach. One random primer (GAGCACGGGA) was found to produce a RAPD band of about 2200 bp that demonstrates linkage to Sw-5. Data from co-segregation of resistance and restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) in a F₂ interspecific population position Sw-5 between the markers CT71 and CT220 near the telomere of the long arm of chromosome 9.     

Interactions between the tomato spotted wilt virus movement protein and plant proteins showing homologies to myosin, kinesin and DnaJ-like chaperones

The non-structural protein encoded by the M RNA segment (NSm) of tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) has been implicated in cell-to-cell movement of nucleocapsids through modified plasmodesmata. Recently, DnaJ-like proteins from Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco) and Arabidopsis thaliana have been identified as NSm interacting host proteins, implying an involvement of molecular chaperones during systemic spread of the virus or other, presently unknown NSm-mediated virus functions. Examination of additional TSWV host plants and improvement of yeast two-hybrid interaction trap experiments led to the isolation of a DnaJ-like protein from Lycopersicon esculentum (tomato) and the identification of a protein from A. thaliana sharing some homologies with myosin and kinesin-like polypeptides. Sequence alignments of the tomato DnaJ-like protein unveiled the corresponding gene as an orthologue to the tobacco and A. thaliana DnaJ genes, substantiating that NSm interacting DnaJ-like polypeptides, identified from three different TSWV host species, apparently form a subgroup distinct from archetypical DnaJ chaperones. Increased levels of DnaJ-like proteins could be detected in TSWV systemically infected leaves and in plants exposed to heat shock, showing that the NSm interacting DnaJ-like chaperones are inducible upon biotic and abiotic stress. All together, the identification of DnaJ-like proteins and a protein resembling myosin and kinesin as NSm interacting plant proteins is in accordance with results accomplished for movement proteins from other plant attacking viruses showing an involvement of molecular chaperones and the cytoskeleton in at least intracellular trafficking.     

Isolation of a <Emphasis Type="Italic">Ve</Emphasis> homolog, <Emphasis Type="Italic">mVe1</Emphasis>, and its relationship to verticillium wilt resistance in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Mentha longifolia</Emphasis> (L.) Huds

As a step toward greater understanding of the genetics of verticillium wilt resistance in plants, we report the sequencing of a candidate wilt resistance gene, mVe1, from the mint diploid model species, Mentha longifolia (Lamiaceae). mVe1 is a putative homolog of tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.) verticillium wilt (Ve) resistance genes. The mVe1 gene has a coding region of 3,051 bp. The predicted mVe1 protein contains a leucine-rich repeat domain, a common feature of plant disease resistance proteins. We compared 13 mVe1 alleles from three mint species. These alleles shared 96.2–99.6% nucleotide identity. We analyzed four M. longifolia populations segregating with respect to mVe1 alleles and wilt resistance versus susceptibility and found one association between mVe1 genotype and wilt phenotype. We conclude that mVe1 may play a role in mint verticillium wilt resistance, but variation for resistance in our segregating progenies is likely polygenic. Therefore, further investigations of mVe1 and identification of additional candidate genes are both warranted.     

A multi-generation analysis of the stability of transgenic virus resistance in doubled-haploid tobacco lines

Plants can be genetically engineered for virus resistance by transformation with a viral gene. We transformed tobacco with the tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) nucleocapsid gene from the Hawaiian L isolate in order to obtain TSWV resistant breeding lines. Doubled-haploid lines were produced from primary transgenic plants that were selected for resistance to the virus. Several of these lines showed very high levels of resistance and were symptomless after inoculation with the Hawaiian L isolate of TSWV. The accumulation of only low levels of full-length transgene RNA and protein observed in these lines is consistent with an RNA-mediated mechanism of resistance. The lines that were highly resistant to the Hawaiian L isolate of TSWV were also found to be highly resistant to several other isolates of TSWV, while lines that were only moderately resistant to the Hawaiian L isolate were often susceptible to the other isolates. The highly resistant lines were advanced over several generations by self-pollination. Although these lines were fully homozygous, several lines lost resistance in later generations, indicating that the resistance was unstable. Selection for resistance in these unstable lines did not prevent the occurrence of susceptible progeny in subsequent generations. Therefore, testing over several generations is required to determine the stability of resistance when breeding crops with transgenic virus resistance.     

Transgenic tomato plants expressing the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis NPR1</Emphasis> gene display enhanced resistance to a spectrum of fungal and bacterial diseases

Development of effective disease-resistance to a broad-range of pathogens in crops usually requires tremendous resources and effort when traditional breeding approaches are taken. Genetic engineering of disease-resistance in crops has become popular and valuable in terms of cost and efficacy. Due to long-lasting and broad-spectrum of effectiveness against pathogens, employment of systemic acquired resistance (SAR) for the genetic engineering of crop disease-resistance is of particular interest. In this report, we explored the potential of using SAR-related genes for the genetic engineering of enhanced resistance to multiple diseases in tomato. The Arabidopsis NPR1 (nonexpresser of PR genes) gene was introduced into a tomato cultivar, which possesses heat-tolerance and resistance to tomato mosaic virus (ToMV). The transgenic lines expressing NPR1 were normal as regards overall morphology and horticultural traits for at least four generations. Disease screens against eight important tropical diseases revealed that, in addition to the innate ToMV-resistance, the tested transgenic lines conferred significant level of enhanced resistance to bacterial wilt (BW) and Fusarium wilt (FW), and moderate degree of enhanced resistance to gray leaf spot (GLS) and bacterial spot (BS). Transgenic lines that accumulated higher levels of NPR1 proteins exhibited higher levels and a broader spectrum of enhanced resistance to the diseases, and enhanced disease-resistance was stably inherited. The spectrum and degree of these NPR1-transgenic lines are more significant compared to that of transgenic tomatoes reported to date. These transgenic lines may be further explored as future tomato stocks, aiming at building up resistance to a broader spectrum of diseases.     

The broad-spectrum tospovirus resistance gene Sw-5 of tomato is a homolog of the root-knot nematode resistance gene Mi

We used a positional cloning approach to isolate the Sw-5 disease resistance locus of tomato. Complementation experiments with overlapping cosmid clones enabled us to demonstrate that Sw-5 is a single gene locus capable of recognizing several tospovirus isolates and species. Analysis of the predicted Sw-5 protein suggests that it is a cytoplasmic protein, with a potential nucleotide binding site (NBS) domain and a C-terminal end consisting of leucine-rich repeats (LRRs). Based on its structural features, Sw-5 belongs to the class of NBS-LRR resistance genes that includes the tomato Mi, 12, and Prf genes; the Arabidopsis RPM1 gene; and the plant potato virus X resistance gene Rx. The overall similarity between the Sw-5 and Mi proteins of tomato suggests that a shared or comparable signal transduction pathway leads to both virus and nematode resistance in tomato. The similarity also supports the hypothesis that Sw-5 provides resistance via a hypersensitive response. Sw-5 is a member of a loosely clustered gene family in the telomeric region of chromosome 9. Members of this family map to other regions of chromosome 9 and also to chromosome 12, where several fungal, virus, and nematode genes have been mapped, suggesting that paralogs of Sw-5 may have evolved to provide different resistance specificities.     

The movement protein (NSm) of Tomato spotted wilt virus is the avirulence determinant in the tomato Sw‐5 gene‐based resistance

The avirulence determinant triggering the resistance conferred by the tomato gene Sw‐5 against Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) is still unresolved. Sequence comparison showed two substitutions (C118Y and T120N) in the movement protein NSm present only in TSWV resistance‐breaking (RB) isolates. In this work, transient expression of NSm of three TSWV isolates [RB1 (T120N), RB2 (C118Y) and non‐resistance‐breaking (NRB)] in Nicotiana benthamiana expressing Sw‐5 showed a hypersensitive response (HR) only with NRB. Exchange of the movement protein of Alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV) with NSm supported cell‐to‐cell and systemic transport of the chimeric AMV RNAs into N. tabacum with or without Sw‐5, except for the constructs with NBR when Sw‐5 was expressed, although RB2 showed reduced cell‐to‐cell transport. Mutational analysis revealed that N120 was sufficient to avoid the HR, but the substitution V130I was required for systemic transport. Finally, co‐inoculation of RB and NRB AMV chimeric constructs showed different prevalence of RB or NBR depending on the presence or absence of Sw‐5. These results indicate that NSm is the avirulence determinant for Sw‐5 resistance, and mutations C118Y and T120N are responsible for resistance breakdown and have a fitness penalty in the context of the heterologous AMV system.     

Cloning and characterization of the durable tomato mosaic virus resistance gene Tm-22 from Lycopersicon esculentum

In tomato, infections by tomato mosaic virus are controlled by durable Tm-2² resistance. In order to gain insight into the processes underlying disease resistance and its durability, we cloned and analysed the Tm-2² resistance gene and the susceptible allele, tm-2. The Tm-2² gene was isolated by transposon tagging using a screen in which plants with a destroyed Tm-2² gene survive. The Tm-2² locus consists of a single gene that encodes an 861 amino acid polypeptide, which belongs to the CC-NBS-LRR class of resistance proteins. The putative tm-2 allele was cloned from susceptible tomato lines via PCR with primers based on the Tm-2² sequence. Interestingly, the tm-2 gene has an open reading frame that is comparable to the Tm-2² allele. Between the tm-2 and the Tm-2² polypeptide 38 amino acid differences are present of which 26 are located in the second half of the LRR-domain. Susceptible tomato plants, which were transformed with the Tm-2² gene, displayed resistance against ToMV infection. In addition, virus specificity, displayed by the Tm-2² resistance was conserved in these transgenic lines. To explain the durability of this resistance, it is proposed that the Tm-2²-encoded resistance is aimed at the Achilles' heel of the virus.     

Recovery of transgenic peanut (Arachis hypogaea L.) plants from elite cultivars utilizing ACCELL® technology

Transgenic plants of Florunner and Florigiant, two of the most widely cultivated peanut cultivars in the USA, have been developed using the ACCELL® gene delivery method. Shoot meristems of mature embryonic axes were bombarded with gold beads coated with DNA encoding β-glucuronidase (gus), phosphinothricin acetyl transferase (bar), and tomato spotted wilt virus-nucleocapsid protein (tswv-np) genes. Transgenic shoots were identified by screening for GUS activity, and independent transformants were recovered from both cultivars. Molecular analysis of two of these transformants in R₀ and R₁ generations demonstrated the stable integration of the foreign genes into the plant genome. One transgenic plant had one to two copies of the genes integrated into the genome of its progeny, whereas the other had multiple copies. Gus and bar genes exhibited predictable segregation ratios in the R₁ and R₂ generations and were genetically linked. Integration of the bar gene conferred resistance to BASTA^TM, a wide-spectrum herbicide, applied at 500 p.p.m. of active ingredient. Resistance of the transgenic plants to tomato spotted wilt virus is currently being tested under greenhouse conditions. The ACCELL® particle bombardment system is expected to be effective for transformation of a wide variety of commercial peanut cultivars.     

Resistance to a DNA and a RNA virus in transgenic plants by using a single chimeric transgene construct

Tomato leaf curl Taiwan virus (ToLCTWV) and Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV) are two major tomato viruses that cause serious economic losses. In this study, a partial C2 gene from ToLCTWV and the middle half of the N gene of TSWV were fused as a chimeric transgene to develop multiple virus resistance in transgenic plants. This construct was introduced into Nicotiana benthamiana and tomato by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Several transgenic lines showed no symptom post agro-inoculation with ToLCTWV and displayed high resistance to TSWV. The detection of siRNAs indicated that the resistance was via RNA silencing. This study demonstrated that linkage of gene segments from two viruses with distinct genomic organization, one DNA and the other RNA, can confer multiple virus resistance in transgenic plants via gene silencing.     

Development of a CAPS marker for the verticillium wilt resistance in tomatoes

The nucleotide sequences of the Verticillium wilt resistance locus of resistant and susceptible tomato genotypes were cloned and analyzed. The nucleotide sequences displaying high degree of homology to the earlier cloned Ve1 and Ve2 genes were detected in the tomato forms susceptible to Verticillium wilt. The polymorphism at this locus between the resistant and susceptible plants was detected and used to elaborate a highly efficient CAPS marker.     

Constitutive Expression of Interferon-Induced Human MxA Protein in Transgenic Tobacco Plants Does not Confer Resistance to a Variety of RNA Viruses

MxA is a key component in the interferon-induced antiviral defense in humans. After viral infections, MxA is rapidly induced and accumulates in the cytoplasm. The multiplication of many RNA viruses,including all bunyaviruses tested so far, is inhibited by MxA. These findings prompted us to express MxA in plants in an attempt to create resistance to tospoviruses. Here, we report the generation of transgenic tobacco plants that constitutively express MxA under the control of the 35S cauliflower mosaic virus promotor. Northern and western blot analysis confirmed the expression of MxA in several transgenic plant lines. MxA expression had no obvious detrimental effects on plant growth and fertility. However, challenge experiments with tomato spotted wilt virus, tomato chlorotic spot virus, and groundnut ringspot virus revealed no increased resistance of MxA-transgenic tobacco plants to tospovirus infections. Neither was the multiplicationof tobacco mosaic virus, cucumber mosaic virus and potato virus Y inhibited in MxA-transgenic plants. The results indicate that the expression of human MxA alone does not enhance virus resistance in planta.     

Identification and comparative mapping of a dominant potyvirus resistance gene cluster in Capsicum

The dominant gene Pvr7 from Capsicum chinense Jacq. ’PI159236’ confers resistance to the pepper mottle potyvirus (PepMoV) Florida (V1182) strain. This gene is tightly linked to the dominant potyvirus resistance gene Pvr4 with observed recombination frequencies of 0.012 to 0.016. A cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (CAPS) marker linked to Pvr4 was used to localize Pvr4 and, by extension, Pvr7, to linkage group 10 on an interspecific map of pepper. Our results indicated that Pvr4, Pvr7, and Tsw, a gene conferring resistance to tomato spotted wilt virus, comprise the first identified cluster of dominant disease resistance genes in Capsicum L. This position does not correspond to the locations of dominant potyvirus resistance genes in potato or to the positions of any other mapped solanaceous resistance genes or resistance gene homologues. Received: 20 September 1999 / Accepted: 21 March 2000     

Map-based cloning of the tomato genomic region that spans the Sw-5 tospovirus resistance gene in tomato

Two yeast artificial chromosomes (YACs) containing genomic DNA from tomato have been isolated using CT220, an RFLP marker which is tightly linked to the tomato spotted wilt virus resistance gene, Sw-5. High-resolution mapping of the YAC ends and internal YAC probes demonstrated that one of the YAC clones, TY257 (400 kb), spans Sw-5. By chromosome walking in a cosmid library, the position of Sw-5 has been delimited within the YAC to a maximal chromosomal segment of 100 kb, spanned by nine overlapping cosmid clones. Received: 13 March 1997 / Accepted: 11 may 1997