Comparison of PERV genomic locations between Asian and European pigs

Xenotransplantation from pigs provides a possible solution to the shortage of human organs for allotransplantation. Porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERVs) are a possible obstacle to using porcine organs in addition to the immunological barriers. Three main types of PERVs (A, B and C) have been previously investigated in diverse pig breeds. To examine the copy numbers of PERVs and their genomic locations in the Korean native pig genome, we screened a BAC (Bacterial Artificial Chromosome) library with PERV-specific protease primers for initial recognition of PERV-positive clones and three sets of envelope-specific primers for the identification of PERV types. A total of 45 PERV-positive clones, nine PERV-A and 36 PERV-B, have been identified from the library screening and the BAC contigs were constructed using the primers designed from BAC end sequences (BESs). These primers were also used for SCH (Somatic Cell Hybrid) and RH (Radiation Hybrid) mapping of the PERV-positive clones. The results indicate that 45 PERV-positive BAC clones belong to nine contigs and a singleton. SCH and IMpRH (INRA-Minnesota Porcine Radiation Hybrid) mapping results indicated that there are at least eight separate PERV genomic locations, consisting of three PERV-A and five PERV-B. One contig could not be mapped, and two contigs are closely located on SSC7. Southern blotting indicates there may be up to 15 additional sites. Further investigation of these clones will contribute to a general strategy to generate PERV-free lines of pigs suitable for xenotransplantation.     

Analysis of natural recombination in porcine endogenous retrovirus envelope genes

Human tropic Porcine Endogenous Retroviruses (PERVs) are the major concern in zoonosis for xenotransplantation because PERVs cannot be eliminated by specific pathogen-free breeding. Recently, a PERV A/C recombinant with PERV-C bearing PERV-A gp70 showed a higher infectivity (approximately 500-fold) to human cells than PERV-A. Additionally, the chance of recombination between PERVs and HERVs is frequently stated as another risk of xenografting. Overcoming zoonotic barriers in xenotransplantation is more complicated by recombination. To achieve successful xenotransplantation, studies on the recombination in PERVs are important. Here, we cloned and sequenced proviral PERV env sequences from pig gDNAs to analyze natural recombination. The envelope is the most important element in retroviruses as a pivotal determinant of host tropisms. As a result, a total of 164 PERV envelope genes were cloned from pigs (four conventional pigs and two miniature pigs). Distribution analysis and recombination analysis of PERVs were performed. Among them, five A/B recombinant clones were identified. Based on our analysis, we determined the minimum natural recombination frequency among PERVs to be 3%. Although a functional recombinant envelope clone was not found, our data evidently show that the recombination event among PERVs may occur naturally in pigs with a rather high possibility.     

Determinants of high titer in recombinant porcine endogenous retroviruses

Porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERVs) pose a potential stumbling block for therapeutic xenotransplantation, with the greatest threat coming from viruses generated by recombination between members of the PERV subgroup A (PERV-A) and PERV-C families (PERV-A/C recombinants). PERV-A and PERV-B have been shown to infect human cells in culture, albeit with low titers. PERV-C has a more restricted host range and cannot infect human cells. A recombinant PERV-A/C virus (PERV-A14/220) contains the PERV-A sequence between the end of pol and the middle of the SU region in env. The remaining sequence is derived from PERV-C. PERV-A14/220 is approximately 500-fold more infectious than PERV-A. To determine the molecular basis for the increased infectivity of PERV-A14/220, we have made a series of vector constructs. The primary determinant for the enhanced replicative potential of the recombinant virus appeared to be the env gene. Using a series of chimeric env genes, we could identify two determinants of high infectivity; one was an isoleucine to valine substitution at position 140 between variable regions A and B, and the other lies within the proline rich region. Taken together, these results show that the novel juxtaposition of env gene sequences enhanced the infectivity of PERV-A14/220 for human cells, perhaps by stabilization of the envelope glycoprotein or increased receptor binding.     

Characterization of two porcine endogenous retrovirus integration loci and variability in pigs

The pig (Sus scrofa) is a potential organ donor for man but porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERVs) represent an important concern for patients, and identification or engineering of PERV-free pigs suitable for xenotransplantation is a major undertaking. Consequently, studies of variability in pigs for the presence of PERVs at specific loci are a prerequisite. We identified genomic flanking sequences of two PERVs cloned in bacterial artificial chromosomes, a replication-competent PERV-A at locus 1q2.4 and a defective PERV-B at locus 7p1.1–2. PERV-A is embedded in the second repeat of a tandem of eight 190 bp repeats. A short duplicated 4 bp cellular motif, AGAC, was found at each flank of PERV-A and a degenerate 4 bp motif was found for PERV-B. At each locus, the PERV flanks matched expressed sequence tags available in public databases. Primer pairs were designed to amplify either genomic flanks or PERV-genomic junctions. Polymerase chain reaction screening was performed on pigs from 11 distinct Chinese breeds and from the European Large White breed. PERV-B at locus 7p1.1–2 was detected in all animals whereas the presence of PERV-A at locus 1q2.4 was variable. Our results suggest that a genetic selection can be designed to identify animals lacking a potentially active PERV at a specific locus and that Chinese and European pig breeds represent large biodiversity reservoirs to explore. Our results point also to the existence of PERVs that might be fixed in the pig genome, and that might not be eliminated by classical genetic selection.Accession numbers: Nucleotide sequence data reported are available in the DDBJ/EMBL/GenBank databases under Accession numbers AY160111–AY160114     

Detailed Mapping of Determinants within the Porcine Endogenous Retrovirus Envelope Surface Unit Identifies Critical Residues for Human Cell Infection within the Proline-Rich Region

Replication-competent porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERVs) are either human cell tropic (PERV-A and PERV-B) or non-human cell tropic (PERV-C). We previously demonstrated that PERV in vitro cell tropism is modulated by 2 residues within the C terminus of SU and that the PERV receptor binding domain (RBD) extends beyond the variable regions A and B (VRA and VRB, respectively), to include the proline rich-region (PRR) of SU (M. Gemeniano et al., Virology 346:108-117, 2000; T. Argaw et al., J. Virol. 82:7483-7489, 2008). The present study aimed to identify the specific elements within the PERV RBD that interact with the C-terminal elements of SU to facilitate human cell infection. We constructed a series of chimeric and mutated envelopes between PERV-A and PERV-C and using pseudotyped retroviral vectors to map the human cell tropism-determining sequences within the PERV RBD. We show that the PRR from PERV-A is both necessary and sufficient to allow human cell infection when substituted into the homologous region of the PERV-C envelope carrying two C-terminal amino acid substitutions shown to influence human cell tropism, Q374R and I412V (PERV-Crv). Furthermore, substitution of a single amino acid residue in the PRR of the non-human-tropic PERV-Crv envelope allows vectors carrying this envelope to infect human cells. Receptor interference assays showed that these modified PERV-C envelopes do not bind either of the human PERV-A receptors, suggesting the presence of a distinct human PERV-C receptor. Finally, vectors carrying these modified PERV-C envelopes infect primary human endothelial cells, a cell type likely to be exposed to PERV in clinical use of certain porcine xenotransplantation products.     

Absence of replication-competent human-tropic porcine endogenous retroviruses in the germ line DNA of inbred miniature Swine

The potential transmission of porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERVs) has raised concern in the development of porcine xenotransplantation products. Our previous studies have resulted in the identification of animals within a research herd of inbred miniature swine that lack the capacity to transmit PERV to human cells in vitro. In contrast, other animals were capable of PERV transmission. The PERVs that were transmitted to human cells are recombinants between PERV-A and PERV-C in the post-VRA region of the envelope (B. A. Oldmixon, J. C. Wood, T. A. Ericsson, C. A. Wilson, M. E. White-Scharf, G. Andersson, J. L. Greenstein, H. J. Schuurman, and C. Patience, J. Virol. 76:3045-3048, 2002); these viruses we term PERV-A/C. This observation prompted us to determine whether these human-tropic replication-competent (HTRC) PERV-A/C recombinants were present in the genomic DNA of these miniature swine. Genomic DNA libraries were generated from one miniature swine that transmitted HTRC PERV as well as from one miniature swine that did not transmit HTRC PERV. HTRC PERV-A/C proviruses were not identified in the germ line DNAs of these pigs by using genomic mapping. Similarly, although PERV-A loci were identified in both libraries that possessed long env open reading frames, the Env proteins encoded by these loci were nonfunctional according to pseudotype assays. In the absence of a germ line source for HTRC PERV, further studies are warranted to assess the mechanisms by which HTRC PERV can be generated. Once identified, it may prove possible to generate animals with further reduced potential to produce HTRC PERV.     

Porcine endogenous retrovirus transmission characteristics of an inbred herd of miniature swine

Here we report the identification of inbred miniature swine that failed to produce human-tropic replication-competent porcine endogenous retroviruses (HTRC PERVs), using in vitro coculture assays. When HTRC PERVs were isolated from transmitting animals, all were recombinant viruses, with the receptor-binding domain of PERV-A combining with PERV-C-related sequences.     

Comparison of replication-competent molecular clones of porcine endogenous retrovirus class A and class B derived from pig and human cells

Vertically transmitted endogenous retroviruses pose an infectious risk in the course of pig-to-human transplantation of cells, tissues, and organs. Two classes of polytropic type C porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERV) which are infectious for human cells in vitro are known. Recently, we described the cloning and characterization of replication-competent PERV-B sequences from productively infected human cells (F. Czauderna, N. Fischer, K. Boller, R. Kurth, and R. R. Tönjes, J. Virol. 74:4028–4038, 2000). Here, we report the isolation of infectious molecular PERV-A and PERV-B clones from pig cells and compare these proviruses with clones derived from infected human 293 cells. In addition to clone PERV-A(42) derived from 293 cells, four “native” full-length proviral PERV sequences derived from a genomic library of the porcine cell line PK15 were isolated. Three identical class A clones, designated PK15-PERV-A(42), PK15-PERV-A(45), and PK15-PERV-A(58), and one class B clone, PK15-PERV-B(213), were characterized. PK15-PERV-B(213) is highly homologous but distinct from the previously described clone PERV-B(43). PK15-PERV-A(58) demonstrates close homology to PERV-A(42) in env and to PERV-C in long terminal repeat, gag, and pro/pol sequences. All three PERV clones described here were replication competent upon infection of susceptible cell lines. The findings suggest that the pig genome harbors a limited number of infectious PERV-A and -B sequences.A better understanding of the cellular and molecular basis of transplant rejection and the generation of transgenic donor animals bearing genes that mediate protection towards rejection (3, 24, 25) have stimulated approaches to use xenotransplantation, i.e., the therapeutic use of animal cells, tissues, and organs, to overcome the shortage of allogeneic transplants (7). Pigs are preferred as donors for xenotransplants (10).Major concerns have been raised about the possibility of introducing new microbial agents from the animal into the recipient, leading to xenozoonosis (2, 11, 18, 27). Viruses that are germ line transmitted, i.e., porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERV) (21), and DNA viruses that can persist without symptoms in their natural host and are transmitted via intrauterine or transplacentar pathways, e.g., herpesviruses (8), are of particular interest.Approximately 50 integration sites of PERV exist in the genomes of different pig breeds (1, 14, 21), and at least three classes are known (14, 28). Those classes, named PERV-A, -B, and -C (PERV-C is also known as PERV-MSL), display high sequence homology in the genes for group-specific antigens (gag) and polymerase (pol) but differ in the envelope (env) genes which determine the host range. In addition, the existence of multiple other PERV sequences in domestic pigs and their phylogenetic relatives has been described. However, only classes A, B, and C appear to be infectious (22).PERV that are released from different pig cell lines are able to infect human cells in vitro (15, 32, 33). PERV-C (1) is ecotropic compared to PERV-A and PERV-B, which are polytropic as deduced from pseudotype experiments utilizing the corresponding env genes (28).A retrospective investigation of 160 patients who had been treated with porcine cells and tissues showed no evidence for transmission of PERV (20); however, no long-term transplantation of a whole vascularized organ has been attempted so far. In contrast, a recent study utilizing NOD/SCID mice revealed PERV infection in several tissue compartments after transplantation of pig pancreatic islets, indicating the xenozoonotic potential of those retroviruses (31).Recently, we have reported the isolation of replication-competent PERV-B molecular clones derived from human embryonic kidney cells infected with PERV (293 PERV-PK) (5). In this communication, we describe the cloning and characterization of PERV-A and PERV-B proviral sequences derived from the porcine kidney cell line PK15 as well as the characterization of the molecular clone PERV-A(42); isolated from 293 PERV-PK cells (5). [Hereafter, clones derived from cell line 293 PERV-PK will be designated 293-PERV-B(33), 293-PERV-B(43), and 293-PERV-A(42); clones derived from cell line PK15 will be designated PK15-PERV-A(58), and so on.] Three proviruses, one PERV-B and two PERV-A clones, produce infectious and replication-competent particles upon transfection of susceptible cells and subsequent infection of different human cell lines. Thus, this study provides the first functional PERV-A and PERV-B clones isolated directly from the pig genome and allows the comparison of proviral PERV sequences from different origins at the molecular and cellular level.     

Evidence and consequence of porcine endogenous retrovirus recombination

The genetic nature and biological effects of recombination between porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERV) were studied. An infectious molecular clone was generated from a high-titer, human-tropic PERV isolate, PERV-A 14/220 (B. A. Oldmixon, et al. J. Virol. 76:3045-3048, 2002; T. A. Ericsson et al. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 100:6759-6764, 2003). To analyze this sequence and 15 available full-length PERV nucleotide sequences, we developed a sequence comparison program, LOHA(TM) to calculate local sequence homology between two sequences. This analysis determined that PERV-A 14/220 arose by homologous recombination of a PERV-C genome replacing an 850-bp region around the pol-env junction with that of a PERV-A sequence. This 850-bp PERV-A sequence encompasses the env receptor binding domain, thereby conferring a wide host range including human cells. In addition, we determined that multiple regions derived from PERV-C are responsible for the increased infectious titer of PERV-A 14/220. Thus, a single recombination event may be a fast and effective way to generate high-titer, potentially harmful PERV. Further, local homology and phylogenetic analyses between 16 full-length sequences revealed evidence for other recombination events in the past that give rise to other PERV genomes that possess the PERV-A, but not the PERV-B, env gene. These results indicate that PERV-A env is more prone to recombination with heterogeneous backbone genomes than PERV-B env. Such recombination events that generate more active PERV-A appear to occur in pigs rather frequently, which increases the potential risk of zoonotic PERV transmission. In this context, pigs lacking non-human-tropic PERV-C would be more suitable as donor animals for clinical xenotransplantation.     

Cell-binding properties of the envelope proteins of porcine endogenous retroviruses

To examine the binding properties of the envelope glycoproteins of porcine endogenous retrovirus subgroups A and B (PERV-A and PERV-B), we produced two forms of soluble envelope proteins, termed Env-ST and Env-SU, using a baculovirus expression system. Env-ST and Env-SU encompass one-third of the N-terminal and the entire surface unit (SU) of the envelope protein, respectively. Using these proteins, binding assays were performed in various mammalian cell lines. The binding properties of the Env-STs that contain the putative receptor binding domain (RBD) did not correlate with the susceptibility to the pseudotype viruses having PERV envelopes, whereas those of the Env-SUs correlated fairly well. These results suggested that the Env-SUs but not Env-STs interacted with their receptors in various cell lines. Interestingly, PERV-A Env-SU did not bind to a mink cell line (Mv1-Lu cells) that is highly susceptible to the PERV-A pseudotype virus. In addition, PERV-B Env-SU did not interfere with the PERV-B pseudotype virus on Mv1-Lu cells. These results suggest the existence of a cognate receptor-independent entry pathway as demonstrated in an immunodeficiency-inducing variant of feline leukemia virus FeLV.     

Host Range and Interference Studies of Three Classes of Pig Endogenous Retrovirus

Recent interest in the use of porcine organs, tissues, and cells for xenotransplantation to humans has highlighted the need to characterize the properties of pig endogenous retroviruses (PERVs). Analysis of a variety of pig cells allowed us to isolate and identify three classes of infectious type C endogenous retrovirus (PERV-A, PERV-B, and PERV-C) which have distinct env genes but have highly homologous sequences in the rest of the genome. To study the properties of these env genes, expression plasmids for the three env genes were constructed and used to generate retrovirus vectors bearing corresponding Env proteins. Host range analyses by the vector transduction assay showed that PERV-A and PERV-B Envs have wider host ranges, including several human cell lines, compared with PERV-C Env, which infected only two pig cell lines and one human cell line. All PERVs could infect pig cells, indicating that the PERVs have a potential to replicate in pig transplants in immunosuppressed patients. Receptors for PERV-A and PERV-B were present on cells of some other species, including mink, rat, mouse, and dog, suggesting that such species may provide useful model systems to study infection and pathogenicity of PERV. In contrast, no vector transduction was observed on nonhuman primate cell lines, casting doubt on the utility of nonhuman primates as models for PERV zoonosis. Interference studies showed that the three PERV strains use receptors distinct from each other and from a number of other type C mammalian retroviruses.Pig-to-human xenotransplantation has the potential to alleviate the shortage of allogeneic organs for transplantation (1, 25). In addition, it may also allow the development of novel therapies by providing unlimited supplies of cells and tissues (9, 11, 13, 18). Recently, substantial progress has been made in overcoming immunological barriers to cross-species transplantation (25, 27). At the same time, however, serious concerns that zoonotic infections might occur as a result of xenotransplantation have been expressed (1, 6, 30). Our report that an established pig cell line produces a porcine endogenous retrovirus (PERV) that can infect human cells fueled these concerns (23). Subsequently, the isolation of human tropic PERV from stimulated miniswine peripheral blood lymphocytes (38) has shown that normal pig cells can also produce potentially hazardous virus. PERVs may be difficult to eliminate from donor animals because multiple copies of PERV genomes are present in normal pig genomes (2, 16, 23). PERV infection may have serious impact on the health of not only transplant recipients but also the human population at large, if spread of an undetected infectious agent into the community were to take place (3, 31). To assess the risk posed by the PERVs for pig-to-human transplantation, a greater understanding of the properties of the PERVs is required.Sequence analyses indicate that the infectious PERVs are closely related to one another in their gag and pol genes, with maximum amino acid divergence of around 5% (2, 16a, 23). The PERVs are members of the mammalian type C retrovirus genus showing closest homology to the gibbon ape leukemia virus (GALV) pol gene, with about 70% amino acid identity, and 60 to 70% identity to murine leukemia viruses (MLV). However, three distinct env genes have now been identified in PERV clones. Two of these env genes, PERV-A and PERV-B, were cloned from human 293 cells infected with PK15 virus (16). The third distinct class of PERV env gene, here designated PERV-C, was reported as a part of a full-length PERV genome isolated from miniature swine lymphocytes (PERV-MSL) and from a swine lymphoma (PERV-Tsukuba-1) (2, 32). The three types show marked differences in the VRA, VRB, and PRO regions of SU surface glycoprotein (2, 16). Differences in these regions determine the host range specificity of the different classes of MLV (4, 5). These observations suggest that the PERVs belong to three distinct classes with different host range specificities. To test this idea, the functions of the three types of PERV env gene were examined and correlated to production, infection, and replication of PERVs in cell culture. Recombinant retrovirus vectors bearing PERV Env proteins were developed and their host ranges, cell tropism, and interference with each other as well as with other type C retroviruses were examined. The results of these experiments are the subject of this report.     

Identification of exogenous forms of human-tropic porcine endogenous retrovirus in miniature Swine

The replication of porcine endogenous retrovirus subgroup A (PERV-A) and PERV-B in certain human cell lines indicates that PERV may pose an infectious risk in clinical xenotransplantation. We have previously reported that human-tropic PERVs isolated from infected human cells following cocultivation with miniature swine peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) are recombinants of PERV-A with PERV-C. Here, we report that these recombinants are exogenous viruses in miniature swine; i.e., they are not present in the germ line DNA. These viruses were invariably present in miniature swine that transmitted PERV to human cells and were also identified in some miniature swine that lacked this ability. These data, together with the demonstration of the absence of both replication-competent PERV-A and recombinant PERV-A/C loci in the genome of miniature swine (L. Scobie, S. Taylor, J. C. Wood, K. M. Suling, G. Quinn, C. Patience, H.-J. Schuurman, and D. E. Onions, J. Virol. 78:2502-2509, 2004), indicate that exogenous PERV is the principal source of human-tropic virus in these animals. Interestingly, strong expression of PERV-C in PBMC correlated with an ability of the PBMC to transmit PERV-A/C recombinants in vitro, indicating that PERV-C may be an important factor affecting the production of human-tropic PERV. In light of these observations, the safety of clinical xenotransplantation from miniature swine will be most enhanced by the utilization of source animals that do not transmit PERV to either human or porcine cells. Such animals were identified within the miniature swine herd and may further enhance the safety of clinical xenotransplantation.     

Isolation and characterization of an infectious replication-competent molecular clone of ecotropic porcine endogenous retrovirus class C

Xenotransplantation of pig organs is complicated by the existence of polytropic replication-competent porcine endogenous retroviruses (PERV) capable of infecting human cells. The potential for recombination between ecotropic PERV-C and human-tropic PERV-A and PERV-B adds another level of infectious risk. Proviral PERV-C were characterized in MAX-T cells derived from d/d haplotype miniature swine. Three proviruses were cloned from a genomic library. Clone PERV-C(1312) generated infectious particles after transfection into porcine ST-IOWA cells. Electron microscopy revealed the same morphologies of virions in MAX-T cells and in ST-IOWA cells infected with cell-free PERV-C(1312) particles, indicating that MAX-T cells harbor one functional PERV-C provirus.     

Xenotransplantation: benefits, risks and relevance of reproductive technology

Xenotransplantation from pigs provides a possible way around the shortage of human organs for transplantation. The highly inbred Westran line of pigs is genetically well characterised and known to lack endogenous retroviruses able to infect human cells. Like most inbreds, it has poor reproductive performance for which reproductive interventions would be desirable.     

异种移植的病毒安全性研究进展

猪-人异种移植有望解决人源器官短缺的严重问题。然而,以前病毒（provirus）形式整合入猪基因组中的猪内源性反转录病毒（porcine endogenous retrovirus,PERV）难以去除,PERV有可能通过异种移植传播给人类,甚至产生新的病毒性疾病。本文回顾了PERV与异种移植病毒安全性及我国特有小型猪中PERV的相关研究。