Phage Display of the Serpin Alpha-1 Proteinase Inhibitor Randomized at Consecutive Residues in the Reactive Centre Loop and Biopanned with or without Thrombin

In spite of the power of phage display technology to identify variant proteins with novel properties in large libraries, it has only been previously applied to one member of the serpin superfamily. Here we describe phage display of human alpha-1 proteinase inhibitor (API) in a T7 bacteriophage system. API M358R fused to the C-terminus of T7 capsid protein 10B was directly shown to form denaturation-resistant complexes with thrombin by electrophoresis and immunoblotting following exposure of intact phages to thrombin. We therefore developed a biopanning protocol in which thrombin-reactive phages were selected using biotinylated anti-thrombin antibodies and streptavidin-coated magnetic beads. A library consisting of displayed API randomized at residues 357 and 358 (P2–P1) yielded predominantly Pro-Arg at these positions after five rounds of thrombin selection; in contrast the same degree of mock selection yielded only non-functional variants. A more diverse library of API M358R randomized at residues 352–356 (P7–P3) was also probed, yielding numerous variants fitting a loose consensus of DLTVS as judged by sequencing of the inserts of plaque-purified phages. The thrombin-selected sequences were transferred en masse into bacterial expression plasmids, and lysates from individual colonies were screening for API-thrombin complexing. The most active candidates from this sixth round of screening contained DITMA and AAFVS at P7–P3 and inhibited thrombin 2.1-fold more rapidly than API M358R with no change in reaction stoichiometry. Deep sequencing using the Ion Torrent platform confirmed that over 800 sequences were significantly enriched in the thrombin-panned versus naïve phage display library, including some detected using the combined phage display/bacterial lysate screening approach. Our results show that API joins Plasminogen Activator Inhibitor-1 (PAI-1) as a serpin amenable to phage display and suggest the utility of this approach for the selection of “designer serpins” with novel reactivity and/or specificity.     

Full or partial substitution of the reactive center loop of alpha-1-proteinase inhibitor by that of heparin cofactor II: P1 Arg is required for maximal thrombin inhibition

The abundant plasma protein alpha(1)-proteinase inhibitor (alpha(1)-PI) physiologically inhibits neutrophil elastase (NE) and factor XIa and belongs to the serine protease inhibitor (serpin) protein superfamily. Inhibitory serpins possess a surface peptide domain called the reactive center loop (RCL), which contains the P1-P1' scissile peptide bond. Conversion of this bond in alpha(1)-PI from Met-Ser to Arg-Ser in alpha(1)-PI Pittsburgh (M358R) redirects alpha(1)-PI from inhibiting NE to inhibiting thrombin (IIa), activated protein C (APC), and other proteases. In contrast to either the wild-type or M358R alpha(1)-PI, heparin cofactor II (HCII) is a IIa-specific inhibitor with an atypical Leu-Ser reactive center. We examined the effects of replacement of all or part of the RCL of alpha(1)-PI with the corresponding parts of the HCII RCL on the activity and specificity of the resulting chimeric inhibitors. A series of 12 N-terminally His-tagged alpha(1)-PI proteins differing only in their RCL residues were expressed as soluble proteins in Escherichia coli. Substitution of the P16-P3' loop of alpha(1)-PI with that of HCII increased the low intrinsic antithrombin activity of alpha(1)-PI to near that of heparin-free HCII, while analogous substitution of the P2'-P3' dipeptide surpassed this level. However, gel-based complexing and quantitative kinetic assays showed that all mutant proteins inhibited thrombin at less than 2% of the rate of alpha(1)-PI (M358R) unless the P1 residue was also mutated to Arg. An alpha(1)-PI (P16-P3' HCII/M358R) variant was only 3-fold less active than M358R against IIa but 70-fold less active against APC. The reduction in anti-APC activity is desired in an antithrombotic agent, but the improvement in inhibitory profile came at the cost of a 3.5-fold increase in the stoichiometry of inhibition. Our results suggest that, while P1 Arg is essential for maximal antithrombin activity in engineered alpha(1)-PI proteins, substitution of the corresponding HCII residues can enhance thrombin specificity.     

Canonical inhibitor-like interactions explain reactivity of alpha1-proteinase inhibitor Pittsburgh and antithrombin with proteinases

The serpin antithrombin is a slow thrombin inhibitor that requires heparin to enhance its reaction rate. In contrast, alpha1-proteinase inhibitor (alpha1PI) Pittsburgh (P1 Met --> Arg natural variant) inhibits thrombin 17 times faster than pentasaccharide heparin-activated antithrombin. We present here x-ray structures of free and S195A trypsin-bound alpha1PI Pittsburgh, which show that the reactive center loop (RCL) possesses a canonical conformation in the free serpin that does not change upon binding to S195A trypsin and that contacts the proteinase only between P2 and P2'. By inference from the structure of heparin cofactor II bound to S195A thrombin, this RCL conformation is also appropriate for binding to thrombin. Reaction rates of trypsin and thrombin with alpha1PI Pittsburgh and antithrombin and their P2 variants show that the low antithrombin-thrombin reaction rate results from the antithrombin RCL sequence at P2 and implies that, in solution, the antithrombin RCL must be in a similar canonical conformation to that found here for alpha1PI Pittsburgh, even in the nonheparin-activated state. This suggests a general, limited, canonical-like interaction between serpins and proteinases in their Michaelis complexes.     

The crystal structure of plasminogen activator inhibitor 2 at 2.0 A resolution: implications for serpin function.

BACKGROUND: Plasminogen activator inhibitor 2 (PAI-2) is a member of the serpin family of protease inhibitors that function via a dramatic structural change from a native, stressed state to a relaxed form. This transition is mediated by a segment of the serpin termed the reactive centre loop (RCL); the RCL is cleaved on interaction with the protease and becomes inserted into betasheet A of the serpin. Major questions remain as to what factors facilitate this transition and how they relate to protease inhibition. RESULTS: The crystal structure of a mutant form of human PAI-2 in the stressed state has been determined at 2.0 A resolution. The RCL is completely disordered in the structure. An examination of polar residues that are highly conserved across all serpins identifies functionally important regions. A buried polar cluster beneath betasheet A (the so-called 'shutter' region) is found to stabilise both the stressed and relaxed forms via a rearrangement of hydrogen bonds. CONCLUSIONS: A statistical analysis of interstrand interactions indicated that the shutter region can be used to discriminate between inhibitory and non-inhibitory serpins. This analysis implied that insertion of the RCL into betasheet A up to residue P8 is important for protease inhibition and hence the structure of the complex formed between the serpin and the target protease.     

Corticosteroid-binding globulin, a structural basis for steroid transport and proteinase-triggered release

Corticosteroid-binding globulin (CBG) is a serine proteinase inhibitor (serpin) family member that transports glucocorticoids in blood and regulates their access to target cells. The 1.9A crystal structure of rat CBG shows that its steroid-binding site resembles the thyroxin-binding site in the related serpin, thyroxin-binding globulin, and mutagenesis studies have confirmed the contributions of key residues that constitute the steroid-binding pocket. Unlike thyroxin-bound thyroxin-binding globulin, the cortisol-bound CBG displays an "active" serpin conformation with the proteinase-sensitive, reactive center loop (RCL) fully expelled from the regulatory beta-sheet A. Moreover, the CBG structure allows us to predict that complete insertion of the proteolytically cleaved RCL into the serpin fold occurs in concert with a displacement and unwinding of helix D that would disrupt the steroid-binding site. This allosteric coupling between RCL positioning and occupancy of the CBG steroid-binding site, which resembles the ligand (glycosamino-glycan)-dependent activation of the thrombin inhibitory serpins heparin cofactor II and anti-thrombin RCLs, ensures both optimal recognition of CBG by target proteinases and efficient release of steroid to sites of action.     

The structure of active serpin 1K from Manduca sexta.

BACKGROUND: The reactive center loops (RCL) of serpins undergo large conformational changes triggered by the interaction with their target protease. Available crystallographic data suggest that the serpin RCL is polymorphic, but the relevance of the observed conformations to the competent active structure and the conformational changes that occur on binding target protease has remained obscure. New high-resolution data on an active serpin, serpin 1K from the moth hornworm Manduca sexta, provide insights into how active serpins are stabilized and how conformational changes are induced by protease binding. RESULTS: The 2.1 A structure shows that the RCL of serpin 1K, like that of active alpha1-antitrypsin, is canonical, complimentary and ready to bind to the target protease between P3 and P3 (where P refers to standard protease nomenclature),. In the hinge region (P17-P13), however, the RCL of serpin 1K, like ovalbumin and alpha1-antichymotrypsin, forms tight interactions that stabilize the five-stranded closed form of betasheet A. These interactions are not present in, and are not compatible with, the observed structure of active alpha1-antitrypsin. CONCLUSIONS: Serpin 1K may represent the best resting conformation for serpins - canonical near P1, but stabilized in the closed conformation of betasheet A. By comparison with other active serpins, especially alpha1-antitrypsin, a model is proposed in which interaction with the target protease near P1 leads to conformational changes in betasheet A of the serpin.     

Conformational changes in thrombin when complexed by serpins

Thrombin possesses two positively charged surface domains, termed exosites, that orient substrates and inhibitors for reaction with the enzyme. Because the exosites also allosterically modulate thrombin's activity, we set out to determine whether the structure or function of the exosites changes when thrombin forms complexes with antithrombin, heparin cofactor II, or alpha(1)-antitrypsin (M358R), serpins that utilize both, one, or neither of the exosites, respectively. Using a hirudin-derived peptide to probe the integrity of exosite 1, no binding was detected when thrombin was complexed with heparin cofactor II or alpha(1)-antitrypsin (M358R), and the peptide exhibited a 55-fold lower affinity for the thrombin-antithrombin complex than for thrombin. Bound peptide or HD-1, an exosite 1-binding DNA aptamer, was displaced from thrombin by each of the three serpins. Thrombin binding to fibrin also was abrogated when the enzyme was complexed with serpins. These data reveal that, regardless of the initial mode of interaction, the function of exosite 1 is lost when thrombin is complexed by serpins. In contrast, the integrity of exosite 2 is largely retained when thrombin is complexed by serpins, because interaction with heparin or an exosite 2-directed DNA aptamer was only modestly altered. The disorganization of exosite 1 that occurs when thrombin is complexed by serpins is consistent with results of protease sensitivity studies and crystallographic analysis of a homologous enzyme-serpin complex.     

Understanding the specificity of serpin–protease complexes through interface analysis

Serpins such as antithrombin, heparin cofactor II, plasminogen activator inhibitor, antitrypsin, antichymotrypsin, and neuroserpin are involved in important biological processes by inhibiting specific serine proteases. Initially, the protease recognizes the mobile reactive loop of the serpin eliciting conformational changes, where the cleaved loop together with the protease inserts into β-sheet A, translocating the protease to the opposite side of inhibitor leading to its inactivation. Serpin interaction with proteases is governed mainly by the reactive center loop residues (RCL). However, in some inhibitory serpins, exosite residues apart from RCL have been shown to confer protease specificity. Further, this forms the basis of multi-specificity of some serpins, but the residues and their dimension at interface in serpin-protease complexes remain elusive. Here, we present a comprehensive structural analysis of the serpin-protease interfaces using bio COmplexes COntact MAPS (COCOMAPS), PRotein Interface Conservation and Energetics (PRICE), and ProFace programs. We have carried out interface, burial, and evolutionary analysis of different serpin-protease complexes. Among the studied complexes, non-inhibitory serpins exhibit larger interface region with greater number of residue involvement as compared to the inhibitory serpins. On comparing the multi-specific serpins (antithrombin and antitrypsin), a difference in the interface area and residue number was observed, suggestive of a differential mechanism of action of these serpins in regulating their different target proteases. Further, detailed study of these multi-specific serpins listed few essential residues (common in all the complexes) and certain specificity (unique to each complex) determining residues at their interfaces. Structural mapping of interface residues suggested that individual patches with evolutionary conserved residues in specific serpins determine their specificity towards a particular protease.     

Partitioning of serpin-proteinase reactions between stable inhibition and substrate cleavage is regulated by the rate of serpin reactive center loop insertion into beta-sheet A

The serpin family of serine proteinase inhibitors is a mechanistically unique class of naturally occurring proteinase inhibitors that trap target enzymes as stable covalent acyl-enzyme complexes. This mechanism appears to require both cleavage of the serpin reactive center loop (RCL) by the proteinase and a significant conformational change in the serpin structure involving rapid insertion of the RCL into the center of an existing beta-sheet, serpin beta-sheet A. The present study demonstrates that partitioning between inhibitor and substrate modes of reaction can be altered by varying either the rates of RCL insertion or deacylation using a library of serpin RCL mutants substituted in the critical P(14) hinge residue and three different proteinases. We further correlate the changes in partitioning with the actual rates of RCL insertion for several of the variants upon reaction with the different proteinases as determined by fluorescence spectroscopy of specific RCL-labeled inhibitor mutants. These data demonstrate that the serpin mechanism follows a branched pathway, and that the formation of a stable inhibited complex is dependent upon both the rate of the RCL conformational change and the rate of enzyme deacylation.     

Mutant recombinant serpins as highly specific inhibitors of human kallikrein 14

The reactive center loop (RCL) of serpins plays an essential role in the inhibition mechanism acting as a substrate for their target proteases. Changes within the RCL sequence modulate the specificity and reactivity of the serpin molecule. Recently, we reported the construction of alpha1-antichymotrypsin (ACT) variants with high specificity towards human kallikrein 2 (hK2) [Cloutier SM, Kündig C, Felber LM, Fattah OM, Chagas JR, Gygi CM, Jichlinski P, Leisinger HJ & Deperthes D (2004) Eur J Biochem271, 607-613] by changing amino acids surrounding the scissile bond of the RCL and obtained specific inhibitors towards hK2. Based on this approach, we developed highly specific recombinant inhibitors of human kallikrein 14 (hK14), a protease correlated with increased aggressiveness of prostate and breast cancers. In addition to the RCL permutation with hK14 phage display-selected substrates E8 (LQRAI) and G9 (TVDYA) [Felber LM, Borgo?o CA, Cloutier SM, Kündig C, Kishi T, Chagas JR, Jichlinski P, Gygi CM, Leisinger HJ, Diamandis EP & Deperthes D (2005) Biol Chem386, 291-298], we studied the importance of the scaffold, serpins alpha1-antitrypsin (AAT) or ACT, to confer inhibitory specificity. All four resulting serpin variants ACT(E8), ACT(G9), AAT(E8) and AAT(G9) showed hK14 inhibitory activity and were able to form covalent complex with hK14. ACT inhibitors formed more stable complexes with hK14 than AAT variants. Whereas E8-based inhibitors demonstrated a rather relaxed specificity reacting with various proteases with trypsin-like activity including several human kallikreins, the two serpins variants containing the G9 sequence showed a very high selectivity for hK14. Such specific inhibitors might prove useful to elucidate the biological role of hK14 and/or its implication in cancer.     

The transferable tail: fusion of the N-terminal acidic extension of heparin cofactor II to alpha1-proteinase inhibitor M358R specifically increases the rate of thrombin inhibition

The conversion of the reactive center bond of the serpin alpha1-proteinase inhibitor (alpha1-PI, also known as alpha1-antitrypsin) from Met-Ser to Arg-Ser decreases the rate at which it inhibits neutrophil elastase and endows it with the ability to inhibit thrombin and activated protein C (APC). Another serpin, heparin cofactor II (HCII), contains a unique N-terminal extension that binds thrombin exosite 1. We fused residues 1-75 of HCII to the N-terminus of alpha1-PI M358R, forming an HCII-alpha1-PI chimera (HAPI M358R). It inhibited alpha-thrombin 21-fold faster than alpha1-PI M358R, with second-order rate constants of 2.3 x 10(8) M(-1) min(-1) versus 1.1 x 10(7) M(-1) min(-1), respectively. When gammaT-thrombin, which lacks an intact exosite 1, was substituted for alpha-thrombin, the kinetic advantage of HAPI M358R over alpha1-PI M358R was reduced to 9-fold, whereas APC and trypsin, proteases lacking exosite 1-like regions, were inhibited only 1.3- and 2-fold more rapidly by HAPI M358R than by alpha1-PI M358R, respectively. Maximal enhancement of alpha1-PI M358R activity required the acidic residues found between HCII residues 55 and 75, because no enhancement was observed either by fusion of residues 1-54 alone or by fusion of a mutated HCII acidic extension in which all Glu and Asp residues between positions 55 and 75 were neutralized by mutation. Fusing residues 55-75 to alpha1-PI M358R yielded a relative rate enhancement of only 6-fold, suggesting a need for the full tail region to achieve maximal enhancement. Our results suggest that transfer of the N-terminal acidic extension of HCII to alpha1-PI M358R enhanced its inhibition of thrombin by conferring the ability to bind exosite 1 on HAPI M358R. This enhancement may aid in efforts to tailor this inhibitor for therapeutic use.     

Structure of native protein C inhibitor provides insight into its multiple functions

Protein C inhibitor (PCI) is a multifunctional serpin with wide ranging protease inhibitory functions, unique cofactor binding activities, and potential non-inhibitory functions akin to the hormone-transporting serpins. To gain insight into the molecular mechanisms utilized by PCI we developed a robust expression system in Escherichia coli and solved the crystal structure of PCI in its native state. The five monomers obtained from our two crystal forms provide an NMR-like ensemble revealing regions of inherent flexibility. The reactive center loop (RCL) of PCI is long and highly flexible with no evidence of hinge region incorporation into beta-sheet A, as seen for other heparin-binding serpins. We adapted an extrinsic fluorescence method for determining dissociation constants for heparin and find that the N-terminal tail of PCI and residues adjacent to helix H are not involved in heparin binding. The minimal heparin length capable of tight binding to PCI was determined to be chains of eight monosaccharide units. A large hydrophobic pocket occupied by hydrophobic crystal contacts was found in an analogous position to the hormone-binding site in thyroxine-binding globulin. In conclusion, the data presented here provide important insights into the mechanisms by which PCI exercises its multiple inhibitory and non-inhibitory functions.     

Interaction between the P14 residue and strand 2 of beta-sheet B is critical for reactive center loop insertion in plasminogen activator inhibitor-2

The molecular interactions driving reactive center loop (RCL) insertion are of considerable interest in gaining a better understanding of the serpin inhibitory mechanism. Previous studies have suggested that interactions in the proximal hinge/breach region may be critical determinants of RCL insertion in serpins. In this study, conformational and functional changes in plasminogen activator inhibitor-2 (PAI-2) following incubation with a panel of synthetic RCL peptides indicated that the P14 residue is critical for RCL insertion, and hence inhibitory activity, in PAI-2. Only RCL peptides with a P14 threonine were able to induce the stressed to relaxed transition and abolish inhibitory activity in PAI-2, indicating that RCL insertion into beta-sheet A of PAI-2 is dependent upon this residue. The recently solved crystal structure of relaxed PAI-2 (PAI-2.RCL peptide complex) allowed detailed analysis of molecular interactions involving P14 related to RCL insertion. Of most interest is the rearrangement of hydrogen bonding around the breach region that accompanies the stressed to relaxed transition, in particular the formation of a side chain hydrogen bond between the threonine at P14 and an adjacent tyrosine on strand 2 of beta-sheet B in relaxed PAI-2. Structural alignment of known serpin sequences showed that this pairing (or the equivalent serine/threonine pairing) is highly conserved ( approximately 87%) in inhibitory serpins and may represent a general structural basis for serpin inhibitory activity.     

Development of recombinant inhibitors specific to human kallikrein 2 using phage-display selected substrates.

The reactive site loop of serpins undoubtedly defines in part their ability to inhibit a particular enzyme. Exchanges in the reactive loop of serpins might reassign the targets and modify the serpin-protease interaction kinetics. Based on this concept, we have developed a procedure to change the specificity of known serpins. First, reactive loops are very good substrates for the target enzymes. Therefore, we have used the phage-display technology to select from a pentapeptide phage library the best substrates for the human prostate kallikrein hK2 [Cloutier, S.M., Chagas, J.R., Mach, J.P., Gygi, C.M., Leisinger, H.J. & Deperthes, D. (2002) Eur. J. Biochem. 269, 2747-2754]. Selected substrates were then transplanted into the reactive site loop of alpha1-antichymotrypsin to generate new variants of this serpin, able to inhibit the serine protease. Thus, we have developed some highly specific alpha1-antichymotrypsin variants toward human kallikrein 2 which also show high reactivity. These inhibitors might be useful to help elucidate the importance of hK2 in prostate cancer progression.     

Serpins Flex Their Muscle: II. STRUCTURAL INSIGHTS INTO TARGET PEPTIDASE RECOGNITION,POLYMERIZATION, AND TRANSPORT FUNCTIONS*

Inhibitory serpins are metastable proteins that undergo a substantial conformational rearrangement to covalently trap target peptidases. The serpin reactive center loop contributes a majority of the interactions that serpins make during the initial binding to target peptidases. However, structural studies on serpin-peptidase complexes reveal a broader set of contacts on the scaffold of inhibitory serpins that have substantial influence on guiding peptidase recognition. Structural and biophysical studies also reveal how aberrant serpin folding can lead to the formation of domain-swapped serpin multimers rather than the monomeric metastable state. Serpin domain swapping may therefore underlie the polymerization events characteristic of the serpinopathies. Finally, recent structural studies reveal how the serpin fold has been adapted for non-inhibitory functions such as hormone binding.     

Mutational analysis of plasminogen activator inhibitor-1.

The serpin plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1) is a fast and specific inhibitor of the plasminogen activating serine proteases tissue-type and urokinase-type plasminogen activator and, as such, an important regulator in turnover of extracellular matrix and in fibrinolysis. PAI-1 spontaneously loses its antiproteolytic activity by inserting its reactive centre loop (RCL) as strand 4 in beta-sheet A, thereby converting to the so-called latent state. We have investigated the importance of the amino acid sequence of alpha-helix F (hF) and the connecting loop to s3A (hF/s3A-loop) for the rate of latency transition. We grafted regions of the hF/s3A-loop from antithrombin III and alpha1-protease inhibitor onto PAI-1, creating eight variants, and found that one of these reversions towards the serpin consensus decreased the rate of latency transition. We prepared 28 PAI-1 variants with individual residues in hF and beta-sheet A replaced by an alanine. We found that mutating serpin consensus residues always had functional consequences whereas mutating nonconserved residues only had so in one case. Two variants had low but stable inhibitory activity and a pronounced tendency towards substrate behaviour, suggesting that insertion of the RCL is held back during latency transition as well as during complex formation with target proteases. The data presented identify new determinants of PAI-1 latency transition and provide general insight into the characteristic loop-sheet interactions in serpins.     

Anti-hemostatic effects of a serpin from the saliva of the tick Ixodes ricinus

Serpins (serine protease inhibitors) are a large family of structurally related proteins found in a wide variety of organisms, including hematophagous arthropods. Protein analyses revealed that Iris, previously described as an immunomodulator secreted in the tick saliva, is related to the leukocyte elastase inhibitor and possesses serpin motifs, including the reactive center loop (RCL), which is involved in the interaction between serpins and serine proteases. Only serine proteases were inhibited by purified recombinant Iris (rIris), whereas mutants L339A and A332P were found devoid of any protease inhibitory activity. The highest Ka was observed with human leukocyte-elastase, suggesting that elastase-like proteases are the natural targets of Iris. In addition, mutation M340R completely changed both Iris substrate specificity and affinity. This likely identified Met-340 as amino acid P1 in the RCL. The effects of rIris and its mutants were also tested on primary hemostasis, blood clotting, and fibrinolysis. rIris increased platelet adhesion, the contact phase-activated pathway of coagulation, and fibrinolysis times in a dose-dependent manner, whereas rIris mutant L339A affected only platelet adhesion. Taken together, these results indicate that Iris disrupts coagulation and fibrinolysis via the anti-proteolytic RCL domain. One or more other domains could be responsible for primary hemostasis inhibition. To our knowledge, this is the first ectoparasite serpin that interferes with both hemostasis and the immune response.