Ligamentous versus physeal failure in murine medial collateral ligament biomechanical testing

This study examines the age at which a femoral physeal failure ceased to occur in a mouse model of medial collateral ligament (MCL) testing. Biomechanical testing of the MCL with load to failure can result in physeal failure rather than MCL failure in skeletally immature animals. Failure mode depended significantly on age (p<0.05). Sixty percent of the knees tested at 4 months failed at the physis rather than at the ligament, whereas, only ten percent of the knees tested at 5 and 6 months failed at the physis. The mean ultimate force to failure for the specimens in which the failure occurred at the ligament was 8.1 N with a higher values for the right side versus the left (p<0.05). For the specimens in which the failure occurred at the physis, the mean ultimate force to failure was 11.2 N. We now consider that 5 month old mice are functionally skeletally mature and old enough to be tested biomechanically with few failures at the physis.     

The symmetry of the medial collateral and anterior cruciate ligament properties: a biochemical study in the rat hind limb

The medial collateral (MCL) and the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) of the rat's knee are frequently used in biomedical research and occasionally in ligament healing studies. The contralateral normal ligament serves as a control. In this study the presence of symmetry in the biomechanical properties of the MCL and the ACL was investigated. Bilateral femur-MCL-tibia and femur-ACL-tibia preparations were obtained from the hind limbs of sixty rats and were subjected to tensile testing to failure under the same loading conditions. Tensile load to failure, stiffness and energy absorption capacity were measured and the mode of failure was recorded. All biomechanical parameters were not significantly different between the two knees of the same animal, although significant individual variation was evident. The most common mechanism of failure was mid-substance tear. Symmetry seems to exist in the biomechanical properties of the MCL and the ACL in the rat knee. When ligament healing is evaluated, increased group size is necessary and the use of a normal control group may be advisable. The contralateral normal knee ligament may serve as a control when the properties of an injured ligament are evaluated and when the parameters of tensile testing failure under similar load conditions are applied.     

Effect of ACL deficiency on MCL strains and joint kinematics

The knee joint is partially stabilized by the interaction of multiple ligament structures. This study tested the interdependent functions of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and the medial collateral ligament (MCL) by evaluating the effects of ACL deficiency on local MCL strain while simultaneously measuring joint kinematics under specific loading scenarios. A structural testing machine applied anterior translation and valgus rotation (limits 100 N and 10 N m, respectively) to the tibia of ten human cadaveric knees with the ACL intact or severed. A three-dimensional motion analysis system measured joint kinematics and MCL tissue strain in 18 regions of the superficial MCL. ACL deficiency significantly increased MCL strains by 1.8% (p<0.05) during anterior translation, bringing ligament fibers to strain levels characteristic of microtrauma. In contrast, ACL transection had no effect on MCL strains during valgus rotation (increase of only 0.1%). Therefore, isolated valgus rotation in the ACL-deficient knee was nondetrimental to the MCL. The ACL was also found to promote internal tibial rotation during anterior translation, which in turn decreased strains near the femoral insertion of the MCL. These data advance the basic structure-function understanding of the MCL, and may benefit the treatment of ACL injuries by improving the knowledge of ACL function and clarifying motions that are potentially harmful to secondary stabilizers.     

Ligament-bone interaction in a three-dimensional model of the knee

In mathematical knee-joint models, the ligaments are usually represented by straight-line elements, connecting the insertions of the femur and tibia. Such a model may not be valid if a ligament is bent in its course over bony-surfaces, particularly not if the resulting redirection of the ligament force has a considerable effect on the laxity or motion characteristics of the knee-joint model. In the present study, a model for wrapping of a ligament around bone was incorporated in a three-dimensional mathematical model of the human knee. The bony edge was described by a curved line on which the contact point of the line element representing a ligament bundle was located. Frictionless contact between the ligament bundle and the bone was assumed. This model was applied to the medial collateral ligament (MCL) interacting with the bony edge of the tibia. It was found that, in comparison with the original model without bony interactions, the bony edge redirected the ligament force of the MCL in such a way that it counterbalanced valgus moments on the tibia more effectively. The effect of the bony interaction with the MCL on the internal-external rotation laxity, however, was negligible.     

Acute modification of biomechanical properties of the bone-ligament insertion to rat limb unweighting

We investigated the acute adaptation of the rat femur-medial collateral ligament-tibia (FMT) complex to 7 days of limb unweighting by means of a hind-limb suspension protocol. Male, young adult, Harlan Sprague-Dawley rats were randomly assigned to either control or suspended groups. Rats deprived of hind limb-to-ground contact forces had a 42% decrease in soleus muscle mass compared with the control group. Medial collateral ligament (MCL) length and cross-sectional area were measured, and each FMT complex was tension tested to failure. All failed at their tibia-MCL insertion. The ultimate load in the FMT and the peak Kirchhoff stress in the MCL (occurring immediately before insertion site failure) were significantly reduced in the suspended group. The suspended MCLs were 9.7% larger in area and 5.7% shorter in length than the controls under the same preload (0.25 N). We found no significant differences between the control and suspended MCLs in Green strain, stretch, or deformation immediately before insertion site failure, nor did we find a significant difference in the MCL tangent modulus. This study indicates that even acute periods of limb unweighting can structurally compromise bone-ligament insertions. Further, this study implies that the adaptations responsible for this structural compromise must involve acute changes in the intrinsic zone (or zones) of the bone-ligament insertion.     

Effects of medial collateral ligament release,limb correction,and soft tissue laxity on knee joint contact force distribution after medial opening wedge high tibial osteotomy: a computational study

In this study, the effects of medial collateral ligament (MCL) release and the limb correction strategies with pre-existing MCL laxity on tibiofemoral contact force distribution after high tibial osteotomy (HTO) were investigated. The medial and lateral contact forces of the knee were quantified during simulated standing using computational modeling techniques. MCL slackness had a primary influence on contact force distribution of the knee, while there was little effect of simulated limb correction. Anterior and middle bundle release, which involved the partial release of two-thirds of the superficial MCL, was shown to be an optimal surgical method in HTO, achieving balanced contact distribution in simulated weight-bearing standing.     

The effect of isolated valgus moments on ACL strain during single-leg landing: A simulation study

Valgus moments on the knee joint during single-leg landing have been suggested as a risk factor for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury. The purpose of this study was to test the influence of isolated valgus moment on ACL strain during single-leg landing. Physiologic levels of valgus moments from an in vivo study of single-leg landing were applied to a three-dimensional dynamic knee model, previously developed and tested for ACL strain measurement during simulated landing. The ACL strain, knee valgus angle, tibial rotation, and medial collateral ligament (MCL) strain were calculated and analyzed. The study shows that the peak ACL strain increased nonlinearly with increasing peak valgus moment. Subjects with naturally high valgus moments showed greater sensitivity for increased ACL strain with increased valgus moment, but ACL strain plateaus below reported ACL failure levels when the applied isolated valgus moment rises above the maximum values observed during normal cutting activities. In addition, the tibia was observed to rotate externally as the peak valgus moment increased due to bony and soft-tissue constraints. In conclusion, knee valgus moment increases peak ACL strain during single-leg landing. However, valgus moment alone may not be sufficient to induce an isolated ACL tear without concomitant damage to the MCL, because coupled tibial external rotation and increasing strain in the MCL prevent proportional increases in ACL strain at higher levels of valgus moment. Training that reduces the external valgus moment, however, can reduce the ACL strain and thus may help athletes reduce their overall ACL injury risk.     

Effects of postmortem storage by freezing on ligament tensile behavior

The purpose of this study is to examine the effect of prolonged postmortem freezing storage (between 1 1/2 and 3 months at -20 degrees C) on the structural properties of the medial collateral ligament (MCL)-bone complex as well as the mechanical properties of the MCL substance from the rabbit knee. Tensile testing of the femur-MCL-tibia specimen was performed and no statistically significant changes were noted between the fresh and stored samples in terms of the cyclic stress relaxation, the load-deformation characteristics, as well as the load, deformation and energy absorbing capability at failure. The area of hysteresis of the stored samples was significantly reduced in the first few cycles, however. The mechanical properties of the MCL substance, as represented by the stress-strain curves, tensile strength and ultimate strain also did not change following storage. We conclude, therefore, proper and careful storage by freezing would have little or no effect on the biomechanical properties of the ligaments.     

A new method of measuring the cross-sectional area of connective tissue structures

There appears to be no generally accepted method of measuring in-situ the cross-sectional area of connective tissues, particularly small ones, before mechanical testing. An instrument has therefore been devised to measure the cross-sectional area of one such tissue, the rabbit medial collateral ligament, directly and nondestructively. However, the methodology is general and could be applied to other tissues with appropriate changes in detail. The concept employed in the instrument is to measure the thickness of the tissue as a function of position along the width of the tissue. The plot obtained of thickness versus width position is integrated to provide the cross-sectional area. This area is accurate to within 5 percent, depending mainly on alignment of the instrument and pre-load of the ligament. Results on the mid-substance of the rabbit medial collateral ligaments are repeatable and reproducible. Values of maximum width and thickness are less variable than those obtained with a vernier caliper. The measured area is considerably less than that estimated assuming rectangular cross-section and slightly less than that estimated on the assumption of elliptical cross-section.     

Recruitment of knee joint ligaments

On the basis of earlier reported data on the in vitro kinematics of passive knee-joint motions of four knee specimens, the length changes of ligament fiber bundles were determined by using the points of insertion on the tibia and femur. The kinematic data and the insertions of the ligaments were obtained by using Roentgenstereophotogrammetry. Different fiber bundles of the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments and the medial and lateral collateral ligaments were identified. On the basis of an assumption for the maximal strain of each ligament fiber bundle during the experiments, the minimal recruitment length and the probability of recruitment were defined and determined. The motions covered the range from extension to 95 degrees flexion and the loading conditions included internal or external moments of 3 Nm and anterior or posterior forces of 30 N. The ligament length and recruitment patterns were found to be consistent for some ligament bundles and less consistent for other ligament bundles. The most posterior bundle of each ligament was recruited in extension and the lower flexion angles, whereas the anterior bundle was recruited for the higher flexion angles. External rotation generally recruited the collateral ligaments, while internal rotation recruited the cruciate ligaments. However, the anterior bundle of the posterior cruciate ligament was recruited with external rotation at the higher flexion angles. At the lower flexion angles, the anterior cruciate and the lateral collateral ligaments were recruited with an anterior force. The recruitment of the posterior cruciate ligament with a posterior force showed that neither its most anterior nor its most posterior bundle was recruited at the lower flexion angles. Hence, the posterior restraint must have been provided by the intermediate fiber bundles, which were not considered in the experiment. At the higher flexion angles, the anterior bundles of the anterior cruciate ligament and the posterior cruciate ligament were found to be recruited with anterior and posterior forces, respectively. The minimal recruitment length and the recruitment probability of ligament fiber bundles are useful parameters for the evaluation of ligament length changes in those experiments where no other method can be used to determine the zero strain lengths, ligament strains and tensions.     

Matrix metalloproteinase-13 expression in rabbit knee joint connective tissues: influence of maturation and response to injury.

The hypothesis of the present work was that expression of matrix metalloproteinase-13 (MMP-13, collagenase-3) would be induced during conditions involving important matrix remodeling such as ligament maturation, scar healing and joint instability. Therefore, MMP-13 expression in the medial collateral ligament (MCL) during the variable situations of tissue maturation and healing was assessed. MMP-13 expression in three intra-articular connective tissues of the knee (i.e. articular cartilage, menisci and synovium) following the transection of the anterior cruciate ligament of the knee was evaluated at 3 and 8 weeks post-injury. MMP-13 mRNA (semi-quantitative RT-PCR) and protein (immunohistochemistry and Western blotting) were detected in all of the tissues studied. Significantly higher MCL mRNA levels for MMP-13 were detected during the early phases of tissue maturation (i.e. 29 days in utero and 2-month-old rabbits) compared to later phases (5- and 12-month-old rabbits). This pattern of expression was recapitulated following MCL injury, with very high levels of expression in scar tissue at 3 weeks post-injury and then a decline to levels not significantly different from control values by 14 weeks. Elevated mRNA levels correlated with increased protein levels for MMP-13 in both menisci and synovium following the transection of the anterior cruciate ligament and during medial collateral ligament healing. These results indicate that MMP-13 expression is regulated by a number of variables and that high levels of expression occur in situations when connective tissue remodeling is very active.     

Location-dependent variations in the material properties of the anterior cruciate ligament.

Our recent anterior drawer studies in human cadaveric knees [Guan and Butler, Adv. Bioengng 17, 5 (1990); Guan et al., Trans. orthop. Res. Soc. 16, 589 (1991)] have suggested that anterior bundles of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) develop higher load-related material properties than posterior bundles. This was confirmed when we reevaluated the axial failure data for these bundle-bone specimens from an earlier study [Butler et al., J. Biomechanics 19, 425-432 (1986)]. The purpose of this study was to determine, in a larger data set, if anteromedial and anterolateral bundles of the anterior cruciate ligament exhibit significantly larger load-related material properties than the posterior ligament bundles. Seven ACL-bone units from seven donors (the three tissues from the original study plus four new ones) were subdivided into three subunits, preserving the bone insertions. The subunits were failed in tension at a constant strain rate (100% s-1) and four material properties were compared within and between donors. The anterior bundles developed significantly larger moduli, maximum stresses, and strain energy densities to maximum stress than the posterior subunits. Moduli for the anterior vs posterior subunits averaged 284 MPa vs 155 MPa, maximum stresses averaged 38 MPa vs 15 MPa, and strain energy densities averaged 2.7 N m cc-1 vs 1.1 N m cc-1, respectively. No significant differences were found, however, among strains to maximum stress or between any of the other properties for the two anterior subunits. These results are important to the design of ligament replacements and suggest new experiments designed to distinguish in vivo force levels in these ACL bands, a possible reason for the material differences.     

Subfailure damage in ligament: a structural and cellular evaluation.

Subfailure damage in ligaments was evaluated macroscopically from a structural perspective (referring to the entire ligament as a structure) and microscopically from a cellular perspective. Freshly harvested rat medial collateral ligaments (MCLs) were used as a model in ex vivo experiments. Ligaments were preloaded with 0.1 N to establish a consistent point of reference for length (and strain) measurements. Ligament structural damage was characterized by nonrecoverable difference in tissue length after a subfailure stretch. The tissue's mechanical properties (via stress vs. strain curves measured from a preloaded state) after a single subfailure stretch were also evaluated (n = 6 pairs with a different stretch magnitude applied to each stretched ligament). Regions containing necrotic cells were used to characterize cellular damage after a single stretch. It should be noted that the number of damaged cells was not quantified and the difference between cellular area and area of fluorescence is not known. Structural and cellular damage were represented and compared as functions of subfailure MCL strains. Statistical analysis indicated that the onset of structural damage occurs at 5.14% strain (referenced from a preloaded length). Subfailure strains above the damage threshold changed the shape of the MCL stress-strain curve by elongating the toe region (i.e., increasing laxity) as well as decreasing the tangential modulus and ultimate stress. Cellular damage was induced at ligament strains significantly below the structural damage threshold. This cellular damage is likely to be part of the natural healing process in mildly sprained ligaments.     

A biomechanical assessment to evaluate breed differences in normal porcine medial collateral ligaments

Little information is available on the role of genetic factors and heredity in normal ligament behaviour and their ability to heal. Assessing these factors is challenging because of the lack of suitable animal models. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to develop a porcine model in order to evaluate and compare the biomechanical differences of normal medial collateral ligaments (MCLs) between Yorkshire (YK) and red Duroc (RD) breeds. It was hypothesized that biomechanical differences would not exist between normal YK and RD MCLs. Comparisons between porcine and human MCL were also made. A biomechanical testing apparatus and protocol specific to pig MCL were developed. Ligaments were subjected to cyclic and static creep tests and then elongated to failure. Pig MCL morphology, geometry, and low- and high-load mechanical behaviour were assessed. The custom-designed apparatus and protocol were sufficiently sensitive to detect mechanical property differences between breeds as well as inter-leg differences. The results reveal that porcine MCL is comparable in both shape and size to human MCL and exhibits similar structural and material failure properties, thus making it a feasible model. Comparisons between RD and YK breeds revealed that age-matched RD pigs weigh more, have larger MCL cross-sectional area, and have lower MCL failure stress than YK pigs. The effect of weight may have influenced MCL geometrical and biomechanical properties, and consequently, the differences observed may be due to breed type and/or animal weight. In conclusion, the pig serves as a suitable large animal model for genetic-related connective tissue studies.     

Collagen fibril D-period may change as a function of strain and location in ligament

The purpose of this study was to determine if the characteristic banding pattern (D-period) of collagen fibrils from rabbit medial collateral ligaments changes as a function of gross ligament strain and, if so, whether the changes are location dependent (insertion versus midsubstance). Femur–medial collateral ligament–tibia complexes were strained to 0, 8, or 12% and immediately chemically fixed in situ. Samples were taken from the medial collateral ligament midsubstance and bony insertions, and prepared for and observed under a transmission electron microscope. D-period length was measured and found to increase (albeit not significantly so, p=0.1) as a function of gross strain for samples obtained from the insertion sites but not for samples obtained from the ligament midsubstance. Results suggested that ligament strains are inhomogeneous at the ultrastructural level.     

Strain measurement in the medial collateral ligament of the human knee: an autopsy study

A strain transducer was developed which employs a magnetic field sensing device to detect linear displacement. The transducer was attached to the medial collateral ligament (MCL) of human autopsy specimens, minimally influencing their physiologic behavior. A strain 'map' of the MCL as a function of knee flexion (full extension to 120 degrees) both with and without abduction force was obtained. Our investigation revealed consistent differences in the strain patterns between proximal, middle and distal segments of the anterior and posterior borders of the MCL. Anatomic variations in the pattern of collagen fibers within the MCL, interactions between posterior oblique capsular fibers and the MCL, and the skeletal configuration may account for these varied strain patterns.     

An improved OpenSim gait model with multiple degrees of freedom knee joint and knee ligaments

Musculoskeletal models are widely used to investigate joint kinematics and predict muscle force during gait. However, the knee is usually simplified as a one degree of freedom joint and knee ligaments are neglected. The aim of this study was to develop an OpenSim gait model with enhanced knee structures. The knee joint in this study included three rotations and three translations. The three knee rotations and mediolateral translation were independent, with proximodistal and anteroposterior translations occurring as a function of knee flexion/extension. Ten elastic elements described the geometrical and mechanical properties of the anterior and posterior cruciate ligaments (ACL and PCL), and the medial and lateral collateral ligaments (MCL and LCL). The three independent knee rotations were evaluated using OpenSim to observe ligament function. The results showed that the anterior and posterior bundles of ACL and PCL (aACL, pACL and aPCL, pPCL) intersected during knee flexion. The aACL and pACL mainly provided force during knee flexion and adduction, respectively. The aPCL was slack throughout the range of three knee rotations; however, the pPCL was utilised for knee abduction and internal rotation. The LCL was employed for knee adduction and rotation, but was slack beyond 20° of knee flexion. The MCL bundles were mainly used during knee adduction and external rotation. All these results suggest that the functions of knee ligaments in this model approximated the behaviour of the physical knee and the enhanced knee structures can improve the ability to investigate knee joint biomechanics during various gait activities.     

Establishment and comparison of fibroblast cell lines from the medial collateral and anterior cruciate ligaments of the rabbit

Summary We have developed a procedure to explant fibroblasts from the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and the medial collateral ligament (MCL) of the rabbit knee, and have optimized conditions for maintaining them in culture. Maximal growth for both ACL and MCL cells was obtained with Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium supplemented with 15% fetal bovine serum and 250 μM ascorbate. ACL and MCL fibroblasts displayed intrinsic differences in their responses to changes in culture parameters. Specifically, they displayed different growth responses when plated at different densities and responded to RPMI 1640 medium in very different ways. There were also biochemical differences between the cell types. Both cell types produced similar amounts of collagen in culture, but the ratio of type I to type III, the major collagen subtypes produced by these cells, were different. ACL fibroblasts produced 86.7% type I and 13.3% type III, and MCL fibroblasts produced 71.1% type I and 28.9% type III. In addition, total protein produced by ACL fibroblasts was higher than that produced by MCL cells. This confirms the suggestions of previous researchers that such differences might exist. This work was funded by a grant-in-aid from Medtronic of Canada, by an R&D Grant from the Alberta Ministry of Technology, Research and Telecommunications, and by the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research.     

Differential response to CoCl2-stimulated hypoxia on HIF-1α, VEGF, and MMP-2 expression in ligament cells

The adult human anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) has a poor functional healing response, whereas the medial collateral ligament (MCL) does not. The difference in intrinsic properties of these ligament cells can be due to their different response to their located microenvironment. Hypoxia is a key environmental regulator after ligament injury. In this study, we investigated the differential response of ACL and MCL fibroblasts to hypoxia on hypoxia-inducible factor-1α, vascular endothelial growth factor, and matrix metalloproteinase-2 (MMP-2) expression. Our results show that ACL cells responded to hypoxia by up-regulating the HIF-1α expression significantly as compared to MCL cells. We also observed that in MCL fibroblasts response to hypoxia resulted in increase in expression of VEGF as compared to ACL fibroblasts. After hypoxia treatment, mRNA and protein levels of MMP-2 increased in both ACL and MCL. Furthermore we found in ACL pro-MMP-2 was converted more into active form. However, hypoxia decreased the percentage of wound closure for both ligament cells and had a greater effect on ACL fibroblasts. These results demonstrate that ACL and MCL fibroblasts respond differently under the hypoxic conditions suggesting that these differences in intrinsic properties may contribute to their different healing responses and abilities.     

The effects of refreezing on the viscoelastic and tensile properties of ligaments

Biomechanical testing protocols for ligaments can be extensive and span two or more days. During this time, a specimen may have to undergo more than one cycle of freezing and thawing. Thus, the objective of this study was to evaluate the effects of refreezing on the viscoelastic and tensile properties of ligaments. The femur-medial collateral ligament-tibia complexes (FMTC) from six pairs of rabbit knees were used for this study. Following sacrifice, one leg in each pair was assigned to the fresh group and the FMTC was immediately dissected and prepared for testing. The contralateral knees were fresh-frozen at -20 degrees C for 3 weeks, thawed, dissected and then refrozen for one additional week before being tested as the refrozen group. The cross-sectional area and shape of the medial collateral ligament (MCL) was measured using a laser micrometer system. Stress relaxation and cyclic stress-relaxation tests in uniaxial tension were performed followed by a load to failure test. When the viscoelastic behavior of the MCL was described by the quasi-linear viscoelastic (QLV) theory, no statistically significant differences could be detected for the five constants (A, B, C, tau1, and tau2) between the fresh and refrozen groups (p > or = 0.07) based on our sample size. In addition, the structural properties of the FMTCs and the mechanical properties of the MCLs were also found to be similar between the two groups (p > or = 0.68). These results suggest that careful refreezing of the specimens had little or no effect on the biomechanical properties measured.