Regulation of H+ Extrusion and Cytoplasmic pH in Maize Root Tips Acclimated to a Low-Oxygen Environment

We tested the hypothesis that H+ extrusion contributes to cytoplasmic pH regulation and tolerance of anoxia in maize (Zea mays) root tips. We studied root tips of whole seedlings that were acclimated to a low-oxygen environment by pretreatment in 3% (v/v) O2. Acclimated root tips characteristically regulate cytoplasmic pH near neutrality and survive prolonged anoxia, whereas nonacclimated tips undergo severe cytoplasmic acidosis and die much more quickly. We show that the plasma membrane H+-ATPase can operate under anoxia and that net H+ extrusion increases when cytoplasmic pH falls. However, at an external pH near 6.0, H+ extrusion contributes little to cytoplasmic pH regulation. At more acidic external pH values, net H+ flux into root tips increases dramatically, leading to a decrease in cytoplasmic pH and reduced tolerance of anoxia. We present evidence that, under these conditions, H+ pumps are activated to partly offset acidosis due to H+ influx and, thereby, contribute to cytoplasmic pH regulation and tolerance of anoxia. The regulation of H+ extrusion under anoxia is discussed with respect to the acclimation response and mechanisms of intracellular pH regulation in aerobic plant cells.     

Improved Cytoplasmic pH Regulation,Increased Lactate Efflux,and Reduced Cytoplasmic Lactate Levels Are Biochemical Traits Expressed in Root Tips of Whole Maize Seedlings Acclimated to a Low-Oxygen Environment

We tested the hypothesis (J.-H. Xia and P.H. Saglio [1992] Plant Physiol 100: 40-46) that the enhanced ability of maize (Zea mays) root tips to survive anoxia, elicited by a 4-h exposure to 3% O2 ("acclimation"), is due to less cytoplasmic acidosis early in anoxia. Cytoplasmic pH and fermentation reactions were monitored in excised and intact (attached) maize root tips by simultaneous in vivo 13C- and 31P-NMR spectroscopy. We demonstrate that both excised and intact acclimated root tips have significantly higher cytoplasmic pH values under anoxia. This reduction in cytoplasmic acidosis is greater in intact root tips. Remarkably, cytoplasmic pH does not change when root tips are transferred from 3% O2 to anoxia. The earlier observation of considerable lactate efflux and lowered intracellular lactate in excised, acclimated root tips (ibid.) was extended to intact seedlings. The predominant fermentation end product retained in the cells of acclimated root tips is alanine. We discuss the relationship between cytoplasmic pH and levels of intracellular lactate and alanine in sugar-replete roots, and the role of cytoplasmic pH in determining survival under anoxia.     

Hypoxic Induction of Anoxia Tolerance in Roots of Adh1 Null Zea mays L

Seedlings of alcohol dehydrogenase 1 null mutants (Adh1-) of Zea mays L., which fail to synthesize alcohol dehydrogenase 1 (ADH1) isozymes, were hypoxically acclimated by 18 h of exposure to an atmosphere of 4% (v/v) O2 in N2 at 25[deg]C. Their ability to tolerate subsequent anoxia by exposure to anaerobic (O2-free) conditions was compared with that of unacclimated seedlings that were transferred immediately from an atmosphere of 40% (v/v) O2 to anaerobic conditions. Only 10% of the root tips of unacclimated seminal roots survived 6 h of anoxia, whereas 70% of the hypoxically acclimated root tips were viable at 24 h. During anoxia, acclimated root tips had enhanced ADH activity compared with unacclimated root tips, through induction of Adh2. Despite this, enzyme activity was still only about 5% that of acclimated, wild-type root tips and about half that of unacclimated, wild-type root tips. During anoxia, acclimated Adh1- root tips showed a higher rate of anaerobic respiration and ethanol production, greater concentrations of ATP and total adenylates, and a greater adenylate energy charge compared with unacclimated root tips. These results suggest that although enhanced ADH activity may have raised fermentation rates in acclimated Adh1- tissues and thereby contributed to energy metabolism and viability, the high levels of ADH activity inducible in acclimated, wild-type maize root tips appear to be in excess of that required to increase rates of fermentation.     

Hypoxic Induction of Anoxia Tolerance in Root Tips of Zea mays

When root tips of fully aerobic, intact maize (Zea mays L.) seedlings are made anaerobic, viability normally is only 24 hours or less at 25°C. We find that viability can be extended to at least 96 hours if seedlings are given a hypoxic pretreatment for 18 hours by sparging the solution with 4% O₂ in nitrogen (v/v) before anoxia. Fully aerobic root tips (sparged with 40% O₂) had very low alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) activity (per gram root fresh weight), and the level remained low under anoxia. In hypoxically pretreated roots, however, high levels of ADH activity were induced, and activity rose further during the initial 24 hours of anoxia, and then remained high at about 20 times that of controls in 40% O₂. ADH activity in roots in solution sparged with air (21% O₂) was about three times that in 40% O₂. Improved viability of hypoxically pretreated root tips was associated with maintenance of a high energy metabolism (ATP concentration, total adenylates, and adenylate energy charge). Roots that were not pretreated lost 94% of the total adenylates and ATP at 24 hours of anoxia. The relation between induced ADH activity, energy metabolism, and improved anoxia-tolerance in acclimated maize root tips is discussed.     

The Role of Sugars,Hexokinase, and Sucrose Synthase in the Determination of Hypoxically Induced Tolerance to Anoxia in Tomato Roots

Hypoxic pretreatment of tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum M.) roots induced an acclimation to anoxia. Survival in the absence of oxygen was improved from 10 h to more than 36 h if external sucrose was present. The energy charge value of anoxic tissues increased during the course of hypoxic acclimation, indicating an improvement of energy metabolism. In acclimated roots ethanol was produced immediately after transfer to anoxia and little lactic acid accumulated in the tissues. In nonacclimated roots significant ethanol synthesis occurred after a 1-h lag period, during which time large amounts of lactic acid accumulated in the tissues. Several enzyme activities, including that of alcohol dehydrogenase, lactate dehydrogenase, pyruvate decarboxylase, and sucrose synthase, increased during the hypoxic pretreatment. In contrast to maize, hexokinase activities did not increase and phosphorylation of hexoses was strongly inhibited during anoxia in both kinds of tomato roots. Sucrose, but not glucose or fructose, was able to sustain glycolytic flux via the sucrose synthase pathway and allowed anoxic tolerance of acclimated roots. These results are discussed in relation to cytosolic acidosis and the ability of tomato roots to survive anoxia.     

Nitrite reduces cytoplasmic acidosis under anoxia

The ameliorating effect of nitrate on the acidification of the cytoplasm during short-term anoxia was investigated in maize (Zea mays) root segments. Seedlings were grown in the presence or absence of nitrate, and changes in the cytoplasmic and vacuolar pH in response to the imposition of anoxia were measured by in vivo (31)P nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Soluble ions and metabolites released to the suspending medium by the anoxic root segments were measured by high-performance liquid chromatography and (1)H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, and volatile metabolites were measured by gas chromatography and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. The beneficial effect of nitrate on cytoplasmic pH regulation under anoxia occurred despite limited metabolism of nitrate under anoxia, and modest effects on the ions and metabolites, including fermentation end products, released from the anoxic root segments. Interestingly, exposing roots grown and treated in the absence of nitrate to micromolar levels of nitrite during anoxia had a beneficial effect on the cytoplasmic pH that was comparable to the effect observed for roots grown and treated in the presence of nitrate. It is argued that nitrate itself is not directly responsible for improved pH regulation under anoxia, contrary to the usual assumption, and that nitrite rather than nitrate should be the focus for further work on the beneficial effect of nitrate on flooding tolerance.     

Lactic Acid efflux as a mechanism of hypoxic acclimation of maize root tips to anoxia

Hypoxic pretreatment (3 kPa oxygen) of maize (Zea mays L.) root tips improved their survival time in a subsequent anoxic incubation from 10 h to more than 3 d, provided that glucose was added to the medium to sustain metabolism. The glycolytic flux (lactate + ethanol) was the same in both pretreated and untreated root tips during the 1st h after transfer to anoxia. It was only after 2 h that it declined sharply in untreated tips, but was sustained in pretreated ones. Right after the transition from normoxia to anoxia of untreated root tips, the only fermentative product detected was lactic acid, which accumulated in a 7:1 proportion after 30 min in tissue and medium, respectively. It took 10 min before ethanol could be detected and 20 min for it to be produced at its maximum rate at the expense of lactate production, which slowed down. In contrast, in hypoxically pretreated root tips, ethanol was produced at a maximum rate right after the transfer to anoxia. Concurrently, low amounts of lactic acid were produced that accumulated in a 1:1 proportion after 30 min in tissue and medium, respectively. This large efflux of lactic acid could account for the higher cytoplasmic pH values always found in pretreated tissues. The presence of cycloheximide during pretreatment abolished this difference, suggesting that the greater efficiency of lactate efflux was linked to protein synthesis. The role of lactate in cytosolic pH regulation and in sensitivity to anoxia is discussed.     

Hemoglobin and Hypoxic Acclimation in Maize Root Tips

Class 1 hemoglobins (Hbs) have a wide distribution in the plant kingdom and have been demonstrated in root, seed, stem, and leaf tissues. They are present at low concentrations in aerobic tissue, but their synthesis is rapidly induced by hypoxic stress. The pattern of expression of the maize Hb gene in roots of young maize plants exposed to hypoxia has been examined. Root Hb gene expression increased rapidly to a maximum within first two hours of hypoxia, then declining to prehypoxia levels within 48-h hypoxic exposure. Limiting oxygen supply to the roots by total plant immersion and darkness did not alter the time course of hemoglobin expression. Hb gene expression was about 20-fold higher in the stele than in the cortex of control, aerobically grown roots. Stele Hb expression increased about fourfold under hypoxic conditions, whereas its expression in the cortex increased about 60-fold. In these samples, alcohol dehydrogenase (Adh) gene expression increased about four- and ten fold in the stele and cortex, respectively. The effect of the state of the Hb on anoxic survival of maize root tips was assessed by exposing root tips to a carbon monoxide atmosphere to maximize the proportion of hemoglobin in the carbonmonoxy form. Carbon monoxide had no significant effect on the survival or the ATP levels in anoxic maize roots, regardless of whether they had been acclimated by exposure to a hypoxic pretreatment. This would suggest that the presence of oxyhemoglobin is not essential for the survival of anoxic root tips.     

Intracellular pH in rice and wheat root tips under hypoxic and anoxic conditions

The influence of anoxia and hypoxia on dynamic of intracellurar pH and ATP content in rice and wheat root tips was investigated with ³¹P-NMR spectroscopy. Both cereals responded to hypoxia similarly, by rapid cytoplasmic acidification (from pH 7.6–7.7 to 7.1), which was followed by slow partial recovery (0.3 units). Anoxia led to a dramatic pH_cyt drop in tissues of both species (from pH 7.6–7.7 to less than 7.0) and partial recovery took place in rice only. In wheat, the acidification continued to pH 6.8 after 6 h of exposure. Anoxic wheat root tips were deficient in ADH induction, whereas increased activity of alcoholic fermentation enzymes took place in anoxic rice root tips, as well as in both species after hypoxic treatment. In both plants, NTP content followed the dynamics of pH_cyt. There was a strong correlation between NTP content and cytoplasmic H⁺ activity ([H⁺]_cyt = 10^−pHcyt) for both hypoxic and anoxic conditions. In this addendum we want to focus the reader''s attention on the importance of adequate experimental design when hypoxia is under investigation and on some further perspectives of intracellular pH regulation in plants under anaerobic conditions.Key words: anoxia, hypoxia, rice, wheat, cytoplasmic pH regulation     

Kinetic studies of the variations of cytoplasmic pH, nucleotide triphosphates (31P-NMR) and lactate during normoxic and anoxic transitions in maize root tips

We have followed the dynamic evolution of intracellular pH and of the intracellular concentration of nucleotides (NDP, NTP), Pi and lactate in maize root tips during the course of normoxia and anoxia transition. The intracellular pH, determined from the 31P-NMR chemical shift of the cytoplasmic P1 peak, dropped from 7.5 to 6.9 during the first few minutes after anaerobiosis. It increased again, then settled to a steady-state value of 7.1-7.2, 25 min after the beginning of the anoxic treatment. Following oxygenation, the chemical shift of the cytoplasmic Pi peak drifted gradually to its initial value. The cytoplasmic pH followed an oscillatory time course which was almost identical to the time course of NTP. Intracellular lactate accumulated steadily during the first 30 min after anaerobiosis, then its intracellular concentration remained almost constant. Following oxygenation, the intracellular concentration of lactate decreased slowly. The cytoplasmic pH followed a time course which was not identical to the time course of lactate. Following hypoxia, the pH dropped to low values long before the intracellular lactate concentration reached a steady-state equilibrium. Conversely, subsequent to oxygenation, the pH returned to normal values long before lactate. These results do not agree with the statement that cytoplasmic acidification in hypoxic maize root tips is necessarily associated with lactic acid synthesis.     

Further Evidence that Cytoplasmic Acidosis Is a Determinant of Flooding Intolerance in Plants

We present two pieces of evidence that regulation of cytoplasmic pH near neutrality is a prerequisite for survival of root tips during hypoxia. First, blackeye peas and navy beans show earlier cytoplasmic acidosis under hypoxia than soybeans or pumpkin or maize, and die earlier. Second, when cytoplasmic acidosis in maize root tips is greatly retarded by treatment with 25 millimolar Ca(NO₃)₂, they remain viable under hypoxia for a much longer period of time than untreated hypoxic root tips. We also show that viability of maize root tips is unaffected by the supply of exogenous sugar (and so on the rate of ethanolic fermentation) for at least 16 hours of hypoxia.     

Activities of proteinases in maize and soybean roots in response to anoxic stress

This study characterized the changes in proteinase activities in maize inbred line H60 and soybean cultivar Keller roots in response to anoxia. After 24 h of anoxia, crude protein extracts from both maize and soybean root tips (10 cm) were assayed for proteinase activities at pHs ranging from 4.5 to 10.2. In anoxic roots of both maize and soybean, activities of proteinases with alkaline pH optima increased, and activities of proteinases with acidic pH optima declined. Proteinases with neutral pH increased in anoxic maize roots, but declined in anoxic soybean roots. Whether the differences in proteinase activities in anaerobic maize and soybean roots contribute to the differental susceptibility of the two species requires further study.Journal Article No. 265-89.     

pH regulation in anoxic plants

BACKGROUND: pH regulation is the result of a complex interaction of ion transport, H+ buffering, H+-consuming and H+-producing reactions. Cells under anoxia experience an energy crisis; an early response thereof (in most tissues) is a rapid cytoplasmic acidification of roughly half a pH unit. Depending on the degree of anoxia tolerance, this pH remains relatively stable for some time, but then drops further due to an energy shortage, which, in concert with a general breakdown of transmembrane gradients, finally leads to cell death unless the plant finds access to an energy source. SCOPE: In this review the much-debated origin of the initial pH change and its regulation under anoxia is discussed, as well as the problem of how tissues deal with the energy crisis and to what extent pH regulation and membrane transport from and into the vacuole and the apoplast is a part thereof. CONCLUSIONS: It is postulated that, because a foremost goal of cells under anoxia must be energy production (having an anaerobic machinery that produces insufficient amounts of ATP), a new pH is set to ensure a proper functioning of the involved enzymes. Thus, the anoxic pH is not experienced as an error signal and is therefore not reversed to the aerobic level. Although acclimated and anoxia-tolerant tissues may display higher cytoplasmic pH than non-acclimated or anoxia-intolerant tissues, evidence for an impeded pH-regulation is missing even in the anoxia-intolerant tissues. For sufficient energy production, residual H+ pumping is vital to cope with anoxia by importing energy-rich compounds; however it is not vital for pH-regulation. Whereas the initial acidification is not due to energy shortage, subsequent uncontrolled acidosis occurring in concert with a general gradient breakdown damages the cell but may not be the primary event.     

Manipulation of ethanol production in anoxic rice coleoptiles by exogenous glucose determines rates of ion fluxes and provides estimates of energy requirements for cell maintenance during anoxia

Ethanol production by anoxic, excised, 7-10 mm tips of rice coleoptiles was manipulated using a range of exogenous glucose concentrations. Such a dose-response curve enabled good estimates at which level of ethanol production (and hence by inference ATP production), injury commenced and also allowed assessments of energy requirements for maintenance in anoxia. Rates of net uptake or loss of K+ and P by these excised coleoptile tips were related to rates of ethanol production (r2 of 0.59 and 0.68, respectively). At 72 h anoxia, ATP levels in excised tips were similar at 0, 2.5, and 50 mol m(-3) exogenous glucose, despite large differences in the inferred rates of ATP production. At 96 h anoxia, tips without exogenous glucose had low ATP concentrations; these may be the cause or the consequence of cell injury. In tips without glucose, injury was indicated by losses of K+ and Cl- between 72-96 h anoxia, and during the first hour after re-aeration, while later than 1 h after re-aeration, rates of net uptake were substantially lower than for re-aerated tips previously in anoxia with exogenous glucose. Between 96 h and 124 h anoxia, ion losses from tips without exogenous glucose increased while recovery of net uptake after re-aeration was very sluggish and incomplete. The energy requirement for maintenance of health and survival of anoxic coleoptile tips, expressed on a fresh weight basis, was lower than for three other anoxia-tolerant plant tissues/cells, studied previously. However, the energy requirement on a protein basis was assessed at 1.4 micromol ATP mg(-1) protein h(-1) and this value is 2.6-5.4-fold higher than for the other plant tissues/cells. Yet, this requirement was still only 58-88% of the published values for aerated tissues. The reason for this relatively high ATP requirement per unit protein in anoxic rice coleoptiles remains to be elucidated.     

Metabolic Acclimation to Anoxia Induced by Low (2-4 kPa Partial Pressure) Oxygen Pretreatment (Hypoxia) in Root Tips of Zea mays

Young intact plants of maize (Zea mays L. cv INRA 508) were exposed to 2 to 4 kilopascals partial pressure oxygen (hypoxic pretreatment) for 18 hours before excision of the 5 millimeter root apex and treatment with strictly anaerobic conditions (anoxia). Hypoxic acclimation gave rise to larger amounts of ATP, to larger ATP/ADP and adenylate energy charge ratios, and to higher rates of ethanol production when excised root tips were subsequently made anaerobic, compared with root tips transferred directly from aerobic to anaerobic media. Improved energy metabolism following hypoxic pretreatment was associated with increased activity of alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH), and induction of ADH-2 isozymes. Roots of Adh1⁻ mutant plants lacked constitutive ADH and only slowly produced ethanol when made anaerobic. Those that were hypoxically pretreated acclimated to anoxia with induction of ADH2 and a higher energy metabolism, and a rate of ethanol production comparable to that of nonmutants. All these responses were insensitive to the presence or absence of NO₃⁻. Additionally, the rate of ethanol production was about 50 times greater than the rate of reduction of NO₃⁻ to NO₂⁻. These results indicate that nitrate reductase does not compete effectively with ADH for NADH, or contribute to energy metabolism during anaerobic respiration in this tissue through nitrate reduction. Unacclimated root tips of wild type and Adhl⁻ mutants appeared not to survive more than 8 to 9 hours in strict anoxia; when hypoxically pretreated they tolerated periods under anoxia in excess of 22 hours.     

Anoxic Responses of Seedling Roots of Rice Cultivars Varying in Tolerance to Submergence

Differences in tolerance to submergence and anoxia exhibited by cultivar-specific rice (Oryza sativa L.) extend to the primary root tips and axes of 3-day-old seedlings. This paper considers the physiological mechanisms which might account for rice root intolerance to anoxia, particularly those implicated in pH regulation and sugar metabolism in relation to hypoxic acclimation. Hypoxic treatment and the presence of glucose during anoxia did not permit root tips and axes of intolerant cultivars to survive 24-h anoxia. The absence of typical glycolytic and fermentative enzyme induction together with no improvement of ethanol production and energy status during anoxia suggest that intolerant cultivars are not capable of hypoxic acclimation at the level of energy and sugar metabolism. However, root tip survival was enhanced in buffered medium after hypoxic treatment, suggesting a relationship between hypoxic treatment and improved pH regulation.     

Manipulating cytoplasmic pH under anoxia: A critical test of the role of pH in the switch from aerobic to anaerobic metabolism

Ethanol production by maize (Zea mays L.) root tips, measured by an enzymic assay of the suspending medium, was correlated with changes in the cytoplasmic pH, determined by in-vivo ³¹P nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy, following the onset of anoxia. Strong evidence for the role of the cytoplasmic pH in triggering the switch to ethanol production under anoxia was obtained by: (i) varying the pH of the suspending medium between pH 4 and pH 10; and (ii) using the permeant weak base methylamine to combat the acidification of the cytoplasm induced by the anoxic conditions. Experimentally, it proved to be much easier to manipulate the cytoplasmic pH under anoxia after the pH had stabilised, rather than during the initial rapid acidification that occurred following the onset of anoxia, and in the presence of methylamine, it was possible to impose a normal aerobic cytoplasmic pH value on tissue that was metabolising anaerobically. By this means it was possible to demonstrate the reversibility of the pH effect on ethanol production under anoxia and thus to provide good evidence in support of the biochemical pH-stat model of the anoxic response. The NMR measurement of the cytoplasmic pH in the presence of methylamine was achieved by using a manganese pretreatment technique to eliminate interference between the cytoplasmic and vacuolar P_i signals, and it seems likely that the experimental approach used here will have further applications in studies of the metabolic response to anoxia.Abbreviations Caps 3-(cyclohexylamino)-1-propane sulphonic acid - Mes 2-(N-morpholino)-ethane sulphonic acid - NMR nuclear magnetic resonance - Pi inorganic phosphate We acknowledge the financial support of the Agricultural and Food Research Council and G.G.F. acknowledges the receipt of a Research Fellowship from the Royal Commission for the Exhibition of 1851.     

Stabilization of adenine nucleotide ratios at various values by an oxygen limitation of respiration in germinating lettuce (Lactuca sativa) seeds.

The concentrations of adenine nucleotides were determined in germinating lettuce (Lactuca sativa) seeds after transitions from air to hypoxic or anoxic atmospheres. The ratio ATP/ADP and the energy charge were rapidly lowered after the transitions and remained stable at low values for hours. The energy charge in anoxia stabilized at a value close to 0.3. After 24 h in anoxia the energy charge rose rapidly to high values (0.9) when N2 was replaced by air. The metabolic properties of lettuce seeds had then been conversed for hours at low energy charge. In hypoxia the O2 uptake was decreased and the energy charge was stabilized at values intermediate between that in air and that in anoxia. When the O2 partial pressures (pO2) were 5 and 2kPa, the values of O2 uptake were one-third and one-sixth of that in air, and the energy charges were 0.7 and 0.5. These results show that the energy charge is regulated over a wide range of values. The ratio ATP/ADP and the energy charge are indicators of the limitation of metabolic activity by hypoxia.