Effects of starvation for potassium and other inorganic ions on protein degradation and ribonucleic acid synthesis in Escherichia coli.

Starvation of Escherichia coli for potassium, phosphate, or magnesium ions leads to a reversible increase in the rate of protein degradation and an inhibition of ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis. In cells deprived of potassium, the breakdown of the more stable cell proteins increased two- to threefold, whereas the hydrolysis of short-lived proteins, both normal ones and analog-containing polypeptides, did not change. The mechanisms initiating the enhancement of proteolysis during starvation for these ions were examined. Upon starvation for amino acids or amino acyl-transfer RNA (tRNA), protein breakdown increases in relA+ (but not relA) cells as a result of the rapid synthesis of guanosine-5'-diphosphate-3'-diphosphate (ppGpp). However, a lack of amino acyl-tRNA does not appear to be responsible for the increased protein breakdown in cells starved for inorganic ions, since protein breakdown increased in the absence of these ions in both relA+ and relA cultures, and since a large excess of amino acids did not affect this response. In bacteria in which energy production is restricted, ppGpp levels also rise, and protein breakdown increases. The ion-deprived cultures did show a 40 to 75% reduction in adenosine-5'-triphosphate levels,l similar to that seen upon glucose starvation. However, this decrease in ATP content does not appear to cause the increase in protein breakdown or lead to an accumulation of ppGpp. No consistent change in intracellular ppGpp levels was found in relA+ or relA cells starved for these ions. In addition, in relX mutants, removal of these ions led to accelerated protein degradation even though relX cells are unable to increase ppGpp levels or proteolysis when deprived of a carbon source. In the potassium-, phosphate-, and magnesium-deprived cultures, the addition of choramphenicol or tetracycline caused a reduction in protein breakdown toward basal levels. Such findings, however, do not indicate that protein synthesis is essential for the enhancement of protein degradation, since blockage of protein synthesis by inactivation of a temperature-sensitive valyl-tRNA synthetase did not restore protein catabolism to basal levels. These various results and related studies suggest that the mechanism for increased protein catabolism on starvation for inorganic ions differs from that occurring upon amino acid or arbon deprivation and probably involves an enhanced susceptibility of various cell proteins (especially ribosomal proteins) to proteolysis.     

Influence of amino acid starvation on guanosine 5''-diphosphate 3''-diphosphate basal-level synthesis in Escherichia coli.

We observed that the synthesis of basal-level guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate (ppGpp) in both relA mutants and relA+ relC strains of Escherichia coli decreased in response to amino acid limitation and that this was accompanied by an increase in ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis. Addition of the required amino acid to starved cultures of relaxed bacteria resulted in the resumption of ppGpp synthesis and a concomitant decrease in RNA production. Our results indicate that relA mutants retain a stringent factor-independent ribosomal mechanism for basal-level ppGpp synthesis. They also suggest that in relA+ bacteria, stringent factor-mediated ppGpp synthesis and the production of basal-level ppGpp are mutually exclusive. These findings substantiate the hypothesis that there are two functionally discrete mechanisms for ppGpp synthesis in E. coli. Through these studies we have also obtained new evidence which indicates that ppGpp serves as a modulator of RNA synthesis during balanced growth as well as under conditions of nutritional downshift and starvation.     

Stringent control during carbon starvation of marine Vibrio sp. strain S14: molecular cloning, nucleotide sequence, and deletion of the relA gene.

In order to evaluate the role of the stringent response in starvation adaptations of the marine Vibrio sp. strain S14, we have cloned the relA gene and generated relaxed mutants of this organism. The Vibrio relA gene was selected from a chromosomal DNA library by complementation of an Escherichia coli delta relA strain. The nucleotide sequence contains a 743-codon open reading frame that encodes a polypeptide that is identical in length and highly homologous to the E. coli RelA protein. The amino acid sequences are 64% identical, and they share some completely conserved regions. A delta relA::kan allele was generated by replacing 53% of the open reading frame with a kanamycin resistance gene. The Vibrio relA mutants displayed a relaxed control of RNA synthesis and failed to accumulate ppGpp during amino acid limitation. During carbon and energy starvation, a relA-dependent burst of ppGpp synthesis concomitant with carbon source depletion and growth arrest was observed. Also, in the absence of the relA gene, there was an accumulation of ppGpp during carbon starvation, but this was slower and smaller than that which occurred in the stringent strains, and it was preceded by a marked decrease in the [ATP]/[ADP] ratio. In both the wild-type and the relaxed strains, carbon source depletion caused an immediate decrease in the size of the GTP pool and a block of net RNA accumulation. The relA mutation did not affect long-term survival or the development of resistance against heat, ethanol, and oxidative stress during carbon starvation of Vibrio sp. strain S14.     

Role of protein synthesis in the survival of carbon-starved Escherichia coli K-12.

In a typical Escherichia coli K-12 culture starved for glucose, 50% of the cells lose viability in ca. 6 days (Reeve et al., J. Bacteriol. 157:758-763, 1984). Inhibition of protein synthesis by chloramphenicol resulted in a more rapid loss of viability in glucose-starved E. coli K-12 cultures. The more chloramphenicol added (i.e., the more protein synthesis was inhibited) and the earlier during starvation it was added, the greater was its effect on culture viability. Chloramphenicol was found to have the same effect on a relA strain as on an isogenic relA+ strain of E. coli. Addition of the amino acid analogs S-2-aminoethylcysteine, 7-azatryptophan, and p-fluorophenylalanine to carbon-starved cultures to induce synthesis of abnormal proteins had an effect on viability similar to that observed when 50 micrograms of chloramphenicol per ml was added at zero time for starvation. Both chloramphenicol and the amino acid analogs had delayed effects on viability, compared with their effects on synthesis of normal proteins. The need for protein synthesis did not arise from cryptic growth, since no cryptic growth of the starving cells was observed under the conditions used. From these and previous results obtained from work with peptidase-deficient mutants of E. coli K-12 and Salmonella typhimurium LT2 (Reeve et al., J. Bacteriol. 157:758-763, 1984), we concluded that a number of survival-related proteins are synthesized by E. coli K-12 cells as a response to carbon starvation. These proteins are largely synthesized during the early hours of starvation, but their continued activity is required for long-term survival.     

Delayed-relaxed response explained by hyperactivation of RelE

Escherichia coli encodes two rel loci, both of which contribute to the control of synthesis of macromolecules during amino acid starvation. The product of relA (ppGpp synthetase I) is responsible for the synthesis of guanosine tetraphosphate, ppGpp, the signal molecule that exerts stringent control of stable RNA synthesis. The second rel locus, relBE, was identified by mutations in relB that confer a so-called 'delayed-relaxed response' characterized by continued RNA synthesis after a lag period of approximately 10 min after the onset of amino acid starvation. We show here that the delayed-relaxed response is a consequence of hyperactivation of RelE. As in wild-type cells, [ppGpp] increased sharply in relB101 relE cells after the onset of starvation, but returned rapidly to the prestarvation level. RelE is a global inhibitor of translation that is neutralized by RelB by direct protein-protein interaction. Lon protease activates RelE during amino acid starvation by degradation of RelB. We found that mutations in relB that conferred the delayed-relaxed phenotype destabilized RelB. Such mutations confer severe RelE-dependent inhibition of translation during amino acid starvation, indicating hyperactivation of RelE. Hyperactivation of RelE during amino acid starvation was shown directly by measurement of RelE-mediated cleavage of tmRNA. The RelE-mediated shutdown of translation terminated amino acid consumption and explains the rapid restoration of the ppGpp level observed in relB mutant cells. Restoration of the prestarvation level of ppGpp, in turn, allows for the resumption of stable RNA synthesis seen during the delayed-relaxed response.     

Characterization of the relA1 mutation and a comparison of relA1 with new relA null alleles in Escherichia coli

The most widely studied "relaxed" mutant of the relA locus, the relA1 allele, is shown here to consist of an IS2 insertion between the 85th and 86th codons of the otherwise wild-type relA structural gene, which normally encodes a 743-amino acid (84 kDa) protein. The RelA protein is a ribosome-dependent ATP:GTP (GDP) pyrophosphoryltransferase that is activated during the stringent response to amino acid starvation and thereby occasions the accumulation of guanosine 3',5'-bispyrophosphate (ppGpp). We propose that the IS2 insertion functionally splits the RelA protein into two (alpha and beta) peptide fragments which can complement each other in trans to yield residual ppGpp synthetic activity; neither fragment shows this activity when expressed alone. Cell strains with a single copy relA null allele show physiological behavior that is much the same as relA1 mutant strains. Both relA1 and relA null strains accumulate ppGpp during glucose starvation and do not accumulate ppGpp during the stringent response. The presence of ppGpp in verifiable relA null strains is interpreted as unequivocal evidence for an alternate route of ppGpp synthesis that exists in addition to the relA-dependent reaction.     

Role of the stringent response in the expression and mechanism of near-ultraviolet induced growth delay

The near-ultraviolet (300-400 nm) induced growth delay of Escherichia coli cells was compared in isogenic relA+ and relA- cells illuminated either in the stationary or the exponential phase. In the latter case: (a) the relA- strains of K12 and B/r exhibited similar maximal growth lags (65 min and 55 min respectively); (b) the maximal lags were 1.5-fold and 4-fold longer, respectively, in the isogenic relA+ strains; (c) the rate of the relA- -dependent guanosine 3',5'-bis(diphosphate) (ppGpp) accumulation was three-times lower in the K12 relA+ strain as compared to the B/r relA- strain: (d) a K12 spoT mutant having an impaired rate of ppGpp degradation had a 2-fold longer lag. On the other hand, when illumination is performed in the stationary phase, isogenic relA+ and relA- cells (B/r or K12) exhibited similar growth lags at any fluences, indicating little if any involvement of the stringent response. These data extend previous observations of T.V. Ramabhadran an J. Jagger [(1976) Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA, 73, 59-63] but do not support their conclusion that the stringent response is the main factor responsible for growth delay. By monitoring the intracellular level of ppGpp in relA+ spoT- and relA+ spoT+ growing cells during illumination and the subsequent growth lag we observed that the initial burst of ppGpp decreases slowly all along the lag; in all relA+ strains checked the return of ppGpp to its basal level coincides with the recovery of normal growth. We conclude that it is the accumulation of ppGpp over the basal level due either to the stringent response or to prevention of ppGpp degradation that is responsible for an amplification of the growth lag.     

Global analysis of the carbon starvation response of a marine Vibrio species with disruptions in genes homologous to relA and spoT.

The stringent control response, which involves a rapid accumulation of ppGpp, is triggered if the marine Vibrio sp. strain S14 is subjected to carbon and energy starvation. By means of high-resolution two-dimensional gel electrophoresis analysis, we addressed the role of the major ppGpp-synthesizing enzyme (RelA) in the regulation of the carbon starvation response of Vibrio sp. strain S14. The finding that a large number of the carbon starvation-induced proteins were underexpressed in the Vibrio sp. S14 relA mutant strain after the onset of glucose starvation suggests that a rapid accumulation of ppGpp is required for induction of many of the carbon starvation-induced proteins. However, it was also found that a majority of the carbon starvation-induced proteins were significantly less induced if the stringent control response was provoked by amino acid starvation. We therefore also addressed the notion that a carbon starvation-specific signal transduction pathway, complementary to the stringent control, may exist in Vibrio sp. strain S14. It was found that a majority of the proteins that were underexpressed in the relA mutant strain were also underexpressed in the Vibrio sp. S14 spoT mutant strain (csrS1). Interestingly, a large proportion of these underexpressed proteins were found to belong to a group of proteins that are not, or significantly less, induced by starvation conditions that do not promote starvation survival. On the basis of these observations and the finding that the csrS1 strain survives poorly but accumulates ppGpp in a fashion similar to the wild type during carbon and energy source starvation, the gene product of the csrS gene is suggested to be responsible for the mediation of a signal which is complementary to ppGpp and essential for the successful development of the starvation- and stress-resistant cell. This conclusion was also supported by experiments in which changes in phenotypic characteristics known to be induced during carbon starvation were studied. The starvation induction of the high-affinity glucose uptake system was found to be dependent on the csrS gene but not relA, and the synthesis of carbon starvation-specific periplasmic space proteins was dependent, at different times of starvation, on both the relA and the csrS gene products.     

Induction of autolysis in nongrowing Escherichia coli

Unless relaxation of the stringent response is achieved, all nongrowing bacteria rapidly develop resistance to autolysis induced by a variety of agents, including all classes of cell wall synthesis inhibitors. We now describe inhibitors of cell wall synthesis which were unusual in that they could continue to effectively induce autolysis in relA+ Escherichia coli even after prolonged amino acid starvation. The process of cell wall degradation seems to be catalyzed by similar hydrolytic enzymes in nongrowing and growing cells, yet the activity of these new agents capable of inducing autolysis in the nongrowing relA+ cells did not involve relaxation of RNA or peptidoglycan synthesis. We propose that the suppression of autolysis characteristic of nongrowing cells can be bypassed by a novel mechanism of autolytic triggering which is independent of the relA locus.     

Ribosomes exist in large excess over the apparent demand for protein synthesis during carbon starvation in marine Vibrio sp. strain CCUG 15956.

Carbon starvation induces the development of a starvation- and stress-resistant cell state in marine Vibrio sp. strain S14 (CCUG 15956). The starved cells remain highly responsive to nutrients during prolonged starvation and exhibit instantaneous severalfold increases in the rates of protein synthesis and RNA synthesis when substrate is added. In order to elucidate the physiological basis for the survival of cells that are starved for a long time, as well as the capacity of these cells for rapid and efficient recovery, we analyzed the ribosome content of carbon-starved Vibrio sp. strain S14 cells. By using direct chemical measurements of the amounts of ribosomal particles in carbon-starved cultures, we demonstrated that ribosomes were lost relatively slowly (half life, 79 h) and that they existed in large excess over the apparent demand for protein synthesis. After 24 h of starvation the total rate of protein synthesis was 2.3% of the rate during growth, and after 3 days this rate was 0.7% of the rate during growth; the relative amounts of ribosomal particles at these times were 81 and 52%, respectively. The ribosome population consisted of 90% 70S monoribosomes, and no polyribosomes were detected in the starved cells. The 70S monoribosomes were responsible for the bulk of the protein synthesis during carbon starvation; some activity was also detected in the polyribosome size region on sucrose density gradients. We suggest that nongrowing carbon-starved Vibrio sp. strain S14 cells possess an excess protein synthesis capacity, which may be essential for their ability to immediately initiate an upshift program when substrate is added.     

Ribonucleic Acid Regulation in Amino Acid-Limited Cultures of Escherichia coli Grown in a Chemostat

The regulation of ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis was examined in cultures of bacteria whose growth was limited in the chemostat by the supply of a required amino acid. Strains possessing the relaxed (relA) mutation accumulated excess RNA (relative to protein) at low growth rates when growth was limited by arginine, histidine, or cysteine but not when limited by methionine. In contrast, stringent (relA(+)) strains maintained a constant RNA/protein ratio with decreasing growth rate regardless of the amino acid used to limit growth. The presence of excess RNA in relaxed strains was accompanied by an absence of increase in RNA production upon addition of chloramphenicol, a lag upon shift-up in growth by addition of excess of the limiting amino acid, and a decreased rate of production of beta-galactosidase upon induction. Analysis of the RNA accumulated in relaxed strains indicated it was present as transfer RNA as well as 50S and 30S ribosomal subunits. Microscope examination of the relaxed strains during histidine-, arginine-, or cysteine-limited growth in the chemostat showed them to be 10 to 20 times longer in size than the stringent strains. Also, cell density was reduced to one-tenth when the increased size was observed. An analysis of the amount of ppGpp present in all slow-growing amino acid-limited cultures (relaxed and stringent) demonstrated that only basal levels of ppGpp were made. These data are consistent with the hypothesis that when growth is limited in the chemostat by an initiation event in protein synthesis, i.e., limited methionine, RNA regulation occurs in relaxed as well as stringent strains. Also, when other amino acids are limiting in concentration during translation, errors occur in relaxed strains, resulting in misread proteins.     

Induction of autolysis in starved Escherichia coli cells by seminalplasmin, an antimicrobial protein from bovine seminal plasma

Abstract A pair of relA ⁺ and relA E. coli strains, otherwise isogenic, were studied with regard to the susceptibility of starved cells to lysis induced by the natural peptide seminalplasmin. Starved relA cells were more sensitive to seminalplasmin-induced lysis when compared to starved relA ⁺ cells. Nevertheless, pronounced lysis of starved relA ⁺ cells was observed with increase in the concentration of seminalplasmin. In conctrast, ampicillin could not lyse starved relA ⁺ cells even at very high concentrations. Further, seminalplasmin could cause loss of viability and degradation of peptidoglycan in starved relA ⁺ cells. These observations suggest that, unlike many other antibiotics, seminalplasmin can induce autolysis under the conditions of a stringent response.     

An immediate and steep increase in ATP concentration in response to reduced turgor pressure in Escherichia coli B

Osmotic treatment with sodium chloride of Escherichia coli B growing in the logarithmic phase induced an immediate increase in ATP concentration in response to increased concentrations of added solute in its growth medium in the first 10 min of the addition. After that, ATP concentration decreased gradually. Sodium arsenate and potassium fluoride almost abolished the ATP increase. The time course of the increase was quite different from that of cells treated with inhibitors of protein synthesis. The osmotic treatment did not decrease the viability of cells. In addition, there was no degradation of RNA by 5 min after sodium chloride addition, and, further, the lag time of ATP increase was extended by an inhibitor of nucleotide synthesis. These results indicated that a major fraction of the stress-increased ATP resulted from de novo synthesis, and that it was mainly dependent upon the reaction of substrate-level phosphorylation, which is regulated by turgor pressure.     

The effect of alcohols on guanosine 5'-diphosphate-3'-diphosphate metabolism in stringent and relaxed Escherichia coli

The effects of a series of alcohols on the stringent response system of Escherichia coli were studied. The alcohols used could be divided into two groups on the basis of the response of pppGpp and ppGpp to the growth downshift induced by the alcohols. The cells responded to the alcohols, methanol, ethanol, and propanol, as if they were being starved of amino acids. In the stringent strain CP78 these alcohols induced pppGpp and ppGpp accumulation and curtailed RNA synthesis, whereas in the relaxed strain CP79, both of these responses were absent. It was determined that this response was most likely due to an interference by these alcohols with the uptake of amino acids required by these strains. By contrast both stringent and relaxed cells elevated their level of ppGpp and decreased RNA accumulation when treated with butanol or pentanol. This response is similar to the effect of carbon source limitation. It was determined that the elevation of ppGpp in the stringent strain was primarily the result of increased ppGpp synthesis in response to these alcohols. In the relaxed strain the rise in ppGpp was dependent on a decrease in ppGpp degradation coupled with a moderate increase in ppGpp synthesis. This stimulation of ppGpp synthesis in relaxed cells, although small, suggests the existence of an enzyme distinct from stringent factor which is capable of synthesizing ppGpp. Data are presented which suggest that the activity of this enzyme is coupled to the potential for protein synthesis and energy availability of the cell, perhaps being regulated by the overall ratio of unchanged to amino-acylated tRNA.     

A new nucleotide involved in the stringent response in Escherichia coli. Guanosine 5'-diphosphate-3'-monophosphate.

A novel nucleotide has been detected in Escherichia coli subjected to the stringent response. However, this nucleotide does not accumulate in relA+ cells subjected to heat shock, in which guanosine 5'-diphosphate-3'-diphosphate does accumulate but stable RNA synthesis is not restricted. The intracellular level of this new nucleotide thus correlates well with control of stable RNA synthesis. Chemical and enzymatic analysis shows that the new nucleotide is guanosine 5'-diphosphate-3'-monophosphate. It is suggested that this nucleotide may play a role in stringent control of stable RNA synthesis.     

Effect of alpha-actinin on actin structure. Actin ATPase activity

The accumulation of low molecular weight RNAs in Escherichia coli cells following amino acid or energy source starvation was examined using two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. 32P-labeled small RNA prepared from serine- or isoleucine-starved stringent strain (relA+) cells was shown to display gel patterns that were grossly different from that of unstarved cells. It appears that the deprivation of serine or isoleucine has little or no inhibitory effect on the accumulation of transfer RNA cognate to the deprived amino acid. This is demonstrated by a relative increase in the concentrations of small RNAs that can be charged with serine or isoleucine following starvation of these amino acids. However, small RNAs labeled during starvation of phenylalanine or energy source showed gel patterns similar to that of control cells. This suggested a heterogenous response in the accumulation of some low molecular weight RNAs, presumably transfer RNAs, following starvation of different amino acids.