Defective B cell tolerance induction in New Zealand black mice. I. Macrophage independence and comparison with other autoimmune strains

B cell unresponsiveness was examined in vitro by using spleen cells from autoimmune NZB, BXSB/Mp male, MRL/Mp-Ipr/Ipr (MRL/l), and control mice, and the tolerogen trinitrophenyl human gamma-globulin (TNP-HGG). The B cell subset responsive to TNP-Brucella abortus in each autoimmune and control strain that was tested was highly susceptible to tolerance induction with the use of high epitope density conjugates (TNP30HGG and TNP32HGG). When a tolerogen with a lower epitope density was used (TNP7HGG), several control strains were all rendered tolerant in a thymic-independent and hapten-specific manner. NZB B cells were resistant to all concentrations of TNP7HGG tested, whereas B cells from BXSB/Mp male and MRL/1 mice were resistant to low concentrations of this tolerogen. NZB mice were resistant in addition to tolerance induction with TNP9HGG, TNP10HGG, and TNP12.7HGG. Experiments were performed to determine whether splenic macrophages played a role in resistance to tolerance in NZB mice. The mixing of NZB and control DBA/2J T cell-depleted splenocytes revealed no modulatory effects by the accessory cells in culture. Moreover, B cells rigorously depleted of macrophages by double Sephadex G-10 column passage exhibited characteristic patterns of resistance or susceptibility in NZB and control strains, respectively. These findings support the conclusion that resistance to tolerance in NZB mice is determined at the B cell level and are consistent with the hypothesis that diverse immunoregulatory disturbances contribute in varying degrees to the development of systemic lupus erythematosus in different inbred strains of mice.     

The use of haptenated immunoglobulins to induce B cell tolerance in vitro. The roles of hapten density and the Fc portion of the immunoglobulin carrier

The relationship between the Fc region of trinitrophenylated (TNP)-immunoglobulins (Ig), and their ability to induce tolerance was examined. It was found that adult B cells responding to a T-independent (TI) antigen were tolerized by TNP11 human gamma globulin (HGG), but not by TNP10F(ab')2 fragments of HGG. Increasing the hapten density on the F(ab')2 fragments overcame their inability to induce tolerance. Thus, a TNP17-F(ab')2 was an effective tolerogen. Murine myeloma proteins of different IgG subclasses were similarly tested. A TNP12-IgG2a and a TNP11-IgG1 induced tolerance, whereas two TNP11-12-IgG3 did not. However, a more heavily haptenated TNP18-IgG3 was tolerogenic. These results suggest that lightly haptenated immunoglobulins depend upon Fc receptor binding to induce tolerance in adult B cells. Non-Fc receptor-binding carriers are not tolerogenic unless they are more heavily haptenated. Finally, T cell and macrophage depletion experiments suggest that the tolerogens act directly on the B cells.     

The use of haptenated-immunoglobulin molecules to induce tolerance in B cells from neonatal mice

The role of the Fc region of trinitrophenylated (TNP)-immunoglobulins (Ig) in their ability to induce tolerance in immature B cells was examined. With the use of B cells from neonatal mice, tolerogens that could or could not bind to Fc receptors were assessed for their ability to induce tolerance. This was accomplished by tolerizing spleen cells in bulk culture and assessing the degree of tolerance by challenging the cells with the thymus-independent antigen TNP-Brucella abortus (TNP-BA) in limiting dilution cultures. It was found that by using tolerogens containing 10 to 11 haptens per Ig molecule, immature B cells were very susceptible to tolerance induction. Mature B cells were not as susceptible. This increased susceptibility was independent of the Fc portion of the tolerogen, because TNP11-HGG and a TNP10-F(ab')2 induced equivalent degrees of unresponsiveness. When the TNP density was lowered to approximately five haptens per Ig molecule, those Ig molecules that contained Fc portions were superior tolerogens with the use of B cells from 6-day-old mice. Thus, a TNP4-HGG, TNP7-mouse IgG1, and TNP6-mouse IgG2a were more effective tolerogens than either TNP5-F(ab')2 or TNP6-mouse IgG3. These results confirm previous findings that immature B cells are inherently more susceptible to tolerance induction than mature B cells. They also suggest that very lightly haptenated Ig molecules may depend on Fc receptor-binding for effective tolerance induction. Finally, by means of a cytofluorograph, the surface IgD (sIgD) and sIgM phenotypes of splenic B cells from neonates of increasing age were determined. When comparing the phenotype of maturing cells with their tolerance susceptibilities, a correlation between the appearance of sIgD and the acquisition of resistance to tolerance was observed.     

Membrane defects of the tolerant B cell. IV. Failure to accelerate antigen receptor loss

Mechanisms of immunologic tolerance affecting antibody responses include conditions extrinsic to the B cell such as dominant suppression by T cells (1), regulation by anti-idiotype (2), and tolerance in T helper cell populations (3). But tolerance can also result from changes in the antigen-reactive B cells such as their deletion (4), or that mysterious process by which they become "intrinsically tolerant", i.e., refractory to stimulation (5). One approach to learning more about the mechanism of intrinsic tolerance at the level of cell physiology is to determine which of the activation events that normally follow antigen contact occur or fail to occur in such cells. An established model of intrinsic B cell tolerance previously exploited in such studies in the trinitrophenyl (TNP)-self-induced tolerance model of Fidler and Golub (6). Having established that BDF1 mice injected with 2,4,6-trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBS) become tolerant to TNP, they showed by appropriate transfer experiments that the tolerance could be not induce antibody to TNP in such mice (8). cells (7). They also showed that lipopolysaccharide could not induce antibody to TNP in such mice (8). Together, these data indicated that in this example, tolerance is intrinsic to the B cells. B cells with receptors for TNP remain in these mice (9), providing an opportunity to study activation events in intrinsically tolerant B cells. This paper is part of an ongoing series of studies of activation events in TNP-antibody-binding cells (ABC)2 using this tolerance model (9-11). It shows that a TNP-antigen that normally induces rapid loss of antigen receptors on TNP-ABC cannot do so in mice rendered tolerant to TNP.     

T cell tolerization in vitro: modulation of helper and suppressor cell activities

This paper analyzes the conditions for in vitro tolerization of purified whole T cell populations and the consequences on helper and suppressor T cell functions. Highly purified splenic T cells from adult DBA/2 mice were incubated in vitro for 24 hr with high doses of trinitrophenyl coupled to human gamma-globulins (TNP-HGG). A profound inhibition of the TNP-specific helper function of these T lymphocytes was observed in a cooperative culture with normal purified splenic B cells and TNP-SRBC as antigen. This state of specific unresponsiveness was maintained after trypsin treatment of the cells, at the end of the 24-hr incubation with the tolerogen. We checked that this procedure removed the vast majority of F23.1 T cell receptor determinants from the cells. This result indicates that T cell receptors for antigen were not merely blocked by the tolerogen. In addition, B cells preincubated with tolerized T cells for 24 hr remained as responsive to TNP as B cells mixed with normal T cells in similar conditions. This demonstrates that the decreased response is not the result of secondary B cell tolerization. In addition, anti-Ia monoclonal antibodies were shown to block the induction of tolerance. We also showed that tolerized T cells significantly decreased the anti-TNP response of normal T and B cells in vitro, whereas the anti-SRBC response in the same cultures was unaffected. When tolerized T cells were separated into Lyt-2- and Lyt-2+ cells, it was found that tolerized Lyt-2- cells had lost about 75% of their helper activity and that Lyt-2+ cells suppressed 70% of the response of a normal T and B cell culture. Thus, in vitro induction of T cell tolerance results in a specific T cell unresponsiveness which is due to both helper T cell inactivation and induction of specific suppressor T cells.     

Immunoregulation in the rat: requirements for in vitro B cell responses to classical TI-1 and TI-2 antigens

The presence of suppressor cells and their mediators has made it difficult to induce B cell mitogenic or immune responses in rat spleen cell cultures. In the present study, we have defined culture conditions required for induction of in vitro thymic independent (TI) immune responses in the rat. Rat spleen cell cultures support low responses to various trinitrophenyl (TNP) haptenated antigens including TNP-Brucella abortus (TNP-BA), TNP-lipopolysaccharide [LPS; either phenol (Ph)- or butanol (Bu)-water extracted], TNP-Ficoll, and TNP-dextran. However, all of these antigens induced good splenic anti-TNP PFC responses when given at appropriate doses in vivo. When spleen cells were depleted of adherent cells and cultured with TI antigens in vitro, good anti-TNP PFC responses were seen with TNP-BA, whereas, lower responses were induced by TNP-LPS (Ph or Bu). No responses were observed in cultures incubated with either TNP-Ficoll or TNP-dextran. Purified splenic B cell cultures [prepared by panning on plates coated with anti-rat F (ab')2] supported good responses to TNP-LPS (Ph or Bu) and TNP-BA. The addition of irradiated splenic adherent cells (macrophages, M phi) to either M phi-depleted or purified B cell cultures completely abrogated in vitro responses to TNP-BA or TNP-LPS (Ph or Bu). Purified splenic B cell cultures generally responded poorly to TNP-Ficoll or TNP-dextran. Addition of indomethacin (IM) to spleen cell cultures abrogated suppression and allowed anti-TNP PFC responses to TNP-BA, TNP-LPS (Ph or Bu), TNP-Ficoll, and TNP-dextran. Furthermore, nude spleen cell cultures treated with IM, also allowed significant TNP-Ficoll and TNP-dextran immune responses; however, untreated cultures did not respond to these antigens. Our studies indicate that rat splenic B cell cultures are responsive to TI antigens, and highest responses occur with the murine TI-1 class, e.g., TNP-BA and TNP-LPS. Inhibition of suppression with IM restored splenic B cell responses to the murine TI-2 class, i.e., TNP-Ficoll and TNP-dextran.     

Activation of antigen-enriched B cells. II. Role of linked recognition in B cell proliferation to thymus-dependent antigens

The responsiveness to T-dependent (TD) and T-independent (TI) TNP-antigens of murine splenic B cells previously enriched for antigen-binding cells (ABC) was examined. TNP-TI antigens induced B cell proliferation. TNP-TD antigens did not induce a proliferative response regardless of the physical form or nature of the TNP-TD antigen (e.g., soluble vs particulate, low or high haptenation of carrier, TNP on various insoluble matrices, etc.). TNP-TD antigens were effective in enhancing the response of the TNP-ABC to all concentrations of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) tested, indicating that binding of antigen to surface immunoglobulin alters the LPS responsiveness of the cell. Irradiated, keyhole limpet hemocyanin- (KLH) primed T cells induced a threefold to fourfold greater B cell proliferative response with TNP-KLH than with fluoresceinated KLH (FLU-KLH) or FLU-KLH together with TNP-human serum albumin (TNP-HSA). Therefore, linked recognition appears essential for optimal T cell-mediated B cell proliferation, whereas the induction of B cell proliferation via nonlinked, carrier-activated T cells is a minor component of the response.     

Expression of specific clones during B cell development.

The expression of DNP- and TNP-specific B cells in spleens of neonatal BALB/c mice was analyzed by the in vitro splenic focus technique. B cells of these specificities were found to be present in slightly higher frequency in neonatal than in adult spleens. The parameters of stimulation of neonatal B cells were similar to those of adult B cells but the antibody-forming cell progeny of neonatal B cells produce predominantly gammaM rather than gammaG antibody and produce less antibody than the progeny of adult B cells. Isoelectric focusing analyses of monoclonal antibodies derived from neonatal B cells stimulated in vitro with DNP or TNP revealed that over 90 per cent of the antibodies could be identified as belonging to one of six predominant clonotypes, three specific for DNP and three for TNP. While individual neonates rarely expressed all of the predominant clonotypes, B cells of each of the six clonotypes were found in several donors. When B cells of a given predominant clonotype were present in an individual many such B cells could be found and in many cases the entire DNP- or TNP-specific B cell population of an individual could be accounted for by B cells of a single clonotype. These findings are discussed in terms of the diversity of clonotype specificities available in neonates, the kinetics of development of cells within a clonotype, and factors that may play a role in controlling the expression of B cell clones.     

Role of T cells in regulating expression of the B cell repertoire. Anti-ssDNA precursor frequency of DBA/2 B cells is increased in the presence of T cells from NZB mice

Splenic B cells from DBA/2 and NZB mice were compared with regard to precursor frequency of anti-ssDNA-producing cells. Using a modification of the splenic fragment assay, we show that NZB T cells are capable of increasing the frequency of expression of anti-ssDNA precursors in DBA/2 splenic B cells. When limiting numbers of splenic B cells of DBA/2 origin were adoptively transferred into an irradiated (1200 rad) recipient, the co-transfer of NZB T cells markedly increased the frequency of anti-ssDNA precursors in cultured splenic fragments. The anti-ssDNA produced under these conditions was exclusively IgM and exhibited a high degree of cross-reactivity with TNP and fluorescein. Thus, the increase in anti-ssDNA precursor frequency reflected an expansion of the B cell repertoire to include precursors of polyspecific antibody-producing cells that under normal circumstances are not expressed. The ability of NZB T cells to increase the anti-ssDNA precursor frequency was further defined by the CBA/N immunodeficiency gene xid, in that B cells from DBA/2.xid donors did not exhibit increased anti-ssDNA precursor frequency in the presence of NZB T cells. When NZB splenic B cells were co-transferred with DBA/2 T cells, the anti-DNA precursor frequency of the NZB B cells was not reduced. This study demonstrates that T cells can influence the emergency of B cell clones in an Ag-nonspecific manner. The well documented in vivo spontaneous polyclonal activation of NZB B cells may be secondary to T cell-mediated expansion of the B cell repertoire.     

Peripheral tolerance induced in lymph nodes by syngeneic spleen cells inhibits generation of CTLs to hapten-altered self antigens but not to alloantigens.

The immunological tolerance that is induced in lymph nodes that have been exposed to syngeneic spleen cells has been examined. Development of cytotoxic T lymphocytes was used to assess the immunological status of the lymph node cells. The tolerance was studied from the viewpoint of its induction, its activation, and its specificity. We had already reported that injecting either T or B cells of splenic origin into a regional lymph node environment a week prior to immunization for CTL to hapten-altered self antigens prevents development of the CTL. Here, we confirm that syngeneic splenic cells but not lymph node cells will induce the suppression provided that spleen cells are not coupled with hapten. We now report that splenic cells that cannot replicate or synthesize and secrete protein are capable of inducing the suppression. The data suggest a preformed surface marker peculiar to spleen cells and perhaps on cells that traverse the thymus induces local tolerance that is mediated by suppressor cells. Triggering the induced suppressor T cells (previously identified as CD8-) was achieved by syngeneic spleen cells as well as by H-2-compatible, Mls-disparate spleen cells but not by syngeneic lymph node cells or apparently by allogeneic spleen cells. Furthermore, triggering suppression was achieved by hapten-coupled syngeneic spleen cells whereas such cells would not induce the suppression. Thus, activating the suppressor cells requires reexposure to splenic cells of the proper MHC haplotype, unaltered or coupled with either TNP or FITC. Once triggered, the suppression was manifested toward CTL generation against hapten-coupled syngeneic antigens on either spleen or lymph node cells but not against allogeneic antigens. Thus, the specificity of the tolerance was directed to altered self antigens despite its induction by unaltered spleen antigen. Furthermore, for suppression to be seen the spleen antigen was not required to be on the hapten-coupled syngeneic cells used for the CTL immunization. The relationship of the splenic cell "antigen" to hapten-altered self antigens and to other surface markers and its site of acquisition within the body and its significance for cell homing have become intriguing questions of importance. This information has been discussed from the viewpoint of its applicability to autoimmune diseases as well as to cessation of inflammatory reactions that may be mediated by lymph node cells.     

The induction of hapten-specific immunological tolerance and immunity in B lymphocytes. V. Evidence for b-cell deletion in vitro with serum from tolerant mice.

The serum from mice that had been rendered specifically tolerant (TolS) to the trinitrophenyl (TNP) hapten by the injection of trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS) is effective in the in vitro induction of immunological unresponsiveness in murine spleen cells. This tolerance system was investigated with particular emphasis upon the mode of induction. The observed inhibition by TolS of responses to the thymic-independent (TI) antigen TNP-lipopolysaccharide (TNP-LPS) was stable following adoptive transfer to lethally irradiated recipients and was due neither to the delay of in vitro responsiveness nor to effector cell blockade at the level of the antibody-forming cell. Neither suppressor cells nor cell-bound tolerogen carry-over were responsible for the tolerance induced by TolS. TNP-LPS doses, including a wide range of polyclonal activating concentrations, were ineffective in reversing the unresponsive state induced by cocultivation with TolS. Additionally, unconjugated LPS in either fetal calf serum (FCS)-containing or FCS-free cultures did not break tolerance. This failure of polyclonal activating substances to reverse the unresponsive state suggests that blockade of TNP-specific receptors is not the mechanism of tolerogenesis, since such compounds trigger cells polyclonally through nonimmunoglobulin receptors. Tolerance induced by incubation of spleen cells with TolS for 24 hr followed by extensive washing was stable whether the immunogenic stimulus was the TI antigen TNP-LPS or the thymic-dependent (TD) form of the hapten, TNP-sheep erythrocytes (TNP-SRC). Washing spleen cells at elevated temperatures after preculturing with TolS to avoid possible reassociation of surface Ig (sIg)-bound TNP conjugates did not lead to escape from tolerance. Antigen-free incubation for 24 hr following cultivation with TolS was equally unsuccessful in reversing the unresponsive state. Thus, extensive washing following tolerance induction and antigen-free cultivation where unblocking or turnover and resynthesis of sIg receptors should have taken place provided no support for receptor blockade as the mode of in vitro induction and maintenance of tolerance by TolS. Treatment with the proteolytic enzyme pronase with the intention of removing potential tolerogen from the cell surface revealed a stable tolerant state. Incubation with anti-Ig or anti-TNP antisera under conditions designed to allow capping and removal of sIg-bound tolerogen or surface-bound TNP conjugates also failed to reverse the tolerance induced by incubation with TolS. The results presented here and previously lend no support to active or passive suppression or blockade of reactive cells as the mechanism of tolerance induction in vitro by TolS. The data are consistent with the hypothesis that TolS-induced unresponsiveness is due to a functional deletion of TNP-specific B lymphocytes. Furthermore, the similarities observed between the induction of tolerance by TNBS injection and TolS-induced unresponsiveness are consistent with the suggestion that TNBS-induced tolerance in vivo is mediated by a component of TolS which is active as a tolerogen in vitro.     

Defective B-cell tolerance in New Zealand black mice. Fc receptor-independence of resistance to low-epitope-density tolerogens

Trinitrophenyl (TNP) human gamma-globulin with low-epitope-density tolerizes B cells from normal BDF1 mice in a Fc gamma receptor-dependent manner but does not tolerize B cells from preautoimmune NZB mice. In order to investigate the relationships between tolerance induction and epitope density independently of Fc gamma receptor function in these two strains, TNP conjugates of two additional thymic-independent tolerogenic carriers, D-glutamic acid-D-lysine (D-GL) and carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC), were tested. A brief pulse with low-epitope-density conjugates such as TNP4.4-D-GL rendered unfractionated or T-cell-depleted spleen cells from BDF1 but not NZB mice tolerant in a hapten-specific manner. Spleen cells from NZB mice, however, were susceptible to tolerization with TNP13.5-D-GL. NZB mice were also resistant to tolerance induction in vivo with TNP5.5-D-GL, TNP3-CMC, and TNP6-CMC, all of which tolerize BDF1 mice in vivo. Both strains were tolerized with TNP13.5-D-GL and TNP13-CMC in vivo. NZB mice were also significantly less susceptible to tolerance induction with TNP3-CMC when TNP-Ficoll was substituted for TNP Brucella abortus as the challenge antigen. These findings militate against the possibility that an Fc gamma receptor defect is the principal mechanism of resistance of NZB B cells to tolerance induction with-low-epitope density conjugates.     

Membrane defects of the tolerant B cell. I. Failure of antigen-induced capping.

In order to study the membrane function of tolerant B antigen-binding cells, tolerance to the trinitrophenyl (TNP) determinant was induced in mice by injecting the reactive form of the hapten, trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBS). By appropriate transfer experiments, Fidler and Golub (J. Immunol.112, 1891, 1974) had previously shown that this form of tolerance is a B-cell property, induced and expressed in the absence of T cells. Hapten inhibition demonstrated the TNP-specificity of receptors on TNP-donkey erythrocyte(TNP-D)-binding cells in tolerant and nontolerant mice. About 88% of these cells were B cells by immunofluorescence, and the remainder were T cells. In the tolerant mice, challenge with TNP-sheep erythrocytes failed to expand the TNP-binding population, but sheep erythrocyte binders and anti-sheep plaque-forming cells expanded normally. Despite little or no change in TNP-binding cell numbers after tolerance induction, the TNP-binding cells of tolerant animals could not cap their receptors, in contrast to the sheep erythrocyte-binding cells from the same animals which capped normally. Although there is no anti-TNP plaque-forming cell response when tolerogen and immunogen are given simultaneously, capping failure is not evident until 2–4 days after tolerogen exposure. By Day 7, substantial recovery of immune responsiveness had occurred, yet even 12 months after a single dose of tolerogen there was no restoration of capping. Thus despite the association of both capping failure and unresponsiveness with tolerogen exposure, these lymphocyte functional defects appeared not to be causally related.     

Establishment of an antigen-specific B cell clone by somatic hybridization

Splenic B cells of A/J mice immunized with 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl (TNP)-lipopolysaccharide were fused with 2.52M, a mutant of a B cell line, in the presence of polyethylene glycol and dimethyl sulfoxide. TP67.21, a subclone of a resulting hybridoma, expresses IAk, IEk, IgM, B220, P50, and receptors for C3 fragment of complement, the Fc portion of IgG, and interleukin 2 receptor on the cell membrane; it also possesses receptor molecules for TNP on its surface, derived from TNP-reactive B cells of A/J mice primed with TNP-lipopolysaccharide used for somatic hybridization, by a rosette-forming assay with TNP-sheep erythrocytes. In contrast, parental 2.52M lacks IAk and IEk on the cell membrane and does not bind to TNP-sheep erythrocytes under the same conditions. Thus, it is likely that TP67.21 is an antigen-specific B cell clone directed against TNP. The antigen binding of cells was markedly inhibited by the specific free hapten or anti-IgM antibodies. Interestingly, TP67.21 was induced to generate a significant amount of anti-TNP antibody when treated with TNP conjugates including T cell-independent and -dependent antigens, such as TNP-lipopolysaccharide, TNP-bovine serum albumin, TNP-ovalbumin, and TNP-keyhole limpet hemocyanine in the absence of T cell help, as well as polyclonal activators; this was followed by a marked decrease in the expression of B cell surface markers on the cell membrane. This suggests that the cross-linkage of receptor molecules on TP67.21 by antigen may directly provide a differentiative signal for maturation to a lineage of B cells, and consequently results in the generation of antigen-specific antibodies without T cell involvement.     

Intrathymic T cell repertoire after prenatal trinitrobenzene-sulfonic acid-treatment

It is still a matter of debate, whether tolerance toward self-non-MHC antigens is due to intrathymic deletion or to regulatory processes in the periphery. To further pursue this question, responsiveness toward TNP and an anti-TNP monoclonal antibody (Sp6) carrying a recurrent idiotype was evaluated in prenatally trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS)-treated mice. In prenatally untreated as well as in TNBS-treated mice, thymocytes proliferating in the absence of nominal antigen were double negative (L3T4-/Lyt2-), but antigen-specific thymocytes were single positive (L3T4+/Lyt2- or L3T4-/Lyt2+). TNBS-treated mice differed from controls inasmuch as in their first week of life T cells proliferating in response to TNP were found in the thymus and detected at increased frequencies in the spleen. The frequency of TNP-specific thymocytes and spleen cells declined rapidly, finally reaching in the spleen a level of 20-30% of controls. Furthermore, after antigenic stimulation, the frequency of thymocytes and spleen cells proliferating in response to TNP was found to be increased in control mice, but TNP-specific T cell were no more recovered in the thymus or the spleen of tolerized mice. The same accounted for thymic and splenic T cells proliferating in response to Sp6. They were expanded in control mice after antigenic stimulation, but were undetectable in TNBS-treated mice. Thus, T cells with specificity for an internal (Sp6) and an external (TNP) antigen, provided the latter was present during ontogeny, were detected in the thymus of control and, transiently, in the thymus of tolerized mice. But, the fate of antigen-specific thymocytes was different in prenatally untreated and TNBS-treated mice. The data are interpreted in the sense that tolerance toward non-MHC antigens may be acquired subsequently to tolerance toward self-MHC antigens and possibly after imprinting of antigen specificity.     

Frequency analysis of immunoglobulin V-gene expression and functional reactivities in bone marrow B cells

Frequency of immunocompetent B cells in bone marrow has been determined in vitro under culture conditions that allow the development in vitro under culture conditions that allow the development of every growth-inducible B cell into a clone of IgM-secreting PFC. Three limiting dilution culture systems were employed: a specific helper assay with SRBC as antigen and using activated T helper cells, a nonspecific helper assay using Con A-induced factors as a source of help, and polyclonal activation with LPS. From unseparated, normal C57BL/6J bone marrow 1 in 2200 to 1 in 2820 B cells were induced to form a clone of PFC to SRBC in each of the 3 systems. This corresponds to a frequency of 1 SRBC-specific clone in every 900 IgM-secreting LPS-reactive clones. The frequencies of specific plaque-forming B cell clones in terms of LPS-reactive B cells was 1 in 36 for NNP1-SRBC, 1 in 58 for TNP30-SRBC, 1 in 75 for NIP1-SRBC, and 1 in 230 for TNP3-SRBC. These frequencies of v-gene expression in bone marrow B cells are of the same magnitude as the corresponding frequencies for splenic B cells. Bone marrow B cells are also fully susceptible to stimulation by antigen in combination with either specific or nonspecific T cell help, as well as polyclonal activation by LPS, since every 3rd Ig-positive cells in marrow could be induced to form a clone of IgM-secreting cells. There is thus no difference in immunocompetence between surface Ig-bearing B cells from bone marrow and spleen.     

Regulation of the primary in vitro response to TNP-polymerized ovalbumin by T suppressor cells induced by ovalbumin feeding

Spleen cells from DBA/2 mice that received a single feeding of 20 mg of ovalbumin (OVA) 7 days previously were specifically hyporesponsive to primary in vitro challenge with the thymic-dependent antigen TNP-polymerized ovalbumin (TNP-POL-OVA). The tolerance observed in spleen cells from OVA-fed animals was dependent upon OVA-specific T suppressor cells, because splenic T cells from OVA-fed mice suppressed the primary response to TNP-POL-OVA of cultures containing normal T and B cells. The tolerance and suppression was OVA specific, because spleen cells from OVA-fed animals responded well to other antigens (including TNP on another carrier), and splenic T cells from OVA-fed mice did not affect the response of normal T and B cells to sheep erythrocytes. These data confirm the existence of T suppressor cells after OVA feeding and provide a direct means of assaying their activity in a primary in vitro response.     

T cell regulation of B cell activation. An antigen-mediated tripartite interaction of Ts cells, Th cells, and B cells is required for suppression

To determine the requirements underlying the antigen specificity observed in T cell-mediated immune response suppression, cloned major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T suppressor (Ts) cells specific for keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and cloned MHC-restricted T helper (Th) cells specific for fowl gamma-globulin (FGG) were employed to study the regulation of trinitrophenyl (TNP)-specific B cell responses. Neither antigen bridging between Ts cells and Th cells (FGG=KLH) nor bridging between Ts cells and B cells (TNP-KLH) was sufficient to allow suppression; a mixture of FGG=KLH and TNP-KLH was also insufficient for suppression. In contrast, suppression was induced by KLH-specific Ts cells only when suppressor determinants (KLH), helper determinants (FGG), and B cell determinants (TNP) were covalently linked on the same molecule (TMP-FGG)=(TNP-KLH) or TNP-(FGG=KLH)). These findings imply that a tripartite antigen-mediated interaction of Ts cells, Th cells, and responding B cells is necessary for the mediation of this antigen-specific suppression.     

Direct involvement of surface IA/E molecules during B cell maturation using an antigen-specific B cell clone

TP67.14 is a subclone of a resulting B cell hybridoma established by somatic hybridization between splenic B cells of A/J mice immunized with TNP-LPS and 2.52 M, a HAT medium-sensitive mutant of a B cell line; it expresses IgM, B220, IAk, and IEk on the cell membrane and also possesses a receptor molecule for TNP on its surface derived from TNP-reactive B cells of A/J mice used for cell fusion. As shown previously, TP67.14 could be induced to generate a significant amount of anti-TNP antibodies when treated with TNP-conjugated protein such as TNP-BSA and TNP-keyhole limpet hemocyanin without T cell help as well as LPS. Our study was undertaken to investigate direct involvement of surface MHC class II molecules on B cells during B cell maturation by analysis with this Ag-specific B cell clone. The data demonstrate that mAb against IAk and IEk molecules, but not IAd and H-2k, markedly inhibited the differentiative effects of LPS on TP67.14. In contrast, both antibodies specifically augmented the secretion of anti-TNP antibodies by TP67.14 treated with TNP-BSA, although these antibodies alone failed to induce the generation of anti-TNP antibodies. Interestingly, TP67.14 significantly differentiated into anti-TNP antibody secreting cells when incubated with TNP-conjugated monoclonal anti-IAk or anti-IEk antibodies alone; this differentiative effect was much greater than that of TNP-conjugated anti-IAd mAb or purified mouse IgG under the same conditions. Our result suggests that surface IA/E molecules on B cells may be directly involved in a transductional signal for B cell maturation mediated by the cross-linkage of receptor molecules on B cells with Ag.     

B cell heterogeneity—Difference in the size of B lymphocytes responding to T dependent and T independent antigens

Spleen cells from either normal (nonimmunized) mice or mice preimmunized with TNP KLH were depleted of T cells by treatment with a heterologous anti θ serum and complement. Fractionation of these B cells by velocity sedimentation followed by challenge with either a T independent antigen (DNP POL) or a T dependent antigen (TNP KLH), the latter being performed in the presence of additional helper T cells, revealed apparent size difference between B cells responding to the two antigens. This difference, while most marked with preimmunized B cells, was also apparent with normal B cells from the spleen or bone marrow, but not from the lymph node. Similar data were observed with other T dependent and T independent antigens. The differences in the sedimentation profile of splenic B cells for T dependent and T independent antigens did not seem to be due to a difference in the kinetics of appearance of antibody upon stimulation with these antigens, though large B cells did seem to give rise to antibody producing cells at later times than small B cells.