Sensitivity to reward loss as an indicator of animal emotion and welfare

The scientific study of animal emotion is an important emerging discipline in subjects ranging from neuroscience to animal welfare research. In the absence of direct measures of conscious emotion, indirect behavioural and physiological measures are used. However, these may have significant limitations (e.g. indicating emotional arousal but not valence (positivity versus negativity)). A new approach, taking its impetus from human studies, proposes that biases in information processing, and underlying mechanisms relating to the evaluation of reward gains and losses, may reliably reflect emotional valence in animals. In general, people are more sensitive to reward losses than gains, but people in a negative affective state (e.g. depression) are particularly sensitive to losses. This may underlie broader findings such as an enhanced attention to, and memory of, negative events in depressed individuals. Here we show that rats in unenriched housing, who typically exhibit indicators of poorer welfare and a more negative affective state than those in enriched housing, display a prolonged response to a decrease in anticipated food reward, indicating enhanced sensitivity to reward loss. Sensitivity to reward reduction may thus be a valuable new indicator of animal emotion and welfare.     

Progesterone concentration as an indicator of ovarian response to superovulation in Chios ewes

We investigated the prediction of the ovarian response to superovulation using progesterone (P4) determination in Chios ewes. During the estrus period. estrus synchronization and multiple ovulations were induced in 100 non-pregnant, non-lactating Chios ewes by a combination of FGA-impregnated intravaginal sponges and 8.8 mg of ovine FSH. Laparoscopic insemination was conducted 24-28 h after the onset of estrus. A concentration of P4 was determined on Day 5 of the estrous cycle and on Day 6 the ovarian response was evaluated by counting the corpus lutea (CL); subsequently, embryo collection was performed. According to the response of their ovaries, ewes were allocated into four groups: A (n = 30); B (n = 37); C (n = 22); D (n = 11), with minimal (0-3 CL), moderate (4-8 CL), good (9-13 CL) or extreme (> 13 CL) ovarian response, respectively. In groups C and D, the mean blood serum P4 concentration (23.2 and 27.3 ng/ml, respectively) was higher (P < 0.001) than that in groups A and B (4.6 and 13.1 ng/ml, respectively); no difference was detected in blood P4 concentration between groups C and D. A strong linear relation (F < 0.00005) was found between blood P4 concentration and the number of CL, as well as between blood P4 and a dummy variable corresponding to poor (< 4 CL) or moderate/good/extreme ovarian response (>3 CL). Our results indicate that based on blood P4 measurement, it is feasible to identify ewes that should show the highest embryo recovery, while it is impossible to predict the exact number of CL formed.     

Effects of low-intensity laser irradiation on the state of blood proteins

The action of a low-intensity 632.8 nm-wavelength laser radiation on blood elements was studied. The degree of binding the fluorescence probes 1.8 ANS by blood proteins and cells was taken to be the index of the response to irradiation. The change of fluorescence of the oppositely charged probes indicates that a He-Ne laser radiation causes processes leading to a change of charge in proteins of a blood plasma with the negative charge decreased in most cases. The effect depends on individual characteristics of a biological object, on the exposure dose and the incubation time following the irradiation.     

Activation of cholesterogenesis in response to ionizing irradiation of the animal body

The assumption is made that ionizing radiation induces cholesterogenesis activation in different cells of mammalian organism as an early reaction to the harmful effect necessary for restoration of biomembranes. Liver cells activate adaptively the cholesterol synthesis in the animal body irradiated with lethal doses in response to the injury to radiosensitive cells in order to make them recover and compensate for their functions (with the gastrointestinal syndrome, for instance, to compensate for the cholesterol-producing function of the intestine and to make it recover). With lethal radiation doses, a change in the lipid content and metabolism of microsomal membrane lipids of the liver is associated with activation of synthetic functions of the liver due to compensation of the injury to radiosensitive tissues.     

Influence of hypoxia and anoxia on endothelium-dependent dilatation response of rat's aorta exposed to low-intensity gamma irradiation

The study of isolated segments of aorta has shown that prolongated exposure of rats to gamma-radiation with 50 cGy dose (with a dose rate of 2.8 x 10(7) Gy/s) causes the decrease in endothelium-dependent dilatation responses to M-cholinoreceptors stimulation. During oxygenation the post-radiation changes are displayed within one month, and under functional loads, specifically, during perfusion by hypoxic and anoxic solutions--in more remote terms of the post-radiation period.     

Biophysics of animal response to an electrostatic field

Numerous reports have described biological effects in animals exposed to electrostatic fields. Present equilibrium theory does not envision such effects because the bulk conductivity of biological tissue is generally held to prevent penetration of the applied electric field. Employing a two-layer mathematical model of an animal exposed to an electrostatic field we show that if the transient response of the animal is considered, then electric fields of significant strength and periodicity can occur inside the animal. We show also that the total energy available to an animal in an electrostatic field is extraordinarily small, and therefore that the biological effects associated with such exposure are not energetically driven by the applied field.     

Intensity of the humoral immune response to herpesviruses as an indicator the body immune deficiency

The state of the local immunity system of the oral cavity was studied by the level of saliva immunoglobulins in patients with different processes on their mucous membranes: herpetic infection, respiratory allergosis and malignant tumors of the mouth cavity and the laryngopharynx. The suppression of the production of sIgA, was accompanied by the enhanced production of antibodies to the most widespread herpesviruses (herpes simplex virus, cytomegalovirus and Epstein-Barr virus). The maximum levels of serum IgG to herpesviruses were determined in patients with malignant tumors. The role of herpesviruses in the pathogenesis of immunodeficient states is discussed.     

Pupillary dilation response as an indicator of auditory discrimination in the barn owl

The pupil of an awake, untrained, head-restrained barn owl was found to dilate in response to sounds with a latency of about 25 ms. The magnitude of the dilation scaled with signal-to-noise ratio. The dilation response habituated when a sound was repeated, but recovered when stimulus frequency or location was changed. The magnitude of the recovered response was related to the degree to which habituating and novel stimuli differed and was therefore exploited to measure frequency and spatial discrimination. Frequency discrimination was examined by habituating the response to a reference tone at 3 kHz or 6 kHz and determining the minimum change in frequency required to induce recovery. We observed frequency discrimination of 125 Hz at 3 kHz and 250 Hz at 6 kHz – values comparable to those reported by others using an operant task. Spatial discrimination was assessed by habituating the response to a stimulus from one location and determining the minimum horizontal speaker separation required for recovery. This yielded the first measure of the minimum audible angle in the barn owl: 3° for broadband noise and 4.5° for narrowband noise. The acoustically evoked pupillary dilation is thus a promising indicator of auditory discrimination requiring neither training nor aversive stimuli. Accepted: 28 February 2000     

Dependence of response reaction of root voles to low-intensity irradiation on initial state of the tissue antioxidant system

There has been studied the response of antioxidant (AO) reaction of the tissue system of the root voles Microtus oeconomus Pall., whose parents belonged to the populations long inhabiting the Republic Komi regions with different degrees of radioactive contamination, on an additional irradiation at low doses. Differences have been revealed in the phospholipid content, activity of AO defense, intensity of processes of lipid peroxidation (LPO) in tissues of the offspring of voles caught in the control and contaminated regions. It has been revealed that direction and degree of changes in the offspring tissues after the additional action are determined by the parameter value in the non-irradiated animal group. Intensity of the LPO processes in liver and brain was leveled after the long low-intensity irradiation. The obtained data and analysis of literature indicate that at predicting effects of chronic action of low doses of a damaging factor both in experiment and in the natural habitation, it is necessary to take into account initial characteristics of biological objects.     

Control of an estuarine microfouling sequence on optical surfaces using low-intensity ultraviolet irradiation

Ultraviolet light has been investigated as an active energy input for the control of slime film formation on optical surfaces submerged in San Francisco Bay for periods up to 6 weeks. Irradiation of quartz underwater windows was carried out from three positions: (i) exterior to the window, (ii) from directly behind the window, and (iii) from the edge of the window with the ultraviolet (UV) energy refracted through the front of the window. Internally administered irradiation reaching levels of 10 to 30 μW per cm² measurable at the glass surface was effective in preventing bacterial slime film formation and settlement of metazoan larvae. When administered from the external position, over one order of magnitude more (500 to 600 μW/cm²) UV energy was required to accomplish the same result. Irradiation from the edge position was most promising logistically and was effective in fouling control for 6 weeks. The results provide a preliminary quantitation of the energy requirement for control of the marine microfouling sequence which precedes development of macrofouling communities.     

Dependence of response reaction of root voles to low-intensity irradiation on the initial state of the tissue antioxidant system

There has been studied the response of antioxidant (AO) reaction of the tissue system of the root voles Microtus oeconomus Pall. whose parents belonged to the populations long inhabiting the Republic Komi regions with different degrees of radioactive contamination on an additional radiation action at low doses. Differences have been revealed in the phospholipid content, activities of AO defense, intensities of processes of lipid peroxidation (LPO) in tissues of the vole offspring caught in the control and contaminated regions. It has been revealed that direction and degree of changes in the offspring tissues after the additional action are determined by the parameter value in the non-irradiated animal group. Intensity of the LPO processes in liver and brain was leveled after the long low-intensity irradiation. The obtained data and analysis of literature indicate that at predicting effects of chronic action of low doses of a damaging factor both in experiment and in the natural habitation, it is necessary to take into account initial characteristics of biological objects.     

Particularities of blood lymphocyte response to irradiation in vitro in breast cancer patients

DNA breaks and their repair efficiency were analyzed in irradiated in vitro lymphocytes (at doses 1 Gy, gamma-radiation of 60Co, dose rate 1 Gy/min) isolated from peripheral blood of 41 untreated patients with breast cancer and 25 healthy donors using the DNA comet assay under non-denaturing conditions (mainly double-strand DNA breaks (DSB), as well as apoptotic cell death using the DNA halo assay. To estimate the expression of bystander effect, the cells were incubated in a culture medium obtained from lymphocytes irradiated in vitro at doses 1 Gy. The average DSB level in blood lymphocytes of breast cancer patients was shown to be significantly higher (p < 0.05) compared with that in control donors. In general, the following effects were observed in irradiated in vitro lymphocytes of cancer patients: (1) increased sensitivity to y-radiation-induced DNA DSBs compared with lymphocytes from healthy donors, (2) reduced repair efficiency of these damages. Incubation of irradiated blood lymphocytes in a medium from irradiated cells led to an increased relative number of DNA DSBs and an elevated fraction of cells dying through apoptotic pathway both in blood lymphocytes from cancer patients and control donors. However, these non-targeted effects were more expressed for the blood lymphocytes of breast cancer patients.     

Space use as an indicator of enclosure appropriateness: A novel measure of captive animal welfare

Empirical measures of animal behavior and space use within the captive environment can provide critical information about animals’ requirements, preferences and internal states. The trend toward naturalistic environments has shown promise in terms of behavioral benefits for animals such as great apes, and there have been several studies of the effects of complex environments on captive apes. However, few recent investigations have objectively compared environmental preferences between two distinct enclosures. In this study, we assessed how ape space use varied within and across two very different environments: an indoor, hardscape enclosure and an indoor/outdoor, naturalistic enclosure. Within-facility tests were conducted by comparing data from behavioral observations of the apes’ position in the enclosures to measurements of the space and the availability of individual environmental elements. Between-facility comparisons utilized electivity index calculations to assess both the degree of use for specific features and the degree to which these selections strengthened or weakened in the new facility. Both gorillas and chimpanzees showed significant structural preferences in the older, hardscape environment: positioning themselves by mesh barriers (chimpanzees: P = 0.005; gorillas: P < 0.001) and corners (P = 0.005; gorillas: P < 0.001) more than would be expected by random spatial utilization, and avoiding open spaces (chimpanzees: P = 0.005; gorillas: P < 0.001) not adjacent to any physical structure. A new, naturalistic enclosure was constructed using preference data from the previous facility. In the new facility, both species of ape substantially altered the way in which they chose to position themselves in the enclosure. Chimpanzees used most of the environmental elements at rates more similar to the proportions they were available. While gorilla's preference corners was maintained in the new facility, preferences for doorways and mesh barriers disappeared. Comparing electivity indices facilitated an empirical comparison of space use preferences. Chimpanzees showed significant differences in how they used structural elements (P = 0.021), mesh barriers (P = 0.009) and corners (P = 0.016) in the new facility. Gorillas’ environmental selections were similarly altered in the new facility, as selections of areas adjacent to doorways (P = 0.003), glass barriers (P = 0.005), structural elements (P < 0.001), and mesh barriers (P = 0.012) were all significantly affected by the transfer. This approach is useful for understanding how captive animals utilize their enclosures and we advocate that electivity indices can be added to a growing list of tools to assess the effect of captive environments on animal welfare.     

Leaf nutrient concentration as an indicator of Populus and Tamarix response to flooding

Plants growing in infertile environments are able to produce more biomass per unit of nutrient taken up than plants of fertile habitats, and also to minimize nutrients loss by resorbing them from senescing leaves. The leaf nutrient concentration variability of two co-existing riparian tree genera (Populus and Tamarix) along a flood inundation gradient was examined to infer nutrient limitation and to compare nutrient use strategies in the two genera. To that end, seasonal and spatial variability in leaf nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) concentration (i.e., % dry mass of N and P) were analyzed in 720 samples of leaves (2 tree genera × 3 seasons × 12 sites × 10 tree replicates). Both Populus and Tamarix showed strong seasonal variability in leaf N and P concentrations, with values decreasing throughout the growing season. However, while N:P atomic ratio remained seasonally constant in Populus (N:P = 33), Tamarix shifted from N:P = 29 in spring to N:P = 36 and 37 in summer and fall. %N, %P and N:P atomic ratios were also spatially variable, but leaf litter N and P concentration (i.e., nutrient resorption proficiency) and leaf litter N:P generally followed the local flood inundation gradient as shown by linear mixed effects models. In particular, nutrient resorption was usually less proficient (higher terminal nutrient concentrations) at higher flood durations (in gravel bars and natural levees), whereas N:P increased in the drier sites (floodplain terrace). At floodplain level, a P-limitation that is higher than N-limitation seems to characterize the plant nutrient circulation in the riparian ecosystem studied. Tamarix was slightly more proficient in P resorption than Populus. The study shows that leaf nutrient concentration (e.g., N and P) derived from nutrient availability is partly controlled by the flood inundation regime and can be used as an indicator of nutrient limitation in forested floodplains. Subtle differences between tree genera provide an additional, novel explanation for the recent expansion of Tamarix in many arid and semi-arid rivers with altered hydrogeomorphic regimes.     

Measurements of human responses to short duration impact

Thirty human volunteers participated in 75 exposures to short duration impact (less than 10 msec). The tests were conducted to investigate the ability of the subjects to discriminate different pulse durations in the short duration region. Theoretical studies done previously imply that the subjects should only be sensitive to velocity change and not pulse duration below 10 msec duration. The tests were conducted on a free-fall facility with the subject in a seated position (G₂). The deceleration pulses were Gaussian in shape. Two durations (4 and 8 msec) were investigated at three velocity levels (2·6 m/sec, 3·5 m/sec, and 4·1 m/sec). The decelerations were accomplished with a coefficient of restitution from 0·4 to 0·6. The peak G ranged from 80 to 210. The tests were conducted in three phases. Phase I established the safety of the peak velocity level by proceeding in small increments from a known safe level. Phase II was conducted by exposing 9 subjects to each of the three velocity levels in a counterbalanced experimental design. The pulse duration was 8 msec. Phase III was a duplicate of Phase II, except that a 4 msec pulse was used. A physical or subjective tolerance level was not reached in these experiments, but the 4·1 m/sec velocity level prompted several subjects to discontinue participation in such exposures. A “Physical Symptom Survey” conducted by questionaire, which asked the subject to score severity of sensation by anatomic area, showed a correlation with velocity level and pulse duration. Symptomatology was diffuse but related primarily to the musculoskeletal system and central nervous system. The results of these tests and data derived are discussed relative to physical tolerance and injury potential.