Changes in center-of-pressure dynamics during upright standing related to decreased balance control in young adults: fractional Brownian motion analysis

We investigated the relationships between the ability to maintain balance in an upright stance and center-of-pressure (COP) dynamic properties in young adults. Included in this study were 10 healthy male subjects in each of two groups with respect to balance ability. Balance ability was evaluated according to the length of time a subject stood on one leg with his eyes closed. The means and ranges of this one-leg balancing time were 17.9 s (3-43 s) and 118.3 s (103-120 s) for the off-balance and balance groups, respectively. The time-varying displacements of the COP under a subject's feet during quiet two-leg (normal) standing were measured by an instrumented force platform. Each subject was tested in both the eyes-open and eyes-closed conditions. The COP trajectories were analyzed as fractional Brownian motions according to the procedure of 'stabilogram-diffusion analysis', proposed by Collins and De Luca (1993). The extracted parameters were the effective diffusion coefficients (D) for the short-term (less than about 1.0 s) and long-term intervals, respectively, as well as the Hurst exponents (H) for the short-term and long-term intervals, and some critical-point coordinates (i.e., critical mean square displacements and critical time intervals). The off-balance group showed significantly higher values for short-term D, short-term H, and critical mean square displacements than the balance group. No significant differences between the groups were found in the long-term D and H or in the critical time intervals. That is, for the off-balance subjects, an increase in the stochastic activity and positively correlated (persistent) behavior of the postural sway during shorter timescales may cause postural instability. These results suggest that the difference in balance ability for young adults is related to the open-loop (i.e., short-term) control mechanisms but not to the corrective feedback (i.e., long-term) mechanisms used to maintain balance in an upright stance.     

Chaos in Balance: Non-Linear Measures of Postural Control Predict Individual Variations in Visual Illusions of Motion

Visually-induced illusions of self-motion (vection) can be compelling for some people, but they are subject to large individual variations in strength. Do these variations depend, at least in part, on the extent to which people rely on vision to maintain their postural stability? We investigated by comparing physical posture measures to subjective vection ratings. Using a Bertec balance plate in a brightly-lit room, we measured 13 participants'' excursions of the centre of foot pressure (CoP) over a 60-second period with eyes open and with eyes closed during quiet stance. Subsequently, we collected vection strength ratings for large optic flow displays while seated, using both verbal ratings and online throttle measures. We also collected measures of postural sway (changes in anterior-posterior CoP) in response to the same visual motion stimuli while standing on the plate. The magnitude of standing sway in response to expanding optic flow (in comparison to blank fixation periods) was predictive of both verbal and throttle measures for seated vection. In addition, the ratio between eyes-open and eyes-closed CoP excursions during quiet stance (using the area of postural sway) significantly predicted seated vection for both measures. Interestingly, these relationships were weaker for contracting optic flow displays, though these produced both stronger vection and more sway. Next we used a non-linear analysis (recurrence quantification analysis, RQA) of the fluctuations in anterior-posterior position during quiet stance (both with eyes closed and eyes open); this was a much stronger predictor of seated vection for both expanding and contracting stimuli. Given the complex multisensory integration involved in postural control, our study adds to the growing evidence that non-linear measures drawn from complexity theory may provide a more informative measure of postural sway than the conventional linear measures.     

Moderate alterations in lower limbs muscle temperature do not affect postural stability during quiet standing in both young and older women.

Older adults demonstrate increased amounts of postural sway, which may ultimately lead to falls. Temperature is known to have a profound effect on the performance of the neuromuscular system which could have important implications on motor control. It is, therefore, of interest to investigate if the age-related decline in postural stability could be affected by changes in local limbs temperature. The present study investigated the effects of localized warming and cooling on postural sway in nine young (22+/-3 years) and nine older (73+/-3 years) women. Postural sway was assessed, using a single force platform, during quiet standing at three muscle temperature conditions: control (34.2+/-0.2 degrees C), cold (31.3+/-0.3 degrees C) and warm (37.0+/-0.1 degrees C). Two stances were evaluated, the Romberg (large support base) and modified Tandem (narrow support base), under both eyes-open and eyes-closed conditions. Root mean square (RMS), mean velocity (MV), sway area (SA) and mean power frequency (MPF) were calculated from the centre of pressure (COP) displacement. Neither warming nor cooling significantly affected any of the postural parameters which were, however, all higher (P<0.05) in the older group than the young group in all conditions. This study demonstrated that, in quiet standing conditions, a moderate variation (+/-3 degrees C) in lower limbs temperature does not affect postural steadiness in either young or older women.     

Effect of different preparatory states on the reflex responses of ankle flexor and extensor muscles to a sudden drop of support surface during standing in humans

The present study hypothesized that if subliminal facilitation of the ankle flexor motoneurons is related to preparatory state to a mechanical perturbation while standing, different standing conditions such as standing with eyes-closed or touching a bar should have different influences on the facilitation levels. While the subjects were maintaining an upright stance posture, sudden drops of support surface were applied several times in the following four different conditions: (1) standing with eyes-open, (2) with eyes-closed, (3) with eyes-open and warning of the drop, and (4) with eyes-open and touching a bar with both hands. The results demonstrated that the EMG responses in the ankle flexor TA muscle increased in the eyes-closed condition, while it reduced in the conditions, such as that the subjects had prior warning or touched a bar. The preparatory state of supraspinal neural centers was suggested to be related to the observed variation in the EMG responses.     

The contribution of vision in dynamic spontaneous sways of male classical dancers according to student or professional level.

We investigated the involvement of vision in the regulation of dynamic equilibrium in male children and young adults performing a physical activity requiring a high level of spatial skill: self-induced body sways of ballet dancers on a free unstable platform, 45 professional male dancers (Paris Opera) participated in the study. They included two student groups (beginners and confirmed) and two performer groups (adolescent and adult). They maintained their equilibrium on the platform under different visual and position conditions. The displacement of the seesaw platform were calculated from accelerometer measures. Fast Fourier transform processing of stabilograms allowed spectral frequency analysis. The total spectrum energy and the energies of the three frequency bands (0-0.5 Hz, 0.5-2 Hz, 2-20 Hz) were determined. For all groups, ANOVA indicated that values were higher for eyes-closed than for eyes-open conditions. The visual dependence differed according to age: for 14-year-old students the postural control for dynamic equilibrium was less visually dependent than for 11-year-old students. The 18-year-old dancers, although professional, were more dependent on vision than 14-year-old student dancers. These 18-year-old dancers were still adolescent because they had recently undergone growth acceleration which could disturb their proprioceptive references and internal body representations. Thus, visual input may dominate over the other sensory inputs in the regulation of postural control.     

Predicting the dynamic postural control response from quiet-stance behavior in elderly adults

Human postural sway, as measured by fluctuations of the center of pressure (COP) under the feet of a quietly standing individual, can be characterized as a stochastic process. The fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) provides a linear relationship between the fluctuations of a quasi-static, stochastic system to the same system's relaxation to equilibrium following a perturbation. We applied a similar linear relationship, based on the FDT, to the human postural control system to explore whether anterior-posterior (AP) fluctuations of the COP during quiet stance can be used to predict the AP response of the postural control system to a weak posteriorly directed mechanical perturbation (tug or pull at the waist). We tested 10 healthy elderly (mean age of 69yr) and 10 healthy young (mean age of 25yr) adult subjects. We found that this linear relationship was applicable to the postural control system of all 10 young and eight of the 10 elderly adult subjects. These results suggest that it is possible to predict an individual's dynamic response to a mild perturbation using quiet-stance data, regardless of age. The existence of this FDT-based linear relationship with respect to the human postural control system suggests that, for a given individual, the postural control system may use the same control mechanisms during quiet stance and mild-perturbation conditions, regardless of age.     

Maintenance of upright stance in humans in normal and virtual visual environments

We recorded in 16 healthy subjects the sagittal and frontal components of the stabilogram when standing on a rigid motionless or movable (oscillating) platform under four conditions of visual control: (i) open eyes, OE; (ii) closed eyes, CE; (iii) central vision, CV, and (iv) virtual visual environment, VVE. Under the latter condition, subjects observed the 3D image of a room, which was generated by the computer; the image was adhered to head movements in such a manner that a peculiar connection for normal visual conditions between movements of the head and displacements of the visible visual environment was reproduced. Through a low-pass filtration of a trajectory of the center of pressure of feet (CPF), two elementary variables were received, horizontal motions of the center of gravity (CG) and the difference between the CPF and the CG (CPF-CG). Changes in these variables (CG and CPF-CG) were estimated using spectral analysis and subsequent calculation of the median frequency (MF) and root mean square value (RMS) of the spectra. The MFs of the spectra of the investigated variables were approximately identical under conditions of standing on oscillating and motionless supports and showed no clear dependence on various visual conditions. Unlike MFs, the RMSs of the spectra of body sways appeared more dependent on changes of conditions of standing and the mode of visual control (differing from each other in the higher sensitivity to modifications of conditions of standing and visual control). With standing on the motionless support, the RMSs of the spectra of both variables were the greatest under VVE and CE conditions and the smallest under OE condition. The body oscillations were considerably amplified under conditions of standing on a movable support, and a different pattern of visual influences on the RMS of both investigated variables was revealed. The RMSs had the greatest value under CE condition and were much smaller (50–40%) under other visual conditions, including the VVE condition. Therefore, our findings show that, under VVE conditions, visual sensory afferentation is ignored by cerebral structures controlling postural adjustments if standing occurs on a motionless support but is effectively used at the maintenance of upright stance on an oscillating support. Neirofiziologiya/Neurophysiology, Vol. 39, No. 6, pp. 476–485, November–December, 2007.     

Specific and Nonspecific Visual Influences on the Stability of the Vertical Posture in Humans

We studied physiological mechanisms of vision-related stabilization of the vertical posture in humans using a stabilographic technique; spontaneous deviations of the projection of the center of gravity during quiet stance and magnitudes of the postural response to vibratory stimulation of proprioceptors of the lower leg muscles under varied conditions of visual control were measured. The stability of quiet stance, as estimated according to the root mean square value of the sagittal component of the stabilogram, was the best with eyes open. Vibration-induced postural responses were the smallest also under these conditions. Spontaneous postural sway and the amplitude of response to vibratory stimulation increased when only a central sector of visual field (20 ang. deg) was preserved and, especially, under conditions of closed eyes and horizontal inversion of visual perception using prismatic spectacles. Parallel changes in the quantitative stabilographic indices and amplitude of vibration-induced postural responses show that the intensity of the latter is probably determined by the background stiffness of the musculoskeletal system. We tried to estimate separately the contributions of the stiffness factor, on the one hand, and specific visual influences, on the other hand, by testing the parameters of quiet stance and postural responses under conditions of standing while lightly touching a support with the index finger. We found that the influence of the conditions of visual control on the stability of quiet stance while touching the support was eliminated. At the same time, the magnitude of postural responses to vibratory stimulation decreased but, nonetheless, changed with visual conditions in the same manner as when standing without additional support. We conclude that vision performs a dual function in the control of the vertical posture; it forms the basis for the spatial reference system and serves the source of information on the movements of one's body.     

Relationship of multiscale entropy to task difficulty and sway velocity in healthy young adults

Abstract

Purpose/background: Multiscale entropy (MSE) is a nonlinear measure of postural control that quantifies how complex the postural sway is by assigning a complexity index to the center of pressure (COP) oscillations. While complexity has been shown to be task dependent, the relationship between sway complexity and level of task challenge is currently unclear. This study tested whether MSE can detect short-term changes in postural control in response to increased standing balance task difficulty in healthy young adults and compared this response to that of a traditional measure of postural steadiness, root mean square of velocity (VRMS).

Methods: COP data from 20?s of quiet stance were analyzed when 30 healthy young adults stood on the following surfaces: on floor and foam with eyes open and closed and on the compliant side of a Both Sides Up (BOSU) ball with eyes open. Complexity index (CompI) was derived from MSE curves.

Results: Repeated measures analysis of variance across standing conditions showed a statistically significant effect of condition (p?<?0.001) in both the anterior–posterior and medio-lateral directions for both CompI and VRMS. In the medio-lateral direction there was a gradual increase in CompI and VRMS with increased standing challenge. In the anterior–posterior direction, VRMS showed a gradual increase whereas CompI showed significant differences between the BOSU and all other conditions. CompI was moderately and significantly correlated with VRMS.

Conclusions: Both nonlinear and traditional measures of postural control were sensitive to the task and increased with increasing difficulty of standing balance tasks in healthy young adults.     

Physiological complexity and system adaptability: evidence from postural control dynamics of older adults

The degree of multiscale complexity in human behavioral regulation, such as that required for postural control, appears to decrease with advanced aging or disease. To help delineate causes and functional consequences of complexity loss, we examined the effects of visual and somatosensory impairment on the complexity of postural sway during quiet standing and its relationship to postural adaptation to cognitive dual tasking. Participants of the MOBILIZE Boston Study were classified into mutually exclusive groups: controls [intact vision and foot somatosensation, n = 299, 76 ± 5 (SD) yr old], visual impairment only (<20/40 vision, n = 81, 77 ± 4 yr old), somatosensory impairment only (inability to perceive 5.07 monofilament on plantar halluxes, n = 48, 80 ± 5 yr old), and combined impairments (n = 25, 80 ± 4 yr old). Postural sway (i.e., center-of-pressure) dynamics were assessed during quiet standing and cognitive dual tasking, and a complexity index was quantified using multiscale entropy analysis. Postural sway speed and area, which did not correlate with complexity, were also computed. During quiet standing, the complexity index (mean ± SD) was highest in controls (9.5 ± 1.2) and successively lower in the visual (9.1 ± 1.1), somatosensory (8.6 ± 1.6), and combined (7.8 ± 1.3) impairment groups (P = 0.001). Dual tasking resulted in increased sway speed and area but reduced complexity (P < 0.01). Lower complexity during quiet standing correlated with greater absolute (R = -0.34, P = 0.002) and percent (R = -0.45, P < 0.001) increases in postural sway speed from quiet standing to dual-tasking conditions. Sensory impairments contributed to decreased postural sway complexity, which reflected reduced adaptive capacity of the postural control system. Relatively low baseline complexity may, therefore, indicate control systems that are more vulnerable to cognitive and other stressors.     

Large postural fluctuations but unchanged postural sway dynamics during tiptoe standing compared to quiet standing

The purpose of this study was to detect the characteristics of center of pressure (COP) movement during tiptoe standing (TS) compared to quiet standing (QS). Eight healthy subjects were asked to perform QS and TS on a force platform. During standing, surface electromyograms (EMGs) were recorded from the soleus (SOL), flexor hallucis brevis (FHB), medial gastrocnemius (MG), lateral gastrocnemius (LG), and tibialis anterior (TA) muscles. The path length and rectangular area of the COP trajectory were significantly larger during TS than during QS. In contrast, irrespective of standing condition, the scaling coefficients in the short and long regions were above and below 0.5, respectively. The coherence spectrum between the COP and EMG from the SOL and FHB muscles was statistically significant during TS at frequencies up to 17 Hz, while that for the QS was only significant below 1 Hz. In conclusion, the control of COP movement during TS was similar to that during QS despite large COP fluctuations during TS. Our results suggest that unstable posture during TS is compensated for by the activities of the SOL and FHB muscles, which enhance postural control.     

Static Postural Stability in Women during and after Pregnancy: A Prospective Longitudinal Study

This longitudinal study aimed to compare static postural stability in women between early pregnancy, advanced pregnancy, and at 2 and 6 months postpartum. Forty-five pregnant women were enrolled and 31 completed the protocol. Data were collected at 7–16 and 34–39 weeks gestation, and at 6–10 and 26–30 weeks postpartum. For each subject, the center of foot pressure path length and mean velocity (with directional subcomponents) were computed from 30-s long quiet-standing trials on a stationary force plate with eyes open or closed. The body mass, stance width, and sleep duration within 24 h before testing were also recorded. Static postural stability was not different between pregnancy and postpartum, except for the anterior posterior sway tested in the eyes-closed condition, which was significantly increased in late pregnancy compared to that at 2 and 6 months postpartum. Pregnant/postpartum women’s body mass weakly positively correlated with anterior-posterior sway in the eyes-closed condition and their stance width weakly positively correlated with the anterior-posterior sway in the eyes-open condition. No effect of sleep duration on postural sway was found. Our findings indicate that under visual deprivation conditions women in advanced pregnancy may have decreased static stability compared to their non-pregnant state.     

Visual and proprioceptive contributions to postural control of upright stance in unilateral vestibulopathy

Preserving upright stance requires central integration of the sensory systems and appropriate motor output from the neuromuscular system to keep the centre of pressure (COP) within the base of support. Unilateral peripheral vestibular disorder (UPVD) causes diminished stance stability. The aim of this study was to determine the limits of stability and to examine the contribution of multiple sensory systems to upright standing in UPVD patients and healthy subjects. We hypothesized that closure of the eyes and Achilles tendon vibration during upright stance will augment the postural sway in UPVD patients more than in healthy subjects. Seventeen UPVD patients and 17 healthy subjects performed six tasks on a force plate: forwards and backwards leaning, to determine limits of stability, and upright standing with and without Achilles tendon vibration, each with eyes open and closed (with blackout glasses). The COP displacement of the patients was significantly greater in the vibration tasks than the controls and came closer to the posterior base of support boundary than the controls in all tasks. Achilles tendon vibration led to a distinctly more backward sway in both subject groups. Five of the patients could not complete the eyes closed with vibration task. Due to the greater reduction in stance stability when the proprioceptive, compared with the visual, sensory system was disturbed, we suggest that proprioception may be more important for maintaining upright stance than vision. UPVD patients, in particular, showed more difficulty in controlling postural stability in the posterior direction with visual and proprioceptive sensory disturbance.     

Characteristics of postural sway in older adults standing on a soft surface

Postural responses to challenging situations were studied in older adults as they stood on a foam surface. The experiment was designed to assess the relative contributions made by visual and somatosensory information to the correction of postural sway. Twenty-four subjects, aged 56-83, stood for 20 s on a 1) firm or 2) foam surface with 1) the eyes open or 2) the eyes closed. Centre-of-pressure trajectories under the subjects' feet were measured by using a force platform. A repeated-measure two-way MANCOVA (two surfaces vs. two vision conditions) showed a significant main effect for the surface, but not for the vision. No covariate effect for age was found. Anterior-posterior sway increased in the subjects who were merely standing on the foam surface independent of the vision condition. Medial-lateral sway dramatically increased if the subjects stood on the foam surface with their eyes closed, but not if they stood with their eyes open. These results indicate that older adults rely more on visual information to correct mediolateral postural sway. It appears that the deterioration in visual acuity that occurs with aging may increase the risk of sideway falls, particularly in challenging situations, e.g., when standing on irregular or soft surfaces.     

Time-to-boundary measures of postural control during single leg quiet standing

A novel approach to quantifying postural stability in single leg stance is assessment of time-to-boundary (TTB) of center of pressure (COP) excursions. TTB measures estimate the time required for the COP to reach the boundary of the base of support if it were to continue on its instantaneous trajectory and velocity, thus quantifying the spatiotemporal characteristics of postural control. Our purposes were to examine: (a) the intrasession reliability of TTB and traditional COP-based measures of postural control, and (b) the correlations between these measures. Twenty-four young women completed three 10-second trials of single-limb quiet standing on each limb. Traditional measures included mean velocity, standard deviation, and range of mediolateral (ML) and anterior-posterior (AP) COP excursions. TTB variables were the absolute minimum, mean of minimum samples, and standard deviation of minimum samples in the ML and AP directions. The intrasession reliability of TTB measures was comparable to traditional COP based measures. Correlations between TTB and traditional COP based measures were weaker than those within each category of measures, indicating that TTB measures capture different aspects of postural control than traditional measures. TTB measures provide a unique method of assessing spatiotemporal characteristics of postural control during single limb stance.     

Vertical heterophoria and postural control in nonspecific chronic low back pain

The purpose of this study was to test postural control during quiet standing in nonspecific chronic low back pain (LBP) subjects with vertical heterophoria (VH) before and after cancellation of VH; also to compare with healthy subjects with, and without VH. Fourteen subjects with LBP took part in this study. The postural performance was measured through the center of pressure displacements with a force platform while the subjects fixated on a target placed at either 40 or 200 cm, before and after VH cancellation with an appropriate prism. Their postural performance was compared to that of 14 healthy subjects with VH and 12 without VH (i.e. vertical orthophoria) studied previously in similar conditions. For LBP subjects, cancellation of VH with a prism improved postural performance. With respect to control subjects (with or without VH), the variance of speed of the center of pressure was higher, suggesting more energy was needed to stabilize their posture in quiet upright stance. Similarly to controls, LBP subjects showed higher postural sway when they were looking at a target at a far distance than at a close distance. The most important finding is that LBP subjects with VH can improve their performance after prism-cancellation of their VH. We suggest that VH reflects mild conflict between sensory and motor inputs involved in postural control i.e. a non optimal integration of the various signals. This could affect the performance of postural control and perhaps lead to pain. Nonspecific chronic back pain may results from such prolonged conflict.     

The spectral content of postural sway during quiet stance: Influences of age, vision and somatosensory inputs

Maintenance of human upright stance requires the acquisition and integration of sensory inputs. Conventional measures of sway have had success in identifying age- and some disease-related changes, but remain unable to address the complexities and dynamics associated with postural control. We investigated the effects of vision, surface compliance, age, and gender on the spectral content of center of pressure (COP) time series. Sixteen healthy young (age 18-24) and older participants (age 55-65) performed trials of quiet, upright stance under different vision (eyes open vs. closed) and surface (hard vs. compliant) conditions. Spectral analyses were conducted to describe COP mean normalized power in discretized bands. Effects of the two sensory modalities and age were distinct in the antero-posterior and medio-lateral directions, and a reorganization of spectral content was evident with increasing task difficulty (eyes open vs. closed and hard vs. compliant surface) and among older adults. These results indicate that vision and surface compliance are predominantly associated with responses from musculature associated with antero-posterior and medio-lateral directions of sway, respectively. Finally, distinguishing between the contributions of different afferent systems to the postural control system using the spectral content of sway bi-directionally may help in diagnosing individuals with balance impairments.     

Difference in Postural Control during Quiet Standing between Young Children and Adults: Assessment with Center of Mass Acceleration

The development of upright postural control has often been investigated using time series of center of foot pressure (COP), which is proportional to the ankle joint torque (i.e., the motor output of a single joint). However, the center of body mass acceleration (COM_acc), which can reflect joint motions throughout the body as well as multi-joint coordination, is useful for the assessment of the postural control strategy at the whole-body level. The purpose of the present study was to investigate children’s postural control during quiet standing by using the COM_acc. Ten healthy children and 15 healthy young adults were instructed to stand upright quietly on a force platform with their eyes open or closed. The COM_acc as well as the COP in the anterior–posterior direction was obtained from ground reaction force measurement. We found that both the COM_acc and COP could clearly distinguish the difference between age groups and visual conditions. We also found that the sway frequency of COM_acc in children was higher than that in adults, for which differences in biomechanical and/or neural factors between age groups may be responsible. Our results imply that the COM_acc can be an alternative force platform measure for assessing developmental changes in upright postural control.     

Responsiveness of the H reflex to loading and posture in patients following stroke

The objective of the research was to examine the effects of loading and posture on motoneuronal excitability of the triceps surae (TS) for patients with hemiplegia. Twelve healthy subjects and 12 patient subjects with post-stroke hemiparesis (onset period: 3–60 months) were enrolled in this study. The subjects were instructed to remain in quiet sitting with the test knee straight and three standing conditions of different superincumbent loads by shifting body weight to the test leg (10%, 50%, and 90% of body weight), while the H reflexes and M waves of the TS were measured. The results clearly indicated that H reflex amplitudes were not affected by different loading conditions in standing for both healthy subjects and patients who had a previous stroke. In addition, the H reflex amplitude in quiet standing for healthy subjects was significantly downward modulated relative to that in relaxed sitting with the test knee straight, but this posturally driven modulation was impaired in patients following stroke. Current electrophysiological findings imply that body weight as a means for rehabilitation facilitation had little immediate effect on paretic TS, and absence in postural gating of reflex excitability appeared to be an incentive for postural instability resulting from post-stroke hemiparesis.