Lipid interaction of diphtheria toxin and mutants with altered fragment B. 1. Liposome aggregation and fusion

The interaction of diphtheria toxin and its cross-reacting mutants crm 45,228 and 1001 with small unilamellar vesicles has been followed by a turbidity assay, electron microscopy, fluorescence energy transfer and membrane permeability. All toxins at pH lower than 6 induce the aggregation and fusion of liposomes containing negatively charged phospholipids; crm 45 and crm 1001 are less potent than diphtheria toxin. Isolated diphtheria toxin fragment B is very effective while isolated fragment A is ineffective. Liposome fusion induced by the toxins at low pH occurs without release of the internal content implying that fusion does not involve vesicle breakage and resealing. The pH dependence of the membrane interaction of diphtheria toxin monitored by turbidity is in close agreement with that monitored by fluorescence energy transfer. It shows that diphtheria toxin can alter the lipid bilayer structure in the pH interval 5-6. This pH range occurs in endosomes and suggests that histidyl and carboxyl residues are likely to be involved in the conformational change of diphtheria toxin triggered by acidic pH.     

Lipid interaction of diphtheria toxin and mutants with altered fragment B. 2. Hydrophobic photolabelling and cell intoxication

The membrane insertion of diphtheria toxin and of its B chain mutants crm 45, crm 228 and crm 1001 has been followed by hydrophobic photolabelling with photoactivatable phosphatidylcholine analogues. It was found that diphtheria toxin binds to the lipid bilayer surface at neutral pH while at low pH both its A and B chains also interact with the hydrocarbon chains of phospholipids. The pH dependence of photolabelling of the two protomers is different: the pKa of fragment B is around 5.9 while that of fragment A is around 5.2. The latter value correlates with the pH of half-maximal intoxication of cells incubated with the toxin in acidic mediums. These results suggest that fragment B penetrates into the bilayer first and assists the insertion of fragment A and that the lipid insertion of fragment B is not the rate-controlling step in the process of membrane translocation of diphtheria toxin. crm 45 behaves as diphtheria toxin in the photolabelling assay but, nonetheless, it is found to be three orders of magnitude less toxic than diphtheria toxin on acid-treated cells, suggesting that the 12-kDa COOH-terminal segment of diphtheria toxin is important not only for its binding to the cell receptor but also for the membrane translocation of the toxin. It is suggested that crm 1001 is non-toxic because of a defect in its membrane translocation which occurs at a lower extent and at a lower pH than that of the native toxin; as a consequence crm 1001 may be unable to escape from the endosome lumen into the cytoplasm before the fusion of the endosome with lysosomes.     

The effect of high pH upon diphtheria toxin conformation and model membrane association: role of partial unfolding

Penetration of membranes by diphtheria toxin in vivo is at least partially triggered by a low pH-induced conformational change occurring within the lumen of an acidic organelle. In order to gain insight into the nature of this change the behavior of the toxin at high pH was characterized and compared to that previously determined at low pH. We find that near pH 10.5 a major conformational change occurs. This change is accompanied by a marked decrease in fluorescence intensity, a red shift in fluorescence emission maximum, and increased susceptibility of protein fluorescence to acrylamide quenching. Differential scanning calorimetry shows that the high pH conformational change involves a cooperative endothermic unfolding transition. These changes at high pH are very similar to those induced by low pH, supporting the conclusion that the changes at low pH also involve a denaturation-like process. In addition, at high pH the toxin gains the ability to bind to model membranes, again similar to its behavior at low pH. On the basis of these studies we conclude that exposure of hydrophobic sequences due to partial unfolding is one dominating component in inducing hydrophobic behavior at both high and low pH, but that at low pH Asp/Glu protonation also contributes to hydrophobicity.     

Involvement of denaturation-like changes in Pseudomonas exotoxin a hydrophobicity and membrane penetration determined by characterization of pH and thermal transitions. Roles of two distinct conformationally altered states

Previous investigators have shown that exotoxin A undergoes a conformational switch to a hydrophobic state at low pH. This change appears to play a role in exotoxin A entry into cells by facilitating its penetration of the membranes of acidic organelles. We have examined the effects of pH, temperature, and denaturants in order to define the role of conformational changes in membrane penetration by the exotoxin. We find that two distinct low pH conformations exist. An intermediate low pH state (LI) dominates at pH 3.7-5.4 and is distinguished by blue-shifted fluorescence and weak or no hydrophobicity. The second low pH state (LII) is dominant below pH 3.7 and is characterized by red shifted fluorescence and strong hydrophobicity. LI is a folded state as judged by its spectroscopic properties and the observation that it undergoes distinct and cooperative thermal and denaturant induced unfolding transitions. LII appears to be more like a denatured state, as it shows no cooperative thermal or denaturant induced transitions and has spectroscopic properties very similar to exotoxin A that has been thermally denatured at pH 7. Exotoxin A in the LII state strongly binds detergent micelles and binds and inserts into model membranes. Therefore, denaturation-like conformational changes appear to play an important role in membrane insertion. The pH of the transition to a membrane-inserting state is influenced by the composition of the model membranes and is close to pH 5 in the presence of vesicles containing a phosphatidylglycerol/phosphatidylcholine mixture. These vesicles probably promote formation of the LII state via mass action effects. The implication of these results for membrane penetration and translocation of proteins without apparent hydrophobic regions, such as exotoxin A, is discussed.     

Effect of pH on the conformation of diphtheria toxin and its implications for membrane penetration

The pH-triggered change in diphtheria toxin conformation and the physical properties of the toxin above and below the transition pH have been examined. Exposure to low pH (less than or equal to 5 at 23 degrees C, less than or equal to 5.3 at 37 degrees C) triggers a rapid (t1/2 less than 30 s) change in toxin conformation; the transition occurs over a narrow pH range (0.2 unit). Below the transition pH, buried tryptophans become exposed, and the toxin becomes hydrophobic, binding very tightly to detergent. Aggregation is observed at low pH, probably due to this extreme hydrophobicity. Circular dichroism and fluorescence properties show that the low-pH conformation is not extensively unfolded. Therefore, the toxin "opens" at low pH without becoming a random coil. The conformation change is partly irreversible, and the degree of irreversibility parallels the degree of aggregation. Reduction of the disulfide bonds does not increase hydrophobicity at neutral pH. Furthermore, none of the structural variants of toxin (monomer or dimer, bound to ApUp or free, and nicked between subunits or intact) are hydrophobic at neutral pH or differ in transition pH markedly. Therefore, these factors do not mimic the effect of low pH. These observations are consistent with a functional role for the pH-triggered changes during penetration of the membranes of acidic organelles. The toxin may have adapted a conformational change similar to partial denaturation for a critical role in function. The possible nature of the pH-sensitive interactions and the effects of aggregation are discussed briefly.     

The pH-dependent conformational change of diphtheria toxin

Labeling by a hydrophobic photoactivatable reagent and limited proteolysis have been used to study conformational changes of diphtheria toxin related to its pH-dependent membrane insertion and translocation. TID (3-(trifluoromethyl)-3-(m-[125I]iodophenyl)diazirine) labels diphtheria toxin at pH 5 much more efficiently than at pH 7, both in the presence and absence of lipid vesicles. In the absence of membranes, the extent of labeling is greater and the pH dependence is stronger. As analyzed on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels and by high pressure liquid chromatography, both the A- and B-subunits and most of the cyanogen bromide fragments of the toxin are labeled by TID at acid pH. The products of trypsin cleavage of diphtheria toxin at pH 5 are different from those seen at neutral pH. Trypsin-susceptible sites were identified by gel electrophoresis of the trypsin fragments, combined with electrophoresis and high pressure liquid chromatography of CNBr digests of trypsin-treated toxin. At neutral pH, the main sites of digestion are at the junction between the A- and B-fragments and near the NH2 terminus of the A-fragment. At pH 5.2, these sites are less efficiently cut, and new sites appear near the NH2 terminus of the B-fragment, in an amphipathic portion of the sequence. Thus, even in the absence of membranes, acid pH induces a significant conformational change in diphtheria toxin. This change involves burial of some previously accessible sites, exposure of previously inaccessible sites, and the formation of hydrophobic regions over an extensive portion of the polypeptide chain.     

Single mutation in the A domain of diphtheria toxin results in a protein with altered membrane insertion behavior

The insertion of the A domain of diphtheria toxin into model membranes has been shown to be both pH- and temperature-dependent (Hu and Holmes (1984) J. Biol. Chem. 259, 12226-12233). In this report, the insertion behavior of two mutant proteins of diphtheria toxin, CRM197 and CRM9, was studied and compared to that of wild-type toxin. Results indicated that both CRM197 and CRM9 resembled toxin with respect to the pH-dependence of binding to negatively-charged liposomes at room temperature. However, CRM197 differed from toxin with respect to both the pH- and temperature-dependence of fragment A insertion; fragment A197 inserts more readily into the bilayer at 0 degrees C and low pH or at neutral pH and room temperature than does wild type fragment A under these same conditions. This result indicates that the single amino acid substitution in the A domain of CRM197 facilitates entry of fragment A197 into the membrane, suggesting that CRM197 may be conformationally distinct from native toxin. In fact, the fluorescence spectra of CRM197 and wild-type toxin as well as their respective tryptic peptide patterns indicate that, at pH 7, CRM197 more closely resembles the acid form of wild-type toxin than the native form of toxin. These data suggest that CRM197 may be naturally in a more 'insertion-competent' conformation. In contrast, the mutation in the B domain of CRM9 which results in a 1000-fold decrease in binding affinity for plasma membrane receptors apparently does not cause a change in either the insertion of fragment A9 or the lipid-binding properties of CRM9 relative to toxin.     

Energetics of diphtheria toxin membrane insertion and translocation: calorimetric characterization of the acid pH induced transition

The pH and temperature stabilities of diphtheria toxin and its fragments have been studied by high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry. These studies demonstrate that the pH-induced conformational transition associated with the mechanism of membrane insertion and translocation of the toxin involves a massive unfolding of the toxin molecule. At physiological temperatures (37 degrees C), this process is centered at pH 4.7 at low ionic strength and at pH 5.4 in the presence of 0.2 M NaCl. At pH 8, the thermal unfolding of the nucleotide-bound toxin is centered at 58.2 degrees C whereas that of the nucleotide-free toxin is centered at 51.8 degrees C, indicating that nucleotide binding (ApUp) stabilizes the native conformation of the toxin. The unfolding profile of the toxin is consistent with two transitions most likely corresponding to the A fragment (Tm = 54.5 degrees C) and the B fragment (Tm = 58.4 degrees C), as inferred from experiments using the isolated A fragment. These two transitions are not independent, judging from the fact that the isolated A fragment unfolds at much lower temperatures (Tm = 44.2 degrees C) and that the B fragment is insoluble in aqueous solutions when separated from the A fragment. Interfragment association contributes an extra -2.6 kcal/mol to the free energy of stabilization of the A fragment. Whereas the unfolding of the entire toxin is irreversible, the unfolding of the A fragment is a reversible process. These findings provide a thermodynamic basis for the refolding of the A fragment after reexposure to neutral pH immediately following translocation across the lysosomal membrane.     

Interactions between diphtheria toxin entry and anion transport in Vero cells. IV. Evidence that entry of diphtheria toxin is dependent on efficient anion transport

Entry of prebound diphtheria toxin at low pH occurred rapidly in the presence of isotonic NaCl, NaBr, NaSCN, NaI, and NaNO3, but not in the presence of Na2SO4, 2-(N-morpholino)ethanesulfonic acid neutralized with Tris, or in buffer osmotically balanced with mannitol. SCN- was the most efficient anion to facilitate entry. Uptake studies with radioactively labeled anions showed that SCN- was transported into cells 3 times faster than Cl-, while the entry of SO2-4 occurred much more slowly. The anion transport inhibitors 4-acetamido-4'-isothiocyanostilbene-2,2'-disulfonic acid and piretanide inhibited entry at low pH even in the presence of permeant anions. When cells with bound toxin were exposed to low pH in the absence of permeant anions, then briefly exposed to neutral pH and subsequently exposed to pH 4.5 in the presence of isotonic NaCl, toxin entry was induced. The data indicate that efficient anion transport at the time of exposure to low pH is required for entry of surface-bound diphtheria toxin into the cytosol. Since insertion of diphtheria toxin into the membrane occurs even in the absence of permeant anions, the results indicate that low pH is required not only for insertion of fragment B into the membrane, but also for the subsequent entry of fragment A into the cytosol.     

Secondary structure of diphtheria toxin and its fragments interacting with acidic liposomes studied by polarized infrared spectroscopy

We used infrared attenuated total reflection spectroscopy to study the structure of diphtheria toxin (DT) and its fragments A, B, CB1, and CB4 as a function of the pH in the absence and in the presence of phospholipid vesicles. Binding of DT to asolectin or DL-alpha-dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine-DL-alpha-dipalmitoylphosphatidic acid liposomes at pH 7.3 results in a 10% increase in its alpha-helix content. At pH 4, in the presence of liposomes, the secondary structure of DT is characterized by the appearance of a beta-sheet structure with strengthened hydrogen bonds which did not exist before pH lowering. DT fragment B displays little conformational change upon pH lowering in the presence of liposomes. However, the alpha-helix content of CB1 increases by 10%, and polarization measurements indicate that the alpha-helices of CB1 at pH 4 are oriented parallel to the lipid acyl chains. On the other hand, the alpha-helix content of CB4 decreases dramatically while the low frequency beta-sheet content increases. Dichroism measurements demonstrate that this sheet lies close to a parallel to the bilayer surface. The fragment A of DT experiences a large conformational change upon pH lowering and binds to the liposome membrane even in the absence of DT fragment B. The conformational modification of DT fragment A is fully reversed when pH is brought back to 7.3.     

Requirement of specific receptors for efficient translocation of diphtheria toxin A fragment across the plasma membrane

The role of specific receptors in the translocation of diphtheria toxin A fragment to the cytosol and for the insertion of the B fragment into the cell membrane was studied. To induce nonspecific binding to cells, toxin was either added at low pH, or biotinylated toxin was added at neutral pH to cells that had been treated with avidin. In both cases large amounts of diphtheria toxin became associated with the cells, but there was no increase in the toxic effect. There was also no increase in the amount of A fragment that was translocated to the cytosol, as estimated from protection against externally added Pronase E. In cells where specific binding was abolished by treatment with 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol 13-acetate, trypsin, or 4,4'-diisothiocyano-2,2'-stilbenedisulfonic acid, unspecific binding did not induce intoxication or protection against protease. This was also the case in untreated L cells, which showed no specific binding of the toxin. When Vero cells with diphtheria toxin bound to specific receptors were exposed to low pH, the cells were permeabilized to K+, whereas this was not the case when the toxin was bound nonspecifically at low pH or via avidin-biotin. The data indicate that the cell-surface receptor for diphtheria toxin facilitates both insertion of the B fragment into the cell membrane and translocation of the A fragment to the cytosol.     

Tetanus toxin induces fusion and aggregation of lipid vesicles containing phosphatidylinositol at low pH

We report here on the ability of tetanus toxin to induce, at low pH, fusion and aggregation of lipid vesicles containing phosphatidylinositol. It has been shown that diphtheria toxin is internalized in acidic vacuoles (endosomes) and that the low endosomal pH could induce a protein conformational change responsible for the interaction with the endosomal membranes and the toxin translocation into the cytoplasm. The data here reported indicate that tetanus toxin might interact with lipid membrane in a similar way as diphtheria toxin suggesting for the two proteins an identical mechanism of entry into cells.     

Membrane interactions of diphtheria toxin analyzed using in vitro synthesized mutants.

We have developed a system to study the interactions of diphtheria toxin with the cell surface using non-toxic mutant proteins synthesized in vitro. Proteins obtained by N-terminal deletions containing the whole B fragment bound strongly to cells. Deletions extending into the B fragment did not yield an autonomous binding domain. Loss of only the N-terminal 3 kd of the B fragment significantly impaired the ability to recognize the receptor. This, together with previous reports that the C-terminal end of the B fragment is required for binding, suggests that both ends of the B fragment are necessary for receptor recognition. Receptor bound diphtheria toxin undergoes a conformational change at pH less than 5.3 that results in translocation of the A fragment to the cytosol and the appearance of a B fragment-derived 25 kd polypeptide (P25) resistant to externally applied protease. Only the B fragment was required for generation of P25. N-terminal deletions of 130 amino acids or more resulted in proteins that gave rise to P25 at higher pH than full length toxin. Furthermore, a second protease-inaccessible polypeptide of 18 kd (P18) was observed.     

Diphtheria toxin entry into cells is facilitated by low pH

At neutral pH, NH4Cl and chloroquine protected cells against diphtheria toxin. A brief exposure of the cells to low pH (4.5-5.5) at 37 degrees completely abolished this protection. When, to cells preincubated with diphtheria toxin and NH4Cl, neutralizing amounts of anti-diphtheria toxin were added before the pH was lowered, the toxic effect was considerably reduced, but it was not completely abolished. A much stronger toxic effect was seen when antibodies were added immediately after incubation at low pH. Upon a short incubation with diphtheria toxin at low pH, the rate of protein synthesis in the cells decreased much faster than when the normal pH was maintained. The data suggest that, at low pH, diphtheria toxin (or its A fragment) penetrates directly through the surface membrane of the cell. The possibility is discussed that, when the medium has a neutral pH, the entry of diphtheria toxin involves adsorptive endocytosis and reduction of the pH in the vesicles possibly by fusion with lysosomes. Low pH did not facilitate the entry of the closely related toxins abrin, ricin, and modeccin.     

Cell-mediated reduction of the interfragment disulfide in nicked diphtheria toxin. A new system to study toxin entry at low pH

When 125I-labeled nicked diphtheria toxin bound to Vero cells was exposed to pH less than 5.0, a small fraction was reduced to yield A- and B-fragments. The pH required for reduction correlates well with that required to induce intoxication, and the amount of A-fragment released was of the same order as that required to intoxicate the cells. Conditions that protect cells against intoxication, such as acidification of the cytosol, treatment with anion transport inhibitors, or treatment with anti-diphtheria toxin antibodies, prevented the reduction of the interfragment disulfide in cell-bound toxin. In vitro, thioredoxin reduced nicked diphtheria toxin only at pH 5.0 and lower, and the reduction was inhibited by anti-toxin antibodies. This indicates that a conformational change in the toxin, necessary for reduction by the thioredoxin system, is prevented by the antibodies. Reduction by glutathione and cysteine was most efficient at neutral pH and was not inhibited by anti-toxin. The results are consistent with the possibility that cell-mediated reduction of the interfragment disulfide is a measure of the entry of fragment A into the cytosol.     

Interaction of diphtheria toxin fragments A, B and protein crm 45 with liposomes

Diphtheria toxin, its fragments A, B and the protein serologically related to toxin, crm 45, have been studied for their hydrophobicity using the method of charge shift electrophoresis. These molecules were then assayed for liposome interaction. The results have shown that the diphtheria toxin B fragment behaves as an amphiphatic protein because it contains a hydrophobic domain located in that portion of the B chain which remains in protein crm 45. Toxin fragment A is hydrophilic. Incubation of protein crm 45 or toxin fragment B with preformed liposomes leads to association of these proteins with lipid vesicles. Fragment A does not interact with liposomes. Binding of protein crm 45 with lipid vesicles is dependent on time and temperature. Protein crm 45 is unidirectionally associated with liposomes, its enzymic fragment A directed outside the liposome. Fragment B or protein crm 45, upon binding with liposomes, does not affect the permeability of the vesicles.     

Requirements for the translocation of diphtheria toxin fragment A across lipid membranes

The translocation of the enzymatic moiety of diphtheria toxin, fragment A, across the membranes of pure lipid vesicles was demonstrated. A new assay, which employed vesicles made to contain radiolabeled NAD and elongation factor-2, was used to measure the appearance of the enzymatic activity of the A fragment in the vesicles. When the vesicles were exposed to a low-pH medium in the presence of diphtheria toxin, small molecules, such as NAD, escaped into the extravesicular medium, whereas large molecules mostly remained inside the vesicles. The vesicle-entrapped elongation factor-2 became ADP-ribosylated, indicating the entry of fragment A into the vesicle. The translocation of the A fragment depended upon the pH of the medium, being negligible at pH greater than 7.0 and maximal at pH 4.5. The entire toxin molecule was needed for function; neither the A fragment nor the B fragment alone was able to translocate itself across and react with the sequestered substrates. After exposure of the toxin to low pH, the entry of the A fragment was rapid, being virtually complete within 2-3 min at pH 5.5, and within 1 min at pH 4.7. Translocation occurred in the absence of any protein in the vesicle membrane. These results are consistent with the notion that the diphtheria toxin molecule enters the cytoplasm of a cell by escaping from an acidic compartment such as an endocytic vesicle.     

Transport of diphtheria toxin fragment A across mammalian cell membranes.

The role of the hydrophobic region of diphtheria toxin B moiety in fragment A membrane traversal has been studied using crm45. This molecule, a serologically related diphtheria toxin protein, contains a normal enzymic fragment A and the hydrophobic domain of the toxin B chain but lacks a C-terminal polypeptide needed for specific cell binding. Relatively high concentrations of crm45 are required to inhibit protein synthesis in cells however, after the loss of its hydrophobic region crm45, which still contains an active fragment A, becomes almost non-toxic. It seems thus that the non-polar peptide found in crm45 or toxin facilitates the transport of the hydrophilic fragment A across the plasma membrane.     

Linked thermal and solute perturbation analysis of cooperative domain interactions in proteins. Structural stability of diphtheria toxin

The temperature and guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) dependence of the structural stability of diphtheria toxin has been investigated by high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetry. In 50 mM phosphate buffer at pH 8.0 and in the absence of GuHCl, the thermal unfolding of diphtheria toxin is characterized by a transition temperature (Tm) of 54.9 degrees C, a calorimetric enthalpy change (delta H) of 295 kcal/mol, and a van't Hoff to calorimetric enthalpy ratio of 0.57. Increasing the GuHCl concentration lowers the transition temperature and the calorimetric enthalpy change. At the same time, the van't Hoff to calorimetric enthalpy ratio increases until it reaches a value of 1 at 0.3 M GuHCl and remains constant thereafter. At low GuHCl concentrations (0-0.3 M), the thermal unfolding of diphtheria toxin is characterized by the presence of two transitions corresponding to the A and B domains of the protein. At higher GuHCl concentrations (0.3-1 M), the A domain is unfolded at all temperatures, and only one transition corresponding to the B domain is observed. Under these conditions, the most stable protein conformation at low temperatures is a partially folded state in which the A domain is unfolded and the B domain folded. A general model that explicitly considers the energetics of domain interactions has been developed in order to account for the stability and cooperative behavior of diphtheria toxin. It is shown that this cooperative domain interaction model correctly accounts for the temperature location as well as the shape and area of the calorimetric curves. Under physiological conditions, domain-domain interactions account for most of the structural stability of the A domain.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Entry of diphtheria toxin into cells: possible existence of cellular factor(s) for entry of diphtheria toxin into cells was studied in somatic cell hybrids and hybrid toxins

Ehrlich ascites tumor cells were found to be very insensitive to diphtheria toxin. We formed 37 hybrids from Ehrlich tumor cells and diphtheria toxin-sensitive human fibroblasts. The effects of diphtheria toxin on protein synthesis in those hybrids were examined. The hybrids were divided into three groups on the basis of toxin sensitivity. Group A hybrids were as sensitive to diphtheria toxin as human fibroblasts, Group C were as resistant as Ehrlich tumor cells, and Group B had intermediate sensitivity. Group A hybrids had diphtheria toxin-binding sites but Group B and C had no detectable binding sites. Elongation factor-2 of all the hybrids was susceptible to ADP-ribosylation by fragment A of diphtheria toxin. Cells of Group A and B became more sensitive to CRM 45 (cross-reacting material 45 of diphtheria toxin) after they were exposed to low pH (pH = 4.5). The resistance of Group C to CRM 45 was not affected by the same treatment. Group A and B hybrids and human fibroblasts had similar sensitivities to a hybrid toxin composed of wheat germ agglutinin and fragment A of diphtheria toxin, but Group C and Ehrlich tumor cells were resistant to this hybrid toxin. All the hybrids and Ehrlich tumor cells were more sensitive to a hybrid toxin composed of wheat germ agglutinin and subunit A of ricin than were human fibroblasts. On subcloning of Group B hybrids, one Group C hybrid was obtained, but no Group A hybrid. These facts suggest that Ehrlich ascites tumor cells differ from human fibroblasts in the expression of a factor(s) that is involved in entry of fragment A of diphtheria toxin into the cytoplasm after the toxin binds to its surface receptors.