Solution-phase library generation: methods and applications in drug discovery

Solution-phase high throughput synthesis has emerged as a powerful method for the rapid generation of chemical libraries. The success of this approach is largely due to the development of novel synthetic methodologies that expedite the preparation of compounds. Several isolation/purification techniques have also been developed to eliminate the time-consuming purification procedures often associated with solution-phase chemistry. These methods are amenable to parallel synthesis and combinatorial strategies and can be fully automated. In addition, the compound libraries generated using solution-phase high throughput synthesis have been used to accelerate both lead identification and lead optimization programs at various companies.     

Polymer-assisted solution-phase (PASP) parallel synthesis of an alpha-ketothiazole library as tissue factor VIIa inhibitors

A solution-phase synthesis of an alpha-ketothiazole library of the general form D-Phe-L-AA-L-Arg-alpha-ketothiazole is described. The five-step synthesis is accomplished using a combination of polymeric reagents and polymer-assisted solution-phase purification protocols, including reactant-sequestering resins, reagent-sequestering resins, and tagged reagents. The multi-step synthesis affords the desired alpha-ketothiazole products in excellent purities and yields. A variety of L-amino acid inputs were used to probe the S2 pocket of the tissue factor (TF) VIIa enzyme to influence both potency and selectivity. An X-ray crystal structure of compound 10e bound to the TF/VIIa complex was obtained that explains the observed selectivity. The alpha-ketothiazoles were found to be potent, reversible-covalent inhibitors of tissue factor VIIa, with some analogues demonstrating selectivity versus thrombin.     

Recent applications of polymer-supported reagents and scavengers in combinatorial, parallel, or multistep synthesis

There has been a wealth of recent reports concerning support-bound reagents and scavengers in the solution-phase synthesis of compound libraries and natural products. Important advances in 1999 include the continued development and use of novel reagents for heterocycle synthesis, the increased use of catch-and-release purification, and the development of increasingly sophisticated techniques to allow sequestering of many types of impurities from desired compounds. These techniques have all been combined to enable the complicated multistep synthesis of natural products and of libraries of novel drug-like molecules, without conventional purification.     

Oligonucleotide synthesis using ionic liquids as soluble supports

The continuing evolution of the methodology for the solution-phase synthesis of oligonucleotides using soluble ionic tags as handles for easy purification is described. This methodology may provide a more cost efficient route for the large scale synthesis of oligonucleotides.     

Polymer-assisted solution-phase (PASP) library synthesis of alpha-ketoamides

A parallel solution-phase library synthesis of alpha-ketoamides is described. The two-step library synthesis is accomplished using polymer-assisted solution-phase (PASP) synthesis techniques. This high-yielding, multi-step sequence utilizes sequestering resins for the removal of reactants, reactant by-products, and tagged reagents. The first step of the library synthesis utilizes PASP resins to mediate the amide coupling of an alpha-hydroxy acid with an amine. The second step uses PASP resins for the periodinane oxidation of the alpha-hydroxy acid to an alpha-ketoamide leaving highly pure products after simple filtration and evaporation.     

Combinatorial carbohydrate chemistry

The application of combinatorial chemistry to the synthesis of carbohydrate-based compound collections has received increased attention in recent years. New strategies for the solution-phase synthesis of oligosaccharide libraries have been reported, and the use of monosaccharides as scaffolds in the generation of combinatorial libraries has been described. Novel approaches to the assembly of carbohydrate-based antibiotics, such as aminoglycoside analogs and vancomycin derivatives, have also been disclosed.     

Structure-based drug design of pyrazinone antithrombotics as selective inhibitors of the tissue factor VIIa complex

Structure-based drug design coupled with polymer-assisted solution-phase library synthesis was utilized to develop a series of pyrazinone inhibitors of the tissue factor/Factor VIIa complex. The crystal structure of a tri-peptide ketothiazole complexed with TF/VIIa was utilized in a docking experiment that identified a benzyl-substituted pyrazinone as a P(2) surrogate for the tri-peptide. A 5-step PASP library synthesis of these aryl-substituted pyrazinones was developed. The sequence allows for attachment of a variety of P(1) and P(3) moieties, which led to synthesis pyrazinone 23. Compound 23 exhibited 16 nM IC(50) against TF/VIIa with >6250x selectivity versus Factor Xa and thrombin. This potent and highly selective inhibitor of TF/VIIa was chosen for pre-clinical intravenous proof-of-concept studies to demonstrate the separation between antithrombotic efficacy and bleeding side effects in a primate model of thrombosis.     

Combinatorial synthetic design.

The range and diversity of solid-phase synthetic methodology continues to develop very rapidly, allowing the generation of previously inaccessible compound libraries. The design of such libraries requires consideration of linkage strategies, newly developed solid-phase reactions and emerging solution-phase processes.     

Are porphyrin mixtures favorable photodynamic anticancer drugs? A model study with combinatorial libraries of tetraphenylporphyrins

Reported here is the preparation of tetraphenylporphyrin libraries via efficient combinatorial solution-phase syntheses, their purification, and preliminary results from a bioorganic study on their uptake in liposome membranes. Libraries with up to 666 components were prepared with substituents including Br, CF3, Cl, CN, CO2Me, Et, F, OAc, and Ph. Further, a first example for the synthesis of more diverse libraries via a "latent libraries" approach is presented. This involves masking polar groups with lipophilic protecting groups. After purification of the latent library, the masking protecting groups are removed in a quantitative reaction that produces the library compounds as the only non-volatile components. Libraries were characterized by laser desorption time-of-flight mass spectrometry, NMR, and UV-vis spectroscopy. In vitro uptake into membranes of small sonicated liposomes was measured, both in terms of total porphyrin incorporation and in terms of structure-incorporation relationships. The latter were determined from isotopically-resolved laser-desorption mass spectra under conditions that yield quantitative results. Smaller libraries showed increased uptake of porphyrins bearing OH and CF3 substituents and lower uptake of ester-, alkyl-, and halide-bearing porphyrins. This structure-dependent selectivity disappears for larger libraries, however, where uniformly high uptake is observed, i.e., at a constant lipid:porphyrin ratio the total porphyrin incorporation is higher for libraries than for single compounds of similar polarity. We propose that the decreased concentration of individual compounds in large libraries is responsible for this effect. Membrane incorporation has previously been shown to correlate with photodynamic activity in vitro and in vivo.16 Therefore, these results may help to explain why photodynamic therapy of tumors, a modern anti-cancer treatment modality, is successfully performed with a complex mixture of porphyrins.     

Assessment of solution-phase positional scanning libraries based on distamycin A for the discovery of new DNA binding agents

The solution-phase synthesis of two 1000-membered positional scanning libraries of distamycin A analogues is described enlisting acid/base liquid-liquid extractions for isolation and purification of all intermediates and final products. The results of their screening for functional activity (L1210 cytotoxic potency) and DNA binding affinity were compared with those derived from libraries containing the same compound members but prepared in a smaller 10-compound mixture format. The positional scanning libraries, which are substantially less demanding to prepare, allowed the accurate detection of the global observations and the clearly more potent activities, but more subtle discoveries and less distinguishable activities were not detected. This is a natural consequence of testing the larger 100-compound mixtures and the relative insensitivity of the assays to the contribution of any single, uniquely acting compound in the mixture. Thus, the disadvantages associated with the loss of some information contained within the library must be balanced against the advantages of the ease of library synthesis and judged in light of the library screening objectives.     

Combinatorial search of substituted beta-cyclodextrins for phosphatase-like activity.

Thirteen per-6-akylamino-6-deoxy-beta-cyclodextrin libraries (beta-CD libraries) were generated by a solution-phase combinatorial synthesis starting from per-6-iodo-6-deoxy-beta-CD and different combinations of eleven individual amine nucleophiles. Certain libraries showed the ability to hydrolyzep-nitrophenyl phosphate in the presence of Zn2+.     

Solid-phase/solution-phase combinatorial synthesis of neuroimmunophilin ligands

A novel solid-phase/solution-phase strategy for the synthesis of neuroimmunophilin ligands based on GPI 1046 was developed. The synthesis employs a solid-phase esterification strategy followed by a solution-phase pyruvic amide formation to produce multi-milligram quantities of discrete compounds for assay. The protocol was applied to a production library of 880 discrete compounds. A highlight of the strategy is an aqueous extractive purification of the final compounds using a novel liquid/ice extraction system developed for high throughput.     

Solid phase synthesis of a functionalized bis-peptide using "safety catch" methodology

In 1962, R.B. Merrifield published the first procedure using solid-phase peptide synthesis as a novel route to efficiently synthesize peptides. This technique quickly proved advantageous over its solution-phase predecessor in both time and labor. Improvements concerning the nature of solid support, the protecting groups employed and the coupling methods employed over the last five decades have only increased the usefulness of Merrifield's original system. Today, use of a Boc-based protection and base/nucleophile cleavable resin strategy or Fmoc-based protection and acidic cleavable resin strategy, pioneered by R.C. Sheppard, are most commonly used for the synthesis of peptides(1). Inspired by Merrifield's solid supported strategy, we have developed a Boc/tert-butyl solid-phase synthesis strategy for the assembly of functionalized bis-peptides(2), which is described herein. The use of solid-phase synthesis compared to solution-phase methodology is not only advantageous in both time and labor as described by Merrifield(1), but also allows greater ease in the synthesis of bis-peptide libraries. The synthesis that we demonstrate here incorporates a final cleavage stage that uses a two-step "safety catch" mechanism to release the functionalized bis-peptide from the resin by diketopiperazine formation. Bis-peptides are rigid, spiro-ladder oligomers of bis-amino acids that are able to position functionality in a predictable and designable way, controlled by the type and stereochemistry of the monomeric units and the connectivity between each monomer. Each bis-amino acid is a stereochemically pure, cyclic scaffold that contains two amino acids (a carboxylic acid with an α-amine)(3,4). Our laboratory is currently investigating the potential of functional bis-peptides across a wide variety of fields including catalysis, protein-protein interactions and nanomaterials.     

Insecticidal lead identification by screening benzopyrano[4,3-c] pyrazol-3(2H)-ones library constructed from multiple-parallel synthesis under microwave irradiation

A rapid library-generation via liquid-phase multiple-parallel synthesis of 2-(substituted)benzyl-1-benzopyrano[4,3-c]pyrazol-3(2H)-ones, bearing two points of diversity, under microwave irradiation was successfully performed using chromenone-3-carboxylic acids as starting materials. Compared to an identical library generated by conventional parallel synthesis, microwave-assisted parallel synthesis dramatically decreased reaction times from an average of 16 h to 13 min, and the yields of products and intermediates were improved in most cases. A bioassay indicated that the compounds of the library exhibited excellent insecticidal activity against T. cinnabarinus at the dosage of 250 mg L⁻¹, and some compounds still exhibited insecticidal activity when the dosage was reduced to 50 mg L⁻¹. This shows that 2-(substituted) benzyl-1-benzopyrano[4,3-c]pyrazol-3(2H)-ones might be used as lead structures for further optimization. To our knowledge, this is the first report about the application of solution-phase multiple-parallel synthesis under microwave irradiation to construct libraries of benzopyrano-[4,3-c]pyrazol-3(2H)-ones with insecticidal activity. The coupling of microwave technology with liquid-phase parallel synthesis constitutes a novel and particularly attractive avenue for the rapid generation of structurally diverse libraries for lead discovery.     

Recent developments and applications of liquid-phase strategies in organic synthesis.

Chemistry on soluble polymer supports, termed liquid-phase organic synthesis, is developing into an increasingly viable alternative or adjunct to the classical solid-phase approach across the broad spectrum of polymer-supported organic chemistry. Recent advances in the field include the use of soluble polymers in the combinatorial synthesis of peptide and small-molecule libraries, as catalyst and reagent supports, and as functionalized polymer-quench reagents for purifying solution-phase combinatorial libraries.     

Solution-phase synthesis of combinatorial libraries designed to modulate protein-protein or protein-DNA interactions

A short personal perspective on the development of an approach to the solution-phase synthesis of combinatorial libraries for modulating cellular signaling by inhibiting, promoting, or mimicking protein-protein or protein-DNA interactions is provided.     

Progress in the preparation of peptide aldehydes via polymer supported IBX oxidation and scavenging by threonyl resin.

Peptide aldehydes are of interest due to their inhibitory properties toward numerous classes of proteolytic enzymes such as caspases or the proteasome. A novel access to peptide aldehydes is described using a combination of solid phase peptide synthesis with polymer-assisted solution phase synthesis based on the oxidation of peptide alcohols with a mild and selective polymer-bound IBX derivative. The oxidation is followed by selective purification via scavenging the peptide aldehyde in a capture-release procedure using threonine attached to an aminomethyl resin. Peptide aldehydes are obtained in excellent purity and satisfying yield. The optical integrity of the C-terminal residue is conserved in a high degree. The procedures are compatible with the use of common side-chain protecting groups. The potential for using the method in parallel approaches is very advantageous. A small collection of new and known peptide aldehydes has been tested for inhibitory activity against caspases 1 and 3.     

A solid supported reagent for internucleoside H-phosphonate linkage formation

A fast and convenient procedure for synthesis of dinucleoside H-phosphonates is obtained through use of the novel polystyrene supported 5-carboxy-5-methyl-2-oxo-2-chloro-1,3,2-diaoxaphosphorinane reagent. Virtually quantitative H-phosphonate condensations are obtained leading to excellent isolatedyields and with only a simple filtration as the purification procedure. This provides for a convenient and high-yielding procedure that should be suited for solution-phase synthesis of oligonucleotides.     

A SOLID SUPPORTED REAGENT FOR INTERNUCLEOSIDE H-PHOSPHONATE LINKAGE FORMATION

A fast and convenient procedure for synthesis of dinucleoside H-phosphonates is obtained through use of the novel polystyrene supported 5-carboxy-5-methyl-2-oxo-2-chloro-1,3,2-dioxaphosphorinane reagent. Virtually quantitative H-phosphonate condensations are obtained leading to excellent isolated yields and with only a simple filtration as the purification procedure. This provides for a convenient and high-yielding procedure that should be suited for solution-phase synthesis of oligonucleotides.     

Synthesis and solid-phase purification of anthranilic sulfonamides as CCK-2 ligands

A novel strategy for the synthesis of cholecystokinin-2 receptor ligands was developed. The route employs a solution-phase synthesis of a series of anthranilic sulfonamides followed by a resin capture purification strategy to produce multi-milligram quantities of compounds for bioassay. The synthesis was used to produce >100 compounds containing various functional groups, highlighting the general applicability of this strategy and to address specific metabolism issues in our CCK-2 program.