Nucleotide analog interference mapping of the hairpin ribozyme: implications for secondary and tertiary structure formation.

The hairpin ribozyme is a small, naturally occurring RNA capable of folding into a distinct three-dimensional structure and catalyzing a specific phosphodiester transfer reaction. We have adapted a high throughput screening procedure entitled nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) to identify functional groups important for proper folding and catalysis of this ribozyme. A total of 18 phosphorothioate-tagged nucleotide analogs were used to determine the contribution made by individual ribose 2'-OH and purine functional groups to the hairpin ribozyme ligation reaction. Substitution with 2'-deoxy-nucleotide analogs disrupted activity at six sites within the ribozyme, and a unique interference pattern was observed at each of the 11 conserved purine nucleotides. In most cases where such information is available, the NAIM data agree with the previously reported single-site substitution results. The interference patterns are interpreted in comparison to the isolated loop A and loop B NMR structures and a model of the intact ribozyme. These data provide biochemical evidence in support of many, but not all, of the non-canonical base-pairs observed by NMR in each loop, and identify the functional groups most likely to participate in the tertiary interface between loop A and loop B. These groups include the 2'-OH groups of A10, G11, U12, C25, and A38, the exocyclic amine of G11, and the minor groove edge of A9 and A24. The data also predict non-A form sugar pucker geometry at U39 and U41. Based upon these results, a revised model for the loop A tertiary interaction with loop B is proposed. This work defines the chemical basis of purine nucleotide conservation in the hairpin ribozyme, and provides a basis for the design and interpretation of interference suppression experiments.     

The structure of the L3 loop from the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme: a syn cytidine.

The structure of the L3 central hairpin loop isolated from the antigenomic sequence of the hepatitis delta virus ribozyme with the P2 and P3 stems from the ribozyme stacked on top of the loop has been determined by NMR spectroscopy. The 26 nt stem-loop structure contains nine base pairs and a 7 nt loop (5'-UCCUCGC-3'). This hairpin loop is critical for efficient catalysis in the intact ribozyme. The structure was determined using homonuclear and heteronuclear NMR techniques on non-labeled and15N-labeled RNA oligonucleotides. The overall root mean square deviation for the structure was 1.15 A (+/- 0.28 A) for the loop and the closing C.G base pair and 0.90 A (+/- 0.18 A) for the loop and the closing C.G base pair but without the lone purine in the loop, which is not well defined in the structure. The structure indicates a U.C base pair between the nucleotides on the 5'- and 3'-ends of the loop. This base pair is formed with a single hydrogen bond involving the cytosine exocyclic amino proton and the carbonyl O4 of the uracil. The most unexpected finding in the loop is a syn cytidine. While not unprecedented, syn pyrimidines are highly unusual. This one can be confidently established by intranucleotide distances between the ribose and the base determined by NMR spectroscopy. A similar study of the structure of this loop showed a somewhat different three-dimensional structure. A discussion of differences in the two structures, as well as possible sites of interaction with the cleavage site, will be presented.     

Investigation of adenosine base ionization in the hairpin ribozyme by nucleotide analog interference mapping.

Tertiary structure in globular RNA folds can create local environments that lead to pKa perturbation of specific nucleotide functional groups. To assess the prevalence of functionally relevant adenosine-specific pKa perturbation in RNA structure, we have altered the nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) approach to include a series of a phosphorothioate-tagged adenosine analogs with shifted N1 pKa values. We have used these analogs to analyze the hairpin ribozyme, a small self-cleaving/ligating RNA catalyst that is proposed to employ a general acid-base reaction mechanism. A single adenosine (A10) within the ribozyme active site displayed an interference pattern consistent with a functionally significant base ionization. The exocyclic amino group of a second adenosine (A38) contributes substantially to hairpin catalysis, but ionization of the nucleotide does not appear to be important for activity. Within the hairpin ribozyme crystal structure, A10 and A38 line opposite edges of a solvent-excluded cavity adjacent to the 5'-OH nucleophile. The results are inconsistent with the model of ribozyme chemistry in which A38 acts as a general acid-base catalyst, and suggest that the hairpin ribozyme uses an alternative mechanism to achieve catalytic rate enhancement that utilizes functional groups within a solvent-excluded cleft in the ribozyme active site.     

NMR structure of the A730 loop of the Neurospora VS ribozyme: insights into the formation of the active site

The Neurospora VS ribozyme is a small nucleolytic ribozyme with unique primary, secondary and global tertiary structures, which displays mechanistic similarities to the hairpin ribozyme. Here, we determined the high-resolution NMR structure of a stem-loop VI fragment containing the A730 internal loop, which forms part of the active site. In the presence of magnesium ions, the A730 loop adopts a structure that is consistent with existing biochemical data and most likely reflects its conformation in the VS ribozyme prior to docking with the cleavage site internal loop. Interestingly, the A730 loop adopts an S-turn motif that is also present in loop B within the hairpin ribozyme active site. The S-turn appears necessary to expose the Watson-Crick edge of a catalytically important residue (A756) so that it can fulfill its role in catalysis. The A730 loop and the cleavage site loop of the VS ribozyme display structural similarities to internal loops found in the active site of the hairpin ribozyme. These similarities provided a rationale to build a model of the VS ribozyme active site based on the crystal structure of the hairpin ribozyme.     

Structure of the ribozyme substrate hairpin of Neurospora VS RNA: a close look at the cleavage site

The cleavage site of the Neurospora VS RNA ribozyme is located in a separate hairpin domain containing a hexanucleotide internal loop with an A-C mismatch and two adjacent G-A mismatches. The solution structure of the internal loop and helix la of the ribozyme substrate hairpin has been determined by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The 2 nt in the internal loop, flanking the cleavage site, a guanine and adenine, are involved in two sheared G.A base pairs similar to the magnesium ion-binding site of the hammerhead ribozyme. Adjacent to the tandem G.A base pairs, the adenine and cytidine, which are important for cleavage, form a noncanonical wobble A+-C base pair. The dynamic properties of the internal loop and details of the high-resolution structure support the view that the hairpin structure represents a ground state, which has to undergo a conformational change prior to cleavage. Results of chemical modification and mutagenesis data of the Neurospora VS RNA ribozyme can be explained in context with the present three-dimensional structure.     

Adenine protonation in domain B of the hairpin ribozyme

Protein enzymes often use ionizable side chains, such as histidine, for general acid-base catalysis because the imidazole pK(a) is near neutral pH. RNA enzymes, on the other hand, are comprised of nucleotides which do not have apparent pK(a) values near neutral pH. Nevertheless, it has been recently shown that cytidine and adenine protonation can play an important role in both nucleic acid structure and catalysis. We have employed heteronuclear NMR methods to determine the pK(a) values and time scales of chemical exchanges associated with adenine protonation within the catalytically essential B domain of the hairpin ribozyme. The large, adenine-rich internal loop of the B domain allows us to determine adenine pK(a) values for a variety of non-Watson-Crick base pairs. We find that adenines within the internal loop have pK(a) values ranging from 4.8 to 5.8, significantly higher than the free mononucleotide pK(a) of 3. 5. Adenine protonation results in potential charge stabilization, hydrogen bond formation, and stacking interactions that are expected to stabilize the internal loop structure at low pH. Fast proton exchange times of 10-50 micros were determined for the well-resolved adenines. These results suggest that shifted pK(a) values may be a common feature of adenines in non-Watson-Crick base pairs, and identify two adenines which may participate in hairpin ribozyme active site chemistry.     

Self-association of adenine-dependent hairpin ribozymes

Hairpin ribozymes are flexible molecules that catalyse reversible self-cleavage after the docking of two independently folded internal loops, A and B. The activities, self-association and structures in solution of two 85 base adenine-dependent hairpin ribozymes (ADHR1 and ADHR2) were studied by native gel electrophoresis, analytical centrifugation, and small angle neutron scattering. Bi-molecular RNA interactions such as linear–linear, loop–loop, loop–linear or kissing interactions have been found to be important in the control of various biological functions, and hairpin loops present rich potential for establishing both intra- and intermolecular interactions through standard Watson-Crick base pairing or non-canonical interactions. Similar results were obtained for ADHR1 and ADHR2. At room temperature, they indicated end-to-end self-association of the ribozymes in rod-like structures with a cross-section corresponding to two double strands side-by-side. Dimers, which predominate at low concentration (∼0.1 mg/ml), associate into longer rods, with increasing concentration (∼1 mg/ml). Above 65°C, the dimers and rods dissociated into compact monomers, with a radius of gyration similar to that of tRNA (about 70 bases). The dimers were non-active for catalysis, which suggests that dimer formation, probably by preventing the correct docking of loops A and B, could act as an inhibition mechanism for the regulation of hairpin ribozyme catalysis.     

Ionization of a critical adenosine residue in the neurospora Varkud Satellite ribozyme active site

The Varkud Satellite (VS) ribozyme catalyzes a site-specific self-cleavage reaction that generates 5'-OH and 2',3'-cyclic phosphate products. Other ribozymes that perform an equivalent reaction appear to employ ionization of an active site residue, either to neutralize the negatively charged transition state or to act as a general acid-base catalyst. To test for important base ionization events in the VS ribozyme ligation reaction, we performed nucleotide analogue interference mapping (NAIM) with a series of ionization-sensitive adenosine and cytidine analogues. A756, a catalytically critical residue located within the VS active site, was the only nucleotide throughout the VS ribozyme that displayed the pH-dependent interference pattern characteristic of functional base ionization. We observed unique rescue of 8-azaadenosine (pK(a) 2.2) and purine riboside (pK(a) 2.1) interference at A756 at reduced reaction pH, suggestive of an ionization-specific effect. These results are consistent with protonation and/or deprotonation of A756 playing a direct role in the VS ribozyme reaction mechanism. In addition, NAIM experiments identified several functional groups within the RNA that play important roles in ribozyme folding and/or catalysis. These include residues in helix II, helix VI (730 loop), the II-III-VI and III-IV-V helix junctions, and loop V.     

Solution structure of the loop B domain from the hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme is a small catalytic RNA with a unique two-domain structure. Here we present the solution structure of the loop B domain of the hairpin ribozyme, which contains most of the catalytically essential nucleotides. The 38-nucleotide domain contains a 16-nucleotide internal loop that forms one of the largest non-Watson-Crick segments of base pairing thus far determined by either NMR or crystallography. Since the solution structure of the smaller loop A domain has been previously solved, an NMR structure-based model of the 22,000 Mr hairpin ribozyme-substrate open complex emerges by joining the two domain structures. Strikingly, catalytically essential functional groups for the loop B domain are concentrated within an expanded minor groove, presenting a clear docking surface for the loop A domain.     

Three-dimensional motifs from the SCOR, structural classification of RNA database: extruded strands, base triples, tetraloops and U-turns

Release 2.0.1 of the Structural Classification of RNA (SCOR) database, http://scor.lbl.gov, contains a classification of the internal and hairpin loops in a comprehensive collection of 497 NMR and X-ray RNA structures. This report discusses findings of the classification that have not been reported previously. The SCOR database contains multiple examples of a newly described RNA motif, the extruded helical single strand. Internal loop base triples are classified in SCOR according to their three-dimensional context. These internal loop triples contain several examples of a frequently found motif, the minor groove AGC triple. SCOR also presents the predominant and alternate conformations of hairpin loops, as shown in the most well represented tetraloops, with consensus sequences GNRA, UNCG and ANYA. The ubiquity of the GNRA hairpin turn motif is illustrated by its presence in complex internal loops.     

Perturbation of DNA hairpins containing the EcoRI recognition site by hairpin loops of varying size and composition: physical (NMR and UV) and enzymatic (EcoRI) studies.

We have investigated loop-induced structural perturbation of the stem structure in hairpins d(GAATTCXnGAATTC) (X = A, T and n = 3, 4, 5 and 6) that contain an EcoRI restriction site in close proximity to the hairpin loop. Oligonucleotides containing either a T3 or a A3 loop were not hydrolyzed by the restriction enzyme and also showed only weak binding to EcoRI in the absence of the cofactor Mg2+. In contrast, hairpins with larger loops are hydrolyzed by the enzyme at the scission site next to the loop although the substrate with a A4 loop is significantly more resistant than the oligonucleotide containing a T4 loop. The hairpin structures with 3 loop residues were found to be thermally most stable while larger hairpin loops resulted in structures with lower melting temperatures. The T-loop hairpins are thermally more stable than the hairpins containing the same number of A residues in the loop. As judged from proton NMR spectroscopy and the thermodynamic data, the base pair closest to the hairpin loop did form in all cases studied. The hairpin loops did, however, affect the conformation of the stem structure of the hairpins. From 31P and 1H NMR spectroscopy we conclude that the perturbation of the stem structure is stronger for smaller hairpin loops and that the extent of the perturbation is limited to 2-3 base pairs for hairpins with T3 or A4 loops. Our results demonstrate that hairpin loops modulate the conformation of the stem residues close to the loop and that this in turn reduces the substrate activity for DNA sequence specific proteins.     

A new NMR solution structure of the SL1 HIV-1Lai loop-loop dimer

Dimerization of genomic RNA is directly related with the event of encapsidation and maturation of the virion. The initiating sequence of the dimerization is a short autocomplementary region in the hairpin loop SL1. We describe here a new solution structure of the RNA dimerization initiation site (DIS) of HIV-1_Lai. NMR pulsed field-gradient spin-echo techniques and multidimensional heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy indicate that this structure is formed by two hairpins linked by six Watson–Crick GC base pairs. Hinges between the stems and the loops are stabilized by intra and intermolecular interactions involving the A8, A9 and A16 adenines. The coaxial alignment of the three A-type helices present in the structure is supported by previous crystallography analysis but the A8 and A9 adenines are found in a bulged in position. These data suggest the existence of an equilibrium between bulged in and bulged out conformations in solution.     

RNA structure and dynamics: A base pairing perspective

RNA is now known to possess various structural, regulatory and enzymatic functions for survival of cellular organisms. Functional RNA structures are generally created by three-dimensional organization of small structural motifs, formed by base pairing between self-complementary sequences from different parts of the RNA chain. In addition to the canonical Watson–Crick or wobble base pairs, several non-canonical base pairs are found to be crucial to the structural organization of RNA molecules. They appear within different structural motifs and are found to stabilize the molecule through long-range intra-molecular interactions between basic structural motifs like double helices and loops. These base pairs also impart functional variation to the minor groove of A-form RNA helices, thus forming anchoring site for metabolites and ligands. Non-canonical base pairs are formed by edge-to-edge hydrogen bonding interactions between the bases. A large number of theoretical studies have been done to detect and analyze these non-canonical base pairs within crystal or NMR derived structures of different functional RNA. Theoretical studies of these isolated base pairs using ab initio quantum chemical methods as well as molecular dynamics simulations of larger fragments have also established that many of these non-canonical base pairs are as stable as the canonical Watson–Crick base pairs. This review focuses on the various structural aspects of non-canonical base pairs in the organization of RNA molecules and the possible applications of these base pairs in predicting RNA structures with more accuracy.     

A remarkably stable kissing-loop interaction defines substrate recognition by the Neurospora Varkud Satellite ribozyme

Kissing loops are tertiary structure elements that often play key roles in functional RNAs. In the Neurospora VS ribozyme, a kissing-loop interaction between the stem–loop I (SLI) substrate and stem–loop V (SLV) of the catalytic domain is known to play an important role in substrate recognition. In addition, this I/V kissing-loop interaction is associated with a helix shift in SLI that activates the substrate for catalysis. To better understand the role of this kissing-loop interaction in substrate recognition and activation by the VS ribozyme, we performed a thermodynamic characterization by isothermal titration calorimetry using isolated SLI and SLV stem–loops. We demonstrate that preshifted SLI variants have higher affinity for SLV than shiftable SLI variants, with an energetic cost of 1.8–3 kcal/mol for the helix shift in SLI. The affinity of the preshifted SLI for SLV is remarkably high, the interaction being more stable by 7–8 kcal/mol than predicted for a comparable duplex containing three Watson–Crick base pairs. The structural basis of this remarkable stability is discussed in light of previous NMR studies. Comparative thermodynamic studies reveal that kissing-loop complexes containing 6–7 Watson–Crick base pairs are as stable as predicted from comparable RNA duplexes; however, those with 2–3 Watson–Crick base pairs are more stable than predicted. Interestingly, the stability of SLI/ribozyme complexes is similar to that of SLI/SLV complexes. Thus, the I/V kissing loop interaction represents the predominant energetic contribution to substrate recognition by the trans-cleaving VS ribozyme.     

A GCUA tetranucleotide loop found in the poliovirus oriL by in vivo SELEX (un)expectedly forms a YNMG-like structure: Extending the YNMG family with GYYA

The cloverleaf structure in the 5'-untranslated region of enterovirus RNA that regulates viral RNA replication contains an evolutionarily conserved YNMG tetraloop closed by a Y-G base pair. This loop is believed to interact specifically with the viral protease 3C. To further characterize the specificity of this interaction, the tetraloop and two flanking base pairs of the poliovirus RNA were randomized, and viable viral clones were obtained using in vivo SELEX. Among many different mutants with the canonical YNMG sequences to be described elsewhere, a large-plaque-forming clone contained a deviating uGCUAg sequence. The NMR structure of a small hairpin capped with uGCUAg that we present here shows that the GCUA tetraloop adopts a novel fold, which is highly similar to that of the YNMG tetraloop with common stacking properties and hydrogen-bond interactions including an unusual syn conformation of the adenosine. Thermodynamic studies show moderate stabilities of hairpins with canonical YNMG and the novel GCUA loops, which, together with the similarity of spatial structures, illustrates that the tetraloop structure itself is crucial for the RNA-protein interaction required for the viral replication. A re-evaluation of the ribosomal secondary structure database reveals a hairpin containing a GCUA loop, which covaries with YNMG and is involved in a tertiary interaction, and in the 50S ribosomal subunit from Haloarcula marismortui the structurally comparable apex of stem-loop 35a is a recognition site for protein L2. These observations show a more general occurrence and importance of the so-far unrecognized GYYA hairpin loops.     

Non-Watson Crick base pairs might stabilize RNA structural motifs in ribozymes — a comparative study of group-I intron structures

In recent decades studies on RNA structure and function have gained significance due to discoveries on diversified functions of RNA. A common element for RNA secondary structure formed by series of non-Watson/Watson Crick base pairs, internal loops and pseudoknots have been the highlighting feature of recent structural determination of RNAs. The recent crystal structure of group-I introns has demonstrated that these might constitute RNA structural motifs in ribozymes, playing a crucial role in their enzymatic activity. To understand the functional significance of these non-canonical base pairs in catalytic RNA, we analysed the sequences of group-I introns from nuclear genes. The results suggest that they might form the building blocks of folded RNA motifs which are crucial to the catalytic activity of the ribozyme. The conservation of these, as observed from divergent organisms, argues for the presence of non-canonical base pairs as an important requisite for the structure and enzymatic property of ribozymes by enabling them to carry out functions such as replication, polymerase activity etc. in primordial conditions in the absence of proteins.     

NMR solution structure of the L 9.1a region of Tetrahymena group I intron.

The solution structure of 20 mer RNA contained of the loop 9.1a region of Tetrahymena group I intron was studied by NMR. This RNA oligomer has hairpin and duplex structures at high concentration (1 mM) of the sample even at low NaCl concentration (5 mM). In the hairpin structure, GC base pairs by the loop-loop interaction are formed. As study of NOESY measurements, and by the compared with the sequence, this loop region is presumed to interact with the loop 5c.     

Polycytosine regions contained in DNA hairpin loops interact via a four-stranded, parallel structure similar to the i-motif.

Thermal denaturation profiles of an oligodeoxynucleotide that forms a hairpin structure with a cytidine-rich loop show an unexpected transition at 60 degrees C at pH 5.0 but not at pH 8.0. Analytical ultracentrifugation shows that this transition reflects dimer formation via the interaction of loops from two molecules to form a novel structure termed the h-dimer. The dependence of this structure on low pH implies the formation of cytosine-protonated cytosine base pairs. NMR spectroscopy, thermal denaturation and ultraviolet absorption spectral analysis suggest a similarity to the i-motif structure recently proposed for the interaction of deoxycytidine oligomers. The use of hairpin loops to form i-motif-like structures may prove useful in searches for cognate proteins and possibly in the production of antibodies.     

Selective Pressures on RNA Hairpins In Vivo and In Vitro

Comparison of the most stable potential hairpins in the sequences of natural ribozymes with those in the randomized sequences has revealed that the hairpin loop energies are lower than expected by chance. Although these hairpins are not necessarily parts of functional structures, there is a selective pressure to diminish the destabilizing free energies of the hairpin loops. In contrast, no significant bias is observed in the stacking values of the most stable stems. In the ribozymes isolated in vitro the loops of potential hairpins are closer to random values, which can result in less efficient folding rates. Furthermore, the effects of kinetic traps seem to be more significant in the folding pathways of the in vitro isolates due to a potential to form stable stacks incompatible with the functional folds. Similarly to natural ribozyme sequences, the untranslated regions of viral RNAs also form hairpins with relatively low loop free energies. These evolutionary trends suggest ways for efficient engineering of improved RNA constructs on the basis of analysis of in vitro isolates and approaches for the search of regions coding for functional RNA structures in large genome sequences. Received: 12 January 2001 / Accepted: 21 May 2001     

The role of essential pyrimidines in the hairpin ribozyme-catalysed reaction.

The hairpin ribozyme is an example of a small catalytic RNA that catalyses the endonucleolytic transesterification of RNA in a highly sequence-specific manner. We have utilised chemical synthesis of RNA to create mutants of the hairpin ribozyme in which a nucleoside analogue replaces one of the essential pyrimidines in the ribozyme. Individual pyrimidine nucleosides were substituted by 4-thiouridine, O4-methyluridine, O2-methyluridine or 2-pyrimidinone-1-beta-d-riboside. To facilitate the synthesis of oligoribonucleotides containing 4-thiouridine, we have devised a new synthetic route to the key intermediate 5'-O-(4, 4'-dimethoxytrityl)-2'-O-tert-butyldimethylsilyl-S-cyanoethyl-4-thiou ridine. The ability of the modified ribozymes to support catalysis was studied and the steady-state kinetic parameters were determined for each mutant. The range of analogues used in this study allows the important functional groups of the essential pyrimidines to be identified. The results demonstrate that each pyrimidine (U41, U42 and C25) plays an important role in hairpin ribozyme catalysis. The findings are discussed in terms of the various models that have been proposed for loop B of the hairpin ribozyme.