Controlled 2D crystallization of membrane proteins using methyl-beta-cyclodextrin

High-resolution structural data of membrane proteins can be obtained by studying 2D crystals by electron crystallography. Finding the right conditions to produce these crystals is one of the major bottlenecks encountered in 2D crystallography. Many reviews address 2D crystallization techniques in attempts to provide guidelines for crystallographers. Several techniques including new approaches to remove detergent like the biobeads technique and the development of dedicated devices have been described (dialysis and dilution machines). In addition, 2D crystallization at interfaces has been studied, the most prominent method being the 2D crystallization at the lipid monolayer. A new approach based on detergent complexation by cyclodextrins is presented in this paper. To prove the ability of cyclodextrins to remove detergent from ternary mixtures (lipid, detergent and protein) in order to get 2D crystals, this method has been tested with OmpF, a typical beta-barrel protein, and with SoPIP2;1, a typical alpha-helical protein. Experiments over different time ranges were performed to analyze the kinetic effects of detergent removal with cyclodextrins on the formation of 2D crystals. The quality of the produced crystals was assessed with negative stain electron microscopy, cryo-electron microscopy and diffraction. Both proteins yielded crystals comparable in quality to previous crystallization reports.     

Two-dimensional crystallization of a membrane protein on a detergent-resistant lipid monolayer

Two-dimensional crystals of a membrane protein, the proton ATPase from plant plasma membranes, have been obtained by a new strategy based on the use of functionalized, fluorinated lipids spread at the air-water interface. Monolayers of the fluorinated lipids are stable even in the presence of high concentrations of various detergents as was established by ellipsometry measurements. A nickel functionalized fluorinated lipid was spread into a monolayer at the air-water interface. The overexpressed His-tagged ATPase solubilized by detergents was added to the subphase. 2D crystals of the membrane protein, embedded in a lipid bilayer, formed as the detergent was removed by adsorption. Electron microscopy indicated that the 2D crystals were single layers with dimensions of 10 microm or more. Image processing yielded a projection map at 9 A resolution, showing three well-separated domains of the membrane-embedded proton ATPase.     

Two-dimensional crystallization of the ryanodine receptor Ca2+ release channel on lipid membranes

The ryanodine receptor (RyR) is the largest known membrane protein with a total molecular mass of 2.3 x 10(3) kDa. Well ordered, two-dimensional (2D) crystals are an essential prerequisite to enable RyR structure determination by electron crystallography. Conventionally, the 2D crystallization of membrane proteins is based on a 'trial-and-error' strategy, which is both time-consuming and chance-directed. By adopting a new strategy that utilizes protein sequence information and predicted transmembrane topology, we successfully crystallized the RyR on positively charged lipid membranes. Image processing of negatively stained crystals reveals that they are well ordered, with diffraction spots of IQ < or = 4 extending to approximately 20 angstroms, the resolution attainable in negative stain. The RyR crystals obtained on the charged lipid membrane have characteristics consistent with 2D arrays that have been observed in native sarcoplasmic reticulum of muscle tissues. These crystals provide ideal materials to enable structural analysis of RyR by high-resolution electron crystallography. Moreover, the reconstituted native-like 2D array provides an ideal model system to gain structural insights into the mechanism of RyR-mediated Ca2+ signaling processes, in which the intrinsic ability of RyR oligomers to organize into a 2D array plays a crucial role.     

Three-dimensional organization of retroviral capsid proteins on a lipid monolayer

We have used a method for the two-dimensional crystallization of retroviral structural proteins to obtain a three-dimensional structure of negatively stained, membrane-bound, histidine-tagged Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV) capsid protein (his-MoCA) arrays. Tilted and untilted micrographs from crystals formed by purified his-MoCA proteins incubated beneath lipid monolayers containing nickel-chelating lipids were used in 3D reconstructions. The 2D crystals had unit cell dimensions of a=72.6 A, b=72.5 A and gamma=119.5 degrees, but appeared to have no intrinsic symmetry (p1) in 3D, in contrast to the trigonal or hexagonal appearance of their 2D projections. Membrane-bound his-MoCA proteins showed a strand-like organization, apparently with dimer building blocks. Membrane-proximal regions, or putative N-terminal domains (NTDs), dimerized with different partners than the membrane-distal putative C-terminal domains (CTDs). Evidence also suggests that CTDs can adopt alternate orientations relative to their NTDs, forming interstrand connections. Our results are consistent with helical-spiral models for retrovirus particle assembly, but are not easily reconcilable with icosahedral models.     

Two-dimensional crystallization of membrane proteins: the lipid layer strategy

Due to the difficulty to crystallize membrane proteins, there is a considerable interest to intensify research topics aimed at developing new methods of crystallization. In this context, the lipid layer crystallization at the air/water interface, used so far for soluble proteins, has been recently adapted successfully to produce two-dimensional (2D) crystals of membrane proteins, amenable to structural analysis by electron crystallography. Besides to represent a new alternative strategy, this approach gains the advantage to decrease significantly the amount of material needed in incubation trials, thus opening the field of crystallization to those membrane proteins difficult to surexpress and/or purify. The systematic studies that have been performed on different classes of membrane proteins are reviewed and the physico-chemical processes that lead to the production of 2D crystals are addressed. The different drawbacks, advantages and perspectives of this new strategy for providing structural information on membrane proteins are discussed.     

Two-dimensional crystallization on lipid layer: A successful approach for membrane proteins.

A considerable interest exists currently in designing innovative strategies to produce two-dimensional crystals of membrane proteins that are amenable to structural analysis by electron crystallography. We have developed a protocol for crystallizing membrane protein that is derived from the classical lipid-layer two-dimensional crystallization at the air/water interface used so far for soluble proteins. Lipid derivatized with a Ni(2+)-chelating head group provided a general approach to crystallizing histidine-tagged transmembrane proteins. The processes of protein binding and two-dimensional crystallization were analyzed by electron microscopy, using two prototypic membrane proteins: FhuA, a high-affinity receptor from the outer membrane of Escherichia coli, and the F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase from thermophilic Bacillus PS3. Conditions were found to avoid solubilization of the lipid layer by the detergent present with the purified membrane proteins and thus to allow binding of micellar proteins to the functionalized lipid head groups. After detergent removal using polystyrene beads, membrane sheets of several hundreds of square micrometers were reconstituted at the interface. High protein density in these membrane sheets allowed further formation of planar two-dimensional crystals. We believe that this strategy represents a new promising alternative to conventional dialysis methods for membrane protein 2D crystallization, with the additional advantage of necessitating little purified protein.     

Use of detergents in two-dimensional crystallization of membrane proteins

Structure determination at high resolution is actually a difficult challenge for membrane proteins and the number of membrane proteins that have been crystallized is still small and far behind that of soluble proteins. Because of their amphiphilic character, membrane proteins need to be isolated, purified and crystallized in detergent solutions. This makes it difficult to grow the well-ordered three-dimensional crystals that are required for high resolution structure analysis by X-ray crystallography. In this difficult context, growing crystals confined to two dimensions (2D crystals) and their structural analysis by electron crystallography has opened a new way to solve the structure of membrane proteins. However, 2D crystallization is one of the major bottlenecks in the structural studies of membrane proteins. Advances in our understanding of the interaction between proteins, lipids and detergents as well as development and improvement of new strategies will facilitate the success rate of 2D crystallization. This review deals with the various available strategies for obtaining 2D crystals from detergent-solubilized intrinsic membrane proteins. It gives an overview of the methods that have been applied and gives details and suggestions of the physical processes leading to the formation of the ordered arrays which may be of help for getting more proteins crystallized in a form suitable for high resolution structural analysis by electron crystallography.     

Membrane protein crystallization

The need for high-resolution structure information on membrane proteins is immediate and growing. Currently, the only reliable way to get it is crystallographically. The rate-limiting step from protein to structure is crystal production. An overview of the current ideas and experimental approaches prevailing in the area of membrane protein crystallization is presented. The long-established surfactant-based method has been reviewed extensively and is not examined in detail here. The focus instead is on the latest methods, all of which exploit the spontaneous self-assembling properties of lipids and detergent as vesicles (vesicle-fusion method), discoidal micelles (bicelle method), and liquid crystals or mesophases (in meso or cubic-phase method). In the belief that a knowledge of the underlying phase science is integral to understanding the molecular basis of these assorted crystallization strategies, the article begins with a brief primer on lipids, mesophases, and phase science, and the related issue of form and function as applied to lipids is addressed. The experimental challenges associated with and the solutions for procuring adequate amounts of homogeneous membrane proteins, or parts thereof, are examined. The cubic-phase method is described from the following perspectives: how it is done in practice, its general applicability and successes to date, and the nature of the mesophases integral to the process. Practical aspects of the method are examined with regard to salt, detergent, and screen solution effects; crystallization at low temperatures; tailoring the cubic phase to suit the target protein; different cubic-phase types; dealing with low-protein samples, colorless proteins, microcrystals, and radiation damage; transport within the cubic phase for drug design, cofactor retention, and phasing; using spectroscopy for quality control; harvesting crystals; and miniaturization and robotization for high-throughput screening. The section ends with a hypothesis for nucleation and growth of membrane protein crystals in meso. Thus far, the bicelle and vesicle-fusion methods have produced crystals of one membrane protein, bacteriorhodopsin. The experimental details of both methods are reviewed and their general applicability in the future is commented on. The three new methods are rationalized by analogy to crystallization in microgravity and with respect to epitaxy. A list of Web resources in the area of membrane protein crystallogenesis is included.     

Structure determination of secondary transport proteins by electron crystallography: two-dimensional crystallization of the betaine uptake system BetP

Structure determination at high resolution is still a challenge for membrane proteins in general, but in particular for secondary transporters due to their highly dynamic nature. X-ray structures of ten secondary transporters have recently been determined, but a thorough understanding of transport mechanisms necessitates structures at different functional states. Electron cryo-microscopy of two-dimensional (2D) crystals offers an alternative to obtain structural information at intermediate resolution. Electron crystallography is a sophisticated way to study proteins in a natural membrane environment and to track conformational changes in situ. Furthermore, basic interactions between protein and lipids can be investigated. Projection and 3-dimensional maps of six secondary transporters from different families have been determined by electron crystallography of 2D crystals at a resolution of 8 A and better. In this review, we give an overview about the principles of 2D crystallization, in particular of secondary transporters, and summarize the important steps successfully applied to establish and improve the 2D crystallization of the high-affinity glycine betaine uptake system from Corynebacterium glutamicum, BetP.     

Monitoring the stability of crosslinked protein crystals biotemplates: a feasibility study

Protein crystals, routinely prepared for the elucidation of protein 3D structures by X-ray crystallography, present an ordered and highly accurate 3D array of protein molecules. Inherent to the 3D arrangement of the protein molecules in the crystal is a complementary 3D array of voids made of interconnected cavities and exhibiting highly ordered porosity. The permeability of the porosity of chemically crosslinked enzyme protein crystals to low molecular weight solutes, was used for enzyme mediated organic synthesis and size exclusion chromatography. This permeability might be extended to explore new potential applications for protein crystals, for example, their use as bio-templates for the fabrication of novel, nano-structured composite materials. The quality of composites obtained from "filling" of the ordered voids in protein crystals and their potential applications will be strongly dependent upon an accurate preservation of the order in the original protein crystal 3D array during the "filling" process. Here we propose and demonstrate the feasibility of monitoring the changes in 3D order of the protein array by a step-by-step molecular level monitoring of a model system for hydrogel bio-templating by glutaraldehyde crosslinked lysozyme crystals. This monitoring is based on step-by-step comparative analysis of data obtained from (i) X-ray crystallography: resolution, unit cell dimensions and B-factor values and (ii) fluorescence decay kinetics of ultra-fast laser activated dye, impregnated within these crystals. Our results demonstrated feasibility of the proposed monitoring approach and confirmed that the stabilized protein crystal template retained its 3D structure throughout the process.     

The 2DX robot: A membrane protein 2D crystallization Swiss Army knife

Among the state-of-the-art techniques that provide experimental information at atomic scale for membrane proteins, electron crystallography, atomic force microscopy and solid state NMR make use of two-dimensional crystals. We present a cyclodextrin-driven method for detergent removal implemented in a fully automated robot. The kinetics of the reconstitution processes is precisely controlled, because the detergent complexation by cyclodextrin is of stoichiometric nature. The method requires smaller volumes and lower protein concentrations than established 2D crystallization methods, making it possible to explore more conditions with the same amount of protein. The method yielded highly ordered 2D crystals diffracting to high resolution from the pore-forming toxin Aeromonas hydrophila aerolysin (2.9 Å), the plant aquaporin SoPIP2;1 (3.1 Å) and the human aquaporin-8 (hAQP8; 3.3 Å). This new method outperforms traditional 2D crystallization approaches in terms of accuracy, flexibility, throughput, and allows the usage of detergents having low critical micelle concentration (CMC), which stabilize the structure of membrane proteins in solution.     

Helical crystallization on lipid nanotubes: streptavidin as a model protein

In this study, we use streptavidin (SA) as a model system to study helical protein array formation on lipid nanotubes, an alternative to 2D studies on lipid monolayers. We demonstrate that wild-type and a mutant form of SA form helical arrays on biotinylated lipid nanotubes. 3D maps from helical arrays of wild-type and mutant SA were reconstructed using two different approaches: Fourier-Bessel methods and an iterative single particle algorithm. The maps show that wild-type and mutant streptavidin molecules order differently. The molecular packing arrangements of SA on the surface of the lipid nanotubes differ from previously reported lattice packing of SA on biotinylated monolayers. Helical crystallization on lipid nanotubes presents an alternative platform to explore fundamentals of protein ordering, intermolecular protein interaction and phase behavior. We demonstrate that lipid nanotubes offer a robust and reproducible substrate for forming helical protein arrays which present a means for studying protein structure and structure-function relationships.     

Growth of Large and Highly Ordered 2D Crystals of a K+ Channel,Structural Role of Lipidic Environment

2D crystallography has proven to be an excellent technique to determine the 3D structure of membrane proteins. Compared to 3D crystallography, it has the advantage of visualizing the protein in an environment closer to the native one. However, producing good 2D crystals is still a challenge and little statistical knowledge can be gained from literature. Here, we present a thorough screening of 2D crystallization conditions for a prokaryotic inwardly rectifying potassium channel (>130 different conditions). Key parameters leading to very large and well-organized 2D crystals are discussed. In addition, the problem of formation of multilayers during the growth of 2D crystals is also addressed. An intermediate resolution projection map of KirBac3.1 at 6 Å is presented, which sheds (to our knowledge) new light on the structure of this channel in a lipid environment.     

Cardiolipin deficiency in Rhodobacter sphaeroides alters the lipid profile of membranes and of crystallized cytochrome oxidase, but structure and function are maintained

Many recent studies highlight the importance of lipids in membrane proteins, including in the formation of well-ordered crystals. To examine the effect of changes in one lipid, cardiolipin, on the lipid profile and the production, function, and crystallization of an intrinsic membrane protein, cytochrome c oxidase, we mutated the cardiolipin synthase (cls) gene of Rhodobacter sphaeroides, causing a >90% reduction in cardiolipin content in vivo and selective changes in the abundances of other lipids. Under these conditions, a fully native cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) was produced, as indicated by its activity, spectral properties, and crystal characteristics. Analysis by MALDI tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) revealed that the cardiolipin level in CcO crystals, as in the membranes, was greatly decreased. Lipid species present in the crystals were directly analyzed for the first time using MS/MS, documenting their identities and fatty acid chain composition. The fatty acid content of cardiolipin in R. sphaeroides CcO (predominantly 18:1) differs from that in mammalian CcO (18:2). In contrast to the cardiolipin dependence of mammalian CcO activity, major depletion of cardiolipin in R. sphaeroides did not impact any aspect of CcO structure or behavior, suggesting a greater tolerance of interchange of cardiolipin with other lipids in this bacterial system.     

On the kinetics of adsorption and two-dimensional self-assembly of annexin A5 on supported lipid bilayers

Annexin A5 is a protein that binds to membranes containing negatively charged phospholipids in a calcium-dependent manner. We previously found that annexin A5 self-assembles into two-dimensional (2D) crystals on supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) formed on mica while a monolayer of disordered trimers is formed on SLBs on silica. Here, we investigated in detail and correlated the adsorption kinetics of annexin A5 on SLBs, supported on silica and on mica, with the protein's 2D self-assembly behavior. For this study, quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring and ellipsometry were combined with atomic force microscopy. We find, in agreement with previous studies, that the adsorption behavior is strongly dependent on the concentration of dioleoylphosphatidylserine (DOPS) in the SLB and the calcium concentration in solution. The adsorption kinetics of annexin A5 are similar on silica-SLBs and on mica-SLBs, when taking into account the difference in accessible DOPS between silica-SLBs and mica-SLBs. In contrast, 2D crystals of annexin A5 form readily on mica-SLBs, even at low protein coverage (< or =10%), whereas they are not found on silica-SLBs, except in a narrow range close to maximal coverage. These results enable us to construct the phase diagram for the membrane binding and the states of 2D organization of annexin A5. The protein binds to the membrane in two different fractions, one reversible and the other irreversible, at a given calcium concentration. The adsorption is determined by the interaction of protein monomers with the membrane. We propose that the local membrane environment, as defined by the presence of DOPS, DOPC, and calcium ions, controls the adsorption and reversibility of protein binding.     

Two-dimensional crystallization of streptavidin: in pursuit of the molecular origins of structure, morphology, and thermodynamics

The streptavidin two-dimensional (2D) crystallization model has served as a paradigm for molecular self-assembly at interfaces. We have developed quantitative Brewster angle microscopy for the in situ measurement of spatially resolved relative protein surface densities. This allows investigation of both the thermodynamics and morphologies of 2D crystal growth. For crystal structure analysis, we employ TEM on grown crystals transferred to solid substrates. Comparison of results between commercially available streptavidin, recombinant streptavidin, and site-directed streptavidin mutants has provided insight into the protein protein and protein-lipid interactions that underlie 2D crystallization.     

Dependence on lipid structure of the coil-to-helix transition of bovine myelin basic protein

In aqueous solution bovine myelin basic protein has a close-to-random coil structure that is partially transformed to helix on interaction with lipids. Circular dichroism spectra have been used to follow this conformational transition which, with phospholipids, decreases in the order phosphatidylglycerol, phosphatidic acid approximately equal to phospholipids, decreases in the order phosphatidylethanolamine. There appears to be a strong correlation between the extent of alpha-helix formation and the degree of penetration of the hydrophobic region of the bilayer, as assessed by other methods. Cholesterol mixed in bilayers with phosphatidylserine has little effect on the protein secondary structure. Although basic protein binds strongly to cerebroside and to cerebroside sulphate, two of the other major myelin lipids, the intrinsic chirality of these lipids precludes assessment of their effect on the protein conformation. No significant changes in the circular dichroism spectra accompany the protein association with either of the zwitterionic bilayer-forming lipids, phosphatidylethanolamine and phosphatidylcholine. This seems to exclude extensive penetration into bilayers of these lipids and hence to exclude appreciable hydrophobic interactions; on the other hand, it is argued that little evidence exists for ionic attractions to these lipids. The optical activity of peptides derived from the basic protein by cleavage at the 42-43 and 88-89 peptides bonds (with cathepsin D) and at the 115-116 bond (with a skatole derivative) has also been measured in an attempt to locate the helix-forming regions within the primary structure.     

Two-dimensional crystallization of streptavidin by nonspecific binding to a surface film: study with a scanning electron microscope.

A two-dimensional (2D) crystal of streptavidin has been obtained by a nonspecific binding method. The protein molecules were bound and formed a dense packing on the film of poly(1-benzyl-L-histidine) spread at the surface of protein solution. The surface film was moderately heated to stimulate crystallization of bound streptavidin. A potential of this method for obtaining 2D crystals of soluble proteins is demonstrated. The present 2D crystal structure of streptavidin resembles that previously obtained by specific binding to biotinylated lipid. We show in addition that the 2D array of protein with usual size approximately 50 A can be imaged using a high resolution scanning electron microscope (HR-SEM) and subject to structural analysis at low resolution. Various limitations in HR-SEM degrade considerably the image quality. However, the usability of a bulk plate as specimen support would make HR-SEM a convenient tool, when such a substrate must be considered in application of protein arrays, and if an intrinsic low resolution is acceptable.     

An automated pipeline to screen membrane protein 2D crystallization

Electron crystallography relies on electron cryomicroscopy of two-dimensional (2D) crystals and is particularly well suited for studying the structure of membrane proteins in their native lipid bilayer environment. To obtain 2D crystals from purified membrane proteins, the detergent in a protein–lipid–detergent ternary mixture must be removed, generally by dialysis, under conditions favoring reconstitution into proteoliposomes and formation of well-ordered lattices. To identify these conditions a wide range of parameters such as pH, lipid composition, lipid-to-protein ratio, ionic strength and ligands must be screened in a procedure involving four steps: crystallization, specimen preparation for electron microscopy, image acquisition, and evaluation. Traditionally, these steps have been carried out manually and, as a result, the scope of 2D crystallization trials has been limited. We have therefore developed an automated pipeline to screen the formation of 2D crystals. We employed a 96-well dialysis block for reconstitution of the target protein over a wide range of conditions designed to promote crystallization. A 96-position magnetic platform and a liquid handling robot were used to prepare negatively stained specimens in parallel. Robotic grid insertion into the electron microscope and computerized image acquisition ensures rapid evaluation of the crystallization screen. To date, 38 2D crystallization screens have been conducted for 15 different membrane proteins, totaling over 3000 individual crystallization experiments. Three of these proteins have yielded diffracting 2D crystals. Our automated pipeline outperforms traditional 2D crystallization methods in terms of throughput and reproducibility.     

A high-throughput strategy to screen 2D crystallization trials of membrane proteins

Electron microscopy of two-dimensional (2D) crystals has demonstrated potential for structure determination of membrane proteins. Technical limitations in large-scale crystallization screens have, however, prevented a major breakthrough in the routine application of this technology. Dialysis is generally used for detergent removal and reconstitution of the protein into a lipid bilayer, and devices for testing numerous conditions in parallel are not readily available. Furthermore, the small size of resulting 2D crystals requires electron microscopy to evaluate the results and automation of the necessary steps is essential to achieve a reasonable throughput. We have designed a crystallization block, using standard microplate dimensions, by which 96 unique samples can be dialyzed simultaneously against 96 different buffers and have demonstrated that the rate of detergent dialysis is comparable to those obtained with conventional dialysis devices. A liquid-handling robot was employed to set up 2D crystallization trials with the membrane proteins CopA from Archaeoglobus fulgidus and light-harvesting complex II (LH2) from Rhodobacter sphaeroides. For CopA, 1 week of dialysis yielded tubular crystals and, for LH2, large and well-ordered vesicular 2D crystals were obtained after 24 h, illustrating the feasibility of this approach. Combined with a high-throughput procedure for preparation of EM-grids and automation of the subsequent negative staining step, the crystallization block offers a novel pipeline that promises to speed up large-scale screening of 2D crystallization and to increase the likelihood of producing well-ordered crystals for analysis by electron crystallography.