Induction of Acid Metabolism in Portulacaria afra

Portulacaria afra, a succulent plant, shifts from a predominantly C₃ mode of gas exchange to a typical Crassulacean acid metabolism type CO₂ uptake in response to water or NaCl stress. Control plants in the absence of water stress assimilated CO₂ during the light (about 7-8 mg CO₂ dm⁻² hr⁻¹), transpiration (about 1.5 g dm⁻² hr⁻¹) was predominantly during the day, stomates were open during the day, and there was little diurnal organic acid fluctuation. Stressed plants showed only dark CO₂ uptake and dark water loss, nocturnal stomatal opening, and an increased diurnal fluctuation of titratable acidity. Within 2 weeks after rewatering, stressed plants returned to the control acid fluctuation levels indicating that the response to stress was reversible.     

Day-Night Variations in Malate Concentration, Osmotic Pressure, and Hydrostatic Pressure in Cereus validus

Malate concentration and stem osmotic pressure concomitantly increase during nighttime CO₂ fixation and then decrease during the daytime in the obligate Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plant, Cereus validus (Cactaceae). Changes in malate osmotic pressure calculated using the Van't Hoff relation match the changes in stem osmotic pressure, indicating that changes in malate level affected the water relations of the succulent stems. In contrast to stem osmotic pressure, stem water potential showed little day-night changes, suggesting that changes in cellular hydrostatic pressure occurred. This was corroborated by direct measurements of hydrostatic pressure using the Jülich pressure probe where a small oil-filled micropipette is inserted directly into chlorenchyma cells, which indicated a 4-fold increase in hydrostatic pressure from dusk to dawn. A transient increase of hydrostatic pressure at the beginning of the dark period was correlated with a short period of stomatal closing between afternoon and nighttime CO₂ fixation, suggesting that the rather complex hydrostatic pressure patterns could be explained by an interplay between the effects of transpiration and malate levels. A second CAM plant, Agave deserti, showed similar day-night changes in hydrostatic pressure in its succulent leaves. It is concluded that, in addition to the inverted stomatal rhythm, the oscillations of malate markedly affect osmotic pressures and hence water relations of CAM plants.     

Characteristics of Crassulacean Acid Metabolism in the Succulent C(4) Dicot, Portulaca oleracea L

Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) was investigated in leaves and stems of the succulent C₄ dicot Portulaca oleracea L. Diurnal acid fluctuations, CO₂ gas exchange, and leaf resistance were monitored under various photoperiod and watering regimes. No CAM activity was seen in well watered plants grown under 16-hour days. Under 8-hour days, however, well watered plants showed a CAM-like pattern of acid fluctuation with amplitudes of 102 and 90 microequivalents per gram fresh weight for leaves and stems, respectively. Similar patterns were also observed in detached leaves and defoliated stems. Leaf resistance values indicated that stomata were open during part of the dark period, but night acidification most likely resulted from refixation of respiratory CO₂. In water-stressed plants maximum acid accumulations were reduced under both long and short photoperiods. At night, these plants showed short periods of net CO₂ uptake and stomatal opening which continued all night long during preliminary studies under natural environmental conditions. Greatest acid fluctuations, in P. oleracea, with amplitudes of 128 microequivalents per gram fresh weight, were observed in water-stressed plants which had been rewatered, especially when grown under short days. No net CO₂ uptake took place, but stomata remained open throughout the night under these conditions. These results indicate that under certain conditions, such as water stress or short photoperiods, P. oleracea is capable of developing an acid metabolism with many similarities to CAM.     

LEAF RESISTANCE TO WATER VAPOR TRANSFER IN SUCCULENT PLANTS: EFFECT OF THERMOPERIOD

Leaf resistance (R_L) of Kalanchoe blossfeldiana to water vapor transfer was determined with a resistance hygrometer. The diurnal leaf-resistance change followed a normal pattern (i.e., low in light and higher in dark) when plants were pretreated with cool thermoperiods or with thermoperiods having little diurnal temperature fluctuation. Large diurnal temperature fluctuations (30-18, 26-15 C) resulted in apparent nocturnal stomatal opening. Nocturnal stomatal opening was more apparent than real since leaf-resistance measurements indicated day stomatal closing rather than complete night opening. Low nocturnal leaf resistances ( < 10 sec/cm) were not measured in the dark; however, resistances tended to decrease toward the end of the dark period indicating some degree of nocturnal stomatal opening. Leaf resistances were generally higher than those reported for nonsucculent plants. The data suggested that gaseous diffusion (Q) into or out of the leaves of K. blossfeldiana would be adequately described by an equation of the form, Q = D Δ e R_L⁻¹. There was little or no indication that physiological long days (15 min of 660 mμ light in the middle of a 16-hr dark period), which prevented flowering and reduced organic acid accumulation, significantly affected leaf resistance. It was concluded that the photoperiod response effects of dark CO₂ fixation were probably not due to leaf-resistance changes and, therefore, not due to stomatal aperture changes.     

Influence of Photoperiod and Leaf Age on Crassulacean Acid Metabolism in Portulacaria afra (L.) Jacq

The possibility that Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) is subject to long day photoperiodic control in Portulacaria afra (L.) Jacq., a facultative CAM plant, was studied. Periodic measurements of ¹⁴CO₂ uptake, stomatal resistance, and titratable acidity were made on plants exposed to long and short day photoperiods. Results indicates that waterstressed P. afra had primarily nocturnal CO₂ uptake, daytime stomatal closure, and a large diurnal acid fluctuation in either photoperiod. Mature leaf tissue from nonstressed plants under long days exhibited a moderate diurnal acid fluctuation and midday stomatal closure. Under short days, there was a reduced diurnal acid fluctuation in mature leaf tissue. Young leaf tissue taken from nonstressed plants did not utilize the CAM pathway under either photoperiod as indicated by daytime CO₂ uptake, lack of diurnal acid fluctuation, and incomplete daytime stomatal closure.

The induction of CAM in P. afra appears to be related to the water status of the plant and the age of the leaf tissue. The photosynthetic metabolism of mature leaves may be partly under the control of water stress and of photoperiod, where CAM is favored under long days.

     

Day-night changes in leaf water relations associated with the rhythm of crassulacean acid metabolism in Kalanchoë daigremontiana

A study was made of the day-night changes under controlled environmental conditions in the bulk-leaf water relations of Kalanchoë daigremontiana, a plant showing Crassulacean acid metabolism. In addition to nocturnal stomatal opening and net CO₂ uptake, the leaves of well-watered plants showed high rates of gas exchange during the whole of the second part of the light period. Measurements with the pressure chamber showed that xylem tension increased during the night and then decreased towards a minimum at about midday; a significant increase in xylem tension was also seen in the late afternoon. Cell-sap osmotic pressure paralleled leaf malate content and was maximum at dawn and minimum at dusk. The relationship between these two variables indicated that the nocturnally synthesized malate was apparently behaving as an ideal osmoticum. To estimate bulk-leaf turgor pressure, values for water potential were derived by correcting the pressurechamber readings for the osmotic pressure of the xylem sap. This itself was found to depend on the malate content of the leaves. Bulk-leaf turgor pressure changed rhythmically during the day-night cycle; turgor was low during the late afternoon and for most of the night, but increased quickly to a maximum of 0.20 MPa around midday. In water-stressed plants, where net CO₂ uptake was restricted to the dark period, there was also an increase in bulk-leaf turgor pressure at the start of the light period, but of reduced magnitude. Such changes in turgor pressure are likely to be of considerable ecological importance for the water economy of crassulacean-acid-metabolism plants growing in their natural habitats.Abbreviation and symbols CAM Crassulacean acid metabolism - P turgor pressure - osmotic pressure - water potential Dedicated to Professor Dr. H. Ziegler on the occasion of his 60th birthday     

Effects of Various Levels of CO(2) on the Induction of Crassulacean Acid Metabolism in Portulacaria afra (L.) Jacq

In response to water stress, Portulacaria afra (L.) Jacq. (Portulacaceae) shifts its photosynthetic carbon metabolism from the Calvin-Benson cycle for CO₂ fixation (C₃) photosynthesis or Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM)-cycling, during which organic acids fluctuate with a C₃-type of gas exchange, to CAM. During the CAM induction, various attributes of CAM appear, such as stomatal closure during the day, increase in diurnal fluctuation of organic acids, and an increase in phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase activity. It was hypothesized that stomatal closure due to water stress may induce changes in internal CO₂ concentration and that these changes in CO₂ could be a factor in CAM induction. Experiments were conducted to test this hypothesis. Well-watered plants and plants from which water was withheld starting at the beginning of the experiment were subjected to low (40 ppm), normal (ca. 330 ppm), and high (950 ppm) CO₂ during the day with normal concentrations of CO₂ during the night for 16 days. In water-stressed and in well-watered plants, CAM induction as ascertained by fluctuation of total titratable acidity, fluctuation of malic acid, stomatal conductance, CO₂ uptake, and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase activity, remained unaffected by low, normal, or high CO₂ treatments. In well-watered plants, however, both low and high ambient concentrations of CO₂ tended to reduce organic acid concentrations, low concentrations of CO₂ reducing the organic acids more than high CO₂. It was concluded that exposing the plants to the CO₂ concentrations mentioned had no effect on inducing or reducing the induction of CAM and that the effect of water stress on CAM induction is probably mediated by its effects on biochemical components of leaf metabolism.     

Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) in Kalanchoë: Changes in intercellular CO2 concentration during a normal CAM cycle and during cycles in continuous light or darkness

In the crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plant Kalanchoë daigremontiana, the internal CO₂ concentrations were measured throughout CAM cycles by gas chromatography. Under normal dark-light cycles, the internal CO₂ concentration was near that of the ambient air and increased up to 0.5% during the phase of maximum malate decarboxylation. A sharp increase in internal CO₂ concentration occurring after the first 12 h of the cycle was exhibited by the plants both when there was a normal day-night cycle and when the night was replaced by illumination, and also when the light period was replaced by darkness. Thus, the increase in internal CO₂ in the morning does not appear to be primarily determined by a light-on signal or by alterations of temperature rather than by inherent factors of the leaves. This view is supported further by a steep increase in ¹⁴CO₂ production from labeted malate occurring during extended darkness at a time when the light period would normally begin. The results are discussed in particular in relation to of how CAM can control stomata movement.Abbreviation CAM Crassulacean acid metabolism     

Influence of Applied NaCl on Crassulacean Acid Metabolism and Ionic Levels in a Cactus, Cereus validus

To determine possible physiological responses to salinity, seedlings of Cereus validus Haworth, a cactus from Salinas Grandes, Argentina, were treated with up to 600 millimolar NaCl for up to 16 days when they were about 9 months old and 100 millimeters tall. Salt stress decreased stem biomass, e.g. it was 19.7 grams for controls and 11.4 grams for plants treated with 400 millimolar NaCl for 14 days. Nocturnal CO₂ uptake in these obligate Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plants was inhibited 67% upon treatment with 400 millimolar NaCl for 14 days (controls, 181 millimoles CO₂ per square meter), while nocturnal accumulation of malate was inhibited 49% (controls, 230 millimoles malate per square meter). The larger accumulation of malate as compared to uptake of atmospheric CO₂ suggests that internal CO₂ recycling occurred during the dark period. Such recycling was lower in the controls (~20%) than in the NaCl-treated plants (~50%). The nocturnal increase in malate and titratable acidity depended on the total daily photosynthetically active radiation available; measurements suggest a quantum requirment of 26 photons per malate. As NaCl in the medium was increased to 600 millimolar in daily increments of 50 millimolar, Na and Cl concentrations in the roots increased from about 7 to 100 millimolar, but K concentration in the cell sap remained near 26 millimolar. Concomitantly, concentrations of Na and Cl in the shoots increased from 8 to 17 millimolar and from 1 to 7 millimolar, respectively, while the K concentration increased about 16 to 60 millimolar. In plants maintained for 14 days at 500 millimolar NaCl, the root levels of Na and Cl increased to 260 millimolar, the shoot levels were about 60 millimolar, and the stem bases began to become necrotic. Such Na retention in the roots together with the special possibilities of carbon reutilization given by CAM are apparently survival mechanisms for the temporarily saline conditions experienced in its natural habitat.     

Characterization and Partial Purification of Aldose-6-phosphate Reductase (Alditol-6-Phosphate:NADP 1-Oxidoreductase) from Apple Leaves

The Pereskia are morphologically primitive, leafed members of the Cactaceae. Gas exchange characteristics using a dual isotope porometer to monitor ¹⁴CO₂ and tritiated water uptake, diurnal malic acid fluctuations, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase, and malate dehydrogenase activities were examined in two species of the genus Pereskia, Pereskia grandifolia and Pereskia aculeata. Investigations were done on well watered (control) and water-stressed plants. Nonstressed plants showed a CO₂ uptake pattern indicating C₃ carbon metabolism. However, diurnal fluctuations in titratable acidity were observed similar to Crassulacean acid metabolism. Plants exposed to 10 days of water stress exhibited stomatal opening only during an early morning period. Titratable acidity, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase activity, and malate dehydrogenase activity fluctuations were magnified in the stressed plants, but showed the same diurnal pattern as controls. Water stress causes these cacti to shift to an internal CO₂ recycling (“idling”) that has all attributes of Crassulacean acid metabolism except nocturnal stomata opening and CO₂ uptake. The consequences of this shift, which has been observed in other succulents, are unknown, and some possibilities are suggested.     

Responses of succulents to plant water stress

Experiments were performed to test the hypothesis that succulents “shift” their method of photosynthetic metabolism in response to environmental change. Our data showed that there were at least three different responses of succulents to plant water status. When plant water status of Portulacaria afra (L.) Jacq. was lowered either by withholding water or by irrigating with 2% NaCl, a change from C₃-photosynthesis to Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) occurred. Fluctuation of titratable acidity and nocturnal CO₂ uptake was induced in the stressed plants. Stressed Peperomia obtusifolia A. Dietr. plants showed a change from C₃-photosynthesis to internal cycling of CO₂. Acid fluctuation commenced in response to stress but exogenous CO₂ uptake did not occur. Zygocactus truncatus Haworth plants showed a pattern of acid fluctuation and nocturnal CO₂ uptake typical of CAM even when well irrigated. The cacti converted from CAM to an internal CO₂ cycle similar to Peperomia when plants were water-stressed. Reverse phase gas exchange in succulents results in low water loss to carbon gain. Water is conserved and low levels of metabolic activity are maintained during drought periods by complete stomatal closure and continual fluctuation of organic acids.     

Crassulacean acid metabolism,CO2-recycling,and tissue desiccation in the Mexican epiphyte Tillandsia schiedeana Steud (Bromeliaceae)

After 23 days without water in a greenhouse, rates of nocturnal CO₂ uptake in Tillandsia schiedeana decreased substantially and maximum rates occurred later in the dark period eventually coinciding with the onset of illumination. Nocturnal CO₂ uptake accounted for less than half the total nighttime increase in acidity measured in well-watered plants. With increased tissue desiccation, only 11–12% of measured acid accumulation was attributable to atmospheric CO₂ uptake. Plants desiccated for 30 days regained initial levels of nocturnal acid accumulation and CO₂ uptake after rehydration for 10h. These results stress the importance of CO₂ recycling via CAM in this epiphytic bromeliad, especially during droughts.Partially supported by Biomedical Sciences Support Grant RR07037.     

Water relations and photosynthesis of a barrel cactus,Ferocactus acanthodes,in the Colorado desert

Summary The structural characteristics, water relations, and photosynthesis of Ferocactus acanthodes (Lemaire) Britton and Rose, a barrel cactus exhibiting Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM), were examined in its native habitat in the western Colorado desert. Water storage in its succulent stem permitted nighttime stomatal opening ot continue for about 40 days after the soil water potential became less than that of the stem, a period whe the plant would be unable to extract water from the soil. After 7 months of drought and consequent unreplenished water loss from a plant, diurnal stomatal activity was not observed and the stem osmotic pressure was 6.4 bars, more than double the value measured during wet periods with nighttime stomatal opening. F. acanthodes had a shallow root system (mean depth of 8 cm) which responded within 24 h to rainfall.When the nocturnal stem surface temperature was raised from 8.0° C to 35.0° C, the stomatal resistance increased 4-fold, indicating that cool nighttime temperatures are advantageous for gas exchange by F. acanthodes. Moreover, the optimal temperature for CO₂ uptake in the dark was only 12.6° C. CO₂ uptake at night became maximal for 3.0 mEinsteins cm^-2 of photosynthetically active radiation incident during the preceding day, and the minimum number of incident quanta absorbed per CO₂ fixed was 68. The transpiration ratio (mass of water transpired/mass of CO₂ fixed) had the relatively low value of 70 for an entire year, consistent with values obtained for other CAM plants. The total amount of water annually diverted to the floral structures was about 6% of the stem wet weight. The annual growth increment estimated from the net CO₂ assimilation corresponded to about 10% of the stem mass for barrel cacti 34 cm tall, in agreement with measured dimension changes, and indicated that such plants were about 26 years old.     

Crassulacean acid metabolism in the ZZ plant, Zamioculcas zamiifolia (Araceae)

Zamioculcas zamiifolia (Araceae), a terrestrial East African aroid, with two defining attributes of crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) (net CO(2) uptake in the dark and diel fluctuations of titratable acidity) is the only CAM plant described within the Araceae, a mainly tropical taxon that contains the second largest number of epiphytes of any vascular plant family. Within the Alismatales, the order to which the Araceae belong, Z. zamiifolia is the only documented nonaquatic CAM species. Zamioculcas zamiifolia has weak CAM that is upregulated in response to water stress. In well-watered plants, day-night fluctuations in titratable acidity were 2.5 μmol H(+)·(g fresh mass)(-1), and net CO(2) uptake in the dark contributed less than 1% to daily carbon gain. Following 10 d of water stress, net CO(2) uptake in the light fell 94% and net CO(2) uptake in the dark increased 7.5-fold, such that its contribution increased to 19% of daily carbon gain. Following rewatering, dark CO(2) uptake returned to within 5% of prestressed levels. We postulate that CAM assists survival of Z. zamiifolia by reducing water loss and maintaining carbon gain during seasonal droughts characteristic of its natural habitat.     

Stomatal Opening Mechanism of CAM Plants

Stomata usually open when leaves are transferred from darkness to light. However, reverse-phase stomatal opening in succulent plants has been known. CAM plants such as cacti and Opuntia ficus–indica achieve their high water use efficiency by opening their stomata during the cool, desert nights and closing them during the hot, dry days. Signal transduction pathway for stomatal opening by blue light photoreceptors including phototropins and the carotenoid pigment zeaxanthin has been suggested. Blue light regulated signal transduction pathway on stomatal opening could not be applied to CAM plants, but the most possible theory for a nocturnal response of stomata in CAM plants is photoperiodic circadian rhythm.     

Effects of water stress on gas exchange and water relations of a succulent epiphyte,Kalanchoë uniflora

Summary Measurements of gas exchange, xylem tension and nocturnal malate synthesis were conducted with well-watered and droughted plants of Kalanchoë uniflora. Corresponding results were obtained with plants grown in 9 h and 12 h photoperiods. In well-watered plants, 50 to 90% of total CO₂-uptake occurred during the light period. Nocturnal CO₂-uptake and malate synthesis were higher and respiration rate was lower in old leaves (leaf pairs 6 to 10) compared to young leaves (leaf pairs 1 to 5). Within four days of drought distinct physiological changes occurred. Gas exchange during the light period decreased and CO₂-uptake during the dark period increased. Nocturnal malate synthesis significantly increased in young leaves.Respiration rate decreased during periods of drought, this decrease being more pronounced in young leaves compared to old leaves. Restriction of gas exchange during the light period resulted in a decrease of transpiration ratio from more than 100 to about 20. The difference between osmotic pressure and xylem tension decreased in young leaves, indicating a reduction in bulk leaf turgor-pressure.We conclude that both the CAM-enhancement in young leaves and the decrease of respiration rate are responsible for the increase of nocturnal CO₂-uptake during water stress. During short drought periods, which frequently occur in humid habitats, the observed physiological changes result in a marked reduction of water loss while net CO₂-uptake is maintained. This might be relevant for plant growth in the natural habitat.Abbreviations LP light period - DP dark period - CAM crassulacean acid metabolism     

Shifts in the Carbon Metabolism of Xerosicyos danguyi H. Humb. (Cucurbitaceae) Brought About by Water Stress : I. General Characteristics

Xerosicyos danguyi H. Humb. (Cucurbitaceae) is an unusual leaf succulent endemic to Madagascar. Under well-watered conditions the plant exhibited Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM), as characterized by large diurnal changes in titratable acidity, predominantly nighttime stomatal opening and CO₂ uptake, and high δ¹³C values. When plants were exposed to water stress for a minimum of a month, they shifted to a mode of carbon metabolism previously labeled CAM-idling. Under this mode of metabolism, the plants exhibited reduced stomatal opening, reduced CO₂ uptake, dampened diurnal fluctuations in titratable acidity, and no apparent changes in the δ¹³C values. Additionally, investigations showed that the stress hormones 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (an ethylene precursor) and abscisic acid increased as much as 6-fold in the water-stressed plants. The results are discussed in relation to physiological significance and evolution of the CAM-idling mode of metabolism.     

Environmental Influences on Open Stomates of a Crassulacean Acid Metabolism Plant, Agave deserti

The major short term stomatal response of Agave deserti was to temperature; increases in leaf temperature led to decreases in water vapor conductance for stomatal opening during the daytime (C₃ mode) as well as at night (Crassulacean acid metabolism or CAM mode). Hourly changes in the water vapor concentration drop from leaf to air had no significant stomatal effect in either mode. Stomatal responses to external CO₂ levels up to 800 microliters per liter were not significant after 15 minutes and only moderate after a few hours, suggesting that CO₂ effects on open stomates of this succulent were indirect in both CAM and C₃ modes.     

Crassulacean Acid Metabolism in the Succulent C(4) Dicot, Portulaca oleracea L Under Natural Environmental Conditions

Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) was examined under natural environmental conditions in the succulent C₄ dicot Portulaca oleracea L. Two groups of plants were monitored; one was watered daily (well watered), while the other received water once every 3 to 4 weeks to produce a ψ of −8 bars (drought stressed). Gas exchange, transpiration rate, and titratable acidity were measured for 24-hour periods during the growing season. CAM activity was greatest in drought-stressed plants during late August which had 13 hour days and day/night temperatures of 35/15°C. Under these conditions net CO₂ uptake occurred slowly throughout the night. Diurnal fluctuations of titratable acidity took place in both leaves and stems with amplitudes of 17 and 47 microequivalents per gram fresh weight, respectively. Transpiration data indicated greater opening of stomata during the night than the day. CAM was less pronounced in drought-stressed P. oleracea plants in July and September; neither dark CO₂ uptake nor positive carbon balance occurred during the July measurements. In contrast, well-watered plants appeared to rely on C₄ photosynthesis throughout the season, although some acid fluctuations occurred in stems of these plants during September.     

On the nature of facultative and constitutive CAM: environmental and developmental control of CAM expression during early growth of Clusia, Kalanchöe, and Opuntia

The capacity to induce crassulacean acid metabolism developmentally (constitutive CAM) and to up-regulate CAM expression in response to drought stress (facultative CAM) was studied in whole shoots of seven species by measuring net CO(2) gas exchange for up to 120 day-night cycles during early growth. In Clusia rosea, CAM was largely induced developmentally. Well-watered seedlings began their life cycle as C(3) plants and developed net dark CO(2) fixation indicative of CAM after the initiation of the fourth leaf pair following the cotyledons. Thereafter, CAM activity increased progressively and drought stress led to only small additional, reversible increases in dark CO(2) fixation. In contrast, CAM expression was overwhelmingly under environmental control in seedlings and mature plants of Clusia pratensis. C(3)-type CO(2) exchange was maintained under well-watered conditions, but upon drought stress, CO(2) exchange shifted, in a fully reversible manner, to a CAM-type pattern. Clusia minor showed CO(2) exchange reponses intermediate to those of C. rosea and C. pratensis. Clusia cretosa operated in the C(3) mode at all times. Notably, reversible stress-induced increases of dark CO(2) fixation were also observed during the developmental progression to pronounced CAM in young Kalancho? daigremontiana and Kalancho? pinnata, two species considered constitutive CAM species. Drought-induced up-regulation of CAM was even detected in young cladodes of a cactus, Opuntia ficus-indica, an archetypal constitutive CAM species. Evidently, the defining characteristics of constitutive and facultative CAM are shared, to variable degrees, by all CAM species.