Isolated microspore culture techniques and recent progress for haploid and doubled haploid plant production

An isolated microspore culture provides an excellent system for the study of microspore induction and embryogenesis, provides a platform for an ever-increasing array of molecular studies, and can produce doubled haploid (DH) plants, which are used to accelerate plant-breeding programs. Moreover, isolated microspore cultures have several advantages over anther culture, wherein presence of the anther walls can lead to the development of diploid, somatic calli and plants. Although protocols for isolated microspore culture vary from laboratory to laboratory, the basic steps of growing donor plants, harvesting floral organs, isolating microspores, culturing and inducing microspores, regenerating embryos, and doubling the chromosomes, remain the same. Over the past few years, a large proportion of the research reports on isolated microspore culture have focused on cereal and Brassica species. For some of these species, isolated microspore culture protocols are well established and routinely used in laboratories around the world for developing new varieties, as well as for basic research in areas such as genomics, gene expression, and genetic mapping. Although these species are considered highly responsive to microspore culture, improvements in efficiency are still being made. However, with many species, isolated microspore culture is simply not yet efficient enough at producing DH plants to be cost-effective for breeding programs. There has been a recent resurgence of haploidy research with response being reported in some species once considered recalcitrant. Future research programs aimed at elucidating pathways involved in microspore induction and embryogenesis will be of benefit, as will novel approaches to improve the efficiency of microspore culture for DH production. With many species, anther culture has proven to be more effective than isolated microspore culture, necessitating more research to clarify the contribution of the anther wall to embryogenesis. The development of molecular markers for use in determining the gametic origin of regenerated plants, irrespective of their ploidy, would also be beneficial. In this review, we aim to provide an overview of the basic isolated microspore culture protocol with an emphasis on recent progress in several crop species.     

Effects of colchicine on anther and microspore culture of bread wheat (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Triticum aestivum</Emphasis> L.)

The aim of this work was to study the effects of colchicine application on chromosome doubling and androgenic response in anther and microspore culture of different bread wheat genotypes. Colchicine was applied during a mannitol stress pretreatment or during the first 48 h of culture at concentrations of 0, 150 and 300 mg l⁻¹. When colchicine was applied during stress pretreatment, the percentage of doubling depended on genotype and concentration. A significant increase in doubling was observed with 300 mg l⁻¹ in the low androgenic responding cv. Caramba. Colchicine incorporation during the first hours of culture improved percentage of doubling in all genotypes, in both anther and microspore culture. Application of 300 mg l⁻¹ colchicine improved the percentage of doubling in the two low responding genotypes, to 118% of control in DH24033, and 75% in Caramba in microspore and anther culture, respectively. Concerning the androgenic response, the effect of colchicine on embryo formation and percentage of green plants depended on the genotype and on the culture method. In cv. Pavon, a 2- and a 3-fold increase in percentage of embryogenesis and green plants, respectively, were obtained with 300 mg l⁻¹ colchicine in microspore culture. However, no significant differences in these two variables were observed in anther culture. The number of green doubled haploid (DH) plants reflects the index of success of the procedure. Regardless of the culture method, when colchicine was incorporated during the first hours of culture, the number of green DH plants increased significantly in three of four genotypes. These results confirm the usefulness of colchicine application during the first hours of culture in wheat breeding programs.     

Improvements in the production of doubled haploids in durum wheat (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Triticum turgidum</Emphasis> L<Emphasis Type="Italic">.</Emphasis>) through isolated microspore culture

The objective of this study was to produce durum wheat doubled haploid (DH) plants through the induction of microspore embryogenesis. The microspore culture technique was improved to maximize production of green plants per spike using three commercial cultivars. Studies on factors such as induction media composition, induction media support and the stage and growth of donor plants were carried out in order to develop an efficient protocol to regenerate green and fertile DH plants. Microspores were plated on a C₁₇ induction culture medium with ovary co-culture and a supplement of glutathione plus glutamine; 300 g/l Ficoll Type-400 was incorporated to the induction medium support. Donor plants were fertilized with a combination of macro and microelements. With the cultivars ‘Ciccio’ and ‘Claudio’ an average of 36.5 and 148.5 fertile plants were produced, respectively, from 1,000 anthers inoculated. This technique was then used to produce fertile DH plants of potential agronomic interest from a collection of ten F₁ crosses involving cultivars of high breeding value. From these crosses 849 green plants were obtained and seed was harvested from 702 plants indicating that 83% of green plants were fertile and therefore were spontaneously DHs. No aneuploid plant was obtained. The 702 plants yielded enough seeds to be field tested. One of the DH lines obtained by microspore embryogenesis, named ‘Lanuza’, has been sent to the Spanish Plant Variety Office for Registration by the Batlle Seed Company. This protocol can be used instead of the labor-intensive inter-generic crossing with maize as an economically feasible method to obtain DHs for most crosses involving the durum wheat cultivars grown in Spain.     

Microspore embryogenesis and programmed cell death in barley: effects of copper on albinism in recalcitrant cultivars

Albinism remains a major problem in cereal improvement programs that rely on doubled haploid (DH) technology, and the factors controlling the phenomenon are not well understood. Here we report on the positive influence of copper on the production of DH plants obtained through microspore embryogenesis (ME) in recalcitrant cultivars of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.). The presence of copper sulphate in the anther pre-treatment medium improved green DH plant regeneration from cultivars known to produce exclusively albino plants using classical procedures. In plastids, the effect of copper was characterized by a decrease in starch and a parallel increase in internal membranes. The addition of copper sulphate in the ME pre-treatment medium should enable breeders to exploit the genetic diversity of recalcitrant cultivars through DH technology. We examined programmed cell death (PCD) during microspore development to determine whether PCD may interfere with the induction of ME and/or the occurrence of albinism. By examining the fate of nuclei in various anther cell layers, we demonstrated that the kinetics of PCD in anthers differed between the barley cultivars Igri and Cork that show a low and a high rate of albinism, respectively. However, no direct correlation between PCD in the anther cell layers and the rate of albinism was observed and copper had no influence on the PCD kinetic in these cultivars. It was concluded that albinism following ME was not due to PCD in anthers, but rather to another unknown phenomenon that appears to specifically affect plastids during microspore/pollen development.     

Improving the efficiency of isolated microspore culture in six-row spring barley: I-optimization of key physical factors

Key message

An improved isolated microspore culture protocol alleviating the recalcitrance typically observed in six-row spring barley was developed by optimizing four key physical factors to increase embryogenesis and reduce albinism.

Abstract

Doubled haploid (DH) plants are completely homozygous individuals that can be generated in just a few months via androgenesis in vitro. DHs are useful tools in genetic research and in plant breeding. Isolated microspore culture (IMC) is the most efficient way to produce DHs, but a strong genotype dependency imposes limitations to its wide application. Six-row, spring barley genotypes are considered as particularly recalcitrant due to a low frequency of embryogenesis and a high rate of albinism. Seeking to develop an efficient IMC protocol for this type of barley, we explored four important factors: (1) the harvest stage of immature spikes, (2) the type of pretreatment applied, (3) the osmotic potential in the induction medium, and (4) the plating density of microspores. This work was first performed using four barley genotypes: two typical six-row spring cultivars (ACCA and Léger), a two-row spring (Gobernadora) and a two-row winter (Igri) cultivar. First, by optimizing the harvest stage for each genotype we obtained a twofold to fourfold increase in the yield of embryogenic microspores. Second, two pretreatments (0.3 M mannitol for 2 days, or a combination of cold and heat over 15 days) both performed significantly better than the commonly used cold pretreatment (28 days at 4 °C). Third, an induction medium-containing mannitol (32 g/l) doubled green plant regeneration. Fourth, a plating density of 10⁶ microspores/ml yielded the highest number of green regenerated plants. Our most important findings were then confirmed using sets of F1s from a six-row, spring-type breeding program.     

Zinc sulphate improved microspore embryogenesis in barley

The effect of ZnSO₄ concentration on barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) microspore embryogenesis was investigated using cultivars of different androgenetic response. Concentrations from 0 (control) to 600 μM in the stress pre-treatment medium alone or in combination with 30 (control) to 600 μM in the embryo induction medium were assayed in anther culture. Incorporation of Zn²⁺ in the pre-treatment medium itself did not affect microspore embryogenesis. The optimum concentration in the stress pre-treatment and induction media was 180 μM for cultivars (cvs.) Igri and Reinette, and 90 μM for cv. Hop. A significant increase of 30 and 300% in cv. Igri and Reinette, respectively, were produced with 180 μM ZnSO₄ in both the number of embryos and green plants. In order to confirm the effect of Zn²⁺ on microspore embryogenesis this micronutrient was incorporated in the induction medium of isolated microspore cultures of cv. Igri. Concentrations of 90–300 μM ZnSO₄ resulted in an increase of 40–53% in the number of embryos and green plants. All these results indicate that the beneficial effect of Zn²⁺ is exerted mainly during the culture phase, increasing the number of embryos, leading to an increased number of green plants, but it had no effect on percentage of regeneration or green plants.     

First stages of microspore reprogramming to embryogenesis through anther culture in Prunus armeniaca L.

Prunus armeniaca L. is a worldwide known species, very important particularly in the Mediterranean basin. Microspore embryogenesis through in vitro anther culture is a widely used method to obtain haploid and doubled haploid (DHs) plants which are being routinely used in breeding programmes for new superior cultivar development in many crops. Haploid-diploidization through gametic embryogenesis allows single-step development of complete homozygous lines from heterozygous parents. In the case of fruit crops, with long reproductive cycle, a high degree of heterozygosity, large size, and, often, self-incompatibility, there is no way to obtain haploidization through conventional methods. Induction of microspore embryogenesis in vitro is switched by a stress treatment. In many species, heat or cold stress has been reported to trigger pollen embryogenesis, the response being genotype dependent. In the present work we analyzed whether microspore reprogramming could be induced in apricot cultivars by cold stress through anther culture. We report the development of an in vitro anther culture protocol in P. armeniaca L. and analyse the response of several cultivars to stress treatments and culture media for inducing pollen embryogenesis. Results showed the formation of multicellular pollen and proembryos. The effect of two culture media in the embryogenic response was also analyzed, being the responses genotype-dependent. Monitoring of the cellular changes on the microspores was performed by structural and confocal microscopy analyses. Results indicated that the reprogramming of the microspore and the first steps of the embryogenic pathway have been achieved in different varieties of P. armeniaca, which constitutes a crucial step in the design of protocols for the regeneration of microspore-derived embryos and DH plants, for future potential applications in breeding programmes of this economically important fruit tree.     

Isolated microspore culture of oat (Avena sativa L.) for the production of doubled haploids: effect of pre-culture and post-culture conditions

The production of doubled haploid (DH) plants from microspores is an important technique used in plant breeding programs and basic research. Although doubled haploidy efficiencies in wheat and barley are sufficient for breeding purposes, oat (Avena sativa L.) is considered recalcitrant. The objective of this project was to develop a protocol for the production of microspore-derived embryos of oat and further develop these embryos into fertile DH plants. A number of experiments were conducted evaluating the factors influencing microspore embryogenesis, i.e. donor plant conditions, pretreatments, media composition, and culture conditions. The initial studies yielded little response, and it was not until high microspore densities (10⁶ microspores/mL and greater) were used that embryogenesis was achieved. Depending on the treatment, yields of over 5,000 embryos/10⁶ microspores were obtained for breeding line 2000QiON43. The doubled haploidy protocol includes: a 0.3 M mannitol pretreatment of the tillers for 7 days, culture in W14 basal medium with a pH of 6.5–7.5, a microspore density of 10⁶ microspores/mL, and continuous incubation at 28 °C incubation. The resulting embryos observed after 28 days were plated onto solidified W14 medium with 0.8 or 1.0 g/L activated charcoal. A colchicine treatment of 0.2 % colchicine for 4 h resulted in conversion of 80 % of the plants from haploid to DH. This protocol was successful for the production of oat microspore-derived embryos and DH green plants with minimal albinism. DH seed was produced and planted for evaluation in a field nursery.     

Androgenic response to preculture stress in microspore cultures of barley

Summary. Various stresses such as starvation and cold or heat shocks have been identified as triggers in the induction of the microspore embryogenesis. This study attempts to quantify the effects of different pretreatment conditions for successful microspore culture of malting barley (cv. Scarlett). While the sporophytic microspore development could be induced from treated and nontreated microspores, abiotic stress was essential for embryo formation and plant regeneration. The type of stress treatment applied affected the numbers and the ratios of albino and green plants regenerated, as well as their fertility. The highest number of green plants was obtained after the treatment of anthers in 0.3 M mannitol at 32 °C for 24 h before microspore culture. Correspondence and reprints: Department of Plant Biotechnology and Cytogenetics, Institute of Plant Breeding and Acclimatization, Radzików, 05-870 Blonie, Poland.     

Comparison of Anther and Microspore Culture in the Embryogenesis and Regeneration of Rye (Secale cereale)

Anther culture in solid and liquid medium and isolated microspore culture were compared in rye genotypes with potential agronomic characteristics. Some important factors influencing androgenic capacity were optimised. Three weeks cold pre-treatment of spikes and two days mannitol pre-treatment of anthers maximized callus and green plant yield in both culture methods. Intensity order of the culture methods in callus and green plant production was: isolated microspore culture, anther culture in liquid medium and anther culture in solid medium. Genotype ability of embryogenesis followed the same pattern in both cultivation methods. Kinetin (BA) with genotype dependent concentrations created the most effective regeneration conditions.     

The agronomic performance of anther culture derived plants of barley produced via pollen embryogenesis

Anther culture was used to generate microspore-derived doubled haploid (DH) plants from four spring barley crosses. The culture medium used contained maltose as the sole carbohydrate source and the mode of plantlet regeneration was mainly via pollen embryogenesis. Both haploid and spontaneously doubled regenerants were produced and the doubled haploids were compared to recom-binant inbred lines generated by several rounds of selfing (single seed descent). Parental, DH and single seed descent (SSD) lines were grown in randomised, replicated field trials and the samples were scored for a range of agronomic traits. The mean performance and phenotypic distribution of the DH and SSD samples were similar and there was little evidence to support the conclusion that anther culture derived lines exhibit a reduction in vigour. Where significant differences were detected between groups these were mainly confined to crosses which were segregating for the denso dwarfing gene. The differential transmission of particular regions of the barley genome may therefore influence and confound the expression of agronomic traits in DH populations. This is the first report of the agronomic performance of anther culture lines produced via pollen embryogenesis and the results are discussed in relation to the exploitation of anther culture technology in barley breeding.     

Improvement of anther culture methods for doubled haploid production in barley breeding

There is potential to accelerate cultivar development with a doubled haploid system for breeding line production. Anther culture methodology was evaluated for U.S.A. spring barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) breeding applications. Gelrite was found to be an acceptable replacement for ficoll in the induction medium to reduce costs while maintaining embryoid and plant production levels. Beneficial effects of 28 d cold pretreatment of donor spikes for anther culture were confirmed with Pacific Northwest USA barley genotypes. A 3 d mannitol solution pretreatment of fresh anthers was shown to be less effective for green plant production compared to 28 d cold pretreatment of donor spikes. Extended donor spike cold pretreatment from 28 to 42 d did not reduce anther culture productivity. Based on this research, anther culture techniques show promise for economical and convenient application in spring barley breeding.Abbreviations DH doubled haploid - LS Linsmaier and Skoog basal medium - BAP benzylaminopurine - GLM Generalized Linear Model - SAS Statistical Analysis System     

Improved plant regeneration from wheat anther and barley microspore culture using phenylacetic acid (PAA)

Summary The effect of the auxin phenylacetic acid (PAA) on wheat anther and on barley anther/microspore culture was investigated. With PAA the induction response was not usually significantly different from controls but a significantly higher number of green plants were produced in wheat anther and barley microspore culture. For wheat anther culture 100 mg/L PAA was beneficial. For barley microspore culture the optimum levels were from 1 to 100 mg/L, depending on genotype. In barley anther culture there were no improvements using PAA. In wheat anther culture, 145 green plants/100 anthers were obtained with cultivar VeeryS, while the average response from twelve F₁ hybrids in the breeding program was 332 green plants/100 anthers. At least 1000 green plants were obtained using isolated microspores from 100 anthers in barley cv. Igri. With cv. Bruce, regeneration occurred only when 100 mg/L PAA was used. The influence of PAA appears at the embryogenic phase of the culture system. The possible mechanisms by which PAA may improve regeneration are discussed.     

Factors affecting the regeneration capacity of isolated barley microspores (Hordeum vulgare L.)

The culture of isolated microspores of barley (Hordeum vulgare L. cv. Kymppi, an elite malting barley cultivar) was studied. A careful choice of culture steps resulted in an average regeneration frequency of 300 green plants per starting material spike. Strong seasonal variation in regeneration capacity was observed. The choice of a cold pretreatment method affected the viability of microspores. A cold pretreatment of the collected starting material at +4°C for 4 weeks was needed for the efficient regeneration of green plants from isolated microspore cultures. Glutamine omission from and copper additions to microspore culture were studied. The omission of glutamine did not affect the number of regenerated green plants but did result in an increase in the number of regenerated albino plants. The addition of copper did not improve the regeneration capacity of isolated barley microspores. Transformation by particle bombardment of isolated microspores did not result in the production of transgenic plants.     

Low responsiveness of six-rowed genotypes to androgenesis in barley does not have a pleiotropic basis.

A heterozygous mutant for the two- and six-rowed character was isolated in the barley cultivar Igri through application of sodium azide to isolated microspore cultures and posterior regeneration. Six-rowed and two-rowed homozygotic plants were subsequently identified in the self-pollinated M2 progenies of the original heterozygous M1. Detailed molecular markers confirmed the isogenic nature of this recovered mutant and the original cultivar Igri. A comparative study of the anther culture response of this six-rowed induced mutant vs. diploid 'Igri' was performed to assess whether the two- or six-rowed gene influences anther culture response in barley through a pleiotropic effect or via linkage disequilibrium. No significant differences for any of the recorded variables throughout the in vitro regeneration process were detected between the 'Igri' six-rowed mutant and any of their two-rowed isogenic lines. This suggests that row-type association with anther culture response in barley cultivars is due to the effect of a tight linkage with other genes directly responsible for androgenic response.     

Enhancement of microspore culture efficiency of recalcitrant barley genotypes

The culture response of isolated microspores of seven recalcitrant cultivars of barley has been largely improved by identifying an appropriate pretreatment and utilizing ovary co-cultivation. After comparison of three pretreatment media, medium B was shown to be most efficient for inducing microspore embryogenesis, while 0.3 M mannitol frequently used for the responsive cv. Igri was found to be ineffective for recalcitrant genotypes. A further significant improvement of embryogenesis was achieved by using ovary co-culture, which resulted in an overall 2.1-fold increase in embryo formation and 2.4-fold increase in green plant regeneration from all cultivars compared with the control. Optimal co-culture conditions were identified as 5 ovaries/ml medium kept over 20 days in induction culture. Microspore plating densities in cultures with and without co-culture were found to be optimal at 4᎒⁴/ml and 8-12᎒⁴/ml, respectively. The most effective and reproducible method for culturing microspores of recalcitrant genotypes appeared to be the combination of medium B pretreatment with ovary co-culture. By using this procedure, the genotypic difference in microspore embryogenesis could be reduced. It was found that medium B mainly enhanced percent live embryogenic microspores, and ovary co-culture subsequently improved cell division and embryogenic development. The method described here is important for the application of the microspore culture technique to barley breeding and biotechnology.     

Enhanced induction of microspore embryogenesis after <Emphasis Type="Italic">n</Emphasis>-butanol treatment in wheat (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Triticum aestivum</Emphasis> L.) anther culture

The aim of this study was the improvement of embryo production in wheat anther culture. Three butanol alcohols, n-butanol, sec-butanol and tert-butanol, were evaluated for their effect on microspore embryogenesis in two spring cultivars of wheat, Pavon and Caramba. Application of n-butanol, at 0.1 and 0.2% (v/v) in the induction media for 5 h, highly improved embryo production in both cultivars. Sec- and tert-butanol performed similarly to control plates. Regeneration ability was unaffected by any butyl-alcohol treatment. As a consequence of the higher embryo production after n-butanol treatment, the number of green regenerated plants increased up to five times in cultivar Pavon and up to three times in cultivar Caramba. The percentage of green plants was improved or unaffected by the treatment. Doubled haploid plant production was between 2 and 4 times higher after n-butanol treatment than in control plates. Therefore, n-butanol was successfully applied in the production of wheat doubled haploids. This primary alcohol is known as an activator of phospholipase D and has been previously reported to disrupt cortical microtubules and detach them from the plasma membrane in plants. Its effects on androgenetic induction could confirm the importance of microtubule regulation in plant cell fate, specifically in microspore development. A possible implication of phospholipase D is discussed.     

Barley anther culture: assessment of carbohydrate effects on embryo yield, green plant production and differential plastid development in relation with albinism

Sugars and polyols were tested at different steps of anther culture in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) to elucidate their influence on both the overall yield of androgenesis and the structure of plastids in relation to albinism. During the pretreatment period, the osmotic regulation in the medium was beneficial to microspore embryogenesis regardless of the type and concentration of the tested osmoticum. The use of mannitol (300 mOsm/kg), sorbitol (180 mOsm/kg), PEG (240 mOsm/kg) and sucrose (180 mOsm/kg) gave the best results in terms of green plant production, although the influence of each substance differed according to the studied parameter. Similarly, during anther culture the regulation of the osmotic pressure in the medium had various effects, according to the osmoticum used. The best results were obtained using mannitol (364 mOsm/kg), providing 139.7 green plants per 100 plated anthers. Plastids were examined by electron microscopy following both pretreatment and culture. In the presence of mannitol and PEG, plastids did not accumulate starch at any stage of the protocol but they started to differentiate into chloroplasts in the microspore-derived embryos. Using sorbitol and sucrose, plastids differentiated poorly but accumulated large amounts of starch, suggesting that these sugars are metabolized by micropores and microspore derived structures. However, the accumulation of starch was not correlated with the occurrence of albinism. These results indicated that, in barley, the osmotic regulation was favourable to switch the microspore gametophytic program toward a sporophytic program regardless of the nature of the osmoticum. In addition, during the pretreatment period, mannito was found to be the most suitable osmoticum for subsequent embryo development.     

Induction of in vitro androgenesis in anther and isolated microspore culture of different spelt wheat (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Triticum spelta</Emphasis> L.) genotypes

This is the first report on isolated microspore culture—derived spelt wheat. The efficiency of anther- and isolated microspore was compared using four genotypes (‘Franckenkorn’, ‘GK Fehér’, ‘Mv Martongold’, ‘Oberkulmer Rotkorn’). In anther culture, genotype dependency was observed, and cold pre-treatment enhanced the efficiency of the method. In isolated microspore culture, the ovary co-culture supported the development of embryo-like structures. The presence of growth regulators (0.5 mg/l 2,4-D and 0.5 mg/l kinetin) were not essential for the induction of androgenesis, but these increased the production of embryo-like structures, green and albino plantlets. The low plant regeneration rate and high number of albinos hinder the practical application of isolated microspore culture while anther culture was efficient for in vitro green plantlets production in spelt wheat. The mean of green plantlets production was 41.45/100 anthers (from 20.93 to 83.07 depending on genotype). The phenomenon of albinism was mitigated in anther culture (3.48 albinos/100 anthers). Altogether, 1720 anther culture—derived green plantlets were produced from the four genotypes.     

Isolated microspore culture overperforms anther culture for green plant regeneration in barley (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Hordeum vulgare</Emphasis> L.)

Barley isolated microspore culture (IMC) was compared to anther culture (AC) for its efficiency in green plant (GP) regeneration. With six cultivars investigated, IMC resulted in significantly more GPs (3.6–287 per 100 anthers) than AC (0–29.6), which was on average 9.3-fold more efficient (113.7 vs 12.2). GPs were produced via IMC from all the genotypes tested, whereas no green shoot was generated by AC in two of the cultivars. In spite of genotype dependency for regeneration rates, the average GP percentage of IMC was just slightly higher than that of AC. Effects of microspore developmental stages and medium-sterilization methods on IMC were examined with the aim of optimizing culture conditions. We found that the optimum stage for cold pretreatment of spikes was different from that for mannitol starvation of anthers. Significant variations in microspore embryogenesis and regeneration were observed among five stages tested. Optimal stages for the two pretreatments were accordingly determined. Percentages of viable microspores were strongly influenced by protocols of medium-aseptisation. Although filter-sterilized media yielded two-time higher frequencies of living microspores and significantly more GPs than autoclaved ones, the filtration protocol was rather labor-intensive and time-consuming. Therefore a new procedure by combining filtering with autoclaving was subsequently developed as it was more effective than autoclaving and more convenient than filter-sterilization. The method described here could be useful for large-scale preparation of culture media.