Augmentation of proliferation and generation of specific cytotoxic cells in human mixed lymphocyte culture reactions by colchicine

Cellular proliferation and generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes in mixed lymphocyte culture reactions (MLC) results from cellular interactions initiated by individual differences in cell surface structures determined by the HLA-D locus. Cellular microtubular assemblies (MTA) modulate cell shape and surface architecture and have also been implicated in mediating stimulatory signals from the lymphocyte plasma membrane to intracellular sites. To assess the role of MTA in alloactivation, we tested the effect of colchicine, a microtubule-disrupting alkaloid, on the MLC. Diametrically opposite results were observed depending upon the colchicine treatment protocol. Brief exposure of stimulating cells to 10^?6M colchicine resulted in an increase in [³H]thymidine incorporation from 30, 694 ± 2787 to 47,345 ± 4361 cpm/culture (mean ± SEM) (P < 0.001), exposure of responding cells to 10^?6M colchicine resulted in an increase from 33,054 ± 4012 to 46,790 ± 5458 cpm/culture (P < 0.01), and exposure of both cells to 10^?6M colchicine resulted in an increase from 33,054 ± 4012 to 52,685 ± 6720 cpm/culture (P < 0.01). However, direct addition of colchicine to a final concentration of 10^?6M to MLCs at different times resulted in complete suppression of proliferation when added as late as 96 hr, and 63% suppression when added at 120 hr. Pretreatment of stimulating, responding, or both cells with lumicolchicine did not enhance proliferation. Pretreatment of cells with 10^?6 and 10^?4 M colchicine enhanced proliferation, while pretreatment with 10^?2M colchicine prevented blastogenesis. The potentiation of proliferation induced by colchicine was evident as early as 48 hr after the initiation of the MLC. Generation of specific cytotoxic cells in the MLC was also enhanced by exposing lymphocytes to colchicine prior to the proliferative phase in six out of eight experiments (specific chromium release = 168% of control) despite constant effector:target ratios. These findings indicate that early disruption of microtubules leads to enhanced cellular proliferation and generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes in allogeneic one-way MLCs and suggest that the state of polymerization of the MTA may modulate immune responses involving cell-cell interactions.     

Generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes in the autologous mixed lymphocyte culture.

We have studied the ability of purified B lymphocytes to generate cytotoxic T lymphocytes in autologous mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC). Cytotoxic lymphocytes were produced but only autologous mononuclear cells stimulated by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) were susceptible target cells. Unstimulated mononuclear cells and purified B cells were not susceptible to killing by cytotoxic cells generated in the autologous MLC. This suggests that the target antigen may be expressed on stimulated or dividing B lymphocytes in a way that renders the cells more susceptible to cytolysis. Autologously stimulated cytotoxic effector cells were found to exhibit specificity. Cy totoxicity for autologous LPS-stimulated target cells occurred but not for an allogeneic, B cell, histiocytic lymphoma cell line. It is postulated that cytotoxic T cells generated in the autologous MLC may play a role in immune surveillance or in regulation of the immune system.     

Progressive changes in cytotoxic potential during mixed lymphocyte culture.

In a previous study it was shown that at least one round of DNA synthesis is required for initial expression of cytotoxic function in mouse lymphocytes responding to alloantigen in vitro. In the experiments reported here we ask whether subsequent rounds of cell division are required simply for clonal expansion of this initial level of cytotoxic function within the population, or whether the amount of cytotoxicity per cytotoxic cell is altered during subsequent rounds of cell division. The amount of cytotoxicity per unit number of cells at various stages of culture was compared with the frequency of cytotoxic cells as estimated principally by effector-target cell conjugates. Our results strongly suggest that the amount of cytotoxicity per cell (cytotoxic potential) is not a static property of cytotoxic cells, but can be modulated up or down during the course of a reaction.     

Production of T cell differentiation factor in syngeneic lymphocyte macrophage culture for cytotoxic T lymphocyte generation

This study demonstrated that T cell differentiation factor (TCDF) was produced in syngeneic lymphocyte-macrophage cultures. Conditioned medium containing TCDF and interleukin 2 (IL 2) induced the differentiation of leukoagglutinin (LA)-activated cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTLp) into cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) effectors. The production of TCDF and IL 2 peaked at day 4 to 5 in cultures containing normal spleen cells, syngeneic peritoneal macrophages, and indomethacin. Macrophages and T cells with Thy-1+, L3T4+, and Lyt-2- phenotype were needed for TCDF production. There was no requirement for xenogeneic serum in the culture medium; thus, TCDF could be produced in a syngeneic system. Recognition of self Ia molecules appeared to be essential for TCDF production, which was completely abolished by the addition of monoclonal anti-Ia antibody. In our experiments, removal of IL 2 from conditioned medium containing TCDF abolished its ability to generate LA-activated CTL. However, the cytotoxic response could be restored by the addition of a small amount (5 U/ml) of purified human recombinant IL 2 (HRIL 2), which alone was unable to generate LA-activated CTL at this dose. The generation of LA-activated CTL by high dose HRIL 2 (greater than 50 U/ml) was likely due to the endogenous production of TCDF. The bulk of TCDF could be separated from IL 2 by gel filtration in a Sephadex G-100 column. The peak of TCDF activity was concentrated at a m.w. of 16K dalton, and there was very little IL 2 activity in these fractions. When added alone to the LA-activated lymphocyte cultures, these active fractions were unable to induce CTL; supplementation of exogenous IL 2 was needed to restore the cytotoxic responses. Our findings indicate that both IL 2 and TCDF, which are needed in CTL generation. are produced in syngeneic cultures in the absence of antigenic or mitogenic stimulation.     

Inhibition of the mixed lymphocyte culture by peritoneal exudate cells.

Inhibition of mixed lymphocyte cultures (MLC) by macrophages and by supernatants of short term cultured macrophages was assessed by incorporation of ³H-thymidine (TdRH3) and also by blast cell counts and by determination of cellmediated lympholysis. Peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) induced by thioglycollate, at concentrations >10%, inhibited all three parameters of MLC. Lower concentrations of PEC, and supernatants from cultured PEC, inhibited TdRH3 incorporation, but had no significant effect on blast cell counts or on generation of cytotoxic effector cells. Inhibition by the supernatants could be reversed by dialysis or by use of low specific activity TdRH3. These data indicate that macrophages can inhibit proliferative responses in MLC, but that this must be carefully distinguished from selective inhibition of TdRH3 incorporation.     

Zinc inhibits the mixed lymphocyte culture

The mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) is an established clinical method for bone marrow transplantation, as it serves as an in vitro model for allogenic reaction and transplantation. We previously showed that cytokine release into the supernatant is a more specific and sensitive parameter for cross-reactivity in the MLC than the common measurement of cell proliferation. Therefore we tried to find an inhibitor of the MLC in vitro with the least side effects in vivo, measuring interferon (IFN)-γ as one of the most important cytokines in posttransplant medicine. Earlier studies showed that zinc is an important trace element for immune function with both stimulatory and inhibitory effects on immune cells. We found that slightly elevated zinc concentrations (three to four times the physiological level), which do not decrease T-cell proliferation in vitro nor produce immunosuppressive effects in vivo, suppress alloreactivity in the mixed lymphocyte culture. In this report we analyzed the mechanism whereby zinc influences the MLC to possibly find a nontoxic way of immunosuppression.     

In vitro generation of human activated lymphocyte killer cells. II. N-acetyl-D-galactosamine inhibits a distinct subpopulation of human activated lymphocyte killer cells generated in mixed lymphocyte culture

A range of monosaccharides was tested for its ability to inhibit the generation of cytotoxic cells during mixed lymphocyte culture. The most discriminatory effect was produced by N-acetyl-D-galactosamine (NADG). The presence of this sugar at the initiation of the coculture significantly inhibited in a dose-dependent manner the induction of a subset of nonspecific activated lymphocyte (ALK) cells preferentially able to lyse the K562 target cell (natural killer, NK-like cells) but had no effect on the generation of either specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes or another separate subset of ALK cells mediating lysis of an NK-insensitive melanoma cell line. The addition of conditioned medium containing interleukin 2 and interferon (IFN) at the start of culture reversed the inhibitory effect of the sugar. Under conditions of limiting dilution, the frequency of NK-like precursors ranged from 1/50 to 1/1200 with different mononuclear cells (MNC) and in all cases the presence of NADG from Day 0 of culture selectively decreased the frequency of these precursors. At the concentrations used NADG had no effect on NK-like cell cytolysis once generated. The addition of recombinant gamma-IFN did not abrogate the inhibitory effect of NADG and in MLC of some individuals decreased the frequencies of ALK cell precursors. These data provide further evidence for the heterogeneity of ALK cells and indicate that what is usually referred to as NK-like cell activity in in vitro culture is mediated by a subpopulation of MNC which are activated and induced to differentiate along a pathway independent of that of other ALK subsets.     

Proteolytically modified human beta 2-microglobulin augments the specific cytotoxic activity in murine mixed lymphocyte culture

A proteolytically modified form of beta 2-microglobulin (beta 2-m) present in the serum of patients suffering from autoimmune, immunodeficient diseases and cancer has been reported in the literature. In the present study we show that human beta 2-m as well as the proteolytically modified human form (M-beta 2-m) bind to murine lymphocytes expressing H-2 class I antigens; M-beta 2-m, when added at day 0 and 1 of culture in nanomolar concentrations to a one-way murine allogeneic mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) augments the generation of specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes; M-beta 2-m increases the endogenous production of interleukin 2 in the MLC culture; monoclonal antibody which reacts with both the native beta 2-m and M-beta 2-m molecule blocks the augmentation of cytotoxic T lymphocyte production induced by M-beta 2-m; murine as well as human MLC responder cells can proteolytically modify native human beta 2-m; and the modifying activity of murine MLC responder cells was blocked in an intermediary step by an alloantibody, which reacts specifically with murine major histocompatibility complex, class I-associated beta 2-m. These findings suggest that the modification process is preceded by an association of human beta 2-m with the cell surface of the responder cells. Our data indicate that the modification of beta 2-m might reflect early events in allospecific responder cell activation.     

Allograft immunity in vitro: V. Generation of cytotoxic effector cells in mixed lymphocyte culture and the specificity of target cell lysis

Cells from one-way mixed lymphocyte cultures lyse allogeneic target cells in vitro. Target cell lysis is effected by lymphoid cells; macrophages do not contribute to cell death to any measurable degree. The cytotolytic effect is detected at the earliest on the 4th culture day, and reaches a maximum on Day 10–12, i.e., considerably later than the peak of cell proliferation. On Day 6 the killer cell is a large cell (blast); later it is a small (lymphocyte). No cytotoxic effect is detected if DNA synthesis and cell division are blocked. Killer cells are not damaged during the lytic reaction. Direct cell-to-cell contacts rather than diffusable factors of long range, such as lymphotoxins, are prerequisites for target cell damage. Target cell lysis is specific. Labeled “third party” target cells, not sharing antigens with the stimulating cell, are not damaged.     

Augmentation of generation of human allospecific cytotoxic T lymphocyte by PPD in in vitro sensitization culture

Summary PPD augmented human lymphocyte blastogeneic response to allogeneic lymphocytes in the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) and generation of human cytotoxic lymphocytes against allogeneic human lymphocytes in in vitro sensitization (IVS) culture. The augmenting effect of PPD in the MLR was unequivocally synergistic at its lower concentrations (0.05 and 0.01 g/ml). The augmentation of MLR was observed following addition of a supernatant of culture medium of lymphocytes which had been precultured with PPD for 24 h then washed free of PPD and recultured without PPD for another 24 h. PHA and Con A, in contrast, suppressed both MLR and the generation of alloreative cytotoxic cells. The alloreactive cytotoxic lymphocytes whose generation was augmented by PPD belonged to the SRBC-rosette forming fraction and passed through a nylon-wool column. The NK cell-like activities of the alloreactive cytotoxic lymphocytes were not augmented by PPD. Analysis of the alloreactive cytotoxic lymphocytes whose generation was augmented by PPD by competitive inhibition assay with unlabeled cells indicated that the same allogeneic lymphocytes used as sensitizing cells in IVS culture inhibited the cytotoxicity, while MOLT-4 cells, which are frequently used as target cells for the human NK-cell assay, did not. When lymphocytes with known HLA-A and HLA-B were used in the IVS culture and the cytotoxicity assay, PPD was found to augment the cytotoxicity only against the target lymphocytes that possessed the same HLA as the sensitizing lymphocytes in IVS.     

Regulation of primary cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses generated during mixed leukocyte culture with H-2d identical Qa-1-disparate cells

Cytotoxic lymphocyte (CTL) responses are not usually generated during primary mixed leukocyte culture (MLC) with H-2 identical cells. Thus NZB mice are unusual in that their spleen cells do mount CTL responses during primary MLC with H-2d identical stimulator cells; the predominant target antigen for these NZB responses is Qa-1b. Considering the numerous immunoregulatory defects in NZB mice, we postulated that these NZB anti-Qa-1 primary CTL responses were due to an abnormality in T suppressor cell activity. Cellular interactions capable of suppressing NZB anti-Qa-1 primary CTL responses were investigated by using one-way and two-way MLC with spleen cells from NZB mice and other H-2d strains. Although H-2d identical one-way MLC with the use of NZB responders resulted in substantial CTL responses, only minimal CTL responses were detected from two-way MLC with the use of NZB spleen cells plus nonirradiated spleen cells from other H-2d mice. Thus the presence of non-NZB spleen cells in the two-way H-2d identical MLC prevented the generation of NZB CTL. Noncytotoxic mechanisms were implicated in the suppression of the NZB CTL responses during two-way MLC, because only minimal CTL activity was generated when NZB spleen cells were cultured with semiallogeneic, H-2d identical (e.g., NZB X BALB) F1 spleen cells. The observed suppression could be abrogated with as little as 100 rad gamma-irradiation to the non-NZB spleen cells. The phenotype of these highly radiosensitive spleen cells was Thy-1+, Lyt-1+, Lyt-2-, L3T4+. The functional presence of these cells in the spleens of semiallogeneic, H-2d identical F1 mice indicated that their deficiency in NZB mice was a recessive trait. These data suggest that NZB mice lack an L3T4+ cell present in the spleens of normal mice that is capable of suppressing primary anti-Qa-1 CTL responses. This model system should facilitate additional investigations of the cellular interactions and immunoregulatory mechanisms responsible for controlling primary CTL responses against non-H-2K/D class I alloantigens. The model may also provide insight into the immunoregulatory defects of autoimmune NZB mice.     

Activation of suppressor T cells in human autologous mixed lymphocyte culture.

Co-culture of autologous T and mitomycin-C treated B cells results in increased DNA synthesis in the responding T cells. T cells thus activated in AMLC exerted suppressive effects on both the proliferative and cytotoxic responses of fresh unstimulated T cells to allogeneic cells in MLC. The suppressor cells generated are sensitive to treatment with mitomycin-C. AMLC-activated cells treated with mitomycin-C failed to suppress both cytotoxicity and proliferation in fresh primary MLC. It appears that the AMLC reaction reflects an immunologic homeostatic mechanism. Since this reaction is defective in patients with CLL and SLE and the homologous mouse syngeneic MLC is defective in NZB mice, the failure of this T-B interaction may be related to the pathogenesis of certain lymphoproliferative and autoimmune disorders.     

Role of dendritic cells in the regulation of class I restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses

Two class I MHC mutant mouse strains, bm14 and bm13, differ from the strain of origin B6 in one and three amino acids in the alpha 1 and alpha 2 domains of the H-2Db molecule, respectively. These alterations result in specific failure to generate a CTL (Tc) response to the male-specific Ag H-Y. Immunization and/or restimulation in vitro with syngeneic male dendritic cells (DC), expressing very high levels of class I MHC molecules, restored the H-Y-specific Tc response of bm14 but not of bm13 mice. Serologically Db determinants were lost in normal spleen cells of both mutants, because FACS analysis showed a decreased binding of Db domain-specific mAb. Although bm13 DC show a higher fluorescence than bm13 normal spleen cells it is still strongly reduced (30 to 50%) in comparison with B6 DC. Surprisingly, bm14 DC show an equally very strong binding compared with B6 DC with these mAb. The quantitative expression of class I molecules on APC thus appears to be a major determinant in the regulation of Tc responses. In addition, immunization with DC markedly influenced the target cell specificity of the ensuing Tc response. The combined data clearly demonstrate that besides the highly efficient class II-restricted presentation of Ag to Th, shown previously, DC are also superior in the presentation of Ag in the context of class I molecules to Tc. bm14 DC are capable of directly activating H-Y-specific Lyt-2+ Tc memory cells without the need for L3T4+ Th. These biologic effects of DC can at least in part be explained by their very high class I MHC expression. Moreover, these results reiterate that class I MHC Db mutants and different APC can be used to study the contribution of specific class I domains to Tc recognition and restriction specificity.     

Epidermal cells as accessory cells in the generation of allo-reactive and hapten-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses

The capacity of epidermal cells (EC) to stimulate T cell activation is a Langerhans cell (LC)-dependent phenomenon. In all in vitro assays probed, LC subserve antigen-presenting cell functions in that they display surface-bound foreign or altered-self structures and thereby activate T cell responses. In contrast, attempts to demonstrate accessory cell (ACC) function of LC-containing EC have yielded negative results, i.e., EC lacking foreign cell surface antigens were not able to restore cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses in Ia+ adherent cell-depleted cultures. Reasoning that the ACC function of EC might be critically linked to cluster formation between LC and other cell types involved, we tested the ACC function of EC under experimental conditions that allow a close physical contact between the cell types involved (round-bottomed microtiter plates and brief centrifugation of culture plates). By using these modifications, the failure of highly purified B6 T cells to develop alloreactive CTL activity when stimulated with either highly purified, mitomycin C-treated C3H or B6CF1 T cells was restored by the addition of B6 EC. The CTL thus generated produced significant lysis of Con-A-stimulated C3H or BALB/c, but not B6, spleen cell targets. In a similar fashion, TNP- or FITC-specific CTL were generated when (in a syngeneic system) mitomycin C-treated TNP- or FITC-modified stimulator T cells and responder T cells were co-cultured in the presence, but not in the absence, of unmodified EC. The capacity of EC to restore CTL activity in a culture system depleted of Ia-bearing cells was not dependent upon their H-2 type, but was critically linked to the presence of Ia-bearing LC. We therefore conclude that LC-containing EC can subserve the ACC function in the generation of H-2-restricted CTL, provided that culture conditions are chosen that allow a close physical contact between the cell types involved.     

Possible regulation of autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction by OKM1+ NK cells

T cells are stimulated by autologous non-T cells and interleukin 2 (IL-2) is produced in the conventional autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (AMLR) in young healthy controls. The role of cells with natural killer (NK) cell markers (OKM1+ cells or Leu 7+ cells) in the AMLR was studied. There were significant inverse correlations between the percentage of input OKM1+ cells minus monocyte (OKM1+ NK cells) and either AMLR proliferation (gamma = -0.9, P less than 0.001) or IL-2 production (gamma = -0.75, P less than 0.01) in the AMLR cultures after 7 days measured at 7 days. A statistically significant correlation was observed between the percentage of input Leu 7+ cells and AMLR proliferation (gamma = -0.64, P less than 0.05), but not IL-2 production. These results suggest that the AMLR is controlled by OKM1+ NK, perhaps acting through IL-2 regulation.     

Cyclosporin A inhibits the proliferative response and the generation of helper, suppressor and cytotoxic T-cell functions in the autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction

Chemical oxidation or reduction of lymphocyte cell surface thiol or disulfide groups, respectively, has been shown to alter the proliferative activity of murine T cells. S-2-(3-aminopropylamino)ethylphosphothioic acid, a compound containing no free thiol group until it is intracellularly dephosphorylated, did not enhance Con A-induced proliferation which suggested that thiols did not mediate proliferative enhancement via an intracellular mechanism. Glutathione, an impermeant thiol, enhanced T-cell proliferation 68% as effectively as 2-mercaptoethanol (2-ME), which suggested that the thiol-sensitive site was at the cell surface. A battery of structural analogs to 2-ME was employed to elucidate the chemical requirements for the biological activity of the thiols. The necessity for a hydrogen-binding moiety on the thiol reagent was determined by the use of non-hydrogen-binding analogs and by competitive inhibition of the thiol-enhancing activity of 2-ME by non-thiol-containing hydrogen-binding analogs. Pretreatment of cells with the copper:phenanthroline complex (CuP), an impermeant oxidant of thiol groups, reduced the Con A-induced response >79%; however, the presence of 2-ME in culture completely reversed the inhibitory effect of CuP pretreatment. Oxidation of T cells by high oxygen tension (17% O₂) also ablated the Con A response but did not alter the response to Con A + 2-ME. Protection from oxidative inhibition also was afforded T cells by sequential reduction and blockage of cell surface thiol groups. Finally, a model which correlates the chemical study of cell surface residues with T-lymphocyte responsiveness is presented.     

Effects of C-reactive protein on the lymphoid system. II. Inhibition of mixed lymphocyte reactivity and generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes.

C-reactive protein (CRP), an acute phase reactant which increases in concentration during inflammation, has been found to bind to human T cells and to inhibit certain of their functions. In the present study CRP was found to display a binding specificity for theta-bearing cells from mouse peripheral lymphoid tissue but not for thymus cells. CRP inhibited the proliferative response in a similar manner in both murine and human mixed lymphocyte reactions. This inhibition was prevented by the addition of the CRP substrate, pneumococcal C-polysaccharide (CPS), and was not a result of toxicity of CRP for lymphocytes. By contrast the response of spleen lymphocytes to mitogenic Con A concentrations was not altered by CRP. CRP also exerted an inhibitory effect on the in vitro generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CL) in mixed lymphocyte reactions of mouse spleen cells. The expression of the cytolytic process by T cells sensitized either in vivo or in mixed lymphocyte cultures was not altered in the presence of CRP. Therefore, CRP appears to influence the inductive phase of the allograft response and perhaps exerts a regulatory effect on cellular immune responsiveness during inflammatory reactions.