Paclobutrazol- and Hardening-Induced Thermotolerance of Wheat: Are Heat Shock Proteins Involved?

The present report describes the effects of paclobutrazol andheat hardening treatments on the protein synthesis patternsin imbibing and germinating wheat seedlings (Triticum aestivumL. cv Frederick) during heat stress. A heat hardening treatmentgiven during the imbibition period induced the transient expressionof 118, 90, 70 and 18 kDa heat shock proteins (HSPs). However,the hardening and paclobutrazol treatments did not enhance thethermotolerance of imbibed seeds or etiolated seedlings. Bycontrast, the hardening and paclobutrazol treatments enhancedthe thermotolerance of light-grown seedlings. While, both hardenedand unhardened control seedlings synthesized several HSPs duringa high temperature stress period, these proteins were not synthesizedby the paclobutrazol-treated, light-grown seedlings. Thus, HSPsynthesis during heat shock may have been a manifestation ofstress perception by the seedlings and may not have mediatedthe thermotolerance induced by the triazole treatments. Sincedifferential thermotolerance was only apparent in light-grownseedlings, it is suggested that chloroplasts may be requiredfor the expression of paclobutrazol- and hardening-induced thermoprotection.Additional evidence indicating that chloroplasts are an importantsite of injury during high temperature stress was obtained fromchlorophyll fluorescence measurements. (Received July 11, 1994; Accepted October 26, 1994)     

Characterization of the heat shock response in cultured sugarcane cells : I. Physiology of the heat shock response and heat shock protein synthesis

Effect of heat shock on the growth of cultured sugarcane cells (Saccharum officinarum L.) was measured. Heat shock (HS) treatment at 36 to 38°C (2 hours) induced the development of maximum thermotolerance to otherwise nonpermissive heat stress at 54°C (7 minutes). Optimum thermotolerance was observed 8 hours after heat shock. Development of thermotolerance was initiated by treatments as short as 30 minutes at 36°C. Temperatures below 36°C or above 40°C failed to induce maximum thermotolerance. In vivo labeling revealed that HS at 32 to 34°C induced several high molecular mass heat shock proteins (HSPs). A complex of 18 kilodalton HSPs required at least 36°C treatment for induction. The majority of the HSPs began to accumulate within 10 minutes, whereas the synthesis of low molecular mass peptides in the 18 kilodalton range became evident 30 minutes after initiation of HS. HS above 38°C resulted in progressively decreased HSP synthesis with inhibition first observed for HSPs larger than 50 kilodaltons. Analysis of two-dimensional gels revealed a complex pattern of label incorporation including the synthesis of four major HSPs in the 18 kilodalton range and continued synthesis of constitutive proteins during HS.     

Molecular responses of plants to an increased incidence of heat shock

Abstract. Climatic change as a result of the greenhouse effect is widely predicted to increase mean temperatures globally and, in turn, increase the frequency with which plants are exposed to heat shock conditions, particularly in the semi-arid tropics. The consequences of extreme high-temperature treatments on plants have been considered, particularly in relation to the synthesis of heat shock proteins (HSPs) and the capacity to acquire thermotolerance. The heat shock response is described using results obtained with seedlings of the tropical cereals, sorghum ( Sorghum bicolor ) and pearl millet ( Pennisetum glaucum ). A gradual temperature increase, as would occur in the field, is sufficient to induce thermotolerance. The synthesis of HSPs is a transient phenomenon and ceases once the stress is released. Despite the persistence of the HSPs themselves, de novo synthesis of HSPs is required for the induction of thermotolerance each time high temperatures are encountered. The effect of a repeated, diurnal heat shock was investigated and genotypic differences found in the ability to induce the heat shock response repeatedly.     

Induction of acquired thermotolerance in Tetrahymena thermophila: effects of protein synthesis inhibitors.

When Tetrahymena thermophila cells growing at 30 degrees C are shifted to either 40 or 43 degrees C, the kinetics and extent of induction of heat shock mRNAs in both cases are virtually indistinguishable. However, the cells shifted to 40 degrees C show a typical induction of heat shock protein (HSP) synthesis and survive indefinitely (100% after 24 h), whereas those at 43 degrees C show an abortive synthesis of HSPs and die (less than 0.01% survivors) within 1 h. Cells treated at 30 degrees C with the drugs cycloheximide or emetine, at concentrations which are initially inhibitory to protein synthesis and cell growth but from which cells can eventually recover and resume growth, are after this recovery able to survive a direct shift from 30 to 43 degrees C (ca. 70% survival after 1 h). This induction of thermotolerance by these drugs is as efficient in providing thermoprotection to cells as is a prior sublethal heat treatment which elicits the synthesis of HSPs. However, during the period when drug-treated cells recover their protein synthesis ability and simultaneously acquire the ability to subsequently survive a shift to 43 degrees C, none of the major HSPs are synthesized. The ability to survive a 1-h, 43 degrees C heat treatment, therefore, does not absolutely require the prior synthesis of HSPs. But, as extended survival at 43 degrees Celsius depends absolutely on the ability of cells to continually synthesize HSPs, it appears that a prior heat shock as well as the recovery from protein synthesis inhibition elicits a change in the protein synthetic machinery which allows the translation of HSP mRNAs at what would otherwise be a nonpermissive temperature for protein synthesis.     

Differences in preferential synthesis and redistribution of HSP70 and HSP28 families by heat or sodium arsenite in Chinese hamster ovary cells

Since both heat and sodium arsenite induce thermotolerance, we investigated the differences in synthesis and redistribution of stress proteins induced by these agents in Chinese hamster ovary cells. Five major heat shock proteins (HSPs; Mr 110, 87, 70, 28, and 8.5 kDa) were preferentially synthesized after heat for 10 min at 45.5 degrees C, whereas four major HSPs (Mr 110, 87, 70, and 28 kDa) and one stress protein (33.3 kDa) were preferentially synthesized after treatment with 100 microM sodium arsenite (ARS) for 1 hr. Two HSP families (HSP70a,b,c, and HSP28a,b,c) preferentially relocalized in the nucleus after heat shock. In contrast, only HSP70b redistributed into the nucleus after ARS treatment. Furthermore, the kinetics of synthesis of each member of HSP70 and HSP28 families and their redistribution were different after these treatments. The maximum rates of synthesis of HSP70 and HSP28 families, except HSP28c, were 6-9 hr after heat shock, whereas those of HSP70b and HSP28b,c were 0-2 hr after ARS treatment. In addition, the maximum rates of redistribution of HSP70 and HSP28 families occurred 3-6 hr after heat shock, whereas that of HSP70b occurred immediately after ARS treatment. The degree of redistribution of HSP70b after ARS treatment was significantly less than that after heat treatment. These results suggest that heat treatment but not sodium arsenite treatment stimulates the entry of HSP70 and HSP28 families into the nucleus.     

Heat shock and ceramide have different apoptotic pathways in radiation induced fibrosarcoma (RIF) cells

Heat shock induces various cellular responses including inhibition of protein synthesis, production of heat shock proteins (HSPs) and induction of thermotolerance. The molecular mechanisms of the processes have not been well understood. It has been proposed that ceramide formation during heat shock mediates heat shock induced apoptosis. We examined whether C2-ceramide mimicked the cellular response to heat shock in RIF-1 cells and their thermotolerant derivative TR-RIF-1 cells. Discernible effects between heat shock and C2-ceramide treatments were observed in cellular changes such as total protein synthesis, HSP synthesis, stress-activated protein kinase/c-Jun N-terminal kinase (SAPK/JNK) activity and PARP cleavage. Heat shock immediately inhibited cellular protein synthesis, which was recovered by synthesizing HSPs first and then whole proteins later. Heat shock also activated SAPK/JNK and increased PARP cleavage in dose-dependent manner. Thermotolerant TR-RIF-1 cells responded to heat shock more insensitively than RIF-1 cells. On the other hand, C2-ceramide treatment did not accompany any changes induced by heat shock. No discernible differences between RIF-1 and TR-RIF-1 cells were observed by C2-ceramide treatment. We tried to figure out how C2-ceramide interacts with cellular membrane and found that exogenous C2-ceramide was incorporated into the outer monolayer and flipped into the inner monolayer of human erythrocytes in ATP-dependent manner. However, the rate of C2-ceramide incorporation was similar in control and thermotolerant cells. In summary, thermotolerant cells are resistant to heat shock induced apoptotic signaling but not resistant, rather sensitive to membrane disturbing C2-ceramide mediated apoptosis. These results suggest that heat shock and ceramide have different signal transduction pathways.     

Acquisition of thermotolerance in bay scallops, Argopecten irradians irradians, via differential induction of heat shock proteins

Many cells and organisms are rendered transiently resistant to lethal heat shock by short exposure to sublethal temperatures. This induced thermotolerance is thought to be related to increased amounts of heat shock proteins (HSPs) which, as molecular chaperones, protect cells from stress-induced damage. As part of a study on bivalve stress and thermotolerance, work was undertaken to examine the effects of sublethal heat shock on stress tolerance of juveniles of the northern bay scallop, Argopecten irradians irradians, in association with changes in the levels of cytoplasmic HSP70 and 40. Juvenile bay scallops heat-shocked at a sublethal temperature of 32 °C survived an otherwise lethal heat treatment at 35 °C for at least 7 days. As determined by ELISA, acquisition of induced thermotolerance closely paralleled HSP70 accumulation, whereas HSP40 accrual appeared less closely associated with thermotolerance. Quantification of scallop HSPs following lethal heat treatment, with or without conditioning, suggested a causal role for HSP70 in stress tolerance, with HSP40 contributing to a lesser, but significant extent. Overall, this study demonstrated that sublethal heat shock promotes survival of A. irradians irradians juveniles upon thermal stress and the results support the hypothesis that HSPs have a role in this induced thermotolerance. Exploitation of the induced thermotolerance response shows promise as a means to improve survival of bay scallops in commercial culture.     

Induction of heat shock proteins in Chinese hamster ovary cells and development of thermotolerance by intermediate concentrations of puromycin

During 4 hr after puromycin (PUR: 20 micrograms/ml) treatment, the synthesis of three major heat shock protein families (HSPs: Mr = 110,000, 87,000, and 70,000) was enhanced 1.5-fold relative to that of untreated cells, as studied by one-dimensional gel electrophoresis. The increase of unique HSPs, if studied with two-dimensional gels, would probably be much greater. In parallel, thermotolerance was observed at 10(-3) isosurvival as a thermotolerance ratio (TTR) of either 2 or greater than 5 after heating at either 45.5 degrees C or 43 degrees C, respectively. However, thermotolerance was induced by only intermediate concentrations (3-30 micrograms/ml) of puromycin that inhibited protein synthesis by 15-80%; a high concentration of PUR (100 micrograms/ml) that inhibited protein synthesis by 95% did not induce either HSPs or thermotolerance. Also, thermotolerance was never induced by any concentration (0.01-10 micrograms/ml) of cycloheximide that inhibited protein synthesis by 5-94%. Furthermore, after PUR (20 micrograms/ml) treatment, the addition of cycloheximide (CHM: 10 micrograms/ml), at a concentration that reduces protein synthesis by 94%, inhibited both thermotolerance and synthesis of HSP families. Thus, thermotolerance induced by intermediate concentrations of PUR correlated with an increase in newly synthesized HSP families. This thermotolerance phenomenon was compared with another phenomenon termed heat resistance and observed when cells were heated at 43 degrees C in the presence of CHM or PUR immediately after a 2-hr pretreatment with CHM or PUR. Heat protection increased with inhibition of synthesis of both total protein and HSP families. Moreover, this heat protection decayed rapidly as the interval between pretreatment and heating increased to 1-2 hr, and did not have any obvious relationship to the synthesis of HSP families. Therefore, there are two distinctly different pathways for developing thermal resistance. The first is thermotolerance after intermediate concentrations of PUR treatment, and it requires incubation after treatment and apparently the synthesis of HSP families. The second is resistance to heat after CHM or PUR treatment immediately before and during heating at 43 degrees C, and it apparently does not require synthesis of HSP families. This second pathway not requiring the synthesis of HSP families also was observed by the increase in thermotolerance at 45.5 degrees C caused by heating at 43 degrees C after cells were incubated for 2-4 hr following pretreatment with an intermediate concentration of PUR.     

Regulation of heat shock protein 70 synthesis by heat shock in the preimplantation murine embryo

Induced thermotolerance in murine embryos occurs at the 8-cell stage when embryos are maintained in vitro but not until the blastocyst stage if development proceeds in vivo. Present results indicate that ability of embryos to undergo induced thermotolerance is not limited by heat shock protein 70 (HSP70) synthesis. Exposure of 8-cell embryos to 40 degrees C enhanced synthesis of 2 constitutive HSP70 proteins (HSC70 and HSC72) and induced another protein, HSP68; exposure of 43 degrees C was required to induce similar responses in expanded blastocysts. Unlike induced thermotolerance, increased synthesis of HSP70 molecules did not depend on whether embryos were cultured or developed in vivo. Thus, other biochemical mechanisms in addition to HSP70 confer thermotolerance in the preimplantation-stage murine embryo. The observation that the temperature threshold for induction of HSP70 synthesis increased from the 8-cell to the blastocyst stage is indicative of these other biochemical processes.     

Synthesis of soluble heat shock proteins in seminal root tissues of some cultivated and wild wheat genotypes

Effect of heat stress on the synthesis of soluble heat shock proteins (HSPs) and the regrowth in seminal roots of three cultivated and three wild wheat genotypes was examined. In regrowth experiments, 2-d-old etiolated seedlings were exposed to 23 (control), 32, 35, 37 and 38 degrees C for 24 h, and 35 and 37 degrees C (24 h) followed by 50 degrees C (1 h). The lengths of the seminal roots generally decreased significantly at the end of 48 and 72 h recovery growth periods at 35, 37 and 38 degrees C temperature treatments compared with control. Genotypic variability was significant level at all temperature treatments for the seminal root length. Also, genotypic differences for the number of seminal roots were determined among the wheat cultivars and between the wild wheat species and the wheat cultivars at all temperature treatments; but genotypic differences among wild wheat species were only detected at 37-->50 degrees C treatment. Acquired thermotolerance for the seminal root length is over 50% at 37-->50 degrees C treatment. The genotypic variability of soluble heat shock proteins in seminal root tissues were analyzed by two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE). Total number of low molecular weight (LMW) HSPs was more than intermediate-(IMW) and high- (HMW) HSPs at high temperature treatments. The most of LMW HSPs which were generally of acidic character ranged between 14.2-30.7 kDa. The genotypes had both common (43 HSP spots between at least two genotypes and 23 HSP spots between 37 and 37-->50 degrees C) and genotype-specific (72 HSP spots) LMW HSPs.     

Heat shock applied early in sporulation affects heat resistance of Bacillus megaterium spores.

Cells of Bacillus megaterium 27 were challenged by a 30-min heat shock at 45 degrees C during various sporulation stages and then shifted back to a temperature permissive for sporulation (27 degrees C), at which they developed spores. Heat shock applied at 120 min after the end of the exponential phase induced synthesis of heat shock proteins (HSPs) in the sporangia and delayed the inactivation of spores at 85 degrees C. Several HSPs, mainly HSP 70, could be detected in the cytoplasm of these spores. An analogous HSP, the main HSP induced by increased temperature during growth, belongs to the GroEL group according to its N-terminal sequence. The identity of this protein was confirmed by Western blot (immunoblot) analysis with polyclonal antibodies against B. subtilis GroEL. Sporangia treated by heat shock immediately or 240 min after exponential phase also synthesized HSPs, but none of them could be detected in the spores in an appreciable amount. These spores showed only a slightly increased heat resistance.     

Heat shock protein expression in thermotolerant and thermosensitive lines of cotton

The expression of heat shock proteins (HSPs) was compared between genetically characterized heat tolerant and heat sensitive lines of cotton (Gossypium hirsutum andG. barbadense) using electrophoretic analysis ofin vivo labelled proteins. No differences were observed between the two lines with regard to: the temperature at which HSP synthesis was induced (37°C); the temperature at which HSP synthesis was maximal (45°C); the rates of recovery from HSP synthesis; the duration of HSP synthesis; or the major size classes of HSPs expressed in these two lines. Several HSPs were identified on 2D gels which were expressed uniquely in either the tolerant or sensitive cotton line. However, the HSP pattern displayed in a heat tolerant BC-3 individual was that of the heat sensitive parent.Abbreviations HSPs heat shock proteins - IEF isoelecticfocusing     

Heat shock proteins in Sorghum bicolor and Pennisetum americanum I. genotypic and developmental variation during seed germination

Abstract The capacity to synthesize heat shock proteins (HSPs) during seed germination of sorghum (Sorghum bicolor) and pearl millet (Pennisetum americanum) has been examined. HSP synthesis is detectable in a thermotolerant genotype of sorghum during the first hour of imbibition of the seed under high temperature stress. A non-coordinate control of HSP synthesis during germination was revealed. Genotypic differences were manifest in the stage of germination at which the ability to synthesize HSPs was first apparent and this related to the thermosensitivity of that genotype.     

Heat shock resistance conferred by expression of the human HSP27 gene in rodent cells

Heat shock induces in cells the synthesis of specific proteins called heat shock proteins (HSPs) and a transient state of thermotolerance. The putative role of one of the HSPs, HSP27, as a protective molecule during thermal stress has been directly assessed by measuring the resistance to hyperthermia of Chinese hamster and mouse cells transfected with the human HSP27 gene contained in plasmid pHS2711. One- and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of [3H]leucine- and [32P]orthophosphate-labeled proteins, coupled with immunological analysis using Ha27Ab and Hu27Ab, two rabbit antisera that specifically recognize the hamster and the human HSP27 protein respectively, were used to monitor expression and inducibility of the transfected and endogenous proteins. The human HSP27 gene cloned in pHS2711 is constitutively expressed in rodent cells, resulting in accumulation of the human HSP27 and all phosphorylated derivatives. No modification of the basal or heat-induced expression of endogenous HSPs is detected. The presence of additional HSP27 protein provides immediate protection against heat shock administered 48 h after transfection and confers a permanent thermoresistant phenotype to stable transfectant Chinese hamster and mouse cell lines. Mild heat treatment of the transfected cells results in an induction of the full complement of the endogenous heat shock proteins and a small increase in thermoresistance, but the level attained did not surpass that of heat-induced thermotolerant control cells. These results indicate that elevated levels of HSP27 is sufficient to give protection from thermal killing. It is concluded that HSP27 plays a major role in the increased thermal resistance acquired by cells after exposure to HSP inducers.     

Ethanol treatment triggers a heat shock-like response but no thermotolerance in soybean (Glycine max cv. Kaohsiung No.8) seedlings

Non‐lethal heat‐shock (HS) treatment has previously been shown to induce thermotolerance in soybean (Glycine max cv. Kaohsiung No.8) seedlings. This acquired thermotolerance correlates with the de novo synthesis of heat‐shock proteins (HSPs). Interestingly, we found that ethanol treatments also elicited HS‐like responses in aetiolated soybean seedlings at their normal growth temperature of 28 °C. Northern blot analyses revealed that the expression of HS genes hsp17.5, hsp70 and hsc 70 was induced by ethanol. Radioactive amino acids were preferentially incorporated into high molecular weight (HMW) HSPs rather than class I low molecular weight (LMW) HSPs during non‐lethal ethanol treatments. Immunoblot analysis confirmed that no accumulation of class I LMW HSPs occurred after non‐lethal ethanol treatment. Pre‐treatment with a non‐lethal dose of ethanol did not provide thermotolerance, as the aetiolated soybean seedlings could not survive a subsequent heat shock of 45 °C for 2 h. In contrast, non‐lethal HS pre‐treatment, 40 °C for 2 h, conferred tolerance on aetiolated soybean seedlings to otherwise lethal treatments of 7·5% ethanol for 8 h or 10% ethanol for 4 h. These results suggest that plant class I LMW HSPs may play important roles in providing both thermotolerance and ethanol tolerance.     

Heat Shock Effects on the Circadian Rhythm of Protein Synthesis and Phosphorylation of Ribosomal Proteins in Gonyaulax polyedra

Circadian changes in protein synthesis and phosphorylation of ribosomal and cytoplasmic proteins in the marine dinoflagellate Gonyaulax polyedra were analyzed by radioactive labeling and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Maximal rates of protein synthesis were found during the subjective night and minimal rates during the subjective day. Protein synthesis was inhibited by heat shock to a different extent at different circadian phases—maximally during the subjective night. Heat shock proteins (HSPs) having molecular weights of approximately 105, 89, 83, 66, 35, and 18 kDa were induced by these treatments. Induction of HSP89 and HSP35 showed circadian differences with maximal synthesis rates at CT 15, whereas most HSPs maintained a constant constitutive and induced synthesis. Recovery of normal protein synthesis after heat shock occurred faster during the subjective night than during the subjective day. Ribosomal proteins with molecular weights of 16 and 18 kDa were highly phosphorylated by [³⁵S] thio gamma adenosine triphosphate during day phase in a light-dark cycle or at CT 6 in constant dim light and labeled only to a minor degree during night phase or at CT 18. A ribosome-associated protein (35 kDa) was labeled during the day and not during the night, but after heat shock during both day and night. In the 200,000 g cytosolic fraction, a 35-kDa protein was found to be more intensely labeled at night than during the day phase after heat shock. The results of this study show a correlation between circadian changes in the overall protein synthesis and ribosomal protein phosphorylation. The rhythm of protein synthesis and phosphorylation of a ribosome-associated protein are drastically altered by heat shock and dependent on the circadian phase.