Why don't all siblicidal eagles lay insurance eggs? The egg quality hypothesis

Several species of birds lay second eggs that are eliminatedby the siblicidal behavior of the first-hatched chick. A widelyaccepted explanation for the occurrence of these second eggsis insurance against complete nest failure. However, if insuranceis seen as an important breeding strategy for two-egg (c/2)layers, the question arises why single-egg species do not layinsurance eggs. The insurance-egg hypothesis predicts that extraeggs should occur where hatch failure is not trivial, whichmay be particularly prevalent in dense populations. Neitherprediction was supported for siblicidal l Wahlberg's eaglesAquila wahlberge Neither could food constraints or allometricrelationships explain the small one-egg clutch (c/1) of thisspecies Instead, clutch size was experimentally shown to berelated to optimal brood size: parents given two young wereunable to rear them, and subsequent breeding opportunities weresignificantly curtailed. Since clutch and brood size are similarlyrelated in c/2 eagles, insurance may be an exaptation of thesecond egg. One-egg spedes, however, appear to trade second(insurance) eggs for large, high-quality eggs, which enhancehatchability and chick viability. This was borne out by comparisonof the world's c/1 eagles, which lay significantly (p<.01)larger eggs than c/2 eagles of the same body size. Large Wahlberg'seagle eggs also showed significantly (p=.02) greater hatchabilitythan small eggs, and other studies show enhanced survival/qualityfor chicks from large eggs. Because only longer-lived eaglestraded two eggs for single, large eggs, this is consistent withthe idea of selection for offspring quality in long-lived species.I condude that higher hatchability of single, large eggs decreasesthe need for an insurance egg and simultaneously enhances viabilityof resultant chicks in sibliddal eagles and possibly sulids.     

Why do Luehdorfia butterflies lay eggs in clusters?

Luehdorfia butterflies lay eggs in clusters. Clones of their host plants (Asiasarum and Heterotropa) are distributed pacthily among the understory of deciduous forests. Groups of Luehdorfia larvae often exhaust the clones and may wander over the forest floor seeking new clones. The highest mortality observed is during this wandering period. To elucidate why Luehdorfia butterflies lay eggs in clusters, a simulation experiment was made for hypothetical populations which lay eggs in clusters or singly. Field data on larval mortality, consumption, density of host clones and leaf weight for Luehdorfia japonica were incorporated into the model. The predictions of the simulation were: (1) When the egg density is low, the single egg type could leave many more pupae than the egg clustering type, but when the egg density is high, the former might leave smaller number of pupae than the latter; and (2) There are optimal sizes of egg clusters for different egg densities and the optimal size becomes larger as the egg density increased.     

Why does the herring gull lay three eggs?

Food supplements placed daily beside the nests of herring gulls, Larus argentatus, for the first 5 days after the first chick hatched produced improved weight gains over this initial period and higher fledging success, particularly in the third chick. The fledging success of the fed group appears to be due to increased weight gain and not to increased parental protection in the supplemented period. Since there is indirect evidence that food is available this suggests that the parents are putting less effort into foraging for their chicks than they are able to, and less than is in the interests of the third chick, in the first days after hatching. On a separate colony we found that having three chicks in the brood for more than 5 days resulted in lower weight gains for the second chick, but not the first. We suggest that fledging three chicks rather than one or two greatly increases the parents' reproductive effort, and consequently interpret the third egg as primarily insurance against the loss of the first or second.     

The problem with zeroes: why don't drosophilids lay eggs?

Summary We present some data on drosophilid oviposition and analyse the distribution of egg numbers over patches using an iterated negative binomial. This suggests that there are three different reasons for empty patches; patches are not found, patches are not suitable, or females are not able to lay eggs. This leads to five categories of site which can be disentangled using the iterated negative binomial. Since empty patches have important consequences for population dynamics and coexistence, this analysis will highlight how microscopic processes influence macroscopic behaviour in population biology.     

Why do female lizards lay their eggs in communal nests?

1. In many reptile species, females oviposit communally (i.e. many clutches are laid within the same nest). This behaviour might result from constraint (scarcity of nest-sites offering suitable incubation conditions) or adaptation (direct fitness benefits accruing from the proximity of other eggs). 2. To test between these alternatives, we gathered field and laboratory data on montane scincid lizards Bassiana duperreyi from south-eastern Australia. Our data support the adaptationist hypothesis. 3. In the field, communal vs. solitary clutches were laid in similar sites, and the relative frequency of communal nesting was not predictable from nest-site availability. Thermal regimes for incubation did not differ between communal vs. solitary nests, nor between eggs at the core vs. periphery of a communal nest. In the laboratory, females selectively oviposited beside existing eggs rather than in otherwise identical potential nesting sites. 4. From cycling-temperature incubation in the laboratory, eggs incubated within a cluster of other eggs took up less water, but produced hatchlings that were larger and faster-running than were hatchlings from eggs incubated alone. 5. Hydric modifications of incubation conditions within a cluster of tightly packed eggs thus may provide a direct fitness benefit to communal oviposition.     

Can birds count eggs in their nests?

Sensory mechanisms controlling avian clutch size have diversified into distinct types, according to the nature of the input that is used to disrupt the growth of ovarian follicles and hence halt egg‐laying. In an article on brood parasitism, Lyon (2003) claimed that female American Coots Fulica americana can reduce their clutch size on the basis of visual cues in response to eggs laid in their nests by other females; in this species, therefore, egg counting would be used to control clutch size. After a close examination of the physiological determination of clutch size in American Coots, I show that seven of 17 parasitized clutches were smaller than the range controlled through the mechanism using an input to disrupt follicular growth (7–10 eggs per clutch). My reanalysis suggests that American Coots are incapable of adjusting clutch size via counting and re‐asserts that a species that can count eggs has yet to be found among birds that rely upon their own body heat for incubation.     

Why don't Svalbard reindeer migrate?

Reindeer and caribou are best known as migratory, seasonally nomadic animals; many continental populations, for example, travel between distinct summer and winter ranges which may lie hundreds of km apart. Much less is known about the movements of animals belonging to island populations. This paper describes seasonal and annual movements of wild reindeer Rangifer tarandus platyrhynchus on the high arctic archipelago of Svalbard, based on observations of nine animals captured and individually marked in Adventdalen, Spitsbergen, between 1977 and 1982. Four ear-tagged reindeer (one male and three females) were followed extensively for between four and seven years. Five radio-collared females were followed intensively for seven months in 1982. Svalbard reindeer seem neither to undertake long migrations nor to be nomadic within seasons like mountain reindeer or barren-ground caribou. They appear instead to use small, traditional, seasonal home ranges more, for example, like red deer or wild sheep. This atypical behaviour is discussed in relation to the dispersion of reindeers' resources in Svalbard.     

Why are some birds polyterritorial?

Whether a male bird is mono- or polyterritorial may be determined by several factors, but a polyterritorial system tends to be found when territories are easy to defend, male competition is not great and the period of defence is short.     

Why are female birds ornamented?

Sexual selection is now widely accepted as the main evolutionary explanation of extravagant male ornaments. By contrast, ornaments occurring in females have received little attention and often have been considered as nonadaptive, correlated effects of selection on males. However, recent comparative evidence suggests that female ornaments have evolved quite independently of male showiness. Also, new theoretical models predict that both male mate choice and female contest competition will occur under certain circumstances. This is supported by recent experimental studies. Thus, selection acting on females might be a widespread cause of female ornaments.     

Why do snow geese adopt eggs?

Nesting female lesser snow geese (Anser caerulescens caerulescens)usually adopt eggs that are laid adjacent to their nests bypotential intraspecific nest parasites. The host female rollsthe parasite’s egg up into the nest, using the same behaviorpatterns used to retrieve her own eggs if they are displacedfrom the nest. The reproductive consequences of adopting eggsare unclear. We consider three selective scenarios that mightmaintain adoption behavior in geese: (1) egg adoption is ofno reproductive consequence to the host; (2) egg adoption augmentshost reproductive success relative to that of unparasitizednests; and (3) egg adoption is making the best of a bad situation,once a female’s options are constrained by the presenceof an egg adjacent to the nest; we also consider (4) the possibilitythat adoption, if not concordant with the selective regime,is maladaptive. Nest parasitism is costly to the host, makinghypotheses 1 and 2 unlikely. However, adopting eggs significantlydecreases the risk of total nest failure during laying, morethan offsetting other probable host costs. This is consistentwith hypothesis 3. Experiments show that geese have limitedabilities to retrieve eggs, which accounts for most cases ofnonadoption of nearby eggs. We conclude that adoption of eggsis an adaptive trait, a form of nest protection. Adopting eggsis the best option within the species’ repertoire to thethreat to nest survival created when a parasite lays an eggnext to the nest. [Behav Ecol 1991;2:181-187]     

Why don't we prevent childhood accidents?

Accidental injury is the most important epidemic in the Western world today, and is especially important as a cause of death and disability in childhood. Many environmental factors are important causes of accidents, but there is no organisation within which doctors, official bodies, industry, and voluntary bodies can pool their experience and co-ordinate their efforts to reduce these environmental risks. A joint committee on childhood accident prevention should be formed in this country similar to that which exists in Sweden.     

Why are birds’ eggs speckled?

Birds are unique in laying eggs with pigmented shells, but for most species (e.g. most passerines, which lay white eggs speckled with reddish spots of protoporphyrin) the pigments’ function is unknown. We studied a bird population at a geologically variable site, and considered a hitherto untested hypothesis: that protoporphyrin pigments might compensate for reduced eggshell‐thickness (caused partly by calcium deficiency), which is known to reduce eggshell‐strength and increase eggshell‐permeability. We found that pigment spots specifically demarcated thinner areas of shell, with darker spots marking yet thinner shell than paler spots. Variation in pigmentation was thus associated with variation in shell thickness both within and between clutches, so accounting for the eggshell's characteristic spot patterns. Geological variability at this site has resulted in a great range of calcium availability and, as predicted by the hypothesis, variation in calcium availability was found to affect between‐clutch variation in both eggshell‐mass (+) and pigmentation characteristics (?). We suggest a physiological mechanism and some important implications of these findings.     

Why don't we have a schistosomiasis vaccine?

Over the past 30 years there has been a concerted effort to understand host immune responses to schistosomes, with the ultimate aim of producing a vaccine for human use. In this issue, Bergquist and Colley, in summarizing recent meetings in Cairo, provide a detailed appraisal of progress towards that goal. It seems an appropriate time to ask why, with reference to Schistosoma mansoni, the development of a vaccine has proved so difficult. This question is explored here by Alan Wilson and Pat Coulson.     

Why do migrating birds fly along coastlines?

If migrating birds compensate completely for wind drift over land but not over the sea, as indicated by recent radar studies, land-birds facing the sea should, under certain conditions, follow the coastline for some distance rather than depart immediately over the sea. Coastal migration is to be expected if onshore drift exceeds the angle between the birds' preferred track direction and the coastline, as will be the case when this angle is small and strong opposed sidewinds or crosswinds prevail. With offshore drift coasting should occur if the flying time to the goal along a route via the coastline is shorter than that along a direct over-sea route, as will be the case for wide sea-crossings, with strong opposed sidewinds or crosswinds and small angles between the migrants' goal direction and the coastline. Field data support this hypothesis.