Auxin Transport Is Required for Hypocotyl Elongation in Light-Grown but Not Dark-Grown Arabidopsis

Many auxin responses are dependent on redistribution and/or polar transport of indoleacetic acid. Polar transport of auxin can be inhibited through the application of phytotropins such as 1-naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA). When Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings were grown in the light on medium containing 1.0 μm NPA, hypocotyl and root elongation and gravitropism were strongly inhibited. When grown in darkness, however, NPA disrupted the gravity response but did not affect elongation. The extent of inhibition of hypocotyl elongation by NPA increased in a fluence-rate-dependent manner to a maximum of about 75% inhibition at 50 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹ of white light. Plants grown under continuous blue or far-red light showed NPA-induced hypocotyl inhibition similar to that of white-light-grown plants. Plants grown under continuous red light showed less NPA-induced inhibition. Analysis of photoreceptor mutants indicates the involvement of phytochrome and cryptochrome in mediating this NPA response. Hypocotyls of some auxin-resistant mutants had decreased sensitivity to NPA in the light, but etiolated seedlings of these mutants were similar in length to the wild type. These results indicate that light has a significant effect on NPA-induced inhibition in Arabidopsis, and suggest that auxin has a more important role in elongation responses in light-grown than in dark-grown seedlings.     

Short-Lived and Phosphorylated Proteins Contribute to Carrier-Mediated Efflux, but Not to Influx, of Auxin in Suspension-Cultured Tobacco Cells

Auxin is transported across the plasma membrane of plant cells by diffusion and by two carriers operating in opposite directions, the influx and efflux carriers. Both carriers most likely play an important role in controlling auxin concentration and distribution in plants but little is known regarding their regulation. We describe the influence of modifications of the transmembrane pH gradient and the effect of agents interfering with protein synthesis, protein traffic, and protein phosphorylation on the activity of the auxin carriers in suspension-cultured tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) cells. Carrier-mediated influx and efflux were monitored independently by measuring the accumulation of [¹⁴C]2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid and [³H]naphthylacetic acid, respectively. The activity of the influx carrier decreased on increasing external pH and on decreasing internal pH, whereas that of the efflux carrier was only impaired on internal acidification. The efflux carrier activity was inhibited by cycloheximide, brefeldin A, and the protein kinase inhibitors staurosporine and K252a, as shown by the increased capability of treated cells to accumulate [³H]naphthylacetic acid. Kinetics and reversibility of the effect of brefeldin A were consistent with one or several components of the efflux system being turned over at the plasma membrane with a half-time of less than 10 min. Inhibition of efflux by protein kinase inhibitors suggested that protein phosphorylation was essential to sustain the activity of the efflux carrier. On the contrary, the pharmacological agents used in this study failed to inhibit [¹⁴C]2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid accumulation, suggesting that rapidly turned-over proteins or proteins activated by phosphorylation are not essential to carrier-mediated auxin influx. Our data support the idea that the efflux carrier in plants constitutes a complex system regulated at multiple levels, in marked contrast with the influx carrier. Physiological implications of the kinetic features of this regulation are discussed.     

Dependency of Nitrate Reduction on Soluble Carbohydrates in Primary Leaves of Barley under Aerobic Conditions

Nitrate reduction was studied as a function of carbohydrate concentration in detached primary leaves of barley (Hordeum vulgare L. cv Numar) seedlings under aerobic conditions in light and darkness. Seedlings were grown either in continuous light for 8 days or under a regimen of 16-hour light and 8-hour dark for 8 to 15 days. Leaves of 8-day-old seedlings grown in continuous light accumulated 4 times more carbohydrates than leaves of plants grown under a light and dark regimen. When detached leaves from these seedlings were supplied with NO₃⁻ in darkness, those with the higher levels of carbohydrates reduced a greater proportion of the NO₃⁻ that was taken up. In darkness, added glucose increased the percentage of NO₃⁻ reduced up to 2.6-fold depending on the endogenous carbohydrate status of the leaves. Both NO₃⁻ reduction and carbohydrate content of the leaves increased with age. Fructose and sucrose also increased NO₃⁻ reduction in darkness to the same extent as glucose. Krebs cycle intermediates, citrate and succinate, did not increase NO₃⁻ reduction, whereas malate slightly stimulated it in darkness.

In light, 73 to 90% of the NO₃⁻ taken up was reduced by the detached leaves; therefore, an exogenous supply of glucose had little additional effect on NO₃⁻ reduction. The results indicate that in darkness the rate of NO₃⁻ reduction in primary leaves of barley depends upon the availability of carbohydrates.

     

Induction and Regulation of Expression of a Low-CO2-Induced Mitochondrial Carbonic Anhydrase in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

The time course of and the influence of light intensity and light quality on the induction of a mitochondrial carbonic anhydrase (CA) in the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii was characterized using western and northern blots. This CA was expressed only under low-CO₂ conditions (ambient air). In asynchronously grown cells, the mRNA was detected 15 min after transfer from air containing 5% CO₂ to ambient air, and the 21-kD polypeptide was detected on western blots after 1 h. When transferred back to air containing 5% CO₂, the mRNA disappeared within 1 h and the polypeptide was degraded within 3 d. Photosynthesis was required for the induction in asynchronous cultures. The induction increased with light up to 500 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹, where saturation occurred. In cells grown synchronously, however, expression of the mitochondrial CA was also detected in darkness. Under such conditions the expression followed a circadian rhythm, with mRNA appearing in the dark 30 min before the light was turned on. Algae left in darkness continued this rhythm for several days.     

In Vivo Nitrate Reduction in Roots and Shoots of Barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) Seedlings in Light and Darkness

In vivo NO₃⁻ reduction in roots and shoots of intact barley (Hordeum vulgare L. var Numar) seedlings was estimated in light and darkness. Seedlings were placed in darkness for 24 hours to make them carbohydrate-deficient. During darkness, the leaves lost 75% of their soluble carbohydrates, whereas the roots lost only 15%. Detached leaves from these plants reduced only 7% of the NO₃⁻ absorbed in darkness. By contrast, detached roots from the seedlings reduced the same proportion of absorbed NO₃⁻, as did roots from normal light-grown plants. The rate of NO₃⁻ reduction in the roots accounted for that found in the intact dark-treated carbohydrate-deficient seedlings. The rates of NO₃⁻ reduction in roots of intact plants were the same for approximately 12 hours, both in light and darkness, after which the NO₃⁻ reduction rate in roots of plants placed in darkness slowly declined. In the dark, approximately 40% of the NO₃⁻ reduction occurred in the roots, whereas in light only 20% of the total NO₃⁻ reduction occurred in roots. A lesser proportion was reduced in roots because the leaves reduced more nitrate in light than in darkness.     

Gibberellic Acid-Promoted Lignification and Phenylalanine Ammonia-lyase Activity in a Dwarf Pea (Pisum sativum)

The effects of gibberellic acid on lignification in seedlings of a dwarf and a tall cultivar of pea (Pisum sativum) grown under red or white light or in the darkness, were studied. Gibberellic acid (10⁻⁶-10⁻⁴ m) promoted stem elongation in both light and dark and increased the percentage of lignin in the stems of the light-grown dwarf pea. The gibberellin had no effect on the lignin content of the tall pea although high concentrations (10⁻⁴ m) promoted growth of the tall plants. Time course studies indicated that the enhanced lignification in the gibberellin-treated dwarf plants occurred only after a lag period of several days. It was concluded that gibberellic acid-enhanced ligmification had no direct relation to gibberellic acid-promoted growth. The activity of phenylalanine ammonia-lyase (E.C. 4.3.1.5) was higher in gibberellin-treated dwarf plants grown under white or red light than in untreated dwarf plants. Gibberellic acid had no detectable effect on the activity of this enzyme when the plants were grown in darkness, just as it had no effect on lignification under dark conditions. The data suggest that in gibberellin-deficient peas the activity of phenylalanine ammonia-lyase is one of the limiting factors in lignification.     

Different Phototransduction Kinetics of Phytochrome A and Phytochrome B in Arabidopsis thaliana

The kinetics of phototransduction of phytochrome A (phyA) and phytochrome B (phyB) were compared in etiolated Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings. The responses of hypocotyl growth, cotyledon unfolding, and expression of a light-harvesting chlorophyll a/b-binding protein of the photosystem II gene promoter fused to the coding region of β-glucuronidase (used as a reporter enzyme) were mediated by phyA under continuous far-red light (FR) and by phyB under continuous red light (R). The seedlings were exposed hourly either to n min of FR followed by 60 minus n min in darkness or to n min of R, 3 min of FR (to back-convert phyB to its inactive form), and 57 minus n min of darkness. For the three processes investigated here, the kinetics of phototransduction of phyB were faster than that of phyA. For instance, 15 min R h⁻¹ (terminated with a FR pulse) were almost as effective as continuous R, whereas 15 min of FR h⁻¹ caused less than 30% of the effect of continuous FR. This difference is interpreted in terms of divergence of signal transduction pathways downstream from phyA and phyB.     

Effect of pH and Auxin on Chloride Uptake into Avena Coleoptile Cells

The effect of pH on ³⁶Cl⁻ movement into coleoptile cells (Avena sativa L. cv. Garry) was investigated and compared with effects of indoleacetic acid. ³⁶Cl⁻ uptake, but not efflux, is stimulated when coleoptile sections are placed in media adjusted to pH levels from 5 to 3 after a preincubation period at pH 6.5. The enhancement is seen within 2 minutes, is not correlated with growth, and is completely erased by respiratory inhibitors. In comparison to the acid-induced stimulation, the stimulatory effect of indoleacetic acid on ³⁶Cl⁻ uptake is also not accompanied by accelerated efflux, and indoleacetic acid does not further stimulate ³⁶Cl⁻ uptake into 1-millimeter sections beyond that seen at pH 3.5 without auxin.     

Effect of photosynthetic inhibitors and uncouplers of oxidative phosphorylation on nitrate and nitrite reduction in barley leaves

The effects of several photosynthetic inhibitors and uncouplers of oxidative phosphorylation on NO₃⁻ and NO₂⁻ assimilation were studied using detached barley (Hordeum vulgare L. cv Numar) leaves in which only endogenous NO₃⁻ or NO₂⁻ were available for reduction. Uncouplers of oxidative phosphorylation greatly increased NO₃⁻ reduction in both light and darkness, while photosynthetic inhibitors did not.

The NO₂⁻ concentration in the control leaves was very low in both light and darkness; 98% or more of the NO₂⁻ formed from NO₃⁻ was further assimilated in control leaves. More NO₂⁻ accumulated in the leaves in light and darkness in the presence of photosynthetic inhibitors. Of this NO₂⁻, 94% or more was further assimilated. It appears that metabolites, either external or internal to the chloroplast, capable of reducing NADP (which, in turn, could reduce ferredoxin via NADP reductase) might support NO₂⁻ reduction in darkness and light when photosynthetic electron flow is inhibited by photosynthetic inhibitors.

Nitrite assimilation was much more sensitive to uncouplers in darkness than in light: in darkness, 74% or more of NO₂⁻ formed from NO₃⁻ was further assimilated, whereas in light, 95% or more of the NO₂⁻ was further assimilated.

     

Motility of Marichromatium gracile in Response to Light, Oxygen, and Sulfide

The motility of the purple sulfur bacterium Marichromatium gracile was investigated under different light regimes in a gradient capillary setup with opposing oxygen and sulfide gradients. The gradients were quantified with microsensors, while the behavior of swimming cells was studied by video microscopy in combination with a computerized cell tracking system. M. gracile exhibited photokinesis, photophobic responses, and phobic responses toward oxygen and sulfide. The observed migration patterns could be explained solely by the various phobic responses. In the dark, M. gracile formed an ~500-μm-thick band at the oxic-anoxic interface, with a sharp border toward the oxic zone always positioned at ~10 μM O₂. Flux calculations yielded a molar conversion ratio S_tot/O₂ of 2.03:1 (S_tot = [H₂S] + [HS⁻] + [S²⁻]) for the sulfide oxidation within the band, indicating that in darkness the bacteria oxidized sulfide incompletely to sulfur stored in intracellular sulfur globules. In the light, M. gracile spread into the anoxic zone while still avoiding regions with >10 μM O₂. The cells also preferred low sulfide concentrations if the oxygen was replaced by nitrogen. A light-dark transition experiment demonstrated a dynamic interaction between the chemical gradients and the cell's metabolism. In darkness and anoxia, M. gracile lost its motility after ca. 1 h. In contrast, at oxygen concentrations of >100 μM with no sulfide present the cells remained viable and motile for ca. 3 days both in light and darkness. Oxygen was respired also in the light, but respiration rates were lower than in the dark. Observed aggregation patterns are interpreted as effective protection strategies against high oxygen concentrations and might represent first stages of biofilm formation.     

Hormonal Control of Parthenocarpic Ovary Growth by the Apical Shoot in Pea

The role of the apical shoot as a source of inhibitors preventing fruit growth in the absence of a stimulus (e.g. pollination or application of gibberellic acid) has been investigated in pea (Pisum sativum L.). Plant decapitation stimulated parthenocarpic growth, even in derooted plants, and this effect was counteracted by the application of indole acetic acid (IAA) or abscisic acid (ABA) in agar blocks to the severed stump. The treatment of unpollinated ovaries with gibberellic acid blocked the effect of IAA or ABA applied to the stump. [³H]IAA and [³H]ABA applied to the stump were transported basipetally, and [³H]ABA but not [³H]IAA was also detected in unpollinated ovaries. The concentration of ABA in unpollinated ovaries increased significantly in the absence of a promotive stimulus. The application of IAA to the stump enhanced by 2- to 5-fold the concentration of ABA in the inhibited ovary, whereas the inhibition of IAA transport from the apical shoot by triiodobenzoic acid decreased the ovary content of ABA (to approximately one-half). Triiodobenzoic acid alone, however, was unable to stimulate ovary growth. Thus, in addition to removing IAA transport from the apical shoot, the accumulation of a promotive factor is also necessary to induce parthenocarpic growth in decapitated plants.     

Characterization of Cadmium Binding, Uptake, and Translocation in Intact Seedlings of Bread and Durum Wheat Cultivars

High Cd content in durum wheat (Triticum turgidum L. var durum) grain grown in the United States and Canada presents potential health and economic problems for consumers and growers. In an effort to understand the biological processes that result in excess Cd accumulation, root Cd uptake and xylem translocation to shoots in seedlings of bread wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) and durum wheat cultivars were studied. Whole-plant Cd accumulation was somewhat greater in the bread wheat cultivar, but this was probably because of increased apoplastic Cd binding. Concentration-dependent ¹⁰⁹Cd²⁺-influx kinetics in both cultivars were characterized by smooth, nonsaturating curves that could be dissected into linear and saturable components. The saturable component likely represented carrier-mediated Cd influx across root-cell plasma membranes (Michaelis constant, 20–40 nm; maximum initial velocity, 26–29 nmol g⁻¹ fresh weight h⁻¹), whereas linear Cd uptake represented cell wall binding of ¹⁰⁹Cd. Cd translocation to shoots was greater in the bread wheat cultivar than in the durum cultivar because a larger proportion of root-absorbed Cd moved to shoots. Our results indicate that excess Cd accumulation in durum wheat grain is not correlated with seedling-root influx rates or root-to-shoot translocation, but may be related to phloem-mediated Cd transport to the grain.     

An in Vitro System from Maize Seedlings for Tryptophan-Independent Indole-3-Acetic Acid Biosynthesis

The enzymatic synthesis of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) from indole by an in vitro preparation from maize (Zea mays L.) that does not use tryptophan (Trp) as an intermediate is described. Light-grown seedlings of normal maize and the maize mutant orange pericarp were shown to contain the necessary enzymes to convert [¹⁴C]indole to IAA. The reaction was not inhibited by unlabeled Trp and neither [¹⁴C]Trp nor [¹⁴C]serine substituted for [¹⁴C]indole in this in vitro system. The reaction had a pH optimum greater than 8.0, required a reducing environment, and had an oxidation potential near that of ascorbate. The results obtained with this in vitro enzyme preparation provide strong, additional evidence for the presence of a Trp-independent IAA biosynthesis pathway in plants.     

Interrelationships between trans-Plasma Membrane Electron/Proton Transfer Stoichiometry, Organic Acid Metabolism, and Nitrate Reduction in Dwarf Bean (Phaseolus vulgaris)

Iron deficiency in dwarf bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) induces an increased activity of a system in the rhizodermal cells, which reduces extracellular ferric salts, and an active proton efflux from the roots, which is coupled to accumulation of citrate and malate in the roots and subsequent export of these compounds in the xylem. During reduction of extracellular ferricyanide by Fe-deficient plants, the stoichiometry of electron transport to proton efflux is 2e⁻/1H⁺, and citrate and malate levels in the roots are strongly decreased. Reduction of ferricyanide by Fe-sufficient plants has no influence on root and shoot levels of citrate and malate, but in such plants the process is characterized by a e⁻/H⁺ efflux stoichiometry close to unity. Apparently, organic acid metabolism and transport are closely associated with the e⁻/H⁺ efflux ratio. To assess the significance of organic acid metabolism as one of the direct intracellular components of the induced unbalanced e⁻/H⁺ efflux by roots, we studied NO₃⁻ reduction in shoots and roots of Fe-deficient and Fe-sufficient plants. Nitrate reductase activity in the roots was positively correlated with the level of citrate and malate, whereas the enzyme activity in the leaves responded positively to the import of these organic acid anions.     

Auxin distribution is differentially affected by nitrate in roots of two rice cultivars differing in responsiveness to nitrogen

Background and Aims

Although ammonium (NH₄⁺) is the preferred form of nitrogen over nitrate (NO₃⁻) for rice (Oryza sativa), lateral root (LR) growth in roots is enhanced by partial NO₃⁻ nutrition (PNN). The roles of auxin distribution and polar transport in LR formation in response to localized NO₃⁻ availability are not known.

Methods

Time-course studies in a split-root experimental system were used to investigate LR development patterns, auxin distribution, polar auxin transport and expression of auxin transporter genes in LR zones in response to localized PNN in ‘Nanguang’ and ‘Elio’ rice cultivars, which show high and low responsiveness to NO₃⁻, respectively. Patterns of auxin distribution and the effects of polar auxin transport inhibitors were also examined in DR5::GUS transgenic plants.

Key Results

Initiation of LRs was enhanced by PNN after 7 d cultivation in ‘Nanguang’ but not in ‘Elio’. Auxin concentration in the roots of ‘Nanguang’ increased by approx. 24 % after 5 d cultivation with PNN compared with NH₄⁺ as the sole nitrogen source, but no difference was observed in ‘Elio’. More auxin flux into the LR zone in ‘Nanguang’ roots was observed in response to NO₃⁻ compared with NH₄⁺ treatment. A greater number of auxin influx and efflux transporter genes showed increased expression in the LR zone in response to PNN in ‘Nanguang’ than in ‘Elio’.

Conclusions

The results indicate that higher NO₃⁻ responsiveness is associated with greater auxin accumulation in the LR zone and is strongly related to a higher rate of LR initiation in the cultivar ‘Nanguang’.     

Oxidative Damage in Pea Plants Exposed to Water Deficit or Paraquat

Enhanced Cl⁻ efflux during acidosis in plants is thought to play a role in cytosolic pH (pH_c) homeostasis by short-circuiting the current produced by the electrogenic H⁺ pump, thereby facilitating enhanced H⁺ efflux from the cytosol. Using an intracellular perfusion technique, which enables experimental control of medium composition at the cytosolic surface of the plasma membrane of charophyte algae (Chara corallina), we show that lowered pH_c activates Cl⁻ efflux via two mechanisms. The first is a direct effect of pH_c on Cl⁻ efflux; the second mechanism comprises a pH_c-induced increase in affinity for cytosolic free Ca²⁺ ([Ca²⁺]_c), which also activates Cl⁻ efflux. Cl⁻ efflux was controlled by phosphorylation/dephosphorylation events, which override the responses to both pH_c and [Ca²⁺]_c. Whereas phosphorylation (perfusion with the catalytic subunit of protein kinase A in the presence of ATP) resulted in a complete inhibition of Cl⁻ efflux, dephosphorylation (perfusion with alkaline phosphatase) arrested Cl⁻ efflux at 60% of the maximal level in a manner that was both pH_c and [Ca²⁺]_c independent. These findings imply that plasma membrane anion channels play a central role in pH_c regulation in plants, in addition to their established roles in turgor/volume regulation and signal transduction.     

Transport of Sterols to the Plasma Membrane of Leek Seedlings

To investigate the intracellular transport of sterols in etiolated leek (Allium porrum L.) seedlings, in vivo pulse-chase experiments with [1-¹⁴C]acetate were performed. Then, endoplasmic reticulum-, Golgi-, and plasma membrane (PM)-enriched fractions were prepared and analyzed for the radioactivity incorporated into free sterols. In leek seedlings sterols are present as a mixture in which (24R)-24-ethylcholest-5-en-3β-ol is by far the major compound (around 60%). The other sterols are represented by cholest-5-en-3β-ol, 24-methyl-cholest-5-en-3β-ol, (24S)-24-ethylcholesta-5,22E-dien-3β-ol, and stigmasta-5,24(24¹)Z-dien-3β-ol. These compounds are shown to reside mainly in the PM. Our results clearly indicate that free sterols are actively transported from the endoplasmic reticulum to the PM during the first 60 min of chase, with kinetics very similar to that of phosphatidylserine. Such a transport was found to be decreased at low temperature (12°C) and following treatment with monensin and brefeldin A. These data are consistent with a membrane-mediated process for the intracellular transport of sterols to the PM, which likely involves the Golgi apparatus.     

Fusicoccin Counteracts the n-Ethylmaleimide and Silver-Induced Stimulation of Oxygen Uptake in Egeria densa Leaves

It was previously shown that a number of sulfhydryl [SH] group reagents (N-ethylmaleimide [NEM], iodoacetate, Ag⁺, HgCl₂, etc.) can induce a marked, transitory stimulation of O₂ uptake (QO₂) in Egeria densa leaves, insensitive to CN⁻ and salicylhydroxamic acid and inhibited by diphenylene iodonium and quinacrine. The phytotoxin fusicoccin (FC) also induces a marked increase in O₂ consumption in E. densa leaves, apparently independent of the recognized stimulating action on the H⁺-ATPase. In this investigation we compared the FC-induced increase in O₂ consumption with those induced by NEM and Ag⁺, and we tested for a possible interaction between FC and the two SH blockers in the activation of QO₂. The results show (a) the different nature of the FC- and NEM- or Ag⁺-induced increases of QO₂; (b) that FC counteracts the NEM- (and Ag⁺)-induced respiratory burst; and (c) that FC strongly reduces the damaging effects on plasma membrane permeability observed in E. densa leaves treated with the two SH reagents. Two alternative models of interpretation of the action of FC, in activating a CN⁻-sensitive respiratory pathway and in suppressing the SH blocker-induced respiratory burst, are proposed.     

Use of a New Tetrazolium-Based Assay to Study the Production of Superoxide Radicals by Tobacco Cell Cultures Challenged with Avirulent Zoospores of Phytophthora parasitica var nicotianae

The relationship between the production of reactive oxygen species and the hypersensitive response (HR) of tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) toward an incompatible race of the Oomycete Phytophthora parasitica var nicotianae has been investigated. A new assay for superoxide radical (O₂⁻) production based on reduction of the tetrazolium dye sodium,3′-(1-[phenylamino-carbonyl]-3,4-tetrazolium)-bis(4-methoxy-6-nitro) benzene-sulfonic acid hydrate (XTT) has enabled the quantitative estimation of perhydroxyl/superoxide radical acid-base pair (HO₂^·/O₂⁻) production during the resistant response. Tobacco suspension cells were inoculated with zoospores from compatible or incompatible races of the pathogen. Subsequent HO₂^·/O₂⁻ production was monitored by following the formation of XTT formazan. In the incompatible interaction only, HO₂^·/O₂⁻ was produced in a minor burst between 0 and 2 h and then in a major burst between 8 and 10 h postinoculation. During this second burst, rates of XTT reduction equivalent to a radical flux of 9.9 × 10⁻¹⁵ mol min⁻¹ cell⁻¹ were observed. The HO₂^·/O₂⁻ scavengers O₂⁻ dismutase and Mn(III)desferal each inhibited dye reduction. An HR was observed in challenged, resistant cells immediately following the second burst of radical production. Both scavengers inhibited the HR when added prior to the occurrence of either radical burst, indicating that O₂⁻ production is a necessary precursor to the HR.