A study of factors affecting embryo yields from anther culture of cabbage

In cabbage (Brassica oleracea var. capitata), a thermal shock treatment of 24 h at 35 °C at the start of the culture period resulted in higher embryos per 100 anthers (30.0) compared to a treatment of 48 h. Similarly , a chilling treatment of 24 h at 4 °C resulted in a higher embryo yield (6.0) per 100 anthers compared to a treatment of 48 h. However, the embryo yields were significantly higher (p> 0.01) in thermal shock than chilling treatments in all experiments. Treatments of 6 days at either 35 °C or 4 °C gave no embryos. The most responsive cultivar was the F₁ hybrid , Hercules, in all experiments. Although anther culture was successful in the other genotypes, the open pollinated ones, the highest number of embryo yields per 100 anthers was obtained in the hybrid. High temperature treatment before culture had a beneficial effect on the embryo yields. The responsiveness of anthers to addition of increasing concentration of silver nitrate (AgN0₃) (the ethylene inhibitor) to the culture medium, showed a progressive increase in the embryo yields in all the genotypes. Since embryos were also formed in the absence of silver nitrate, probably, due to a greater genotype × medium interaction, it is noted that the presence of silver nitrate in the medium may not be essential for cabbage anther culture as reported earlier. The findings of this study may be recommended for large production of cabbage embryos in culture.     

Variations in response to high temperature treatments in anther culture of Brussels sprouts

The level, time of application and duration of the high temperature treatment necessary for embryo production from Brussels sprouts anther culture were examined. The effects of 29, 32, 35, and 38°C given for 24 h immediately following removal of the anthers from the bud, were tested on different cultivars, on different plants within the cultivars and on different occasions for each plant. Most embryos were produced following 32 and 35°C, very few following 30°C and none following 38°C. Although there was a tendency for some cultivars to respond better to one or other of the two more favourable temperatures, this varied considerably between individual plants. Plant to plant variation was also seen in the overall level of the response, although responsiveness tended to decline with successive samplings of the same plant. Experiments with cultivars Hal and Gower suggested that high temperature was required for at least 12 h after anther removal, but beyond that time the optimum period varied from plant to plant. If the excised anthers were held at 25°C for 16 h or more with Hal or 24 h or more with Gower before being exposed to the high temperature treatment, embrogenesis tended to be reduced. It is suggested that apparent non-responsiveness in anther culture may result to a large extent from the specific conditions that are used during the anther culture process.     

The effect of starch and ineubation temperature in anther culture of potato

Three Andean tetraploid potato genotypes (2n=48) and 7 anther-derived dihaploids (2n=24) originating from two of the tetraploids were used in anther culture. Relative number of embryos/vial was significantly higher when the anther culture media was gelatinized with 3% potato starch than when Gelrite or wheat starch (3%) were used as gelatinizing agents. The degree of anther culture response varied between tetraploids but also within a group of related dihaploids. Additionally, the embryo production of individual genotypes, tetraploids as well as dihaploids, was dependent on the incubation temperature (10, 15, 20, 25, 30°C) of the anther culture. The incubation temperature of the anther culture was also important for the regeneration rate. Direct regeneration was mostly stimulated when the anther culture was incubated at 20°C.Abbreviations BAP 6-benzylaminopurine - IAA indole-3-acetic acid     

The influence of various physical parameters on anther culture of broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. italica)

Embryo formation by cultured broccoli (Brassica oleracea L. var. italica) anthers was best in the pH range of 5.5 to 5.8. Manipulation of the initial medium pH showed, however, that embryos could be recovered throughout the entire pH range tested. Experiments designed to test the influence of anther density on embryo production exhibited an apparent population effect. Comparison of anthers cultured with and without filaments showed a significantly lower level of embryo formation with filaments attached. The importance of anther orientation with the adaxial surface up was also demonstrated. Detailed studies of the effect of temperature on anther response showed the importance of 35°C treatments. Other temperatures and a variety of temperature manipulations were either comparatively ineffective or inhibitory. The duration of 35°C exposure required for optimal response varied widely between 18 and 48 h. Wide variation in plant to plant response was observed despite attempts to optimize the manipulation of physical parameters. Individual plants were identified that reliably formed many thousands of embryos, whereas other plants failed to form embryos under all tested conditions.     

Microspore embryogenesis in anther cultures of two Indian cultivars of Brassica juncea (L.) Czern.

Direct microspore-derived embryo formation in anther cultures of two cultivars of Brassica juncea was obtained. Preliminary culture of anthers at 35°C for 1–5 days prior to maintenance at 25°C stimulated embryogenesis. Embryogenesis was also stimulated by an initial culture at 5°C for 3 days. Analysis of squashed anthers revealed that approximately 10% of the microspores began dividing, but less than 1% developed into macroscopic embryos. All embryos transferred to embryo culture medium survived, but only 30% of these developed directly into normal plantlets. The androgenic plants were haploid (2n=18).     

Factors affecting variability in anther culture and in conversion of androgenic embryos ofSolanum phureja

The variation for embryo production in anther ofSolanum phureja was examined as a function of maximum greenhouse temperature prior to bud harvest and innate responsiveness among anthers within a bud. Four clones ofS. phuyreja were grown in a greenhouse under a 16-h photoperiod. The temperature was monitored continuously. Buds (60 per day on 10 days) were collected and the anthers cultured in two groups of five flasks (30 anthers per flask). In the first group, each flask contained the 30 anthers from six buds; in the second group, each flask contained one anther from each of 30 buds. Significantly smaller coefficients of variation were observed for the second group, suggesting that variation for embryogenic capcity among buds was greater than that among anthers within a bud. Variation in embryo yield as a function of greenhouse temperature was examined by stepwise regression analysis. Embryogenic capacity of one clone was adversely affected by high temperatures (31–37°C) that occurred two and seven days before bud harvest. However, similarly high temperatures appeared to enhance the androgenic response of another clone. Conversion of anther-derived embryos over three subcultures to fresh regeneration medium was examined as a function of anther donor or clone, cold pretreatment of embryos, and morphological classification of embryos. Only clonal origin significantly affected conversion rate which ranged from 12.5% to 46.0%. Conversion rate declined on each serial subculture.Abbreviations BA N⁶-benzyladenine - GA₃ gibberellic acid, IAA-indole-3-acetic acid     

Heat shock response during anther culture of broccoli (Brassica oleracea var italica)

Embryo formation from microspores of Brassica oleracea var Italica (Broccoli) and other Brassica species is greatly enhanced by an initial incubation at elevated temperatures (eg 35°C) followed by continued incubation of 25°C. In the present study we observed that a three hour high temperature treatment induced the formation of heat shock proteins in cultured anthers. These were identified in two dimensional gels by silver staining, and labelled heat shock proteins were synthesised in vitro from isolated anther RNA. The appearance of heat shock proteins in anthers followed a similar pattern and displayed similar characteristics to that from leaves. Comparison of the heat shock proteins induced in isolated cultured anthers of known highly embryogenic and less embryogenic plans did not reveal obvious qualitative differences.     

Improved androgenesis of interspecific potato and efficiency of SSR markers to identify homozygous regenerants

Three interspecific diploid potato hybrids between selections of Solanum phureja Juz. & Buk. and S. chacoense Bitt. were used in anther culture experiments to construct a monoploid family. Different aspects of the anther culture process were affected by the treatments, such as: growing conditions of donor plants, ways of preparing the anther culture medium, and conditions of anthers in culture. Genotype and date of culture initiation were among the most significant sources of variation. Significant improvements in anther culture response were achieved by growing plants at 30°C and by a heat shock of 35°C for 12 h given to anthers in culture, which gave an increase of up to 40% in embryo yield. However, the heat shock reduced the plant regeneration rate. The majority of regenerated plants was diploid, suggesting that there were several recessive lethal alleles in heterozygous status in the anther-donor. Among the regenerants, the homozygotes could be successfully identified by simple sequence repeat analysis, using eight polymorphic primer pairs. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Indifference of potato anther culture to colchicine and genetic similarity among anther-derived monoploid regenerants determined by RAPD analysis

Effects of colchicine on androgenesis of diploid potato (Solanum phureja Juz. & Buk.) and ploidy of anther-derived plants were examined in three experiments. In the first, no significant difference was found for mean embryos per anther of an interspecific potato clone after application of five colchicine treatments (0, 25, 50, 100 and 200 mg l^-1) for 24 h to freshly excised anthers containing late uninucleate microspores. The same colchicine treatments were applied to six hybrid potato families in the second experiment. Families differed for number of embryos per anther and embryo regeneration frequency; however, androgenic response did not differ significantly among colchicine treatments. The 312 regenerated plants included 233 (75%) monoploids. The third experiment examined durations (0, 90 s vacuum infiltration, 24, 48 and 72 h) of high colchicine treatment (200 mg l^-1) on anther culture of seedlings representing one family. Mean embryos per anther, though not statistically significant, ranged from 0.96 to 1.90 for 48 h colchicine and 90 s vacuum infiltration, respectively. There were 126 plants regenerated of which 62% were monoploid. Frequency of monoploid plants regenerated from colchicine treatments did not differ significantly. RAPD analysis was conducted on 26 anther-derived monoploids of one family, based on common flasks of origin. The 13 decamer primers revealed 54 polymorphic loci. These were used to characterize the monoploids genetically. From one flask, two pairs of monoploids among six examined were genetically indistinguishable. Examination of a second and third flask revealed, six of seven and three of seven monoploids that were genetically indistinguishable. These data suggest the regeneration of genetic clones within flasks and may indicate the occurrence of secondary embryogenesis during anther culture. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Stimulation of androgenesis in white cabbage (Brassica oleracea var. capitata) anthers by low temperature and anther dissection

Anther culture was performed on two local cultivars, Ljubljansko and Varadinsko, and the F₁ cv. Krautman (Bejo-Zaden). The effects on androgenesis of hot and cold temperature treatments and different dissections of anthers were evaluated. In contrast to cv. Krautman, cvs. Ljubljansko and Varadinsko produced more embryos after cold pretreatment of flower buds (4°C, 48 h) than after standard treatment (35°C, 24h). Simultaneous cutting of the anther tip and removal of the filament gave the best results in comparison to other tested dissections. Microscopical observations of sectioned anthers revealed enhanced embryo development near the cut ends of the anthers. Ploidy analysis revealed the presence of haploids among embryos resulting from cold treatment (4°C, 48 h), treatment at elevated temperature (35°C, 24 h), and among embryos resulting from dissections of anther tips.     

Stimulation of embryogenesis and haploid production in Brassica campestris anther cultures by elevated temperature treatments

Summary Culture of Brassica campestris anthers at 35°C for one or three days prior to culture at 25°C significantly stimulated the yield of microspore-derived embryos. More than 100 plants were regenerated from cultured embryos and haploids were identified amongst them. The haploid frequency was greater than 70% if all small-flowered sterile plants were considered to be haploid. The yield of microspore-derived plants in B. campestris is approaching the level where anther culture may be utilized as a practical breeding tool.     

The response of anther culture to culture temperature in Triticum aestivum

Summary The response of anther culture to culture temperature was studied in detail using many varieties, F₁ hybrids and pollen-derived lines of wheat (Triticum aestivum) as materials. The suitable culture temperature for inducing pollen callus (or embryoids) in wheat anther culture ranged from 26 °C to 30 °C, varying with genotypes. But for the great majority of wheat genotypes the suitable culture temperatures lay between 28 °C and 30°C. The most significant genotypic variation in the response to culture temperature was observed in the comparison between the culture at 33 °C for eight days followed by culture at 25 °C (or 26 °C) and the continuous culture at 25 °C (or 26 °C). This genotypic variation in the response to culture temperature is a heritable character which may be controlled by multiple genes. The effect of culture at 30 °C for eight days followed by culture at 26 °C was similar to, or in some cases, better than that of continuous culture at 28 °C, and the effect of culture at 32 °C for eight days followed by culture at 28 °C was similar to that of continuous culture at 30 °C. In the range from 26 °C to 32 °C, the overwhelming majority of pollen calli emerged before the 40th day after anther inoculation, and the higher the culture temperature, the earlier and more concentrated the emerging period of the pollen callus. The pollen callus obtained at high temperatures above 28 °C should be transferred in time onto the regeneration medium at 25°–27°C to induce shoots.     

Embryogenesis and plant regeneration from isolated microspores of Brassica rapa L. ssp. Oleifera

Summary Conditions favourable to embryogenesis from isolated microspores of Brassica rapa L. ssp. oleifera (canola quality) were identified. A population with enhanced responsiveness for microspore embryogenesis (C200) was synthesized by crossing individual plants showing microspore embryogenic potential. For optimal microspore embryogenesis, buds (2–3mm in length, containing mid-late uninucieate microspores) were collected from older plants (2 months old) and microspores isolated and washed in iron-free B5 medium. NLN medium with its iron content reduced to half was beneficial for initial microspore culture. An elevated temperature(33–35°C) during the first day of culture, followed by maintenance at 25°C resulted in dozens of embryos from each isolation (about 100 buds). Seeds were obtained from plants regenerated from microsporederived embryos after colchicine treatment.     

Anther culture of kale (Brassica oleracea L. convar.acephala (DC.) Alef.)

The pollen development and androgenic ability of 18 kale (Brassica oleracea convar.acephala) genotypes was observed during an anther culture study. Anther culture was successful in 6 of the genotypes and the highest yield obtained was 17 embryos per 100 anthers plated. Two stages of anther development were identified as being responsive to anther culture. The first and most responsive was that corresponding to the late uninucleated stage and the second to the late binucleated stage. These stages correspond with the onset of mitotic events in the microspores. Pollen viability was studied and low viability was noted which declined to zero after 9 days of anther culture. The initial viability level however was not clearly related to androgenic ability. The significance of the production of haploid and dihaploid kale genotypes in the study and breeding of resistance to clubroot is discussed.     

Differential effect of temperature on mitrochondrial activity in shoots from freshly harvested and moderately aged kernels of maize (Zea mays L.)

This paper reports on a study of mitochondrial activity in etiolated shoots of freshly harvested and moderately aged kernels of maize. Activity was investigated after incubation at a favourable temperature (25°C), sub-optimal temperature (13°C) and after a heat shock (46°C for 2h). Although impaired mitochondrial activity in shoots from moderately aged maize kernels was not detected at 25°C, deficiencies became evident under low temperature stress (13°C). State 3 oxygen uptake, cyanide-insensitive oxygen uptake and cytochrome oxidase activity were lower in mitochondria from these shoots at 13°C than in mitochondria from shoots of freshly harvested kernels at this temperature. After a heat shock, cyanide-insensitive oxygen uptake was higher, and cytochrome oxidase activity lower, in shoots of aged kernels than in shoots of fresh kernels. No significant differences in ADP: O ratio or succinate dehydrogenase activity occurred between mitochondria from shoots of the two seed lots in any of the temperature treatments.     

Pollen germination in vitro at low temperature in European and Andean tetraploid potatoes

Summary Confined design combined with use of tolerance ratio was used to compare pollen germination capacity at low and high temperature in Andean and European potato material. Four clones of Solanum tuberosum from the European gene pool were compared with four Andean potato clones derived from the breeding program for frost resistance at the International Potato Center (CIP), Lima, Peru. For each clone, the same pollen lot was used throughout each replication. Pollen were germinated at 9 °C and 21 °C. Fortification of media with potato starch and 14 min preincubation at 25 °C were used as variables. The Andean material maintained its germination capacity better than the European material when temperature was decreased. It was possible significantly to distinguish potato clones with low temperature requirement for pollen germination if incubation proceeded germination at 21 °C, but not at 9 °C. Fortification with starch had no significant effect.     

Isolated microspore culture of Chinese flowering cabbage (Brassica campestris ssp. parachinensis)

Microspores of several genotypes of Brassica campestris ssp. parachinensis have been cultured in vitro and induced to undergo embryogenesis and plant formation. Conditions favourable for embryogenesis in this species include a bud size of 2–2.9 mm, NLN-13 culture medium (Nitsch and Nitsch 1967; Lichter 1981, 1982; Swanson 1990), and an induction through exposure to 32°C for a period of 48 h. Longer periods of an elevated temperature for induction of embryogenesis resulted in embryo abortion at early developmental stages. With the protocol developed here, microspores of 60–80% of donor plants could be induced to produce embryos, although embryo yields were low, i.e. 2–5 embryos per 10 buds. Some genotypes responded to culture conditions with high numbers of embryo formation (100–150 embryos per 10 buds) but most of these subsequently failed to mature. The pattern of cell division and morphological changes of the microspores in culture were studied using various microscopic techniques.     

Effect of incubation temperature on zearalenone production by strains of Fusarium crookwellense

After 6 weeks incubation on rice 2 strains of Fusarium crookwellense produced more zearalenone (6060–5010 mg/kg dry wt of culture) at ambient temperature (16–29°C) in daylight than at ambient temperature (18–23 °C) in darkness or at controlled temperatures of 11 °C, 20 °C or 25 °C in darkness. Yields at 25 °C were low. Incubation at 11 °C during the second 3 weeks incubation increased yields only when preliminary incubation had been at 25 °C. After 6 weeks incubation at controlled temperatures in darkness, 4 strains produced most zearalenone at 20 °C (2460-21 360 mg/kg), 1 strain at 11 °C (6570 mg/kg). Yields at a temperature oscillating daily from 10–20 °C were less than at 15 °C. One of the 5 strains produced appreciable amounts of a-zearalenol (1645 mg/kg at 20°C) and 2 of nivalenol (340 and 499 mg/kg at 20 °C).     

The influence of culture conditions on anther culture response of commercial varieties of Solanum tuberosum L.

The effect of media manipulatioss, temperature pretreatment, carbohydrate source, and seasonal variation on tetraploid potato anther cultures was investigated. The anther culture responses of three commercial Nordic potato varieties from Scandinavia and two from Germany were compared on different media manipulations. With most of the varieties, solid MS media gave better yields than other published media manipulations. Pretreatments at +6°C and at +30°C were studied on Pito and Danva varieties. The +6°C pretreatment and no pretreatment had the same effect on the anther culture response of cv. Pito, while with cv. Danva pretreatment at +6°C promoted embryogenesis. The +30°C pretreatment had no positive effect on anther culture response on either cultivar. The effect of maltose, melibiose and mannitol individually and in combination with sucrose were compared to normal sucrose medium in cv. Pito anther cultures. Anthers incubated on normal sucrose medium gave the highest embryoid and plant yields; the second highest plant yields were obtained on pure maltose medium. Strong seasonal variation was observed throughout the year in cv. Pito anther cultures. The percentage of anthers producing embryoids ranged from 15–20% during September and October to just 1–3% from February through May. The annual average embryoid production rate was 6.18%.     

High temperature enhances ethylene promotion of anther filament growth in Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var. gemmifera)

A study was made of the effect of high temperature on the growth response of Brussels sprout filaments to ethylene. Filaments with or without the anthers attached were incubated continuously at 25 °C or 35 °C for 7 days or for 2 days at 35 °C followed by 5 days at 25 °C. Growth was reduced during both 35 °C treatments compared to that of filaments at continuous 25 °C. Ethylene had little effect on filament growth at continuous 25 °C, whereas with treatment for either 2 or 7 days at 35 °C ethylene promoted filament growth considerably. Thus ethylene effectively overcame the growth inhibition induced by the 35 °C treatment.High temperature treatments reduced ethylene production from filaments alone, and from filaments with anthers attached. The ethylene biosynthesis inhibitor aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) and the ethylene action inhibitor AgNO₃ enhanced filament growth at 25 °C but had little or no effect at 35 °C. The relevance of temperature to ethylene sensitivity is discussed in relation to filament growth and to other plant processes in general.