The root as a drill: An ethylene-auxin interaction facilitates root penetration in soil

Plant roots forage the soil for water and nutrients and overcome the soil’s physical compactness. Roots are endowed with a mechanism that allows them to penetrate and grow in dense media such as soil. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying this process are still poorly understood. The nature of the media in which roots grow adds to the difficulty to in situ analyze the mechanisms underlying root penetration. Inhibition of ethylene perception by application of 1-methyl cyclopropene (1-MCP) to tomato seedlings nearly abolished the root penetration in Soilrite. The reversal of this process by auxin indicated operation of an auxin-ethylene signaling pathway in the regulation of root penetration. The tomato pct1–2 mutant that exhibits an enhanced polar transport of auxin required higher doses of 1-MCP to inhibit root penetration, indicating a pivotal role of auxin transport in this process. In this update we provide a brief review of our current understanding of molecular processes underlying root penetration in higher plants.     

Ethylene Interacts with Auxin in Regulating Developmental Attenuation of Gravitropism in Flax Root

Previous research shows that gravity-sensing in flax (Linum usitatissimum) root is initiated during seed imbibition and precedes root emergence. In this study we investigated the developmental attenuation of flax root gravitropism post-germination and the involvement of ethylene. Gravity response deteriorated significantly from 3 to 11?h after root emergence, which occurred at around 19?h after imbibition (that is, from “age” 22 to 30?h). Although the root elongation rate increased from 22 to 30?h, the gravitropic curving rate declined steadily. Older roots were able to tolerate higher levels of exogenous IAA before inhibition of elongation and gravitropism occurred. The age-dependent effect of IAA on root growth and gravitropism suggests that young roots are more sensitive to auxin and respond to a smaller vertical auxin gradient than older roots upon horizontal gravistimulation. The ethylene synthesis inhibitor AVG (2-aminoethoxyvinyl glycine, 10?μM) or ethylene action inhibitor Ag⁺ (10?μM) stimulated gravitropic curvature of 30?h roots by 24 and 32%, respectively, but had no effect on 22?h roots, suggesting that as roots age, ethylene begins to play a role in root gravitropism. The auxin transport inhibitor NPA (N-naphthylphthalamic acid, 50?μM) reduced gravitropic curvature of 30?h roots by 24% but had no effect on 22?h roots. On the other hand, treating roots simultaneously with the auxin transport inhibitor and ethylene synthesis or action inhibitor stimulated gravitropic curvature of 30?h roots but not 22?h roots. Taken together, these data indicate that as roots develop, their weakened gravity response is due to decreased auxin sensitivity and possibly auxin transport regulated by ethylene.     

Effects of Ethylene on the Kinetics of Curvature and Auxin Redistribution in Gravistimulated Roots of Zea mays

We tested the involvement of ethylene in maize (Zea mays L.) root gravitropism by measuring the kinetics of curvature and lateral auxin movement in roots treated with ethylene, inhibitors of ethylene synthesis, or inhibitors of ethylene action. In the presence of ethylene the latent period of gravitropic curvature appeared to be increased somewhat. However, ethylene-treated roots continued to curve after control roots had reached their final angle of curvature. Consequently, maximum curvature in the presence of ethylene was much greater in ethylene-treated roots than in controls. Inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis or action had effects on the kinetics of curvature opposite to that of ethylene, i.e. the latent period appeared to be shortened somewhat while total curvature was reduced relative to that of controls. Label from applied ³H-indole-3-acetic acid was preferentially transported toward the lower side of stimulated roots. In parallel with effects on curvature, ethylene treatment delayed the development of gravity-induced asymmetric auxin movement across the root but extended its duration once initiated. The auxin transport inhibitor, 1-N-naphthylphthalamic acid reduced both gravitropic curvature and the effect of ethylene on curvature. Since neither ethylene nor inhibitors of ethylene biosynthesis or action prevented curvature, we conclude that ethylene does not mediate the primary differential growth response causing curvature. Because ethylene affects curvature and auxin transport in parallel, we suggest that ethylene modifies curvature by affecting gravity-induced lateral transport of auxin, perhaps by interfering with adaptation of the auxin transport system to the gravistimulus.     

RCN1-regulated phosphatase activity and EIN2 modulate hypocotyl gravitropism by a mechanism that does not require ethylene signaling

The roots curl in naphthylphthalamic acid1 (rcn1) mutant of Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana) has altered auxin transport, gravitropism, and ethylene response, providing an opportunity to analyze the interplay between ethylene and auxin in control of seedling growth. Roots of rcn1 seedlings were previously shown to have altered auxin transport, growth, and gravitropism, while rcn1 hypocotyl elongation exhibited enhanced ethylene response. We have characterized auxin transport and gravitropism phenotypes of rcn1 hypocotyls and have explored the roles of auxin and ethylene in controlling these phenotypes. As in roots, auxin transport is increased in etiolated rcn1 hypocotyls. Hypocotyl gravity response is accelerated, although overall elongation is reduced, in etiolated rcn1 hypocotyls. Etiolated, but not light grown, rcn1 seedlings also overproduce ethylene, and mutations conferring ethylene insensitivity restore normal hypocotyl elongation to rcn1. Auxin transport is unaffected by treatment with the ethylene precursor 1-aminocyclopropane carboxylic acid in etiolated hypocotyls of wild-type and rcn1 seedlings. Surprisingly, the ethylene insensitive2-1 (ein2-1) and ein2-5 mutations dramatically reduce gravitropic bending in hypocotyls. However, the ethylene resistant1-3 (etr1-3) mutation does not significantly affect hypocotyl gravity response. Furthermore, neither the etr1 nor the ein2 mutation abrogates the accelerated gravitropism observed in rcn1 hypocotyls, indicating that both wild-type gravity response and enhanced gravity response in rcn1 do not require an intact ethylene-signaling pathway. We therefore conclude that the RCN1 protein affects overall hypocotyl elongation via negative regulation of ethylene synthesis in etiolated seedlings, and that RCN1 and EIN2 modulate hypocotyl gravitropism and ethylene responses through independent pathways.     

Auxin distribution and transport during embryogenesis and seed germi-nation of Arabidopsis

INTRODUCTIONAuxin plays an important role in regu1ating celldivision, e1ongation and differentiatiou, vascular tis-sue fOrmation[1], pollen deve1opment[2] and 1eafyhead fOrmation[3]. Adrin polar transport is be-1ieved to invohe in a variety of important growthand developmenial processes, including the patternfOrmation of eInbryO, leaf morphogenesis and theroot gravity response[4--8]. Auxin po1ar transportinhibitor has been proved essential illterference ofataln transport leading to patte…     

Complex regulation of Arabidopsis AGR1/PIN2-mediated root gravitropic response and basipetal auxin transport by cantharidin-sensitive protein phosphatases

Polar auxin transport, mediated by two distinct plasma membrane-localized auxin influx and efflux carrier proteins/complexes, plays an important role in many plant growth and developmental processes including tropic responses to gravity and light, development of lateral roots and patterning in embryogenesis. We have previously shown that the Arabidopsis AGRAVITROPIC 1/PIN2 gene encodes an auxin efflux component regulating root gravitropism and basipetal auxin transport. However, the regulatory mechanism underlying the function of AGR1/PIN2 is largely unknown. Recently, protein phosphorylation and dephosphorylation mediated by protein kinases and phosphatases, respectively, have been implicated in regulating polar auxin transport and root gravitropism. Here, we examined the effects of chemical inhibitors of protein phosphatases on root gravitropism and basipetal auxin transport, as well as the expression pattern of AGR1/PIN2 gene and the localization of AGR1/PIN2 protein. We also examined the effects of inhibitors of vesicle trafficking and protein kinases. Our data suggest that protein phosphatases, sensitive to cantharidin and okadaic acid, are likely involved in regulating AGR1/PIN2-mediated root basipetal auxin transport and gravitropism, as well as auxin response in the root central elongation zone (CEZ). BFA-sensitive vesicle trafficking may be required for the cycling of AGR1/PIN2 between plasma membrane and the BFA compartment, but not for the AGR1/PIN2-mediated root basipetal auxin transport and auxin response in CEZ cells.     

Flavonoids redirect PIN-mediated polar auxin fluxes during root gravitropic responses

The rate, polarity, and symmetry of the flow of the plant hormone auxin are determined by the polar cellular localization of PIN-FORMED (PIN) auxin efflux carriers. Flavonoids, a class of secondary plant metabolites, have been suspected to modulate auxin transport and tropic responses. Nevertheless, the identity of specific flavonoid compounds involved and their molecular function and targets in vivo are essentially unknown. Here we show that the root elongation zone of agravitropic pin2/eir1/wav6/agr1 has an altered pattern and amount of flavonol glycosides. Application of nanomolar concentrations of flavonols to pin2 roots is sufficient to partially restore root gravitropism. By employing a quantitative cell biological approach, we demonstrate that flavonoids partially restore the formation of lateral auxin gradients in the absence of PIN2. Chemical complementation by flavonoids correlates with an asymmetric distribution of the PIN1 protein. pin2 complementation probably does not result from inhibition of auxin efflux, as supply of the auxin transport inhibitor N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid failed to restore pin2 gravitropism. We propose that flavonoids promote asymmetric PIN shifts during gravity stimulation, thus redirecting basipetal auxin streams necessary for root bending.     

Role of Auxin-Induced Reactive Oxygen Species in Root Gravitropism

We report our studies on root gravitropism indicating that reactive oxygen species (ROS) may function as a downstream component in auxin-mediated signal transduction. A transient increase in the intracellular concentration of ROS in the convex endodermis resulted from either gravistimulation or unilateral application of auxin to vertical roots. Root bending was also brought about by unilateral application of ROS to vertical roots pretreated with the auxin transport inhibitor N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid. Furthermore, the scavenging of ROS by antioxidants (N-acetylcysteine, ascorbic acid, and Trolox) inhibited root gravitropism. These results indicate that the generation of ROS plays a role in root gravitropism.     

Negative gravitropic response of roots directs auxin flow to control root gravitropism

Root tip is capable of sensing and adjusting its growth direction in response to gravity, a phenomenon known as root gravitropism. Previously, we have shown that negative gravitropic response of roots (NGR) is essential for the positive gravitropic response of roots. Here, we show that NGR, a plasma membrane protein specifically expressed in root columella and lateral root cap cells, controls the positive root gravitropic response by regulating auxin efflux carrier localization in columella cells and the direction of lateral auxin flow in response to gravity. Pharmacological and genetic studies show that the negative root gravitropic response of the ngr mutants depends on polar auxin transport in the root elongation zone. Cell biology studies further demonstrate that polar localization of the auxin efflux carrier PIN3 in root columella cells and asymmetric lateral auxin flow in the root tip in response to gravistimulation is reversed in the atngr1;2;3 triple mutant. Furthermore, simultaneous mutations of three PIN genes expressed in root columella cells impaired the negative root gravitropic response of the atngr1;2;3 triple mutant. Our work revealed a critical role of NGR in root gravitropic response and provided an insight of the early events and molecular basis of the positive root gravitropism.     

Sites of auxin action: regulation of geotropism, growth, and ethylene production by inhibitors of auxin transport

The inhibitors of auxin transport-NPA (N-1-naphthylphthalamic acid), DPX1840 (3,3a-dihydro-2-(p-methoxyphenyl)-8H-pyrazolo[5,1-a] isoindol-8-one), and TIBA (2,3,5-triiodobenzoic acid)-inhibited geotropism in roots of intact Pisum sativum L. seedlings. NPA and DPX1840 also caused cellular swelling in the roots. The swelling was due to a greater inhibition of elongation than increase in weight and looked identical to the one caused by ethylene. However, ethylene did not act as an intermediate in the action of auxin transport inhibitors because all three failed to stimulate ethylene production and some of their growth-inhibiting effect was retained in the presence of saturating levels of ethylene. In the presence of 10 mum indoleacetic acid the growth-inhibiting effect of auxin transport inhibitors was lost after 18 hours. On the other hand, auxin transport inhibitors did not interfere with the ability of auxin to promote ethylene production. Growth inhibition caused by auxin transport inhibitors was reversible. Pea root sections resumed normal growth following flushing of treated sections with inhibitor-free solutions. Experiments with (14)C-2, 4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid revealed that the herbicide and auxin transport inhibitors may have the same binding site. It was concluded that a class of structurally dissimilar compounds may share a similar physiological role since they all appear to compete with endogenous auxin for certain binding sites and they all have similar growth-regulating activities.     

Separating the roles of acropetal and basipetal auxin transport on gravitropism with mutations in two Arabidopsis multidrug resistance-like ABC transporter genes

Two Arabidopsis thaliana ABC transporter genes linked to auxin transport by various previous results were studied in a reverse-genetic fashion. Mutations in Multidrug Resistance-Like1 (MDR1) reduced acropetal auxin transport in roots by 80% without affecting basipetal transport. Conversely, mutations in MDR4 blocked 50% of basipetal transport without affecting acropetal transport. Developmental and auxin distribution phenotypes associated with these altered auxin flows were studied with a high-resolution morphometric system and confocal microscopy, respectively. Vertically grown mdr1 roots produced positive and negative curvatures threefold greater than the wild type, possibly due to abnormal auxin distribution observed in the elongation zone. However, upon 90 degrees reorientation, mdr1 gravitropism was inseparable from the wild type. Thus, acropetal auxin transport maintains straight growth but contributes surprisingly little to gravitropism. Conversely, vertically maintained mdr4 roots grew as straight as the wild type, but their gravitropism was enhanced. Upon reorientation, curvature in this mutant developed faster, was distributed more basally, and produced a greater total angle than the wild type. An amplified auxin asymmetry may explain the mdr4 hypertropism. Double mutant analysis indicated that the two auxin transport streams are more independent than interdependent. The hypothesis that flavanols regulate MDR-dependent auxin transport was supported by the epistatic relationship of mdr4 to the tt4 phenylpropanoid pathway mutation.     

Extracellular ATP inhibits root gravitropism at concentrations that inhibit polar auxin transport

Raising the level of extracellular ATP to mM concentrations similar to those found inside cells can block gravitropism of Arabidopsis roots. When plants are grown in Murashige and Skoog medium supplied with 1 mM ATP, their roots grow horizontally instead of growing straight down. Medium with 2 mM ATP induces root curling, and 3 mM ATP stimulates lateral root growth. When plants are transferred to medium containing exogenous ATP, the gravity response is reduced or in some cases completely blocked by ATP. Equivalent concentrations of ADP or inorganic phosphate have slight but usually statistically insignificant effects, suggesting the specificity of ATP in these responses. The ATP effects may be attributable to the disturbance of auxin distribution in roots by exogenously applied ATP, because extracellular ATP can alter the pattern of auxin-induced gene expression in DR5-beta-glucuronidase transgenic plants and increase the response sensitivity of plant roots to exogenously added auxin. The presence of extracellular ATP also decreases basipetal auxin transport in a dose-dependent fashion in both maize (Zea mays) and Arabidopsis roots and increases the retention of [(3)H]indole-3-acetic acid in root tips of maize. Taken together, these results suggest that the inhibitory effects of extracellular ATP on auxin distribution may happen at the level of auxin export. The potential role of the trans-plasma membrane ATP gradient in auxin export and plant root gravitropism is discussed.     

Root gravitropism requires lateral root cap and epidermal cells for transport and response to a mobile auxin signal

Re-orientation of Arabidopsis seedlings induces a rapid, asymmetric release of the growth regulator auxin from gravity-sensing columella cells at the root apex. The resulting lateral auxin gradient is hypothesized to drive differential cell expansion in elongation-zone tissues. We mapped those root tissues that function to transport or respond to auxin during a gravitropic response. Targeted expression of the auxin influx facilitator AUX1 demonstrated that root gravitropism requires auxin to be transported via the lateral root cap to all elongating epidermal cells. A three-dimensional model of the root elongation zone predicted that AUX1 causes the majority of auxin to accumulate in the epidermis. Selectively disrupting the auxin responsiveness of expanding epidermal cells by expressing a mutant form of the AUX/IAA17 protein, axr3-1, abolished root gravitropism. We conclude that gravitropic curvature in Arabidopsis roots is primarily driven by the differential expansion of epidermal cells in response to an influx-carrier-dependent auxin gradient.     

Mechanisms of Root Penetration of Seeds Germinating on the Soil Surface

Methods used by seedlings to affix themselves to soil and toproduce sufficient force to counterbalance the penetrating radicle,were studied. Seeds of five taxa—macaroni wheat, cucumber,lentil, bitter vetch and the sorghum hybrid Vidan—weresown on the surface of sand and sandy loam. Roots of lentiland bitter vetch did not affix themselves and penetrate intothe soil. In lentil, putting weights on the seeds or transferringgerminating seedlings to rims of holes, enabled subsequent rootpenetration. Roots of Vidan grew horizontally a few cm on thesoil, and mostly in sandy loam anchoring by root hairs occurred,followed by a downturning of the root tip and penetration. Asmall viscous drop on the tips of Vidan root hairs apparentlyaids adherence to soil particles. In cucumber, the root hairsanchored first, followed by the thin lateral roots, and finallypenetration of the main root occurred. In wheat, the three seminalroots supported each other during superficial penetration oftheir root tips and this enabled the root hairs to anchor, providingsupport for the further penetration of the roots in the soil. seed germination, root penetration, soil     

Effect of Competition and Treatment with Inhibitor of Ethylene Perception on Growth and Hormone Content of Lettuce Plants

We elucidated the effect of increased planting density (single and grouped competing plants) on concentrations of auxin, abscisic acid, and cytokinins in normal lettuce plants and in those with ethylene perception inhibited by 1-methylcyclopropene (1-MCP). An attempt was made to relate the changes in hormone concentration induced by competition and inhibition of ethylene sensitivity to growth responses of lettuce planting. The results showed changes in concentrations of auxins, cytokinins, and ABA in the response of lettuce to crowding. Accumulation of ABA in shoots was likely to contribute to inhibition of transpiration of the plants grown in the presence of neighbors. This assumption was supported by the results of application of an inhibitor of ABA synthesis (fluridone and carotenoid biosynthesis herbicide) resulting in increased transpiration of grouped, but not single plants. Increased planting density led to the decline in root auxins paralleled by inhibition of root growth. This effect was likely to be due to decreased auxin transport to the roots from the shoots suggested by accumulation of auxins in the shoots and inhibition of root growth by application of the auxin transport inhibitor [N-(1-naphtyl)phtalamic acid (NPA)]. Importance of the changes in hormone concentrations was confirmed by data showing that disturbance of auxin and cytokinin distribution detected in MCP-treated plants was accompanied by corresponding modification of the growth response.

     

Tomato root growth, gravitropism, and lateral development: correlation with auxin transport.

Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum, Mill.) roots were analyzed during growth on agar plates. Growth of these roots was inhibited by the auxin transport inhibitors naphthylphthalamic acid (NPA) and semicarbazone derivative I (SCB-1). The effect of auxin transport inhibitors on root gravitropism was analyzed by measurement of the angle of gravitropic curvature after the roots were reoriented 90 degrees from the vertical. NPA and SCB-1 abolished both the response of these roots to gravity and the formation of lateral roots, with SCB-1 being the more effective at inhibition. Auxins also inhibited root growth. Both auxins tested has a slight effect on the gravity response, but this effect is probably indirect, since auxins reduced the growth rate. Auxins also stimulated lateral root growth at concentration where primary root growth was inhibited. When roots were treated with both IAA and NPA simultaneously, a cumulative inhibition of root growth was found. When both compounds were applied together, analysis of gravitropism and lateral root formation indicated that the dominant effect was exerted by auxin transport inhibitors. Together, these data suggest a model for the role of auxin transport in controlling both primary and lateral root growth.     

Detailed quantitative analysis of architectural traits of basal roots of young seedlings of bean in response to auxin and ethylene

Vertical placement of roots within the soil determines their efficiency of acquisition of heterogeneous belowground resources. This study quantifies the architectural traits of seedling basal roots of bean (Phaseolus vulgaris), and shows that the distribution of root tips at different depths results from a combined effect of both basal root growth angle (BRGA) and root length. Based on emergence locations, the basal roots are classified in three zones, upper, middle, and lower, with each zone having distinct architectural traits. The genotypes characterized as shallow on BRGA alone produced basal roots with higher BRGA, greater length, and more vertically distributed roots than deep genotypes, thereby establishing root depth as a robust measure of root architecture. Although endogenous indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) levels were similar in all genotypes, IAA and 1-N-naphthylphthalamic acid treatments showed different root growth responses to auxin because shallow and deep genotypes tended to have optimal and supraoptimal auxin levels, respectively, for root growth in controls. While IAA increased ethylene production, ethylene also increased IAA content. Although differences in acropetal IAA transport to roots of different zones can account for some of the differences in auxin responsiveness among roots of different emergence positions, this study shows that mutually dependent ethylene-auxin interplay regulates BRGA and root growth differently in different genotypes. Root length inhibition by auxin was reversed by an ethylene synthesis inhibitor. However, IAA caused smaller BRGA in deep genotypes, but not in shallow genotypes, which only responded to IAA in the presence of an ethylene inhibitor.     

The Microtubule-Associated Protein END BINDING1b, Auxin, and Root Responses to Mechanical Cues

The ability of roots to penetrate through the soil and maneuver around rocks and other impenetrable objects requires a system for modulating output from mechanosensory response networks. The microtubule-associated protein END BINDING1b (EB1b) has a role in this process; it represses root responses to mechanical cues. In this study, a possible relationship between EB1b and auxin during root responses to mechanical cues was investigated. We found that eb1b-1-mutant roots are more sensitive than wild-type roots to chemicals that disrupt auxin transport, whereas the roots of mutants with defects in auxin transport are resistant to these treatments. Using seedlings that express the auxin-sensitive DR5rev::GFP construct, we also found that wild-type and eb1b-1 roots treated with the auxin transport inhibitor naphthylphthalamic acid exhibited dose-dependent reductions in basipetal auxin transport that were indistinguishable from each other. The responses of eb1b-1 roots to mechanical cues were also enhanced over wild type in the presence of p -chlorophenoxyisobutyric acid, a chemical thought to inhibit auxin signaling. Finally, roots of eb1b-1 and wild-type plants exhibited slight increases in loop formation in response to increasing levels of exogenously applied indole-3-acetic acid or 1-naphthalene acetic acid. Taken together, these results suggest that the repression of loop formation by EB1b and auxin transport/signaling occurs by different mechanisms.