Internal dynamics of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor in reconstituted membranes

The structure and 1H/2H exchange kinetics of affinity-purified nAChR reconstituted into egg phosphatidylcholine membranes with increasing levels of either dioleoylphosphatidic acid (DOPA) or cholesterol (Chol) have been examined using infrared spectroscopy. All spectra of the reconstituted nAChR membranes recorded after 72 h in 2H2O exhibit comparable amide I band shapes, suggesting a similar secondary structure for the nAChR in each lipid environment. Increasing levels of either DOPA or Chol, however, lead to an increasing intensity of the amide II band, indicating a decreasing proportion of nAChR peptide hydrogens that have exchanged for deuterium. Spectra recorded as a function of time after exposure of the nAChR to 2H2O show that the presence of either lipid slows down the 1H/2H exchange of those peptide hydrogens that normally exchange on the minutes to hours time scale. The slowing of peptide 1H/2H exchange correlates with both an increasing ability of the nAChR to undergo agonist-induced conformational change [Baenziger, J. E., Morris, M.-L., Darsaut, T. E., and Ryan, S. E. (1999) in preparation] and possibly a decreasing membrane fluidity. Our data suggest that lipid composition dependent changes in nAChR peptide 1H/2H exchange kinetics reflect altered internal dynamics of the nAChR. Lipids may influence protein function by changing the internal dynamics of integral membrane proteins.     

The lipid environment of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor in native and reconstituted membranes

Detailed knowledge of the membrane framework surrounding the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) is key to an understanding of its structure, dynamics, and function. Recent theoretical models discuss the structural relationship between the AChR and the lipid bilayer. Independent experimental data on the composition, metabolism, and dynamics of the AChR lipid environment are analyzed in the first part of the review. The composition of the lipids in which the transmembrane AChR chains are inserted bears considerable resemblance among species, perhaps providing this evolutionarily conserved protein with an adequate milieu for its optimal functioning. The effects of lipids on the latter are discussed in the second part of the review. The third part focuses on the information gained on the dynamics of AChR and lipids in the membrane, a section that also covers the physical properties and interactions between the protein, its immediate annulus, and the bulk lipid bilayer.     

The effect of amantadine on nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAchR) in reconstituted membranes

The antiviral drug amantadine is also a potent neuromuscular blocking agent. When the nicotinic receptor from a Torpedinidae species is reconstituted into soybean liposomes, the binding of α-bungarotoxin is not altered although the carbamylcholine induced radioactive cation influx is blocked.By studying cation fluxes in amantadine preincubated membranes previously exposed to different concentrations of carbamylcholine for different periods of time, we have shown that the drug accelerates the conversion of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor from a state of low affinity to a state of high affinity for carbamyalcholine, a phenomenon correlated with receptor desensitization. The drug did not induce such a shift by itself.The present data and those by Earnest et al. (Biochemistry22, 5523–5535, 1984) show that the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor reconstituted into liposomes is a good model for studying the effects of noncompetitive blockers of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor function.     

Lipid-protein interactions in reconstituted membranes containing acetylcholine receptor

Functional membranes containing purified Torpedo californica acetylcholine receptor and dioleoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC) were prepared by a cholate dialysis procedure with lipid to protein ratios of 100-400 to 1 (mol/mol). Spin-labeled lipids were incorporated into the reconstituted membranes and into native membranes prepared from Torpedo electroplax, and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra were recorded between 0 and 20 degrees C. The spin-labels included nitroxide derivatives of stearic acid (16-doxylstearic acid), androstane, phosphatidylcholine (PC), phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), phosphatidylserine (PS), and phosphatidic acid (PA). The phospholipid spin-labels had 16-doxylstearic acid in the sn-2 position. All the spectra showed two components corresponding to a relatively mobile bilayer component and a motionally restricted "protein-perturbed" component. The relative amounts of mobile and perturbed components were quantitated by spectral subtraction and integration techniques. The mobile/perturbed ratio was somewhat temperature dependent, and the results are discussed in terms of exchange between mobile and perturbed environments. Plots of the mobile/perturbed ratios vs. lipid/protein ratios at 1 degree C gave straight lines from which the relative binding affinity of each spin-label and the number of perturbed lipids per receptor protein could be calculated. All the spin-labels gave similar values for the number of perturbed lipids (40 +/- 7), a number close to the number of lipids that will fit around the intramembranous perimeter of the receptor. The affinities of the spin-labeled lipids for the receptor relative to DOPC were androstane (K = 4.3) congruent to 16-doxylstearic acid (4.1) greater than PA (2.7) greater than PE (1.1) approximately PC (1.0) approximately PS (0.7). The lipids having the highest affinity for the acetylcholine receptor were also those that have the largest effects on the ion flux functional properties of the receptor, and the results are discussed in terms of lipid effects on receptor function.     

The effects of amantadine on liposomally reconstituted nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

The effects of amantadine on liposomally reconstituted nicotinic acetylcholine receptor function were studied. At 1 × 10^?4M, the drug blocked 85% of the carbamylcholine-induced cation influx into liposomes, but left 90% of the αbungarotoxin binding intact. In addition, amantadine was shown to be a non-competitive inhibitor of membrane bound acetylcholinesterase. These experiments are relevant to the mechanism of action of amantadine at the motor end plate, where it produces electrophysiological changes compatible with an inhibition of cholinergic agonist mediated ion flux.     

Segregation of phosphatidic acid-rich domains in reconstituted acetylcholine receptor membranes

Purified Acetylcholine Receptor (AcChR) from Torpedo has been reconstituted at low (approximately 1:3500) and high (approximately 1:560) protein to phospholipid molar ratios into vesicles containing egg phosphatidylcholine, cholesterol, and different dimyristoyl phospholipids (dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylglycerol and phosphatidic acid) as probes to explore the effects of the protein on phospholipid organization by differential scanning calorimetry, infrared, and fluorescence spectroscopy. All the experimental results indicate that the presence of the AcChR protein, even at the lower protein to phospholipid molar ratio, directs lateral phase separation of the monoanionic phosphoryl form of the phosphatidic acid probe, causing the formation of specific phosphatidic acid-rich lipid domains that become segregated from the bulk lipids and whose extent (phosphatidic acid sequestered into the domain, out of the total population in the vesicle) is protein-dependent. Furthermore, fluorescence energy transfer using the protein tryptophan residues as energy donors and the fluorescence probes trans-parinaric acid or diphenylhexatriene as acceptors, establishes that the AcChR is included in the domain. Other dimyristoyl phospholipid probes (phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylglycerol) under identical conditions could not mimic the protein-induced domain formation observed with the phosphatidic acid probe and result in ideal mixing of all lipid components in the reconstituted vesicles. Likewise, in the absence of protein, all the phospholipid probes, including phosphatidic acid, exhibit ideal mixing behavior. Since phosphatidic acid and cholesterol have been implicated in functional modulation of the reconstituted AcChR, it is suggested that such a specific modulatory role could be mediated by domain segregation of the relevant lipid classes.     

Electron spin resonance studies of the membranes of the cellular slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum.

Doxylstearic acid spin labels are used to study the fluidity of the membranes of the cellular slime mold, Dictyostelium discoideum. The tau omicron value of the wild-type cell membrane is close to that of egg lecithin indicating a rather fluid membrane. No detectable change in the fluidity of the bulk lipids at the 16-carbon depth occurs during differentiation of the myxamoebae into stalk and spore cells despite reported changes in the individual lipid components. The results of studies on temperature-sensitive and aggregationless mutants are also presented.     

Electron spin resonance of some bacterial respiratory membranes

Electron spin resonance measurements have been carried out on extracts from eight different bacterial respiratory membranes. The available evidence suggests that the copper is probably associated with the terminal cytochromes. From the Fe^3* (g=4.3) signal, copper: cytochrome ratios and the absence of any detectable copper in the ESR spectra at 77° K under varying oxidation and reduction conditions, it is concluded that most of the copper in the membranes is paired with other coppers or more probably with a high-spin ferric ion with the copper-metal distance not greater than 5 Å.     

Electron spin resonance spin label studies of intercalation of nitrobenzene in DNA.

Nitrobenzene-DNA intercalation mechanisms have been studied by means of electron spin resonance spin label techniques. Of the seven derivatives prepared and examined, 2,4-dinitrobenzene analogs with amine linkage to the nitroxide reporter demonstrate the strongest binding with DNA by intercalation, and the reporter nitroxide is oriented 45 ° to the plane of the benzene ring and is due primarily to the steric hindrance of the 2-nitro substituent. This binding is found to be largely dependent upon the number of nitrosubstituents, their relative position on the benzene ring, and the type of linkage between the ligand and the nitroxide reporter, suggesting that polarization bonding is a major driving force in their complex formation with DNA.     

Electron spin resonance studies of starch-water-probe interactions

Interactions between starch, water and stable nitroxide radicals were studied by electron spin resonance. The motional properties of TEMPO, 4-(2-bromoacetamido) TEMPO (BrAcTEMPO), 5-DOXYL-stearic acid and 16-DOXYL-stearic acid probes as well as a label covalently attached to amylopectin were investigated in concentrated (10–50%) starch-water systems as a function of temperature, concentration of polymer and storage period. Compared with the free probes in solution, TEMPO and BrAcTEMPO showed slower tumbling rates in starch-water dispersions or gels, suggesting a higher microviscosity in the probe's environment. The spectra, however, remained motionally narrowed. In contrast, the three line spectra of the fatty acid probes in solution became highly anisotropic in the presence of starch. The results indicated that these probes were highly immobilized at room temperature by the starch granules or by the polysaccharide gel matrix. These interactions are weakened at elevated temperatures where the spectra revealed the presence of both motionally narrowed and motionally slowed spin populations. The nitroxide label on the amylopectin exhibited a much slower mobility than the corresponding free probe as well as being found to be more motionally sensitive to temperature changes; such motional behavior was interpreted as reflecting contributions from rotation of the label around the chain backbone as well as local segmental motion of the polymer chain itself. Starch gels doped with free probes or the spin labelled amylopectin displayed no change in the motion of the nitroxide group upon storage, i.e. the tumbling rates did not follow the time-dependent conformational changes associated with the retrogradation phenomenon.     

Functional immobilisation of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor in tethered lipid membranes

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor from Torpedo was immobilised in tethered membranes. Surface plasmon resonance was used to quantify the binding of ligands and antibodies to the receptor. The orientation and structural integrity of the surface-reconstituted receptor was probed using monoclonal antibodies, demonstrating that approximately 65% of the receptors present their ligand-binding site towards the lumen of the flow cell and that at least 85% of these receptors are structurally intact. The conformation of the receptor in tethered membranes was investigated with Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and found to be practically identical to that of receptors reconstituted in lipid vesicles. The affinity of small receptor ligands was determined in a competition assay against a monoclonal antibody directed against the ligand-binding site which yielded dissociation constants in agreement with radioligand binding assays. The presented method for the functional immobilisation of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor in tethered membranes might be generally applicable to other membrane proteins.     

Outer membrane of Salmonella typhimurium. Electron spin resonance studies

The supramolecular structure of the outer membrane of Salmonella typhimurium that produces an Rc-type lipopolysaccharide was studied by adding spin-labeled fatty acid probes to membranes as well as model bilayers. Lipopolysaccharide of this organism apparently formed a bilayer structure in 0.2 M NaCl/0.01 M MgCl₂, and the electron spin resonance spectra suggested that the motion of the segments of hydrocarbon chains near the carboxyl end was quite restricted even at high temperature; this is presumably due to the anchoring of more than a dozen fatty acid residues to a single backbone structure. In the presence of Mg²⁺, we could produce lipopolysaccharide-phospholipid mixed bilayers containing up to 50% (by weight) lipopolysaccharide. Their spectra showed no sign of major heterogeneity, and the maximum hypertine splitting values were considerably larger than in phospholipid-only liposomes; these results suggest that the two components are finely interspersed and that the mobility of phospholipid hydrocarbons in severely restricted by the hydrocarbon chains of lipopolysaccharide. In spite of the presence of lipopolysaccharide in an amount equal to or exceeding that of phospholipids, the outer membrane produced spectra remarkably similar to those of the inner membrane, which does not contain lipopolysaccharide, and there was little sign of immobilization by lipopolysaccharides. Signals corresponding to the pure lipopolysaccharide phase were not detected, either. These results suggest that the phospholipids and lipopolysaccharides are segregated into separate domains in the outer membrane, and the fatty acid probes enter almost exclusively into the phospholipid domains. This conclusion was fully corroborated by determining, through the exchange broadening of line width, the total area of the domains that accommodated the spin label probes.     

Electron spin resonance evidence for vertical asymmetry in animal cell membranes.

Two electron spin resonance (ESR) spin labels were used to monitor the physical state of bacterial and animal cell membranes: 5N10, a nitroxide derivative of decane, and 12NS-GA, a glucosamine derivative of 12-nitroxide stearic acid. Spectra were recorded at 1 degrees C intervals from approximately 5 to 45 degrees C. Arrhenius plots of log hH/hP vs. 1/K were obtained by measuring the amplitudes of the hydrocarbon and water signals, hH and hP, respectively. Two discontinuities in the Arrhenius plot (at characteristic temperatures t1 and th) were observed with bacterial cell membranes independent of the spin label employed. Analysis of sealed animal cell membrane samples revealed four characteristic temperatures when the hydrophobic spin lable 5N10 was used, but only two when the amphiphilic spin label 12NS-GA was used. The specific set of characteristic temperatures revealed with 12NS-GA depended on whether the membrane preparation was inside out (ISO) or right side out (RSO). Analysis of Newcastle disease virus, a source of RSO plasma membrane derived from host, revealed two characteristic temperatures at approximately 14 and 33 degrees C. Analysis of phagosomes, a source of ISO plasma membrane derived from LM cells, revealed two characteristic temperatures at approximately 23 and 38 degrees C. When unsealed or disrupted membrane preparations were spin labeled with 12NS-GA, both sets (RSO and ISO) of characteristic temperatures were revealed. The results indicate that the inner and outer monolayers of animal cell membranes are physically distinct and that the glycosylated spin label, 12NS-GA, is apparently restricted in its ability to flip across the membrane bilayer. In this study, characteristic temperatures were pinpointed by computer analysis of the ESR spectral data.     

Activation and inactivation kinetics of Torpedo californica acetylcholine receptor in reconstituted membranes

By use of a quench-flow technique to measure tracer ion flux rates in a physiologically significant time domain, the kinetics of activation and inactivation of purified reconstituted acetylcholine receptor (AChR) were investigated. After solubilization in sodium cholate, purification by affinity chromatography, and reconstitution into soybean lipids, the AChR from Torpedo californica displayed a characteristically fast rate of ion influx measured with 86Rb+. At 4 degrees C 1 mM carbamoylcholine (Carb) stimulated a fast (t1/2 = 7 ms) first-order filling of vesicle internal volume that presented a 10(4)-fold stimulation of ion flux rate by Carb. The concentration dependence of activation was sigmoidal with a half-maximal value at 3 X 10(-4) M Carb. In the presence of Carb, the purified AChR also underwent a two-step inactivation (desensitization) process. Inactivation was measured by preincubating AChR with Carb for various times (milliseconds to minutes) and then measuring the 86Rb+ influx rate. The two inactivation processes were each characterized by a distinct maximum rate (5.3 and 0.10 s-1) and by a different dependence on Carb concentration. The slow phase of inactivation gave a half-maximal rate at 2.5 X 10(-4) M Carb, and the fast inactivation was half-maximal at 1.3 X 10(-3) M Carb. The concentration dependence curves for both inactivation processes were approximately hyperbolic. The results are discussed in terms of models that describe the relationship between ligand binding and the processes of channel activation and desensitization.     

Functional properties of acetylcholine receptor monomeric and dimeric forms in reconstituted membranes

The dimeric and monomeric forms of the acetylcholine receptor from $\text{Torpedo californica}$ electroplax have been purified in the presence of lipids and reconstituted. A spectroscopic method was applied to study the rapid kinetics of cation transport mediated by each of the reconstituted AcChR oligomers. Both the AcChR dimer and monomer responded to carbamylcholine by mediating cation transport on the time scale of a few milliseconds. The responses to carbamylcholine were blocked by histrionicotoxin and by desensitization, demonstrating that both forms manifest pharmacological properties observed $\text{in vivo}$. Analysis of the fast ion transport produced by various agonist concentrations yielded estimated rates of transport through a single receptor channel. These were comparable for the monomer and dimer and in agreement with those obtained for a preparation containing a mixture of both oligomers.     

Outer membrane of Salmonella typhimurium. Electron spin resonance studies.

The supramolecular structure of the outer membrane of Salmonella typhimurium that produces an Rc-type lipopolysaccharide was studied by adding spin-labeled fatty acid probes to membranes as well as model bilayers. Lipopolysaccharide of this organism apparently formed a bilayer structure in 0.2 M NaCl/0.01 M MgCl2, and the electron spin resonance spectra suggested that the motion of the segments of hydrocarbon chains near the carboxyl end was quite restricted even at high temperature; this is presumably due to the anchoring of more than a dozen fatty acid residues to a single backbone structure. In the presence of Mg2+, we could produce lipoplysaccharide-phospholipid mixed bilayers contining up to 50% (by weight) lipoplysaccharide. Their spectra showed no sign of major heterogeneity, and the maximum hyperfine splitting values were considerably larger than in phospholipid-only liposomes; these results suggest that the two components are finely interspersed and that the mobility of phospholipid hydrocarbons is severely restricted by the hydrocarbon chains of lipopolysaccharide. In spite of the presence of lipoplysaccharide in an amount equal to or exceeding that of phospholipids, the outer membrane produced spectra remarkably similar to those of the inner membrane, which does not contain lipoplysaccharide, and there was little sign of immobilization by lipopolysaccharides. Signals corresponding to the pure lipoplysaccharide phase were not detected, either. These results suggest that the phospholipids and lipopolysaccharides are segregated into separate domains in the outer membrane, and the fatty acid probes enter almost exclusively into the phospholipid domains. This conclusion was fully corroborated by determining, through the exchange broadening of line width, the total area of the domains that accommodated the spin label probes.     

Molecular studies of the neuronal nicotinic acetylcholine receptor family

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors on neurons are part of a gene family that includes nicotinic acetylcholine receptors on skeletal muscles and neuronal alpha bungarotoxin-binding proteins that in many species, unlike receptors, do not have an acetylcholine-regulated cation channel. This gene superfamily of ligand-gated receptors also includes receptors for glycine and gamma-aminobutyric acid. Rapid progress on neuronal nicotinic receptors has recently been possible using monoclonal antibodies as probes for receptor proteins and cDNAs as probes for receptor genes. These studies are the primary focus of this review, although other aspects of these receptors are also considered. In birds and mammals, there are subtypes of neuronal nicotinic receptors. All of these receptors differ from nicotinic receptors of muscle pharmacologically (none bind alpha bungarotoxin, and some have very high affinity for nicotine), structurally (having only two types of subunits rather than four), and, in some cases, in functional role (some are located presynaptically). However, there are amino acid sequence homologies between the subunits of these receptors that suggest the location of important functional domains. Sequence homologies also suggest that the subunits of the proteins of this family all evolved from a common ancestral protein subunit. The ligand-gated ion channel characteristic of this superfamily is formed from multiple copies of homologous subunits. Conserved domains responsible for strong stereospecific association of the subunits are probably a fundamental organizing principle of the superfamily. Whereas the structure of muscle-type nicotinic receptors appears to have been established by the time of elasmobranchs and has evolved quite conservatively since then, the evolution of neuronal-type nicotinic receptors appears to be in more rapid flux. Certainly, the studies of these receptors are in rapid flux, with the availability of monoclonal antibody probes for localizing, purifying, and characterizing the proteins, and cDNA probes for determining sequences, localizing mRNAs, expressing functional receptors, and studying genetic regulation. The role of nicotinic receptors in neuromuscular transmission is well understood, but the role of nicotinic receptors in brain function is not. The current deluge of data using antibodies and cDNAs is beginning to come together nicely to describe the structure of these receptors. Soon, these techniques may combine with others to better reveal the functional roles of neuronal nicotinic receptors.