Network regulation of the immune response: modulation of suppressor lymphocytes by alternative signals including contrasuppression

In the preceding paper we demonstrated that comparison of alternative designs for the immune network can be used to examine the functional significance of specified interactions in normal immune responses. In this paper we examine mathematically the functional significance of three interactions affecting the production of suppressor lymphocytes involved in regulation of normal immune responses. The interactions examined in detail are 1) antigenic stimulation of the production of suppressor lymphocytes, 2) idiotypic stimulation of the production of suppressor lymphocytes, and 3) antigenic inhibition of the production of suppressor lymphocytes (i.e., contrasuppression). The results of our analysis suggest that an immune system with only antigenic stimulation of suppressor production is less effective than a system with both antigenic and idiotypic stimulation of suppressor production on the basis of all of the criteria examined in this study. In turn, the latter system is less effective than a system with only idiotypic stimulation of suppressor production. Furthermore, a system with both idiotypic stimulation and antigenic inhibition of suppressor production can be equal or superior to a system with only idiotypic stimulation of suppressor production on the basis of the same criteria. Similar conclusions hold for the comparison of systems in which regulation by the suppressor lymphocytes of interest is exerted upon production of effector molecules rather than upon production of effector lymphocytes, and also for the comparison of systems in which interactions affecting the production of suppressor factors are of interest.     

Antigen-specific inhibition of immune interferon production by suppressor cells of autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Previous work from this laboratory has revealed that spleen and/or lymph node cells from Lewis rats, that have recovered from an acute episode of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), suppress the development of EAE when injected into syngeneic recipients subsequently challenged with myelin basic protein (MBP) in CFA. In an effort to understand the mechanism of this suppression, we measured the production of immune IFN-gamma, which may be required for the induction of an immune response, by EAE effector T cells (which transfer disease) and EAE suppressor cells when cultured in vitro with MBP. We now report that EAE effector T cells produce IFN-gamma when cultured in vitro with MBP. In contrast, spleen cells from recovered rats (which manifest suppressor activity in vivo) do not produce IFN-gamma. Moreover, in cell mixing experiments, these suppressor spleen cells inhibited the production of IFN-gamma by EAE effector cells. This inhibition was not eliminated by the removal of macrophages nor by the inhibition of PG synthesis by indomethacin. Furthermore, the inhibition was shown to be Ag-specific and mediated by nylon-adherent, radiation-sensitive splenic T cells. The findings suggest that suppressor cells regulate EAE by inhibiting IFN-gamma production by effector cells. This inhibition may result in the down-regulation of IFN-gamma-induced expression of class II major histocompatibility Ag on cells of the central nervous system, thus reducing the presentation of tissue-specific Ag (i.e., MBP) to autoreactive lymphocytes.     

Clearance of a persistent paramyxovirus infection is mediated by cellular immune responses but not by serum-neutralizing antibody.

Infection of the lungs of immunodeficient mice with the paramyxovirus simian virus 5 (SV5) was prolonged compared with the time course of infection in immunocompetent mice. Although there was a significant increase in both viral RNA and proteins, little infectious virus was produced. Adoptive transfer of immune lymphocytes (isolated from the spleens of mice previously infected with SV5) but not of nonimmune lymphocytes increased the speed of clearance of virus from the lungs of immunodeficient mice. In contrast, passive transfer of a pool of neutralizing monoclonal antibodies specific for the HN and F glycoproteins of SV5 did not have a significant effect on the speed of clearance of virus. Furthermore, no significant increase in the rate of virus clearance was observed upon adoptive transfer of purified immune B lymphocytes to SV5-infected immunodeficient mice despite production by the mice of high titers of neutralizing antibodies. Evidence is presented that CD8+ effector cells are primarily responsible for the clearance observed. The general significance of these results with respect to immune clearance of persistent virus infections is discussed.     

Regulation of contact sensitivity reaction: contrasuppressor T cells and contrasuppressor factor downregulate efferent T suppressor cells.

Contact sensitivity (CS) reaction mediated by CD 4+8- Th 1 cells is under the control of several antigen-specific regulatory lymphocytes. Reaction is downregulated at the induction stage by T afferent suppressor T cells (Ts-aff) that prevent immunization and at the effector stage by efferent T suppressor cells (Ts-eff) that made immune Th 1 cells inoperative. Both suppressor cells are CD 4-8+ Th 1 effector cells and are protected against the suppressive action of Ts-eff cells by CD 4+8- contrasuppressor T cells (Tcs). As has been already shown there are also regulatory interactions between regulatory cells themselves and Ts-aff cells in addition to their effect on precursors of Th 1 cells, also preventing the induction of Ts-eff cells. The present experiments extend these findings and demonstrate that Ts-eff cells are also under negative control of Tcs lymphocytes. Likewise, antigen-specific factor produced by contrasuppressor T-T cell hybridoma, used in lieu of Tcs cells, impedes the activation of Ts-eff cells. In both cases regulation is aimed at the precursors of Ts-eff cells. Our experiments demonstrate that the outcome of immunization is dependent not only on the balance between immune cells and regulatory cells, but also on interactions between regulatory cells themselves.     

Tumor-induced disruption of proximal TCR-mediated signal transduction in tumor-infiltrating CD8+ lymphocytes inactivates antitumor effector phase

The presence in cancer tissue of Ag-specific, activated tumor infiltrating CD8(+) T cells proves that tumors express Ags capable of eliciting immune response. Therefore, in general, tumor escape from immune-mediated clearance is not attributable to immunological ignorance. However, tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes are defective in effector phase function, demonstrating tumor-induced immune suppression that likely underlies tumor escape. Since exocytosis of lytic granules is dependent upon TCR-mediated signal transduction, it is a reasonable contention that tumors may induce defective signal transduction in tumor infiltrating T cells. In this review, we consider the biochemical basis for antitumor T cell dysfunction, focusing on the role of inhibitory signaling receptors in restricting TCR-mediated signaling in tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes.     

Trypanosoma cruzi-induced suppression of IL-2 production. II. Evidence for a role for suppressor cells

Suppression of IL-2 production during experimental Chagas' disease accounts at least in part for the overall depressed state of the immune system in infected mice. The failure to produce IL-2 in response to mitogen stimulation is not the result of the lack of cells capable of producing IL-2, but appears to be due to regulation of IL-2 production by suppressor cells. This conclusion is supported by cell-mixing experiments where the ability of cells from infected mice to suppress normal spleen cell IL-2 production is evident. Although depletion of plastic and Sephadex G-10 adherent cells results in modest increases in IL-2 production by spleen cells from infected mice, even in the presence of normal adherent cells as a source of IL-1 producers, IL-2 production does not approach normal levels. Also, isolated macrophages are not by themselves suppressive for normal spleen cell IL-2 production, whereas plastic and G-10 nonadherent cells from infected mice are. Depletion of Thy-1+ and Ly-2+ cells not only completely abrogates the ability of spleen cells from infected mice to suppress normal IL-2 production, but results in a cell preparation which actually enhances IL-2 production. Anti-Ly-2 and C treatment of infected spleen cells also markedly enhances their ability to produce IL-2. These results indicate a major role for Ts cells in the regulation of IL-2 production, and a relatively minor role of macrophages as direct effector cells of suppression in this response. The ability to enhance IL-2 production in this system with PG synthesis inhibitors suggests a role for PG-producing cells such as macrophages in the suppressor mechanism, perhaps as inducers of the suppressor effector cells.     

Distinct mechanisms for cross-protection of the upper versus lower respiratory tract through intestinal priming

A main feature of the common mucosal immune system is that lymphocytes primed in one mucosal inductive site may home to distant mucosal effector sites. However, the mechanisms responsible for such cross-protection remain elusive. To address these we have used a model of local mucosal infection of mice with reovirus. In immunocompetent mice local duodenal priming protected against subsequent respiratory challenge. In the upper respiratory tract this protection appeared to be mainly mediated by specific IgA- and IgG2a-producing B cells, whereas ex vivo active effector memory CTL were found in the lower respiratory tract. In accordance with these findings, clearance of reovirus from the lower respiratory tract, but not from the upper respiratory tract, of infected SCID mice upon transfer of gut-primed lymphocytes depended on the presence of T cells. Taken together this study reveals that intestinal priming leads to protection of both the upper and lower respiratory tracts, however through distinct mechanisms. We suggest that cross-protection in the common mucosal immune system is mediated by trafficking of B cells and effector memory CTL.     

The immunologic response in mice unresponsive to experimental allergic encephalomyelitis

The suppressor cells that are involved in antigen-induced protection against EAE in mice were investigated with respect to their effect on the immune response. The cellular immune response to the basic encephalitogenic protein (BE) and to PPD were studied in mice with either actively induced or adoptively transferred unresponsiveness to EAE. The results demonstrate that the DTH response to BE, as assayed in the radiometric ear skin test, was suppressed in mice protected against EAE. Moreover, the passive transfer of DTH response to BE by effector lymphocytes was also inhibited by the preinjection of suppressor cells. On the other hand, the suppressor cells did not affect the response to PPD in all these experiments. The results indicate that suppressor cells that mediate unresponsiveness to EAE regulate also the cellular immune response to BE in a specific manner. These suppressor cells are probably active both at the induction and the effector phase of the immune response.     

Suppression of the in vitro secondary response to syngeneic tumor and of in vivo tumor therapy with immune cells by culture-induced suppressor cells.

Mice with advanced disseminated syngeneic tumor can be successfully treated with a combination of chemotherapy and adoptively transferred syngeneic immune cells. We have previously demonstrated that in vivo primed cells secondarily sensitized in vitro became more effective in tumor therapy, whereas primed cells cultured for 5 days without tumor stimulation became less effective than an equal number of uncultured fresh primed cells. Therefore, we examined stimulated and unstimulated cultures of tumor-primed cells for the presence of culture-induced suppressor cells, and determined whether in vivo tumor therapy with immune cells could be inhibited by concurrent inoculation of immune effector cells and cultured normal spleen cells, which contain culture-induced suppressor cells but are devoid of additional effector cells. The in vitro primary allogeneic response was suppressed by cultured normal spleen cells, or tumor-primed spleen cells previously cultured for 5 days with or without tumor stimulation. In vitro secondary sensitization to syngeneic tumor was suppressed by normal or tumor-primed cells that had previously been cultured for 5 days without stimulation. The majority of this suppression was mediated by T cells in the cultured populations. The efficacy of fresh tumor-primed cells, as well as primed cells secondarily sensitized in vitro, in adoptive chemoimmunotherapy of advanced tumor was diminished by concurrent inoculation of cultured normal cells. The cells mediating suppression of in vivo therapy required previous in vitro culture for induction, and were radiation sensitive.     

Regulation of the immune response to tumor antigen. VI. Differential specificities of suppressor T cells or their products and effector T cells.

Suppressor T cells arising during the development of certain murine methylcholanthrene-induced fibrosarcomas have previously been shown capable of limiting only those effector responses generated against the homologous tumor. Thus, S1509a-induced suppressor T cells inhibit immune reactivity only to the S1509a tumor in S1509a immune mice and have no effect on the rejection of SAI tumors in SAI-immune animals. In contrast to this is the cross-reactivity of effector cells in this system, whereby animals rendered immune to either the S1509a or SAI sarcoma are equally capable of rejecting a challenge of the opposite tumor. The specificity of suppression has been further defined in the present study, which demonstrates that S1509a-induced suppressor cells can inhibit responsiveness only to the S1509a sarcoma, even in the simultaneous presence of both the S1509a and SAI tumors. Furthermore, the suppressor factor that is obtainable from suppressor T cells demonstrates a similar precise specificity in its ability to limit selectively reactivity only against the inducing tumor, regardless of the simultaneous expression of antigens on other tumors recognized by cross-reactive effector cells. These results suggest that the antigenic determinants recognized by effector and suppressor T cells are different, and may provide a model for further dissection of suppressor cell function in vivo.     

Generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes in the autologous mixed lymphocyte culture.

We have studied the ability of purified B lymphocytes to generate cytotoxic T lymphocytes in autologous mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC). Cytotoxic lymphocytes were produced but only autologous mononuclear cells stimulated by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) were susceptible target cells. Unstimulated mononuclear cells and purified B cells were not susceptible to killing by cytotoxic cells generated in the autologous MLC. This suggests that the target antigen may be expressed on stimulated or dividing B lymphocytes in a way that renders the cells more susceptible to cytolysis. Autologously stimulated cytotoxic effector cells were found to exhibit specificity. Cy totoxicity for autologous LPS-stimulated target cells occurred but not for an allogeneic, B cell, histiocytic lymphoma cell line. It is postulated that cytotoxic T cells generated in the autologous MLC may play a role in immune surveillance or in regulation of the immune system.     

The role of suppressor factors in the regulation of immune responses by ultraviolet radiation-induced suppressor T lymphocytes. I. Activity of suppressor cell culture supernatants

The purpose of this study was to determine whether soluble suppressor factors are involved in the regulation of immune responses by ultraviolet radiation-induced suppressor T lymphocytes (UV Ts). The UV Ts were induced by applying contact allergens to the ventral, unirradiated skin of mice that had been exposed 5 days earlier to UVB radiation. Supernatants from cultures that contained a mixture of UV Ts, normal responder lymphocytes, and hapten-modified stimulator cells were injected iv into normal recipients at the time of sensitization; they inhibited the induction of contact hypersensitivity (CHS) in vivo in an hapten-specific manner. The supernatants similarly suppressed the generation of specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in vitro. Moreover, supernatants from cultures that contained either UV Ts alone or UV Ts in combination with either the responder or the stimulator cells failed to suppress the CHS and CTL responses. These results suggest that hapten-specific inhibitory factors may participate in the regulation of immune responses by suppressor cells generated by epicutaneous sensitization of UV-irradiated mice.     

Antipeptide antibody specific for the N-terminal of soluble immune response suppressor neutralizes concanavalin A and IFN-induced suppressor cell activity in an in vitro cytotoxic T lymphocyte response

Soluble immune response suppressor (SIRS) is a nonspecific immunosuppressive lymphokine produced by Lyt-2+ lymphocytes after exposure to Con A, IFN-alpha, or IFN-gamma. The N-terminal 21 residues of SIRS have recently been elucidated and antisera specific for this sequence have been raised in rabbits by using a synthetic peptide coupled to an immunogenic carrier protein. In a series of experiments, we have established that this antiserum blocks the suppressive activity of Con A- or IFN-activated suppressor cells. These data establish that Con A- or IFN-activated suppressor cells exert some or all of their suppressive effects via SIRS. Further studies show that SIRS acts primarily during the induction of CTL and not at the effector phase. Last, we show that SIRS is not involved in the radiation-resistant Ag-specific suppressor cell circuit that can be induced during the in vitro MLR.     

Lack of generation of killer cells in the mixed lymphocyte reaction between mitogen-stimulated and unstimulated autologous lymphocytes.

The present study has demonstrated that the Con A-activated cell-mediated autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR) is not associated with the generation of cytotoxic effector cells that kill autologous targets. Thus, the suppression of antibody production of PWM stimulated lymphocytes by autologous Con A-activated suppressor cells cannot be explained by detectable cytotoxicity. We have further demonstrated that the stimulator cell in this system is a nonadherent non-T cell.     

Suppressor T lymphocyte induction by a factor released from cultured blastocysts

For the analysis of immunologic escape mechanisms of embryos during the implantation period in mice, the effects of culture supernatant of blastocysts on in vitro responsiveness to alloantigen of mice was investigated. Blastocyst-cultured conditioned medium was prepared by culturing late blastocysts of outbred ICR mice for 5 days. The addition of culture supernatant containing four or eight blastocysts to allogeneic mixed lymphocyte culture inhibited both the MLR responses and the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). Preincubation of the culture supernatant with lymphocytes syngeneic to the responder cells of MLR induced potent suppressor cell activity in the MLR. The supernatant did not inhibit the activity of CTL at the effector phase, but preinduced suppressor cells obtained by incubation of splenocytes with the supernatant showed almost complete suppression of CTL activity at the effector phase. Both of the suppressor cells, active on MLR and at the generation phase of CTL as well as active at the effector phase, had a surface phenotype of Thy-1+ and Ig-. The suppressive material could be extracted from the eight-cell stage of fertilized ova or blastocysts but not from unfertilized ova, indicating that the production of the factor(s) is dependent on the stages of early embryogenesis. These results suggest that the active induction of suppressor T lymphocytes by the factor(s) released from implanted embryos is one of the protective mechanisms from maternal immunologic attack.     

An in vitro system for the generation of suppressor cells and the requirement for B cells in their induction

An in vitro method for the generation of effector suppressor cells (Ts3) was developed. By utilizing this protocol, it was possible to investigate both the cellular and genetic requirements for suppressor cell induction. It was determined that populations containing Ts3 cells can be induced after a 4-day culture of spleen cells and antigen. These Ts3 cells are similar to Ts3 cells generated by in vivo immunization. Both populations are I-J+, bind NP hapten, bind NP hapten, bear receptors which share NPb idiotypic determinants with anti-NP antibodies, function during the effector phase of the immune response, and require activation with Ts2 cells. Generation of Ts3-containing populations required both nylon wool-nonadherent T cells and a nylon-adherent, B cell-enriched population from an Igh-identical donor. T cells cultured with antigen alone or with syngeneic macrophages and antigen did not develop suppressive activity. Lytic treatment of the nylon-adherent population with a B cell-specific monoclonal antibody (J11d) removed the ability to generate suppressor cells. These results imply that the induction of suppressor T cells requires B lymphocytes, and that this induction process is dependent on Igh-linked gene products.     

CD4+ suppressor cells differentially affect the production of IFN-gamma by effector cells of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Spleen cells from rats that have recovered from experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) suppress the production of IFN-gamma by effector T cells of EAE in an Ag-specific manner. These postrecovery suppressor cells also inhibit EAE in vivo. Fractionation of the postrecovery suppressor spleen cells on nylon wool and OX-8 coated plates yields a nylon wool-adherent CD4+ suppressor cell population that, when cocultured with effector T cells, suppresses IFN-gamma production by these effector cells. In contrast, the nylon wool-adherent, CD4+ postrecovery suppressor cell population fails to inhibit the production of IL-2 by the effector T cells. In further experiments, the effector T cell population was depleted of CD8+ cells and cocultured with the nylon wool-adherent, CD4+ postrecovery suppressor cells, and the supernatants were assayed for IFN-gamma and IL-2. IFN-gamma production was inhibited in these cultures but IL-2 production was not inhibited. Irradiated effector T cells were cocultured with CD4+ postrecovery suppressor cells, without myelin basic protein, in an effort to determine whether the mechanism of differential lymphokine suppression involved an anti-idiotypic response against effector T cells. No IL-2 was produced, indicating that there was no CD4+ suppressor cell mediated anti-idiotypic response against effector T cells. These studies suggest that the suppressor cell is a nylon wool adherent, CD4+ T cell that functions to down-regulate EAE effector T cells by differential inhibition of lymphokine production.     

Interactions and quantitative analysis of immunoregulatory cells in the chicken thymus

Step-wise dilution of chicken thymus cell suspensions has been used to sequentially reveal suppressor, effector, and helper cells in these suspensions. The cells were tested either alone or in autologous mixture combinations with peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) as a source of effector cells. The assays studied were graft-vs-host reaction (GvHR) and mixed lymphocyte (MLR) reaction, spontaneous cellular cytotoxicity and antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity, and mitogen responsiveness to Con A, PHA, and PWM. When tested alone, high numbers of thymus cells (1 X 10(7) gave weak or low responses, with the exception of GvHR, which was high. When this number of thymocytes was mixed with a strongly responding PBL effector population, there was marked suppression of the latter. Nonspecific crowding was excluded as a cause for the decreased responsiveness, and the data therefore demonstrated the presence of suppressor cells in the thymus. With gradual reduction of the thymus cell number in the mixtures, the suppressor activity was lost, but concomitant with this was the appearance of, or a gradual increase in, thymus effector cells giving good responses. Further dilutions of the thymus (to, e.g., 1 X 10(5) cells) depleted the suspension of effector cells, but helper cells capable of markedly amplifying the effector potential of PBL were revealed. The suppressor/helper function of the thymus was not only dependent on the absolute numbers of thymus cells present, but also on the degree of inherent responsiveness of the effector PBL. If the response of PBL alone was strong, a thymus suspension containing both helper and suppressor cells (e.g., 1 X 10(6) cells) caused suppression of the PBL; if the PBL alone were weak, this same thymus cell suspension caused enhancement. The outcome of an immune response is therefore dependent not only on the presence or absence of particular cell types, but also on the ratios between these cells. An imbalance in these ratios in vivo may underlie diseases of immunologic origin, e.g., autoimmunity.