Impact of protozoan grazing on nitrification and the ammonia- and nitrite-oxidizing bacterial communities in activated sludge

In activated sludge, protozoa feed on free-swimming bacteria and suspended particles, inducing flocculation and increasing the turnover rate of nutrients. In this study, the effect of protozoan grazing on nitrification rates under various conditions in municipal activated sludge batch reactors was examined, as was the spatial distribution of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) within the activated sludge. The reactors were monitored for ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, and total nitrogen concentrations, and bacterial numbers in the presence and absence of cycloheximide (a protozoan inhibitor), allylthiourea (an inhibitor of ammonia oxidation), and EDTA (a deflocculating agent). The accumulations of nitrate, nitrite, and ammonia were lower in batches without than with protozoa grazing. Inhibition of ammonia oxidation also decreased the amount of nitrite and nitrate accumulation. Inhibiting protozoan grazing along with ammonia oxidation further decreased the amounts of nitrite and nitrate accumulated. Induction of deflocculation led to high nitrate accumulation, indicating high levels of nitrification; this effect was lessened in the absence of protozoan grazing. Using fluorescent in situ hybridization and confocal laser scanning microscopy, AOB and NOB were found clustered within the floc, and inhibiting the protozoa, inhibiting ammonia oxidation, or inducing flocculation did not appear to lower the number of AOB and NOB present or affect their position within the floc. These results suggest that the AOB and NOB are present but less active in the absence of protozoa.     

Nitrification in activated sludge batch reactors is linked to protozoan grazing of the bacterial population

Protozoa feed upon free-swimming bacteria and suspended particles inducing flocculation and increasing the turnover rate of nutrients in complex mixed communities. In this study, the effect of protozoan grazing on nitrification was examined in activated sludge in batch cultures maintained over a 14-day period. A reduction in the protozoan grazing pressure was accomplished by using either a dilution series or the protozoan inhibitor cycloheximide. As the dilutions increased, the nitrification rate showed a decline, suggesting that a reduction in protozoan or bacterial concentration may cause a decrease in nitrification potential. In the presence of cycloheximide, where the bacterial concentration was not altered, the rates of production of ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate all were significantly lower in the absence of active protozoans. These results suggest that a reduction in the number or activity of the protozoans reduces nitrification, possibly by limiting the availability of nutrients for slow-growing ammonia and nitrite oxidizers through excretion products. Furthermore, the ability of protozoans to groom the heterotrophic bacterial population in such systems may also play a role in reducing interspecies competition for nitrification substrates and thereby augment nitrification rates.     

Comparison of cadmium biosorption by Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria from activated sludge

Summary Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria were isolated from activated sludge and used to evaluate differences in cadmium biosorption. Gram-positive bacteria exhibited approximately 20% more cadmium biosorption at 30°C and pH 6.6 than Gram-negatives. Biosorption was largely passive in both cases, although metabolic uptake appeared to occur to a higher extent with Gram-positive bacteria.     

Mechanism of cadmium uptake by activated sludge

Summary The significance of metabolic activity in cadmium uptake by unacclimated activated sludge was studied. Below 30 mg/l cadmium in solution, biosorption was found to follow the Freundlich isotherm, which is the most common pattern for physico-chemical adsorption. More than 95% of total cadmium uptake was achieved within 5 min metal-sludge contact time. Biosorption increased strongly when the initial cadmium concentration in solution was raised from 10 to 100 mg/l, whereas in the same concentration range the metabolic activity of the sludge, as measured by respiratory activity and extracellular protein production, was very significantly inhibited. The addition of nutrients at low but significant levels failed to increase cadmium uptake in 2 h contact time, while in 24 h the addition of nutrients caused the biosorption to increase by only 5–10% without any significant growth of the biomass. Biosorption was found to increase with temperature between 5° C and 40° C, in correlation with an increase in the metabolic activity of the sludge. Pretreatment of the sludge with metabolic inhibitors (NaN₃ and UV rays) appeared to cause only a very slight decrease (5–10%) of biosorption. These results suggest that metabolic uptake of cadmium was low and that adsorption to the surface of the cells was the major mechanism of uptake.Offprint requests to: S. S. Sofer     

Toxic effects of toluene on the growth of activated sludge bacteria

Two bacteria were isolated from the activated sludge sample of a wastewater treatment plant in Dublin by enrichment culture technique with toluene as the sole source of carbon and energy. They were identified as Aeromonas caviae (To-4) and Pseudomonas putida (To-5). The growth of these bacteria depended on the manner in which toluene was supplied. In general, growth was better when toluene was supplied in the vapour phase. When toluene was added directly to the growth medium it was found to be toxic to the organisms but the toxic effect could be alleviated in the presence of other carbon sources and by the acclimation of the cells. The growth of To-4 on toluene has never been previously reported.     

Detection of nitrifying bacteria in activated sludge by fluorescent in situ hybridization and fluorescence spectrometry

16S rRNA-targeted oligonucleotide probes for eubacteria (EUB338), ammonium-oxidizing bacteria (Nsm156) and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (Nb1000) were used for the rapid detection of nitrifying bacteria in the activated sludge of a pilot nitrifying reactor by whole-cell, fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH). Emission scanning and synchronous scanning fluorescence spectrometry were used to measure the hybridization. The binding of the probes at a temperature significantly lower than the melting temperature of the hybrids was conventionally considered as non-specific. Total binding of the probes at a temperature significantly higher than the melting temperature of the hybrids was conventionally considered as the sum of non-specific and specific binding (hybridization). Non-specific binding of the oligonucleotide probes with a biomass of activated sludge was 37% of the total binding of the EUB338 probe, 54% of the total binding of the Nsm156 probe, and 69% of the total binding of the Nb1000 probe. The ratio of the specific binding of the Nsm156 and Nb1000 probes was 2.3:1. The ratio of the numbers of ammonium-oxidizing bacteria to nitrite-oxidizing bacteria, determined by microbiological methods, was 2.4:1. Measuring fluorescent in situ hybridization by fluorescence spectrometry appears to be a practical tool for monitoring the microbial communities that contain nitrifying bacteria. However, a method that accounts for the non-specific binding of the probes more easily and reliably should be developed for practical application.     

Effect of hexavalent chromium on the activated sludge process and on the sludge protozoan community

The objectives of this study were the determination of chromium effects to the performance of an activated sludge unit and the investigation of the response of the activated sludge protozoan community to Cr(VI). Two bench scale activated sludge reactors were supplied with synthetic sewage containing Cr(VI), at concentrations from 1 up to 50 mg L(-1). Protozoan species were identified and were related to the system efficiency. Variations in the abundance and diversity of the protozoan species were observed under various chromium concentrations. High removal rates of organics and nutrients were observed after the acclimatization of the activated sludge, which were related to the initial chromium(VI) concentration. Chromium(VI) removal efficiency was high in all cases. The protistan community was affected by the influent chromium content. Dominance of sessile species was observed in the reactor receiving 5 mg L(-1) influent chromium, whereas co-dominance of sessile and carnivorous species was observed in the reactors receiving higher chromium concentrations.     

Effect of growth rate and hydrophobicity on bacteria surviving protozoan grazing

Measurements were made of the predation by Tetrahymena thermophila on several bacterial species in media containing heat-killed Escherichia coli cells to serve as an alternative prey. If grazing pressure was initially not intense on a mixture of bacterial species, the species that survived protozoan feeding at greater densities were those that grew quickly before the onset of active predation. If members of several species were incubated individually at similar initial densities with actively grazing T. thermophila, some species survived at ca. 10(4)/ml, some survived at ca. 10(2)/ml, and others were eliminated. Members of the first two groups but not the third group were able to multiply in the medium in the absence of the protozoan, but the growth rates in the protozoan-free medium did not correlate with the number of survivors. However, the species that persisted at the higher densities possessed highly hydrophobic cell surfaces. The size of the surviving population of four bacterial species whose growth was prevented by chloramphenicol correlated with the initial cell density that was incubated with T. thermophila. It is concluded that the individual species surviving predation on a mixture of species is related to the capacity of the bacterium to grow, the hydrophobicity of its cell surface, and the population density of the species before the onset of intense grazing.     

Extraction of activated sludge bacteria exopolymers by ultrasonication

Ultrasonication for the extraction of activated sludge exopolymers was evaluated by total cell count, exopolymer extraction and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). A high deflocculation was achieved after 30 s of sonication in PBS (phosphate-buffered saline). TEM showed that cell lysis was minimal only when sludges were sonicated for 30 s. For sludges sonicated for 30, 90 and 420 s and stained with Ruthenium Red, exopolymers were not extracted on a large scale without considerable cell lysis. Sludges sonicated for 30 s in EDTA gave a larger fraction of damaged cells and also showed copious amounts of attached exopolymers.     

Effect of growth rate and hydrophobicity on bacteria surviving protozoan grazing.

Measurements were made of the predation by Tetrahymena thermophila on several bacterial species in media containing heat-killed Escherichia coli cells to serve as an alternative prey. If grazing pressure was initially not intense on a mixture of bacterial species, the species that survived protozoan feeding at greater densities were those that grew quickly before the onset of active predation. If members of several species were incubated individually at similar initial densities with actively grazing T. thermophila, some species survived at ca. 10(4)/ml, some survived at ca. 10(2)/ml, and others were eliminated. Members of the first two groups but not the third group were able to multiply in the medium in the absence of the protozoan, but the growth rates in the protozoan-free medium did not correlate with the number of survivors. However, the species that persisted at the higher densities possessed highly hydrophobic cell surfaces. The size of the surviving population of four bacterial species whose growth was prevented by chloramphenicol correlated with the initial cell density that was incubated with T. thermophila. It is concluded that the individual species surviving predation on a mixture of species is related to the capacity of the bacterium to grow, the hydrophobicity of its cell surface, and the population density of the species before the onset of intense grazing.     

Competition for ammonium between plant roots and nitrifying and heterotrophic bacteria and the effects of protozoan grazing

The competition for limiting amounts of ammonium between the chemolithotrophic ammonium-oxidizing species Nitrosomonas europaea, the heterotrophic species Arthrobacter globiformis and roots of Plantago lanceolata (Ribwort plantain) was studied in a series of model systems of increasing complexity, i.e. energy-limited continuous cultures, non-water-saturated continuously percolated soil columns and pots with γ-sterilized soil planted with axetic P. lanceolata seedlings. The effects of bacterial grazing by the flagellate species Adriamonas peritocrescens on the competition for ammonium were also investigated in the three model systems. It was found that N. europaea was a weaker competitor for ammonium than either A. globiformis or plant roots of P. lanceolata. It is assumed that the heterotrophic bacteria have a higher affinity for ammonium than the nitrifying bacteria, whereas growing plant roots have a greater capacity to exploit the soil for ammonium than the immobile nitrifying bacteria. It is not very likely that allelochemicals were involved in suppressing the nitrification process. Four reasons are given for this assumption. Presence of the flagellates strongly stimulated the potential nitrification rate in all model systems. It is assumed that there is a more even distribution over the soil of either nitrifying bacteria or their substrate ammonium in the presence of flagellates. In addition to the distribution effect, there is a stimulation of the potential ammonium oxidation rate. The results are discussed in the light of the function of nitrate as nitrogen sink in the biogeochemical nitrogen cycle.     

Competitive ability of amylolytic bacteria in activated sludge

Shifts were induced into the microbial community of activated sludge by the pulse addition of soluble starch. The subsequent changes of amylolytic and proteolytic microbial populations were recorded. Four amylolytic strains were isolated and characterized with regard to carrying capacity, specific surface and growth kinetics. The competitive ability of these strains was studied by means of two-member competition experiments. These experiments were analysed according to the Lotka-Volterra model and the de Wit method. The different results obtained suggest that the dominance of the amylolytic Pseudomonas sp. (code 01) is based on a combined occurrence of high amylolytic activity, large relative cell surface, high maximum specific growth rate and reduced sensitivity towards associated proteolytic populations.     

Degradation of substituted thiophenes by bacteria isolated from activated sludge

Actinomycetes were isolated from activated sludge acclimated to thiophene-2-carboxylic acid (T2C) or 5-methyl-thiophene-2-carboxylic acid (T5M2C). These isolates were apparently identical and were identified as strains ofRhodococcus. The strains could grow on T2C, T5M2C, or thiophene-2-acetic acid as sole sources of carbon and energy, but could not use thiophene, methyl thiophenes, several other substituted thiophenes, dibenzothiophene, dimethyl sulfide, or pyrrole-2-carboxylic acid. T2C was degraded quantitatively to sulfate, and its carbon was converted almost entirely to cell biomass and carbon dioxide. Growth yields indicated about 25% conversion of T2C-carbon to cell-carbon. Growth was not supported by thiosulfate or methionine, nor were these compounds oxidized.Rhodococcus strain TTD-1 grown on T2C oxidized both T2C and T5M2C with an apparent K_m of 1.3×10^–5 M. Sulfide was also oxidized by T2C-grown organisms. This is the first demonstration of an actinomycete capable of the complete degradation of thiophene derivatives and of their use by it as sole substrates for growth.     

Improved identification of methanogenic bacteria by fluorescence microscopy.

Methanogenic bacteria can be tentatively identified by fluorescence microscopy. This technique was improved by carefully selecting a series of excitation and barrier filters that matched the excitation and emission spectra of some unique coenzymes viz., F420 and F350, in methanogenic bacteria.     

Improved identification of methanogenic bacteria by fluorescence microscopy.

Methanogenic bacteria can be tentatively identified by fluorescence microscopy. This technique was improved by carefully selecting a series of excitation and barrier filters that matched the excitation and emission spectra of some unique coenzymes viz., F420 and F350, in methanogenic bacteria.     

Bacteriology of activated sludge,in particular the filamentous bacteria

Microscopic examination of bulking activated sludge samples showed the presence of a variety of filamentous microorganisms, some of which have not yet been described in the literature. A method was developed to obtain pure cultures of these threaded bacteria. To date, five clearly different groups of filamentous bacteria may be distinguished by the determination of a few morphological and physiological characteristics of the isolates. A variety of sheathed bacteria are included in Group I. Group II includes non-motile, gram-negative, orange- or yellow-pigmented filamentous bacteria. These microorganisms are thought to be related to some species of the genusFlavobacterium. The gram-negative, threaded bacteria of Group III show a more or less distinct gliding movement and form red colonies on rich agar media. These bacteria may apparently be related to species described in the generaMicroscilla andFlexibacter. The filamentous bacteria of Group IV structurally resemble someCyanophyceae, but do not contain photosynthetic pigments. They are gram-positive and non-motile. A number of unknown, non-motile bacteria which stain gram-positive with a variable number of gram-negative autolyzed cells in the filaments, are assigned to Group V. The properties of the isolated bacteria are described briefly and their occurrence in bulking activated sludge is discussed.     

Competitive ability of amylolytic bacteria in activated sludge.

Shifts were induced into the microbial community of activated sludge by the pulse addition of soluble starch. The subsequent changes of amylolytic and proteolytic microbial populations were recorded. Four amylolytic strains were isolated and characterized with regard to carrying capacity, specific surface and growth kinetics. The competitive ability of these strains was studied by means of two-member competition experiments. These experiments were analysed according to the Lotka-Volterra model and the de Wit method. The different results obtained suggest that the dominance of the amylolytic Pseudomonas sp. (code 01) is based on a combined occurrence of high amylolytic activity, large relative cell surface, high maximum specific growth rate and reduced sensitivity towards associated proteolytic populations.     

Identity and ecophysiology of filamentous bacteria in activated sludge

Excessive growth of filamentous bacteria in activated sludge wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) can cause serious operational problems. With some filaments there may be the problem of bulking, where inadequate flocculation and settling of the biomass in the secondary clarifier results in a carryover of solids with the final treated liquid effluent. Their proliferation often encourages the development of stable foams on the surface of the reactors, and these foams may impact negatively on plant performance and operation. The availability of culture-independent molecular methods now allows us to identify many of the more common filamentous organisms encountered in WWTPs, which are phylogenetically diverse, affiliating to seven separate bacterial phyla. Furthermore, the extensive data published in the past decade on their in situ behaviour from the application of these culture-independent methods have not been summarized or reviewed critically. Hence, here, we attempt to discuss what we now know about their identity, ecophysiology and ecological niches and its practical value in better managing activated sludge processes. Some of this knowledge is already being applied to control and manage full-scale WWTPs better, and the hope is that this review will contribute towards further developments in this field of environmental microbiology.