Protein translocation into and within cyanelles (review)

The cyanelles of the glaucocystophyte alga Cyanophora paradoxa resemble endosymbiotic cyanobacteria in morphology, pigmentation and, especially, in the presence of a peptidoglycan wall situated between the inner and outer envelope membranes. However, it is now clear that cyanelles in fact are primitive plastids. Phylogenetic analyses of plastid, nuclear and mitochondrial genes support a single primary endosymbiotic event. In this scenario cyanelles and all other plastid types are derived from an ancestral photosynthetic organelle combining the high plastid gene content of the Porphyra purpurea rhodoplast and the peptidoglycan wall of glaucocystophyte cyanelles. This means that the import apparatus of all primary plastids should be homologous. Indeed, heterologous in vitro import can now be shown in both directions, provided a phenylalanine residue essential for cyanelle import is engineered into the N-terminal part of chloroplast transit peptides. The cyanelle and likely also the rhodoplast import apparatus can be envisaged as prototypes with a single receptor showing this requirement for N-terminal phenylalanine. In chloroplasts, multiple receptors with overlapping and less stringent specificities have evolved explaining the efficient heterologous import of native precursors from C. paradoxa. With respect to conservative sorting in cyanelles, both the Sec and Tat pathways could be demonstrated. Another cyanobacterial feature, the dual location of the Sec translocase in thylakoid and inner envelope membranes, is also unique to cyanelles. For the first time, protease protection of internalized lumenal proteins could be shown for cyanobacteria-like, phycobilisome-bearing thylakoid membranes after import into isolated cyanelles.     

Homologous protein import machineries in chloroplasts and cyanelles

The cyanelles of the glaucocystophyte alga Cyanophora paradoxa resemble endosymbiotic cyanobacteria, especially in the presence of a peptidoglycan wall between the inner and outer envelope membranes. However, it is now clear that cyanelles are in fact primitive plastids. Phylogenetic analyses of plastid, nuclear and mitochondrial genes support a single primary endosymbiotic event. In this scenario, cyanelles and all other plastid types are derived from an ancestral photosynthetic organelle combining the high gene content of rhodoplasts and the peptidoglycan wall of cyanelles. This means that the import apparatuses of all primary plastids, i.e. those from glaucocystophytes, red algae, green algae and higher plants, should be homologous. If this is the case, then transit sequences should be similar and heterologous import experiments feasible. Thus far, heterologous in vitro import has been shown in one direction only: precursors from C. paradoxa were imported into isolated pea or spinach chloroplasts. Cyanelle transit sequences differ from chloroplast stroma targeting peptides in containing in their N-terminal domain an invariant phenylalanine residue which is shown here to be crucial for import. In addition, we now demonstrate that heterologous precursors are readily imported into isolated cyanelles, provided that the essential phenylalanine residue is engineered into the N-terminal part of chloroplast transit peptides. The cyanelle and likely also the rhodoplast import apparatus can be envisaged as prototypes with a single receptor/channel showing this requirement for N-terminal phenylalanine. In chloroplasts, multiple receptors with overlapping and less stringent specificities have evolved, explaining the efficient heterologous import of native precursors from C. paradoxa.     

Cytochrome c6 from Cyanophora paradoxa. Characterization of the protein and the cDNA of the precursor and import into isolated cyanelles.

In the eukaryotic alga Cyanophora paradoxa, which does not contain plastocyanin, photosynthetic electron transport from the cytochrome b6/f complex to photosystem I is mediated by cytochrome c6. Cytochrome c6 was purified to homogeneity by column chromatography and FPLC. The relative molecular mass of the holoprotein was determined by two different mass spectrometric methods (californium-252 plasma desorption and UV matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization) giving 9251 +/- 3.3 Da. N-terminal Edman microsequencing yielded information on approx. 30 amino acid residues. Based on these data and on highly conserved regions of cytochromes c6, degenerate oligonucleotides were designed and used for PCR to amplify the genomic DNA of C. paradoxa. Screening of a C. paradoxa cDNA library yielded several clones coding for preapo-cytochrome c6. The deduced sequence of the mature protein was verified by plasma desorption mass spectrometric peptide mapping and shows high similarity to those of cytochromes c6 from cyanobacteria and algae. Cytochrome c6 appears to be encoded by a single nuclear gene (petJ) in C. paradoxa. As the mature protein is located in the lumen of the thylakoid membrane, it has to traverse three biological membranes as well as the unique peptidoglycan layer of the cyanelles before it reaches its final subcellular locale. Thus the transit sequence is composed of two different targeting signals: a stroma targeting peptide resembling those of higher plants with respect to hydropathy plots and amino acid composition and a hydrophobic signal peptide functioning as a thylakoid-traversing domain. There are indications for alternative sorting of part of the cyanelle cytochrome c6 pool to the periplasmic space. This is the first known bipartite transit sequence of a cyanelle precursor protein from C. paradoxa, a model organism concerning the endosymbiotic origin of plastids. Labeled precursor is efficiently imported into isolated cyanelles, then routed into thylakoids and processed to the mature protein. Hitherto, in vitro protein translocation was not reported for cyanobacterial-type thylakoids.     

Protein translocation into and within cyanelles (Review)

The cyanelles of the glaucocystophyte alga Cyanophora paradoxa resemble endosymbiotic cyanobacteria in morphology, pigmentation and, especially, in the presence of a peptidoglycan wall situated between the inner and outer envelope membranes. However, it is now clear that cyanelles in fact are primitive plastids. Phylogenetic analyses of plastid, nuclear and mitochondrial genes support a single primary endosymbiotic event. In this scenario cyanelles and all other plastid types are derived from an ancestral photosynthetic organelle combining the high plastid gene content of the Porphyra purpurea rhodoplast and the peptidoglycan wall of glaucocystophyte cyanelles. This means that the import apparatus of all primary plastids should be homologous. Indeed, heterologous in vitro import can now be shown in both directions, provided a phenylalanine residue essential for cyanelle import is engineered into the N-terminal part of chloroplast transit peptides. The cyanelle and likely also the rhodoplast import apparatus can be envisaged as prototypes with a single receptor showing this requirement for N-terminal phenylalanine. In chloroplasts, multiple receptors with overlapping and less stringent specificities have evolved explaining the efficient heterologous import of native precursors from C. paradoxa. With respect to conservative sorting in cyanelles, both the Sec and Tat pathways could be demonstrated. Another cyanobacterial feature, the dual location of the Sec translocase in thylakoid and inner envelope membranes, is also unique to cyanelles. For the first time, protease protection of internalized lumenal proteins could be shown for cyanobacteria-like, phycobilisome-bearing thylakoid membranes after import into isolated cyanelles.     

An ORF323 with homology to crtE, specifying prephytoene pyrophosphate dehydrogenase, is encoded by cyanelle DNA in the eukaryotic alga Cyanophora paradoxa.

Carotenoids are essential constituents of the light-harvesting and light-protective systems of photosynthetic organisms. The biochemistry of carotenoid biosynthesis in eukaryotes is known, whereas evidence for the genes specifying this biosynthetic pathway is scant. We report here the nucleotide sequence and expression of a gene likely encoding crtE (prephytoene pyrophosphate dehydrogenase). The reaction product of this enzyme is phytoene, a C40 carotenoid precursor common to all organisms. The gene is found in the cyanelle (plastid) DNA of an eukaryotic alga, Cyanophora paradoxa. The expression into protein of cyanelle crtE has been demonstrated in vitro. The identity and similarity scores of CrtE from cyanelles with the corresponding protein from the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter capsulatus are 28.6 and 68.5%, respectively.     

The cyanelle genome of Cyanophora paradoxa, unlike the chloroplast genome, codes for the ribosomal L3 protein.

We describe a 1132 bp sequence of the cyanelle genome of Cyanophora paradoxa containing the rpl3 gene. This gene, which is not chloroplast encoded in plants, is the first of a long cyanelle ribosomal operon whose organization resembles that of the S10 operon of E. coli. We have shown that the rpl3 gene is transcribed in cyanelles as a 7500 nucleotide precursor and that the 5'-end of the mRNA starts approximately 90 nucleotides upstream from the initiation codon. However, no typical procaryotic promoter could be found for this gene. We have detected, using anti E. coli L3 antibodies, the cyanelle L3 protein in cyanelle extracts and in E. coli cells transformed with the cyanelle rpl3 gene.     

A carboxysomal carbon-concentrating mechanism in the cyanelles of the 'coelacanth' of the algal world, Cyanophora paradoxa?

Cyanelles are the peculiar plastids of glaucocystophyte algae that retained a peptidoglycan wall from the ancestral cyanobacterial endosymbiont. All cyanobacteria and most algae possess an inorganic carbon-concentrating mechanism (CCM) that involves a microcompartment--carboxysomes in prokaryotes and pyrenoids in eukaryotes--harboring the bulk of cellular (plastidic) Rubisco. In the case of the living fossil, Cyanophora paradoxa, the existence of a CCM was a matter of debate. Microarray data revealing 142 CO(2)-responsive genes (induced or repressed through a shift from high to low CO(2) conditions), gas exchange measurements and measurements of photosynthetic affinity provided strong support for a CCM. We favor a recent hypothesis that glaucocystophyte cyanelles as the closest cousins to cyanobacteria among plastids contain 'eukaryotic carboxysomes': bicarbonate enrichment within cyanelles should be considerably higher than in chloroplasts with their pyrenoid-based CCM. Thus, the stress-bearing function of the peptidoglycan layer, the other unique heritage, would be indispensable. An isolation method for cyanelle 'carboxysomes' was developed and the protein components other than Rubisco analyzed by MS. Rubisco activase was identified and corroborated by western blotting. The well-established cyanelle in vitro import system allows to use them as 'honorary cyanobacteria': assembly processes of supramolecular structures as phycobilisomes and carboxysomes thus can be studied after import of nucleus-encoded precursor proteins and subsequent fractionation. Even minor components can easily be tracked and a surprisingly dynamic view is obtained. Labeled pre-activase was imported into isolated cyanelles and 30% of the mature protein was found to be incorporated into the carboxysome fraction. A final decision between carboxysome or pyrenoid must await the identification of cyanelle carbonic anhydrase and, especially, the demonstration of shell proteins.     

A class-I intron in a cyanelle tRNA gene from Cyanophora paradoxa: phylogenetic relationship between cyanelles and plant chloroplasts

Cyanelles are photosynthetic organelles which are considered as intermediates between cyanobacteria and chloroplasts, and which have been found in unicellular eukaryotes such as Cyanophora paradoxa. The nucleotide sequence of a 667-bp region of the cyanelle genome from Cyanophora paradoxa containing genes coding for tRNA(UUCGlu) and tRNA(UAALeu) has been determined. The gene coding for tRNA(UAALeu) is split by a 232-bp intron which has a secondary structure typical for class-I structured introns and which is closely related to the intron located in the corresponding gene from liverwort and higher plant chloroplasts. It appears therefore that these tRNA(UAALeu) genes are all derived from one common ancestral gene which already contained a class-I intron.     

The Cyanelles of Cyanophora Paradoxa

The cyanelles of Cyanophora paradoxa, plastids surrounded by a peptidoglycan wall, are considered as a surviving example for an early stage of plastid evolution from endosymbiotic cyanobacteria. We highlight the model character of the system by focusing on three aspects: “organelle wall” structure, plastid genome organization, and protein translocation.

The biosynthetic pathway for cyanelle peptidoglycan appears to be analogous to that in Escherichia coli. Also, the basic structure of this peculiar organelle wall corresponds to that of the E. coli sacculus, with one notable exception: the C-1 carboxyl group of the D-isoglutamyl residue is partially amidated with N-acetylputrescine. Cyanelles harbor on their completely sequenced 135.6-kb genome genes for approximately 150 polypeptides, many of which are nucleus encoded in higher plants. Nevertheless, there are striking parallels in genome organization between cyanelles (and other primitive plastids) and higher plant chloroplasts. The transit sequences of nucleus-encoded cyanelle preproteins resemble stroma targeting peptides of higher plant chloroplast precursors. Heterologous import of precursors from C. paradoxa into isolated pea chloroplasts is possible and vice versa. Cyanelles are considered to represent a very early, diverging branch of plastid evolution and are derived from the semiautonomous endosymbiont that had already abandoned about 90% of its genetic information but still retained its prokaryotic wall. Recent data on the molecular biology of cyanelles and rhodoplasts are consistent with the assumption of a primary endosymbiotic event that was not only monophyletic with respect to the cyanobacterial invader, but also singular.

Cyanophora paradoxa is the best-investigated member of the glaucocystophyceae, phototrophic protists containing cyanelles, that is, plastids stabilized by a peptidoglycan-containing envelope. The classification of this group, comprising only eight (mostly monotypic) genera, is also based on parallels in morphology and organization of the “host cells” (Kies, 1992). Recently, this was corroborated by 16S and 18S rRNA-based phylogenetic analysis (Helmchen et al., 1995; Bhattacharya et al, 1995). Apart from C. paradoxa, only Glaucocystis nostochinearum can be grown at a reasonable rate. Thus, biochemical and molecular genetic data are mostly available for C. paradoxa and more precisely for the isolate 555UTEX (Pringsheim) that is kept in the major culture collections of algae. Biochemical work done on C. paradoxa and the sequencing of individual cyanelle genes have been described in several recent reviews (Schenk, 1992; Löffelhardt and Bohnert, 1994a,b). Here we discuss three topics: the cyanelle wall, aspects deduced from the complete cyanelle genome sequence, and protein translocation into and within cyanelles.     

Molecular evidence for the origin of plastids from a cyanobacterium-like ancestor

Summary The origin of plastids by either a single or multiple endosymbiotic event(s) and the nature of the progenitor(s) of plastids have been the subjects of much controversy. The sequence of the small subunit rRNA (Ssu rRNA) from the plastid of the chlorophyllc-containing algaCryptomonas is presented, allowing for the first time a comparison of this molecule from all of the major land plant and algal lineages. Using a distance matrix method, the phylogenetic relationships among representatives of these lineages have been inferred and the results indicate a common origin of plastids from a cyanobacterium-like ancestor. Within the plastid line of descent, there is a deep dichotomy between the chlorophyte/land plant lineage and the rhodophyte/chromophyte lineage, with the cyanelle ofCyanophora paradoxa forming the deepest branch in the latter group. Interestingly,Euglena gracilis and its colorless relativeAstasia longa are more related to the chromophytes than to the chlorophytes, raising once again the question of the origin of the euglenoid plastids.     

Functional expression of plastid allophycocyanin genes in a cyanobacterium.

In Cyanophora paradoxa, the allophycocyanin apoprotein subunits, alpha and beta, are encoded in the cyanelle (plastid) genome. These genes were transferred to the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002 on a plasmid replicon. Phycobilisomes isolated from transformed cyanobacteria were found to contain C. paradoxa allophycocyanin subunits. Thus, these plastid genes are expressed in the cyanobacterium as polypeptides which become linked to a chromophore and are incorporated into the light-harvesting apparatus.     

Analyses of ribosomal RNA sequences from glaucocystophyte cyanelles provide new insights into the evolutionary relationships of plastids

Glaucocystophyte algae (sensu Kies, Berl. Deutsch. Bot. Ges. 92, 1979) contain plastids (cyanelles) that retain the peptidoglycan wall of the putative cyanobacterial endosymbiont; this and other ultrastructural characters (e.g., unstacked thylakoids, phycobilisomes) have suggested that cyanelles are primitive plastids that may represent undeveloped associations between heterotrophic host cells (i.e., glaucocystophytes) and cyanobacteria. To test the monophyly of glaucocystophyte cyanelles and to determine their evolutionary relationship to other plastids, complete 16S ribosomal RNA sequences were determined for Cyanophora paradoxa, Glaucocystis nostochinearum, Glaucosphaera vacuolata, and Gloeochaete wittrockiana. Plastid rRNAs were analyzed with the maximum-likelihood, maximumparsimony, and neighbor joining methods. The phylogenetic analyses show that the cyanelles of C. paradoxa, G. nostochinearum, and G. wittrockiana form a distinct evolutionary lineage; these cyanelles presumably share a monophyletic origin. The rDNA sequence of G. vacuolata was positioned within the nongreen plastid lineage. This result is consistent with analyses of nuclear-encoded rRNAs that identify G. vacuolata as a rhodophyte and support its removal from the Glaucocystophyta. Results of a global search with the maximumlikelihood method suggest that cyanelles are the first divergence among all plastids; this result is consistent with a single loss of the peptidoglycan wall in plastids after the divergence of the cyanelles. User-defined tree analyses with the maximum-likelihood method indicate, however, that the position of the cyanelles is not stable within the rRNA phylogenies. Both maximumparsimony and neighbor-joining analyses showed a close evolutionary relationship between cyanelles and nongreen plastids; these phylogenetic methods were sensitive to inclusion/exclusion of the G. wittrockiana cyanelle sequence. Base compositional bias within the G. wittrockiana 16S rRNA may explain this result. Taken together the phylogenetic analyses are interpreted as supporting a near-simultaneous radiation of cyanelles and green and nongreen plastids; these organelles are all rooted within the cyanobacteria.Correspondence to: D. Bhattacharya     

The cyanelle genome of Cyanophora paradoxa encodes ribosomal proteins not encoded by the chloroplasts genomes of higher plants

The rpl35, rpl20, rpl5, rps8, and a portion of the rpl6 genes of the cyanelle genome of Cyanophora paradoxa have been cloned, mapped and sequenced. Homologs of the rpl35, rpl5, and rpl6 genes are not found in the chloroplasts of higher plants. The rpl35 genes most likely form a dicistronic operon which is located upstream from the apcE-apcA-apcB locus of the cyanelle and which is divergently transcribed from this locus. The rpl5, rpl8, and rpl6 genes probably form a part of a larger cluster of genes encoding components of the cyanellar ribosomes. These genes are organized in a fashion similar to that observed in all procaryotes examined to date, with the exception that the rps14 gene is not found between the rpl5 and rps8 coding sequences. Hypotheses concerning the origins of cyanelles and chloroplasts are discussed.     

Conservative sorting in a primitive plastid. The cyanelle of Cyanophora paradoxa

Higher plant chloroplasts possess at least four different pathways for protein translocation across and protein integration into the thylakoid membranes. It is of interest with respect to plastid evolution, which pathways have been retained as a relic from the cyanobacterial ancestor ('conservative sorting'), which ones have been kept but modified, and which ones were developed at the organelle stage, i.e. are eukaryotic achievements as (largely) the Toc and Tic translocons for envelope import of cytosolic precursor proteins. In the absence of data on cyanobacterial protein translocation, the cyanelles of the glaucocystophyte alga Cyanophora paradoxa for which in vitro systems for protein import and intraorganellar sorting were elaborated can serve as a model: the cyanelles are surrounded by a peptidoglycan wall, their thylakoids are covered with phycobilisomes and the composition of their oxygen-evolving complex is another feature shared with cyanobacteria. We demonstrate the operation of the Sec and Tat pathways in cyanelles and show for the first time in vitro protein import across cyanobacteria-like thylakoid membranes and protease protection of the mature protein.     

Cladistic analysis of ribosomal RNAs--the phylogeny of eukaryotes with respect to the endosymbiotic theory

A strict cladistic analysis of 5S and 16S rRNA secondary and primary structure confirms particular hypotheses concerning the phylogeny of eukaryotes: plastids of Euglena, green algae and land plants, and the cyanelle of Cyanophora share a specific character and are closely related to cyanobacteria of the Synechococcus-type. Angiosperm mitochondria share specific signatures with the alpha subdivision of rhodobacteria. Cyanophora is a member of the Euglenozoa, the Oomycetes are derived from a group of heterokont algae.     

In vitro synthesis of peptidoglycan precursors modified with N-acetylputrescine by Cyanophora paradoxa cyanelle envelope membranes

The photosynthetic organelles (cyanelles) of the protist Cyanophora paradoxa are surrounded by a peptidoglycan wall, modified through amidation with N-acetylputrescine. Cyanelle envelope membrane preparations were shown to catalyze the lipid-linked steps of peptidoglycan biosynthesis as well as the putrescinylation and subsequent acetylation, occurring at the stage of lipid I and/or lipid II.