Impact of methanol concentration on secreted protein production in oxygen-limited cultures of recombinant Pichia pastoris

The methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris is a powerful system for production of recombinant proteins, showing high ability to secrete properly folded proteins. A major plus is the strong AOX1 promoter highly induced by methanol. During growth on methanol, however, oxygen readily becomes limiting. In oxygen-limited cultivations of recombinant Pichia pastoris, the methanol concentration had a strong impact on the production of a single-chain antibody fragment (scFv). High methanol concentrations were required to compensate the lack of oxygen and fully induce recombinant protein production, at the same time reducing gratuitous biomass formation due to a lower biomass yield. Product concentrations of 60, 150, and 350 mg/L were obtained with methanol concentrations of 0.3, 1, and 3% (v/v). Moreover, accumulation of a putative product fragment that cannot be removed during affinity purification was prevented at high methanol concentrations. Cell vitality after 100 h was maintained above 98% and 96% of the culture with 0.3% and 3% methanol, respectively. In cultivations supplemented with oxygen, in contrast, methanol concentration between 0.3% and 3% did not influence the product yield of 300-400 mg/L. Thus, efficient recombinant protein production under oxygen-limitation seems to require high methanol concentrations, enabling product concentration as high as otherwise obtained only with expensive supply of pure oxygen.     

Oxygen-limited control of methanol uptake for improved production of a single-chain antibody fragment with recombinant Pichia pastoris

The yeast Pichia pastoris is a suitable production system for recombinant proteins due to its strong methanol-inducible AOX1 promoter. A key parameter of the production process is the specific methanol uptake rate. To control the methanol uptake and simultaneously maintain a constant methanol concentration during the production phase, two strategies were developed to generate purposeful oxygen limitation and to feed-forward control the specific methanol uptake rate into the optimum range. First, the cell density at induction was adjusted by prolonged preinduction glycerol feeding. Alternatively, the airflow rate was restricted and increased in parallel with the biomass. While the product accumulation started 20 h earlier with the first approach, the specific production rate of a single-chain antibody fragment was three times higher in the latter case. After 70 h of production, both schemes yielded product concentrations in the gram-per-liter range. Moreover, they release the requirement for dosage of pure oxygen and thereby can facilitate the scale-up of the production process. The different production profiles indicate that the impact of specific methanol uptake rate on protein production by recombinant P. pastoris depends on the control mode.     

Effect of process change from perfusion to fed-batch on product comparability for biosimilar monoclonal antibody

A fed-batch process for the production of biosimilar monoclonal antibody was developed. Since the brand product is produced by perfusion process, the impact of process change from perfusion to fed-batch on product quality and cell performance was evaluated. Perfusion culture was performed at 0.47–1.00 (v/v/d) perfusion rate by spin-filter method with 15–17 μm mesh. Culture parameters such as pH (6.8–7.2), dissolved oxygen (40–70% air saturation), temperature (37 °C) and agitation speed (250 rpm) were applied in both culture modes. In terms of cell performance, volumetric productivity increased 3.7 times while process performance increased 7.5 times in fed-batch culture due to 10 times higher scalability. Considering the glycosylation pattern and charge variants, no significant changes in product quality were observed upon process change, although intact IgG level slightly decreased in fed-batch mode. The change of production media showed more effect on glycosylation patterns than the operation in different culture modes. Furthermore, there were no differences in biological activity, including TNFα, FcγRIIIa, and C1q-binding affinity. Through a scale-up study from 3 L to 12,500 L, it was confirmed that cell performance and product quality could be maintained. In conclusion, product quality of the fed-batch process was comparable to that of the reference product.     

Oxygen availability and growth of Escherichia coli W3110: Dynamic responses to limitation and starvation

It is well known that oxygen availability can have a profound effect upon the growth of an Escherichia coli culture with respect to acetate excretion or lower product yield. The current investigation seeks to determine the dynamic responses of steady state continuous cultures to abrupt changes in the oxygen supply. This should yield information regarding the behaviour of such cells as they circulate through areas of low and high oxygen availability in an industrial-scale bioreactor. It was found that a decoupling of catabolism and anabolism occurred following sudden switches both from and to oxygen limitation. It also appeared that the imposed growth rate had an effect on the speed of recovery of the system following any such changes.     

Production of a Rhizopus oryzae lipase from Pichia pastoris using alternative operational strategies

Different cultivation strategies have been compared for the production of Rhizopus oryzae lipase (ROL) from Pichia pastoris. Several drawbacks have been found using a methanol non-limited fed-batch. On the one hand, oxygen limitation appeared at early cell dry weights and, on the other hand, high cell death was observed. A temperature limited fed-batch has been proposed to solve both problems. However, in our case study a methanol non-limited fed-batch results in better productivities. Finally, a lower salt medium were used to overcome cell death problems and a temperature limited fed-batch was applied thereafter to solve oxygen transfer limitations. This combined strategy has resulted in lower productivities when compared to a methanol non-limited fed-batch. However the culture could be longer prolonged and a 1.3-fold purer final product was obtained mainly due to cell death reduction.     

Methanol induction optimization for scFv antibody fragment production in Pichia pastoris

Fibronectin splice variant ED B (extracellular domain B) is a promising marker for angiogenesis in growing solid tumors. Currently, recombinant antibodies against ED B are being investigated concerning their potential use, for either therapeutic or diagnostic purposes. Single-chain antibody fragments directed against the ED B can be efficiently expressed in Pichia pastoris; thus, a recombinant strain of the methylotropic yeast P. pastoris was used for this work. Three different forms of scFv antibody fragment are found in the supernatant from this fermentation: covalent homodimer, associative homodimer, and monomer. Both homodimeric forms can be converted to the monomeric form (under reducing conditions) and be efficiently radiolabeled, whereas the monomeric form of scFv already present in the supernatant cannot. It was also found that the fraction of protein in the monomeric form is highly dependent on the mode of induction rather than scFv concentration. This suggests that the monomeric form of the scFv present in the supernatant might be a result of events occurring at the expression, secretion, or folding level. A high cell density fermentation protocol was developed by optimizing methanol induction, yielding the highest scFv antibody fragment production rate and product quality; cell concentration at the induction point and specific methanol uptake rate were found to be the most important control variables. A decrease in specific methanol uptake rate led to a higher specific production rate for the scFv antibody fragment (5.4 microg g(cell) h(-1)). Product quality, i.e., percentage of product in a homodimeric form, also increased with the decrease in methanol uptake rate. Furthermore, the volumetric productivity depended on cell concentration at the induction point, increasing with the increase of cell concentration up to 320 g L(-1) wet cell weight (WCW). The reduction of the methanol feeding rate for induction, and consequently of the oxygen uptake rate, have important consequences for optimizing product titers and quality and thus on the scale-up of this production process; hence one of the major limitations upon high cell density cultivation in bioreactors is keeping the high oxygen transfer rate required. From the results obtained, a scale-up strategy was developed based on the available oxygen transfer rates at larger scales, allowing the definition of the optimum biomass concentration for induction and methanol feeding strategy for maximization of product titer and quality.     

Optimizing the Production of Bacterial Cellulose in Surface Culture: A Novel Aerosol Bioreactor Working on a Fed Batch Principle (Part 3)

Parts 1 and 2 have shown that the rate of production of bacterial cellulose stagnates because of the limitation of substrate supply and a wall effect, which hinders the removal of the product from the active cell zone. This paper demonstrates, how both of these problems can be eliminated in a novel bioreactor, where the substrates (mainly glucose and oxygen) are both fed directly to the surface of the product cellulose. This involves the generation of an aerosol spray of glucose and its even distribution to the living bacteria on the medium‐air interface. The apparatus was built and operated up to eight weeks with a constant rate of cellulose production. The aerosol system provides the basis for an economic production of bacterial cellulose in surface culture.     

Methanol Inhibition in Continuous Culture of Hansenula polymorpha

Growth inhibition of Hansenula polymorpha DL-1 by methanol, formaldehyde, formate, and formic acid was examined to determine the causes of unstable behavior observed during continuous cultures on methanol. The much greater inhibition of growth by formic acid than by formate and the effect of formic acid excretion and assimilation on pH helped to explain culture dynamics observed after transitory oxygen limitations. Oxygen limitation caused by temporary reduction of agitation in a continuous fermentation caused methanol to accumulate to inhibitory concentrations. Immediately after resumption of agitation, formic acid was produced and caused culture inhibition. To ensure the stability of H. polymorpha in continuous culture, it was therefore necessary to prevent transient methanol accumulation.     

Cyclic fed-batch culture for production of human serum albumin in Pichia pastoris

Simple cyclic fed-batch culture (cfbc), consisting of a constant medium feed with periodic withdrawals of culture, resulted in a product yield (13.4 mg protein per gram biomass) similar to that obtained using the complex multiphase industrial production strategy (13.7 mg protein per gram biomass). In cfbc, productivity was ultimately limited by the rate at which the cells could assimilate methanol. Glycerol was inhibitory to growth at high concentrations. However, product yield continued to increase as the glycerol concentration was increased. In chemostat culture, dissolved oxygen concentration influenced product yield independently of any detectable influence on cell growth.     

Oxygen-limited fed-batch process: an alternative control for Pichia pastoris recombinant protein processes

An oxygen-limited fed-batch technique (OLFB) was compared to traditional methanol-limited fed-batch technique (MLFB) for the production of recombinant Thai Rosewood β-glucosidase with Pichia pastoris. The degree of energy limitation, expressed as the relative rate of respiration (q _O/q _O,max), was kept similar in both the types of processes. Due to the higher driving force for oxygen transfer in the OLFB, the oxygen and methanol consumption rates were about 40% higher in the OLFB. The obligate aerobe P. pastoris responded to the severe oxygen limitation mainly by increased maintenance demand, measured as increased carbon dioxide production per methanol, but still somewhat higher cell density (5%) and higher product concentrations (16%) were obtained. The viability was similar, about 90–95%, in both process types, but the amount of total proteins released in the medium was much less in the OLFB processes resulting in substantially higher (64%) specific enzyme purity for input to the downstream processing.     

A simulation model for the continuous production of acetoin and butanediol using Bacillus subtilis with integrated pervaporation separation

The potential for producing acetoin and butanediol with a Bacillus subtilis strain was investigated with continuous culture using molasses as carbon substrate. The steady-state results were influenced by both oxygen and undetermined limiting compounds. Employing the known metabolic pathways, four overall stoichiometry relations were used with an energetic assumption on the energy requirements for biomass formation to establish a linear relations were used with an energetic assumption on the energy requirements for biomass formation to establish a linear relation between the overall rates, whose parameters were determined by linear regression. This provided a relationship for the product formation rate. The chemostat culture data were described with a growth kinetics model, which included limitation by molasses and oxygen as well as diauxic effects and product inhibition. The biokinetics model was combined with an experimentally verified model for the membrane Pervaporation. From this combined model were determined the influence of the membrane characteristics (enrichment factors and membrane area) and the dilution rate on the performance of the integrated process. Simulations revealed that an increase of the enrichment factor, possible by membrane improvement, would have counteracting influences, owing to decreased product inhibition but with lower biomass concentration. (c) 1993 Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Effect of methanol feeding strategies on production and yield of recombinant mouse endostatin from Pichia pastoris

Pichia pastoris, a methylotrophic yeast, is an efficient producer of recombinant proteins in which the heterologous gene is under the control of the methanol-induced AOX1 promoter. Hence, the accepted production procedure has two phases: In the first phase, the yeast utilizes glycerol and biomass is accumulated; in the second phase, the yeast utilizes methanol which is used both as an inducer for the expression of the recombinant protein and as a carbon source. Since the yeast is sensitive to methanol concentration, the methanol is supplied gradually to the growing culture. Three methanol addition strategies were evaluated for the purpose of optimizing recombinant endostatin production. Two strategies were based on the yeast metabolism; one responding to the methanol consumption using a methanol sensor, and the other responding to the oxygen consumption. In these two strategies, the methanol supply is unlimited. The third strategy was based on a predetermined exponential feeding rate, controling the growth rate at 0.02 h(-1), in this strategy the methanol supply is limited. Throughout the induction phase glycerol, in addition to methanol, was continuously added at a rate of 1 g L h(-1). Total endostatin production was similar in all three strategies, (400 mg was obtained from 3 L initial volume), but the amount of methanol added and the biomass produced were lower in the predetermined rate method. This caused the specific production of endostatin per biomass and per methanol to be 2 times higher in the predetermined rate than in the other two methods, making the growth control strategy not only more efficient but also more convenient for downstream processing.     

Regulation of calbindin-D9k expression by 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) and parathyroid hormone in mouse primary renal tubular cells

Membranes of the obligate methylotroph Methylobacillus flagellatus KT contained hemes B, O, and C and cytochromes b, o, and c both in batch and in continuous cultures. Neither heme A nor heme D was detected in the membranes. The cytochromes o and bb were the main components reversibly binding carbon monoxide (CO) in the terminal part of the respiratory chain. The alpha-region and especially the alpha-peaks at 568 and 573 nm and the alpha-troughs at 586 and 592 on the CO-difference spectra were diagnostic for the cytochromes o and bb, respectively. The cytochrome o content increased up to 1.8 times upon increasing the dilution rate of the culture from 0.15 to 0.55 h(-1) under methanol limitation. By contrast, the level of the CO-binding cytochrome bb was not affected by methanol concentration but its content increased up to 1.9 times when the level of oxygen decreased from 95 to 21 microM under the constant dilution rate (mu = 0.55 h(-1)). The maximum ratio between the cytochromes o and bb reached 2 during continuous cultivation under methanol-limited conditions (mu = 0.55 h(-1)), whereas the minimum ratio between them was about 0.7 during batch cultivation at stationary phase of growth. The synthesis of the CO-binding cytochrome bb but not of the cytochrome o in M. flagellatus KT was assumed to depend on the ambient redox potential of the medium. The cytochrome o synthesis was supposed to depend on the transmembrane gradient of protons (Delta(mu)H+).     

Interactions in a mixed bacterial population growing on methane in continuous culture

The growth of a mixed methane-utilizing culture in a continuous flow fermenter has been studied under both methane and oxygen limitation. Small additions of methanol have been shown to inhibit the methane-utilizing moiety in the culture and it has been shown that the Hyphomicrobium sp. in the mixed culture removes any inhibitory methanol. The interaction between the methane-utilizing Pseudomonas sp., and the Hyphomicrobium sp. has been explained and a model of the continuous mixed culture under oxygen limitation has been formulated. Qualitative predictions of transient phenomena by the model have been verified experimentally.     

Growth and lipid production of Umbelopsis isabellina on a solid substrate—Mechanistic modeling and validation

Microbial lipids are an interesting feedstock for biodiesel. Their production from agricultural waste streams by fungi cultivated in solid-state fermentation may be attractive, but the yield of this process is still quite low. In this article, a mechanistic model is presented that describes growth, lipid production and lipid turnover in a culture of Umbelopsis isabellina on κ-carrageenan plates containing the monomers glucose and alanine as C-source and N-source, respectively, and improves the understanding of the complex solid-state system. The model includes reaction kinetics and diffusion of glucose, alanine and oxygen. It is validated empirically and describes the different phases of the culture very well: exponential growth, linear growth because of oxygen limitation, accumulation of lipids and carbohydrates after local N-depletion and turnover of lipids after local C-depletion. Extending the model with an unidentified extracellular product improved the fit of the model to the data. The model shows that oxygen limitation is extremely important in solid-state cultures using monomers, and explains the difference in production rate with submerged cultures. However, the results also show that the specific lipid production rate in solid-state cultures is much lower than in submerged cultures, which results in a low lipid yield.     

Pichia pastoris fermentation optimization: energy state and testing a growth-associated model

A growth-associated model was applied to the production of recombinant ovine interferon-τ (rOvIFN-τ) with Pichia pastoris for the purpose of manufacturing preclinical and clinical active material. This model predicts that product yields will be the greatest when the specific growth of the culture is maintained at a steady and optimal rate. However, rOvIFN-τ yields did not meet the expected linear model but most closely corresponded to a polynomial relationship. After transitioning from glycerol to methanol, product accumulated for 31–45 h, and then the yield decreased. This production shift, which has been termed decoupling, was clearly related to time on methanol and not culture density. It was determined that a correlation exists between the decoupling point and a drop in energy state of the cell when expressing β-galactosidase. By assigning decoupling as a constraint that limits productivity and by reformulating the growth medium, the time prior to decoupling increased to 46.8±2.4 h, product yield improved for rOvIFN-τ from 203 to 337 mg l⁻¹, and the coefficient of variation for yield decreased from 67.9 to 23.3%. A robust and stable fermentation process was realized, resulting in a 210% improvement in total yield from 557±357 to 1,172±388 mg.     

Modeling of growth and energy metabolism of Pichia pastoris producing a fusion protein

A fusion protein composed of a cellulose binding domain from Neocallimastix patriciarum cellulase A and Candida antarctica lipase B (CBD-lipase) was produced by Pichia pastoris methanol utilization plus phenotype in high cell-density cultures. The genes expressing CBD-lipase were fused to the alpha-factor secretion signal sequence of Saccharomyces cerevisiae and placed under the control of the alcohol oxidase gene (AOX1) promoter. To control the repression and induction of AOX1 and oxygen demand at high cell density, a four-stage process was used. Batch growth on glycerol was used in the first step to provide biomass (28 g L^-1) while product formation was prevented due to repression of the AOX1. The second stage was exponential fed-batch growth on glycerol, which caused a slight increase of the enzyme alcohol oxidase activity due to derepression of the AOX1. This procedure resulted in smooth transition to exponential fed-batch growth on methanol, the third stage, in which the AOX1 was strongly induced. The fourth stage was constant fed-batch growth on methanol used to control the oxygen demand at the high cell density. A kinetic model was developed that could predict biomass growth and oxygen consumption in processes with and without oxygen-enriched air. With oxygen enrichment to 34% O₂ in the inlet air the methanol feed rate could be increased by 50% and this resulted in 14% higher final cell density (from 140 to 160 g L^-1 cell dry weight). The increased methanol feed rate resulted in a proportionally increased specific rate of product secretion to the medium. After an initial decrease, the synthesis capacity of the cell was kept constant throughout the cultivation, which made the product concentration increase almost constantly during the process. The kinetic model also describes how the low maintenance demand of P. pastoris compared with E. coli enables this organism to grow to such high cell densities.     

Dissolved-oxygen-stat controlling two variables for methanol induction of rGuamerin in Pichia pastoris and its application to repeated fed-batch

A DO-stat control strategy for two variables was introduced to the rGuamerin production process in Pichia pastoris and applied to repeated fed-batch culture. Two interrelated variables, namely the ratio of partial pressure of pure O2 in the inlet air-stream and the methanol feed rate, were controlled simultaneously. By using this control strategy, methanol feeding for induction could be controlled automatically while efficiently controlling the dissolved oxygen level. As a result, the cell concentration reached more than 140 g l(-1) and rGuamerin expression level 450 iu l(-1). rGuamerin was secreted into the culture medium and reached a level that was 40% higher than achieved in a fed-batch process using manual control of the methanol feeding rate. Repeated rGuamerin induction was achieved by repeating the methanol feeding and withdrawing the culture broth during extended production. During more than 250 h of culture, expression of rGuamerin was maintained at an average of about 430 iu l(-1 )(473 mg l(-1)), without causing the cell density to decrease. In addition to the rGuamerin production process, the proposed control system might be applied to cultivation of other methylotrophic yeasts in the production of therapeutic proteins.     

High-cell-density production of poly-β-hydroxybutyrate (PHB) from methanol by Methylobacterium extorquens: production of high-molecular-mass PHB

Methylobacterium extorquens ATCC 55366 was successfully cultivated at very high cell densities in a fed-batch fermentation system using methanol as a sole carbon and energy source and a completely minimal culture medium for the production of poly--hydroxybutyrate (PHB). Cell biomass levels were between 100 g/l and 115 g/l (dry weight) and cells contained between 40% and 46% PHB on a dry-weight basis. PHB with higher molecular mass values than previously reported for methylotrophic bacteria was obtained under certain conditions. Shake-flask and fermentor experiments showed the importance of adjusting the mineral composition of the medium for improved biomass production and higher growth rates. High-cell-density cultures were obtained without the need for oxygen-enriched air; once the oxygen transfer capacity of the fermentor was reached, methanol was thereafter added in proportion to the amount of available dissolved oxygen, thus preventing oxygen limitation. Controlling the methanol concentration at a very low level (less than 0.01 g/l), during the PHB production phase, led not only to prevention of oxygen limitation but also to the production of very high-molecular-mass PHB, in the 900–1800 kDa range. Biomass yields relative to the total methanol consumed were in the range 0.29–0.33 g/g, whereas PHB yields were in the range 0.09–0.12 g/g. During the active period of PHB synthesis, PHB yields relative to the total methanol consumed were between 0.2 g/g and 0.22 g/g. M. extorquens ATCC 55366 appears to be a promising organism for industrial PHB production.