Evidence that the nerve controls molecular identity of progenitor cells for limb regeneration

Adult urodele amphibians can regenerate their limbs after amputation by a process that requires the presence of axons at the amputation plane. Paradoxically, if the limb develops in the near absence of nerves (the 'aneurogenic' limb) it can subsequently regenerate in a nerve-independent fashion. The growth zone (blastema) of regenerating limbs normally contains progenitor cells whose division is nerve-dependent. A monoclonal antibody that marks these nerve-dependent cells in the normal blastema does not stain the mesenchymal cells of developing limb buds and only stains the amputated limb bud when axons have reached the plane of amputation. This report shows that the blastemal cells of the regenerating aneurogenic limb also fail to react with the antibody in situ. These data suggest that the blastemal cells arising during normal regeneration have been altered by the nerve. This regulation may occur either at the time of amputation (when the antigen is expressed) or during development (when the limb is first innervated).     

Glial growth factor and nerve-dependent proliferation in the regeneration blastema of Urodele amphibians

After amputation of a limb from Urodele amphibians, division of the blastemal cells (the progenitor cells of the regenerate) depends on one or more unidentified growth factors provided by the nerve supply. Here we show that glial growth factor (GGF), a mitogenic protein previously purified from the bovine pituitary, is present in newt nervous system extracts. It is also detectable in extracts of the forelimb regeneration blastema, and its level there decreases after denervation. We have previously shown that blastemal cells dependent on the nerve for division are marked by a monoclonal antibody called 22/18. When denervated blastemas are cultured in the presence of partially purified GGF from newt brain, or pure GGF from the bovine pituitary, the thymidine labeling index of blastemal cells that are 22/18-positive is increased as much as sevenfold. These data indicate that GGF plays a role in nerve-dependent proliferation in the blastema.     

The monoclonal antibody 22/18 recognizes a conformational change in an intermediate filament of the newt,Notophthalmus viridescens,during limb regeneration

Summary Previous work has shown that the monoclonal antibody 22/18 identifies progenitor cells (blastemal cells) which depend on the nerve for their division in the early stages of limb regeneration in the newt,Notophthalmus viridescens. This antibody also reacts with cultured cells derived from the newt limb, and the intensity of immunoreactivity appears related to cell density and differentiation into myotubes. We report here that the monoclonal antibody 22/18 recognizes a polypeptide (22/18 antigen) which is intracellular and filamentous. Double staining of cells with 22/18 monoclonal antibody and antibodies against various cytoskeletal components indicates that the epitope is expressed on an intermediate filament component. Although this antibody is specific for blastemal cells in cryostat sections of the regenerating limb, its reactivity on immunoblots is not confined to this tissue. The 22/18 antigen is differentially affected by aldehyde fixatives distinguished by the spacing of their reactive groups. While formaldehyde fixation impairs detection of the antigen, ethylene glycol-bis[succinic acid n-hydroxysuccinimide ester] reveals the antigen in sections of normal and regenerating limbs in a distribution that is consistent with the one obtained from immunoblots. We suggest that the 22/18 monoclonal antibody detects a change in protein conformation, probably related to changes in the physiological state of the cell, that occurs transiently during regeneration and possibly during development.     

A monoclonal antibody stains myogenic cells in regenerating newt muscle

Monoclonal antibodies have been used to study minced muscle regeneration in the adult newt, Notophthalmus viridescens. The contralateral limb was amputated and the immunostaining patterns in the regenerating blastema were compared with the minced tissue in sectioned material. Staining with a myofibre-specific antibody, called 12/101 (Kintner & Brockes, 1984), showed that myofibre degeneration was complete by 8-10 days after mincing, with myogenesis commencing 2 days later. Another monoclonal antibody, called 22/18, previously shown to label a subset of cells in the regeneration blastema of the newt (Kintner & Brockes, 1984, 1985), was found also to recognize a population of cells in regenerating minced muscle. At 6 days after mincing, the number of 22/18-positive (22/18+) cells was low but by days 12-16, during the period of myogenesis, their number had increased to become a major population within the minced tissue. A small number of the 22/18+ cells could be double labelled with 12/101 at this time. Prior to this, there was a phase in which 12/101 staining had disappeared from the mince. Cells immunoreactive with both antibodies after this phase confirm that at least some of the 22/18+ cells are myogenic. The number of 22/18+ cells decreased as muscle repair and maturation progressed. These results show that 22/18 is not specifically associated with blastemal cells but is a more general marker for regenerating systems in the newt. They further suggest an alternative interpretation of the double-labelled cells used by Kintner & Brockes (1984) as evidence for myofibre dedifferentiation in limb regeneration. Instead, we propose that such cells represent new myogenesis occurring by tissue repair of locally damaged muscle fibres.     

New regulators of vertebrate appendage regeneration

Appendage regeneration is a complex and fascinating biological process exhibited in vertebrates by urodele amphibians and teleost fish. A current focus in the field is to identify new molecules that control formation and function of the regeneration blastema, a mass of proliferative mesenchyme that emerges after limb or fin amputation and serves as progenitor tissue for lost structures. Two studies published recently have illuminated new molecular regulators of blastemal proliferation. After amputation of a newt limb, the nerve sheath releases nAG, a blastemal mitogen that facilitates regeneration. In amputated zebrafish fins, regeneration is optimized through depletion of the microRNA miR-133, a mechanism that requires Fgf signaling. These discoveries establish research avenues that may impact the regenerative capacity of mammalian tissues.     

An immunofluorescent study of the distribution of fibronectin and laminin during limb regeneration in the adult newt

Fibronectin and laminin are two extracellular glycoproteins which are involved in various processes of cellular development and differentiation. The present investigation describes changes in their distribution during regeneration of the newt forelimb, as determined by indirect immunofluorescence. The distribution of fibronectin and laminin was similar in normal limb tissue components. These glycoproteins were localized in the pericellular region of the myofibers corresponding to its basement membrane; the perineurium and endoneurium of the nerves; and the basement membranes of blood vessels, skin epithelium, and dermal glands. The cytoplasm of myofibers, axons, skin epithelium, and bone matrix lacked fluorescence for both glycoproteins. After limb amputation in the regenerating blastema, extensive presence of fibronectin, but not laminin, was seen in and around the undifferentiated blastemal cells. Increased fluorescence for fibronectin was also seen during blastema growth, blastemal cell aggregation, and early stages of redifferentiation. As redifferentiation continued, staining for fibronectin slowly disappeared from the cartilage matrix and the myoblast fusion zone. Laminin was first observed around the regenerated myotubes; this was followed by the appearance of fibronectin suggesting a sequential formation of these two components of the new myotube basement membrane. In the regenerated limb, the distribution of laminin and fibronectin was similar to that seen in normal limb. Based on the distribution pattern of these glycoproteins, it is concluded that fibronectin may play an important role in blastemal cell aggregation, cell alignment, and initiation of redifferentiation. After redifferentiation, both laminin and fibronectin may be important in the determination of the architecture of the regenerated limb.     

Hedgehog and Wnt coordinate signaling in myogenic progenitors and regulate limb regeneration

Amphibians have a remarkable capacity for limb regeneration. Following a severe injury, there is complete regeneration with restoration of the patterning and cellular architecture of the amputated limb. While studies have focused on the structural anatomical changes during amphibian limb regeneration, the signaling mechanisms that govern cellular dedifferentiation and blastemal progenitors are unknown. Here, we demonstrate the temporal and spatial requirement for hedgehog (Hh) signaling and its hierarchical correlation with respect to Wnt signaling during newt limb regeneration. While the dedifferentiation process of mature lineages does not depend on Hh signaling, the proliferation and the migration of the dedifferentiated cells are dependent on Hh signaling. Temporally controlled chemical inactivation of the Hh pathway indicates that Hh-mediated antero-posterior (AP) specification occurs early during limb regeneration and that Hh is subsequently required for expansion of the blastemal progenitors. Inhibition of Hh signaling results in G0/G1 arrest with a concomitant reduction in S-phase and G2/M population in myogenic progenitors. Furthermore, Hh inhibition leads to reduced Pax7-positive cells and fewer regenerating fibers relative to control tissue. We demonstrate that activation of Wnt signaling rescues the inhibition of Hh pathway mainly by enhancing proliferative signals, possibly mediated through TCF4 activity. Collectively, our results demonstrate coordinated signaling of Hh and Wnt activities in regulating blastemal progenitors and their hierarchical positioning during limb regeneration.     

Retinoic acid-induced pattern duplication in regenerating urodele limbs

The effects of varying doses of retinoic acid on forelimb regeneration in larval Ambystoma mexicanum amputated through the wrist joint and in adult Notophthalmus viridescens amputated through the basal carpals were compared. In both species, the major effect of retinoic acid was to cause the proximodistal duplication, in the regenerate, of stump segments proximal to the amputation plane. Transverse axial duplications (anteroposterior and dorsoventral) occurred in a smaller percentage of cases; these consisted of cartilage spurs in axolotls, and extra digits in newts. The frequency and magnitude of the proximodistal and (in the newt) transverse duplications were dose dependent, and the regenerating limbs were maximally sensitive to the retinoid during the period of dedifferentiation and accumulation of blastema cells. The effect of retinoic acid is exerted on cells local to the amputation surface, as shown by the fact that retinoic acid caused the proximodistal duplication of stump segments in regenerates derived from amputated distal lower arm segments grafted to the eyesocket.     

Nerve interactions and regenerative processes occurring in newt limbs fused end-to-end

Peripheral nerve interactions and regenerative phenomena were studied in newt forelimbs fused end to end. After simple fusion, one or two spikelike structures regenerated at the plane of fusion in 88% of the cases. When one of the limbs was denervated at the time of fusion, no regeneration occurred from the plane of fusion. If the limbs were fused and one was amputated at the shoulder more than 10 days after fusion, regeneration from the amputation surface did not occur. When the limbs were reamputated 30 days later, regeneration of left limbs from the proximodistally reversed right limb stumps followed. If one of the limbs was denervated at the time of fusion, and amputation was subsequently carried out through the formerly denervated limb, regeneration always took place after the first amputation. On the basis of these results it is postulated that when regenerating nerves of opposite proximodistal polarity meet head-on, the majority of fibers, at least, do not grow into territories occupied by the other nerve. These results have also demonstrated that full limb regeneration can occur at a greater distance from the midline than the end of a normal limb. These experiments also provide a technique for artificially elongating peripheral nerves.     

Evidence that regenerative ability is an intrinsic property of limb cells in Xenopus

Xenopus laevis exhibits an ontogenetic decline in the ability to regenerate its limbs: Young tadpoles can completely regenerate an amputated limb, whereas post metamorphic froglets regenerate at most a cartilagenous "spike." We have tested the regenerative competence of normally regenerating limb buds of stage 52-53 Xenopus tadpoles grafted onto limb stumps of postmetamorphic froglets. The limb buds become vascularized and innervated by the host and, when amputated, regenerate limbs with normal or slightly less than normal numbers of tadpole hindlimb digits. Reciprocal grafts of froglet forelimb blastemas onto tadpole hindlimb stumps resulted in either autonomous development of tadpole hindlimb structures and/or formation of a cartilaginous spike typical of froglet forelimb regeneration. Our results suggest that the Xenopus froglet host environment is completely permissive for regeneration and that the ability to regenerate a complete limb pattern is an intrinsic property of young tadpole limb cells, a property that is lost during ontogenesis.     

In vitro and in vivo characterization of blastemal cells from regenerating newt limbs.

To better characterize the cells involved in newt limb regeneration, blastemal cells from accumulation and differentiation phase blastemas were grown in dissociated cell culture, and their morphology and antigenic phenotype determined using a variety of antibodies directed against intermediate filaments, cell adhesion molecules, and extracellular matrix molecules. In addition to previously described blastemal cell morphologies, many of the cells in these cultures had a round cell body, with an eccentrically placed nucleus and a cytoplasm filled with autofluorescent granules. The majority of accumulation phase blastemal cells labeled with antibodies against GFAP, vimentin, 22/18 as well as with antibodies against NCAM, L-1, laminin, and fibronectin. The majority of differentiation phase blastemal cells had a similar phenotype but lacked expression of vimentin and fibronectin. Comparison of the blastemal phenotype in vitro and in vivo showed similar expression characteristics. However, in differentiation phase blastemas, laminin immunoreactivity was concentrated in specific locations. In addition, the proliferation of cultured blastemal cells is stimulated by the addition of a crude brain extract, consistent with previous studies in vivo and in vitro. Taken together, these observations suggest that dissociated cultures of newt limb blastemal cells provide a suitable model for the analysis of the cell and molecular mechanisms involved in limb regeneration.     

Blastema cell proliferation in vitro: effects of limb amputation on the mitogenic activity of spinal cord extracts

Primary cultures of mesenchymal cells of axolotl limb blastemas provide a very sensitive in vitro bioassay for studying nerve dependence of newt regeneration. These cells can be stimulated by crude spinal cord extracts of non-amputated animals in a dose-dependent manner up to 60 micrograms protein/ml of culture medium; at this concentration the mitotic index is increased 4-fold. Spinal cord extracts of axolotls 14 days after forelimb amputation (i.e., late bud stage) are more efficient in stimulating blastema cell proliferation (+50%) than extracts of axolotls 7 days after forelimb amputation (i.e., early bud stage) or of axolotls without amputation. In a similar manner, spinal cord extracts of young axolotls 14 days after forelimb amputation, are more stimulatory than older axolotls 14 d after forelimb amputation which regenerate only a very small blastema during the same time. It appears that spinal cord mitogenic activity is enhanced after limb amputation, probably in correlation with blastema cell requirements for limb regeneration.     

Expression of the 9G1 antigen in the apical cap of axolotl regenerates requires nerves and mesenchyme

Monoclonal antibody 9G1 (mAb 9G1) is reactive to the wound epithelium of axolotl larvae and therefore provided the opportunity to examine the interaction between the wound epithelium, nerves, and blastemal mesenchyme during axolotl limb regeneration. In unamputated limbs, mAb 9G1 is reactive to most or all cells of the dermis, skeletal elements, blood vessels, and nerves, to a few unidentified cells in muscle, and to none in epidermis. During regeneration of axolotl limbs, mAb 9G1 reacts strongly to an intracellular antigen of the blastemal mesenchyme and of the distal-most portion of the wound epithelium, the so-called apical epithelial cap (AEC). Because this thickened wound epithelium of regenerating amphibian limbs has been suggested as functioning in a manner similar to the apical ectodermal ridge (AER) of embryonic limb buds, it was of interest to further examine the reactivity of mAb 9G1 during various stages of regeneration. Whether mAb 9G1 reactivity in the AEC depended on mesenchyme and/or nerves was also tested. Monoclonal antibody 9G1 reactivity appears in the AEC of regenerating limbs prior to outgrowth of the blastema and persists throughout blastemal stages. Apical epithelial cap reactivity to mAb 9G1 is nerve dependent during early stages of blastema development and becomes nerve-independent at later stages. When epithelium-free blastemal mesenchyme is grafted onto injured flank musculature, ectopic limb regeneration occurs and the AEC derived from flank epidermis exhibits mAb 9G1 reactivity. These results show that a mAb 9G1 reactive AEC is characteristic of regenerating limbs and that expression of the 9G1 antigen by the AEC is dependent upon underlying blastemal mesenchyme and nerves.     

Treatment of brachial nerves with colchicine inhibits limb regeneration in the newt Notophthalmus viridescens

In urodele amphibians, limb regeneration is dependent on innervation and is blocked by the administration of colchicine. The objective of this experiment was to determine if colchicine blocks limb regeneration by a direct action on the blastema cells or by an indirect action on the nerves, specifically, if colchicine treatment of the brachial nerves would inhibit limb regeneration in the newt Notophthalmus viridescens. Colchicine was applied to the nerves by implanting a colchicine-loaded silastin block adjacent to the brachial nerves of an amputated newt limb. With appropriate dose levels of colchicine, limb regeneration was completely inhibited. Contralateral control limbs, carrying unloaded silastin blocks, and control limbs with colchicine-loaded blocks implanted equidistant from the blastema, but not adjacent to the brachial nerves, regenerated normally. Thus, the results indicate that the colchicine inhibition of limb regeneration is mediated by colchicine effects on the nerves. The possible mechanism of colchicine action on nerves may involve either wallerian degeneration, or inhibition of axoplasmic transport, or both.     

The influence of the nerve on lower jaw regeneration in the adult newt, Triturus viridescens

The present investigation was undertaken in an attempt to determine the role played by the nerve in the regeneration of the lower jaw of the adult newt, Triturus viridescens. The results indicated that the number of nerve fibers normally available at the amputation surface was very low compared with that of the newt forelimb. Furthermore, denervation of the lower jaw reduced the number of nerve fibers available to an extremely low level and maintained the number at a low level for up to four weeks without intervening redenervations. The regenerative events in the denervated and amputated lower jaws were indistinguishable histologically from those in amputated jaws having normal innervation. This presented an apparent exception to the general rule that regeneration of external body parts is dependent on the nerve. Several possible explanations are proposed by which this apparent exception might be explained. The process following amputation might be an exaggerated form of wound healing and tissue regeneration which can occur in the absence of nerves. The tissues of the lower jaw might be more sensitive to the influence of those nerve fibers present. The nerve fibers themselves might be qualitatively different and thus exert a greater influence on the tissues.     

Cell interactions and regeneration control

This paper is a review of the main findings of our laboratory on the control of regeneration by cell interactions. These include results related to the role of both cell contact and local soluble factors in regeneration of the legs of insects and newts and of the parapodia and segments of nereis. The pattern of these structures is considered to be defined by positional information distributed as longitudinal and transverse positional value sequences carried by epidermal (insect) or mesenchymal (newt) cells. By associating tissues to create transverse and longitudinal discontinuities in these sequences, single or multiple regenerating structures were obtained. These structures are formed by the intercalation of cells characterized by intermediate positional values which fill the gap between the tissues in contact. Positional information may also be changed during regeneration by the nerve cord in nereis and retinoids in the newts. We describe additional cases where morphogenesis occurs without any overt discontinuity in positional information, such as from a locally injured or non-injured insect trochanter, or after deflection of nerves in nereis and newt. Regeneration following an amputation may be considered as a special case of intercalary regeneration, the first stage being the juxtaposition of normally non-contiguous cells resulting in a longitudinal or/and a transverse gap. We also report studies on local factors produced by nerves and the blastema during newt limb regeneration. The nerve factor is necessary for the division of blastemal cells. After denervation, mesenchyme differentiates in an abnormal way. The mitogenic signal from the nerves is mediated by the PKC pathway. Its production is enhanced by regeneration of cut nerve fibers. The blastema also produces growth factors. We show that the epidermal cap and mesenchyme contain acidic FGF-like factor, and that the proliferating mesenchyme stimulates nerve fibers to regrow into the blastema.     

In vitro effects of insulin on macromolecular events in newt limb regeneration blastemata

This work provides data demonstrating a stimulatory effect of insulin on macromolecular events occurring in cultured regeneration blastemata and demonstrates a synergistic interdependence between nerves and insulin in newt limb regeneration. The current experiments provide evidence for the following: (1) Insulin is paramount for expression of the mitogenic effect of nerves on cultures blastemata. (2) Insulin stimulates the incorporation of (3H)uridine into the acid-insoluble fraction of blastemal homogenates, but it does not alter the turnover rate of incorporated labeled uridine. (3) Insulin also stimulates the incorporation of 35SO4 and (3H)leucine into both chondroitinase-sensitive and chondroitinase-resistant blastemal proteoglycans. (4) Insulin increases the uptake of radiolabeled precursors by the blastemata, namely, (3H)leucine, (3H)uridine, 35SO4, (3H)alpha-aminoisobutyrate, and (3H)2-deoxy-D-glucose. The importance of insulin in the regulation of newt limb regeneration is discussed.     

Relationship between innervation and forelimb regenerative capacity in the postmetamorphic pond frog Rana brevipoda porosa.

The limb regenerative capacity and the quantity of innervation (the percentage of a cross-sectional area of amputation forelimb stump occupied by nerves) in the pond frog, Rana brevipoda porosa, was investigated in postmetamorphic froglets and adults of various sizes by means of amputating forelimbs through the zeugopodium. Nearly all the amputated limbs of newly metamorphosed froglets, 18-19 mm in snout-vent length, showed heteromorphic regeneration. However, the larger the body size, the lower the presence of limb regeneration. Limb regenerative capacity was completely lost in froglets and adults with snout-vents larger than 35 mm. The quantity of innervation of limbs was highest in newly metamorphosed froglets, gradually decreasing with growth. The nerve quantity in adults with a snout-vent length between 60-67 mm was approximately half that of the froglets. When the nerve supply was augmented by deviating ipsilateral sciatic nerve bundles to the forelimb stump, almost all limbs, which were usually non-regenerative with normal innervation, regenerated heteromorphically. These results show that the decline in limb regenerative capacity during postmetamorphic growth is in part attributable to the reduction in innervation levels to below the threshold level required for regeneration.     

The relationship of innervation and differentiation to regenerative capacity in the reamputated hindlimb of larval Xenopus laevis

Regenerated hindlimbs of larval Xenopus laevis were reamputated at critical larval stages and levels, viz when amputation of the control limb at the same larval stage and level is followed by reduced regeneration. Reamputations were performed at the level of (1) the original plane of amputation, (2) the early regenerate (cone/palette stage), (3) the late regenerate (digit stage). Reamputation increased both the percentage rate of regeneration and the morphological complexity of the regenerates in all experimental series. Cell counts in lateral motor columns and spinal ganglia innervating the hindlimb, together with histological observations and mitotic index and labelling index determinations in reamputated and control limbs showed that improved regeneration in the reamputated limb was related to an increase in undifferentiated and proliferating cells in the stump. We did not find any evidence suggesting that renewed regeneration in reamputated anuran limbs results from an increase in innervation, as has previously been hypothesized. We support our conclusions by demonstrating an improvement in regenerationen in the reamputated and denervated hindlimbs.