Chicken avidin exhibits pseudo-catalytic properties. Biochemical, structural, and electrostatic consequences

Avidin and its bacterial analogue streptavidin exhibit similarly high affinities toward the vitamin biotin. The extremely high affinity of these two proteins has been utilized as a powerful tool in many biotechnological applications. Although avidin and streptavidin have similar tertiary and quaternary structures, they differ in many of their properties. Here we show that avidin enhances the alkaline hydrolysis of biotinyl p-nitrophenyl ester, whereas streptavidin protects this reaction even under extreme alkaline conditions (pH > 12). Unlike normal enzymatic catalysis, the hydrolysis reaction proceeds as a single cycle with no turnover because of the extremely high affinity of the protein for one of the reaction products (i.e. free biotin). The three-dimensional crystal structures of avidin (2 A) and streptavidin (2.4 A) complexed with the amide analogue, biotinyl p-nitroanilide, as a model for the p-nitrophenyl ester, revealed structural insights into the factors that enhance or protect the hydrolysis reaction. The data demonstrate that several molecular features of avidin are responsible for the enhanced hydrolysis of biotinyl p-nitrophenyl ester. These include the nature of a decisive flexible loop, the presence of an obtrusive arginine 114, and a newly formed critical interaction between lysine 111 and the nitro group of the substrate. The open conformation of the loop serves to expose the substrate to the solvent, and the arginine shifts the p-nitroanilide moiety toward the interacting lysine, which increases the electron withdrawing characteristics and consequent electrophilicity of the carbonyl group of the substrate. Streptavidin lacked such molecular properties, and analogous interactions with the substrate were consequently absent. The information derived from these structures may provide insight into the action of artificial protein catalysts and the evolution of catalytic sites in general.     

Biotin reagents for antibody pretargeting. 5. Additional studies of biotin conjugate design to provide biotinidase stability.

An investigation was conducted in which the stabilities of four structurally different biotin derivatives were assessed with regard to biotinamide bond hydrolysis by the enzyme biotinidase. The biotin derivatives studied contained an extra methylene in the valeric acid chain of biotin (i.e., homobiotin), or contained conjugated amino acids having hydroxymethylene, carboxylate, or acetate functionalities on a methylene alpha to the biotinamide bond. The biotinidase hydrolysis assay was conducted on biotin derivatives that were radioiodinated at high specific activity, and then subjected to diluted human serum at 37 degrees C for 2 h. After incubation, assessment of biotinamide bond hydrolysis by biotinidase was readily achieved by measuring the percentage of radioactivity that did not bind with avidin. As controls, an unsubstituted biotin derivative which is rapidly cleaved by biotinidase and an N-methyl-substituted biotin derivative which is stable to biotinidase cleavage were included in the study. The results indicate that increasing the distance from the biotin ring structure to the biotinamide bond by one methylene only decreases the rate of biotinidase cleavage, but does not block it. The data obtained also indicate that placing a hydroxymethylene, carboxylate, or acetate alpha to the biotinamide bond is effective in blocking the biotinamide hydrolysis reaction. These data, in combination with data previously obtained, which indicate that biotin derivatives containing hydroxymethylene or carboxylate moieties retain the slow dissociation rate of biotin from avidin and streptavidin [Wilbur, D. S., et al. (2000) Bioconjugate Chem. 11, 569-583], strongly support incorporation of these structural features into biotin derivatives being used for in vivo targeting applications.     

Colorimetric competitive inhibition method for the quantification of avidin, streptavidin and biotin.

A colorimetric competitive inhibition assay for avidin, streptavidin and biotin was developed. The method for avidin or streptavidin was based on the competitive binding between avidin or streptavidin and a streptavidin-enzyme conjugate for biotinylated dextrin immobilized on the surface of a microtitre plate. For biotin quantitation the competition is between free biotin and the immobilized biotin for the streptavidin-enzyme conjugate. The limits of detection which was determined as the concentration of competitor required to give 90% of maximal absorbency (100% inhibition) was approximately 20 ng/100 microl per assay for avidin and streptavidin and 0.4 pg/100 microl per assay for biotin. The methods are simple, rapid, highly sensitive and adaptable to high throughput analysis.     

Factors dictating the pseudocatalytic efficiency of avidins

The hydrolysis of biotinyl p-nitrophenyl ester (BNP) by a series of avidin derivatives was examined. Surprisingly, a hyperthermostable avidin-related protein (AVR4) was shown to display extraordinary yet puzzling hydrolytic activity. In order to evaluate the molecular determinants that contribute to the reaction, the crystal structure of AVR4 was compared with those of avidin, streptavidin and key mutants of the two proteins in complex with biotinyl p-nitroanilide (BNA), the inert amide analogue of BNP. The structures revealed that a critical lysine residue contributes to the hydrolysis of BNP by avidin but has only a minor contribution to the AVR4-mediated reaction. Indeed, the respective rates of hydrolysis among the different avidins reflect several molecular parameters, including binding-site architecture, the availability of the ligand to solvent and the conformation of the ligand and consequent susceptibility to efficient nucleophilic attack. In avidin, the interaction of BNP with Lys111 and disorder of the L3,4 loop (and consequent solvent availability) together comprise the major driving force behind the hydrolysis, whereas in AVR4 the status of the ligand (the pseudo-substrate) is a major distinguishing feature. In the latter protein, a unique conformation of the L3,4 loop restrains the pseudo-substrate, thereby exposing the carbonyl carbon atom to nucleophilic attack. In addition, due to its conformation, the pseudo-substrate in the AVR4 complex cannot interact with the conserved lysine analogue (Lys109); instead, this function is superseded by polar interactions with Arg112. The results demonstrate that, in highly similar proteins, different residues can perform the same function and that subtle differences in the active-site architecture of such proteins can result in alternative modes of reaction.     

A sensitive enzyme assay for biotin, avidin, and streptavidin

Reciprocal enzyme assays are described for the vitamin biotin and for the biotin-binding proteins avidin and streptavidin. The assays are based on the following steps: (a) biotinylated bovine serum albumin is adsorbed onto microtiter plates; (b) streptavidin (or avidin) is bound to the biotin-coated plates; (c) biotinylated enzyme (in this case alkaline phosphatase) is then interacted with the free biotin-binding sites on the immobilized protein. For biotin assay, competition between the free vitamin and the biotinylated enzyme is carried out between steps (b) and (c). The method takes advantage of the four biotin-binding sites which characterize both avidin and streptavidin. The method is extremely versatile and accurate over a concentration range exceeding three orders of magnitude. The lower limits of detection are approximately 2 pg/ml (0.2 pg/sample) for biotin and less than 100 ng/ml (10 ng/sample) for either avidin or streptavidin.     

X-ray crystallographic studies of streptavidin mutants binding to biotin

On the basis of high resolution crystallographic studies of streptavidin and its biotin complex, three principal binding motifs have been identified that contribute to the tight binding. A flexible binding loop can undergo a conformational change from an open to a closed form when biotin is bound. Additional studies described here of unbound wild-type streptavidin have provided structural views of the open conformation. Several tryptophan residues packing around the bound biotin constitute the second binding motif, one dominated by hydrophobic interactions. Mutation of these residues to alanine or phenylalanine have variable effects on the thermodynamics and kinetics of binding, but they generate only small changes in the molecular structure. Hydrogen bonding interactions also contribute significantly to the binding energetics of biotin, and the D128A mutation which breaks a hydrogen bond between the protein and a ureido NH group results in a significant structural alteration that could mimic an intermediate on the dissociation pathway. In this review, we summarize the structural aspects of biotin recognition that have been gained from crystallographic analyses of wild-type and site-directed streptavidin mutants.     

Structure-based rational design of streptavidin mutants with pseudo-catalytic activity

Introduction of enzymatic activity into proteins or other types of polymers by rational design is a major objective in the life sciences. To date, relatively low levels of enzymatic activity could be introduced into antibodies by using transition-state analogues of haptens. In the present study, we identify the structural elements that contribute to the observed hydrolytic activity in egg white avidin, which promote the cleavage of active biotin esters (notably biotinyl p-nitrophenyl ester). The latter elements were then incorporated into bacterial streptavidin via genetic engineering. The streptavidin molecule was thus converted from a protector to an enhancer of hydrolysis of biotin esters. The conversion was accomplished by the combined replacement of a "lid-like loop" (L3,4) and a leucine-to-arginine point mutation in streptavidin. Interestingly, neither of these elements play a direct role in the hydrolytic reaction. The latter features were thus shown to be responsible for enhanced substrate hydrolysis. This work indicates that structural and non-catalytic elements of a protein can be modified to promote the induced fit of a substrate for subsequent interaction with either a catalytic residue or water molecules. This approach complements the conventional design of active sites that involves direct modifications of catalytic residues.     

Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopic studies on avidin secondary structure and complexation with biotin and biotin-lipid assemblies.

Fourier-transform infrared studies have been carried out to investigate the secondary structure and thermal stability of hen egg white avidin and its complexes with biotin and with a biotinylated lipid derivative, N-biotinyl dimyristoyl phosphatidylethanolamine (DMBPE) in aqueous dispersion. Analysis of the amide I stretching band of avidin yielded a secondary structural content composed of approximately 66% beta-sheet and extended structures, with the remainder being attributed to disordered structure and beta-turns. Binding of biotin or specific association with the biotinylated lipid DMBPE did not result in any appreciable changes in the secondary structure content of the protein, but a change in hydrogen bond stability of the beta-sheet or extended chain regions was indicated. The latter effect was enhanced by surface interactions in the case of the biotin-lipid assemblies, as was demonstrated by electrostatic binding to a nonspecific negatively charged lipid. Difference spectra of the bound biotin implicated a direct involvement of the ureido moiety in the ligand interaction that was consistent with hydrogen bonding to amino acid residues in the avidin protein. It was found that complexation with avidin leads to a decrease in bond length of the biotin ureido carbonyl group that is consistent with a reduction of sp3 character of the C-O bond when it is hydrogen bonded to the protein. Studies of the temperature dependence of the spectra revealed that for avidin alone the secondary structure was unaltered up to approximately 75 degrees C, above which the protein undergoes a highly cooperative transition to an unfolded state with concomitant loss of ordered secondary structure. The complexes of avidin with both biotin and membrane-bound DMBPE lipid assemblies display a large increase in thermal stability compared with the native protein.     

UV resonance Raman study of streptavidin binding of biotin and 2-iminobiotin: comparison with avidin

UV resonance Raman (UVRR) spectroscopy is used to study the binding of biotin and 2-iminobiotin by streptavidin, and the results are compared to those previously obtained from the avidin-biotin complex and new data from the avidin-2-iminobiotin complex. UVRR difference spectroscopy using 244-nm excitation reveals changes to the tyrosine (Tyr) and tryptophan (Trp) residues of both proteins upon complex formation. Avidin has four Trp and only one Tyr residue, while streptavidin has eight Trp and six Tyr residues. The spectral changes observed in streptavidin upon the addition of biotin are similar to those observed for avidin. However, the intensity enhancements observed for the streptavidin Trp Raman bands are less than those observed with avidin. The changes observed in the streptavidin Tyr bands are similar to those observed for avidin and are assigned exclusively to the binding site Tyr 43 residue. The Trp and Tyr band changes are due to the exclusion of water and addition of biotin, resulting in a more hydrophobic environment for the binding site residues. The addition of 2-iminobiotin results in spectral changes to both the streptavidin and avidin Trp bands that are very similar to those observed upon the addition of biotin in each protein. The changes to the Tyr bands are very different than those observed with the addition of biotin, and similar spectral changes are observed in both streptavidin and avidin. This is attributable to hydrogen bond changes to the binding site Tyr residue in each protein, and the similar Tyr difference features in both proteins supports the exclusive assignment of the streptavidin Tyr difference features to the binding site Tyr 43.     

An avidin-like domain that does not bind biotin is adopted for oligomerization by the extracellular mosaic protein fibropellin

The protein avidin found in egg white seems optimized for binding the small vitamin biotin as a stable homotetramer. Indeed, along with its streptavidin ortholog in the bacterium Streptomyces avidinii, this protein shows the strongest known noncovalent bond of a protein with a small ligand. A third known member of the avidin family, as similar to avidin as is streptavidin, is found at the C-terminal ends of the multidomain fibropellin proteins found in sea urchin. The fibropellins form a layer known as the apical lamina that surrounds the sea urchin embryo throughout development. Based upon the structure of avidin, we deduced a structural model for the avidin-like domain of the fibropellins and found that computational modeling predicts a lack of biotin binding and the preservation of tetramerization. To test this prediction we expressed and purified the fibropellin avidin-like domain and found it indeed to be a homotetramer incapable of binding biotin. Several lines of evidence suggest that the avidin-like domain causes the entire fibropellin protein to tetramerize. We suggest that the presence of the avidin-like domain serves a structural (tetrameric form) rather than functional (biotin-binding) role and may therefore be a molecular instance of exaptation-the modification of an existing function toward a new function. Finally, based upon the oligomerization of the avidin-like domain, we propose a model for the overall structure of the apical lamina.     

Neoglycoproteins: preparation and properties of complexes of biotinylated asparagine-oligosaccharides with avidin and streptavidin

Neoglycoproteins in which the oligosaccharide moieties are attached noncovalently to the protein through a high-affinity ligand have been prepared from biotinylated oligosaccharides and avidin or the nonglycosylated microbial analogue streptavidin. One of the asparagine-oligosaccharides purified from Pronase-digested ovalbumin (Man6-GlcNAc2-Asn) was reacted with an excess of the hydroxysuccinimide ester of biotin or, for the purpose of quantitation, [3H]biotin. Derivatives were also prepared with an extension "arm", a 6-aminohexanoyl group, between biotin and asparagine. When the purified biotinyl-Asn-oligosaccharide was added to avidin or streptavidin, a complex was formed containing 3 mol of oligosaccharide/mol of protein. The complexes were stable at neutral pH in the absence of biotin and could be dialyzed for 2 weeks without any significant loss of ligand. In the presence of biotin, or under denaturing conditions, the oligosaccharide derivative was released and could be quantitatively recovered. To assess the influence of the protein matrix on the reactivity of the oligosaccharide units, free biotinyl-Asn-oligosaccharide and the corresponding avidin and streptavidin complexes were exposed to alpha-mannosidase in parallel experiments. The rate of hydrolysis of the free derivative was severalfold faster than that of the two protein complexes, and at the time when about 90% of the free derivative had all five alpha-mannosyl residues removed, the majority of the protein-bound derivatives contained two to four undigested alpha-mannosyl residues and also had a significant amount of undigested starting material. The ease of preparation and the properties of these neoglycoproteins suggest that they should be excellent models for the study of glycoprotein-receptor binding and glycoprotein processing.     

Interaction between biotin lipids and streptavidin in monolayers: formation of oriented two-dimensional protein domains induced by surface recognition

Highly specific ligand-receptor interactions generally characterize surface recognition reactions. Such processes can be simulated by streptavidin-biotin-specific binding. Biotin lipids have thus been synthesized, and their interaction with streptavidin (or avidin) at the air-water interface was directly shown by measurement of surface pressure isotherms and fluorescence microscopy. These proteins interact with the biotin lipid monolayer via specific binding or nonspecific adsorption. Both phenomena were clearly distinguished by use of the inactivated form of streptavidin. The binding of fluorescein-labeled streptavidin to monolayers was also directly observed by fluorescence microscopy. The fluorescence of the protein domains is directly related to the state of polarization of the exciting light. This anisotropy can only be explained by the formation of oriented two-dimensional biotin lipid-streptavidin domains.     

Chicken avidin-related protein 4/5 shows superior thermal stability when compared with avidin while retaining high affinity to biotin

The protein chicken avidin is a commonly used tool in various applications. The avidin gene belongs to a gene family that also includes seven other members known as the avidin-related genes (AVR). We report here on the extremely high thermal stability and functional characteristics of avidin-related protein AVR4/5, a member of the avidin protein family. The thermal stability characteristics of AVR4/5 were examined using a differential scanning calorimeter, microparticle analysis, and a microplate assay. Its biotin-binding properties were studied using an isothermal calorimeter and IAsys optical biosensor. According to these analyses, in the absence of biotin AVR4/5 is clearly more stable (T(m) = 107.4 +/- 0.3 degrees C) than avidin (T(m) = 83.5 +/- 0.1 degrees C) or bacterial streptavidin (T(m) = 75.5 degrees C). AVR4/5 also exhibits a high affinity for biotin (K(d) approximately 3.6 x 10(-14) m) comparable to that of avidin and streptavidin (K(d) approximately 10(-15) m). Molecular modeling and site-directed mutagenesis were used to study the molecular details behind the observed high thermostability. The results indicate that AVR4/5 and its mutants have high potential as new improved tools for applications where exceptionally high stability and tight biotin binding are needed.     

A monovalent streptavidin with a single femtomolar biotin binding site

Streptavidin and avidin are used ubiquitously because of the remarkable affinity of their biotin binding, but they are tetramers, which disrupts many of their applications. Making either protein monomeric reduces affinity by at least 10(4)-fold because part of the binding site comes from a neighboring subunit. Here we engineered a streptavidin tetramer with only one functional biotin binding subunit that retained the affinity, off rate and thermostability of wild-type streptavidin. In denaturant, we mixed a streptavidin variant containing three mutations that block biotin binding with wild-type streptavidin in a 3:1 ratio. Then we generated monovalent streptavidin by refolding and nickel-affinity purification. Similarly, we purified defined tetramers with two or three biotin binding subunits. Labeling of site-specifically biotinylated neuroligin-1 with monovalent streptavidin allowed stable neuroligin-1 tracking without cross-linking, whereas wild-type streptavidin aggregated neuroligin-1 and disrupted presynaptic contacts. Monovalent streptavidin should find general application in biomolecule labeling, single-particle tracking and nanotechnology.     

Tissue distribution of avidin and streptavidin injected to mice. Effect of avidin carbohydrate, streptavidin truncation and exogenous biotin

Radioionated avidin and streptavidin were characterized for their biodistribution and tissue association in Balb/c mice, in comparison to their interaction with cells in vitro. Binding of avidin to spleen and bone-marrow cells in vitro was up to 20-fold higher than that of streptavidin, but when tested in vivo avidin clearance from blood and tissues was considerably faster than that of streptavidin. Levels of avidin at 24 h after an intravenous injection were below 1% (of the injected dose/mass tissue) in most organs. Non-glycosylated avidin was similar in its biodistribution to native avidin. Native streptavidin exhibited higher and prolonged tissue association with 5-10% levels in lung, liver, spleen, kidney and blood, whereas its truncated form showed low tissue levels (1-3%) but a remarkably high affinity to the kidney (80%). Exogenous biotin did not affect streptavidin distribution in vivo but caused a 2-7-fold increase in the retention of avidin (but not non-glycodylated avidin) in some of the organs.     

The highly dynamic oligomeric structure of bradavidin II is unique among avidin proteins

Bradavidin II is a biotin‐binding protein from Bradyrhizobium japonicum that resembles chicken avidin and bacterial streptavidin. A biophysical characterization was carried out using dynamic light scattering, native mass spectrometry, differential scanning calorimetry, and isothermal titration calorimetry combined with structural characterization using X‐ray crystallography. These observations revealed that bradavidin II differs from canonical homotetrameric avidin protein family members in its quaternary structure. In contrast with the other avidins, bradavidin II appears to have a dynamic (transient) oligomeric state in solution. It is monomeric at low protein concentrations but forms higher oligomeric assemblies at higher concentrations. The crystal structure of bradavidin II revealed an important role for Phe42 in shielding the bound ligand from surrounding water molecules, thus functionally replacing the L7,8 loop essential for tight ligand binding in avidin and streptavidin. This bradavidin II characterization opens new avenues for oligomerization‐independent biotin‐binding protein development.     

Accurate measurement of avidin and streptavidin in crude biofluids with a new, optimized biotin-fluorescein conjugate

A new biotin-fluorescein conjugate with an ethylene diamine spacer was found to be the first fluorescent biotin derivative which truly mimicked d-biotin in terms of high affinity, fast association, and non-cooperative binding to avidin and streptavidin tetramers. These exceptional properties were attributed to the small size/length of the new ligand since all larger/longer biotin derivatives are known for their mutual steric hindrance and anti-cooperative binding in 4:1 complexes with avidin and streptavidin tetramers. Specific binding of the new biotin-fluorescein conjugate towards avidin and streptavidin was accompanied by 84-88% quenching of ligand fluorescence. In the accompanying study this effect was used for rapid estimation of avidin and streptavidin in a new 'single tube assay'. In the present study the strong quenching effect was utilized to accurately monitor stoichiometric titration of biotin-binding sites in samples with >/=200 pM avidin or streptavidin. The concentration was calculated from the consumption of fluorescent ligand up to the distinct breakpoint in the fluorescence titration profile which was marked by the abrupt appearance of strongly fluorescent ligands which were in excess. Due to this protocol the assay was not perturbed by background fluorescence or coloration in the unknown samples. The new fluorescence titration assay is particularly suited for quick checks on short notice because getting started only means to thaw an aliquot of a standardized stock solution of fluorescent ligand. No calibration is required for the individual assay and the ligand stock solution needs to be restandardized once per week (or once per year) when stored at -25 degrees C (or at -70 degrees C, respectively).     

Improved affinity of engineered streptavidin for the Strep-tag II peptide is due to a fixed open conformation of the lid-like loop at the binding site

The Strep-tag II is a nine-amino acid peptide that was developed as an affinity tool for the purification of corresponding fusion proteins on streptavidin columns. The peptide recognizes the same pocket of streptavidin where the natural ligand is normally bound so that biotin or its chemical derivatives can be used for competitive elution. We report here the crystal structures of the streptavidin mutants '1' and '2,' which had been engineered for 10-fold higher affinity towards the Strep-tag II. Both streptavidin mutants carry mutations at positions 44, 45, and 47, that is, in a flexible loop region close to the binding site. The crystal structures of the two apo-proteins and their complexes with the Strep-tag II peptide were refined at resolutions below 2 A. Both in the presence and absence of the peptide, the lid-like loop next to the ligand pocket--comprising residues 45 through 52--adopts an 'open' conformation in all four subunits within the asymmetric unit. The same loop was previously described to be disordered in the wild-type apo-streptavidin and to close over the pocket upon complexation of the natural ligand biotin. Our findings suggest that stabilization of the 'open' loop conformation in the absence of a ligand abolishes the need for conformational rearrangement prior to the docking of the voluminous peptide. Because no direct contacts between the flexible part of the loop and the peptide ligand were detected, it seems likely that the higher affinity of the two streptavidin mutants for the Strep-tag II is caused by a predominantly entropic mechanism.     

Cooperative biotin binding by streptavidin. Electrophoretic behavior and subunit association of streptavidin in the presence of 6 M urea

We describe the cooperativity in the biotin binding of streptavidin. We have developed an electrophoretic method which can separate streptavidin molecules with bound biotin from those without biotin. In 6 M urea, the electrophoretic mobility of streptavidin in polyacrylamide gels becomes significantly faster upon biotin binding. When streptavidin was titrated with biotin, only two major bands were observed on the gel, consisting of streptavidin molecules without bound biotin and those saturated with biotin. The change in mobility is due partly to the negative charge of the bound biotin, but it must reflect conformational changes of the protein molecule associated with biotin binding. Gel filtration chromatography showed that the streptavidin molecule dissociates into two subunit dimers in the presence of 6 M urea. These results suggest that the biotin binding by the streptavidin subunit dimer is cooperative and that some communication must exist between the two subunits.